What do you think?
Rate this book
The Silver Teapot #2
Not Precisely Mr. Knightley
Can the Matchmaker Find True Love?
Emma-Jane (EJ) Bennett and Jordan Knight are longtime best friends who codesigned the immensely successful dating app, Dream Match. Success starts to go to EJ's head when she gets caught up in the famous and money-hungry social circles and starts dating the son of a TV mogul. But Jordan's feelings have grown from friendship to more. He determines to protect her by exposing Eric Churchill for the two-timer he is, finally agreeing to attend a function with her at the Sydney Opera House. But his best intentions go awry when EJ is embarrassed and runs for the security of home, small-town roots, and The Silver Teapot Café, feeling like Jane Austen's chastised Emma--only without her Mr. Knightley.
Don't miss book 1 in The Silver Teapot series, Not Exactly Mr. Darcy
Emma-Jane (EJ) Bennett and Jordan Knight are longtime best friends who codesigned the immensely successful dating app, Dream Match. Success starts to go to EJ's head when she gets caught up in the famous and money-hungry social circles and starts dating the son of a TV mogul. But Jordan's feelings have grown from friendship to more. He determines to protect her by exposing Eric Churchill for the two-timer he is, finally agreeing to attend a function with her at the Sydney Opera House. But his best intentions go awry when EJ is embarrassed and runs for the security of home, small-town roots, and The Silver Teapot Café, feeling like Jane Austen's chastised Emma--only without her Mr. Knightley.
Don't miss book 1 in The Silver Teapot series, Not Exactly Mr. Darcy
256 pages, Kindle Edition
Published May 1, 2026
16 people are currently reading
1303 people want to read
About the author
Carolyn Miller
61 books1,192 followersLibrarian Note: There is more than one author in the Goodreads database with this name.
Carolyn Miller lives in the beautiful Southern Highlands of New South Wales, Australia, with her husband and four children. A longtime lover of romance, Carolyn loves drawing readers into fictional worlds that show the truth of God’s grace in our lives. Her bestselling, award-winning Regency and contemporary novels are stories that offer hope, heart, and a twist of Aussie humour. Connect with her at www.carolynmillerauthor.com where you can find our more about her books, and sign up for her newsletter to be the first to know her book news.
Carolyn Miller lives in the beautiful Southern Highlands of New South Wales, Australia, with her husband and four children. A longtime lover of romance, Carolyn loves drawing readers into fictional worlds that show the truth of God’s grace in our lives. Her bestselling, award-winning Regency and contemporary novels are stories that offer hope, heart, and a twist of Aussie humour. Connect with her at www.carolynmillerauthor.com where you can find our more about her books, and sign up for her newsletter to be the first to know her book news.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 62 reviews
March 1, 2026
EJ (Emma-Jane) is a modern girl with goals. Big goals. The creator of a highly successful dating app, she's eager to improve both her social connections and her app. And she's eager to rub elbows with the ultra rich in order to make that happen.
Jordan, EJ's lifelong BFF, is a hard-working corporate guy and solid man of faith. He instantly sees through EJ's new so-called friends, and is willing to risk their friendship to point out their highly questionable motives.
I especially liked the extended family involvement and relationships, and how faith is naturally woven into the character's thoughts and responses, with Scripture and spontaneous prayers popping up often.
I enjoyed this poignant, well written story of a young woman's eye opening discovery that all that glitters is not gold. And that faith, family, truth, and love matter more than all the so-called success in the world.
Thank you to the author and publisher providing me an ARC of "Not Precisely Mr Knightley".
Jordan, EJ's lifelong BFF, is a hard-working corporate guy and solid man of faith. He instantly sees through EJ's new so-called friends, and is willing to risk their friendship to point out their highly questionable motives.
I especially liked the extended family involvement and relationships, and how faith is naturally woven into the character's thoughts and responses, with Scripture and spontaneous prayers popping up often.
I enjoyed this poignant, well written story of a young woman's eye opening discovery that all that glitters is not gold. And that faith, family, truth, and love matter more than all the so-called success in the world.
Thank you to the author and publisher providing me an ARC of "Not Precisely Mr Knightley".
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Oh, this book had me feeling all the emotions, including irritation, frustration, contrition, and joy. In other words, all the things that make us human. It's no secret that the author is able to evoke such responses based on how real she gets in her stories. Characters are three-dimensional and they become people whom you want to hug and sometimes offer a hard truth to at the same time (in love, of course). Emma-Jane, or EJ as she prefers to be called, is no exception. Seeing her gradual descent into hurtful thinking and behaviours, I couldn't help but want her to see just what she was doing to herself in her pursuit of the good life. That's the same attitude that Jordan, her best friend, has adopted, which allowed me to step into his shoes while witnessing EJ in her actions. Yet, it wouldn't be a Carolyn Miller book without that mirror being turned around on us as readers where we can witness the very same things happening in our lives that we need deliverance from.
I love that this isn't an easy story to read because it shows how quickly things can escalate when we operate in our own strength instead of the Lord's. With many nods to Jane Austen, including a touch of the Crawford siblings in the form of new advisers and potential investors, there are an incredible amount of Easter eggs to unearth in this modern rendition of Emma. Even when we are at our most unlikeable and stubborn, God still pursues and redeems us when we call out to Him. Readers looking for books that don't gloss over seemingly innocuous sins will appreciate the end result of God refining us through the help of His people, especially when they become the Mr. Knightleys who care enough to say something and to lovingly offer correction. Those scenes alone in this book will strike your heart while expounding biblical truths about who we really we and who we belong to.
Review link: https://christianshelves.blogspot.com...
Many thanks to Barbour Books and NetGalley for providing a complimentary copy of this book for review consideration. All opinions are my own.
I love that this isn't an easy story to read because it shows how quickly things can escalate when we operate in our own strength instead of the Lord's. With many nods to Jane Austen, including a touch of the Crawford siblings in the form of new advisers and potential investors, there are an incredible amount of Easter eggs to unearth in this modern rendition of Emma. Even when we are at our most unlikeable and stubborn, God still pursues and redeems us when we call out to Him. Readers looking for books that don't gloss over seemingly innocuous sins will appreciate the end result of God refining us through the help of His people, especially when they become the Mr. Knightleys who care enough to say something and to lovingly offer correction. Those scenes alone in this book will strike your heart while expounding biblical truths about who we really we and who we belong to.
Review link: https://christianshelves.blogspot.com...
Many thanks to Barbour Books and NetGalley for providing a complimentary copy of this book for review consideration. All opinions are my own.
April 26, 2026
4.5 ⭐️
I went into this not really knowing what to expect as I’ve never read this author before and I was absolutely blown away by the beautiful depth of this story.
I’ll admit, there were a few times I wanted to knock some sense into EJ but then I stopped & thought just how relatable and “real life” her struggles were: struggling with knowing that God is enough, that God has great plans for her even if they look different then what the world says is “great”, that she is loved & cherished just the way she is, and learning what truly is most important to her in life.
And then Jordan, oh sweet green flag Jordan, having to sit on the sidelines and watch his best friend make certain choices…..having to learn that only God can change hearts, that only God can get someone to see & accept the truth and struggling to trust that he could leave it all in God’s hands and trust Him to accomplish His Will.
This is so much more than a contemporary Christian “romcom”. There is depth and real life. I absolutely loved this story. And all of the Emma/Jane Austen nods were so great and fun to pick out!
If you enjoy contemporary Christian fiction, definitely give this one a try. Yes, there’s (clean) romance but there’s a whole lot more to it than that and the Faith-lessons are things that I think we all need reminders of!
*This is book 2 in the series. Book 1 main characters are minor side characters in this book, so you do get some spoilers with their relationship but overall it’s a completely different storyline then book 1*
*Thank you to Barbour Books for this ARC copy. All opinions are my own and not influenced in any way.*
I went into this not really knowing what to expect as I’ve never read this author before and I was absolutely blown away by the beautiful depth of this story.
