What do you think?
Rate this book
Only Murders in the Square #1
In the Midnight Hour
An inquisitive bachelor. A mysterious widow. A dangerous partnership in Regency London.
Idle heir to an earldom, Viscount Northwood drifts through life with little purpose—until a shocking murder shatters the calm of his quiet London square. His prime suspect? The beautiful but enigmatic widow across the way. Determined to uncover her secrets, North calls upon the investigative tricks he’s learned from his Bow Street Runner twin.
Except anonymous broadsheets are circulating, exposing every lurid detail of the crime and bringing a crowd of intrusive onlookers into the square, complicating North’s investigation. When he discovers the author of the scandalous publication is none other than the suspicious widow and that she is also apparently trying to solve the murder, they reluctantly join forces.
Their uneasy alliance is soon tested when the killer sets his sights on them. Can they trust each other in the face of danger, or will the murderer claim two more victims?
Idle heir to an earldom, Viscount Northwood drifts through life with little purpose—until a shocking murder shatters the calm of his quiet London square. His prime suspect? The beautiful but enigmatic widow across the way. Determined to uncover her secrets, North calls upon the investigative tricks he’s learned from his Bow Street Runner twin.
Except anonymous broadsheets are circulating, exposing every lurid detail of the crime and bringing a crowd of intrusive onlookers into the square, complicating North’s investigation. When he discovers the author of the scandalous publication is none other than the suspicious widow and that she is also apparently trying to solve the murder, they reluctantly join forces.
Their uneasy alliance is soon tested when the killer sets his sights on them. Can they trust each other in the face of danger, or will the murderer claim two more victims?
400 pages, Kindle Edition
First published September 8, 2026
About the author
Darcy Burke
158 books2,329 followersDarcy Burke is the USA Today Bestselling Author of sexy, emotional historical and contemporary romance. Darcy wrote her first book at age 11, a happily ever after about a swan addicted to magic and the female swan who loved him, with exceedingly poor illustrations. Join her Reader Club at http://www.darcyburke.com/readerclub.
A native Oregonian, Darcy lives on the edge of wine country with her guitar-strumming husband, their two hilarious kids who seem to have inherited the writing gene, two Bengal cats and a third cat named after a fruit. In her “spare” time Darcy is a serial volunteer enrolled in a 12-step program where one learns to say “no,” but she keeps having to start over. Her happy places are Disneyland and Labor Day weekend at the Gorge.
A native Oregonian, Darcy lives on the edge of wine country with her guitar-strumming husband, their two hilarious kids who seem to have inherited the writing gene, two Bengal cats and a third cat named after a fruit. In her “spare” time Darcy is a serial volunteer enrolled in a 12-step program where one learns to say “no,” but she keeps having to start over. Her happy places are Disneyland and Labor Day weekend at the Gorge.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 109 reviews
September 13, 2026
Books in a historical setting that's not magical based typically do not gauge my interest, but this was very bingeable. I loved the mystery aspect of it, and my gosh, the case itself was entirely heartbreaking. This is a HISTORICAL MYSTERY, not a romance.
There's been a murder, and Hypatia is the prime suspect. Viscount Northwood can't help but feel a pull to uncover the truth, and Hypatia wants to clear her name. Things are not looking in Hypatia's favor either, because shortly after the murder, she was announced as the beneficiary of most of the victim's estate. Something she says she knew nothing of. That they were just friends. The truth of things becomes difficult to unravel when she isn't sharing the full story, and the only other people who had motive to murder him are coming out innocent.
I've seen this described as a cozy mystery, but I wouldn't categorize it as that, primarily because of the topic of interest talked about more as the mystery unravels. I feel like murder (off-page)can kind of fit the category since it's a mystery, but SA is treading a dangerous line.
Thank you to Ingram Spark and the Author for a copy of this book!
There's been a murder, and Hypatia is the prime suspect. Viscount Northwood can't help but feel a pull to uncover the truth, and Hypatia wants to clear her name. Things are not looking in Hypatia's favor either, because shortly after the murder, she was announced as the beneficiary of most of the victim's estate. Something she says she knew nothing of. That they were just friends. The truth of things becomes difficult to unravel when she isn't sharing the full story, and the only other people who had motive to murder him are coming out innocent.
I've seen this described as a cozy mystery, but I wouldn't categorize it as that, primarily because of the topic of interest talked about more as the mystery unravels. I feel like murder (off-page)can kind of fit the category since it's a mystery, but SA is treading a dangerous line.
Thank you to Ingram Spark and the Author for a copy of this book!
Review of advance copy received from Author
This is a great start to a new series. Jeremy Sheffield, Viscount Northwood has just moved into his new house in Pemberton Square. North is the heir to an earldom and his twin brother Harry is the coroner. Lady Hypatia Cartwright also lives nearby but in a grander house. As a close knit community, gossip is rife, there is also a news sheet that somehow knows all the happenings in the area. It isn’t long before North and Hypatia are drawn into a murder investigation. I did like the characters, North is a loose end and is looking for something worthwhile to do. Hypatia didn’t have a happy marriage, although not everything has been revealed. Something also happened while North was at Oxford, that he feels guilty about. There is an attraction between them but Hypatia has had enough of Marriage and wants to live an independent life. The murder itself, is quite complex but very intriguing. This is a very engaging read and I look forward to the next in the series. I received a copy and have voluntarily reviewed it. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
September 12, 2026
Only murders in the building Victorian England style. Quite fun but a bit more formal lol. I enjoyed this book, a little on the longer side but I’m gonna put that down to introducing the characters and setting as it’s a book one. North is a bit rudderless and the unexpected death in his new neighborhood gives him a purpose. Lady Cartwright is a widow and book lover who’s caught up in the investigation and catches North’s attention as he is both drawn to her and believes her innocent. The unexpected pair sets to clear her name and find a killer. Lots of unexpected twists and a few red herrings along the way. A doozy of an ending with hints of things to come. Great beginning to a new series!.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
September 27, 2026
This is a great start to a new mystery series. I was really drawn to the historical setting and the mystery was really intriguing. The story was a pretty slow burn, but it was interesting to see how all the pieces fit together in the end.
The two main characters are really what had me into this story, just as much as the mystery itself. They were so different from one another and that dynamic worked really well for the story.
I look forward to getting to know some of the other characters that were introduced more as the series continues.
Read this if you like:
🐈⬛ Regency era
🌚 Cozy mystery
🐈⬛ Amateur sleuths
🌚 Reluctant allies
🐈⬛ Feline sidekick
Thank you @IngramSparkBooks for the gifted copy of the book.
The two main characters are really what had me into this story, just as much as the mystery itself. They were so different from one another and that dynamic worked really well for the story.
I look forward to getting to know some of the other characters that were introduced more as the series continues.
Read this if you like:
🐈⬛ Regency era
🌚 Cozy mystery
🐈⬛ Amateur sleuths
🌚 Reluctant allies
🐈⬛ Feline sidekick
Thank you @IngramSparkBooks for the gifted copy of the book.
October 9, 2026
Enjoyed the story. I had to drop my review from 4 ***. The female narrators voice was so distracting. She sounded like a kid with a cold. Spare yourself and read the book.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
3.5 stars
If you are stepping into Darcy Burke’s In the Midnight Hour expecting a quick-burning historical romance, you will need to reframe your expectations—and you will be better off for it. While Burke is widely known for her romantic fiction, this opening installment of the Pemberton Square Mystery series puts the whodunit firmly in the spotlight. What we get instead of instant passion is a sharp, clever, page-turning historical mystery anchored by two compelling leads whose dynamic lays a fascinating foundation for future books.
The novel introduces us to Pemberton Square, a seemingly quiet, polished enclave that quickly proves to have a dark underbelly. When a sudden murder disrupts the neighborhood, a web of secrets begins to unspool. Enter Lord Northwood, a bachelor and relative newcomer to Pemberton Square. North finds himself pulled into the investigation under rather unique circumstances. His twin brother serves as a coroner—a profession North finds genuinely intriguing. However, as a titled heir, social expectations prevent North from pursuing that kind of hands-on, professional career himself. The murder presents him with a rare opportunity to indulge his natural curiosity and exercise his investigative mind.
His sleuthing quickly brings him into the orbit of Lady Hypatia Cartwright, a fellow resident whose connection to the events makes her central to the unfolding drama. Together, they are thrust into a murky world of motives, secrets, and high-society intrigue where nothing is quite as respectable as it seems.
What makes the book so engaging isn't just the mechanics of the murder plot, but the contrast between the two main characters:
North is charming, observant, and restless under the constraints of his aristocratic title. He isn't just investigating a crime to pass the time; he craves the purpose that his brother’s line of work provides. His entry into Pemberton Square's secrets gives him a focus he's clearly been searching for. Furthermore, North is immediately captivated by Hypatia and makes continuous, subtle attempts to engage her beyond the parameters of the case. He is persistent, curious, and very interested in breaking through her guarded exterior.
Hypatia is the ultimate fortress. Self-reliant, guarded, and fiercely protective of her boundaries, she has no intention of letting North—or anyone else—in. While North is actively trying to gauge her interest and draw her out, Hypatia consistently shuts down his attempts at personal connection. Her focus remains strictly on the matter at hand, making her a cool, formidable, and delightfully unyielding protagonist.
To be clear: there is no romance in this book. But that isn't for a lack of trying on North's side! The dynamic is a slow burn in the truest sense—so slow that the embers are barely starting to warm by the final page. North’s one-sided attempts to charm Hypatia and her staunch refusal to engage create a fantastic tension that elevates their banter.
I found the overarching story and the central mystery thoroughly entertaining. While it isn't a romance-forward novel, the way this first book ended leaves me deeply curious to see how their dynamic will evolve as the series progresses. Burke leaves just enough subtle promise in the air to make you want to stick around for round two.
