I think I liked the story of Hook, the second book of the Untold Stories of Neverland series better than the first book, Pan. This one tells a longer, more satisfying story of Archibald Jameson, a printer in London, and how he became the legendary pirate, Captain Hook. Once again Tinker Bell is the driving force behind the arrival of Jameson and his shipmates in Neverland, but we don’t see nearly as much of her in this book as we did in Pan.
Archibald begins as a basically nice man. He runs a print shop he inherited from his parents. It gives him a job, which is good, but he finds it boring. He longs for more adventure in his life. He begins to hear bells occasionally, and before long he finds himself taking refuge from a rainstorm in a tavern frequented by pirates. Before he knows what’s going on, he finds himself shanghaied aboard the ship the Queen Anne’s Revenge – captained by the infamous (real life) pirate, Edward Teach, more popularly known as Blackbeard. It’s not very obvious, but this turn of events seems to have been orchestrated by Tinker Bell, who appears to Archibald occasionally but mostly stays out of sight as many of the other pirates seem to regard her as a source of bad luck.
Most of the first half of the book details Archibald’s education in how to be a sailor and a pirate. With the help of his first friend, Harper, and the ship’s doctor, Smee, Archie quickly goes from being an embarrassed misfit to a useful member of the crew. When the pirates capture a merchant ship by the name of the Jolig Roger (Jolly Roger), Archie joins several of the other pirates as part of a crew to sail that ship. While the Jolig Roger is separated from the Queen Anne’s Revenge, they encounter another merchant ship, this one headed for Spain with a cargo of Indian slaves and capture it. Unfortunately, Blackbeard’s first mate who was put in charge of the Jolig Roger is killed in the encounter after naming Archie captain if anything should happen to him.
Archie befriends the one Indian who can understand him – a woman who acquires the name Tiger Lily.
After another adventure or two, Archie is sailing one night and encounters a sky full of stars he doesn’t recognize. Tinker Bell shows up again and points out the way he should go before disappearing again. Not long after, they find themselves approaching Neverland.
Neverland is nice for a day or two but is not where they want to be. They spend a very long time trying to find their way back to their own world with no success.
The pirates are terrible at hunting. Eventually, to have something to eat, they set the Indians free in exchange for their hunting skills.
Inevitably, they encounter Peter Pan, the Lost Boys, and Tic-Tock the crocodile.
Peter likes to play games. But he gets very upset if the game doesn’t go exactly as he envisioned it. Also, he resents having grown-ups on what he thinks of as his island. He sets up a trap in which to kill Archie’s friend, Harper. This ignites a blood feud. For his next trick, Peter sets up something like a scavenger hunt – with Tiger Lilly as the prize.
The ending is inevitable. But I didn’t like how both Archie – now Captain Hook – and Peter both became so hardened and vicious.