A Noir Mystery with Period Charm – 3.5 Stars
Clandestine Encounters delivers a competent 1930s Palm Beach mystery that successfully channels classic noir aesthetics while tackling an ambitious dual-timeline plot. Drake Marlow investigates stolen cufflinks at The Breakers Hotel, only to uncover a decades-old jewel heist, a skeleton in the walls, and a tangled web of British aristocrats, insurance investigators, and undercover agents.
The historical setting is well-researched and atmospheric. The mystery structure is complex, with multiple layers that keep you guessing. The connection between the 1933 thefts and the 1927 heist provides satisfying scope. The supporting characters like Betty Lou and Constance add warmth, though the romantic subplot feels underdeveloped.
However, the pacing drags considerably in the middle third. There are too many scenes of Drake interviewing staff members who provide minimal information, creating a repetitive rhythm. The story frequently tells rather than shows, particularly during action sequences that should crackle with tension but instead feel narrated at arm's length.
Drake himself lacks distinctive character traits beyond being competent and persistent. His internal voice doesn't stand out in a crowded noir detective field.
The Verdict: This is a mystery that fans of historical crime fiction will find satisfying without being memorable. It's well-constructed enough to hold your attention through its 227 pages, but it doesn't transcend its genre conventions. If you're looking for a comfortable period mystery with a Florida setting, this delivers. If you want something that reinvents the wheel, look elsewhere.
I received an advance review copy and am leaving this review voluntarily.