If you are looking for a page-turning historical mystery with sharp character writing and a slow-burn dynamic that keeps you guessing, consider picking this up. I will definitely be checking out the next book as soon as I can!
Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for a copy in exchange for an honest review.
If you are stepping into Darcy Burke’s In the Midnight Hour expecting a quick-burning historical romance, you will need to reframe your expectations—and you will be better off for it. While Burke is widely known for her romantic fiction, this opening installment of the Pemberton Square Mystery series puts the whodunit firmly in the spotlight. What we get instead of instant passion is a sharp, clever, page-turning historical mystery anchored by two compelling leads whose dynamic lays a fascinating foundation for future books.
The novel introduces us to Pemberton Square, a seemingly quiet, polished enclave that quickly proves to have a dark underbelly. When a sudden murder disrupts the neighborhood, a web of secrets begins to unspool. Enter Lord Northwood, a bachelor and relative newcomer to Pemberton Square. North finds himself pulled into the investigation under rather unique circumstances. His twin brother serves as a coroner—a profession North finds genuinely intriguing. However, as a titled heir, social expectations prevent North from pursuing that kind of hands-on, professional career himself. The murder presents him with a rare opportunity to indulge his natural curiosity and exercise his investigative mind.
His sleuthing quickly brings him into the orbit of Lady Hypatia Cartwright, a fellow resident whose connection to the events makes her central to the unfolding drama. Together, they are thrust into a murky world of motives, secrets, and high-society intrigue where nothing is quite as respectable as it seems.
What makes the book so engaging isn't just the mechanics of the murder plot, but the contrast between the two main characters:
North is charming, observant, and restless under the constraints of his aristocratic title. He isn't just investigating a crime to pass the time; he craves the purpose that his brother’s line of work provides. His entry into Pemberton Square's secrets gives him a focus he's clearly been searching for. Furthermore, North is immediately captivated by Hypatia and makes continuous, subtle attempts to engage her beyond the parameters of the case. He is persistent, curious, and very interested in breaking through her guarded exterior.
Hypatia is the ultimate fortress. Self-reliant, guarded, and fiercely protective of her boundaries, she has no intention of letting North—or anyone else—in. While North is actively trying to gauge her interest and draw her out, Hypatia consistently shuts down his attempts at personal connection. Her focus remains strictly on the matter at hand, making her a cool, formidable, and delightfully unyielding protagonist.
To be clear: there is no romance in this book. But that isn't for a lack of trying on North's side! The dynamic is a slow burn in the truest sense—so slow that the embers are barely starting to warm by the final page. North’s one-sided attempts to charm Hypatia and her staunch refusal to engage create a fantastic tension that elevates their banter.
I found the overarching story and the central mystery thoroughly entertaining. While it isn't a romance-forward novel, the way this first book ended leaves me deeply curious to see how their dynamic will evolve as the series progresses. Burke leaves just enough subtle promise in the air to make you want to stick around for round two.
If you are looking for a page-turning historical mystery with sharp character writing and a slow-burn dynamic that keeps you guessing, consider picking this up. I will definitely be checking out the next book as soon as I can!
Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for a copy in exchange for an honest review.
Review of advance copy
Thanks to Booksprout for a copy of this novel and this is my freely given opinion.
This is the first novel in a new cozy mystery series by Darcy Burke, with some connections to other series written by the author, thanks to some references and cross over characters.
This story features Jeremy Sheffield, Viscount Northfield, the heir to an earldom, also known as North. An idle aristocrat who recently moved from his bachelor's lodgings at the Albany to his own abode in Pemberton Square. After a night of excess, he is headed home, when the peace of dawn is broken by a distressed footman running out of the home of one his neighbours, desperately seeking assistance. North, the only person about, goes to the aid of his neighbour, Sir Radnor, to discover a grisly scene of an unfortunate death.
Despite his twin brother being newly appointed coroner, after being a Runner, North has no experience in detective work himself. But something about the scenario he comes upon makes him suspect that Sir Radnor's death is not as innocuous as his retainers put forth - that the man in a drunken state, fell, and caused himself a fatal injury. He decides to act on his instincts and calls in a Runner and involves his brother, and eventually this leads to an investigation into the murder of Sir Radnor.
One of the suspects is Sir Radnor's lovely, wealthy and independent young widowed neighbour, Lady Hypatia Cartwright. She is known to be friends with Sir Radnor, sharing an interest in literature, and frequently at his home for meals and late night discussions. Suspicion and gossip coalesce when Sir Radnor's only relatives are cut out of his will and it is revealed that she is his named heir. Lady Cartwright is aghast, as she did not even know of Sir Radnor's will. But her reputation becomes torn further when it becomes known that he had a romantic interest in her, and other details about his last night alive come to light, involving her.
Despite being strangers and not quite trusting of each other, Lady Cartwright and North become wary partners to seek out the truth of Sir Radnor and his murderer; Lady Cartwright to prove her innocence and scrub her reputation, and North in the sudden desire to seek justice and with the belief that Lady Cartwright is innocent of the crime... though his belief faces some challenges when he finds that she may be keeping secrets from him.
A good start to series, introducing some interesting people in the backdrop of a small community. Lady Cartwright and North start out as strangers who form a reluctant partnership and grudging friendship, but in order to preserve her fragile reputation, Lady Cartwright does not let it become more, especially as her last friendship with a neighbour ended so badly, and put her under the scrutiny of her nosy neighbours and the law. I do love the introduction of her cat, Quill, as a character and a connection for North and Lady Cartwright as well. The murder mystery took some interesting twists as well, with an unexpected resolution of justice as well. It was also an revelation about power dynamics, and women's safety in that world at the time, especially those in service.
Looking forward to what else happens in the Square and how things develop between North and Lady Cartwright.
4 stars out of 5
This is the first novel in a new cozy mystery series by Darcy Burke, with some connections to other series written by the author, thanks to some references and cross over characters.
This story features Jeremy Sheffield, Viscount Northfield, the heir to an earldom, also known as North. An idle aristocrat who recently moved from his bachelor's lodgings at the Albany to his own abode in Pemberton Square. After a night of excess, he is headed home, when the peace of dawn is broken by a distressed footman running out of the home of one his neighbours, desperately seeking assistance. North, the only person about, goes to the aid of his neighbour, Sir Radnor, to discover a grisly scene of an unfortunate death.
Despite his twin brother being newly appointed coroner, after being a Runner, North has no experience in detective work himself. But something about the scenario he comes upon makes him suspect that Sir Radnor's death is not as innocuous as his retainers put forth - that the man in a drunken state, fell, and caused himself a fatal injury. He decides to act on his instincts and calls in a Runner and involves his brother, and eventually this leads to an investigation into the murder of Sir Radnor.
One of the suspects is Sir Radnor's lovely, wealthy and independent young widowed neighbour, Lady Hypatia Cartwright. She is known to be friends with Sir Radnor, sharing an interest in literature, and frequently at his home for meals and late night discussions. Suspicion and gossip coalesce when Sir Radnor's only relatives are cut out of his will and it is revealed that she is his named heir. Lady Cartwright is aghast, as she did not even know of Sir Radnor's will. But her reputation becomes torn further when it becomes known that he had a romantic interest in her, and other details about his last night alive come to light, involving her.
Despite being strangers and not quite trusting of each other, Lady Cartwright and North become wary partners to seek out the truth of Sir Radnor and his murderer; Lady Cartwright to prove her innocence and scrub her reputation, and North in the sudden desire to seek justice and with the belief that Lady Cartwright is innocent of the crime... though his belief faces some challenges when he finds that she may be keeping secrets from him.
A good start to series, introducing some interesting people in the backdrop of a small community. Lady Cartwright and North start out as strangers who form a reluctant partnership and grudging friendship, but in order to preserve her fragile reputation, Lady Cartwright does not let it become more, especially as her last friendship with a neighbour ended so badly, and put her under the scrutiny of her nosy neighbours and the law. I do love the introduction of her cat, Quill, as a character and a connection for North and Lady Cartwright as well. The murder mystery took some interesting twists as well, with an unexpected resolution of justice as well. It was also an revelation about power dynamics, and women's safety in that world at the time, especially those in service.
Looking forward to what else happens in the Square and how things develop between North and Lady Cartwright.
4 stars out of 5
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
I genuinely want you to know how much I enjoyed In the Midnight Hour and how deeply I respect the care you put into both the mystery and the characters. Hypatia touched me because you gave her such a believable mix of strength and vulnerability. She has already been through painful experiences, yet she does not allow those experiences to completely control her. She is cautious, but she is also curious. She is frightened, but she keeps searching for answers. I really admired that about her. Her decision to become involved in discovering what happened to Sir Radnor feels very personal because she is not simply chasing a mystery for entertainment. Her own safety and reputation are tied to the truth, and that makes every step she takes feel important. Northwood also won me over because of the way you wrote his kindness. He is intelligent and capable, but what makes him special is the respect he shows Hypatia. He listens to her. He takes her concerns seriously. He never treats her as though she is incapable simply because she is a woman investigating something dangerous. I loved watching their friendship grow because it feels natural and gentle, with little moments of humor and attraction that make their relationship so enjoyable to follow. I also have enormous respect for the way you built the mystery around Sir Radnor. You do not simply tell us that something is wrong. You allow us to discover it through conversations, memories and small details that slowly change the way we see him. The missing dressing gown was especially clever because it seems like such a small thing at first, yet it opens the door to a much bigger question. I found myself thinking about it long after the scene ended. The household characters also add so much life to the story. Maberly's concern for the servants, Usher's memories of Sir Radnor and the different reactions of the people around the house all make the mystery feel like something that affected an entire group of lives rather than just one person. I also loved the historical setting because you understand how much reputation and social rules can affect a person's choices. Hypatia has to be careful about how she behaves and who she trusts, which makes her courage even more meaningful. What I respect most is that you never let the mystery completely overpower the emotional story. Beneath the murder investigation is a woman who has been hurt before and is slowly discovering that she may be able to trust someone again. That gave the book a warmth that I really appreciated. Thank you for creating characters I genuinely cared about and a mystery that kept me asking questions. Thank you for giving Hypatia a voice and allowing her to be brave in her own way. And thank you for giving Northwood such a kind and steady presence beside her. I could feel the care you put into their relationship, and I found myself hoping they would continue finding reasons to spend time together even while trying to solve the mystery. I have enormous respect for the thought you put into this story. You made me care about the truth, but you also made me care deeply about the people searching for it. That is what made the book special to me, and I sincerely hope you know how much heart I found in these pages.
