Hunting Baby Bro

Their Baby Bro #1

by Ally Avery

"Don't let us catch you, baby brother…"

I've always wanted to prove myself against my big brothers, and now I've got the perfect chance. Just me and them in a cabin for the weekend. Well, us and our feral cousin Jake.

The bet is simple: they hunt me down, and if I win, they serve me for the rest of our stay.

But if they catch me, they'll take me, claim me, and use me however they please.

I thought I wanted victory. Yet, when the hunt begins and they pounce on me like hungry wolves, I wonder if losing might be better than winning.

Hunting Baby Bro is a taboo MMMM novella featuring brothers, a cousin, primal play, dubcon, and a HFN ending. This story is for adventurous readers only and is not intended for audiences under 18.

Genres: M M Romance, M M M, Dark Romance, Erotica, Polyamory, Romance, BDSM

ebook

Published October 28, 2025

About the author

Ally found her love for reading and writing at a young age. MM romance in particular has been part of her life since her first exposure to late-2000s Shounen Ai.

She likes to write about fierce, damaged boys who need a lot of love, and she doesn’t shy away from dark and taboo topics that some readers might find disturbing.

Reviews

[Kim Reads · Rating 4 out of 5]

4,5 ⭐️!

This was a hot quick read y'all 🤭

Tyler, Shawn, Mark are brothers, and they have a cousin, Jake. They spend some time in a cabin together and things get.. interesting 😏

I'm not gonna write much in this review, since it's a novella and there is not very much story but very high spiciness and tenderness happening between these boys.

The writing was amazing and I need to read more of these boys 🥰

If you like to read tab0o stories, this one is a must-read ❤️‍🔥

[Ally Avery]

Get it on Smashwords: https://www.smashwords.com/books/view/1863394
or
Payhip: https://payhip.com/b/ysYjN

[Ayla Shoulders · Rating 5 out of 5]

Well, this was a fun and filthy little MMMM taboo as fuck story about 3 bothers and their cousin finding love (with eachother) after a game of Hunt and Fuck (that’s what I’m calling it) one weekend at their families cabin by the lake 🫪

Hunting Baby Bro was HOT. It was messy. And it was OH SO SWEET. These boys start off the book as you would expect brothers and cousins to act, playful and competitive and rough… but it very quickly evolves into something insanely sweet, passionate and possessive.

Baby Ty’s bratty and submissive personality pairs PERFECTLY with Daddy Mark’s dominate, caring side. Shawn’s quiet affection and Jake’s chaos. *chefs kiss*

There is an age gap of 10+ years between all of them. Tyler being the youngest at 20 and SEXY DADDDDYYYY MARK being the oldest at 31. I LOVE A GOOD AGE GAP!!!

Hunting Baby Bro DELIVERS the sluttiness on an epic level. Shawn with his glasses, cousin Jake with his slutty little (big) dick piercing. And Mark, don’t even get me started on Mark. I mean, fuck me, Daddy? 🥵

I loved the relationship between the brothers, obviously. But the dynamic between Jake and Tyler had me squirming for more! Jake’s intensity when it came to Tyler was top notch obsession. I was dying for more between the two of them.

Can’t wait to see what comes next!

[Sabrina · Rating 4 out of 5]

3.75 ⭐️

[⭐Toonasa⭐ *Romance Book Lovers' Haven* (For long and deep.... reviews!) · Rating 5 out of 5]

A MMMM taboo romance novella with brothers/cousin in a cabin, a hunt of depravity that leads to smut & sweetness! So freaking good.
I had wanted to read this & its sequel for so long, I've owned them for a while. FINALLY got to read it! I'm so happy that this is my last book of March. I had so much fun with it! Devoured it in around 2hrs.

Mark is eldest, stern & bossy but caretaker. Shawn is quiet & looming, calm, nerdy vibes with glasses. Tyler is the youngest, reactive, sensitive with a temper (I relate) but just wants to be loved. Jake is the cousin, shit-stirer asshole creep who flirts endlessly with Ty. There's age gap of ~10yrs most.

It starts as a hunt to teach Ty a lesson but then blooming desires get unleashed. The primal play, taking care while taking apart IS SO HOT 🥵. Like OMFG. Especially I loved the consent & there's safeword.

I liked the dynamics of everyone. The story focus is on Ty most, with Mark being next. J's too prominent to not let us know what he thinks lol. I wish we got to see more of what S thinks, but that's his vibe 🤷‍♀️.

All had attraction to Ty & Ty to em, but T especially focused on M. I was wondering about that, but it ends more like MMM/m till end, even romantically which is great, & they have the familial care + banter between them too. That little tease with M+J, I wonder if J'll ever bottom for M or S!

I REALLY LOVED how this one-night-only thing becomes "You belong to us, only" 🥹! It was spicy, then unexpectedly (pleasantly) emotional 😭 & so sweet. The confessions, care & planning is lovely. I'm so excited to read the sequel!

