"For readers who first met Harpman via her melancholic digital afterlife, We Were Forbidden will arrive as a revelation."—Katy Waldman, The New Yorker
From the bestselling author of I Who Have Never Known Men comes a startling trio of novellas—translated into English for the first time—each plumbing the depths of that vital human defiance.
In the wake of some unfathomable war, a woman wanders the forest. She and her fellow survivors are forbidden from leaving its boundaries or pausing in their eternal march through its strange depths.
Attending a rigid French school in 1940s Casablanca, a teenage girl is barred from ever questioning the dogma she is taught to believe—her punishment for doing so will be as swift as it is shocking.
Locked in a loveless marriage in the Belgian bourgeoisie, a young woman satisfies her husband's desires, twice weekly, as required. She has not yet thought to pursue her own.
These novellas—the first works by Jacqueline Harpman to arrive in English in decades—reveal her incredible stylistic range and demonstrate once more her penetrating psychological insight. Here we find the origins of a singular, relentless voice.
Jacqueline Harpman was born in Etterbeek, Belgium, in 1929. Being half Jewish, the family moved to Casablanca when the Nazis invaded, and returned home after the war. After studying French literature she started training to be a doctor, but could not complete her medical studies when she contracted tuberculosis. She turned to writing in 1954 and her first work was published in 1958. In 1980 she qualified as a psychoanalyst. She had given up writing after her fourth book was published, and resumed her career as a novelist only some twenty years later. She wrote twelve novels and won several literary prizes, most recently the Médicis for the present novel. She was married to an architect and had two children.
A very quick read (I didn’t realize this was 100 pages) but not necessarily one that will stick with me.
The Ardennes Forest is a great first story with an ominous, ambiguous set-up that feels very reminiscent of I Who Have Never Known Men. It was by far my favourite of the three.
The Outcast was solid — there’s an excerpt that gives the necessary historical context, and the story itself has a few interesting things to say about perspective.
The Broom Closet was a bit of a flop for me, sadly. A woman conjures up a fictional woman and her adultery, but the layers of storytelling don’t quite work in such a short story. Again, this one is quite similar to Orlanda, another of her published works.
If you like Harpman’s work I don’t think you’ll be disappointed! I just think objectively it’s difficult for three ~30 page stories to offer much lasting impression. These are by no means a cohesive trio, and I’m curious if they’re early ideas for what later became her novels? The parallels are hard to ignore!
Thank you to Transit Books for the ARC! —- Jacqueline Harpman will always have a fan in me <3
The Publisher Says: From the author of I Who Have Never Known Men comes a startling new collection of three never-before-translated stories, each plumbing the depths of that most necessary human defiance.
Wandering the forest in the wake of some unfathomable war, a woman and her fellow survivors are forbidden from leaving its boundaries or pausing in their march through its strange depths.
As part of her rigid schooling, a teenage girl is barred from questioning the dogma she is taught to believe—her punishment for doing so will be as disturbing as it is disproportionate.
Locked in a loveless marriage, a young woman satisfies her husband’s desires, twice-weekly, as directed. She has not yet thought to pursue her own.
In varying ways, and across varying worlds, each of these women are trapped. Do they have the will to escape?
I RECEIVED A DRC FROM THE PUBLISHER VIA EDELWEISS+. THANK YOU.
My Review: One of the most enduring stories in Western Anglophone culture is the princess in the tower, locked away and in the absolute control of A Man/A System/An Enemy, and how she must connive to survive with whatever degree of success the cruel, cruel storyteller allows her. Now firmly grounded in the reality of being female over the millennia, along comes Author Harpman with Translator Schwartz as amanuensis, extrapolating this cultural juggernaut to include all those trapped in subservience and obedience to high-control systems.
In "The Outcast" Author Harpman uses the most familiar iteration of the story. A teenaged girl is in the intertwining coils of adolescence and sexual maturation and cultural demands for conformity. It's harrowing to see Author Harpman's keen observations of fascism turned loose on one so hugely vulnerable and malleable...it is a shorter and refocused version of the juggernaut I Who Have Never Known Men and should appeal to those seeking more of that story only dressed in a shorter, more contemporaneous skirt.
Moving into times and ties more concrete, "The Broom Closet" is a woman's struggle to find her footing in 1920s Belgium. The demands of domesticity on women are different from those made on men even now; in the deeply conservative culture of postwar Belgium, where the battles that killed millions were barely over let alone their damage repaired, they were starkly different. As one adds the inexorable advance of marriage's compromises conflicting with the absolute tyranny of the need to create stories, the trap of cultural expectations springs shut. Virginia Woolf's A Room of One's Own's observations made specific and played out with the intensity of "The Yellow Wallpaper."