September 9, 2026
A Great Start To The Series
I thoroughly enjoyed the start of this new cozy amateur sleuth mystery series set in Regency London. The story centers on Jeremy Sheffield, Viscount Nortwood “North”—whose twin brother, Harry is already familiar to Darcy Burke fans from "A Secret Surrender"—and Lady Hypatia Cartwright a content and affluent widow who becomes a suspect in a murder case. The gripping plot is well-written, fast-paced, and brimming with action, intrigue, suspense, twists, and off-page violence and SA. Those expecting a blossoming romance right from the start may be disappointed, as this book is primarily about building mutual trust and becoming friends. Hypatia is a complex character; scarred by past experiences, she finds it difficult to trust men, yet she is both strong and vulnerable. North is endearing. Despite his former carefree lifestyle, he is honorable, trustworthy and compassionate, and wants to do something meaningful. I really liked how patient and protective he was, and how their partnership developed slowly. I was also happy to meet Harry again.
At the request of his father, the Earl of Aylesbury, Jeremy “North” Sheffield, Viscount Northwood, is finally supposed to give up his bachelor lifestyle and settle down. He has just moved into his new home on Pemberton Square when, by chance, he becomes entangled in the death of his neighbor, Sir Radnor Fieldstone. Although the police assume it was an accident, North is fairly certain it was murder and begins investigating on his own, eventually managing to convince his brother Harry—the newly appointed coroner—to hold an inquest. Soon, Sir Radnor’s neighbor and friend, Lady Cartwright, comes under suspicion of having murdered him, as she was the last person to spend time with the victim and was the one to whom he had unexpectedly bequeathed his house and fortune—much to the displeasure of his relatives.
After her unhappy marriage to a tyrannical husband, the widowed Lady Hypatia Cavendish no longer trusted any man and enjoyed her independent life as a widow. Through their shared love of literature, she had become friends some time ago with her elderly neighbor, Sir Radnor, and often dined with him to discuss their common interests. But when he suddenly became violent during their last meeting, Hypatia fled his house, and the next morning, Sir Radnor was found dead.
North, who finds the enigmatic widow likable, believes her and is determined to prove her innocence and save her reputation, which has been tarnished by gossip among the neighbors and a newspaper article, and he succeeds in convincing Hypatia to join him in finding the true murderer…
If you enjoy historical detective mysteries with endearing protagonists, twists and turns, a touch of suspense, emotion, and the potential for a future romance, this book is for you.
I received a free ARC of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own and left voluntarily.
I thoroughly enjoyed the start of this new cozy amateur sleuth mystery series set in Regency London. The story centers on Jeremy Sheffield, Viscount Nortwood “North”—whose twin brother, Harry is already familiar to Darcy Burke fans from "A Secret Surrender"—and Lady Hypatia Cartwright a content and affluent widow who becomes a suspect in a murder case. The gripping plot is well-written, fast-paced, and brimming with action, intrigue, suspense, twists, and off-page violence and SA. Those expecting a blossoming romance right from the start may be disappointed, as this book is primarily about building mutual trust and becoming friends. Hypatia is a complex character; scarred by past experiences, she finds it difficult to trust men, yet she is both strong and vulnerable. North is endearing. Despite his former carefree lifestyle, he is honorable, trustworthy and compassionate, and wants to do something meaningful. I really liked how patient and protective he was, and how their partnership developed slowly. I was also happy to meet Harry again.
At the request of his father, the Earl of Aylesbury, Jeremy “North” Sheffield, Viscount Northwood, is finally supposed to give up his bachelor lifestyle and settle down. He has just moved into his new home on Pemberton Square when, by chance, he becomes entangled in the death of his neighbor, Sir Radnor Fieldstone. Although the police assume it was an accident, North is fairly certain it was murder and begins investigating on his own, eventually managing to convince his brother Harry—the newly appointed coroner—to hold an inquest. Soon, Sir Radnor’s neighbor and friend, Lady Cartwright, comes under suspicion of having murdered him, as she was the last person to spend time with the victim and was the one to whom he had unexpectedly bequeathed his house and fortune—much to the displeasure of his relatives.
After her unhappy marriage to a tyrannical husband, the widowed Lady Hypatia Cavendish no longer trusted any man and enjoyed her independent life as a widow. Through their shared love of literature, she had become friends some time ago with her elderly neighbor, Sir Radnor, and often dined with him to discuss their common interests. But when he suddenly became violent during their last meeting, Hypatia fled his house, and the next morning, Sir Radnor was found dead.
North, who finds the enigmatic widow likable, believes her and is determined to prove her innocence and save her reputation, which has been tarnished by gossip among the neighbors and a newspaper article, and he succeeds in convincing Hypatia to join him in finding the true murderer…
If you enjoy historical detective mysteries with endearing protagonists, twists and turns, a touch of suspense, emotion, and the potential for a future romance, this book is for you.
I received a free ARC of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own and left voluntarily.
Review of advance copy received from Author
In the Midnight Hour is the first book in Darcy Burke’s Murders in the Square series, and it’s shaping up to be another winner from an author whose work I already enjoy. This series centers around the residents of Pemberton Square, and this opening installment immediately pulls you into its world of secrets, intrigue, and murder.
Our story begins with Jeremy Sheffield, Viscount Northwood—better known as North—who has just moved into his new home on the Square. He’s the heir to an earldom, but he’s clearly a man in search of purpose. His twin brother, Harry, recently became the local coroner after working as a Bow Street investigator. One late evening, as North is returning home, he hears a neighbor’s footman crying out for help. Rushing into Sir Radnor’s house, North finds the man dead in his bedroom, and just like that, he’s drawn into a mystery he can’t seem to step away from.
North’s first call is to his brother, but instead, Drummond from Bow Street arrives to investigate. All suspicion immediately falls on Lady Hypatia Cartwright, the last person to see Sir Radnor alive, and whose connection to him might have been… more than friendly. North, however, doesn’t believe she’s guilty. When the death is officially ruled a murder, he and Hypatia—despite being strangers and initially wary of one another—form an uneasy alliance to uncover the truth.
The mystery is full of satisfying twists and turns. Just when you think you’ve got it figured out, Darcy Burke throws in another surprise. Alongside the murder plot, there’s an emotional thread running through North’s story—haunted by a moment of inaction from his Oxford days, he’s driven not to repeat that mistake. The book also casts a thoughtful light on the harsh realities faced by women and servants in high society, showing how easily they were silenced and exploited.
I particularly enjoyed the growing bond between North and Hypatia, the clever little appearances of Quill the cat, and the way the investigation drew me deeper into the lives of Pemberton Square’s residents. And that ending? A perfectly shocking note that left me eager for the next book.
If you enjoy historical mysteries with complex characters, slow-building partnerships, and plenty of unexpected turns, In the Midnight Hour is a fantastic start to what promises to be a compelling series. I can’t wait to see where North, Hypatia, and the rest of Pemberton Square take us next.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Our story begins with Jeremy Sheffield, Viscount Northwood—better known as North—who has just moved into his new home on the Square. He’s the heir to an earldom, but he’s clearly a man in search of purpose. His twin brother, Harry, recently became the local coroner after working as a Bow Street investigator. One late evening, as North is returning home, he hears a neighbor’s footman crying out for help. Rushing into Sir Radnor’s house, North finds the man dead in his bedroom, and just like that, he’s drawn into a mystery he can’t seem to step away from.
North’s first call is to his brother, but instead, Drummond from Bow Street arrives to investigate. All suspicion immediately falls on Lady Hypatia Cartwright, the last person to see Sir Radnor alive, and whose connection to him might have been… more than friendly. North, however, doesn’t believe she’s guilty. When the death is officially ruled a murder, he and Hypatia—despite being strangers and initially wary of one another—form an uneasy alliance to uncover the truth.
The mystery is full of satisfying twists and turns. Just when you think you’ve got it figured out, Darcy Burke throws in another surprise. Alongside the murder plot, there’s an emotional thread running through North’s story—haunted by a moment of inaction from his Oxford days, he’s driven not to repeat that mistake. The book also casts a thoughtful light on the harsh realities faced by women and servants in high society, showing how easily they were silenced and exploited.
I particularly enjoyed the growing bond between North and Hypatia, the clever little appearances of Quill the cat, and the way the investigation drew me deeper into the lives of Pemberton Square’s residents. And that ending? A perfectly shocking note that left me eager for the next book.
