What do you think?
Rate this book
Enduring Hope #4
The Caregiver at Wounded Knee
Rose Seeks Peace at All Costs
Collect a new series of historical romances. When life seems weighed down by challenges, there are always pillars of enduring hope and love to be discovered.
Rose Rushing Water, an Oglala Sioux trained back East in nursing, is torn between two brothers—one who seeks to appease the government and one who fights to cling to the old ways at all costs. Tribal policeman Nathaniel Gray Cloud struggles to keep peace on the reservation and support his sister, who is also desperate to hold on to family traditions. Can Rose and Nathaniel find a peace that comes only from God, or will they lose their families and their lives as tensions reach a boiling point at Wounded Knee Creek, South Dakota?
More from the Enduring Hope
The Angel of Second Street by Barbara Tifft Blakey
The Undercover Heiress of Brockton by Kelly J. Goshorn
The Daughter of Shiloh by Terri J. Haynes
Collect a new series of historical romances. When life seems weighed down by challenges, there are always pillars of enduring hope and love to be discovered.
Rose Rushing Water, an Oglala Sioux trained back East in nursing, is torn between two brothers—one who seeks to appease the government and one who fights to cling to the old ways at all costs. Tribal policeman Nathaniel Gray Cloud struggles to keep peace on the reservation and support his sister, who is also desperate to hold on to family traditions. Can Rose and Nathaniel find a peace that comes only from God, or will they lose their families and their lives as tensions reach a boiling point at Wounded Knee Creek, South Dakota?
More from the Enduring Hope
The Angel of Second Street by Barbara Tifft Blakey
The Undercover Heiress of Brockton by Kelly J. Goshorn
The Daughter of Shiloh by Terri J. Haynes
295 pages, Kindle Edition
Published February 1, 2026
7 people are currently reading
919 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 45 reviews
March 1, 2026
Thanks to NetGalley and Barbour Publishing for access to this title. All opinions expressed are my own.
I was intrigued by the cover of this title. One should never judge a book by its cover, but I knew this one wasn't a title I wanted to skip over.
Rose Rushing Water, taken from her home and placed in a residential school, was later sent to school in Boston, and has returned to help as a nurse for the local white doctor. But upon her return, Rose discovers turmoil in her family and community. A romance sparks between Rose and Nathaniel Gray Cloud, a local tribal policeman. Nathaniel, a Christian, realizes that Rose struggles with US policies that restrict her ability to practice her culture. Their discussions are some of the highlights of this novel. However, I did get tired of her brother, Peter, always barging in and yelling at them about their romance. But I do suppose it was 1890, and there were certain conventions to follow.
I do feel that the author does a very good job with the historical event. Overall, I am going to put it at a 3 because, at times, there were conversations taking place that I wasn't sure if fit the time period or if the publisher wanted to make sure book characters were having those conversations. Maybe I am overthinking it too much, not too sure.
Genres: Christian | Historical Fiction | Romance
Publication Date 01/02/26
Goodreads Review 21/02/26
#TheCaregiveratWoundedKnee #NetGalley.
I was intrigued by the cover of this title. One should never judge a book by its cover, but I knew this one wasn't a title I wanted to skip over.
Rose Rushing Water, taken from her home and placed in a residential school, was later sent to school in Boston, and has returned to help as a nurse for the local white doctor. But upon her return, Rose discovers turmoil in her family and community. A romance sparks between Rose and Nathaniel Gray Cloud, a local tribal policeman. Nathaniel, a Christian, realizes that Rose struggles with US policies that restrict her ability to practice her culture. Their discussions are some of the highlights of this novel. However, I did get tired of her brother, Peter, always barging in and yelling at them about their romance. But I do suppose it was 1890, and there were certain conventions to follow.
I do feel that the author does a very good job with the historical event. Overall, I am going to put it at a 3 because, at times, there were conversations taking place that I wasn't sure if fit the time period or if the publisher wanted to make sure book characters were having those conversations. Maybe I am overthinking it too much, not too sure.
Genres: Christian | Historical Fiction | Romance
Publication Date 01/02/26
Goodreads Review 21/02/26
#TheCaregiveratWoundedKnee #NetGalley.
November 8, 2025
I really enjoyed this book. It was an era i do not know a lot about, and for me sim e parts of the book could have more drama. But still a highly recommend book. Thank you to netgalley
February 2, 2026
Release date February 1, 2026
New author for me, I will be following her. This book really touched my heart. Since I was a young girl I’ve always had a soft spot for the Native Americans. Of course they were known as Indians at that point in time. They had their land stolen, were purposely infected with smallpox and feared greatly by the whites.
This book starts with following Rose, a nurse returning to her family home from Boston. She was taken from her family and forced to live with the nuns, who beat the Lakota words and lifestyle from her. She has mixed feelings about what her life will be. She meets a man named Nathaniel who is a Christian but also a Lakota. Her brother Peter is a tribal policeman and younger brother “Kane” are a part of the story. Rose and Nathaniel quickly developed feelings for each other. But Rose is reluctant to give up being a nurse to marry and become a mother.
The slaughter at Wounded knee plays a big part of the ending of the book.
I received a digital advance copy of this book from Barbour Publishing through NetGalley. This did not affect my honest review.
New author for me, I will be following her. This book really touched my heart. Since I was a young girl I’ve always had a soft spot for the Native Americans. Of course they were known as Indians at that point in time. They had their land stolen, were purposely infected with smallpox and feared greatly by the whites.
This book starts with following Rose, a nurse returning to her family home from Boston. She was taken from her family and forced to live with the nuns, who beat the Lakota words and lifestyle from her. She has mixed feelings about what her life will be. She meets a man named Nathaniel who is a Christian but also a Lakota. Her brother Peter is a tribal policeman and younger brother “Kane” are a part of the story. Rose and Nathaniel quickly developed feelings for each other. But Rose is reluctant to give up being a nurse to marry and become a mother.
The slaughter at Wounded knee plays a big part of the ending of the book.
I received a digital advance copy of this book from Barbour Publishing through NetGalley. This did not affect my honest review.
February 1, 2026
This historical event is something I did not know until I read this book.
The struggle of the natives to fit in with the “new normal” but still keep their culture and traditions were difficult. It made me wonder why we can’t all work together to a new future but still embrace and respect everyone’s differences which makes us unique.
This story had me engaged. I planned to read 2 hours a day but ended up finishing it over two days.
It was a heartbreaking event and one of those things which could have been prevented if someone just took the time to learn about each other’s beliefs and traditions instead of forcing everyone to act the same.
*I received a complimentary copy from the publisher. All opinions expressed are my own.*
The struggle of the natives to fit in with the “new normal” but still keep their culture and traditions were difficult. It made me wonder why we can’t all work together to a new future but still embrace and respect everyone’s differences which makes us unique.
This story had me engaged. I planned to read 2 hours a day but ended up finishing it over two days.