Expanding the story logic to those enmeshed in the military of an apocalyptic future, "The Ardennes Forest" is the most immediately reminiscent in its setting to I Who Have Never Known Men while expanding scope beyond one woman's life. A group of conscripts are mapping and scouting the terrain for what they imagine, not unreasonably, to be a future battlefield. That future never comes. They continue the work they've been assigned.
Endlessly.
As the story goes into nothing deeply, it became obvious to me this is Author Harpman meditating on the tedious tasks of daily life performed under nebulous, ominous duress. There's a weirdly onanistic edge to the submission of these soldiers to their assigned task even as they begin to question what it is they're doing as nothing ever changes as a result of its self-similar patterns.
Three stories of people in a system of depersonalizing cruelty, and how that strips an individual of any sense of agency; numbing the essential "You"ness of you into submissive obedience. I'm not a bit sure it will make new Harpman fans. For one thing, there are limits to the efficacy of compactness in the involving process of storytelling. I think these three stories are on the shortest end of that effort, possibly too short for anyone not already familiar with Author Harpman's thematic hobbyhorses to fully invest in them.
Billed as three stories about defiance, this small collection showcases Harpman's unique and varied styles of writing with her signature ability to create atmosphere and use fiction to reveal the artifice of human existence.
"The Ardennes Forest" - calling to mind the speculative/post-apocalyptic setting of her beloved novel I Who Have Never Known Men, we follow a group of soldiers assigned the task of wandering and surveying a forest for years on end, leading them to question the meaning of their work and the pitfalls of blind obedience.
"The Outcast" - an intelligent young girl experiences the realities of conflict and the inability for logic to win over emotion amidst a politically shifting culture.
"The Broom Closet" - a meta-narrative in which Harpman contemplates storytelling by bringing the reader into the creative process to craft the life of a young, passionate woman in 1920s Belgium, exploring ideas of female agency, marriage, and the creative process.
If you aren't already a fan of Harpman, I'm not sure these 3 short stories will completely win you over. They're good, though the collection feels a bit randomly put together and obviously at only 90 pages total there's not a lot of material here. I enjoyed them all for what they were and would recommend, but wish it had been a fuller collection with a more clear throughline.
The first story is phenomenal, transported me right back to I Who Have Never Known Men and the deep exploration of morality I felt reading it.
The second story isn't as strong in my opinion, it felt unfinished....or maybe I just didn't quite grasp the reason the author needed to tell his story.
I wish we had a few more stories but overall it was a fabulous read.
The first short story was easily my favorite because it had the strongest narrative. The second story was autobiographical, which didn’t engage me as much. The third story was metafictional and while I could appreciate what Harpman was trying to do by blurring the lines between author and story, it ultimately didn’t work for me. Overall, this collection was a bit of a mixed-bag, but it was well-written.
Three short stories by Harpman translated from the French. The first is very similar to her novel, I Who Have Never Known Men, a book that has caused a stir in online book communities (and is pretty good). It has the same quiet desperation: a group of people wander aimlessly through a forest, wondering if 'the war' is still waging or not. The second story is a strange, possibly autobiographical story, about two rival schoolgirls. I possibly enjoyed the last story the least, but it was, at least stylistically, the most compelling. A meta story, constructing itself as you read it. Overall a fine trio that can be read in an afternoon, but nothing special.
This is the third book I’ve read by Jacqueline Harpman, and I remain a total fan girl. This is a collection of three short stories. The first is a dystopian tale that feels reminiscent of I Who Have Never Known Men, and the third is giving Orlanda vibes. The middle story is autofiction that was the least fascinating of the three, but gave some interesting insight into what it was like to grow up in Morocco as a WWII era exile. I love this author’s witty voice and I feel like her imagination is absolutely unparalleled.
We Were Forbidden is a collection of three short stories by Jacqueline Harpman. I really enjoyed the first story, The Ardennes Forest, which is very reminiscent of her most popular work, I Who Have Never Known Men. It has an eerie vibe and many questions left unanswered, making the story feel more like a thought experiment than a traditional story. Harpman's command of language is strong and she creates an excellent balance of giving just enough information while still leaving many things ambiguous. The rest of the book went downhill from there and I really did not care for the second two stories. The last story, The Broom Closet, was honestly pretty boring to slog through and I didn't get the point. I would probably recommend skipping this collection and just reading I Who Have Never Known Men.
