3.75 stars rounded up
If this is Elin Hildebrand's final book, I wouldn't say it ended with a bang, but more of a loud whimper.
Another ultimate beach read, again in Nantucket, where there's a possible murder mystery, drama around new islanders, friendships, forbidden romances, and the ultimate retirement of Ed Kapenash, Nantucket's everlasting chief of police.
Swan Song is a fun, however not as impactful as some of her other (Golden Girl, Hotel Nantucket) beach reads.
There were times were I cringed at Hildebrand's decision to pull in some of her younger readers with her choice of words:
"Kacy feels embarrassed that she’s never read Moby-Dick. Like all the other nurses on her unit, she reads Colleen Hoover."
"Then Coco heads into town—where finding parking is like an episode of Dude, You’re Screwed" (I have no idea what that means)
"Her sister is the biggest gossip on the island and anything Heather tells Sharon about Bull’s business will be all over Nantucket quicker than you can say Vanderpump Rules."
"I know this is the most overused phrase of our generation but… let’s do this.”"
And then there are of course the names of the characters: Celadon Morse (?!), Gryphon Dreck, Addison (who is a man), you get the idea.
Of course, we get to know Nantucket like we've never left, with the Chicken Box taking center stage:
"Back when Kacy and Isla used to talk about coming to Nantucket on vacation, Kacy imagined a weekend trip to the Vineyard—staying at the Charlotte Inn, hanging out at clothing-optional, Lucy Vincent Beach, drinks at Nancy’s, dinner at the Red Cat, dancing at the Ritz, breakfast at Morning Glory Farm."
There are plenty of eggs thrown in from her past books, names, faces, storylines that you will remember. It's like we've been taken on a 20 year ride to Nantucket, and I one, despite all of its flaws, hope the ferry keeps going.
"But she would have made Charles Darwin proud, the way she adapted to Nantucket life."