If you enjoy historical mysteries with complex characters, slow-building partnerships, and plenty of unexpected turns, In the Midnight Hour is a fantastic start to what promises to be a compelling series. I can’t wait to see where North, Hypatia, and the rest of Pemberton Square take us next.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
September 7, 2026
Oh, this is going to be to be a great new series by one of my favorite authors. I have read a lot of Darcy’s books and enjoyed hours of reading. This new series is different as it forces more on the mystery than a romance so if you are looking for a great regency romance between the main characters this is not the best book for you. If you love the mystery and suspense of a murder investigation by a Viscount and a Widow, with great characters and clues, this is it! Jeremy Viscount Northwood, known to all as North, is heir to Earldom. His twin brother, Harry, has worked for Bow Street, and he is now the coroner. North is not allowed to work as he is a peer. He is a Rake and spends his days learning about the family estates. Lucky he will not take over soon as his father is healthy. He has just moved from the family home to his new house in Pemberton Square. His mother wanted him to marry and settle down, so it was time to get his own place. The townhouses numbered Eleven thru Sixteen are known as bachelor row. The community is very close knit and even has its own paper/gossip sheet called “The Observer”. No one knows who writes it, but it is very accurate with what is going on. North is stopped by a young footman very upset looking for help and learns one of his neighbors was found dead in his bedroom. North goes to help and finds its Sir Radner. He stops the housekeeper from cleaning up, knowing from his brother this is wrong. As the dr is called and others show up, it becomes clear many things are off. Lady Hypatia Cartwright is a wealthy widow who also lives in the square. When she learns Sir Radner is dead, she is very upset and worried as they were friends. She had dinner with him as they both had a love of new and old books. She is the last one to see him alive and the authorities question her. North offers to help her find out who or how he died and so begins a new friendship and team! There are a lot of twists and turns, false leads, and tons of secrets ahead. North has tired of flirting with Hypatia, and she shuts him down. She had a horrible marriage and now a man she was friends with is dead. I Foresee more about their friendship in upcoming books. The attraction between is there. I received an ARC from the author and wish to thank her. This is my honest opinion and am freely giving it. Rush and get your copy to see what happens next. Great read, Darcy never lets us down.
Review of advance copy
"In the midnight hour" is a fun and engaging cozy mystery set in the Regency period, with an intriguing murder, plenty of gossip and suspicion and a heroine who refuses to sit back and let others decide her fate.
Lady Hypatia finds herself the main suspect when her elderly baronet neighbor dies unexpectedly. Unfortunately for Hypatia, she was not only his friend but also the one inheriting his fortune. As a result, she quickly becomes the subject of judgement and gossip, while facing the very real possibility of being hanged for a crime she didn't commit.
Determined to clear her name, Hypatia decides to investigate the murder herself. She soon receives help from her new neighbor North, a viscount and a bachelor. I really enjoyed watching their partnership develop throughout the investigation. North believes and supports her, while she proves time and again that she is more than capable of standing on her own. As their trust grows and a friendship begins to form, they uncover some disturbing secrets about the supposedly honorable baronet, he was not at all the man everyone believed him to be.
Hypatia was definitely one of my favorite characters. She is smart, independent, brave and isn't afraid to stand up for herself. I loved that she took matters into her own hands rather than allowing society's judgement or the threat hanging over her head to break her spirit.
The mystery itself kept me entertained, with some interesting twists and nicely placed clues along the way. I also appreciated that the story touches on the sensitive subject of violence against women, adding some more serious and thought provoking elements beneath the cozy mystery setting.
Since this is the beginning of a series, I'm very curious to see how Hypatia and North's relationship develops in the books to come. Their growing friendship already has me hoping for a slow burn romance and I will definitely be sticking around to see where their story goes.
Overall, the novel was a thoroughly enjoyable regency cozy mystery with a clever heroine, an entertaining investigation, great character development and a partnership I really enjoyed watching unfold.
*** This was an ARC received on Booksprout
Lady Hypatia finds herself the main suspect when her elderly baronet neighbor dies unexpectedly. Unfortunately for Hypatia, she was not only his friend but also the one inheriting his fortune. As a result, she quickly becomes the subject of judgement and gossip, while facing the very real possibility of being hanged for a crime she didn't commit.
Determined to clear her name, Hypatia decides to investigate the murder herself. She soon receives help from her new neighbor North, a viscount and a bachelor. I really enjoyed watching their partnership develop throughout the investigation. North believes and supports her, while she proves time and again that she is more than capable of standing on her own. As their trust grows and a friendship begins to form, they uncover some disturbing secrets about the supposedly honorable baronet, he was not at all the man everyone believed him to be.
Hypatia was definitely one of my favorite characters. She is smart, independent, brave and isn't afraid to stand up for herself. I loved that she took matters into her own hands rather than allowing society's judgement or the threat hanging over her head to break her spirit.
The mystery itself kept me entertained, with some interesting twists and nicely placed clues along the way. I also appreciated that the story touches on the sensitive subject of violence against women, adding some more serious and thought provoking elements beneath the cozy mystery setting.
Since this is the beginning of a series, I'm very curious to see how Hypatia and North's relationship develops in the books to come. Their growing friendship already has me hoping for a slow burn romance and I will definitely be sticking around to see where their story goes.
Overall, the novel was a thoroughly enjoyable regency cozy mystery with a clever heroine, an entertaining investigation, great character development and a partnership I really enjoyed watching unfold.
*** This was an ARC received on Booksprout
September 8, 2026
Cosy mystery led escapism
North and Hypatia must untangle a web of lies, secrets and evasiveness as the death of a neighbour appears to be more than it seems in this fun, engaging whodunit and new series opener: IN THE MIDNIGHT HOUR
The closeknit community of Pemberton Square provides the intriguing backdrop for a host of characters and one smart cat to hook you in and have you rooting out the secrets and motives hidden beneath the facades on display.
Focusing around the investigations of our protagonists, that each pull you in and make you want to dig deeper into the secrets unraveling on the square, just as much as you want to unpick what makes them tick as individuals themselves.
North and Hypatia so subtly have you warming to them and wishing to delve headfirst into their newly budding friendship. Producing a chemistry of brushed back flirtation, guardedness, mutual wit and slowly won trust.
Making this one compellingly crafted tale that allows the reader to focus on unpicking the mystery unfolding before them, dig deeper behind each clue and help puzzle out the answers alongside our audacious pair. Who shine with this effecting realism born of hard to brush aside vulnerabilities and carefully crafted back stories that tantalise and hint at their emotional impaction as they slowly open and come to trust each other. As a result a true partnership begins to unfurl so satisfyingly out of this building mutual admiration as it slowly hooks you in despite those deep rooted vulnerabilities putting up walls, understanding and attraction attempting to slowly and respectfully chip and whittle them back down again and wrap them up so tightly in the reasons they want so desperately to solve the case before them.
A series starter that alone provides an enjoyably absorbing mystery yet holds such great promise and scope for more to evolve between the pair in a tale that from the very beginning is so much more than a cosy, highly engaging mystery. Can't wait to see what the future holds for these two and the mysteries they uncover along the way!
~I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own~
North and Hypatia must untangle a web of lies, secrets and evasiveness as the death of a neighbour appears to be more than it seems in this fun, engaging whodunit and new series opener: IN THE MIDNIGHT HOUR
The closeknit community of Pemberton Square provides the intriguing backdrop for a host of characters and one smart cat to hook you in and have you rooting out the secrets and motives hidden beneath the facades on display.
Focusing around the investigations of our protagonists, that each pull you in and make you want to dig deeper into the secrets unraveling on the square, just as much as you want to unpick what makes them tick as individuals themselves.
North and Hypatia so subtly have you warming to them and wishing to delve headfirst into their newly budding friendship. Producing a chemistry of brushed back flirtation, guardedness, mutual wit and slowly won trust.
Making this one compellingly crafted tale that allows the reader to focus on unpicking the mystery unfolding before them, dig deeper behind each clue and help puzzle out the answers alongside our audacious pair. Who shine with this effecting realism born of hard to brush aside vulnerabilities and carefully crafted back stories that tantalise and hint at their emotional impaction as they slowly open and come to trust each other. As a result a true partnership begins to unfurl so satisfyingly out of this building mutual admiration as it slowly hooks you in despite those deep rooted vulnerabilities putting up walls, understanding and attraction attempting to slowly and respectfully chip and whittle them back down again and wrap them up so tightly in the reasons they want so desperately to solve the case before them.
A series starter that alone provides an enjoyably absorbing mystery yet holds such great promise and scope for more to evolve between the pair in a tale that from the very beginning is so much more than a cosy, highly engaging mystery. Can't wait to see what the future holds for these two and the mysteries they uncover along the way!
~I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own~
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Thank you to Xpresso Book Tours for sending me this arc in exchange for an honest review.
I found this book to be decent. I liked the murder-mystery aspect of it. I found the murder to be well thought out. While I started to get an idea of who killed the victim, I was still quite surprised by who actually did it. Though again, their motive was rational and clear.
As for the characters, I can't say that I really cared about them. For starters, I didn't really like North. I also find his involvement within the murder case to be a it strange. It was made clear from the start of the book that he had only been living in the square for a few weeks by the time that the murder took place. If he had been living there for a few years and was acquainted with the people who were involved, then that would make more sense.
The same goes for his dynamic with Hypatia. This was a woman who he literally never knew before the murder and suddenly he was ready to prove her innocence. While I do admire that he cared for her, again, I felt it didn't make sense. If he had known Hypatia before the murder took place, then I could get behind that.
As for Hypatia, I really liked her. The book alternates between North and Hypatia's povs (third person), with more chapters being in North's povs. I feel if we got more of Hypatia's then this would have been a bit more enjoyable.
I'm also not the biggest fan of the writing style. This book is very clearly geared towards an adult audience, but when I first started it it felt like it was geared towards a slightly younger audience. I also wasn't a big fan of the fact that so many characters were being introduced within the first three chapters of the book. So many names were being mentioned at once and I was losing track of who was who. Mind you, a lot of those people serve little to no purpose other than being residents of the square.
Overall, I found this book to be okay. If you like murder-mysteries and the regency era, then I would recommend this book.
I found this book to be decent. I liked the murder-mystery aspect of it. I found the murder to be well thought out. While I started to get an idea of who killed the victim, I was still quite surprised by who actually did it. Though again, their motive was rational and clear.
