What do you think?
Rate this book
Ashland #2
Wonder, Wonder
For a year now the romance between Arrick Filan and Evan Miller has been going strong. Between rehearsals, running Ashland High, teaching, Arrick’s jealous ex, and a menagerie of pets at home, life is hectic and messy, but Evan decides to ask the question of questions anyway.
Everything seems perfect, until a sudden series of deaths uncovers a family secret in the form of Arrick's baby brother – a spare turned heir. Now the caretaker of the brother who was meant to replace him, Arrick and Evan must learn to navigate unfamiliar waters and how to keep their relationship intact.
Everything seems perfect, until a sudden series of deaths uncovers a family secret in the form of Arrick's baby brother – a spare turned heir. Now the caretaker of the brother who was meant to replace him, Arrick and Evan must learn to navigate unfamiliar waters and how to keep their relationship intact.
- GenresContemporary
302 pages, Kindle Edition
First published November 25, 2025
2 people are currently reading
29 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 42 reviews
November 30, 2025
It's been sooooo wonderful to be back with Arrick and Evan again!
After loving "Mirror, Mirror" to absolute pieces, I was looking forward to this second part, and it did not disappoint. I was a bit worried, because my slump has been kicking my butt since summer, but I'm so glad my brain behaved for this one.
Arrick and Evan's journey towards a HEA is wild and compelling and romantic, full of ups and downs and twists, emotional upheavals and heart-warming moments. I adored being in their heads again and meeting the wonderful side characters again was just as amazing.
I highly recommend this duology.
Many thanks to the author for the ARC. This is my honest opinion
After loving "Mirror, Mirror" to absolute pieces, I was looking forward to this second part, and it did not disappoint. I was a bit worried, because my slump has been kicking my butt since summer, but I'm so glad my brain behaved for this one.
Arrick and Evan's journey towards a HEA is wild and compelling and romantic, full of ups and downs and twists, emotional upheavals and heart-warming moments. I adored being in their heads again and meeting the wonderful side characters again was just as amazing.
I highly recommend this duology.
Many thanks to the author for the ARC. This is my honest opinion
November 22, 2025
I’ve grown sooo attached to these characters and absolutely loved reading their story.
The dark cloud that is Silver Rock carried over from the previous book, keeping me on the edge of my seat and making me question and distrust everything right along with Arrick. Even with all the chaos happening in Ashland, I was so proud of Arrick’s growth. He definitely had his moments, but I feel like he always bounced back and learned to rely on Evan, which made me extremely happy 🥹
Little Arthur was such an adorable addition to the story, adding a whole new layer to their dynamic. Reading their interactions and seeing how he slowly but surely became part of their lives was the cutest thing ever. And I loooooved the musical theatre aspect!! Arrick’s bond with their students and Evan’s steady support was just… it might be a strange way to put it, but it felt healing. I could practically feel part of Arrick’s heartbreak stitching itself back together through staying connected to what he loved most. And with Evan and their friends right there to lift him up and give him confidence ❤️
And also… THE question???? Yes, please. These two are absolutely soulmates and I couldn’t love them more.
I’m gonna miss these guys so much!!!! I’m completely in love with their love and their journey. And even though I’d happily read a five-part series lol, the author promised a HEA and she absolutely delivered. What a wonderful book :’)
The dark cloud that is Silver Rock carried over from the previous book, keeping me on the edge of my seat and making me question and distrust everything right along with Arrick. Even with all the chaos happening in Ashland, I was so proud of Arrick’s growth. He definitely had his moments, but I feel like he always bounced back and learned to rely on Evan, which made me extremely happy 🥹
Little Arthur was such an adorable addition to the story, adding a whole new layer to their dynamic. Reading their interactions and seeing how he slowly but surely became part of their lives was the cutest thing ever. And I loooooved the musical theatre aspect!! Arrick’s bond with their students and Evan’s steady support was just… it might be a strange way to put it, but it felt healing. I could practically feel part of Arrick’s heartbreak stitching itself back together through staying connected to what he loved most. And with Evan and their friends right there to lift him up and give him confidence ❤️
And also… THE question???? Yes, please. These two are absolutely soulmates and I couldn’t love them more.
I’m gonna miss these guys so much!!!! I’m completely in love with their love and their journey. And even though I’d happily read a five-part series lol, the author promised a HEA and she absolutely delivered. What a wonderful book :’)
November 13, 2025
Arrick and Evan are happy, building their home by renovating the barn on Evan’s Dad’s property and working at the school where Evan is now the principal.
The company that keeps giving them money for improvements is causing a lot of tension, especially after it hires people to work at the wharf and 3 people are injured, apparently getting beat up.
Arrick’s father shows up to meet Ben, who owns the company, and another man, John, at a restaurant, and Evan has to get Arrick out. He then hears from his Dad’s wife, Joan, who has a son and wants to leave him and has reached out to Ben for help.
She sends Arrick documents that he’s not ready to look at, then she and Arrick’s Dad are killed in a car accident. That leaves the baby, little Arthur, orphaned, and Arrick and Evan face becoming his adoptive parents.
Meanwhile, there’s more suspicion about the wharf after one worker who was injured dies, and upon returning home with Arthur, John, one of Ben’s associates, quits and shows he’s the one who sent them papers that incriminate Ben in the deaths in the town. He killed Joan because she learned about his crooked dealings.
The papers also show Arrick’s Dad’s involvement, and all he owns which will go to Arthur. Arrick confronts Ben and the information is released, and Arrick and Evan sell the properties and stocks, leaving them plenty to raise their son Arthur.
This was a great story, with Arthur changing the couples’ lives forever. The business side of things is a bit confusing and hard to follow, though Ben being behind the deaths is no surprise.
I received this ARC for free and am glad to give it my honest review with thanks.
The company that keeps giving them money for improvements is causing a lot of tension, especially after it hires people to work at the wharf and 3 people are injured, apparently getting beat up.