I’ll admit, there were a few times I wanted to knock some sense into EJ but then I stopped & thought just how relatable and “real life” her struggles were: struggling with knowing that God is enough, that God has great plans for her even if they look different then what the world says is “great”, that she is loved & cherished just the way she is, and learning what truly is most important to her in life.
And then Jordan, oh sweet green flag Jordan, having to sit on the sidelines and watch his best friend make certain choices…..having to learn that only God can change hearts, that only God can get someone to see & accept the truth and struggling to trust that he could leave it all in God’s hands and trust Him to accomplish His Will.
This is so much more than a contemporary Christian “romcom”. There is depth and real life. I absolutely loved this story. And all of the Emma/Jane Austen nods were so great and fun to pick out!
If you enjoy contemporary Christian fiction, definitely give this one a try. Yes, there’s (clean) romance but there’s a whole lot more to it than that and the Faith-lessons are things that I think we all need reminders of!
*This is book 2 in the series. Book 1 main characters are minor side characters in this book, so you do get some spoilers with their relationship but overall it’s a completely different storyline then book 1*
*Thank you to Barbour Books for this ARC copy. All opinions are my own and not influenced in any way.*
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Oh, EJ, what are you thinking?… This is what I kept telling her (Emma-Jane Bennett AKA EJ) throughout the book. I absolutely adore Emma by Jane Austen, and I adored Not Precisely Mr. Knightley too! If you’re a Jane Austen fan, you’ll love finding the similarities between the two novels. I’m sure there are some that I didn’t even pick up on, but it sure was fun when I discovered them.
EJ and Jordan Knight, her best friend since elementary school, are co-creators of Dream Match which is an app designed for Christian singles. It's meant to be unique, and it is. However, EJ loves the finer life, and when investors and potential investors push to get rid of the Christian element, EJ starts wavering. These characters just leap off of the page, and if you’re anything like I am (a flawed human), you might just start seeing yourself in EJ, yet hoping you are more like Jordan.
EJ is SO self-centered, and I feel that. It’s a joke among my 2 sisters and me that as long as the world revolves around me, life is good. Yeah, I was that teenager… Thankfully, I’ve grown, yet it is so easy to be selfish and want what you want! EJ loves the high life. She lives in her great-aunt’s flat with a view of the Sydney Opera House. She wants designer clothes and is always concerned with appearances. You know, there’s nothing wrong with having nice things, and EJ gives a lot to charity. However, when appearances and living the high life become first in your life, that’s an issue. Here’s a quote that sums up EJ’s thinking near the beginning of the book. I found it very amusing because sometimes I can justify my selfishness just like she does!
(After arguing with Jordan about her selfishness…)
“And okay, maybe she had been a teensy bit selfish, focusing on her own goals and not making time for others, nor making time for him.” Then she thinks to herself that SHE is the bigger person because she forgave him for his “jealousy” of her shiny new friends with money. Oh, EJ.
Needless to say, Jordan is the much more mature of the two, not only in general but also in his faith. He truly loves EJ and wants the best for her. Jordan knows that EJ needs to get her relationship right with God, and only God can turn her back around to Him. Here’s a quote about Jordan that I loved:
“He wanted his ears tuned into the One whose voice set the world in motion.”
Carolyn Miller’s books are some of my favorites because she writes characters like this. Characters that are flawed. Ones like EJ who depicts how easy it is to be drawn into wanting worldly treasures and how easy it is to stop making time for God. To stop listening to that “still small voice.” Miller also knows how to develop characters that experience growth throughout the book, and that’s exactly what happens with EJ. She realizes that it doesn’t matter how much money she has if she is putting God last. Putting family and loyal friends last. What’s important is God and your relationship with Him, and Miller portrays this amazingly!
Needless to say, I highly recommend Not Precisely Mr. Knightly for its characters, Biblical message, and of course, the sweet romance! 5 stars!
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.
EJ and Jordan Knight, her best friend since elementary school, are co-creators of Dream Match which is an app designed for Christian singles. It's meant to be unique, and it is. However, EJ loves the finer life, and when investors and potential investors push to get rid of the Christian element, EJ starts wavering. These characters just leap off of the page, and if you’re anything like I am (a flawed human), you might just start seeing yourself in EJ, yet hoping you are more like Jordan.
EJ is SO self-centered, and I feel that. It’s a joke among my 2 sisters and me that as long as the world revolves around me, life is good. Yeah, I was that teenager… Thankfully, I’ve grown, yet it is so easy to be selfish and want what you want! EJ loves the high life. She lives in her great-aunt’s flat with a view of the Sydney Opera House. She wants designer clothes and is always concerned with appearances. You know, there’s nothing wrong with having nice things, and EJ gives a lot to charity. However, when appearances and living the high life become first in your life, that’s an issue. Here’s a quote that sums up EJ’s thinking near the beginning of the book. I found it very amusing because sometimes I can justify my selfishness just like she does!
(After arguing with Jordan about her selfishness…)
“And okay, maybe she had been a teensy bit selfish, focusing on her own goals and not making time for others, nor making time for him.” Then she thinks to herself that SHE is the bigger person because she forgave him for his “jealousy” of her shiny new friends with money. Oh, EJ.
Needless to say, Jordan is the much more mature of the two, not only in general but also in his faith. He truly loves EJ and wants the best for her. Jordan knows that EJ needs to get her relationship right with God, and only God can turn her back around to Him. Here’s a quote about Jordan that I loved:
“He wanted his ears tuned into the One whose voice set the world in motion.”
Carolyn Miller’s books are some of my favorites because she writes characters like this. Characters that are flawed. Ones like EJ who depicts how easy it is to be drawn into wanting worldly treasures and how easy it is to stop making time for God. To stop listening to that “still small voice.” Miller also knows how to develop characters that experience growth throughout the book, and that’s exactly what happens with EJ. She realizes that it doesn’t matter how much money she has if she is putting God last. Putting family and loyal friends last. What’s important is God and your relationship with Him, and Miller portrays this amazingly!
Needless to say, I highly recommend Not Precisely Mr. Knightly for its characters, Biblical message, and of course, the sweet romance! 5 stars!
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Stars: 4.25
“God is faithful, EJ. See what He’s done in the past ten years? You can keep trusting Him with the rest of your future too.”
This book is so different than what I expected and not at all in a bad way! I really enjoyed it! It’s well-written and goes into the life of a Christian and what it means to put God first - it’s a story that makes you reflect.
EJ struggles with proving herself through money and success above all else. Jordan has always been there to support her but is struggling to call her out in love as her decisions become more damaging. It’s hard to watch EJ make some of the decisions that she does, and she isn’t entirely likeable (but necessary for her character arc). Jordan doesn’t handle everything perfectly either. But they grow, and I love the growth that they both experience. The dual POV storytelling is perfect for showcasing this. Overall, it’s a very real feeling story - someone is wrestling with their faith, temptation, and God’s position in their life while someone else is watching a loved one make damaging choices and having to trust God with the outcome. I’ve certainly been on both sides of that!
I really appreciate the heavy faith themes. I love that EJ and Jordan are having conversations about God, wrestling with God and their faith, and praying. I especially love that he prays for her over and over again!
And a special shoutout to the setting! Australia is a bucket list destination for me, so it was fun to read a book set in and around Sydney.
Having never read or seen adaptations of Jane Austen’s Emma, those references and connections didn’t mean much to me, but I caught on to some of the other Austen references.
There are a few times where the writing feels a little redundant or over explained IMO, but it didn’t really detract from my overall reading experience.
Content: kisses-only, clean romance; clean language; heavy faith themes; a couple of unwanted advances from men; social drinking with slight over-indulgence at times; cheating (not by our main characters!)
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and was under no obligation to post a review.
“God is faithful, EJ. See what He’s done in the past ten years? You can keep trusting Him with the rest of your future too.”
This book is so different than what I expected and not at all in a bad way! I really enjoyed it! It’s well-written and goes into the life of a Christian and what it means to put God first - it’s a story that makes you reflect.