As for the characters, I can't say that I really cared about them. For starters, I didn't really like North. I also find his involvement within the murder case to be a it strange. It was made clear from the start of the book that he had only been living in the square for a few weeks by the time that the murder took place. If he had been living there for a few years and was acquainted with the people who were involved, then that would make more sense.
The same goes for his dynamic with Hypatia. This was a woman who he literally never knew before the murder and suddenly he was ready to prove her innocence. While I do admire that he cared for her, again, I felt it didn't make sense. If he had known Hypatia before the murder took place, then I could get behind that.
As for Hypatia, I really liked her. The book alternates between North and Hypatia's povs (third person), with more chapters being in North's povs. I feel if we got more of Hypatia's then this would have been a bit more enjoyable.
I'm also not the biggest fan of the writing style. This book is very clearly geared towards an adult audience, but when I first started it it felt like it was geared towards a slightly younger audience. I also wasn't a big fan of the fact that so many characters were being introduced within the first three chapters of the book. So many names were being mentioned at once and I was losing track of who was who. Mind you, a lot of those people serve little to no purpose other than being residents of the square.
Overall, I found this book to be okay. If you like murder-mysteries and the regency era, then I would recommend this book.
September 8, 2026
In the Midnight Hour by Darcy Burke
Only Murders in the Square #1
~ Murder mystery with a “cozy” vibe that sees Lord Sheffield and Lady Cartwright pair up to solve a murder ~ Solid start to a series with potential ~
What I liked:
* Lady Hypatia Cartwright: widow, wealthy, independent, loves literature, Quill the black cat’s person, empathetic, had a miserable marriage, doesn’t seem close to her parents, enjoys being on her own, primary suspect in the Sir Radnor Fieldstone Murder
* Jeremy Sheffield “North”, Viscount Norwood: will inherit and become Earl of Aylesbury, twin, loves his family, educated, a flirt, seems at loose ends and in need of a purpose, intrigued by Hypatia, incensed by some behavior he hears about, will probably grow and mature through the series
* Coming into a new series on the first book
* The well-planned plot with clues paced well and plenty of possible suspects
* Harry Sheffield: Jeremy’s brother, coroner, married to Selina ~ Their story can be read in A Secret Surrender – book one of the Pretenders series – thought he seemed familiar ;) (5 Stars)
* Learning more about Pemberton Square and those that live there – I wonder if all the murders in this series will take place there
* The way the murder was solved and the magistrate’s decision when all facts were given
* The potential for this series
What I didn’t like:
* Who and what I was meant not to like
* Thinking about men who feel entitled to behave as they please and don’t hear the word no – they existed in the past and still exist today
* That I had trouble warming up to and relating to the main characters and couldn’t understand why North became involved so quickly in trying to solve Radnor’s murder while supporting Hypatia without really knowing her…that said…I have read and loved this author’s works so know that this series has potential
Did I like this book? Mostly
Would I read more in this series? I think so
Thank you to the author for the ARC – This is my honest review
3-4 Stars
Only Murders in the Square #1
~ Murder mystery with a “cozy” vibe that sees Lord Sheffield and Lady Cartwright pair up to solve a murder ~ Solid start to a series with potential ~
What I liked:
* Lady Hypatia Cartwright: widow, wealthy, independent, loves literature, Quill the black cat’s person, empathetic, had a miserable marriage, doesn’t seem close to her parents, enjoys being on her own, primary suspect in the Sir Radnor Fieldstone Murder
* Jeremy Sheffield “North”, Viscount Norwood: will inherit and become Earl of Aylesbury, twin, loves his family, educated, a flirt, seems at loose ends and in need of a purpose, intrigued by Hypatia, incensed by some behavior he hears about, will probably grow and mature through the series
* Coming into a new series on the first book
* The well-planned plot with clues paced well and plenty of possible suspects
* Harry Sheffield: Jeremy’s brother, coroner, married to Selina ~ Their story can be read in A Secret Surrender – book one of the Pretenders series – thought he seemed familiar ;) (5 Stars)
* Learning more about Pemberton Square and those that live there – I wonder if all the murders in this series will take place there
* The way the murder was solved and the magistrate’s decision when all facts were given
* The potential for this series
What I didn’t like:
* Who and what I was meant not to like
* Thinking about men who feel entitled to behave as they please and don’t hear the word no – they existed in the past and still exist today
* That I had trouble warming up to and relating to the main characters and couldn’t understand why North became involved so quickly in trying to solve Radnor’s murder while supporting Hypatia without really knowing her…that said…I have read and loved this author’s works so know that this series has potential
Did I like this book? Mostly
Would I read more in this series? I think so
Thank you to the author for the ARC – This is my honest review
3-4 Stars
September 10, 2026
📚✨ BOOK REVIEW ✨📚
Title: In the Midnight Hour
Series: Only Murders in the Square (Book 1)
Author: Darcy Burke
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
📝 My Thoughts: Cozy, Clever, Captivating
If you enjoy classic Regency romance wrapped in a clever, low-stakes murder mystery, this feels just like a game of Clue! The plot kicks off when an elderly baronet turns up dead in his home, and a charming, slightly bored viscount decides to play amateur detective alongside the neighborhood's sharp-witted young widow. The MMC, Viscount Northwood, thinks she is the possible murderess one moment, and at the next turn he is right beside her offering help because he believes she is innocent. The FMC, Lady Hypatia, is independent, bright, and holds her ground. Half the fun is watching the whole square's cast of nosy neighbors get pulled into the investigation, everyone's got a theory, a secret, or both, and it makes Pemberton Square feel like its own character.
😊 Why I Liked It:
This feels lighter than the Raven and Wren series. The chemistry between North and Hypatia is great, and the writing quality made every scene feel alive. That said, there is a lot of shoulder twitching amongst the characters in this book!😏 Also, regarding the audiobook: I didn't care much for the voice used on this one, and I definitely prefer the narrator used for the Raven and Wren series. Overall, it's not quite as good as the Raven and Wren series, but the story quality and smooth readability still make it completely effortless to dive into.
🔖 Favorite Quote:
"She was, perhaps, a murderess."
📌 Final Verdict:
A delightful, easy read for fans of historical cozy mysteries, witty banter, and sweet, slow-burn romance! It stands alone as a complete mystery, but sets up the rest of the series beautifully. If you love a cozy suspense (with one dark thread) definitely grab this one!
#BookReview #RegencyRomance #CozyMystery #InTheMidnightHour #DarcyBurke #Bookstagram #RomanceReads #HistoricalRomance #BookRecommendation #CleanReads
Title: In the Midnight Hour
Series: Only Murders in the Square (Book 1)
Author: Darcy Burke
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
📝 My Thoughts: Cozy, Clever, Captivating
If you enjoy classic Regency romance wrapped in a clever, low-stakes murder mystery, this feels just like a game of Clue! The plot kicks off when an elderly baronet turns up dead in his home, and a charming, slightly bored viscount decides to play amateur detective alongside the neighborhood's sharp-witted young widow. The MMC, Viscount Northwood, thinks she is the possible murderess one moment, and at the next turn he is right beside her offering help because he believes she is innocent. The FMC, Lady Hypatia, is independent, bright, and holds her ground. Half the fun is watching the whole square's cast of nosy neighbors get pulled into the investigation, everyone's got a theory, a secret, or both, and it makes Pemberton Square feel like its own character.
😊 Why I Liked It:
This feels lighter than the Raven and Wren series. The chemistry between North and Hypatia is great, and the writing quality made every scene feel alive. That said, there is a lot of shoulder twitching amongst the characters in this book!😏 Also, regarding the audiobook: I didn't care much for the voice used on this one, and I definitely prefer the narrator used for the Raven and Wren series. Overall, it's not quite as good as the Raven and Wren series, but the story quality and smooth readability still make it completely effortless to dive into.
🔖 Favorite Quote:
"She was, perhaps, a murderess."
📌 Final Verdict:
A delightful, easy read for fans of historical cozy mysteries, witty banter, and sweet, slow-burn romance! It stands alone as a complete mystery, but sets up the rest of the series beautifully. If you love a cozy suspense (with one dark thread) definitely grab this one!
#BookReview #RegencyRomance #CozyMystery #InTheMidnightHour #DarcyBurke #Bookstagram #RomanceReads #HistoricalRomance #BookRecommendation #CleanReads
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Solid 3.5 leading to 4 stars for this delightful new book in a hopefully long-running series.
This is my first Darcy Burke, and I really enjoyed her take on the whodunit. Our main characters, the setting, and the style of the (hopefully) future series was very well established. While the mystery felt a bit rushed, or too easy (I was able to identify whodunit pretty quickly) I think that it was appropriate for a first-book, where most of the heavy lifting is done in establishing our main characters and their motivations. And what main characters!
I admit, it took awhile for North to grow on me. The author did a great job in mellowing out my initial reaction to him using some well-placed backstory drops. He is the heir and a Peer, so of course he grew up a bit spoiled and without too many life skills. That's part of his charm. He also has a true sense of right, wrong, and justice, and he stands up for what's right. He also has keen observational skills that he uses to great effect. And then there is Lady Hypatia. She was my absolute favorite, and my preferred POV character. She has been through a lot - all historically accurate to the time, even if her and North's reactions to it may skew a bit more modern - and she still remains intelligent, steadfast, and kind.
If you're looking for romance, this may not be the series for you. There are hints of a connection, but despite North's near instant attraction, Hypatia is determined to be friends. If there is any romance, this will be a slow-burn one. Hopefully over several future books? I think that worked well for the story - this is a murder mystery, and the plot was more about the characters learning to trust each other.
