This has been on my bookshelf for many years and I regularly take it down to read ... everyone who has or works with animals, not just horses, should read this.
Not that I entirely agree on everything she says...but that's not the point of the book. It makes you think, makes you question how we keep horses in a modern world, and whether what we are doing is right FROM THE HORSES' POINT OF VIEW!
The first half of the book is hard to argue with. The author examines the type of modern stable that we are all sadly familiar with - horses kept it stables, turned out in individual paddocks, rugged or bandaged at all times for fear of injury, fed restricted high concentrate diets and exercised for an hour under saddle if they're lucky. While I know a lot of horse owners who don't do this, there are a lot of stables that run this way, because 'that's the way it has always been done.' By discussing how horses have evolved, how they interact with other horses and with humans, how they play, eat, graze, have sex in the wild, she makes you realise that maybe some things really should change if we are truly dedicated to upping the welfare of any domesticated horse. She is not one of these people who believes that all animals should be returned to the wild and left alone - far from it. She truly believes that horses and humans can enrich each other's lives, but that the present 'recommended' practices might actually be detrimental to both.
The second half of the book is, for me, a bit harder to read - and only because I don't always agree with her. Again, that doesn't spoil my enjoyment of the book - growling aloud and arguing as you read is at least interacting with the prose. The book was first published in 1997, when I was at college studying Equine Science, and much of the 'proof' that the author says isn't available (such as the number of horse deaths at the Olympics), I clearly remember including in my own reports. So it may genuinely be that things have started to move on - that welfare is becoming more about the horse and less about keeping things the same.
What I do think the author fails to address is that the majority of horse owners (especially in the UK) are not as she suggest - city folk paying to keep horses in livery stables where they barely see them. They're like me - one or two horses that yes, get kept on someone else's land or stables, but who do all of the care, the exercise and are completely responsible for that horse. I would love to have the money to buy my own place, so my horse can live a fabulous life like those on her 'experimental' farm. But sadly I don't - so I do the best I can to make sure his behavioural, physiological and social needs are met, under the constraints of someone else's yard.
Still, I will always enjoy reading this book, even when it frustrates me or occasionally makes me angry. Anything that makes you think about WHY you do something in a certain way and encourages you to question tradition, is always going to be a good thing.