4.5 stars
This was a solid read.
Let’s start with Nicola. She’s a tough character to warm up to. Though she is successful, sharp, brilliant but at the same time she is emotionally closed off, especially when it comes to her daughter, Charlotte. It’s frustrating to watch her intellectualize everything while completely missing the emotional needs of the people around her, except perhaps Geeta. But the brilliance of Clare Ashton’s writing is that she never asks us to excuse Nicola. The internalized homophobia, the shame, the deep-rooted fear are all rooted in Nicola’s past and the times and surroundings she grew up in.
Somewhere in the book, you start to understand why Nicola is the way she is, even if you don’t always agree with her. That understanding builds slowly, and by the end, you find yourself hoping she figures things out. Not because she’s perfect, but because she’s trying.
Geeta, on the other hand, is pure heart. She’s warm, grounded, and the emotional glue of the story. Her capacity to care, her connection to food and family, and her resilience after divorce make her immediately likeable. She is there not only for her family but also for her daughter's friends who she has befriended. What stood out to me was how her softness is never treated as weakness. Geeta knows who she is, even when life throws uncertainty her way.
Their romance is kinda a slow burn. Tbh, I was skeptical at first. They’re such opposites, it was hard to imagine them ever making sense together. But Ashton lets their dynamic simmer with baggage, tension, and good amount of spice. And when it finally clicks, it really clicks. It feels believable, not because they magically fix each other, but because they learn to meet halfway.
Another element that really stood out was the way the book handles mother-daughter relationships. Nicola and Charlotte’s bond is complicated and often painful. Years of distance and misunderstanding have left scars that don’t heal easily. Charlotte has clearly internalized the feeling of being othered and unaccepted, and it’s heartbreaking. That slow, stumbling rebuild of trust was one of the most rewarding arcs in the book, even if Nicola’s growth sometimes felt a little sudden.
Then there’s Geeta and Olivia. Their relationship feels closer on the surface in this book as compared to the 2nd book, but there’s an ache beneath despite the closeness. The kind that comes with growing up and diverging paths. Olivia, in some ways, mirrors Nicola. She is strong-willed, independent, and not always easy to read. Those hugs between her and Geeta said more than words ever could. About pride, love, and the bittersweetness of watching your child become someone you don’t always fully understand.
We get little glimpses of familiar faces from the previous books, which is a lovely reward for longtime readers of the series. What really elevated the ending for me was how Ashton tied everything together. The final chapters offer glimpses from everyone’s perspectives. Charlotte and Millie, Olivia and Kate. It brought the entire series full circle in a way that felt warm and complete. If you’ve read the earlier books, this closing arc feels like coming home.
Yes, Nicola’s turnaround might feel a little too sudden and rushed. But Ashton doesn’t erase the mess. She simply shows what happens when people choose to face it and grow from it rather than be defined by it. And that’s what makes the ending feel earned, not forced.
Discovering Nicola isn’t exactly a sweeping romance. It’s a story about showing up better, about parenting and queerness and the ways adults fail and try again. Basically, a satisfying close to a trilogy.