Story ratings: Enjoyed—> SO MUCH! 5!!/5
POV: 1st person, Dual POV
1) The Characters: 4.75/5
2) The feels: 😅🤭🥹😏😂😁🥵😳😍🤔😌😭😘😆☺️
3) Sexy/Steamy scenes: 3.5/5
4) Levels: Mild Angst, Sorta Cute, Low Dark
5) Build up & Style: 4/5 (Sexy & short, but so good!)

FB Page | Instagram | Bookbub | FB group

[Ev Reads A Lot · Rating 4 out of 5]

What’s not to love about 3 brothers and their cousins fucking like wild animals in the forest?

[Chloe · Rating 4 out of 5]

Hunting Baby Bro by Ally Avery

💜 MMMM Taboo (🩸 brothers & cousin)
💜 Lost Bet
💜 Erotic Novella
🔥 Primal Play, Dub Con, Humiliation, Pierced 🍆, Spitroast, DP, Rimming, Shower S*x

Overall: ⭐⭐⭐⭐.5
Spice: 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️.5
Humour: 🤭🤭
Intimacy: 🫂🫂🫂.5
Angst: 🥺.5

First person dual pov 👀

Content Warnings
On page: mild violence
Mentioned: hazing

[Christina Sturgill · Rating 5 out of 5]

Rating: 5/5 🌟
Spice: 4.5/5 🌶️
Heroes: Tyler, Mark, Shawn, Jake

Brothers: Tyler, Mark, Shawn
Cousin: Jake

This was a fun and extremely hot little novella.
It starts out with typical brotherly antics, competitive racing and turns into a bit of a fight when the youngest brother (Tyler) loses his cool on their cousin, Jake.
Tired of Tyler's quick temper they decide on a bet to race, and the winner gets to use the other for anything. Only, it's not entirely fair since it's Mark, Shawn, and Jake against Tyler.
Obviously, Tyler loses that race and from there it's absolutely delicious.
Very taboo blood related sweet and dirty boys. A quick and dirty good time!

[angie_bookrecs · Rating 5 out of 5]

Ty said “I’m a brat,” and Mark, Shawn & Jake said, “Challenge accepted.”

It was exactly what I hoped for
..filthy, fun, and surprisingly sweet in all the right places.

Ty’s bratty energy had me grinning, and watching him get put in his place by his brothers and cousin? Chef’s kiss.

I love a messy, tangled poly dynamic, and I can’t wait to see how it all deepens in the sequel (and let's be honest, we're all hoping for one!)

Short, dirty, and completely addictive.

[WickedRiverReads · Rating 4 out of 5]

Sometimes you just need a good, short, smutty taboo read and this gave me what I was looking for! Primal play will always get me intrigued and boy did these four have and keep my attention. The chase was fun, the capturing even more so and Tyler, Mark, Shawn and Jake…HOT!! If you want a quick, steamy taboo read with four men and a cabin in the woods then I definitely say pick this up! 🖤💜🖤

[Victoria]

No sé qué decir al respecto.


Hunting Baby Bro is a taboo MMMM novella (🩸 brothers & cousin).

[Jessica Swan · Rating 3 out of 5]

3.5 stars

taboo but fun

[KS · Rating 5 out of 5]

Holy Shit!

If you're looking for a taboo book about a bratty brother who just wants to be loved, by his brothers... *cough* and cousin *cough* well, he sure gets loved all right, 6 ways to sunday baby!

Damn!

This book came in hot, and it came in swinging!
& now I'm going to scream about it because it Delivered🔥

[Jurnee Mccarty · Rating 5 out of 5]

Okay Ally I see you Queen. This was SPICY. my god, I think I was drooling a little. this was next level. and I NEED MORE. not just want. Because this was utter perfection. Any way you want to give me a full length novel of them 😩

I’m desperate over here lol. As always this wasn’t just spice, all of her characters always have such amazing depth to them. And I truly love that even for such a short novella. 🖤💋

[Misty · Rating 5 out of 5]

This one is short and S€XY and mmm mmm good!

Holy hot! I’ve been counting down for this one, and oh. my. gosh worth every second of the wait. So filthy. So delicious. So good!
I hope Ally gives us more! Mark, Shawn, Jake and Baby Ty definitely need that Thanksgiving get away!

[ashlee ❤ · Rating 4 out of 5]

Tyler, Mark, Shawn, + Jake

-mmmm whychoose
-🩸 taboo
-brothers & cousin
-primal play
-free use/degredation
-secret getaways

these were NAUGHTYYYY & NASSTYYYY!! & i loved it v much thank yewww! lol

[Maggie May · Rating 4 out of 5]

Fun, filthy, sweet. Perfect for when you want some taboo fun with a little affection and not much story.

[Pyro Aleksandr · Rating 4 out of 5]

This was such a fun read! Yabba dabba tabboooooo.

[Mal · Rating 5 out of 5]

Enjoyed this! Hope to read more about their escapades in the future.

[Audiobook S1ut · Rating 5 out of 5]

Hey, this counts as reading. Gave me everything I came for and therefore it deserves all the stars. Thanks Ally!

[Eve]

Sometimes you just need to vibe and read a short, fun and filthy little novella!

