What do you think?
Rate this book
Dreadful Sorry, Clementine
Both and Neither
Following My Darling Clementine, the second half of the story continues with Dreadful Sorry, Clementine. It’s 1848 and the Dennisons are traveling as a married couple by covered wagon to reach the gold rush in California.
Clem, a prospector and writer who’s passing for a man, is cautious by nature. A loner by choice, she makes plans and prefers being prepared, dealing with life on her own terms. She surprised herself when she proposed one night and was married the next.
Kizzy, her spirited and impulsive wife, is unprepared for the dangers on the trail, but willing to do what it takes to chase her dream. She learns to fight and proves it at a dance, gets taken in by Jim Bridger’s tall tales, and assists the royal physician to a four-year-old king, experiencing both life and death.
During their journey, the Dennisons make friends, take on responsibility, and earn unexpected respectability. Life seems sweet, their lesbian sex is explosive, and they grow ever closer, sharing their dreams and encouraging one another. Each is falling in love with the other, but neither will say so. After all, their marriage is based on an agreement to reach gold territory. Each thinks the other will leave once they reach their destination.
Can Clem and Kizzy overcome their insecurities and speak up in time? Or will illness, claim jumpers, and a sensual shaman tear them apart?
Following My Darling Clementine, the second half of the story continues with Dreadful Sorry, Clementine. It’s 1848 and the Dennisons are traveling as a married couple by covered wagon to reach the gold rush in California.
Clem, a prospector and writer who’s passing for a man, is cautious by nature. A loner by choice, she makes plans and prefers being prepared, dealing with life on her own terms. She surprised herself when she proposed one night and was married the next.
Kizzy, her spirited and impulsive wife, is unprepared for the dangers on the trail, but willing to do what it takes to chase her dream. She learns to fight and proves it at a dance, gets taken in by Jim Bridger’s tall tales, and assists the royal physician to a four-year-old king, experiencing both life and death.
During their journey, the Dennisons make friends, take on responsibility, and earn unexpected respectability. Life seems sweet, their lesbian sex is explosive, and they grow ever closer, sharing their dreams and encouraging one another. Each is falling in love with the other, but neither will say so. After all, their marriage is based on an agreement to reach gold territory. Each thinks the other will leave once they reach their destination.
Can Clem and Kizzy overcome their insecurities and speak up in time? Or will illness, claim jumpers, and a sensual shaman tear them apart?
326 pages, Kindle Edition
Published December 1, 2025
8 people are currently reading
16 people want to read
About the author
Genta Sebastian
27 books70 followersGenta Sebastian runs with scissors, always laughs without shame, sometimes writes naked, and can’t help dreaming big.
A multiple award-winning author, she sometimes writes Sapphic romances, like the Troublemaker series:
When Butches Cry (2nd ed. rel. August, 2023)as:
A Troublemaker Never Cries
A Troublemaker May Surprise (rel. August, 2023)
A Troublemaker Sometimes Lies (exp. rel. date Nov. 2023)
A Troublemaker in Her Eyes (exp. rel. date May, 2024)
She’s also written two novels for children living in Rainbow Families: Riding the Rainbow (GCLS award winner 2015) for middle-school readers, and A Man’s Man for Young Adults.
She stepped into the horror genre with: We Don’t Say Gay in Tranquility Bay! a trigger-warning horror story with a twist.
Lost is a novelette right out of the Twilight Zone. A grieving widow finds a strange child lost in a snowstorm, made of snow and ice.
But she started out writing wlw (women loving women, i.e. lesbian) erotica short stories that range from super-hot sexy sci-fi Martian/Human first contact, to culinary cunnilinguists, to drag kings, to college and tropical vacations, exotic settings, unforgettable characters, and quirky situations. These stories are fully adult and not intended for young audiences.
See her Amazon Author Page for current releases.
A multiple award-winning author, she sometimes writes Sapphic romances, like the Troublemaker series:
When Butches Cry (2nd ed. rel. August, 2023)as:
A Troublemaker Never Cries
A Troublemaker May Surprise (rel. August, 2023)
A Troublemaker Sometimes Lies (exp. rel. date Nov. 2023)
A Troublemaker in Her Eyes (exp. rel. date May, 2024)
She’s also written two novels for children living in Rainbow Families: Riding the Rainbow (GCLS award winner 2015) for middle-school readers, and A Man’s Man for Young Adults.
She stepped into the horror genre with: We Don’t Say Gay in Tranquility Bay! a trigger-warning horror story with a twist.
Lost is a novelette right out of the Twilight Zone. A grieving widow finds a strange child lost in a snowstorm, made of snow and ice.
