The Battle of Malvern Hill on July 1, 1862, marked the climax of the Seven Days’ Battles around Richmond, Virginia. For the first time since the Civil War began, the full might of Maj. Gen. George B. McClellan’s Union Army of the Potomac and Gen. Robert E. Lee’s Confederate Army of Northern Virginia met. The world watched and wondered as this high-stakes combat played out on the doorstep of the Confederate capital. McClellan’s army emerged victorious with its superior positions and overwhelming artillery firepower. Yet, McClellan retreated from victory to establish a safe base on the James River. Lee’s army secured a default victory simply by holding the battlefield and saving Richmond from capture.
Francis Augustín O’Reilly’s long-awaited Retreat from Victory: The Battle of Malvern Hill and the End of the Seven Days, July 1, 1862 is the first book-length treatment of this critical and pivotal battle. O’Reilly examines the singular struggle at Malvern Hill in depth and from a wide variety of perspectives, including its implications for the war, the armies, the opposing governments, the people, and slavery. He pieces together the tactical movements of troops on the battlefield and the intentions of leaders on the front lines and in the halls of government in Washington, D.C., and Richmond. Above all, he gives voice to the soldiers, sharing their experiences in combat and on campaign.
Two decades in the making, Retreat from Victory draws on hundreds of primary sources—many previously unused—including official records, diaries, newspapers, and regimental histories. O’Reilly’s sound and reasoned conclusions are grounded in his deep archival research and keen understanding of the complex terrain. This climactic Civil War battle elevated General Lee’s career and marked the beginning of the end of General McClellan’s. It was a watershed moment when the Civil War transformed from a rebellion into a revolution. The war grew exponentially larger and more brutal—and ultimately doomed slavery in America. O’Reilly’s Retreat from Victory provides a definitive account of the Battle of Malvern Hill, setting a standard that will endure for the foreseeable future.
Retreat from Victory was a phenomenal book written by Francis Augustin O'Reilly. Before reading this book, I had some idea about the battle. When I read Earl Hess' incredible book about Pickett's Charge the author quoted several Confederate soldiers and officer stating before the assault on July 3rd, 1863, that it would be another Malvern Hill. O'Reilly points out in his book that battle terrified Confederates more than any other battle. After reading a more in-depth study about the battle I can see why.
In 1862 Union commander George McClellan had a plan to capture Richmond and bring an end to the war. He would move his army to the Virginia Peninsula by water and attack the Confederate capital. When the Union army was close to Richmond, Confederate general Joseph Johnston was wounded and that led to Robert E. Lee taking command. Lee attacked McClellan aggressively driving them back.
Now, if you are looking for an overall look at the Peninsula Campaign, you will not find that here. It is briefly explained and leads to the set-up of Malvern Hill. O'Reilly excels explaining both sides perspectives and where each side was before the battle.
Then, O'Reilly skillfully explains what happened on July 1st, 1862. The sources from soldiers on both sides really help you picture the carnage of the battle. One example comes from Captain Eugene Blackford, a Confederate soldier, stated succinctly after attacking the Federals, "On Tuesday, we were murdered."
Another strength of O'Reilly's book is his use of anecdotes to bring the story to life. One story I remember was seventeen-year-old Peter Rafferty, who served in the 69th New York. When he engaged in battle, he was shot in his thigh and was advised to medical attention, but the young soldier refused and continued fighting. He was shot in the jaw and lost part of his tongue by two other shots. He was then shot in the foot. He was left for dead and taken prisoner, but he survived his ordeal. His comrades thought he deserved the Medal of Honor.
Another story I found interesting was the story of two brother named James and Lewis Branscombe, who fought for the South. In fact, The Battle of Malvern Hill was the one-year anniversary of leaving home. James wrote, "You know I have often wished a chance at the Yankees....I don't care now if I never hear another boom or ball." Lewis wrote after the Confederate attack on Union batteries "Where our men charged their batteries there were men piled up by the dozens." Both brothers survived, but many of their comrades did not.
I was extremely impressed with this book. It was readable and well-researched. I especially enjoyed O'Reilly's commentary at the end regarding who performed well in battle on both sides and who did not. His thoughts on how the battle impacted the war were also interesting. If you have little to no knowledge of the Peninsula Campaign, I recommend starting with Stephen Sears' book To the Gates of Richmond and then reading O'Reilly's book afterwards. A welcome collection in my Civil War library.
Frank O’Reilly’s book on the Battle of Malvern Hill, Retreat from Victory, is a masterpiece of research and writing. He brings the reader right onto the battlefield with intense firsthand descriptions of the bloody fighting. O’Reilly also provides smart analysis of the actions of the military leaders involved on both sides of the battle. This book is an immediate classic and should be on all Civil War bookshelves.
It is clear after reading O'Reilly's book why Confederate and Union survivors of Malvern Hill chose not to write much about it. For the Confederates it was a disaster, as if a group of amateurs took control of the Army of Northern Virginia and launched suicidal frontal attacks upon well paced Union artillery and infantry. The Army of the Potomac fought well but their commander, George McClellan, exercised no command even though he was close by, leaving his corps commanders to manage the battle on their own. Then, after smashing the Confederate attacks, McClellan ordered a retreat, hence the name of the book. O'Reilly's research is superb and his maps are adequate. The text however, could have used an editor to tighten things up. Overall, a fine job of bringing to light a major battle of the war that has lanquished in obscurity.