Arrick’s father shows up to meet Ben, who owns the company, and another man, John, at a restaurant, and Evan has to get Arrick out. He then hears from his Dad’s wife, Joan, who has a son and wants to leave him and has reached out to Ben for help.
She sends Arrick documents that he’s not ready to look at, then she and Arrick’s Dad are killed in a car accident. That leaves the baby, little Arthur, orphaned, and Arrick and Evan face becoming his adoptive parents.
Meanwhile, there’s more suspicion about the wharf after one worker who was injured dies, and upon returning home with Arthur, John, one of Ben’s associates, quits and shows he’s the one who sent them papers that incriminate Ben in the deaths in the town. He killed Joan because she learned about his crooked dealings.
The papers also show Arrick’s Dad’s involvement, and all he owns which will go to Arthur. Arrick confronts Ben and the information is released, and Arrick and Evan sell the properties and stocks, leaving them plenty to raise their son Arthur.
This was a great story, with Arthur changing the couples’ lives forever. The business side of things is a bit confusing and hard to follow, though Ben being behind the deaths is no surprise.
I received this ARC for free and am glad to give it my honest review with thanks.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
December 3, 2025
4.5/5 stars! I love the covers in this series. This is the second book in the Ashland series by author Christina Nolte. This is with the established couple Arrick and Evan. I loved getting to spend more time with them. Their chemistry is amazing, but it is their honest love and devotion to supporting each other that shines through the most. Highly recommend reading this series.
November 16, 2025
so i’m really emotional over finishing this book 😭😭😭😭😭
i loved Evan and Arrick so so so much and after reading the first book i was obsessed !!!!!!!!! being able to read their second book makes me so happy and despite all of the things they went through at the end they got the ending they deserve 💗💗💗💗💗💗 Arthur is so so cute 🥺, they are fathers and they are doing a great job !!!! 🫶🫶🫶🫶
Thank you to Christina for giving me an arc, as always this was a wonderful book and so happy i got the opportunity to read it early 🫶
I have so much to say but right now I can say this book was awesome and you should read it !!!
i loved Evan and Arrick so so so much and after reading the first book i was obsessed !!!!!!!!! being able to read their second book makes me so happy and despite all of the things they went through at the end they got the ending they deserve 💗💗💗💗💗💗 Arthur is so so cute 🥺, they are fathers and they are doing a great job !!!! 🫶🫶🫶🫶
Thank you to Christina for giving me an arc, as always this was a wonderful book and so happy i got the opportunity to read it early 🫶
I have so much to say but right now I can say this book was awesome and you should read it !!!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
November 26, 2025
WONDER, WONDER
By Christina Nolte
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️.25
I received an E-book ARC edition of this novel in exchange for an honest review. It Is available NOW on Amazon & Kindle Unlimited!
www.amazon.com/B0FTFYJ4TS
This is a 300-page Medium Paced, Established Couple with Black Cat / Golden Retriever Vibes, Teacher Romance, Small-Town, Sudden Life Changing, Part 2 of a Duology MM Romance. Part One, MIRROR, MIRROR, must be read first to completely enjoy this novel that concludes their story. Picking up a short time after Part One ended, life for Arrick and Evan looks promising, other than the stress of work, as their school needs some big repairs and big life decisions that are both exciting and scary.
Arrick is still feeling the effects of what happened with his Ex and his Father ending his career and relationship, but having Evan in his life is making that memory blur. He is happy with teaching and directing the high school play, Peter Pan. He has made a connection with his students that we all hope for our children. Evan has settled into his new position as Principal after the conclusion of Mirror, Mirror. However, its constant paperwork, finances, and dealing with school repairs. The town is in trouble financially so Arrick’s Ex, Ben, and his Company as well as his father have stepped in to turn it all around by buying the Wharf, employing townspeople to work there and donating funds to repair the school. Arrick doesn’t trust Ben or his father and has a constant itch up his back about the whole sketchy situation. Then life gets turned on it head so fast, the reader gets whiplash.
This duology is the most REAL contemporary story I think I have ever read. Christina Nolte wrote with such passion, emotion, and a sense of hesitation creating a tension that the reader feels in their fingertips while holding this book. The scenarios she puts our MCs through were not written in fantasy but felt like it came from actual experiences. These things could all happen. The drama with the wharf was the perfect amount of drama and mystery, I thought I was actually reading an article in a real newspaper. The aftermath of the life changing accidents felt so realistic, I felt them in my bones. Please see Content Warnings. She wrote in a nice flow that kept your attention, even during the slow parts, which were needed to break from the stress of what life throws at you suddenly. The way she wrote conflicted grief was brilliant. It’s the oddest feeling to go through, I should know, and she absolutely nailed it! She even showed how grief isn’t one sided. When a partner goes through that, you go through it too, except the other person in the relationship takes on the responsibility of getting them through it all by being a cushion to fall on when the griever crumbles apart.
The spice was minimal. 1.5/5 🌶. Part 1 was the same. The author shows the connection between the MCs with emotion during these scenes instead of detail of their actions. I wouldn’t say they are closed door, but the door is left cracked open. I do give her props for writing how stress and life situations can get in the way to experience intimacy with a partner. This topic isn’t talked about enough. Again, Christina Nolte wrote a real situation, but showing it’s not a failure on the relationship and anything can be worked through with communication and love.