Great start to the fall season. While this wasn't a fall book, it had the cozy vibes that I'm looking for as the weather turns cooler. Thank you very much to NetGalley and Oliver Heber Books for access to this e-ARC in exchange for my review!
This is my first Darcy Burke, and I really enjoyed her take on the whodunit. Our main characters, the setting, and the style of the (hopefully) future series was very well established. While the mystery felt a bit rushed, or too easy (I was able to identify whodunit pretty quickly) I think that it was appropriate for a first-book, where most of the heavy lifting is done in establishing our main characters and their motivations. And what main characters!
I admit, it took awhile for North to grow on me. The author did a great job in mellowing out my initial reaction to him using some well-placed backstory drops. He is the heir and a Peer, so of course he grew up a bit spoiled and without too many life skills. That's part of his charm. He also has a true sense of right, wrong, and justice, and he stands up for what's right. He also has keen observational skills that he uses to great effect. And then there is Lady Hypatia. She was my absolute favorite, and my preferred POV character. She has been through a lot - all historically accurate to the time, even if her and North's reactions to it may skew a bit more modern - and she still remains intelligent, steadfast, and kind.
If you're looking for romance, this may not be the series for you. There are hints of a connection, but despite North's near instant attraction, Hypatia is determined to be friends. If there is any romance, this will be a slow-burn one. Hopefully over several future books? I think that worked well for the story - this is a murder mystery, and the plot was more about the characters learning to trust each other.
Great start to the fall season. While this wasn't a fall book, it had the cozy vibes that I'm looking for as the weather turns cooler. Thank you very much to NetGalley and Oliver Heber Books for access to this e-ARC in exchange for my review!
September 11, 2026
In the Midnight Hour is a wonderfully moody and addictive beginning to Darcy Burke’s new Regency mystery series. From the first pages, the atmosphere of Pemberton Square feels alive. The quiet respectability of the neighborhood is pierced by a shocking murder, and suddenly every shadow seems to hold a secret.
Viscount Northwood is a compelling anchor for the story. His disciplined routines and keen intelligence make him the perfect observer of the strange events unfolding around him. When Lady Hypatia enters the narrative, the energy shifts. She is elegant, enigmatic, and far more perceptive than society gives her credit for. Their early encounters carry a delicious tension, shaped by suspicion, curiosity, and an undeniable pull neither of them wants to acknowledge.
Burke builds the mystery with a deft hand. The anonymous broadsheets, the gathering crowds, the whispers that ripple through the square, all create a sense of tightening pressure. The partnership between North and Hypatia grows in that pressure, revealing layers of vulnerability, determination, and quiet courage. Even the presence of Quill, Hypatia’s sleek black cat (I love black cats!), adds to the book’s atmosphere, slipping through scenes like a familiar spirit.
The investigation is engaging and full of satisfying turns, but what truly elevates the story is the emotional undercurrent between the leads. Their guarded trust, their shared pursuit of truth, and the danger that begins to circle them make the final chapters especially gripping.
This is a beautifully crafted series opener. Rich setting, smart plotting, and two leads who feel wonderfully real. I loved this book and am already looking forward to the next mystery in Pemberton Square.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Viscount Northwood is a compelling anchor for the story. His disciplined routines and keen intelligence make him the perfect observer of the strange events unfolding around him. When Lady Hypatia enters the narrative, the energy shifts. She is elegant, enigmatic, and far more perceptive than society gives her credit for. Their early encounters carry a delicious tension, shaped by suspicion, curiosity, and an undeniable pull neither of them wants to acknowledge.
Burke builds the mystery with a deft hand. The anonymous broadsheets, the gathering crowds, the whispers that ripple through the square, all create a sense of tightening pressure. The partnership between North and Hypatia grows in that pressure, revealing layers of vulnerability, determination, and quiet courage. Even the presence of Quill, Hypatia’s sleek black cat (I love black cats!), adds to the book’s atmosphere, slipping through scenes like a familiar spirit.
The investigation is engaging and full of satisfying turns, but what truly elevates the story is the emotional undercurrent between the leads. Their guarded trust, their shared pursuit of truth, and the danger that begins to circle them make the final chapters especially gripping.
This is a beautifully crafted series opener. Rich setting, smart plotting, and two leads who feel wonderfully real. I loved this book and am already looking forward to the next mystery in Pemberton Square.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Review of advance copy received from Author
Jeremy Sheffield, the Viscount Northwood, heir to an Earldom, known to everyone as North, has just moved from his bachelor's quarters to a home of his own in Pemberton Square an exclusive neighborhood in 1819 London. Taking a stroll in the enclosed park in the early morning, he comes across an overwrought young footman looking for help. His employer, Sir Randor is dead. It appears that he fell out of bed and hit his head. As North's twin brother, Harry, has recently been promoted the position of coroner, and North has listened fascinatingly to his brother's stories when he was an officer on Bow Street, North starts an examination and asking questions that he believes his brother would do , while he also sends someone to get his brother. He also sends for a doctor. Harry sends a bow runner in his stead, Lachlan Drummond, who is not happy about North's interference, even though North prevented some evidence from being destroyed. The doctor was about to declare the death an accident, until North places doubts in his mind. Suspicions fall on Randor's lovely next door neighbor Lady Hypatia Cartwright, as she was his dinner guest earlier that evening. North doesn't believe she is a murderer, but she does have a secret. They decide to join forces to solve the murder, much to the chagrin of Harry. Harry had appeared earlier in one of the Raven and Wren stories and like them, it appears that this is the beginning of a similar slow burn romance for North and Hypatia. Well developed characters in this engaging story. Look forward to the next installment.
I read an ARC gifted to me by the publisher. This is my unbiased, voluntary and honest review.
I read an ARC gifted to me by the publisher. This is my unbiased, voluntary and honest review.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
If you enjoy murder mysteries, don't miss reading this book! I enjoyed it from beginning to end.
This is the first of an upcoming series, Only Murders in the Square.
The two main characters are North and Hypatia. North is actually Jeremy Sheffield, Viscount Northwood who goes by North. Hypatia is Lady Cartwright. They live across the square from each other in Pemberton Square of London.
North has just moved there. He is single and this is his first actual house. Hypatia has been living there for a short while. She bought it as a widow, so lives alone with some staff and a cat, Quinn.
When North left home that morning, he found a very upset footman of his neighbor crying out for help, that his master needs help. North goes with the footman and finds that the man, Sir Randor, is dead, lying on the floor of his bedroom.
Is it a natural death or a murder? North tells the staff to get a doctor and the police.
Lady Cartwright loves stories/books. She's been talking with Sir Randor about books frequently. Both of them are big readers. The last time she was with Sir Randor was Friday night before his dead body is found on Saturday.
The story unfolds well. Turns out that North is a twin and his twin brother, Harry Sheffield, has just been named the coroner.
North goes to Lady Cartwright and says that he'd like to work with her to prove her innocence. For the rest of the book, they work together and make progress. Brother Harry is not always happy about it, but they do give him some helpful information.
I'll be looking for the next book in this series!
This is the first of an upcoming series, Only Murders in the Square.
The two main characters are North and Hypatia. North is actually Jeremy Sheffield, Viscount Northwood who goes by North. Hypatia is Lady Cartwright. They live across the square from each other in Pemberton Square of London.
North has just moved there. He is single and this is his first actual house. Hypatia has been living there for a short while. She bought it as a widow, so lives alone with some staff and a cat, Quinn.
When North left home that morning, he found a very upset footman of his neighbor crying out for help, that his master needs help. North goes with the footman and finds that the man, Sir Randor, is dead, lying on the floor of his bedroom.
Is it a natural death or a murder? North tells the staff to get a doctor and the police.
Lady Cartwright loves stories/books. She's been talking with Sir Randor about books frequently. Both of them are big readers. The last time she was with Sir Randor was Friday night before his dead body is found on Saturday.
The story unfolds well. Turns out that North is a twin and his twin brother, Harry Sheffield, has just been named the coroner.
North goes to Lady Cartwright and says that he'd like to work with her to prove her innocence. For the rest of the book, they work together and make progress. Brother Harry is not always happy about it, but they do give him some helpful information.
I'll be looking for the next book in this series!
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Another great mystery and a first in the series.
Northwood "North" hasn't really done much in life, he lives the life of leisure, drinking, and gaming, a typical Lords idle life.
On one such evening of fun, as he is returning to his home in the early hours, a neighbours servant seeks his aid. He immediately follows the footman to the scene of Sir Radnor's murder.
Of course none of the servants know any wiser but they are removing vital evidence and North gets involved because something doesn't seem right. North understands the importance of leaving the scene untouched because his brother is a former Bow Street Runner and now a Coroner.
Within his limited experience but asking important questions, he has his own suspicions on who might be a suspect and that would be no other than Sir Radnor's friend and neighbour, the widow Lady Cartwright. She was the last one to see him alive.
Lady Cartwright seems to be the most likely suspect but North just can't believe she did it and once he realises she is doing her own investigation to clear her name, they decide to team up, work together on the case, and find the true killer!
This is a good first book to a the story. Good world building and as the series continues, we will learn more about the characters involved.
I enjoyed the intriguing mystery, the twists & turns, and the friendship that is building between North and Cartwright...I also loved her cat Quill!
Looking forward to the second book and hoping their relationship progresses
I received an ARC. All opinions expressed are my own and voluntarily provided
Northwood "North" hasn't really done much in life, he lives the life of leisure, drinking, and gaming, a typical Lords idle life.
On one such evening of fun, as he is returning to his home in the early hours, a neighbours servant seeks his aid. He immediately follows the footman to the scene of Sir Radnor's murder.
Of course none of the servants know any wiser but they are removing vital evidence and North gets involved because something doesn't seem right. North understands the importance of leaving the scene untouched because his brother is a former Bow Street Runner and now a Coroner.