But she started out writing wlw (women loving women, i.e. lesbian) erotica short stories that range from super-hot sexy sci-fi Martian/Human first contact, to culinary cunnilinguists, to drag kings, to college and tropical vacations, exotic settings, unforgettable characters, and quirky situations. These stories are fully adult and not intended for young audiences.
See her Amazon Author Page for current releases.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 11 of 11 reviews
November 21, 2025
4 Stars
You know how it is when it’s a duology and the first book was really exciting but usually the second book sort of stalls a bit and doesn’t have as much oomph because all the excitement happened in book one? (I can’t help but think of this specific “popular” book amongst sapphics that was an OK book for me but very well loved by readers so I don’t voice my opinion publicly). Anyway, Clementine Duology by Genta Sebastian didn’t suffer the same fate!
Dreadful Sorry, Clementine carried most of the fireworks of the duology. The train’s travel through the desert held so much rousing adventures with new characters introduced and you eventually learn to love. And while lulled into a false sense of comfort, cunning booby traps come out of nowhere and leave you stunned, in despair and the rest you’ll have to find out yourself.
The Clementine duology is every bit the Wild West, romance and sapphic novel it promises. Highly recommended.
You know how it is when it’s a duology and the first book was really exciting but usually the second book sort of stalls a bit and doesn’t have as much oomph because all the excitement happened in book one? (I can’t help but think of this specific “popular” book amongst sapphics that was an OK book for me but very well loved by readers so I don’t voice my opinion publicly). Anyway, Clementine Duology by Genta Sebastian didn’t suffer the same fate!
Dreadful Sorry, Clementine carried most of the fireworks of the duology. The train’s travel through the desert held so much rousing adventures with new characters introduced and you eventually learn to love. And while lulled into a false sense of comfort, cunning booby traps come out of nowhere and leave you stunned, in despair and the rest you’ll have to find out yourself.
The Clementine duology is every bit the Wild West, romance and sapphic novel it promises. Highly recommended.
January 23, 2026
Both and Neither
Oh this tale had me going. The details of the wagon train to California gold is outstanding. But the winner is the relationships on the way
I loved the alternative genders and the life they lived with a tribute to the Sharman. Great titles for both duology. I can guess what you are humming
Oh this tale had me going. The details of the wagon train to California gold is outstanding. But the winner is the relationships on the way
I loved the alternative genders and the life they lived with a tribute to the Sharman. Great titles for both duology. I can guess what you are humming
November 30, 2025
**** ARC REVIEW ****
Another great book by Genta Sebastian. This was a great follow up to My Darling Clementine with more of the characters we came to love in that book. This book, I think, can best be described as a story told in two parts.. one tragic event separating the first and second halves. Without giving any spoilers, I’ll just say that the event took me by surprise but the second half of the book more than made up for it.
There is a lot to this book… almost too much. It gets a bit overwhelming locating our MCs love story in the midst of so many other relationships that are represented in this book. There is polyamory, bisexuality, transgender representation, and more; all portrayed respectfully and keeping with the time period that this story is set. There is so much that I feel like Clem and Kizzy’s story gets lost for a bit. The author does a great job of pulling it all together in the end. A really unique and spicy take on historical fiction that’s definitely worth the read
Another great book by Genta Sebastian. This was a great follow up to My Darling Clementine with more of the characters we came to love in that book. This book, I think, can best be described as a story told in two parts.. one tragic event separating the first and second halves. Without giving any spoilers, I’ll just say that the event took me by surprise but the second half of the book more than made up for it.
There is a lot to this book… almost too much. It gets a bit overwhelming locating our MCs love story in the midst of so many other relationships that are represented in this book. There is polyamory, bisexuality, transgender representation, and more; all portrayed respectfully and keeping with the time period that this story is set. There is so much that I feel like Clem and Kizzy’s story gets lost for a bit. The author does a great job of pulling it all together in the end. A really unique and spicy take on historical fiction that’s definitely worth the read
January 6, 2026
Some Native American "exotic sexual magic" going on. In fact, this played a major role and was actually pretty uncomfortable to read at times. It is a pity, because until that point I was enjoying this dualology quite a lot.
I could forgive the story being written around "Oh my Darling", even though this song wouldn't be first recorded until almost 30 years after it was set, but the racist exoticism (even if portrayed as a "positive") was just too much for me.
I could forgive the story being written around "Oh my Darling", even though this song wouldn't be first recorded until almost 30 years after it was set, but the racist exoticism (even if portrayed as a "positive") was just too much for me.
November 19, 2025
4.5
In a world that often demands one or the other, Dreadful Sorry, Clementine dares to celebrate the beauty of being Both and Neither.
Review of Dreadful Sorry, Clementine by Genta Sebastian
Dreadful Sorry, Clementine is an absolute gem of a novel. Layered, heartfelt, and powerfully affirming. It weaves together love, resilience, and identity against the hardships of the westward journey, creating a story that lingers long after the last page.