EJ struggles with proving herself through money and success above all else. Jordan has always been there to support her but is struggling to call her out in love as her decisions become more damaging. It’s hard to watch EJ make some of the decisions that she does, and she isn’t entirely likeable (but necessary for her character arc). Jordan doesn’t handle everything perfectly either. But they grow, and I love the growth that they both experience. The dual POV storytelling is perfect for showcasing this. Overall, it’s a very real feeling story - someone is wrestling with their faith, temptation, and God’s position in their life while someone else is watching a loved one make damaging choices and having to trust God with the outcome. I’ve certainly been on both sides of that!
I really appreciate the heavy faith themes. I love that EJ and Jordan are having conversations about God, wrestling with God and their faith, and praying. I especially love that he prays for her over and over again!
And a special shoutout to the setting! Australia is a bucket list destination for me, so it was fun to read a book set in and around Sydney.
Having never read or seen adaptations of Jane Austen’s Emma, those references and connections didn’t mean much to me, but I caught on to some of the other Austen references.
There are a few times where the writing feels a little redundant or over explained IMO, but it didn’t really detract from my overall reading experience.
Content: kisses-only, clean romance; clean language; heavy faith themes; a couple of unwanted advances from men; social drinking with slight over-indulgence at times; cheating (not by our main characters!)
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and was under no obligation to post a review.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
**★★★★☆ | Charming, Thoughtful, and Full of Heart**
*Not Precisely Mr. Knightley* by Carolyn Miller is a warm and engaging modern retelling that captures the spirit of *Emma* while adding its own heartfelt, contemporary twist.
At the center of the story is EJ, a driven and ambitious character whose journey feels both relatable and meaningful. Watching her navigate success, pride, and the pull between ambition and authenticity adds a strong emotional layer to the story. Her growth is one of the highlights, especially as she begins to reevaluate what truly matters.
The dynamic between EJ and Jordan is where the story really shines. Their friends-to-lovers relationship is filled with tension, loyalty, and quiet emotion that builds naturally over time. Jordan, in particular, brings a steady, grounded presence that balances EJ’s more impulsive decisions, making their connection feel both realistic and rewarding.
The modern elements—especially the dating app—offer a fresh take on the classic matchmaking theme, while still maintaining clear parallels to the original inspiration. Fans of *Emma* will recognize familiar character types and story beats, but the updated setting keeps it feeling new.
The inclusion of faith is woven thoughtfully throughout the story, adding depth to the characters’ decisions and personal growth without overpowering the narrative.
The pacing is smooth and easy to follow, though there are a few moments where certain conflicts or resolutions feel a bit predictable. Still, the emotional journey and character development make it an enjoyable and satisfying read.
Overall, *Not Precisely Mr. Knightley* is a charming and uplifting romance that blends humor, heart, and meaningful life lessons. It’s a great pick for readers who enjoy modern Austen retellings, friends-to-lovers dynamics, and stories centered on growth and second chances.
**Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing an ARC in exchange for an honest review.**
*Not Precisely Mr. Knightley* by Carolyn Miller is a warm and engaging modern retelling that captures the spirit of *Emma* while adding its own heartfelt, contemporary twist.
At the center of the story is EJ, a driven and ambitious character whose journey feels both relatable and meaningful. Watching her navigate success, pride, and the pull between ambition and authenticity adds a strong emotional layer to the story. Her growth is one of the highlights, especially as she begins to reevaluate what truly matters.
The dynamic between EJ and Jordan is where the story really shines. Their friends-to-lovers relationship is filled with tension, loyalty, and quiet emotion that builds naturally over time. Jordan, in particular, brings a steady, grounded presence that balances EJ’s more impulsive decisions, making their connection feel both realistic and rewarding.
The modern elements—especially the dating app—offer a fresh take on the classic matchmaking theme, while still maintaining clear parallels to the original inspiration. Fans of *Emma* will recognize familiar character types and story beats, but the updated setting keeps it feeling new.
The inclusion of faith is woven thoughtfully throughout the story, adding depth to the characters’ decisions and personal growth without overpowering the narrative.
The pacing is smooth and easy to follow, though there are a few moments where certain conflicts or resolutions feel a bit predictable. Still, the emotional journey and character development make it an enjoyable and satisfying read.
Overall, *Not Precisely Mr. Knightley* is a charming and uplifting romance that blends humor, heart, and meaningful life lessons. It’s a great pick for readers who enjoy modern Austen retellings, friends-to-lovers dynamics, and stories centered on growth and second chances.
**Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing an ARC in exchange for an honest review.**
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
3.5 stars
" . . she'd always had a thing for the finer things in life, something that was shown by her wannabe-designer clothes and focus on money, money, money . .. . "
Emma-Jane Bennett had worked really hard for a long time, designing a highly successful dating app, while excelling at her full time position with Donwell Enterprises. Now was the time to see if the little bird could fly out of the nest and scale up "Dream Match" into a global product, meaning she and her business partner (and best friend!) Jordan Knight needed investors.
In theory, dropping her day job and schmoozing with the rich and famous had seemed like a good idea until Jordan starting reminding her of the true source of security and it wasn't listed on the stock market. Brushing off Jordan's caution, and not wanting to be reminded that her heart was dangerously close to being handed off to the wrong man, Emma-Jane convinces herself that the creator of a dating app certainly knows who the right man should be, right?
What kept me from loving this book as much as I wanted to was the setting, it continually muffled the narrative; details about travel modes, parks, shorelines, restaurants and other forms of entertainment took time away from quality conversations between characters who were battling for relationship and purpose, burying core elements of the story under a veritable travelogue.
That being said, the author did a wonderful job of bringing to light the challenges of building and maintaining a firm foundation of faith in a world, particularly the business world, that cares more about appearance and prestige than truth and integrity. Bravo to Emma-Jane and Jordan for finding their way!
I voluntarily reviewed a copy of this book for Barbour Publishing, the opinions stated above are entirely my own.
" . . she'd always had a thing for the finer things in life, something that was shown by her wannabe-designer clothes and focus on money, money, money . .. . "
Emma-Jane Bennett had worked really hard for a long time, designing a highly successful dating app, while excelling at her full time position with Donwell Enterprises. Now was the time to see if the little bird could fly out of the nest and scale up "Dream Match" into a global product, meaning she and her business partner (and best friend!) Jordan Knight needed investors.
In theory, dropping her day job and schmoozing with the rich and famous had seemed like a good idea until Jordan starting reminding her of the true source of security and it wasn't listed on the stock market. Brushing off Jordan's caution, and not wanting to be reminded that her heart was dangerously close to being handed off to the wrong man, Emma-Jane convinces herself that the creator of a dating app certainly knows who the right man should be, right?
What kept me from loving this book as much as I wanted to was the setting, it continually muffled the narrative; details about travel modes, parks, shorelines, restaurants and other forms of entertainment took time away from quality conversations between characters who were battling for relationship and purpose, burying core elements of the story under a veritable travelogue.
That being said, the author did a wonderful job of bringing to light the challenges of building and maintaining a firm foundation of faith in a world, particularly the business world, that cares more about appearance and prestige than truth and integrity. Bravo to Emma-Jane and Jordan for finding their way!
I voluntarily reviewed a copy of this book for Barbour Publishing, the opinions stated above are entirely my own.
May 1, 2026
EJ was mocked for wearing second-hand clothing as a kid, and ever since, she's been determined to make sure she's never in that position again. But when the search for investors for her Christian dating app throws her together with billionaire Eric Churchill, her search for worldly success more than ever causes her to question her motives and values. Can she come to see that her worth isn't in what she has or her social position but in God? And as she begins to see Jordan, her long-time friend and partner in the app's development, in a new light, will she be in time to see whether there could truly be something between them - or has she been blind for too long?