It was a heartbreaking event and one of those things which could have been prevented if someone just took the time to learn about each other’s beliefs and traditions instead of forcing everyone to act the same.
*I received a complimentary copy from the publisher. All opinions expressed are my own.*
February 28, 2026
“A stab of betrayal pierced her. The Lakota culture had been torn from her, and those in authority hadn’t given her a choice. Peter had had the option to retain his culture, like their younger brother had, but he had willingly chosen the white man’s ways. If the Lakota people weren’t careful, many of their traditions, oral histories, and stories would be lost forever. And her brother didn’t seem to care.”
After finishing Debby Lee’s The Caregiver at Wounded Knee, I have to say my feelings are in a jumble. There is no happily-ever-after in this story. Given the magnitude of the loss to the Lakota tribe and their culture, there cannot be. But slowly, there emerges a glimmer of Hope, that can only shine if people choose to let the Light in.
In 1890, after years away in the East, nurse Rose Rushing Water returns to the Lakota reservation in South Dakota, eager to help her people. She is also eager to reunite with her two brothers, Peter and Kaneenawup. Perhaps just as much, Rose wishes to re-enter into the customs and language of her people that were lost to her while in Boston.
What Rose finds on the reservation is fear, resentment, and hostility. The Lakota are distrustful of the whites who have taken over their land, brought new diseases, and have not shown concern or care for their welfare. The whites are afraid of the Indian dances, particularly the Ghost dance, and have put severe restrictions on the Native Americans to keep them subjugated and assimilated. In between are the Tribal police, Lakota men who are tasked as mediators between the government officials and the tribal people. Peter, Rose’s oldest brother and his best friend, Nathaniel are part of this small group.
As tensions ratchet, Rose tends to the sick of the reservation along with Dr. Eastman. She also begins secretly meeting with Nathaniel to re-learn the Lakota language, though being caught speaking it could land a person in jail. As Rose and her two brothers walk a tightrope in their relationships with each other because of their views on assimilation, a terrible tragedy for the Lakota stirs up rumors of an uprising. The government uses that as an excuse to come in to the camp at Wounded Knee, and a terrible massacre of mostly women and children takes place.
Rose has many questions for God. She is attracted to Nathaniel, but he believes God is in control. Rose wants nothing to do with the God that has been forced on her by people who have misused her and her people. Rose asks the age-old question, “How can a loving God allow… I loved how Nathaniel is able to empathize with Rose’s feelings, but separate angry feelings from bitterness and the need for revenge. Finally, Nathaniel lands on a word picture that helps Rose understand. He compares wood and religion. “We don’t blame the creator of the wood that’s used for evil. We blame the person using the wood for evil purposes.” He continues, “In a time when the world seems to be going crazy and there’s so much fighting between people, we can’t allow the evil actions of a few to keep us from enjoying the good things God has to offer us.” We can all mull that one over.
A heavy read, to be sure, but one that may give most readers a better understanding of the Wounded Knee massacre and the surrounding events.
I received a copy of the book from Celebrate Lit via NetGalley. I also purchased my own ebook. No positive review was required, and all opinions are my own.
Notable Quotables:
“Did his God really snuggle close to those who knew Him, and offer them companionship in the midst of trouble?” (Rose)
“It seemed that everything about her people was being yanked from them and vanishing in the air like the vapor her breath left behind on this bitterly cold winter day.” (Rose)
“We can’t let our righteous anger fester into rage, bitterness, and a thirst for vengeance, no matter how much it hurts.”- Nathaniel
“She pushed her secrets deeper into the recesses of her mind, fearing they would someday fester.” (Rose)
After finishing Debby Lee’s The Caregiver at Wounded Knee, I have to say my feelings are in a jumble. There is no happily-ever-after in this story. Given the magnitude of the loss to the Lakota tribe and their culture, there cannot be. But slowly, there emerges a glimmer of Hope, that can only shine if people choose to let the Light in.
In 1890, after years away in the East, nurse Rose Rushing Water returns to the Lakota reservation in South Dakota, eager to help her people. She is also eager to reunite with her two brothers, Peter and Kaneenawup. Perhaps just as much, Rose wishes to re-enter into the customs and language of her people that were lost to her while in Boston.
What Rose finds on the reservation is fear, resentment, and hostility. The Lakota are distrustful of the whites who have taken over their land, brought new diseases, and have not shown concern or care for their welfare. The whites are afraid of the Indian dances, particularly the Ghost dance, and have put severe restrictions on the Native Americans to keep them subjugated and assimilated. In between are the Tribal police, Lakota men who are tasked as mediators between the government officials and the tribal people. Peter, Rose’s oldest brother and his best friend, Nathaniel are part of this small group.
As tensions ratchet, Rose tends to the sick of the reservation along with Dr. Eastman. She also begins secretly meeting with Nathaniel to re-learn the Lakota language, though being caught speaking it could land a person in jail. As Rose and her two brothers walk a tightrope in their relationships with each other because of their views on assimilation, a terrible tragedy for the Lakota stirs up rumors of an uprising. The government uses that as an excuse to come in to the camp at Wounded Knee, and a terrible massacre of mostly women and children takes place.
Rose has many questions for God. She is attracted to Nathaniel, but he believes God is in control. Rose wants nothing to do with the God that has been forced on her by people who have misused her and her people. Rose asks the age-old question, “How can a loving God allow… I loved how Nathaniel is able to empathize with Rose’s feelings, but separate angry feelings from bitterness and the need for revenge. Finally, Nathaniel lands on a word picture that helps Rose understand. He compares wood and religion. “We don’t blame the creator of the wood that’s used for evil. We blame the person using the wood for evil purposes.” He continues, “In a time when the world seems to be going crazy and there’s so much fighting between people, we can’t allow the evil actions of a few to keep us from enjoying the good things God has to offer us.” We can all mull that one over.
A heavy read, to be sure, but one that may give most readers a better understanding of the Wounded Knee massacre and the surrounding events.
I received a copy of the book from Celebrate Lit via NetGalley. I also purchased my own ebook. No positive review was required, and all opinions are my own.
Notable Quotables:
“Did his God really snuggle close to those who knew Him, and offer them companionship in the midst of trouble?” (Rose)
“It seemed that everything about her people was being yanked from them and vanishing in the air like the vapor her breath left behind on this bitterly cold winter day.” (Rose)
“We can’t let our righteous anger fester into rage, bitterness, and a thirst for vengeance, no matter how much it hurts.”- Nathaniel
“She pushed her secrets deeper into the recesses of her mind, fearing they would someday fester.” (Rose)
February 19, 2026
🔶🔷♦️🔷🔶 🔶🔷♦️🔷🔶
Review:
Returning to her roots on the Pine Ridge Reservation of South Dakota, a young Ogalala Lakota (Sioux) woman finds herself between the extremes of two brothers’ ideologies – one is trying to adjust to the white man’s ways and the other wants the free-spirited ways of the past before reservations and White Man’s ways. Debby Lee is a new to me author and I was intrigued that she tackled this tumultuous time in history for her setting and characters.