Within his limited experience but asking important questions, he has his own suspicions on who might be a suspect and that would be no other than Sir Radnor's friend and neighbour, the widow Lady Cartwright. She was the last one to see him alive.
Lady Cartwright seems to be the most likely suspect but North just can't believe she did it and once he realises she is doing her own investigation to clear her name, they decide to team up, work together on the case, and find the true killer!
This is a good first book to a the story. Good world building and as the series continues, we will learn more about the characters involved.
I enjoyed the intriguing mystery, the twists & turns, and the friendship that is building between North and Cartwright...I also loved her cat Quill!
Looking forward to the second book and hoping their relationship progresses
I received an ARC. All opinions expressed are my own and voluntarily provided
September 5, 2026
I thank NetGalley and Oliver-Huber Books for an advanced reader copy of In the Midnight Hour. All opinions and comments are my own.
With In the Midnight Hour, there’s another competent detective duo on the scene. A reluctant one at first (as so many profess to be), but as things progress, Jeremy Sheffield, Viscount Northwood and Lady Hypatia Cartwright form an effective team solving the murder of a Pemberton Square neighbor. One who, as the story unfolds, definitely needed killing.
Not that that’s known at the beginning, of course. The police have Lady Cartwright in their sights, being Sir Radner’s last known visitor. Handy, the Regency propensity to accuse single women who visit single men of being up to no good! Luckily Lord ‘North’ is quick to help ensure that is foolishness. Someone killed the man, though, and since the police are sadly lacking in detective skills, it’s up to these two upper class ton members to solve the case.
There’s backstory galore to flesh out the characters, always a nice touch. Author Darcy Burke is no stranger to the historical mystery scene, and certainly knows how to bring setting, people and plot alive. It is apparent to all that Sir Radnor got what was coming to him, and not a moment too soon. Luckily, justice prevails, not always something that happened at the time the book is set. Readers even get a satisfying final twist of sorts.
Lord North and Lady Cartwright seem to be quite good at this investigative business, and their skills are going to be needed soon, it appears. In the Midnight Hour is a welcome addition to the genre.
With In the Midnight Hour, there’s another competent detective duo on the scene. A reluctant one at first (as so many profess to be), but as things progress, Jeremy Sheffield, Viscount Northwood and Lady Hypatia Cartwright form an effective team solving the murder of a Pemberton Square neighbor. One who, as the story unfolds, definitely needed killing.
Not that that’s known at the beginning, of course. The police have Lady Cartwright in their sights, being Sir Radner’s last known visitor. Handy, the Regency propensity to accuse single women who visit single men of being up to no good! Luckily Lord ‘North’ is quick to help ensure that is foolishness. Someone killed the man, though, and since the police are sadly lacking in detective skills, it’s up to these two upper class ton members to solve the case.
There’s backstory galore to flesh out the characters, always a nice touch. Author Darcy Burke is no stranger to the historical mystery scene, and certainly knows how to bring setting, people and plot alive. It is apparent to all that Sir Radnor got what was coming to him, and not a moment too soon. Luckily, justice prevails, not always something that happened at the time the book is set. Readers even get a satisfying final twist of sorts.
Lord North and Lady Cartwright seem to be quite good at this investigative business, and their skills are going to be needed soon, it appears. In the Midnight Hour is a welcome addition to the genre.
Review of advance copy received from Author
Jeremy Sheffield, Viscount Northwood (“North”) and heir to an Earldom is a bachelor who moves into a neighbourhood in Pemberton Square in London. While strolling in the early morning his next-door neighbour’s footman seems stressed out and urgently seeking someone’s assistance. North steps up to the man and asks what’s happening and how he may be of assistance. It is then that he hears Sir Radnor was found dead on the floor of his bedroom and there was lots of blood. He rushes up to offer his assistance and asks the housekeeper to stop cleaning up the blood from the carpet. At the same time, he sends for his twin brother, Harry, the newly appointed coroner to come take a look and the doctor.
Initial investigation seems to point the finger at the beautiful widow, Lady Hypatia Cartwright who was last seen having drinks with Sir Radnor last evening. North is convinced that Hypatia is innocent and persuades her to team up with him to clear her name. After an initial rejection of the idea, she realises unless she does some investigation of her own, she is likely to be named the chief and only suspect.
Lots of twists and turns and each time a potential suspect is identified, it quickly falls away leaving Hypatia once again with the “best” motive of killing Sir Radnor.
I am a big fan of Darcy Burke, and this new series is another winner. I cannot wait to read book 2 and would recommend it wholeheartedly. I received and ARC from the author with thanks and submit my honest review voluntarily.
Initial investigation seems to point the finger at the beautiful widow, Lady Hypatia Cartwright who was last seen having drinks with Sir Radnor last evening. North is convinced that Hypatia is innocent and persuades her to team up with him to clear her name. After an initial rejection of the idea, she realises unless she does some investigation of her own, she is likely to be named the chief and only suspect.
Lots of twists and turns and each time a potential suspect is identified, it quickly falls away leaving Hypatia once again with the “best” motive of killing Sir Radnor.
I am a big fan of Darcy Burke, and this new series is another winner. I cannot wait to read book 2 and would recommend it wholeheartedly. I received and ARC from the author with thanks and submit my honest review voluntarily.
Review of advance copy
Tropes: opposites attract; MC's team up to solve a mystery
Steam level: none
First in a series.
This is the first book in a new series by this author. I haven't read the books in her previous mystery series, but I have read previous HR's by her.
What I liked:
--Hypatia is a strong, intelligent MFC who is easy to sympathize with.
--The world building is good overall.
--The mystery is fairly intriguing, although I didn't care for the slight twist at the end, with the true baddie making a huge presumption and throwing the morality/justice motif into question.
What bugged me at times:
--Early chapters bring in characters such as Harry and Piers Huxley, without giving them enough backstory.
--Anachronistic behavior and speech from the servants.
What didn't work for me:
MMC North. He's presumptuous in both speech and behavior toward Hypatia; completely wrong for the time period. Even by today's standards, I would consider him annoying. Harry was exactly right in questioning his motives, which were vague, and while he behaved as if he had the authority of a Runner, he could have easily turned the case against Hypatia. And their pairing just felt off. It would have been less awkward if they were formerly engaged, or if she were the sister of a deceased best friend, at least. I didn't feel any connection or chemistry between them.
Bottom line: some mystery aspects are OK but the partnership/romance held no appeal for me.
This is my honest, voluntary of an advanced reader copy of this book. Thanks to the author, publisher, and Booksprout.
Steam level: none
First in a series.
This is the first book in a new series by this author. I haven't read the books in her previous mystery series, but I have read previous HR's by her.
What I liked:
--Hypatia is a strong, intelligent MFC who is easy to sympathize with.
--The world building is good overall.
--The mystery is fairly intriguing, although I didn't care for the slight twist at the end, with the true baddie making a huge presumption and throwing the morality/justice motif into question.
What bugged me at times:
--Early chapters bring in characters such as Harry and Piers Huxley, without giving them enough backstory.
--Anachronistic behavior and speech from the servants.
What didn't work for me:
MMC North. He's presumptuous in both speech and behavior toward Hypatia; completely wrong for the time period. Even by today's standards, I would consider him annoying. Harry was exactly right in questioning his motives, which were vague, and while he behaved as if he had the authority of a Runner, he could have easily turned the case against Hypatia. And their pairing just felt off. It would have been less awkward if they were formerly engaged, or if she were the sister of a deceased best friend, at least. I didn't feel any connection or chemistry between them.
Bottom line: some mystery aspects are OK but the partnership/romance held no appeal for me.
This is my honest, voluntary of an advanced reader copy of this book. Thanks to the author, publisher, and Booksprout.
September 21, 2026
Jeremy Sheffield, Viscount Northwood, has just moved to Pemberton Square. He comes across a disturbed footman on his way home from a night out and offers assistance. When he enters the townhouse of Sir Radnor Fieldstone, he finds the man dead in his bedroom. North calls his brother Henry, the newly appointed coroner, and a Bow Street Runner. He meets Lady Hypatia Cartwright, a widow, friend of Fieldstone, and a suspect in the murder (it doesn’t help that he left her most of his wealth in his will). They dined together on occasion when they discussed literature. She was at the house on the night of the murder. She declares her innocence, and she and North set out to prove it and find the real culprit. Darcy Burke’s new mystery series is off to a great start. There are a lot of twists and turns, and the story holds your attention and keeps you guessing the murder’s identity right up to the surprising solution. Hypatia and North work well together even though she is a bit uneasy. North has little trouble letting go of his idle lifestyle and throws himself into the investigation, which surprises Henry who has always been the more serious brother. He, like Hypatia, keeps a wary eye on North. There is a hint of a future romance between North and Hypatia. Pemberton Square promises to be an interesting community. I look forward to more adventures with North, Hypatia, and their neighbors. Entertaining narration by Eilidh Beaton and Philip Battley.
I voluntarily reviewed a special copy of this book.
I voluntarily reviewed a special copy of this book.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
The dead man was a gross old man, the kind who sees a widow's friendship as a marriage prospect and turns aggressive when she says no. Hypatia flees Sir Radnor's house that night and wakes up the prime suspect. But North is the one person who believes her, and that makes the whole story work.
Jeremy Sheffield, Viscount Northwood (or "North") and Lady Cartwright (Hypatia) are new neighbors on Pemberton Square. North's a little lost and a little bored, an idle aristocrat. Hypatia is a well-off widow who loves books. She's wary about partnering with him to solve this murder, but when she realizes he's the only one who believes her, and that he's serious about it, she gives in. And they're great together: funny, flirty and sincere.