The ensemble was purposeful. There was no reason for a character not to be there. She wrote with the intension of getting to know everyone as best as a 300-page book allowed. Even though your main focus is on Arrick and Evan, there are side plots with other individuals, whether it was in their own story or involved in the main plot. Kevin, Evan’s dad, is a dad that everyone hopes to have. Their connection makes me jealous, but also makes me hope for a better future for all queer boys and men to have this type of relationship with their fathers. Kevin’s support and love during every turn of events was like keeping a train on the track while it was trying to derail. Obviously, Arrick’s Ex, Ben, plays a big part in this novel again. He is a roach that just won’t go away no matter how many traps you place. Even when he isn’t present, you feel him there through Arrick. Christina wrote this like Ben was Arrick’s shadow and night never comes. The constant feeling of dread and mistrust vibes off the page. The student body and the relationship between Teacher & Student, and Student & Student plays a big part in the plot, for me at least. Teachers now a days have such strict guidelines they must follow when it comes with interaction with their youngens. The way that Arrick cares for his pupils is magical. He cares for them in a way that isn’t seen today in modern USA schools. He takes the time to get to know them and takes a group of them under his wing when they ask for support and guidance. Also, seeing through Arrick’s eyes the relationships the students have with each other is a detail I greatly appreciated. It shows the comfortability they have with him and others that us middle-aged readers didn’t have the chance to show when in school out of fear. There are other friends and townspeople that make appearances from Book 1 as well. I am hoping as a reader that has fallen for this town, that the author expanse this universe and tell another story with another promising couple in a rarely used and shown sexual identity.
Arrick and Evans story is complete, but life keeps going as shown in the ending. Undertaking the responsibility that they do could have torn them apart but the strength of their love for each other and the fight inside themselves helps them find the lost boy within find their purpose together. Lost boys are never fully lost. All they needs is the sprinkle of pixie dust from someone else to find their way, whether its from a loved one, a teacher, or a friend. Christina Nolte wrote this so the reader can see that hope and happy thoughts are possible even in the toughest and most brutal situations. She also showed that TEACHERS ARE HUMANS with real emotions, feelings, and fears. They are put into positions to be perfect with someone else’s children when perfection is impossible. Showing this side of life-like working scenarios and outside work life for teachers is eye opening and something that isn’t talked about or respected enough. I also love the writing style she wrote, like the reader was walking into a conversation already in progress, leaving an open-ended feeling, only giving small pieces of details, leaving you guessing on what is actually happening on the edge of your seat, until it all hits together in moments of emotion. It kept the plot moving forward even in moments of pause without missing any details in the end.
💜Happy Reading🫶
By Christina Nolte
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️.25
I received an E-book ARC edition of this novel in exchange for an honest review. It Is available NOW on Amazon & Kindle Unlimited!
www.amazon.com/B0FTFYJ4TS
This is a 300-page Medium Paced, Established Couple with Black Cat / Golden Retriever Vibes, Teacher Romance, Small-Town, Sudden Life Changing, Part 2 of a Duology MM Romance. Part One, MIRROR, MIRROR, must be read first to completely enjoy this novel that concludes their story. Picking up a short time after Part One ended, life for Arrick and Evan looks promising, other than the stress of work, as their school needs some big repairs and big life decisions that are both exciting and scary.
Arrick is still feeling the effects of what happened with his Ex and his Father ending his career and relationship, but having Evan in his life is making that memory blur. He is happy with teaching and directing the high school play, Peter Pan. He has made a connection with his students that we all hope for our children. Evan has settled into his new position as Principal after the conclusion of Mirror, Mirror. However, its constant paperwork, finances, and dealing with school repairs. The town is in trouble financially so Arrick’s Ex, Ben, and his Company as well as his father have stepped in to turn it all around by buying the Wharf, employing townspeople to work there and donating funds to repair the school. Arrick doesn’t trust Ben or his father and has a constant itch up his back about the whole sketchy situation. Then life gets turned on it head so fast, the reader gets whiplash.
This duology is the most REAL contemporary story I think I have ever read. Christina Nolte wrote with such passion, emotion, and a sense of hesitation creating a tension that the reader feels in their fingertips while holding this book. The scenarios she puts our MCs through were not written in fantasy but felt like it came from actual experiences. These things could all happen. The drama with the wharf was the perfect amount of drama and mystery, I thought I was actually reading an article in a real newspaper. The aftermath of the life changing accidents felt so realistic, I felt them in my bones. Please see Content Warnings. She wrote in a nice flow that kept your attention, even during the slow parts, which were needed to break from the stress of what life throws at you suddenly. The way she wrote conflicted grief was brilliant. It’s the oddest feeling to go through, I should know, and she absolutely nailed it! She even showed how grief isn’t one sided. When a partner goes through that, you go through it too, except the other person in the relationship takes on the responsibility of getting them through it all by being a cushion to fall on when the griever crumbles apart.
The spice was minimal. 1.5/5 🌶. Part 1 was the same. The author shows the connection between the MCs with emotion during these scenes instead of detail of their actions. I wouldn’t say they are closed door, but the door is left cracked open. I do give her props for writing how stress and life situations can get in the way to experience intimacy with a partner. This topic isn’t talked about enough. Again, Christina Nolte wrote a real situation, but showing it’s not a failure on the relationship and anything can be worked through with communication and love.
The ensemble was purposeful. There was no reason for a character not to be there. She wrote with the intension of getting to know everyone as best as a 300-page book allowed. Even though your main focus is on Arrick and Evan, there are side plots with other individuals, whether it was in their own story or involved in the main plot. Kevin, Evan’s dad, is a dad that everyone hopes to have. Their connection makes me jealous, but also makes me hope for a better future for all queer boys and men to have this type of relationship with their fathers. Kevin’s support and love during every turn of events was like keeping a train on the track while it was trying to derail. Obviously, Arrick’s Ex, Ben, plays a big part in this novel again. He is a roach that just won’t go away no matter how many traps you place. Even when he isn’t present, you feel him there through Arrick. Christina wrote this like Ben was Arrick’s shadow and night never comes. The constant feeling of dread and mistrust vibes off the page. The student body and the relationship between Teacher & Student, and Student & Student plays a big part in the plot, for me at least. Teachers now a days have such strict guidelines they must follow when it comes with interaction with their youngens. The way that Arrick cares for his pupils is magical. He cares for them in a way that isn’t seen today in modern USA schools. He takes the time to get to know them and takes a group of them under his wing when they ask for support and guidance. Also, seeing through Arrick’s eyes the relationships the students have with each other is a detail I greatly appreciated. It shows the comfortability they have with him and others that us middle-aged readers didn’t have the chance to show when in school out of fear. There are other friends and townspeople that make appearances from Book 1 as well. I am hoping as a reader that has fallen for this town, that the author expanse this universe and tell another story with another promising couple in a rarely used and shown sexual identity.