Representation of Gender and Identity
One of the novel’s greatest strengths is its exploration of sexuality and gender beyond the binary. Clem’s description of being “Both and Neither” is a breathtakingly honest moment, capturing the essence of gender fluidity with compassion and depth. Instead of being portrayed as a struggle to be “fixed,” Clem’s identity is simply part of who they are, and it is honored with dignity and respect throughout the narrative. This made the story feel not only authentic, but revolutionary in its tenderness.
Indigenous Respect and Wisdom
The novel also shines in how it acknowledges the perspectives of Indigenous people, particularly their recognition of gender-fluid individuals as special, respected members of their communities. That inclusion broadens the narrative beyond a Eurocentric lens and grounds the story in a deeper cultural truth that resonates with history and present-day conversations about gender diversity. It takes guts to write something like this.
Tender Relationships
The relationships in this book are what truly make it unforgettable. Kizzy’s tenderness with Poppy was deeply moving. A reminder of the nurturing power of care, even in harsh times. Their bond carried so much softness, and it beautifully contrasted with the grit of frontier survival. Equally striking was Clem’s healing relationship with Foxtail. Those moments of connection revealed Clem’s growth, vulnerability, and capacity for love beyond romantic partnership, showcasing another layer of the novel’s emotional richness.
A Story of Resilience and Love
At its heart, this is a story about survival. Not just on the trail, but in living authentically. Clem and Kizzy’s partnership is radiant, full of trust, humor, and unshakable devotion. The historical backdrop of wagons, hardships, and uncertainty is vividly painted, but it’s the characters’ humanity, their tenderness, their willingness to love despite fear that really makes the story soar.
Final Thoughts
Genta Sebastian has given us more than a historical novel; she has given us a love story that celebrates difference, honors Indigenous voices, and embraces the complexity of human identity. Truly giving the reader, a gritty look into the frontier life. Dreadful Sorry, Clementine is tender, brave, and unflinchingly real. I cannot recommend it enough.
In a world that often demands one or the other, Dreadful Sorry, Clementine dares to celebrate the beauty of being Both and Neither.
Review of Dreadful Sorry, Clementine by Genta Sebastian
Dreadful Sorry, Clementine is an absolute gem of a novel. Layered, heartfelt, and powerfully affirming. It weaves together love, resilience, and identity against the hardships of the westward journey, creating a story that lingers long after the last page.
Representation of Gender and Identity
One of the novel’s greatest strengths is its exploration of sexuality and gender beyond the binary. Clem’s description of being “Both and Neither” is a breathtakingly honest moment, capturing the essence of gender fluidity with compassion and depth. Instead of being portrayed as a struggle to be “fixed,” Clem’s identity is simply part of who they are, and it is honored with dignity and respect throughout the narrative. This made the story feel not only authentic, but revolutionary in its tenderness.
Indigenous Respect and Wisdom
The novel also shines in how it acknowledges the perspectives of Indigenous people, particularly their recognition of gender-fluid individuals as special, respected members of their communities. That inclusion broadens the narrative beyond a Eurocentric lens and grounds the story in a deeper cultural truth that resonates with history and present-day conversations about gender diversity. It takes guts to write something like this.
Tender Relationships
The relationships in this book are what truly make it unforgettable. Kizzy’s tenderness with Poppy was deeply moving. A reminder of the nurturing power of care, even in harsh times. Their bond carried so much softness, and it beautifully contrasted with the grit of frontier survival. Equally striking was Clem’s healing relationship with Foxtail. Those moments of connection revealed Clem’s growth, vulnerability, and capacity for love beyond romantic partnership, showcasing another layer of the novel’s emotional richness.
A Story of Resilience and Love
At its heart, this is a story about survival. Not just on the trail, but in living authentically. Clem and Kizzy’s partnership is radiant, full of trust, humor, and unshakable devotion. The historical backdrop of wagons, hardships, and uncertainty is vividly painted, but it’s the characters’ humanity, their tenderness, their willingness to love despite fear that really makes the story soar.
Final Thoughts
Genta Sebastian has given us more than a historical novel; she has given us a love story that celebrates difference, honors Indigenous voices, and embraces the complexity of human identity. Truly giving the reader, a gritty look into the frontier life. Dreadful Sorry, Clementine is tender, brave, and unflinchingly real. I cannot recommend it enough.
February 4, 2026
The exciting adventure continues…
Clem and Kizzy have made good progress as part of the travelling party out to reach California, but things start to get tough along the way. With frightful moments, and experiences beyond their wildest dreams, both of them have a very different experience before reaching the dream.