🦬🩺Rose Rushing Water was taken as a girl from the reservation, sent to Boston for school and went into the nursing program. She has met and admired Clara Barton and Chief Sitting Bull, but now she is returned home to nurse with the white doctor in the nearby town and on the reservation with only a thin connection to her tribe and wants to learn more about her own people.
👮♂️🐎She meets tribal policeman and a strong Christian, Nathaniel Gray Cloud, who works with her older brother Peter, when she nurses his brother-in-law after a wagon accident. They spark an interest from the beginning. Nathaniel sees Rose as far above him with her college education and experiences in the East, but is drawn to her caring heart for others.
💥💔It isn’t long before she encounters her younger brother, Kaneenawup, who is part of the group participating in the ghost dance and acting aggressive around the local Indian agent and Peter is ordered to arrest him. Things escalate from there all the way to the tragic Battle of Wounded Knee (or Massacre at Wounded Knee).
Set in 1890, The Caregiver of Wounded Knee was loaded with excellent historical and cultural background in the story of a woman who was being pulled two opposing directions due to her race, her family, and her heart. The internal conflict fit well with the historical circumstances portrayed. It was heartrending on one level and yet hopeful for individuals like Rose. Definitely worth the read if one wants Christian sweet romance with Native American history by a Native American author.
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️💫
I rec’d an eARC via NetGalley to read in exchange for an honest review.
🔶🔷♦️🔷🔶 🔶🔷♦️🔷🔶
#TheCaregiverAtWoundedKnee #DebbyLee #EnduringHope #HistoricalFiction #BarbourPublishing #NativeAmericanHistory #NativeAmericanAuthor #InspirationalFiction
My full review will post at my Instagram page, @sophiarose1816 on 2.6.26
Review:
Returning to her roots on the Pine Ridge Reservation of South Dakota, a young Ogalala Lakota (Sioux) woman finds herself between the extremes of two brothers’ ideologies – one is trying to adjust to the white man’s ways and the other wants the free-spirited ways of the past before reservations and White Man’s ways. Debby Lee is a new to me author and I was intrigued that she tackled this tumultuous time in history for her setting and characters.
🦬🩺Rose Rushing Water was taken as a girl from the reservation, sent to Boston for school and went into the nursing program. She has met and admired Clara Barton and Chief Sitting Bull, but now she is returned home to nurse with the white doctor in the nearby town and on the reservation with only a thin connection to her tribe and wants to learn more about her own people.
👮♂️🐎She meets tribal policeman and a strong Christian, Nathaniel Gray Cloud, who works with her older brother Peter, when she nurses his brother-in-law after a wagon accident. They spark an interest from the beginning. Nathaniel sees Rose as far above him with her college education and experiences in the East, but is drawn to her caring heart for others.
💥💔It isn’t long before she encounters her younger brother, Kaneenawup, who is part of the group participating in the ghost dance and acting aggressive around the local Indian agent and Peter is ordered to arrest him. Things escalate from there all the way to the tragic Battle of Wounded Knee (or Massacre at Wounded Knee).
Set in 1890, The Caregiver of Wounded Knee was loaded with excellent historical and cultural background in the story of a woman who was being pulled two opposing directions due to her race, her family, and her heart. The internal conflict fit well with the historical circumstances portrayed. It was heartrending on one level and yet hopeful for individuals like Rose. Definitely worth the read if one wants Christian sweet romance with Native American history by a Native American author.
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️💫
I rec’d an eARC via NetGalley to read in exchange for an honest review.
🔶🔷♦️🔷🔶 🔶🔷♦️🔷🔶
#TheCaregiverAtWoundedKnee #DebbyLee #EnduringHope #HistoricalFiction #BarbourPublishing #NativeAmericanHistory #NativeAmericanAuthor #InspirationalFiction
My full review will post at my Instagram page, @sophiarose1816 on 2.6.26
November 6, 2025
The Enduring Hope series published by Barbour publishing is starting to become a huge favorite of mine! Each book is written by a different author and is a standalone book but they each carry the message of staying strong and never giving up. I will say that The Caregiver at Wounded Creek by Debby Lee is a very moving one as it displays an important part of American history.
We are introduced to Rose who is a Souix native who was trained back East as a nurse and eventually returns to the reservation to help her people. She struggles to keep her family together due to the challenging differences in the world. Another man Nathaniel who lives on the reservation is facing the same challenges.
I will say I deeply moved by this story. I look forward to reading what the next two books will have in store.
I received an arc copy from Netgalley and all opinions are of my own.
We are introduced to Rose who is a Souix native who was trained back East as a nurse and eventually returns to the reservation to help her people. She struggles to keep her family together due to the challenging differences in the world. Another man Nathaniel who lives on the reservation is facing the same challenges.
I will say I deeply moved by this story. I look forward to reading what the next two books will have in store.
I received an arc copy from Netgalley and all opinions are of my own.
February 6, 2026
The Caregiver at Wounded Knee by Debby Lee
Barbour Publishing | Barbour Fiction
Genres: Christian • Historical Fiction • Romance
This was my first time reading Debby Lee, and I found The Caregiver at Wounded Knee to be a thoughtful and emotionally resonant historical romance set during a deeply difficult period in American history.
Rose Rushing Water, an Oglala Sioux woman trained as a nurse back East, is caught between conflicting loyalties—family, tradition, and survival. Nathaniel Gray Cloud, a tribal policeman striving to keep peace on the reservation, is a strong and steady presence whose inner struggle adds depth to the story. As tensions rise and events move toward Wounded Knee Creek, the emotional weight of the setting becomes increasingly powerful.
I appreciated how the novel explores themes of faith, sacrifice, identity, and peace, and how the message of hope is rooted in trusting God even when circumstances feel impossible. The romance unfolds gently alongside the historical conflict, adding heart without overshadowing the seriousness of the story.
This book is part of the Enduring Hope series, written by a variety of Christian authors, and it works well as a standalone novel.
I received a complimentary copy from Barbour Publishing and was under no obligation to post a review.
#TheCaregiveratWoundedKnee
Barbour Publishing | Barbour Fiction
Genres: Christian • Historical Fiction • Romance
This was my first time reading Debby Lee, and I found The Caregiver at Wounded Knee to be a thoughtful and emotionally resonant historical romance set during a deeply difficult period in American history.
Rose Rushing Water, an Oglala Sioux woman trained as a nurse back East, is caught between conflicting loyalties—family, tradition, and survival. Nathaniel Gray Cloud, a tribal policeman striving to keep peace on the reservation, is a strong and steady presence whose inner struggle adds depth to the story. As tensions rise and events move toward Wounded Knee Creek, the emotional weight of the setting becomes increasingly powerful.
I appreciated how the novel explores themes of faith, sacrifice, identity, and peace, and how the message of hope is rooted in trusting God even when circumstances feel impossible. The romance unfolds gently alongside the historical conflict, adding heart without overshadowing the seriousness of the story.