Arrick and Evans story is complete, but life keeps going as shown in the ending. Undertaking the responsibility that they do could have torn them apart but the strength of their love for each other and the fight inside themselves helps them find the lost boy within find their purpose together. Lost boys are never fully lost. All they needs is the sprinkle of pixie dust from someone else to find their way, whether its from a loved one, a teacher, or a friend. Christina Nolte wrote this so the reader can see that hope and happy thoughts are possible even in the toughest and most brutal situations. She also showed that TEACHERS ARE HUMANS with real emotions, feelings, and fears. They are put into positions to be perfect with someone else’s children when perfection is impossible. Showing this side of life-like working scenarios and outside work life for teachers is eye opening and something that isn’t talked about or respected enough. I also love the writing style she wrote, like the reader was walking into a conversation already in progress, leaving an open-ended feeling, only giving small pieces of details, leaving you guessing on what is actually happening on the edge of your seat, until it all hits together in moments of emotion. It kept the plot moving forward even in moments of pause without missing any details in the end.
💜Happy Reading🫶
November 25, 2025
A Joyfully Jay review.
3.5 stars
This is a follow up to Mirror, Mirror and that story definitely needs to be read first. As happy as I was to see these two guys again, and to see the progress they’ve made—both personally and romantically—this story didn’t quite hit the mark for me.
I absolutely adored how rock solid the MCs are. Arrick is still anxious and prone to thinking bad about himself, but Evan is right there to support him and remind him how strong he is. Evan is dealing with a lot himself, now that he’s the principal of the high school, and just coming home to Arrick is all he needs. The proposal is very them, and it was sweet to see, especially when Arrick had his moment as well.
Read Kris’ review in its entirety here.
3.5 stars
This is a follow up to Mirror, Mirror and that story definitely needs to be read first. As happy as I was to see these two guys again, and to see the progress they’ve made—both personally and romantically—this story didn’t quite hit the mark for me.
I absolutely adored how rock solid the MCs are. Arrick is still anxious and prone to thinking bad about himself, but Evan is right there to support him and remind him how strong he is. Evan is dealing with a lot himself, now that he’s the principal of the high school, and just coming home to Arrick is all he needs. The proposal is very them, and it was sweet to see, especially when Arrick had his moment as well.
Read Kris’ review in its entirety here.
November 27, 2025
I needed this. There were just too many things left in Mirror, Mirror that I wanted answers and closure to. Most importantly was the growth of Evan and Arrick’s relationship. While I do think they would have eventually gotten there, I do think having Arthur made it faster and deeper. I have to say that I was both surprised and not by what was revealed. Not surprised to find out what had been done but by the depths and by who. Though I shouldn’t have been because of that person’s character. Interestingly this one didn’t hit my emotions as strongly as the previous one and I think it’s because we had already learned Arrick’s coping methods. So while I was just as connected his reactions didn’t surprise me. I actually liked that. I do wish we had gotten to witness the final resolution.
December 6, 2025
This is a great sequel to Mirror, Mirror. Evan and Arrick have all the chemistry from book 1 but their relationship is deeper, more secure, more familiar. It was the high point of the book for me.
I loved seeing Arrick stand up to both his father and his ex. Plotlines where the giant private equity firm is the ultimate villain are always close to my heart and I enjoyed it here too.
At the same time, the adoption and baby plot wasn't really my thing (not the book's fault, it's never my thing), and I feel that the pacing was both too slow and too fast at different points of the book. In the end, I definitely prefer Mirror, Mirror overall, though I think the sequel doesn't really have anything to be ashamed of.
Thank you to the author for trusting me with an ARC.
I loved seeing Arrick stand up to both his father and his ex. Plotlines where the giant private equity firm is the ultimate villain are always close to my heart and I enjoyed it here too.
At the same time, the adoption and baby plot wasn't really my thing (not the book's fault, it's never my thing), and I feel that the pacing was both too slow and too fast at different points of the book. In the end, I definitely prefer Mirror, Mirror overall, though I think the sequel doesn't really have anything to be ashamed of.
Thank you to the author for trusting me with an ARC.
November 23, 2025
Book 2 of the Ashland series is an enjoyable, easy read with just enough drama to keep it interesting. Evan and Arrick have been together for more than a year now. We follow them through their daily life and watch them build a future together. Part of the story is taking place in London (Arrick‘s former home). Although there was (obviously) a lot of angst in the storyline here, I especially enjoyed the christmasy setting. I guess my favourit scenes were the stroll along the Thames and the pub scene. Nonetheless I missed some of the side characters from book 1, who thankfully made a lot of great appearances in the second half of the book. I also immensly enjoyed the down-to-earth and heartwarming glimpses into parenthood here. Big recommendation for the holidays!
November 27, 2025
3.5 stars
This continuation of Mirror, Mirror is a super sweet romance. I do like the MCs, Evan and Arrick, but I did struggle with the pacing. The flow felt off and a bit jumpy. The story is good, the premise is intriguing, and the characters are interesting, but this just felt a little more disjointed than Mirror, Mirror. I had a good time reading this, but it's not a favorite of mine.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
This continuation of Mirror, Mirror is a super sweet romance. I do like the MCs, Evan and Arrick, but I did struggle with the pacing. The flow felt off and a bit jumpy. The story is good, the premise is intriguing, and the characters are interesting, but this just felt a little more disjointed than Mirror, Mirror. I had a good time reading this, but it's not a favorite of mine.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
November 24, 2025
Arrick and Evan are living together and thinking about marriage. Evan is the high school principal, and Arrick is still teaching and directing the school play. This book moves the main story forward with a possible adoption and new trouble involving Silver Rock, Arrick’s father’s company.
