Nicely distinctive junior fantasy, that has a lot of chutzpah in the telling and ends with the merits and power of stories. Patience is a girl with a broom seeking her place in the world, but doesn't expect anything like where she ends up. Sure, her work of being a cleaner and server and assistant at a small tavern is no shock, but there is the humanoid made of rotten food scraps, there is the alleged madwoman in the attic, and there is the bonkers isolated gate, with no wall either side, stuck attached to its lock and free-standing in the middle of the town hall square. What could any of it mean?
What it means is a story that balances the traditional and expected with things that are definitely on the fresher side. And even when it seems a touch old-hat – the very nature of Patience, in her kind of Victorian workhouse aspect and consequent summons to the world of the upper classes – it's done with a brio and liveliness that makes it all thoroughly worth reading. It's not that it's ever exceptional, but all told is a very lively, and stable, selection – this is one of those girl-completely-unaware-of-her-magical-destiny reads that judges a lot of the key elements just about right. A healthy four stars.
And from what I can tell – especially as it seems 70pp trimmer – a fair bit better than the original, 2020 edition.