This book is part of the Enduring Hope series, written by a variety of Christian authors, and it works well as a standalone novel.
I received a complimentary copy from Barbour Publishing and was under no obligation to post a review.
#TheCaregiveratWoundedKnee
February 20, 2026
The Caregiver at Wounded Knee is a deeply moving historical romance that blends heartbreak, healing, and hope against one of the most sobering backdrops in American history.
The author handles the setting of Wounded Knee with care and reverence, never diminishing the weight of the tragedy while still crafting a fictional story that highlights compassion and courage. The caregiving thread woven throughout the novel is especially powerful—showing how quiet acts of service can become instruments of redemption.
I appreciated how the romance developed with patience and emotional depth rather than rushing toward an easy resolution. The relationship felt earned, shaped by loss, faith, and resilience. The characters are layered and believable, carrying wounds that mirror the historical setting yet finding strength in unexpected ways.
What stood out most to me was the theme of restoration—both personal and communal. The story doesn’t shy away from suffering, but it also doesn’t leave the reader there. It gently reminds us that even in places marked by sorrow, God can bring beauty and renewal.
If you enjoy historical romance that balances authenticity, emotional richness, and a strong thread of hope, this one is well worth the read. It’s a tender, thoughtful novel that lingers long after the final page.
Thank you Barbour Publishing for providing this book for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
The author handles the setting of Wounded Knee with care and reverence, never diminishing the weight of the tragedy while still crafting a fictional story that highlights compassion and courage. The caregiving thread woven throughout the novel is especially powerful—showing how quiet acts of service can become instruments of redemption.
I appreciated how the romance developed with patience and emotional depth rather than rushing toward an easy resolution. The relationship felt earned, shaped by loss, faith, and resilience. The characters are layered and believable, carrying wounds that mirror the historical setting yet finding strength in unexpected ways.
What stood out most to me was the theme of restoration—both personal and communal. The story doesn’t shy away from suffering, but it also doesn’t leave the reader there. It gently reminds us that even in places marked by sorrow, God can bring beauty and renewal.
If you enjoy historical romance that balances authenticity, emotional richness, and a strong thread of hope, this one is well worth the read. It’s a tender, thoughtful novel that lingers long after the final page.
Thank you Barbour Publishing for providing this book for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
December 29, 2025
I have enjoyed most of the books in this series. I love that they are written by different authors and are stand alones. That being said, I just couldn't finish this one. I got about 2/3 through and I lost complete interest. The characters were pretty flat to me. And there were moments where it was like time seemed to jump. I wanted to like it as the topic is excellent--the challenged faced with forced assimilation for the native tribes. It's heartbreaking. But it just didn't really have the emotion in it, like it could have.
The author writes well, but it was just a light non-meaty book for me. And like I said I lost interest and no longer cared about the story.
*Thank you to NetGAlley for the ARC of this book. All opinions are 100% my own.
The author writes well, but it was just a light non-meaty book for me. And like I said I lost interest and no longer cared about the story.
*Thank you to NetGAlley for the ARC of this book. All opinions are 100% my own.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I believe the author when she said that this is the most difficult book she’s ever had to write. The atrocities that were committed against the Indians in their own country is unimaginable. This book is based on a true story and it explores the thoughts of those involved. I was given a complementary copy of this book and the opinions are my own.
December 25, 2025
This is such an important book. Anyone at all curious about this subject should read this book. It’s very carefully written from the perspective of a native who has been educated in Boston and returns home to be a nurse serving her people.
We see both sides of the story and we see her frustrations being torn between a changing world. Her brothers show that pull very well.
There’s a small romance but the focus for me was Wounded Knee.
Highly recommend.
And if you haven’t read her WW2 book about the Philippines I recommend that too!
We see both sides of the story and we see her frustrations being torn between a changing world. Her brothers show that pull very well.
There’s a small romance but the focus for me was Wounded Knee.
Highly recommend.
And if you haven’t read her WW2 book about the Philippines I recommend that too!
February 28, 2026
"The Caregiver At Wounded Knee" by Debby Lee is a Christian Historical Fiction book Taking Pace during the time of the Battle of wounded Knee. This historic event took place on December 29, 1890 on the Lakota Pine Ridge Indian Reservation in south Dakota. It is the story of Rose Rushing Water - a Native American Lakota girl who returns to South Dakota after completing some health care studies in Boston. She goes home to care for her people people - the Oglala Lakota peoples and her brothers. Tensions are high - the native languages, customs, dress, and dances are outlawed and there are stories of many deaths of Native Americans and US Soldiers. Tragically, these tensions lead to the Battle of Wounded Knee. of 1890.
This story is written is a simple, repetitive manner, and would be good as a young adult book. Christianity is introduced in the midst of this story, and then settled very quickly. Perhaps the Christian part of this story deserves it's own book.
3 Stars
Thank You to NetGalley and Barbour Publishing for the ARC of this book. All opinions are my own.
This story is written is a simple, repetitive manner, and would be good as a young adult book. Christianity is introduced in the midst of this story, and then settled very quickly. Perhaps the Christian part of this story deserves it's own book.
3 Stars
Thank You to NetGalley and Barbour Publishing for the ARC of this book. All opinions are my own.
November 27, 2025
This is a very emotional story. It’s about Native American Indigenous people and the treatment they received. Wonderfully written and so heartbreaking. A must read.
February 6, 2026
I loved this fast-paced, compelling novel, written with excellence. The engaging characters, especially Rose, her brothers Peter and Kane, and Peter’s best friend, Nathaniel, mirrored the personalities and concerns of many tribal members. I was happily surprised that many Lakota believed in Jesus.
Rose, Peter, and Nathaniel had courage that was forged through incredible adversity. Rose was twelve when their parents died. Peter, at 16, raised Kane, only ten years old, as best he could. Rose was sent away to a boarding school, then attended nursing school in Boston. The boarding school and university were difficult places for Native Americans, especially with the prevailing attitude that they should be exterminated.
Rose returned to Pine Ridge Reservation to use her skills to help her people. The place she called home had changed so much! Settlers lived nearby now, forcing the tribe to cease activities such as the Ghost Dance and their ceremonies as the settlers were afraid the tribe was preparing for war.
Rose had looked forward to re-learning the language and customs of her people. Instead, she learned the consequences faced by those who disregarded the laws. The government wanted the Lakota to assimilate with the white settlers, to give up their language and culture. How could Rose assess the elderly people who came to the clinic if she couldn’t speak or understand Lakota?
Rose worked for Dr. Eastman in the clinic, and could dispense treatments for certain illnesses. She also checked on pregnant women, delivered their babies, and followed up with moms and babies.
Nathaniel and Rose became good friends, and he helped her re-learn Lakota words that would help her assess the elderly who went into the clinic. While the Indian Agent, Mr. Royer, advised that she would be turned in and punished if overheard, he was aware of the need of helping those who were ill.