Plenty of intriguing happenings.
Plenty of intriguing happenings.
December 3, 2025
I’m going to start off by saying I absolutely loved this book. I’m only giving it 4 stars though because I did not read the first book and felt like I missed out on a lot of back story. I do not have KU so was unable to read it, sorry guys. But I absolutely love of both of the MMC’s. They proved that no matter what, you have a strong relationship, you can persevere through anything. The love these two shared found a place in my heart. And now I’m going to go back and figure out how to read the first one LOL because these guys are my guy to for feel good moments. ❤️
December 1, 2025
4.5/5
I loved Mirror, Mirror (which needs to be read first) and have been looking forward to this. I am so happy that Arrick and Evan find their HEA - but there is a lot that happens before they can get there! Arrick has a lot to work through still, but had the support of Evan to get there, once he finally trusted and accepted it. I thought Arthur helped to bring them closer together as they learned how to deal with their new reality. This book tackles some difficult topics and situations, and I thought it handled them well. Overall I'd recommend it!
I loved Mirror, Mirror (which needs to be read first) and have been looking forward to this. I am so happy that Arrick and Evan find their HEA - but there is a lot that happens before they can get there! Arrick has a lot to work through still, but had the support of Evan to get there, once he finally trusted and accepted it. I thought Arthur helped to bring them closer together as they learned how to deal with their new reality. This book tackles some difficult topics and situations, and I thought it handled them well. Overall I'd recommend it!
December 2, 2025
After overcoming all of the obstacles in book 1, Arrick & Evan have settled into a routine. They now live together and are building a home for themselves & the pets. . Everything is going great for them, Evan is now principal, Arrick the music teacher. Everything is going according to plan, until it isn't. Low to medium angst with a HEA. I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
November 16, 2025
I love Aarick and Evan so much. These two are proof of the fact that life isn’t always easy, but relationships are worth it. The situation in town looks great on the outside, but both men know there is something just underneath the surface. They can’t really change that but they can stop letting Ben and Brian live in their brain. Arrick may not be the best at talking or letting people behind his walls, but Evan is his rock and together, they can get through almost anything. And little Arthur is worth it.
December 14, 2025
In this beautiful and intimate conclusion to the Ashland duet we find Arrick and Evan a year later, living together, building a home, and navigating life in their struggling town.
With Arrick’s Ex’s company revitalizing the wharf and throwing money into the town comes difficult dynamics, suspicious activity, and inevitably sets in motion a series of events that change their lives forever.
This was an amazing second book for our couple. Not only do we get to see them grow closer and stronger together but a riveting and well thought out plot, set up in the first book, plays out marvelously. Like the warmest and coziest romance meets an emotional hurt/comfort drama, meets a small town mystery. All together you end up with a brilliant two part romance.
What you’ll get:
•Established Relationship
•2nd book of a duet “1 year later”
•High School Principal/Teacher
•Building a Future Together
•Proposal(s)
•Family issues
•Grief & Loss
•Hurt/Comfort
•Bonus Mystery!
•Found Family
•Theatre kids
•Christmas (Back) in London
With Arrick’s Ex’s company revitalizing the wharf and throwing money into the town comes difficult dynamics, suspicious activity, and inevitably sets in motion a series of events that change their lives forever.
This was an amazing second book for our couple. Not only do we get to see them grow closer and stronger together but a riveting and well thought out plot, set up in the first book, plays out marvelously. Like the warmest and coziest romance meets an emotional hurt/comfort drama, meets a small town mystery. All together you end up with a brilliant two part romance.
What you’ll get:
•Established Relationship
•2nd book of a duet “1 year later”
•High School Principal/Teacher
•Building a Future Together
•Proposal(s)
•Family issues
•Grief & Loss
•Hurt/Comfort
•Bonus Mystery!
•Found Family
•Theatre kids
•Christmas (Back) in London
November 30, 2025
*ARC Review* Thank you to Christina Nolte for sending me a copy!
Intro:
This book is the second book in the Ashland duology series and is an MM romance between Arrick, a teacher in a small town and Evan, the principal of the school Arrick teaches at
Tropes/Highlights:
-MM
-Open Door Romance (Kind of)
-Small Town
-Grumpy/Sunshine
-Hurt/Comfort
-Music Teacher
-Loss/Hardship
Likes:
-Unique humor shared between MCs
-The new character in the story
-Both MCs are just as sweet and endearing as the first book
-I love Evan's glasses, a cute detail
-Arrick's surprise outfit
-Much more drama and suspense than the first book
-A lot of new environments
-The struggles and challenges were handled well
Neutrals/Criticisms
-I felt like a few scenes where skipped over that would have been nice to experience
-One of the phrases used was a little repetitive
-I didn't like that Evan was brushing off Arrick's gut feelings, but it didn't ruin the story for me
Quotes
-"Of course I was always going to say yes, you idiot."
-"Arrick couldn't remember ever having felt this fulfilled, holding someone or being held like this in return. Nobody had ever felt like a part of him he hadn't known he'd missed."
-"Never in all his life had he felt so enthralled by someone."
-"Evan, who was far too bright and perfect for this shitty world of Arrick's."
-"Yes, Arrick sighed. Yes, I know he's prettier than me."
-"You deserved one last fuck you."
This book is the final book in the duology, Wonder, Wonder. I love Arrick and Evan as a couple and really enjoyed reading about their continued story. This book has more drama and suspense than the first book does. It really highlights the internal struggles as well as the strain created between the MCs due to the central problem of the story. If you liked the first book, I would definitely recommend reading the second and if you haven't read the first book I would recommend starting with that one first. You may like this book if you are looking for a book about two educators from a small town trying to balance their relationship with the multiple problems that keep popping up. I think this book was very well done and I am thankful to have been chosen as an ARC reader.