An enjoyable loose retelling of Emma in a modern setting. I'm not a fan of Emma's character for most of the original, and the same carries through to here - but Jordan (and Mr Knightley) are great. EJ's focus on social climbing put me offside before I got fairly started, but the hope of improvement/redemption kept me reading - and I don't regret it. After lots of foolish choices, Jordan's patience and willingness to say what needed to be said finally got through to her, which was great to see. As for Eric, I don't understand that sort of lifestyle and don't want to. But Jordan and EJ's families are great and I loved getting to know them. As a retelling, it sticks close enough to the original in the main points to be obvious, but avoids being so close that you're constantly comparing the two to predict what will happen next (though there was one point where I assume the character's words had been lifted from the original and I cringed at how anachronistic it felt). All in all, a good read, and I appreciated the specific pointing to God that 'Emma' is missing.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
An enjoyable loose retelling of Emma in a modern setting. I'm not a fan of Emma's character for most of the original, and the same carries through to here - but Jordan (and Mr Knightley) are great. EJ's focus on social climbing put me offside before I got fairly started, but the hope of improvement/redemption kept me reading - and I don't regret it. After lots of foolish choices, Jordan's patience and willingness to say what needed to be said finally got through to her, which was great to see. As for Eric, I don't understand that sort of lifestyle and don't want to. But Jordan and EJ's families are great and I loved getting to know them. As a retelling, it sticks close enough to the original in the main points to be obvious, but avoids being so close that you're constantly comparing the two to predict what will happen next (though there was one point where I assume the character's words had been lifted from the original and I cringed at how anachronistic it felt). All in all, a good read, and I appreciated the specific pointing to God that 'Emma' is missing.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
*service presse numérique (ARC)*
4/5⭐️
Not Precisely Mr. Knightley by Carolyn Miller
I absolutely loved this modern retelling inspired by Emma.
This story follows Emma-Jane (EJ) Bennett and her best friend Jordan Knight. Together, they created a successful Christian dating app called Dream Match. EJ is smart, ambitious, and talented. But when success and fame grow, so does her pride. She starts chasing money, status, and recognition : and slowly forgets what really matters.
Jordan has loved her for a long time. He is loyal, patient, and protective. I loved that he falls first. His feelings are clear, but he also respects her space. Their relationship is such a good friends-to-lovers story, full of tension, misunderstandings, and emotional moments.
If you know Emma, you will recognize many parallels — the matchmaking, the “perfect” new guy, the pride, the hard lessons. But this is not just a copy. The modern Australian setting feels fresh and natural. The Dream Match app idea is such a clever update of Emma’s matchmaking personality.
What I appreciated most is the strong faith element. This book clearly talks about God, pride, forgiveness, and putting faith before success. EJ makes mistakes, real ones, and she has to face the consequences. Her growth feels meaningful.
The story is emotional but still light and comforting. It has romance, friendship, family, and important life lessons. It reminds us that success without humility can lead us in the wrong direction.
If you love Jane Austen retellings, friends-to-lovers, “he falls first,” and faith-based romance, this is definitely for you.
I can’t wait for the next book in The Silver Teapot series.
With all my love,
Ur Lina
4/5⭐️
Not Precisely Mr. Knightley by Carolyn Miller
I absolutely loved this modern retelling inspired by Emma.
This story follows Emma-Jane (EJ) Bennett and her best friend Jordan Knight. Together, they created a successful Christian dating app called Dream Match. EJ is smart, ambitious, and talented. But when success and fame grow, so does her pride. She starts chasing money, status, and recognition : and slowly forgets what really matters.
Jordan has loved her for a long time. He is loyal, patient, and protective. I loved that he falls first. His feelings are clear, but he also respects her space. Their relationship is such a good friends-to-lovers story, full of tension, misunderstandings, and emotional moments.
If you know Emma, you will recognize many parallels — the matchmaking, the “perfect” new guy, the pride, the hard lessons. But this is not just a copy. The modern Australian setting feels fresh and natural. The Dream Match app idea is such a clever update of Emma’s matchmaking personality.
What I appreciated most is the strong faith element. This book clearly talks about God, pride, forgiveness, and putting faith before success. EJ makes mistakes, real ones, and she has to face the consequences. Her growth feels meaningful.
The story is emotional but still light and comforting. It has romance, friendship, family, and important life lessons. It reminds us that success without humility can lead us in the wrong direction.
If you love Jane Austen retellings, friends-to-lovers, “he falls first,” and faith-based romance, this is definitely for you.
I can’t wait for the next book in The Silver Teapot series.
With all my love,
Ur Lina
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
“Not Precisely Mr. Knightly” by Carolyn Miller is a wonderful continuation of this series. As a very loose retelling of Jane Austen’s Emma, this story drew me in right away. However, if it is possible, I got more frustrated at this Emma than I ever did at Austen’s Emma. Just like all of us are prone to be at some point or to some extent, Emma is drawn to the finer things and the life of the wealthier members of society. Dear friend (and app developer partner) Jordan encourages Emma to quit her job where they both work, but then things change and shift between them, so that now everything feels awkward instead of easy. Emma is networking and making new friends, and in the process her old friends and family begin to feel like an old shoe that she doesn’t fit into anymore. She is a matchmaker (through the app she and Jordan created), and she feels like she is embarking on a new journey of matchmaking or making her own match! Truth is needed, and as the Good Book says, “faithful are the wounds of a friend.”
Ugh. How many times is it one of us who is following after the wrong things and needing a friend or family member to speak Truth to us? How many times are we the Truth speaking one and end up feeling like we have royally botched it up? Emma and Jordan both go on a personal growth journey throughout this book. I loved this aspect of the story.
I also loved the easy friendship that Jordan and Emma have and watching how their relationship changes and matures and stretches throughout this story. What a lovely tale that is so relatable and real-to-life! Read it. You will not regret it.
Ugh. How many times is it one of us who is following after the wrong things and needing a friend or family member to speak Truth to us? How many times are we the Truth speaking one and end up feeling like we have royally botched it up? Emma and Jordan both go on a personal growth journey throughout this book. I loved this aspect of the story.
I also loved the easy friendship that Jordan and Emma have and watching how their relationship changes and matures and stretches throughout this story. What a lovely tale that is so relatable and real-to-life! Read it. You will not regret it.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Not Precisely Mr. Knightley is the second book in The Silver Teapot series and can easily be enjoyed as a standalone, though reading Not Exactly Mr. Darcy first adds extra charm and familiarity with the returning characters.
Emma Jane Bennett—EJ to everyone who knows her—and Jordan Knight have been inseparable since childhood. Together they built Dream Match, a successful dating app with the potential to become something truly extraordinary. EJ, ever the visionary, dreams of taking the company all the way to the New York Stock Exchange. Determined to make that dream a reality, she quits her day job to focus on securing the kind of high-profile investors who could elevate the app to the next level.
Her search leads her into the orbit of an elite, wealthy social circle—and even into a relationship with a man whose fortune is as vast as his lifestyle is glamorous. Swept up in the glitter and influence of this new world, EJ begins to drift from the values that once grounded her. Jordan, whose long buried feelings for EJ have begun to surface, sees the shift and bravely confronts her, reminding her of who she is and what truly matters.
Carolyn Miller delivers another charming, uplifting story filled with friendship, heart, and personal growth. EJ and Jordan’s journey is tender and relatable, and the themes of ambition, integrity, and love make this installment every bit as engaging as the first.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. All comments and opinions are my own.
Emma Jane Bennett—EJ to everyone who knows her—and Jordan Knight have been inseparable since childhood. Together they built Dream Match, a successful dating app with the potential to become something truly extraordinary. EJ, ever the visionary, dreams of taking the company all the way to the New York Stock Exchange. Determined to make that dream a reality, she quits her day job to focus on securing the kind of high-profile investors who could elevate the app to the next level.
Her search leads her into the orbit of an elite, wealthy social circle—and even into a relationship with a man whose fortune is as vast as his lifestyle is glamorous. Swept up in the glitter and influence of this new world, EJ begins to drift from the values that once grounded her. Jordan, whose long buried feelings for EJ have begun to surface, sees the shift and bravely confronts her, reminding her of who she is and what truly matters.
Carolyn Miller delivers another charming, uplifting story filled with friendship, heart, and personal growth. EJ and Jordan’s journey is tender and relatable, and the themes of ambition, integrity, and love make this installment every bit as engaging as the first.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. All comments and opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
I absolutely adored this contemporary retelling of Austen's Emma, set in the author's home country of Australia. Although the expected plot lines of Emma are recognizable, I felt as if I was reading a well-loved story with an original twist. While I knew what to expect, there were many surprises along the way.