Rose and Nathaniel grew closer, going on picnics at least once a week. Rose had misgivings, however. Nathaniel, like Peter, had a strong faith in and relationship with the Lord. Rose was required to go to mass when in school in the east, and didn’t understand a deity that didn’t help her people. She didn’t want to marry, as men back east did not allow their wives to work. She wanted to help her people as long as she could. She struggled mightily to understand the God that Nathaniel believed in. Nathaniel shared timeless advice with Rose: “…we can’t allow the evil actions of a few to keep us from enjoying the good things God has to offer us”.
Chief Sitting Bull, at a nearby camp, was killed by one of his own tribal police officers, devastating many. Rose had met Sitting Bull when attending a circus in Boston, and had hoped to see him again and hear his culturally rich stories. Soon after, terrifying events began that one could only survive if a miracle occurred. Most in the military nursed bitter feelings since “Custer’s last stand” in 1876. Their treatment of the Lakota at Wounded Knee Creek was devastating!
This is a thoughtful, fully engaging novel. It was well-researched and written by an excellent storyteller/ author. I highly recommend this novel, especially to those who appreciate Christian historical fiction based on true events, with rich characters determined to survive inadequate food rations, sickness, and military reprisals.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and was under no obligation to post a review.
Rose, Peter, and Nathaniel had courage that was forged through incredible adversity. Rose was twelve when their parents died. Peter, at 16, raised Kane, only ten years old, as best he could. Rose was sent away to a boarding school, then attended nursing school in Boston. The boarding school and university were difficult places for Native Americans, especially with the prevailing attitude that they should be exterminated.
Rose returned to Pine Ridge Reservation to use her skills to help her people. The place she called home had changed so much! Settlers lived nearby now, forcing the tribe to cease activities such as the Ghost Dance and their ceremonies as the settlers were afraid the tribe was preparing for war.
Rose had looked forward to re-learning the language and customs of her people. Instead, she learned the consequences faced by those who disregarded the laws. The government wanted the Lakota to assimilate with the white settlers, to give up their language and culture. How could Rose assess the elderly people who came to the clinic if she couldn’t speak or understand Lakota?
Rose worked for Dr. Eastman in the clinic, and could dispense treatments for certain illnesses. She also checked on pregnant women, delivered their babies, and followed up with moms and babies.
Nathaniel and Rose became good friends, and he helped her re-learn Lakota words that would help her assess the elderly who went into the clinic. While the Indian Agent, Mr. Royer, advised that she would be turned in and punished if overheard, he was aware of the need of helping those who were ill.
Rose and Nathaniel grew closer, going on picnics at least once a week. Rose had misgivings, however. Nathaniel, like Peter, had a strong faith in and relationship with the Lord. Rose was required to go to mass when in school in the east, and didn’t understand a deity that didn’t help her people. She didn’t want to marry, as men back east did not allow their wives to work. She wanted to help her people as long as she could. She struggled mightily to understand the God that Nathaniel believed in. Nathaniel shared timeless advice with Rose: “…we can’t allow the evil actions of a few to keep us from enjoying the good things God has to offer us”.
Chief Sitting Bull, at a nearby camp, was killed by one of his own tribal police officers, devastating many. Rose had met Sitting Bull when attending a circus in Boston, and had hoped to see him again and hear his culturally rich stories. Soon after, terrifying events began that one could only survive if a miracle occurred. Most in the military nursed bitter feelings since “Custer’s last stand” in 1876. Their treatment of the Lakota at Wounded Knee Creek was devastating!
This is a thoughtful, fully engaging novel. It was well-researched and written by an excellent storyteller/ author. I highly recommend this novel, especially to those who appreciate Christian historical fiction based on true events, with rich characters determined to survive inadequate food rations, sickness, and military reprisals.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and was under no obligation to post a review.
February 13, 2026
REVIEW- 3 5 stars
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for this ARC. I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
STORYLINE :
I've always thought that native Americans and their culture are underrepresented in fiction. So, I didn't hesitate when I saw the storyline. A historical book about the FMC, a nurse trying to learn more if her culture after it was cruelly snatched away from her. The MMC, a tribal police who's trying to 'assimilate' because of the fear of the unknown. I loved reading about the history because I've never read a book like this, especially one written by a native American. Then, if they didn't assimilate and this means neglecting their culture, they'll be killed, starved or have their kids forcefully taken away.
As I was reading, it felt like I was present in 1890s and I could experience what they could. The book was quite heavy considering the injustices the Native Americans faced, but I'm glad that there was a bit of romance to make things lighter. One thing I feel is missing from this book is the righteous anger towards the politely called 'settlers', but that's just me.
Anyway, I liked what the author did with the clinical setting, though. It showed their vulnerabilities, most caused by the white colonizers, and the rest of the characters.
CHARACTERS:
The characters were unique in their way and reflective of their time and circumstances. There were those tightly holding on to their dwindling culture, those trying to abandon their culture for peace and those just trying to live their l simple lives with their families. My favourite was Rose of course, because of how she cared about her people and her culture, and Kaneenawup who refuses to let go of who he was. However, I also understood the reasonings of those who did otherwise like Peter.
WRITING STYLE:
The writing style was okay and I liked that date was clearly written and the short chapters.
SETTINGS:
The settings were lively and realistic, especially the clinic and Rose's house.
OVERALL:
The book had a nice storyline, but I wished it had more anger and more romance. Once the climax hit, my interest in the book waned. But, it was still okay beause of the Native Americans' history
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for this ARC. I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
STORYLINE :
I've always thought that native Americans and their culture are underrepresented in fiction. So, I didn't hesitate when I saw the storyline. A historical book about the FMC, a nurse trying to learn more if her culture after it was cruelly snatched away from her. The MMC, a tribal police who's trying to 'assimilate' because of the fear of the unknown. I loved reading about the history because I've never read a book like this, especially one written by a native American. Then, if they didn't assimilate and this means neglecting their culture, they'll be killed, starved or have their kids forcefully taken away.
As I was reading, it felt like I was present in 1890s and I could experience what they could. The book was quite heavy considering the injustices the Native Americans faced, but I'm glad that there was a bit of romance to make things lighter. One thing I feel is missing from this book is the righteous anger towards the politely called 'settlers', but that's just me.
Anyway, I liked what the author did with the clinical setting, though. It showed their vulnerabilities, most caused by the white colonizers, and the rest of the characters.
CHARACTERS:
The characters were unique in their way and reflective of their time and circumstances. There were those tightly holding on to their dwindling culture, those trying to abandon their culture for peace and those just trying to live their l simple lives with their families. My favourite was Rose of course, because of how she cared about her people and her culture, and Kaneenawup who refuses to let go of who he was. However, I also understood the reasonings of those who did otherwise like Peter.
WRITING STYLE:
The writing style was okay and I liked that date was clearly written and the short chapters.
SETTINGS:
The settings were lively and realistic, especially the clinic and Rose's house.