Intro:
This book is the second book in the Ashland duology series and is an MM romance between Arrick, a teacher in a small town and Evan, the principal of the school Arrick teaches at
Tropes/Highlights:
-MM
-Open Door Romance (Kind of)
-Small Town
-Grumpy/Sunshine
-Hurt/Comfort
-Music Teacher
-Loss/Hardship
Likes:
-Unique humor shared between MCs
-The new character in the story
-Both MCs are just as sweet and endearing as the first book
-I love Evan's glasses, a cute detail
-Arrick's surprise outfit
-Much more drama and suspense than the first book
-A lot of new environments
-The struggles and challenges were handled well
Neutrals/Criticisms
-I felt like a few scenes where skipped over that would have been nice to experience
-One of the phrases used was a little repetitive
-I didn't like that Evan was brushing off Arrick's gut feelings, but it didn't ruin the story for me
Quotes
-"Of course I was always going to say yes, you idiot."
-"Arrick couldn't remember ever having felt this fulfilled, holding someone or being held like this in return. Nobody had ever felt like a part of him he hadn't known he'd missed."
-"Never in all his life had he felt so enthralled by someone."
-"Evan, who was far too bright and perfect for this shitty world of Arrick's."
-"Yes, Arrick sighed. Yes, I know he's prettier than me."
-"You deserved one last fuck you."
This book is the final book in the duology, Wonder, Wonder. I love Arrick and Evan as a couple and really enjoyed reading about their continued story. This book has more drama and suspense than the first book does. It really highlights the internal struggles as well as the strain created between the MCs due to the central problem of the story. If you liked the first book, I would definitely recommend reading the second and if you haven't read the first book I would recommend starting with that one first. You may like this book if you are looking for a book about two educators from a small town trying to balance their relationship with the multiple problems that keep popping up. I think this book was very well done and I am thankful to have been chosen as an ARC reader.
November 26, 2025
I would like to thank BookSirens for the opportunity to read and review this ARC.
Wonder, Wonder started off with the sweetest VIBES...and then, as all complicated, bad-father/icky-ex/sketchy-corporation-buying-up-the-town are wont to do, it turned intense af.
A c c i d e n t s, and then d e a t h s by accidents, started to colour the Silver Rock endowment experience, on top of the already shady power dynamics the company had over Ashland because of all their funding. The ewwww was strong in this one.
Something dangerous was happening, and as some very suspicious things were obviously going down, I was very happy that Arrick could lean into Evan who was just as solid and as lovely as ever. I felt for them when their lifepath together suddenly went from newly-ringed fiancés to dads of a 9 month old within days. But their supportive family, furbabies and friends made that transition so much more bearable than the alternative, and I was glad to see it.
There were moments when I found the narrative didn't have much give, notably from Arrick's perspective. The taut, drawn in, uneasy flow was understandably a reflection of Arrick's way of dealing with all the tragic drama. But I had trouble connecting because of how stiff and unrelaxed a lot of this came across at times. I enjoyed the whimsical theatre bits, and piano playing with baby Arthur though. There was a softness in those moments that I appreciated, because it showed Arrick's alignment with creative flow, music and his passion for the performing arts.
There was lots of love here, with Best-dad Kevin offsetting the not-so-great one, sweet ex-Oliver countering Ben's super-sliminess, and Arrick and Evan's relationship emerging stronger after some intense emotional challenges.
This was a lovely, sweet follow up to Mirror, Mirror, with some achy tension and quite a few life-changing events boosting the dimensions of the Ashland series beyond a simple romance. Happy to have discovered Christina Nolte and looking forward to whatever comes next! Can't wait!
Wonder, Wonder started off with the sweetest VIBES...and then, as all complicated, bad-father/icky-ex/sketchy-corporation-buying-up-the-town are wont to do, it turned intense af.
A c c i d e n t s, and then d e a t h s by accidents, started to colour the Silver Rock endowment experience, on top of the already shady power dynamics the company had over Ashland because of all their funding. The ewwww was strong in this one.
Something dangerous was happening, and as some very suspicious things were obviously going down, I was very happy that Arrick could lean into Evan who was just as solid and as lovely as ever. I felt for them when their lifepath together suddenly went from newly-ringed fiancés to dads of a 9 month old within days. But their supportive family, furbabies and friends made that transition so much more bearable than the alternative, and I was glad to see it.
There were moments when I found the narrative didn't have much give, notably from Arrick's perspective. The taut, drawn in, uneasy flow was understandably a reflection of Arrick's way of dealing with all the tragic drama. But I had trouble connecting because of how stiff and unrelaxed a lot of this came across at times. I enjoyed the whimsical theatre bits, and piano playing with baby Arthur though. There was a softness in those moments that I appreciated, because it showed Arrick's alignment with creative flow, music and his passion for the performing arts.
There was lots of love here, with Best-dad Kevin offsetting the not-so-great one, sweet ex-Oliver countering Ben's super-sliminess, and Arrick and Evan's relationship emerging stronger after some intense emotional challenges.
This was a lovely, sweet follow up to Mirror, Mirror, with some achy tension and quite a few life-changing events boosting the dimensions of the Ashland series beyond a simple romance. Happy to have discovered Christina Nolte and looking forward to whatever comes next! Can't wait!
November 30, 2025
Thank you Christina for the ARC!
After reading mirror, mirror, I was excited to get more of Arrick and Evan, especially since this sequel has them facing new adventures.
In this one, the two have proposals, marriage, a new house, sudden baby and a zoo of pets. There's also the drama of the school funding, Arrick's father's business being sketchy and meddling ex boyfriends.
I don't know what kept me from liking this book more, the characters are solid, and there are plenty of tender moments between the two, as well as with their sudden baby.
I kind of struggled with the plot, and keeping my motivation up to keep reading.
The story kind of skipped some parts. I was really sad that the wedding got skipped!
