Thank you NetGalley and Delacorte Press for the ARC in exchange for an honest review!
E. Kennedy’s “Thornbird” combines small-town secrets, buried grief, and the lingering shadow of a serial killer into a slow-burn mystery that ultimately delivers emotional depth and a dark, satisfying payoff. While it may open with familiar high-school dynamics and a touch of “new girl in town” melodrama, “Thornbird” steadily shifts into something more complex and unsettling; it’s more a character study than a traditional thriller, yet still rich with tension and unexpected revelations.
Ryan Shipley returns to Starling, Tennessee under a name that hides who she really is: the daughter of notorious serial killer Gabriel Thorn. Her grandmother’s recent death leaves her no choice but to move back to the place she’s spent her life trying to forget, just as the ten-year anniversary of her father’s arrest and upcoming execution reignites community obsession with his crimes. Rumors swirl, rewards resurface, and the search for his missing victims becomes town gossip, especially since many believe Ryan may secretly know where the bodies are hidden.
The beginning leans into high-school stereotypes. Almost every archetype seems drawn to Ryan, and the drama surrounding her social circle can feel shallow at first. Yet beneath that surface is a heavier emotional core: Ryan’s struggle to reconcile her lingering love for the father who raised her with the monstrous legacy he left behind. Kennedy slowly reveals how this tension has shaped her identity, her trauma, and the way others see her. The story’s pacing mirrors Ryan’s internal conflict; it’s quiet, steady, and introspective in the middle, but builds toward an ending laced with darkness and revelation.
Though I didn’t find “Thornbird” traditionally “thrilling,” especially since it’s such a long book, the mystery deepens in the final act as long-hidden truths surface and the eerie symbolism of birds becomes disturbingly clear. The twist involving one of the victims is haunting, and the way Kennedy ties the imagery of preservation, beauty, and captivity to Gabriel Thorn’s worldview makes the resolution particularly chilling. By the end, the characters emerge scarred but striving toward growth, showing that no one is perfect, but everyone is capable of becoming more than the past that shaped them.
With careful pacing, emotional weight, and just enough romantic tension to complicate rather than distract, “Thornbird” is well-suited for older teens and fans of mysteries that prioritize character over shock factor. Those looking for nonstop action may find the journey slow, but those who appreciate layered storytelling, morally tangled characters, and an ending that lingers long after the final page will find much to admire.
Overall, “Thornbird” is a reflective, atmospheric mystery that quietly sharpens into something dark and unforgettable. Stick through the slow start; the final revelations are worth the wait.