OVERALL:
The book had a nice storyline, but I wished it had more anger and more romance. Once the climax hit, my interest in the book waned. But, it was still okay beause of the Native Americans' history
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This is my first book by Debbie Lee and this Christian historical book is part of the Enduring Hope series written by a variety of Christian authors. Each book can be read as a stand alone story.
This book is about the Oglala/Lakota Indians in the Lakota Pine Ridge Indian Reservation in South Dakota in 1890. The story is seen through the eyes of Rose Rushing Water - a Native American Lakota who was taken from her family in forced assimilation to Boston, where she eventually become a nurse. She returns home to care for her tribe and is caught between the culture clashes between the Native Americans, politics and settlers.
Here the authors research shines with historical details about the landscape, medical care at that time, including herbal medicine, Lakota culture and the hostility toward Native Americans, culminating in the Wounded Knee Massacre.
She also weaves spiritual thoughts and reflections throughout, bringing hope and healing to the terrible situation.
Areas that needed more depth and fleshing out were the character building of the main protagonists and descriptiveness throughout the story. It did have some building suspense, a clean, budding romance and a sensitivity with such a tragic event, accurate without being too graphic. It was a solid 3.5 stars for me.
If you would like to learn more about this lesser known historical Native American era with all its heroic and devastating moments with a spiritual overlay, I would recommend it.
A big note of appreciation to Barbour Publishing and NetGalley for the ARC,it was a pleasure to read. All opinions expressed are my own.
This book is about the Oglala/Lakota Indians in the Lakota Pine Ridge Indian Reservation in South Dakota in 1890. The story is seen through the eyes of Rose Rushing Water - a Native American Lakota who was taken from her family in forced assimilation to Boston, where she eventually become a nurse. She returns home to care for her tribe and is caught between the culture clashes between the Native Americans, politics and settlers.
Here the authors research shines with historical details about the landscape, medical care at that time, including herbal medicine, Lakota culture and the hostility toward Native Americans, culminating in the Wounded Knee Massacre.
She also weaves spiritual thoughts and reflections throughout, bringing hope and healing to the terrible situation.
Areas that needed more depth and fleshing out were the character building of the main protagonists and descriptiveness throughout the story. It did have some building suspense, a clean, budding romance and a sensitivity with such a tragic event, accurate without being too graphic. It was a solid 3.5 stars for me.
If you would like to learn more about this lesser known historical Native American era with all its heroic and devastating moments with a spiritual overlay, I would recommend it.
A big note of appreciation to Barbour Publishing and NetGalley for the ARC,it was a pleasure to read. All opinions expressed are my own.
February 1, 2026
The Caregiver at Wounded Knee follows Rose Rushing Water, a member of the Lakota tribe who had been educated in Boston to be a nurse. While in Boston, Rose's experiences included the pains of prejudice against her people as well as the joys of learning nursing, discovering new authors, and making a best friend. Rose was ready to liver her dream of returning home to her brothers and serving the Indians and settlers residing there. She also was excited to reconnect with her language and traditions, something that was far more difficult than she had ever anticipated. The story of Rose's life leads to her presence at the Wounded Knee Creek on the day of the infamous massacre.
The theme of understanding how an all-powerful and loving God allows people to do horrible things to one another, sometimes in the name of Christianity, and that of justice unrealized are at the center of The Caregiver at Wounded Knee and are well-developed. There is a particular analogy the author uses that goes a long way in explaining why we should not give up on God when people do terrible things.
For the most part, I truly enjoyed this novel. There were a few places where the dialogue or the descriptive prose seemed to be that of a less mature writer, but that certainly wasn't a consistent feature. I enjoyed the story and may seek out others based on this time period in the American West. I am grateful to have received a complimentary copy of The Caregiver at Wounded Knee from Barbour Publishing via NetGalley without obligation. All opinions expressed here are my own.
The theme of understanding how an all-powerful and loving God allows people to do horrible things to one another, sometimes in the name of Christianity, and that of justice unrealized are at the center of The Caregiver at Wounded Knee and are well-developed. There is a particular analogy the author uses that goes a long way in explaining why we should not give up on God when people do terrible things.
For the most part, I truly enjoyed this novel. There were a few places where the dialogue or the descriptive prose seemed to be that of a less mature writer, but that certainly wasn't a consistent feature. I enjoyed the story and may seek out others based on this time period in the American West. I am grateful to have received a complimentary copy of The Caregiver at Wounded Knee from Barbour Publishing via NetGalley without obligation. All opinions expressed here are my own.
February 4, 2026
"We're made in God's image too, aren't we?"
Rose Rushing Water has been living in Boston after being taken away from her brothers and their Lakota territory after her parents' deaths. Over the years she has trained to be a nurse and has been sent back to her homeland to serve the people. She will be able to see her brothers again and work with the local doctor.
Nathaniel Gray Cloud notices the sister of his best friend. The nurse is dedicated to the care of indigenous and white people on the reservation and the surrounding territory. There is unrest in the area as people mistrust one another and the whites try to force the Lakota to give up their customs.
I received an advance reader's copy of The Caregiver at Wounded Knee by Debby Lee from Barbour Publishing through NetGalley. I choose every book in the Enduring Hope series which gives me a fictionalized account of a true historic event. This is another emotional read. There is great stress between the people, even creating a separation between Rose's brothers. Nathaniel becomes her friend as tensions increase. It takes a while for the story to move to the heart break of the massacre at Wounded Knee. I feel that the author kept the horror at a minimum while getting the point of the story across. I think she showed the stress between the people and the mismanagement of care for the Lakota who weren't even provided for as needed. Rose's bitterness and search for God is reasonable with all that she went through and observed. It's a good story. I learned things I didn't know from the obvious research. I give this book 4 stars. I appreciate this series.
Rose Rushing Water has been living in Boston after being taken away from her brothers and their Lakota territory after her parents' deaths. Over the years she has trained to be a nurse and has been sent back to her homeland to serve the people. She will be able to see her brothers again and work with the local doctor.
Nathaniel Gray Cloud notices the sister of his best friend. The nurse is dedicated to the care of indigenous and white people on the reservation and the surrounding territory. There is unrest in the area as people mistrust one another and the whites try to force the Lakota to give up their customs.
I received an advance reader's copy of The Caregiver at Wounded Knee by Debby Lee from Barbour Publishing through NetGalley. I choose every book in the Enduring Hope series which gives me a fictionalized account of a true historic event. This is another emotional read. There is great stress between the people, even creating a separation between Rose's brothers. Nathaniel becomes her friend as tensions increase. It takes a while for the story to move to the heart break of the massacre at Wounded Knee. I feel that the author kept the horror at a minimum while getting the point of the story across. I think she showed the stress between the people and the mismanagement of care for the Lakota who weren't even provided for as needed. Rose's bitterness and search for God is reasonable with all that she went through and observed. It's a good story. I learned things I didn't know from the obvious research. I give this book 4 stars. I appreciate this series.