That and the house renovation, it didn't get finished before the book ended. I want to read about them all settling in, making the house how they like it.
I would have also loved some more moments between the two, and maybe some fun moments with the baby.
Like going shopping for new clothes, or a few milestones for the kid.
Maybe if the author did an epilogue that showed the couple a bit in the future. I'd love to see them more settled in, and especially Arrick!
You never really get much of the pay off of him overcoming his trauma, and how he handles fatherhood after vowing to do better than his father.
I know that this book gives a more realistic depiction of a couple who is going through the lows and highs of life. That the book followed the couple through their challenges (that they faced together!), so after the book is over, they can just focus on being a family.
After reading mirror, mirror, I was excited to get more of Arrick and Evan, especially since this sequel has them facing new adventures.
In this one, the two have proposals, marriage, a new house, sudden baby and a zoo of pets. There's also the drama of the school funding, Arrick's father's business being sketchy and meddling ex boyfriends.
I don't know what kept me from liking this book more, the characters are solid, and there are plenty of tender moments between the two, as well as with their sudden baby.
I kind of struggled with the plot, and keeping my motivation up to keep reading.
The story kind of skipped some parts. I was really sad that the wedding got skipped!
That and the house renovation, it didn't get finished before the book ended. I want to read about them all settling in, making the house how they like it.
I would have also loved some more moments between the two, and maybe some fun moments with the baby.
Like going shopping for new clothes, or a few milestones for the kid.
Maybe if the author did an epilogue that showed the couple a bit in the future. I'd love to see them more settled in, and especially Arrick!
You never really get much of the pay off of him overcoming his trauma, and how he handles fatherhood after vowing to do better than his father.
I know that this book gives a more realistic depiction of a couple who is going through the lows and highs of life. That the book followed the couple through their challenges (that they faced together!), so after the book is over, they can just focus on being a family.
November 24, 2025
Christina’s writing style really draws you in. I find myself lulled into the story unable to stop with how it flows and intrigues. And I enjoy this couple because they are real. The story surrounding them may feel like fiction, but the people, their imperfections, the work it takes every day to choose to be better, to love one another - it’s beautiful.
Tension looms with Silver Rock’s fingers getting into everything, and Arrick’s ex and father both hovering on the periphery. Not to mention the school they both work for is falling apart, held together by sheer determination and duct tape, and the promise of money from Silver Rock.
And when life seems to be settling between them, Arrick becomes guardian to a baby brother he’s never met. Doing what’s right doesn’t mean it’s easy, and they’ll need to lean on each other even more to make it all work.
But damn, seeing two people fight for love makes it all the more beautiful.
Tension looms with Silver Rock’s fingers getting into everything, and Arrick’s ex and father both hovering on the periphery. Not to mention the school they both work for is falling apart, held together by sheer determination and duct tape, and the promise of money from Silver Rock.
And when life seems to be settling between them, Arrick becomes guardian to a baby brother he’s never met. Doing what’s right doesn’t mean it’s easy, and they’ll need to lean on each other even more to make it all work.
But damn, seeing two people fight for love makes it all the more beautiful.
November 29, 2025
I’ve grown incredibly attached to Arrick and Evan, and this instalment made me love them even more. With Silver Rock’s shadow still hanging over Ashland, the tension had me questioning everything right alongside Arrick, but his growth throughout the book was genuinely rewarding. I loved seeing him learn to lean on Evan, and Evan’s steady, grounding presence made their relationship feel stronger than ever.
Arthur’s arrival is absolutely adorable and adds a lovely new layer to their lives, and the musical theatre elements bring so much warmth. Watching Arrick reconnect with what he loves and seeing how healing that becomes for him was one of my favourite parts. And that question? Completely perfect. They really are soulmates.
A beautiful, heartfelt conclusion that gave the HEA they deserved. I’m going to miss these two so much.
I received a free arc copy and this is my honest review
Arthur’s arrival is absolutely adorable and adds a lovely new layer to their lives, and the musical theatre elements bring so much warmth. Watching Arrick reconnect with what he loves and seeing how healing that becomes for him was one of my favourite parts. And that question? Completely perfect. They really are soulmates.
A beautiful, heartfelt conclusion that gave the HEA they deserved. I’m going to miss these two so much.
I received a free arc copy and this is my honest review
November 15, 2025
After reading the first book in the series (& you HAVE to read book 1 before you read this), I wasn't sure I wanted to continue. Arrick is not a happy person, he's always finding ways to avoid talking about things/taking action. Still....when the ARC for book#2 became available, I realized that I remembered the first book really well and decided I wanted to see how it ended up for these 2. I was glad I read it.
This book starts off with Arrick and Evan still in love, moved in together, and thinking about getting married. Evan is still principal at the high school, and Arrick is still teaching music & physics, and directing the school play. This book is where the plot picks up. There's a child (brother) to adopt, and a lot of intrigue with Silver Rock, Arrick's father's company that is putting a lot of money into Ashland. Enjoyed this 2nd book more than the first.
This book starts off with Arrick and Evan still in love, moved in together, and thinking about getting married. Evan is still principal at the high school, and Arrick is still teaching music & physics, and directing the school play. This book is where the plot picks up. There's a child (brother) to adopt, and a lot of intrigue with Silver Rock, Arrick's father's company that is putting a lot of money into Ashland. Enjoyed this 2nd book more than the first.
November 16, 2025
4.5 stars
Wonder, Wonder is the second book in the Ashaland series.
I read it immediately after the first book. It features the same protagonists, Evan and Arrick, but now their relationship is established.
It continues and resolves the plots that were left open in the first book: the company that wants to invest in the town and the high school, although not in good faith; Arrick has unfinished business with his father, which is resolved abruptly, opening up another front that Evan and Arrick have to face.
The character who evolves the most in this one is Arrick.
I did like it, but everything is a bit rushed, in my opinion. Arrick has to face what has caused him trauma in his life, and his relationship with Evan is a pillar in that.