Emma Jane, or EJ as she likes to be called, is striving for success with her dating app. The more time she spends away from her family and hometown, she loses her way in the bustling world of Sydney. Blinded by the promises of success, she needs to decide if she will adjust her moral compass to attain her dreams.
Her best friend, Jordan, has followed her to Sydney. He has always been relied upon to talk straight. His steadiness provides clarity and discernment.
The author tells the story from both POV. She skillfully describes the various emotions both feel as they traverse the line between friends and possibly more. While true fans of Emma will find the plot predictable, they will love the setting and characters. And appreciate the fact that the story is just as relevant and realistic in a modern setting.
Things I love about the story and the Silver Teapot series is the Bennett family and their hometown community. But most importantly, the skillful way Ms. Miller weaves a compelling faith thread naturally through her stories.
**I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author/publisher through Netgalley. I was not required to write a review. All opinions expressed are my own.
Emma Jane, or EJ as she likes to be called, is striving for success with her dating app. The more time she spends away from her family and hometown, she loses her way in the bustling world of Sydney. Blinded by the promises of success, she needs to decide if she will adjust her moral compass to attain her dreams.
Her best friend, Jordan, has followed her to Sydney. He has always been relied upon to talk straight. His steadiness provides clarity and discernment.
The author tells the story from both POV. She skillfully describes the various emotions both feel as they traverse the line between friends and possibly more. While true fans of Emma will find the plot predictable, they will love the setting and characters. And appreciate the fact that the story is just as relevant and realistic in a modern setting.
Things I love about the story and the Silver Teapot series is the Bennett family and their hometown community. But most importantly, the skillful way Ms. Miller weaves a compelling faith thread naturally through her stories.
**I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author/publisher through Netgalley. I was not required to write a review. All opinions expressed are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I absolutely ENJOYED this second story of the Silver Tea Pot series. I can’t wait to get my hands on a paperback copy!
Once again, Carolyn Miller strikes it out of the park with her Jane Austen inspired contemporary novels. This isn’t one of those re-tellings, but there are many Easter eggs that are simply a treat to read that any Austen fan will love.
This time, we catch up with EJ, or Emma-Jane, and her best friend, Jordan Knight. The success of a dating app she created with Jordan is a result of hard-work. But EJ wants to take it a step further, and list it on the stock exchange. But in order to do so, she’ll have to find investors that believe in her Christian dating app as much as she does.
What follows is a journey reminiscent of Emma Woodhouse in Jane Austen’s Emma. It’s a beautiful story about the cost of success, of fame and chasing fortune. It’s a story of family-ties and of friendship. A friends-to-more story that has readers on edge thinking that this relationship just turned from friends-to-enemies…
But it’s a story of faith – of God’s faithfulness to us and of his forgiveness. Yes – this story digs into the faith aspect and I’m so grateful for authors who write faith-filled stories.
This is definitely one of my top reads of 2026.
I can’t wait for the next story in the Silver Teapot series.
I received an ecopy from the publisher through NetGalley. All opinions expressed are my own.
Once again, Carolyn Miller strikes it out of the park with her Jane Austen inspired contemporary novels. This isn’t one of those re-tellings, but there are many Easter eggs that are simply a treat to read that any Austen fan will love.
This time, we catch up with EJ, or Emma-Jane, and her best friend, Jordan Knight. The success of a dating app she created with Jordan is a result of hard-work. But EJ wants to take it a step further, and list it on the stock exchange. But in order to do so, she’ll have to find investors that believe in her Christian dating app as much as she does.
What follows is a journey reminiscent of Emma Woodhouse in Jane Austen’s Emma. It’s a beautiful story about the cost of success, of fame and chasing fortune. It’s a story of family-ties and of friendship. A friends-to-more story that has readers on edge thinking that this relationship just turned from friends-to-enemies…
But it’s a story of faith – of God’s faithfulness to us and of his forgiveness. Yes – this story digs into the faith aspect and I’m so grateful for authors who write faith-filled stories.
This is definitely one of my top reads of 2026.
I can’t wait for the next story in the Silver Teapot series.
I received an ecopy from the publisher through NetGalley. All opinions expressed are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Not Precisely Mr. Knightley is a creative modern adaptation of Jane Austen’s novel Emma. I enjoyed reading about Emma-Jane’s friendship with Jordan Knight and watching their relationship develop throughout the book. Emma-Jane, known as EJ, is focused on networking and growing her career as an entrepreneur. Jordan has always been her supporter. He begins to worry when EJ makes some new connections with great business experience but a questionable moral compass. As their paths diverge in separate directions, EJ and Jordan will have to decide if their long lasting friendship since childhood can survive the changing season life throws at them.
This was a sweet romance story that showed great growth, particularly for Emma-Jane in the final portion of the book. Jordan was ever patient and endured quite a lot as Emma-Jane navigated the networking opportunities over the priorities of family and her best friend. I found the conclusion to be a sweet ending, just found myself feeling a bit frustrated with how long it took the FMC to wake up and realize the consequences of her actions. She got there eventually, it just felt a bit longer than I would’ve liked in the middle. All in all, a creative adaptation of Emma set in Sydney, Australia that features themes of matchmaking, entrepreneurship, the value of integrity and relationships, and faith.
Many thanks to the author and Great Reads Book Promotion for an advanced copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
This was a sweet romance story that showed great growth, particularly for Emma-Jane in the final portion of the book. Jordan was ever patient and endured quite a lot as Emma-Jane navigated the networking opportunities over the priorities of family and her best friend. I found the conclusion to be a sweet ending, just found myself feeling a bit frustrated with how long it took the FMC to wake up and realize the consequences of her actions. She got there eventually, it just felt a bit longer than I would’ve liked in the middle. All in all, a creative adaptation of Emma set in Sydney, Australia that features themes of matchmaking, entrepreneurship, the value of integrity and relationships, and faith.
Many thanks to the author and Great Reads Book Promotion for an advanced copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Yes, my Jane Austen lovers, if you guessed that this second book in The Silver Teapot series was a nod to Emma--well you would be right. ;) Emma-Jane--or EJ as she prefers to be called--is the next oldest sister of the Bennett clan. And if you know the Emma story, you will easily follow this tale...but there ARE some twists of course. However, Mr. Knight and Mr. Churchill, as well as Mr. Elton and Harriet are 100% present.
Just as with the book, EJ is a matchmaker--even owns a matchmaking app that she designed and created with her best friend Jordan Knight. But EJ wants to be recognized. She wants to be acknowledged. She wants to leave her small town roots behind and LIVE the high life she was "destined" to find.
Along the way she decides to put God and her faith on the back burner. And this book is a lesson in pride and chasing the world's treasures. There are many excellent messages woven throughout the book. Including not being afraid to tell your friends the truth--even when they don't want to hear it.
And if you know how the actual book Emma ends...you will be very satisfied indeed.
Now I'm eager for Katie and Elinor's story--as it will CLEARLY be based on Sense & Sensibility, which means we are going to have a Colonel Brandon character!
4 stars
*Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC of this novel. All opinions are 100% my own.
Just as with the book, EJ is a matchmaker--even owns a matchmaking app that she designed and created with her best friend Jordan Knight. But EJ wants to be recognized. She wants to be acknowledged. She wants to leave her small town roots behind and LIVE the high life she was "destined" to find.
Along the way she decides to put God and her faith on the back burner. And this book is a lesson in pride and chasing the world's treasures. There are many excellent messages woven throughout the book. Including not being afraid to tell your friends the truth--even when they don't want to hear it.
And if you know how the actual book Emma ends...you will be very satisfied indeed.
Now I'm eager for Katie and Elinor's story--as it will CLEARLY be based on Sense & Sensibility, which means we are going to have a Colonel Brandon character!
4 stars
*Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC of this novel. All opinions are 100% my own.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This is a warm, modern romantic-comedy with strong “friends-to-more” tension and a light Austen-inspired vibe.