February 16, 2026
Hard to read at some points but so worth it. The history in this book is rich with detail from the Native American point of view. Pushed onto reservations, exposed to diseases they had no immunity for, not enough food or medical supplies and families torn apart. It all happened and we see it from Rose and Nathaniel's eyes. Lakota by birth but forced to "assimilate" into American culture, they both choose to serve the Lakotan people however they can in an attempt to provide hope and comfort during a very dark time. Rose trained in Boston as a nurse but she has forgotten the Lakotan language. Nathaniel helps her recall it so she can better serve the medical needs of the Lakotans, even though it is against rules for them to ever use the language. Romance begins to bloom between the pair but Rose's los of her faith in a kind and loving God will push them apart. Then, when the unthinkable happens, Rose and Nathaniel must work together to provide what aid and assistance they can in the face of possible punishment for providing that help to Lakotans.
The other side of the story, excruciating and heartbreaking, but full of the courage and culture of those trying to defend the old ways and live as they have for generations, even when the government tells them they cannot. I admire the extensive research that has gone into this book and recommend it to both those curious about the Lakotan history and the romantics who enjoy stories of love that blossoms despite hardship and trying times.
The other side of the story, excruciating and heartbreaking, but full of the courage and culture of those trying to defend the old ways and live as they have for generations, even when the government tells them they cannot. I admire the extensive research that has gone into this book and recommend it to both those curious about the Lakotan history and the romantics who enjoy stories of love that blossoms despite hardship and trying times.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
3.7 stars (4/10 hearts). I wanted to love this, I really did. The author's heart shone through, and I really appreciated the story's theme and setting. Being Canadian, I never heard of the Wounded Knee Massacre, and I've read very little about the reservations, especially in the 1890s, so this was an eye-opener. I was as furious as the characters were about the lack of justice and the disgusting way the Oglala tribe was treated. I also appreciated getting to see both sides of the issue—from Rose and Kaneenawup, who as a nurse raised in a residential school wanted to cling to the traditions before they vanished, and Nathaniel + Peter, who as tribal police wanted to assimilate and avoid destruction at the hands of anxious or racist settlers. Unfortunately, I didn't really click with any of the characters, really; I struggled with the writing style; and I was annoyed by Rose & Nathaniel's way of handling their relationship. But I thought the author had the best explanation and analogy for "why do Christians do bad things and why God allows bad things to happen" question that is so relevant to our world. Overall, I'm thankful I read this and I think it was an important read.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book for promotional purposes. I was not required to write a positive review. These are my honest thoughts and opinions.*
*I received a complimentary copy of this book for promotional purposes. I was not required to write a positive review. These are my honest thoughts and opinions.*
February 13, 2026
The 1890s were a very tough time for the Oglala Lakota people. The buffalo had been eradicated to allow settlers to move into South Dakota. The Pine Ridge Reservation experienced extreme poverty, illness, hunger and more. Children were taken away from their families and sent to reservation schools and some even out of state. Rose Rushing Water was one of these children. Her studies in Boston taught her to become a nurse, knowledge with which she returned home to benefit her people.
Settlers, nervous about Indian traditions, caused much fear and sometimes ended in great sadness. The various dances, etc. were just the way the Indians expressed their joy and sorrow. What could be so wrong about that? Such fear brought about the massacre at Wounded Knee. How could a God of love allow such horror to occur was one of the many questions Rose asked? Was there any solution good for everyone? Should she reject Christianity because evil people used it as a weapon to hurt and control others?
This novel of Enduring Hope was received through Barbour Publishing and NetGalley. These impressions are my own and were in no way solicited.
Settlers, nervous about Indian traditions, caused much fear and sometimes ended in great sadness. The various dances, etc. were just the way the Indians expressed their joy and sorrow. What could be so wrong about that? Such fear brought about the massacre at Wounded Knee. How could a God of love allow such horror to occur was one of the many questions Rose asked? Was there any solution good for everyone? Should she reject Christianity because evil people used it as a weapon to hurt and control others?
This novel of Enduring Hope was received through Barbour Publishing and NetGalley. These impressions are my own and were in no way solicited.
March 7, 2026
The Caregiver at Wounded Knee is the last book in the Enduring Hope series, written by different authors. I’ve read all the books and enjoyed the unique writing styles and strong characters. You don’t need to read the earlier books to understand this one.
The story tells about the Wounded Knee Massacre through the eyes of Rose, a Lakota nurse, and Nathaniel, a deputy who helps her reconnect with her heritage. I appreciate how the book reveals the struggles Native Americans faced, such as sickness, violence, and being forced to adjust their ways. I would have liked a bit more connection to Rose, and some parts are hard to read, but the story is also full of bravery, kindness, faith, and strength. It’s well researched emotional and gives an important view of a painful time in history.
First Line: An overturned wagon lay sprawled along the road ahead.
Series: Enduring Hope, book 4
Genre: Christian Historical Romance
Author: Debby Lee
Page Count: 295
#CoverLoverBookReview received a review copy of this book. Opinions are my own.
The story tells about the Wounded Knee Massacre through the eyes of Rose, a Lakota nurse, and Nathaniel, a deputy who helps her reconnect with her heritage. I appreciate how the book reveals the struggles Native Americans faced, such as sickness, violence, and being forced to adjust their ways. I would have liked a bit more connection to Rose, and some parts are hard to read, but the story is also full of bravery, kindness, faith, and strength. It’s well researched emotional and gives an important view of a painful time in history.
First Line: An overturned wagon lay sprawled along the road ahead.
Series: Enduring Hope, book 4
Genre: Christian Historical Romance
Author: Debby Lee
Page Count: 295
#CoverLoverBookReview received a review copy of this book. Opinions are my own.
November 20, 2025
This is an emotional read, and it wasn't long that I was walking in Rose Rushing Water's shoes. We are with her as she comes home as a nurse, she had been living in Boston, and now want to come back to her culture, more or less stolen from her.
We are with Rose when she goes to the Pine Ridge Reservation, and of course the famous events that take place there. So very sad.
There are facts here that I didn't remember, like changing the name of the tribe. Also the famous writer, who was very anti-native American.
The author drew me in with a young women that I soon cared about, we meet her brothers, and really worry about one of them. We follow her as she goes about helping the local doctor, and helping those in need.
She wants to dedicate her life to helping her people, can there their be room for some romance?
I found myself wanting to continue on in this book, even after the last page is turned.
I will be looking for more reads by Debby Lee!
I received this book through Net Galley and the Publisher Barbour, and was not required to give a positive review.
We are with Rose when she goes to the Pine Ridge Reservation, and of course the famous events that take place there. So very sad.
There are facts here that I didn't remember, like changing the name of the tribe. Also the famous writer, who was very anti-native American.
The author drew me in with a young women that I soon cared about, we meet her brothers, and really worry about one of them. We follow her as she goes about helping the local doctor, and helping those in need.
She wants to dedicate her life to helping her people, can there their be room for some romance?
I found myself wanting to continue on in this book, even after the last page is turned.