+ i want to thank GRR for the ARC. This is my voluntary and honest opinion.
Wonder, Wonder is the second book in the Ashaland series.
I read it immediately after the first book. It features the same protagonists, Evan and Arrick, but now their relationship is established.
It continues and resolves the plots that were left open in the first book: the company that wants to invest in the town and the high school, although not in good faith; Arrick has unfinished business with his father, which is resolved abruptly, opening up another front that Evan and Arrick have to face.
The character who evolves the most in this one is Arrick.
I did like it, but everything is a bit rushed, in my opinion. Arrick has to face what has caused him trauma in his life, and his relationship with Evan is a pillar in that.
+ i want to thank GRR for the ARC. This is my voluntary and honest opinion.
December 1, 2025
I thought this book would start in he moment the first one ends, but a year has passed.
Arrick and Evan are going strong, both still work as teachers and Arrick's father and ex try to insert themselves in their life.
There is a big change in Arrick throughout this book, he grows to be more assertive, more secure and strong. It shows in that last meeting with his ex, when he demands many things, knowing he has the upper hand.
Evan is perfect always, he is Arrick's refuge and rock, so sweet and steady.
I had a couple surprises reading this, the book is quite more fast paced that the first, there's more things happening and still the school is important, the town, the kids...
I liked it more than the first, maybe because it feels more closed, more rounded.
I recommend this duology if you like small town romances.
Arrick and Evan are going strong, both still work as teachers and Arrick's father and ex try to insert themselves in their life.
There is a big change in Arrick throughout this book, he grows to be more assertive, more secure and strong. It shows in that last meeting with his ex, when he demands many things, knowing he has the upper hand.
Evan is perfect always, he is Arrick's refuge and rock, so sweet and steady.
I had a couple surprises reading this, the book is quite more fast paced that the first, there's more things happening and still the school is important, the town, the kids...
I liked it more than the first, maybe because it feels more closed, more rounded.
I recommend this duology if you like small town romances.
November 28, 2025
I cannot stress enough if you want the full wonderful impact of this book, please read Mirror, Mirror first. This one continues to beautifully written love story of Arrick and Evan. I loved so many things about this one but the thing I truly loved was that both men are written as stable, normal men. the love one another, deal with life and its issues, and support one another. So often books have gay men as flawed but not this one. They are just like anyone else, settled into their lives, jobs and lives (with all of its up and downs). In this one it a new found family member they become the caretaker of but once again they are there to love and support one another through it. A great book that reminds us love is worth it when it is with the right person.
December 1, 2025
Okay, I made the mistake of not reading the first book, well, first. It would have helped getting into it quite a bit! Still, it was definitely worth the read!
Evan isn’t quit the staid high school principal you might have expected. His life is rather more exciting than that. He might argue the question, but he’s a great character to read about. Aarick (with an A) is the more dynamic one of the couple. He’s hounded by his ex and his father, whose company seems to be wanting to take over their small town. Violence is new, and seems to be part of the takeover of the Wharf.
Not the spiciest of stories, but with a very heartfelt romance between the two as they build their life together. Lovely book.
Evan isn’t quit the staid high school principal you might have expected. His life is rather more exciting than that. He might argue the question, but he’s a great character to read about. Aarick (with an A) is the more dynamic one of the couple. He’s hounded by his ex and his father, whose company seems to be wanting to take over their small town. Violence is new, and seems to be part of the takeover of the Wharf.
Not the spiciest of stories, but with a very heartfelt romance between the two as they build their life together. Lovely book.
November 24, 2025
An emotional continuation of Arrick and Evan's story. I love them SO much.
This book made me laugh, cry, and swoon. I have such a connection to these two, I could not put it down. Arrick and Evan really go through it here, complex family dynamics, becoming fathers, all while trying to start their own life and find their path as a couple. The love they have for each other is deep and Christina does a great job of showing that through their actions and words. Ugh I could cry again just thinking about it.
Also you KNOW Christina is a teacher by the way she writes. A lot of the school aspects are way too real!
This book made me laugh, cry, and swoon. I have such a connection to these two, I could not put it down. Arrick and Evan really go through it here, complex family dynamics, becoming fathers, all while trying to start their own life and find their path as a couple. The love they have for each other is deep and Christina does a great job of showing that through their actions and words. Ugh I could cry again just thinking about it.
Also you KNOW Christina is a teacher by the way she writes. A lot of the school aspects are way too real!
December 4, 2025
black velvet, circuit board, off-key singing, fricative, vomit green, dummy, antique lunatic, David Bowie shirt, citrus & nutmeg, ugly vases
This is a great follow-up to the first book, "Mirror, Mirror". This book opens one year after Book #1's ending. So, prior reading is required.
Arrick Filan and Evan Miller are now living together. Their lives center around home and school. Life as they know it undergoes a major upheaval. I won't say more as I will spoil your reading experience.
I really enjoyed reading this and highly recommend it.
This is a great follow-up to the first book, "Mirror, Mirror". This book opens one year after Book #1's ending. So, prior reading is required.
Arrick Filan and Evan Miller are now living together. Their lives center around home and school. Life as they know it undergoes a major upheaval. I won't say more as I will spoil your reading experience.
I really enjoyed reading this and highly recommend it.
November 20, 2025
Mirror, Mirror drew me into Ashland and the adorably awkward courtship of Evan and Arrick. Wonder, Wonder takes them into uncharted territory not only as corporate greed threatens their way of life, but as the addition of a new charge makes them a family.
You will need to read Mirror, Mirror prior to this but I promise it's worth it. These are beautiful stories about a couple overcoming their pasts to accept how worthy they are of love.
Thanks to the author for the ARC.
You will need to read Mirror, Mirror prior to this but I promise it's worth it. These are beautiful stories about a couple overcoming their pasts to accept how worthy they are of love.
Thanks to the author for the ARC.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 42 reviews