At its heart, EJ Bennett and Jordan Knight are the kind of best-friend duo readers immediately root for—comfortable, creative, and clearly orbiting something deeper than either wants to admit. Their success with the dating app Dream Match adds an interesting twist: they understand love logically, but not personally, which sets up a great irony as their own feelings stay unspoken.
EJ is especially compelling. Watching her get swept into flashy social circles and a high-profile relationship with a TV mogul’s son feels believable, and it highlights how easily ambition and validation can blur self-awareness. When things unravel, her retreat to small-town comfort and the familiar safety of The Silver Teapot Café gives the story its emotional grounding.
Jordan, meanwhile, is the quietly steady emotional core. His decision to step in and expose Eric Churchill shows how deeply he cares—but also how imperfectly he handles it. His intentions are good, but the fallout creates real conflict rather than an easy fix, which strengthens the story.
I believe fans of slow-burn friendship, Christian romances, small-town comfort settings, and emotional self-discovery will enjoy reading this story.
Thank you Netgalley for my ARC copy. My Review is my own.
At its heart, EJ Bennett and Jordan Knight are the kind of best-friend duo readers immediately root for—comfortable, creative, and clearly orbiting something deeper than either wants to admit. Their success with the dating app Dream Match adds an interesting twist: they understand love logically, but not personally, which sets up a great irony as their own feelings stay unspoken.
EJ is especially compelling. Watching her get swept into flashy social circles and a high-profile relationship with a TV mogul’s son feels believable, and it highlights how easily ambition and validation can blur self-awareness. When things unravel, her retreat to small-town comfort and the familiar safety of The Silver Teapot Café gives the story its emotional grounding.
Jordan, meanwhile, is the quietly steady emotional core. His decision to step in and expose Eric Churchill shows how deeply he cares—but also how imperfectly he handles it. His intentions are good, but the fallout creates real conflict rather than an easy fix, which strengthens the story.
I believe fans of slow-burn friendship, Christian romances, small-town comfort settings, and emotional self-discovery will enjoy reading this story.
Thank you Netgalley for my ARC copy. My Review is my own.
May 6, 2026
If you are a Jane Austen fan, you will “get” the subtle hints of her story Emma in Carolyn Miller’s latest book Not Precisely Mr. Knightley.
I loved this book and this series. If you didn’t read Not Exactly Mr. Darcy, then I highly encourage you to do so, even though Not Precisely Mr. Knightley can be read as a standalone.
In this book, we meet Emma-Jane Bennett (E.J. to her friends) and Jordan Knight. Then have been friends forever. Together then have designed a Christian dating app called Dream Match. The app proves to be so popular that E.J. starts looking for investors because she dreams of more money and prestige. Unfortunately, she meets all the wrong people who want to invest in her app, and soon, she is not only losing the reason she created Dream Match, but putting her faith and her relationship with Jordan, last in her life.
For his part, Jordan is E.J.’s dream match, and he wonders if she will ever recognize how much he wants to be more than “just friends.”
I loved the faith element in this book, and Jordan’s deep convictions and unwavering faith. The writing was superb! The dialogue was natural, as was the dangerous progression of E.J.’s desire to make Dream Match so much more.
I highly recommend this book!
I received a complimentary copy courtesy of Barbour Fiction via NetGalley for my honest opinion.
I loved this book and this series. If you didn’t read Not Exactly Mr. Darcy, then I highly encourage you to do so, even though Not Precisely Mr. Knightley can be read as a standalone.
In this book, we meet Emma-Jane Bennett (E.J. to her friends) and Jordan Knight. Then have been friends forever. Together then have designed a Christian dating app called Dream Match. The app proves to be so popular that E.J. starts looking for investors because she dreams of more money and prestige. Unfortunately, she meets all the wrong people who want to invest in her app, and soon, she is not only losing the reason she created Dream Match, but putting her faith and her relationship with Jordan, last in her life.
For his part, Jordan is E.J.’s dream match, and he wonders if she will ever recognize how much he wants to be more than “just friends.”
I loved the faith element in this book, and Jordan’s deep convictions and unwavering faith. The writing was superb! The dialogue was natural, as was the dangerous progression of E.J.’s desire to make Dream Match so much more.
I highly recommend this book!
I received a complimentary copy courtesy of Barbour Fiction via NetGalley for my honest opinion.
May 7, 2026
"Not Precisely Mr. Knightley" by Carolyn Miller is a Jane Austen Emma retelling that has a lot of depth. This is a book I'd totally recommend to ages 16+ because it has such a good message about how material things and rich people isn't everything in life. Emma, aka E.J. has a dating app that is faith based and is doing well on a small scale. She's looking for investors to take it to the next level. What she finds by associating with those with money, fame and appear to have it all doesn't necessarily mean she'll be happy.
E.J. goes through so much character growth. Her best friend Jordan is by her side though he struggles in his relationship with E.J. and the choices she is making. He's in love with her and wants her success, but not if it means risking her faith in God and family. I also loved the setting in Australia and the ability to read a bit more about life in Sydney.
This book is dual point of view. It's faith filled and the faith passages are excellent and encouraging to the reader. It's well written and it brought out my own emotions as I became emotionally involved with the characters. I became frustrated with E.J. and her decisions and sympathized with Jordan and her family. I celebrated with the characters as well.
Thank you to Barbour Publishing for the opportunity to read an ARC of this book. All opinions expressed are my own.
E.J. goes through so much character growth. Her best friend Jordan is by her side though he struggles in his relationship with E.J. and the choices she is making. He's in love with her and wants her success, but not if it means risking her faith in God and family. I also loved the setting in Australia and the ability to read a bit more about life in Sydney.
This book is dual point of view. It's faith filled and the faith passages are excellent and encouraging to the reader. It's well written and it brought out my own emotions as I became emotionally involved with the characters. I became frustrated with E.J. and her decisions and sympathized with Jordan and her family. I celebrated with the characters as well.
Thank you to Barbour Publishing for the opportunity to read an ARC of this book. All opinions expressed are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I received this arc and this is my honest opinion.
This is a christian, slow burn, small town, retelling of Emma by Jane Austen. I gave it 3.5 stars and I will explain why.
I'm a big sucker of Jane Austen and have read (and watched) her stories multiple times, so if there's a retelling it's a must read for me. That's why I picked this one.
The heroine is Emma-Jane or EJ as they call her and like Emma Woodhouse she's privileged, a little bit self-centered and know-it-all. While Emma Woodhouse was presented making mistakes, they were under some sense of humor and despite being flawed she was well liked by everyone. EJ here was presented with some seriousness and not lightness. Her ambition and superficial lifestyle was kind of off putting. So not really a fan of hers. There is of course some redemption when she realises how misguided she was and how her actions hurt other people who didn't deserve it.
On the other hand Jordan is presented as a loyal friend who always criticise his friend not because he's petty but because he truly cares for her like the original but in a more stern way.
Though the original is more witty and humorous, this one is more faith focused that sets the tone of the story in a more serious level.
This is a christian, slow burn, small town, retelling of Emma by Jane Austen. I gave it 3.5 stars and I will explain why.
I'm a big sucker of Jane Austen and have read (and watched) her stories multiple times, so if there's a retelling it's a must read for me. That's why I picked this one.
The heroine is Emma-Jane or EJ as they call her and like Emma Woodhouse she's privileged, a little bit self-centered and know-it-all. While Emma Woodhouse was presented making mistakes, they were under some sense of humor and despite being flawed she was well liked by everyone. EJ here was presented with some seriousness and not lightness. Her ambition and superficial lifestyle was kind of off putting. So not really a fan of hers. There is of course some redemption when she realises how misguided she was and how her actions hurt other people who didn't deserve it.
On the other hand Jordan is presented as a loyal friend who always criticise his friend not because he's petty but because he truly cares for her like the original but in a more stern way.
Though the original is more witty and humorous, this one is more faith focused that sets the tone of the story in a more serious level.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
After enjoying the first book in this series, Not Exactly Mr Darcy, I was looking forward to more, and was very glad to read Emma-Jane's (or more so known as EJ) story.