These three stories could not be more different: light post-apocalyptic speculative fiction, autobiographical essay, contemporary marriage melodrama. As I’ve started to read more from this author, it shouldn’t be so surprising, as her work seems hard to categorize or predict (also part of what makes this collection feel a bit random).
But between these three stories alongside I Who Have Never Known Men and Orlanda, it seems to me that Harpman is keenly interested in what makes us who we are, which could be glibly boiled down to nature vs nurture or social conditioning vs primal instinct, but approached from angles that make it feel fresh, insightful and thought-provoking.
I recently saw this on the staff picks shelf at one of my favorite indie bookstores, and, to the extent I'd be quite taken with the author's I Who Have Never Known Men, I figured I'd give it a try. I'm glad I did, although it didn't captivate me to the same extent.
Still, it's a surprisingly thought-provoking and - for such a slender volume - diverse collection of three seemingly unconnected novellas (or something like that).
The first was, to my mind, pretty classic (and rather compelling) post-war/conflict dystopia, nicely constructed and artfully concluded. The second was more of an autobiographical reminiscence or retrospective of a unique (and, to my mind, quite interesting) place (Casablanca, which I've only visited once), situation, and period in time. The third (again, to me) felt like a seasoned author's narration of a thought-experiment that never evolved into a fully-fledged novel.
But, no doubt, other more knowledgeable readers (or sophisticated literary reviewers) might describe the work quite differently.
Well worth reading, particularly given the return on investment (although that's intended more so in terms of time, given that the author passed away more than a decade ago, so she won't be benefitting from any royalties from my purchase, if any, ... and, given that the publisher is a not-for-profit, I'll tip my hat for their efforts to aid "the discovery and promotion of enduring works that carry readers across borders and communities." A worthy aspiration, in my book (no pun intended).)
I love Harpman’s writing. The first two stories were really strong, but the last one pulls down the rating to a 4⭐️. Also I think my Barnes put this out too early??? Because idk how I have this if it isn’t published yet 🤓
I just want to begin this by saying that I really loved Jacqueline Harpman's I who have never known men and her deadpan writing style in that one. This is a collection of 3 short stories about people who are forbidden from doing certain things. The first story titled 'Ardennes forest' is a post apocalyptic story. It's the only one worth reading in my opinion. The second one titled 'The Outcast' is okayish. It's about the authors first experience dealing with cognitively dissonant individuals with whom it can be very hard to argue with. I can go on to describe the many interesting things that it's about but the story itself is very underwhelming. The third one titled 'the broom closet' is the one which I found the most boring to read. If you want to watch an author attempt to write a metaphysical story (story within a story within a story) and fail spectacularly read this one. Also in a collection where people are forbidden from doing various things forgive me for not caring about a woman who's forbidden from committing adultery. (interestingly she's the least forbidden character in the entire collection) And for a writer who wrote "Being beautiful, was that for men?' 'Yes. Some women say that it is for ourselves. What on earth can we do with it? I could have loved myself whether I was hunchbacked or lame, but to be loved by others, you had to be beautiful." to also write "My gaze passed over Madame X because I was looking for a beauty, not a fat lump" even in the context of the character that she's writing feels like a fall from grace.
This may or may not be a hot take, but I think literary fiction as short stories are difficult to pull off - mostly because they risk feeling underdeveloped, especially when it comes to character work (which I feel is usually the defining part of a litfic).
These stories had some beautiful prose - the first one especially was more reminiscent of I Who Have Never Known Men. But as a whole I didn’t feel super connected to this collection. The blurbs for each also felt like they oversold the concept (i.e., execution didn’t live up for me).
Not terrible, but didn’t quite hit the mark for me. I acknowledge that the expectations/reality gap is in large part due to IWHNKM being such a resonant story.
I loved I Who Have Never Known Men, so I immediately checked this out when it became available. My feelings are very mixed.
I really enjoyed the first story, The Ardennes Forest. Though it doesn’t have the feminist tone I Who Have Never Known Men has, the story is eerily similar. It’s almost like seeing an artist’s sketches for a masterpiece. It has that same otherworldly, empty feeling that will leave you thinking. I’d definitely read this one if you’re a Harpman fan.
The second story, The Outcast, was interesting, but I’m not sure if it was worth giving up reading time for.