I can see some first-of-a-new-series setup, and I assume we'll get to know the ensemble and side characters more as it goes. A few threads wrapped up too cleanly – like jumping to conclusions without a net. And at first the book feels like it lives in a world the reader is already supposed to know. Not quite a sequel, but some overlap: I did a bit of research, and North's twin brother was the MMC in a previous book. You don't need his story to enjoy this one, but it would've helped just to know. Thinking I'd missed something took me out of the story.
Overall, a fun, fast cozy mystery, and I'll probably come back for book two just to see North and Hypatia (and her cat, Quill) work together again.
Jeremy Sheffield, Viscount Northwood (or "North") and Lady Cartwright (Hypatia) are new neighbors on Pemberton Square. North's a little lost and a little bored, an idle aristocrat. Hypatia is a well-off widow who loves books. She's wary about partnering with him to solve this murder, but when she realizes he's the only one who believes her, and that he's serious about it, she gives in. And they're great together: funny, flirty and sincere.
I can see some first-of-a-new-series setup, and I assume we'll get to know the ensemble and side characters more as it goes. A few threads wrapped up too cleanly – like jumping to conclusions without a net. And at first the book feels like it lives in a world the reader is already supposed to know. Not quite a sequel, but some overlap: I did a bit of research, and North's twin brother was the MMC in a previous book. You don't need his story to enjoy this one, but it would've helped just to know. Thinking I'd missed something took me out of the story.
Overall, a fun, fast cozy mystery, and I'll probably come back for book two just to see North and Hypatia (and her cat, Quill) work together again.
Review of advance copy received from Author
Idle heir to an earldom, Jeremy Sheffield, Viscount Northwood drifts through life with little purpose until a shocking murder shatters the calm of his quiet London square. He’s just moved from his rooms in the Albany to Pemberton Square. He’s heading home after a night on the town when he sees a distraught footman. He immediately offers his aid & enters Sir Radnor Fieldstone’s home to find Radnor lying dead in his bedroom. North sends for his twin brother Henry, the newly appointed coroner & for a Bow Street Runner. The prime suspect is widow Lady Hypatia Cartwright who was a friend a Radnor’s as they shared a love of literature & frequently dined together.
The start of a new series but we’ve met the Sheffield twins before. Another well written riveting murder mystery from the author & also what I hope will be a slow burn romance. I loved both North & Hypatia, he’s been drifting so this mystery came at the right time for him to find a purpose. Hypatia is determined to prove her innocence especially after she’s named as the main beneficiary in Radnor’s will. I loved how they begin an uneasy partnership to solve the case. Pemberton Square is a close knit community & I look forward to getting to know more of the inhabitants. The secondary characters are well portrayed. There are twists & turns as the couple delve into motives for the murder & not everything is as it seems.
I voluntarily read and reviewed a special copy of this book; all thoughts and opinions are my own
The start of a new series but we’ve met the Sheffield twins before. Another well written riveting murder mystery from the author & also what I hope will be a slow burn romance. I loved both North & Hypatia, he’s been drifting so this mystery came at the right time for him to find a purpose. Hypatia is determined to prove her innocence especially after she’s named as the main beneficiary in Radnor’s will. I loved how they begin an uneasy partnership to solve the case. Pemberton Square is a close knit community & I look forward to getting to know more of the inhabitants. The secondary characters are well portrayed. There are twists & turns as the couple delve into motives for the murder & not everything is as it seems.
I voluntarily read and reviewed a special copy of this book; all thoughts and opinions are my own
September 8, 2026
In the Midnight Hour: A Regency Mystery Series is a new series by Darcy Burke.
Jeremy Sheffield, Viscount Northwood, has recently moved into his new home on Pemberton Square. North is at loose ends after moving into his new house. One morning, he comes across a stray black cat as a man in livery yells for help. He cannot help but be curious about the man's behavior. The footman tells North, as he is known, that one of the distinguished neighbors is dead. He offers to contact his twin brother, who is the coroner, to come help. A Bow Street Runner is sent instead. As the Runner investigates, he primarily accepts the versions he is told at face value. But he quickly focuses on Lady Hypatia Cartwright, who also lives nearby. She apparently left by the backway around midnight. North decides to do his own investigation and informs his brother of what he has found. His brother reluctantly investigates what his brother has learned. Soon after, North and Hypatia become partners and investigate to clear her name.
I found this story to be very charming. I was hooked from the first few pages. I enjoyed the characters. They were entertaining and believable. The story took many twists and turns, though I kept wondering about certain things that were not resolved until they were. Everything was wrapped up into a nice bow. I look forward to the next book in the series.
I received an ARC from NetGalley for an unbiased review.
Jeremy Sheffield, Viscount Northwood, has recently moved into his new home on Pemberton Square. North is at loose ends after moving into his new house. One morning, he comes across a stray black cat as a man in livery yells for help. He cannot help but be curious about the man's behavior. The footman tells North, as he is known, that one of the distinguished neighbors is dead. He offers to contact his twin brother, who is the coroner, to come help. A Bow Street Runner is sent instead. As the Runner investigates, he primarily accepts the versions he is told at face value. But he quickly focuses on Lady Hypatia Cartwright, who also lives nearby. She apparently left by the backway around midnight. North decides to do his own investigation and informs his brother of what he has found. His brother reluctantly investigates what his brother has learned. Soon after, North and Hypatia become partners and investigate to clear her name.
I found this story to be very charming. I was hooked from the first few pages. I enjoyed the characters. They were entertaining and believable. The story took many twists and turns, though I kept wondering about certain things that were not resolved until they were. Everything was wrapped up into a nice bow. I look forward to the next book in the series.
I received an ARC from NetGalley for an unbiased review.
September 8, 2026
Book 1 in the Only Murders in the Square series by Darcy Burke is a bit different than she's written before. I've read a few of Ms. Burke's prior books and they're romancy and fun. This book is different and very intriguing!
Lord Northwood, intercepts a footman from another home on Pemberton Square when the footman is calling for help. His master, Sir Radnor, is dead! North, goes with the footman to see if he can help. Something feels 'off' about the scene and North asks his twin brother, who is the coroner, to help.
Lady Hypatia Cartwright, another resident of Pemberton Square soon is found out to have possibly been the last person to see Sir Radnor before he died. She has had a literary friendship with Sir Radnor, talking books and plays. But, after their last meeting is there something deeper and more sinister happening?
After the inquest that is inconclusive, Hypatia and North team up to make sure Hypatia is not railroaded into being named as the murderess. With no formal detective training between them, but pretty good reasoning skills, North and Hypatia figure out what happened...and it's not what you might think.
I just loved this fast paced mystery. Lots of twists and turns as the story fills in gaps. Quill was my favorite and has an immense part in figuring out what happened! The somewhat cliffhanger ending has me marking time until the next book in this series. Can. Not. Wait.
Lord Northwood, intercepts a footman from another home on Pemberton Square when the footman is calling for help. His master, Sir Radnor, is dead! North, goes with the footman to see if he can help. Something feels 'off' about the scene and North asks his twin brother, who is the coroner, to help.
Lady Hypatia Cartwright, another resident of Pemberton Square soon is found out to have possibly been the last person to see Sir Radnor before he died. She has had a literary friendship with Sir Radnor, talking books and plays. But, after their last meeting is there something deeper and more sinister happening?
After the inquest that is inconclusive, Hypatia and North team up to make sure Hypatia is not railroaded into being named as the murderess. With no formal detective training between them, but pretty good reasoning skills, North and Hypatia figure out what happened...and it's not what you might think.
I just loved this fast paced mystery. Lots of twists and turns as the story fills in gaps. Quill was my favorite and has an immense part in figuring out what happened! The somewhat cliffhanger ending has me marking time until the next book in this series. Can. Not. Wait.
September 9, 2026
I struggled to understand North’s involvement since he was new to the square and everyone is a stranger to him. Why was he invested and why defend Hypatia? And why does he care deeply about justice and for women to be believed?
Don’t expect a romance. I never believed North genuinely liked Hypatia. She’s alluring, charming, beguiling because she ignores you and is pretty? He’s not even considering love, just maybe a hookup in the future. The lack of chemistry surprised me since this author’s romances have a ton of it. Hypatia of course rebuffs him and I can’t see why she wouldn’t.
I felt like there was another series of books I had to read before this one. Characters mentioned and dropped, or others brought in like I was supposed to already care about them and know their history. I don’t mind starting a story late, but I felt like I was missing things.
Two characters have the same blue and red carpet and I thought that was a clue, but it was just a mistake, and the servants relationships with employees felt anachronistic. The square was set up like a community, but we never see the neighbors interact until the epilogue. This mystery was a little weak with not enough clues for me to solve, and the pacing not great.
I’ve liked other mystery and romance books from this author and I’ll give the next book in this series a try. Maybe the romance and storytelling will improve when there’s no setup or backstories the slow things down.
I received an arc through BookSprout
Don’t expect a romance. I never believed North genuinely liked Hypatia. She’s alluring, charming, beguiling because she ignores you and is pretty? He’s not even considering love, just maybe a hookup in the future. The lack of chemistry surprised me since this author’s romances have a ton of it. Hypatia of course rebuffs him and I can’t see why she wouldn’t.
I felt like there was another series of books I had to read before this one. Characters mentioned and dropped, or others brought in like I was supposed to already care about them and know their history. I don’t mind starting a story late, but I felt like I was missing things.
Two characters have the same blue and red carpet and I thought that was a clue, but it was just a mistake, and the servants relationships with employees felt anachronistic. The square was set up like a community, but we never see the neighbors interact until the epilogue. This mystery was a little weak with not enough clues for me to solve, and the pacing not great.
I’ve liked other mystery and romance books from this author and I’ll give the next book in this series a try. Maybe the romance and storytelling will improve when there’s no setup or backstories the slow things down.
I received an arc through BookSprout
Displaying 1 - 30 of 109 reviews