[Leo · Rating 4 out of 5]

4☆

ᔑᑭᏆᑕᗴ: 🔥🔥🔥🔥
しᗩᑌᏀᕼᔑ: 🤣
Ꭲᗴᗩᖇᔑ:😭
ᗰᑕᔑ. Tyler, Mark, Shaw, Jake
ᑭᝪᐯ: 1st Person
Ꭲᖇᝪᑭᗴᔑ: MMMM, Taboo, Incest, BBBC, Primal Play

[Charlotte.s.library · Rating 3 out of 5]

What was the point of Jake if you made sure to tell us time and time again that he wasn't welcomed there?

The novella was short and hot. This is why I finished it... ah, and Jake. Jake was actually the only pleasant person in this story.

I hope the author makes up to him in the next book cuz... wth?

[Ana · Rating 4 out of 5]

This is a well written short story. There are hot noncon-dubcon with a little incest: brothers and cousin scenes. I have never read anything by this author but I will lookout for more stories.
This is (besides being pwp) a kind of coming-of-age story where the baby bro finds his place (haha) in the family dynamics. Maybe even some self-discovery with having some "aha" moments for baby brother and the others.

[Leanne · Rating 3 out of 5]

The cesty tale was great, but I was a bit disappointed that the chase wasn’t much of one. If you’re going to go for a primal-esque scene, please make it longer than a few pages. It would have been more exciting if Tyler had escaped and been chased again at least once before the final takedown so to speak. I would have happily read a longer story to get some of those details. I mean we got forest details for after the fact…

Overall it was a spicy read with some spicy characters and one domineering big brother.

[Dani (Daniiireads) · Rating 4 out of 5]

A little lake time family bonding

[⭐️ · Rating 5 out of 5]

This was soooo fcking hot jfc WOOOWWWWW theres a special place in hell for us if we enjoyed this a little too much ahahah cya there 🫶

[Sarah☀️ Somerville · Rating 3 out of 5]

Sweet and fun.

[Nicanne · Rating 5 out of 5]

Wowzers that was a super sweet and extremely hot read!!

📚Book = Standalone,
💕Burn = Fast,
🎭OW/OM Drama = No,
🐺 Alpha Men = Yep,
🔥Heat/spice = 10/10,
😬Angst = Low,
🍆🌮 MM/FF = Yes, MMMM
🔹POV = 1st Person, MPV,
🔸Genre = Contemporary Romance,
🔹Tropes = MMMM✨Tabøo✨Brothers & Cousin✨Alone in the cabin✨Bėts and competitions✨Prímål Play✨ Soft Døm✨Praise✨ Dùb Con✨DP✨Happy for now✨
‼️Check TW’s before reading‼️

Ok this story was wrong in some ways, but the connection and heāt between them all was scorching 🔥, the way their bond shifted and deepens with every interaction was beautiful and in the end, they all realised they needed each other more than they knew

The pace was perfect and for a short story Ally crammed a lot of intímācy, høt, raw, emotions and very høt s*xy scenes, without it feeling rushed.

Tyler was such an attention seeking brāt at first, but he just needed love, undivided attention and to be taken care of. He certainly got that by the bucket load from his big brothers and his cousin.
Mark was obviously the Daddy of the group and he played that part very well. He was the Soft Døm, taking charge, giving praise and ensuring Tyler was cønsėnting, comfortable and taken care off….literally 😋
Shawn was a feisty mix between Mark and Jake,
Jake was hilarious, brāsh and chaøtic, but you couldn’t help but fall in love with him. Jake was the most íntėnse and eager to be with Tyler, after years of secret ínfatúation, he’s finally given the opportunity to be with Tyler and he isn letting it go!

It’s such a shame this was a short story, I would have loved to have read more from them and to see how their relationship develops. I definitely need Baby Ty, Mark, Shawn and Jake’s Thanksgiving get away book!!

I love Ally Avery’s books and this is another I can highly recommend.

[Ashley Dead.inside_but_reads · Rating 5 out of 5]

This is a Tab00 story involving 🩸Brothers and A cousin so if that's not your thing I suggest you skip this one....if it is...😈
This is also a Novella it's only about 75 pages with with HFN ending no Cliffhanger or anything just left open for more possibilities 🔥🥵

🌶🌶🌶🌶

Tyler is spending the weekend with his 2 brothers Mark and Shawn and their cousin Jake. He hasn't seen his brothers in over a year due to college so he is excited to catch up. Tyler is the youngest of the group with the biggest gap being 10 years between him and Mark so he sometimes feels like he has to prove himself and since they are all super athletic there has always been a competitive vibe between them.
Mark has basically taken care of Tyler since he was younger, their parents sort of quit the whole parenting thing after Tyler was born. Tyler has turned into a sort of attention seeking Brat and Mark has a plan to put him back in his place and give him an attitude adjustment. Shawn and Jake are all to happy to go along with this plan, but after everything goes down some truths are spilled and feelings come out.
Um...I need more...like Stat! I need so0o0o much more on Jake and the mystery surrounding him and definitely need more of our quiet but feisty Shawn. I can totally see Mark growing into the group Dom and calling all the shots...but I am very interested in seeing him open up a bit and experiment more 🥵 So even though it's a HFN I'm excited to know we will be coming back to visit this group! Hopefully many more visits 🤣