This is the second part of a duology, so it is important to have read My Darling, Clementine, before starting this part. It sets up the story and provides all the history you need to really understand Clem, Kizzy, and where they find themselves now. It’s difficult to share too much about this part of the story without spoilers, but it was packed with unexpected surprises that left me shocked, excited, and filled with hope. It was quite the emotional rollercoaster for both Clem and Kizzy, and me reading it. There were so many sweet moments though, filled with sentiment and heart that often bought a tear. Alongside that though, Kizzy was really growing with all her experience and it was magical to join her on that journey.
To Kizzy everything about this travelling and train, prospecting for gold, and the different way of life in California was a new experience, and she went through so much during those times of discovery that was interesting to experience. She didn’t let anything hold her back, and she was definitely taking centre stage in this part of the story. She was strong and determined, and I admired her spirit and ambition. She was loved, supported, and everything she was given, she made sure to give back to others to keep spreading the good fortune that had come to her on her adventure. With Clem, their connection only grew, and they were insatiable, and Kizzy ended up pouring that same energy into everything she did. They really were pioneers for women being able to succeed in a man’s world.
I really enjoyed this part of the story and am excited for any future stories we might get about Kizzy and Clem, as they really have a bright one waiting.
Clem and Kizzy have made good progress as part of the travelling party out to reach California, but things start to get tough along the way. With frightful moments, and experiences beyond their wildest dreams, both of them have a very different experience before reaching the dream.
This is the second part of a duology, so it is important to have read My Darling, Clementine, before starting this part. It sets up the story and provides all the history you need to really understand Clem, Kizzy, and where they find themselves now. It’s difficult to share too much about this part of the story without spoilers, but it was packed with unexpected surprises that left me shocked, excited, and filled with hope. It was quite the emotional rollercoaster for both Clem and Kizzy, and me reading it. There were so many sweet moments though, filled with sentiment and heart that often bought a tear. Alongside that though, Kizzy was really growing with all her experience and it was magical to join her on that journey.
To Kizzy everything about this travelling and train, prospecting for gold, and the different way of life in California was a new experience, and she went through so much during those times of discovery that was interesting to experience. She didn’t let anything hold her back, and she was definitely taking centre stage in this part of the story. She was strong and determined, and I admired her spirit and ambition. She was loved, supported, and everything she was given, she made sure to give back to others to keep spreading the good fortune that had come to her on her adventure. With Clem, their connection only grew, and they were insatiable, and Kizzy ended up pouring that same energy into everything she did. They really were pioneers for women being able to succeed in a man’s world.
I really enjoyed this part of the story and am excited for any future stories we might get about Kizzy and Clem, as they really have a bright one waiting.
November 28, 2025
Book two of this duology was an exciting continuation, beginning right where My Darling Clementine left off. Sometimes the second book of a duology doesn’t bring the same intensity as the first, but that’s definitely not the case with Dreadful Sorry, Clementine. I remained fascinated throughout the wagon train’s journey. I loved all the side characters such as Jed, Mara, Olga and Paps.
Clem and Kizzy’s relationship grows more each day on the trail. Although they showed each other many ways over how they truly felt for one another, they didn’t use words until tragedy struck. I couldn’t wait for, well I don’t want to give everything away!
Highly recommend this fascinating historical sapphic romance duology!!
Clem and Kizzy’s relationship grows more each day on the trail. Although they showed each other many ways over how they truly felt for one another, they didn’t use words until tragedy struck. I couldn’t wait for, well I don’t want to give everything away!
Highly recommend this fascinating historical sapphic romance duology!!
February 25, 2026
This book completely hit me in the feels. I loved it even more than the first one. It was incredibly poignant and so interesting and different from other books. I loved all the bada$$ women and thoroughly fleshed out side characters. This series is so well-written. There’s plenty of spice, adventure, longing, and lots of laughs along the way. The last 20% of the book was a total sprint to the finish with all of the action, it makes up for some of the slower parts.
February 22, 2026
A good continuation on the first story. There was sadness in the story which made me almost quit reading it, this only shows that the author is doing such a good job keeping a reader hooked. Personally I could go for a Clem and Kizzy book number 3.
October 11, 2025
This was a good book. I loved the story between the MCs. I laughed and cried while reading their story.
December 4, 2025
Well, that was quite a ride. I was only disappointed that everything was wrapped up so neatly that it makes it unlikely that the series will continue. Having read and enjoyed the first book I must admit I did not see what was coming in the second one but it was so much more that I could have expected. Besides Clem and Kizzy there are a whole host of side characters who are well developed in their own right and I found myself rooting for them all.
The whole book was a celebration of strong women and what we are all able and willing to go through to thrive, not just survive.
The whole book was a celebration of strong women and what we are all able and willing to go through to thrive, not just survive.
Displaying 1 - 11 of 11 reviews