As a Whovian since (almost) birth, I don’t spend much time reading Who fiction. I did as a child and teenager, with books from my local library during those 90s Wilderness Years; I’ve forgotten almost all of them.
An unforgettable writer, however, is Robert Shearman, who got into recent media-fabricated 'hot water' when he was quoted as declaring the show ‘as dead as it’s ever been’. In the days since, the BBC have announced the show has a future from 2026 – that’s all well and good, but it’s obvious the show is in a bad place. Shearman’s fair point was that, for the first time, we don’t have a ‘current’ Doctor in any new media.
Instead, our new media for 2025 includes his novelisation of Jubilee; originally a 2003 audio drama starring Colin Baker as good ol’ Sixie, and Maggie Stables as Evelyn Smythe. It’s one of the greatest audios the show has. So great, in fact, it was adapted into the TV episode ‘Dalek’ in 2005, when the show returned and reintroduced its iconic villain to audiences old and new for the first time since 1988.
Us lucky fans; Shearman wrote the ‘Dalek’ Target novelisation, published in 2021. Having read it a few weeks ago, I gave it 5 stars for sheer enjoyment. This is because Shearman is a great, natural writer; anyone who’s read his short story series ‘We All Hear Stories in the Dark’ can tell you. Shearman gets dark in his material, mostly around human nature. Jubilee is no exception.
What makes a Doctor Who novel great? Sure, you’ve got to get the Who part right. But this is subjective in fandom. Much of the writing around Who since the 90s has been about creating and expanding on a lore, an expanded universe – I’m far less interested in that. Doctor Who on TV was always best as an anthology series, telling different stories – sometimes a historical, sometimes a soft fantasy, sometimes a harder sci-fi. What Shearman does is tell a dark tale with soft science fiction elements around the characters and world of Doctor Who.
Jubilee is primarily about the darkness of human nature, and English arrogance, and reactionary sexism, and historical mythologising. It’s also about the Dalek – the absolutist hating, racist, and genocidal alien civilisation. Human societies can, as we know, become the Dalek in real life; after all, it was invented in the 1960s as a very conscious stand-in for Nazism. It’s also about the Doctor – why he travels with companions, why he interferes in events, and how the consequences of that interference are not always heroic or good. Because that is the nature of time travel – interrupting and interfering with lives and societies. It’s also about Evelyn, a character I knew very little about despite the audios, but whom Shearman imbues with a deep but conflicted passion for academic History – and how time travel itself interferes with that core part of her identity.
Shearman writes a dedication to the late Maggie Stables, and to Colin Baker – whom he calls the best Doctor to write for. I can see why. For a long time, the Sixth Doctor was my least favourite (not these days). That style of 80s-Who during his run is just not for me; but the BBC also treated Colin rather abysmally at the time. His tenure was remarkably short and controversial – attempting to strangle his companion in his first story is perhaps a lesser crime, however, than his costume. With decades of audio dramas, however, Colin’s Sixie has built upon essentially an almost-blank canvas, and become the greatest Doctor on audio alongside Paul MacGann’s Eight.
Shearman writes this Sixth Doctor as a conflicted, and slightly tragic, figure; this story feels like his darkest hour. It’s hard to place this Doctor in that context while also picturing his insanely eye-sore costume, but Shearman even addresses this more than once. And it works - Shearman writes the Sixth Doctor exactly as he should be written. In media beyond television and in my imaginings, Colin Baker's Doctor is one of my favourite characters in the Whoniverse, and Evelyn is the perfect companion for him.
It leaves me to say that no one writes the Daleks better than Shearman. With him it’s not the ‘villain of the week’; it’s not a lazy stand in for any old baddie. The Dalek is a philosophy of hatred and purity and taking orders and murder as its primary function. Telly viewers of ‘Dalek’ got some of this too, but Jubilee takes it to more engrossing and deeper level.
And what of the English Empire, with its banned contractions and oppression of women and subjugation of the Earth, and it’s obsession with the Daleks and the Doctor as the twin foundations of its civilisation? Read and find out.
Isn’t this nerdy? Doctor Who as literature!? Well, with Robert Shearman we get excellent fiction and great Doctor Who all in one. Next up: The Chimes of Midnight (2025)!