I will be looking for more reads by Debby Lee!
I received this book through Net Galley and the Publisher Barbour, and was not required to give a positive review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Through much research, Debby Lee tells the story of Wounded Knee through her main characters of Rose Rushing Water and Nathaniel Gray Cloud. Having been sent by the government to school in the East, separating her from her brothers when their parents died, Rose was trained as a nurse. She returned home to Wounded Knee upon completion of her training and reunited with her brothers. Nathaniel was a deputy with the town. Circumstances and Nathaniel's friendship with Rose's brother Peter kept drawing Rose and Nathaniel together. Rose ministered to the needs of the townspeople and the Indian village nearby.
The massacre at Wounded Knee was a horrible tragedy in our history. Lee did a wonderful job in her story of "The Caregiver of Wounded Knee". She relayed the details compassionately and as gently as they can be delivered. Prepare for this heart-wrenching retelling of a tragic part of our history.
Releases Feb. 1st. I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
The massacre at Wounded Knee was a horrible tragedy in our history. Lee did a wonderful job in her story of "The Caregiver of Wounded Knee". She relayed the details compassionately and as gently as they can be delivered. Prepare for this heart-wrenching retelling of a tragic part of our history.
Releases Feb. 1st. I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I thought this sounded like an intriguing story. I have had the opportunity to read the other books in the series. I was impressed with the strong character development, the historical research and the enduring faith and hope each story portrayed. Each of the stories are standalone and address a different period of time, circumstances and historical events. This story is about a young Sioux woman who, after her parents died, was sent back east and eventually graduate with a nursing degree. She is then sent back to the reservation, which her only family still reside, to work among her people. The beginning of the story, in my opinion, read like a daily journal. I enjoyed the story as a whole but I thought it was a little bit dull and found myself skimming through quite a bit of it. The characters were lacking in charisma, and the actual deadly attack at wounded knee was a minimal part of the overall story. All in all not a bad story, but I’ve read more captivating books. I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
March 1, 2026
This is one of the best stories I’ve read about an injustice to people. I found it hard to read at times but the truth hurts. People were mistreated because of their traditions and culture. Rose is definitely my favorite character because of her strong determination not to lose her roots. She hungers for the people she was sent away from and yearns to remember their language. I loved that she was willing to help others.
The book is rich in history and is evident of how the author did research to make it realistic. I could go on and talk about other characters but for me it is important for us to never forget what happened. Native Americans had no choice but to give up their land. As they tried to survive , they faced diseases that destroyed families. I like how we see the heart of Native Americans from their viewpoint which opens the eyes of those who didn’t know. The mention of a few very famous people in the book was a highlight and gave a nod to those who made a difference.
I received a copy of this book from Celebrate Lit. The review is my own opinion.
The book is rich in history and is evident of how the author did research to make it realistic. I could go on and talk about other characters but for me it is important for us to never forget what happened. Native Americans had no choice but to give up their land. As they tried to survive , they faced diseases that destroyed families. I like how we see the heart of Native Americans from their viewpoint which opens the eyes of those who didn’t know. The mention of a few very famous people in the book was a highlight and gave a nod to those who made a difference.
I received a copy of this book from Celebrate Lit. The review is my own opinion.
March 5, 2026
The Caregiver at Wounded Knee is written by Debby Lee. This is book 4 in the Enduring Hope Series. This series is written by a wonderful group of authors, but can be read as a stand alone. I am a huge fan when authors get together and write such a compelling series.
This book drew me in within the first few pages. Rose Rushing Water was taken from her home and placed in a residential school. She was later sent to school in Boston, and has returned to help as a nurse for the local white doctor. When she returns, she can feel the rising tensions. Her path crosses with Nathaniel Gray Cloud. Nathaniel is a local tribal policeman, and a Christian. Rose is struggling with the tensions and navigating the policies in place to be able to honor her culture.
I really loved these characters. I loved how accurate the era is. It’s a lesser known era to read, but the author has captured it beautifully. The book is well written, the storyline is engaging. Thank you to the author, publisher and Celebrate Lit for allowing me to read a copy of this book - all thoughts are my own.
This book drew me in within the first few pages. Rose Rushing Water was taken from her home and placed in a residential school. She was later sent to school in Boston, and has returned to help as a nurse for the local white doctor. When she returns, she can feel the rising tensions. Her path crosses with Nathaniel Gray Cloud. Nathaniel is a local tribal policeman, and a Christian. Rose is struggling with the tensions and navigating the policies in place to be able to honor her culture.
I really loved these characters. I loved how accurate the era is. It’s a lesser known era to read, but the author has captured it beautifully. The book is well written, the storyline is engaging. Thank you to the author, publisher and Celebrate Lit for allowing me to read a copy of this book - all thoughts are my own.
November 28, 2025
I couldn't help myself with this one. It was very good. I loved learning about Wounded Knee!
So well written that I finished it in the early morning hours. I loved Rose's story. I've gotten to know her and her family pretty well. I felt so sorry for her younger brother. Changes is so hard! Its hard to give up friends and the old ways.
Fear is the main culprit in this story. We often fear the unknown or what we do not understand. It keeps us from embracing the future. Time has a way of marching on whether we want it to or not. Im like Rose's brother. I do NOT like change. Its not easy.
I learned much about the Indians. Their way of life.
This was a wonderful story that I devoured in one sitting. I couldn't put it down until Rose's told me her story.
5 stars for keeping me interested all the way through.
I was NOT required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are mine.
Come back to your
So well written that I finished it in the early morning hours. I loved Rose's story. I've gotten to know her and her family pretty well. I felt so sorry for her younger brother. Changes is so hard! Its hard to give up friends and the old ways.
Fear is the main culprit in this story. We often fear the unknown or what we do not understand. It keeps us from embracing the future. Time has a way of marching on whether we want it to or not. Im like Rose's brother. I do NOT like change. Its not easy.
I learned much about the Indians. Their way of life.
This was a wonderful story that I devoured in one sitting. I couldn't put it down until Rose's told me her story.
5 stars for keeping me interested all the way through.
I was NOT required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are mine.
Come back to your
November 13, 2025
An absolutely beautifully written and narrated historical fiction about the Battle at Wounded Knee. During the time that this story takes place, the United States enters a very tumultuous time and the battles that take place throughout the country from the civil war to fighting over native land and sending their children off to schools to be "humanized". It's an absolutely devastating time and the mood is ever present in Rose's story. You can feel the pain that her family has gone through but she still cares for those she knows and those who are strangers to her.
I highly recommend this book to anyone who isn't familiar with this time in American History or is looking for a story that speaks to the soul in a truly profound way.
I would love to thank the author, publisher and NetGalley for giving me the opportunity to read to this book in exchange for an honest review.
I highly recommend this book to anyone who isn't familiar with this time in American History or is looking for a story that speaks to the soul in a truly profound way.
I would love to thank the author, publisher and NetGalley for giving me the opportunity to read to this book in exchange for an honest review.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 45 reviews