The final story, The Broom Closet, was a flop for me. I didn’t find anything to connect with, and the storytelling didn’t resonate with me.
I’d pick it up just to read Ardennes and skip the rest.
“What was the point of our strict compliance if the world where the decisions had been made no longer existed?”
This is a collection of three short stories; the first was absolutely phenomenal and reminiscent of I Who Have Never Known Men as it was set in an eerie dystopian post-apocalyptic world. I craved more from this. The second short story was autobiographical and frankly forgettable. The third story was metafictional which was cool but somewhat confusing. I love Harpman’s writing style and how every story is through a feminist lense but prefer reading her sci-fi stories.
It is a shame because the first story was so interesting but the rest fell a little flat for me. They didn't feel like they worked well together in one collection. Which is a shame, but I am glad I read it.
We Were Forbidden by Jacqueline Harpman — out now!
» READ IF YOU « 🌲 love dystopian and literary fiction 📚 are still thinking about I Who Have Never Known Men 🚪 want women who harbor a quiet defiance
» SYNOPSIS « Three never-before-translated stories from Jacqueline Harpman, loosely connected by a thread of defiance. In "The Ardennes Forest," survivors of war wander an endless woodland, forbidden from ever stopping. In "The Outcast," a Jewish girl in the 1940s is reprimanded for questioning her teachers. And in "The Broom Cupboard," a young wife fulfills her husband's desires, until she starts wondering about her own.
» REVIEW « "The Ardennes Forest" was a clear standout for me, and if you loved I Who Have Never Known Men, this one will likely scratch that itch. It’s got the same eerie, unexplained dystopian setting, and the same slow-burn unraveling of "why are we doing this, again?" There's something so unsettling about characters who adhere to strange orders long after the reason for them has evaporated, and Harpman writes that dread beautifully.
"The Outcast" is a very different tone but still sharp, and then "The Broom Cupboard" closes things out on a genuinely feral note—hear me out, but it's got an unhinged Simone de Beauvoir energy, like a more feral cousin to The Woman Destroyed. Watching a woman's compliance curdle into something else entirely, in real time, was a delight.
Three very different flavors of stories, all in Harpman's singular, spiky voice. A great, short companion piece to I Who Have Never Known Men.
» RATING « 🌳 I'm Wandering 🌳
» READ-A-LIKES « • Into the Forest (movie) • The Woman Destroyed by Simone de Beauvoir • The Country Will Bring Us No Peace by Matthieu Simard • The Vegetarian by Han Kang
“The Ardennes Forest” is the novella that makes this trio of stories worth buying, and reading it felt like stepping right back into the world of I Who Have Never Known Men. In fact this almost could have been a B story woven into that novel, with the two characters meeting in the end.
Harpman drops us among a band of soldiers, men and women, who keep following orders to roam the forest long after all communication has stopped and all contact with the outside world has ceased (in this way it also reminds me of the Donald Barthelme story “Game” I just read). Between “Ardennes” and “Never Known Men”, Harpman’s post-apocalypse has this addicting pastoral quality mixed with dread and confusion that weirdly makes me want to live in her world.
The other two novellas didn’t really move the needle for me, honestly, even knowing they pull from Harpman’s own life. “The Outcast” comes out of her adolescence as a Jewish refugee in wartime Casablanca, and I could appreciate the nerve of the girl at its center without ever getting pulled into her story the way I wanted to be. “The Broom Closet” is a strange, self-aware piece where Harpman writes herself inventing a story on a train. I’d buy this collection for that first novella alone and treat the rest as interesting context to inform your knowledge of the author.
Really enjoyed these three short stories. Though it feels unfair to compare this to I Who Have Never Known Men given this is completely different in form, the first short story felt like an echo of that novel. Immediately gripping and atmospheric.
The other two were much different style. Jacqueline Harpman’s nihilism & sense of humor really shines in these, found myself laughing at her witty skepticism in challenging her childhood friend’s belief in heaven. I don’t usually love the style of the third short story where the author’s voice is present and interjects commentary, but this became an exception for me. It’s a simple story but her intellectual and vain asides made it amusing.
“The only men who suited me were the heroes of novels who led their lives without getting involved in mine.”
What a good line.
“In that Heaven which, to my great regret, I do not believe in at all, the harvested ears seated at God’s right hand can happily enjoy eternity.”
“…I can’t help being drawn to her. She had been a well-behaved child, a docile wife, submissive before being aware of the battle, and then at the first invitation she rejects subservience and rises up furious in the face of adversity.”