While I haven't read Jane Austen's Emma, I still was able to recognize the similarities this (very loose) retelling held, which was fun.
EJ and Jordan have always been best friends. They balance each other out. But as the story progresses, EJ wants more and better in her world and gets distracted by those things. Jordan was still pretty patient with her.
I admit that I found EJ a little annoying at times. Definitely wanted to give her a good shake. But I could also see how and why she was like that, and it certainly added plot to the book.
The whole story was well written. It was also fun to see some of the other characters from the first book briefly.
I also appreciated the faith aspect and how Jordan helped prompt EJ to remember the importance of her faith. Both of the main characters did their own growing which was good to see!
I am looking forward to the next book in this fun series!
I received an ecopy through Netgalley. I was not required to write a positive review and all thoughts expressed are entirely my own.
While I haven't read Jane Austen's Emma, I still was able to recognize the similarities this (very loose) retelling held, which was fun.
EJ and Jordan have always been best friends. They balance each other out. But as the story progresses, EJ wants more and better in her world and gets distracted by those things. Jordan was still pretty patient with her.
I admit that I found EJ a little annoying at times. Definitely wanted to give her a good shake. But I could also see how and why she was like that, and it certainly added plot to the book.
The whole story was well written. It was also fun to see some of the other characters from the first book briefly.
I also appreciated the faith aspect and how Jordan helped prompt EJ to remember the importance of her faith. Both of the main characters did their own growing which was good to see!
I am looking forward to the next book in this fun series!
I received an ecopy through Netgalley. I was not required to write a positive review and all thoughts expressed are entirely my own.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
This was an enjoyable rom-com with lots of references to Emma by Jane Austen.
A dating app, Dream Match, was thought up by Emma Jane Bennett and Jordan Knight, officially the firm of Woodhouse-Knightly as a nod to Jane Austen. It is meant to be a safe pkace for Christian singles to meet and possibly find love.
Welcome to Australia and the atmosphere of Sydney and an appearance of a billionaire playboy Eric Churchill. Emma gets stars in her eyes as Eric wines and dines her. But is it for her or to take over her dating app? Best friend Jordan tries to get Emma to pray about investors and tread carefully. Things go awry.
Many things reminded me of Emma and other tomes by Jane Austin including flighty Mrs. Bennett, sisters Olivia, Katie and Elinor and assistant Harriet. Nice references to Australian places and items- But I could do without the Vegemite. I have tasted it and am not a fan!
Jordan must find a way to go from best friends to marriage prospect and it is a fun ride.
I enjoyed the witty banter, the family connections, the spiritual struggles of the characters and the eventual happily ever after.
*A complimentary copy of this book was provided by Barbour and via NetGalley. I was not required to post a favorable review. All opinions are mine alone.*
A dating app, Dream Match, was thought up by Emma Jane Bennett and Jordan Knight, officially the firm of Woodhouse-Knightly as a nod to Jane Austen. It is meant to be a safe pkace for Christian singles to meet and possibly find love.
Welcome to Australia and the atmosphere of Sydney and an appearance of a billionaire playboy Eric Churchill. Emma gets stars in her eyes as Eric wines and dines her. But is it for her or to take over her dating app? Best friend Jordan tries to get Emma to pray about investors and tread carefully. Things go awry.
Many things reminded me of Emma and other tomes by Jane Austin including flighty Mrs. Bennett, sisters Olivia, Katie and Elinor and assistant Harriet. Nice references to Australian places and items- But I could do without the Vegemite. I have tasted it and am not a fan!
Jordan must find a way to go from best friends to marriage prospect and it is a fun ride.
I enjoyed the witty banter, the family connections, the spiritual struggles of the characters and the eventual happily ever after.
*A complimentary copy of this book was provided by Barbour and via NetGalley. I was not required to post a favorable review. All opinions are mine alone.*
May 1, 2026
Not Precisely Mr. Knightley begins with an engaging premise, following Emma-Jane (EJ) Bennett and her longtime best friend Jordan Knight, co-creators of the wildly successful dating app Dream Match. Yet before EJ leaves her current job to focus solely on the app, Jordan realises that his feelings for EJ are more than those of a friend. As EJ is swept into a glamorous, high-profile lifestyle and begins dating Eric Churchill, a TV mogul’s son, Jordan feels that he must step in to protect her from Eric. However, in doing so, things start to unravel and send EJ retreating to her small-town roots, questioning everything.
I initially found the concept fresh and appealing, particularly with its nods to Emma and the friends-to-lovers dynamic. However, while I enjoy Christian fiction, the frequent religious references occasionally felt a bit heavy-handed and detracted from my overall immersion in the story. However, I found there were still elements to appreciate, especially the underlying character dynamics and the emotional potential between EJ and Jordan. Overall, an interesting idea that didn’t fully land for me, earning a three-star rating.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book from NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
I initially found the concept fresh and appealing, particularly with its nods to Emma and the friends-to-lovers dynamic. However, while I enjoy Christian fiction, the frequent religious references occasionally felt a bit heavy-handed and detracted from my overall immersion in the story. However, I found there were still elements to appreciate, especially the underlying character dynamics and the emotional potential between EJ and Jordan. Overall, an interesting idea that didn’t fully land for me, earning a three-star rating.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book from NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This is a faith-filled retelling of Jane Austen's novel Emma. Most of the plotline follows Emma's very closely, with some lines that you will recognize from the original. There are a few notable differences; Emma does not consider herself either "handsome" or "rich" here, and there is also no age gap between EJ & Jordan in this adaptation. Emma-Jane's questionable choices here result in even slimier behavior from the Frank Churchill character than in the original, and Gwen is way less sweet than Jane Fairfax. It's too bad Harriet didn't get more time in the story, but this is a more focused retelling with an interesting plot point (Emma's matchmaking tendencies have manifested in a Dream Match app). Jordan Knight's pining throughout the novel, rather than a later realization, adds some additional complexity to the relationship, and readers who enjoy the "he-falls-first" or "friends-to-lovers" tropes will enjoy this contemporary Christian retelling.
Thank you to NetGalley and Barbour for the free eARC! I post this review with my honest opinions.
Content warnings: non-consenual kiss, dubious-consent kiss
Thank you to NetGalley and Barbour for the free eARC! I post this review with my honest opinions.
Content warnings: non-consenual kiss, dubious-consent kiss
March 15, 2026
3.25 stars
Sigh. I really wanted to love this book because I love Austen's Emma Woodhouse, flaws notwithstanding. But Miller's Emma (Emma-Jane "EJ" Bennet) wasn't very likable from the beginning and only got more unappealing as the story progressed. And her long-time best friend, Jordan Knight, although an admirably strong Christian, sometimes wasn't my favorite either. He prided himself on always being honest with EJ, but I felt that he could have tempered his honestly with a bit more tact and lovingkindness.
I thought the modern take on Emma's matchmaking methods was a clever update, but I really enjoyed the numerous references to the original story. A word for word quote from the original was especially well placed near the end of the book.
So far, the author is 2 for 2 in this series with an unlikable main character, so I'm really hoping book 3 doesn't continue this trend
I commend the author for the overt Christianity expressed in this series, but thought this 2nd book was just a bit heavy handed.
I received a digital copy of this novel from Barbour Publishing via NetGalley. I am under no obligation to leave a positive review. The opinions expressed in this review are my own.
Sigh. I really wanted to love this book because I love Austen's Emma Woodhouse, flaws notwithstanding. But Miller's Emma (Emma-Jane "EJ" Bennet) wasn't very likable from the beginning and only got more unappealing as the story progressed. And her long-time best friend, Jordan Knight, although an admirably strong Christian, sometimes wasn't my favorite either. He prided himself on always being honest with EJ, but I felt that he could have tempered his honestly with a bit more tact and lovingkindness.
I thought the modern take on Emma's matchmaking methods was a clever update, but I really enjoyed the numerous references to the original story. A word for word quote from the original was especially well placed near the end of the book.
So far, the author is 2 for 2 in this series with an unlikable main character, so I'm really hoping book 3 doesn't continue this trend
I commend the author for the overt Christianity expressed in this series, but thought this 2nd book was just a bit heavy handed.
I received a digital copy of this novel from Barbour Publishing via NetGalley. I am under no obligation to leave a positive review. The opinions expressed in this review are my own.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Is it possible for dating apps to help you find your true love? Emma-Jane (EJ) Bennet certainly believes so. Along with her best friend, Jordan Knight, EJ designed a Christian dating app called Dream Match, aimed at helping single adults who share the same morals connect and find lasting love. While EJ is determined to take Dream Match to new heights and hopes to achieve financial success, Jordan's ambitions differ. He seeks to guide EJ back to her faith, offering Godly truth and spiritual support as she embarks on this journey.
This is a story about true love, complete with its fair share of challenges and obstacles. The path to love is rarely smooth, and this book reflects that reality beautifully. One of the standout aspects of the novel is its strong Christian foundation, with thoughtfully integrated verses that enhance the narrative. The writing is engaging and heartfelt, making it difficult to put the book down. Overall, this is a wonderfully crafted story that I would highly recommend to others.
Thank you to NetGalley and Barbour Publishing for providing an ARC of this book. All opinions expressed are my own.
This is a story about true love, complete with its fair share of challenges and obstacles. The path to love is rarely smooth, and this book reflects that reality beautifully. One of the standout aspects of the novel is its strong Christian foundation, with thoughtfully integrated verses that enhance the narrative. The writing is engaging and heartfelt, making it difficult to put the book down. Overall, this is a wonderfully crafted story that I would highly recommend to others.
Thank you to NetGalley and Barbour Publishing for providing an ARC of this book. All opinions expressed are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Author
I thought this adaptation of Jane Austen’s Emma was very well written, with enough changes to hold my interest and plenty of references to the original. The characters seemed to come alive from the pages, and the issues they fought with were relevant and common to mankind. As always in Carolyn Miller’s work, the emphasis on God and truths from the Bible were prominent. Of course, just as in the original book, Mr. Knightley was a wonderful, patient character who knew exactly what to say to Emma (E.J.) when she went astray. I thought the author did a great job of portraying E.J. as hard to like, but somehow she was also someone I felt badly for at times. I was so frustrated with her pride and poor decisions! By the end of the story, my opinion of E.J. improved a great deal from the changes she made in her life. I highly recommend this book and the rest of the series to anyone who enjoys retellings of Jane Austen’s work. I am looking forward to reading the next book in the series!
I voluntarily read and reviewed this book for the author. A positive review was not required, and all opinions expressed are entirely my own.
I voluntarily read and reviewed this book for the author. A positive review was not required, and all opinions expressed are entirely my own.
May 2, 2026
This is the second book in the Silver Teapot series. Each book is a stand alone story.
The Silver Teapot café in the small Australian town of Wattle Vale is a place where locals come to celebrate and experience a taste of bygone days-and the place where the four Bennett girls all learned a love of Jane Austen. {Amazon}
Poor EJ (Emma Jane) over extends herself and gets caught up in the whirlwind of high society so much so that she embarrasses herself after finding out that the supposedly rich boyfriend she thinks she loves is two timing her and with all the gusto she can muster EJ flees home to her small roots hometown and The Silver Teapot.
Now Jordan Knight has always been EJ's BFF so when she comes dragging back to town he realizes he wants to expose Eric Churchill, the two timing boyfriend for who he is.
Jordan and EJ have to figure out what makes their relationship more than friendship. And can EJ see Jordan for more than a friend? Can see how he loves and protects her honor?
Serious moments of truth and longing but a fun at times comical story of finding true love admits a money hungry crowd. And The Silver Teapot makes for a lovely setting of teas and scones.
The Silver Teapot café in the small Australian town of Wattle Vale is a place where locals come to celebrate and experience a taste of bygone days-and the place where the four Bennett girls all learned a love of Jane Austen. {Amazon}
Poor EJ (Emma Jane) over extends herself and gets caught up in the whirlwind of high society so much so that she embarrasses herself after finding out that the supposedly rich boyfriend she thinks she loves is two timing her and with all the gusto she can muster EJ flees home to her small roots hometown and The Silver Teapot.
Now Jordan Knight has always been EJ's BFF so when she comes dragging back to town he realizes he wants to expose Eric Churchill, the two timing boyfriend for who he is.
Jordan and EJ have to figure out what makes their relationship more than friendship. And can EJ see Jordan for more than a friend? Can see how he loves and protects her honor?
Serious moments of truth and longing but a fun at times comical story of finding true love admits a money hungry crowd. And The Silver Teapot makes for a lovely setting of teas and scones.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
3.5/5 This retelling of Emma is the second in a series of novels about a group of sisters, each of whom is a type for a famous Austen heroine. In this case, the type is of Emma Woodhouse. I found the story fun and interesting overall, I still love the Bennett family, and I found Jordan Knight to be incredibly charming. But I really couldn't stand Emma-Jane. In Austen's novel, Emma Woodhouse is misguided and self-important at times, but generally likeable. Emma-Jane was the worst, least likeable character I've seen from this author, and it was honestly a struggle to keep reading at times. I get that there needed to be space for a redemption arc, but this character's flaws were excessive. I found myself wanting Jordan to get an HEA but praying it would be with anyone but her.
I enjoyed the Darcy book and I'll certainly read the next one because I think the stories are good. But this one definitely won't go on my reread list.
Many thanks to NetGalley and Barbour Publishing for an ARC in exchange for my honest assessment of this work.
I enjoyed the Darcy book and I'll certainly read the next one because I think the stories are good. But this one definitely won't go on my reread list.
Many thanks to NetGalley and Barbour Publishing for an ARC in exchange for my honest assessment of this work.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Thanks to Barbour Publishing and Netgalley for an advanced reader's copy of this book.
This was a fun read. The author wrote a spin off of Jane Austen's Knightley with a modern Australian twist and a few different characters.
The main character, Emm Jane (or EJ), quits her job at a big company to focus on an app that she designed with her best friend, Jordan Knight. She is distracted by high society and loses sight of the Lord, her family, friends, and even her best friend Jordan. Will she find her way back and maybe love in the process?
The character development in this book was phenomenal, for both Emma Jane and Jordan. I loved how they both grew to a place where they could admit their feelings for, and fall in love, with each other.The only thing that I had a hard time with was Emma Jane. She was a very difficult character to like until the very end, which was probably by intention. I loved how Jordan stuck by her and supported her, always pointing her back to Christ. The ending was also so cute!! Definitely recommend this book!
This was a fun read. The author wrote a spin off of Jane Austen's Knightley with a modern Australian twist and a few different characters.
The main character, Emm Jane (or EJ), quits her job at a big company to focus on an app that she designed with her best friend, Jordan Knight. She is distracted by high society and loses sight of the Lord, her family, friends, and even her best friend Jordan. Will she find her way back and maybe love in the process?
The character development in this book was phenomenal, for both Emma Jane and Jordan. I loved how they both grew to a place where they could admit their feelings for, and fall in love, with each other.The only thing that I had a hard time with was Emma Jane. She was a very difficult character to like until the very end, which was probably by intention. I loved how Jordan stuck by her and supported her, always pointing her back to Christ. The ending was also so cute!! Definitely recommend this book!
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Not Precisely, by Carolyn Miller is Book 2 of "The Silver Teapot" series and it is one I could not put down. Emma Jane or EJ as she is known to her friends & her lifelong pal Jordan Knight create a Christian dating app called Dream Match. EJ is searching for investors to take their business to the next level, while Jordan is trying to keep EJ close to her roots & not get sidelined by worldly trappings. When EJ is thrust into the limelight of riches, rich friends & the elegant lifestyle she has wanted, she sees how a lot of the other half live. This book was extremely interesting from start to finish. We all have "absorbed someone else's words into our soul & carried them for too many years," pushing us all away from what keeps us grounded, when all we need is "wisdom & grace." The characters were people you can relate to, and the story line is a great reminder to stay true to yourself. I was given a complimentary copy of this book by Barbour Publishing & was under no obligation to post a review.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 62 reviews