Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book
LIVE

Nominee for the 2026 Goodreads Choice Awards

Vote for this book, or another nominee in Readers' Favorite Historical Fiction.

Whale Harbor

Rate this book
Même dans l'Irlande des années 1960, où les familles nombreuses sont monnaie courante, le clan des Joyce et ses onze fils sortent du lot. Mary, la mère, élève tant bien que mal les garçons tandis que Cathal, le père, producteur illicite de poitín, disparaît souvent pendant des jours entiers. Tous savent déjà que les enfants devront un jour quitter leur Cuan, une crique enclavée entre mer et montagne, dans l'espoir de trouver un emploi.


Lorsque Mary meurt brusquement, c'est au deuxième fils, Macdara, qu'il revient de s'occuper des plus jeunes. Du moins avant que son père ne prenne des mesures radicales, en commençant par se remarier. Pour Mac, qui se voit offrir une place dans un ranch du Montana, où la vie pourra enfin se conjuguer au singulier, il faut alors rompre une promesse : celle faite à Ryan, son cadet, de ne jamais l'abandonner...


Avec cette ballade, Mary Beth Keane nous offre un grand roman de l'exil et des liens du sang. Du Connemara à New York, dans une fresque à la fois épique et intime, elle excelle à raconter la fragilité du bonheur, les loyautés, les trahisons. Et ce que signifie faire famille sans pour autant renoncer à soi.

338 pages, Kindle Edition

First published October 20, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Mary Beth Keane

5 books3,861 followers
Mary Beth Keane attended Barnard College and the University of Virginia, where she received an MFA. She was awarded a John S. Guggenheim fellowship for fiction writing, and has received citations from the National Book Foundation, PEN America, and the Hemingway Society. She is the author of five novels, including ASK AGAIN, YES, which was a New York Times Best Seller and was translated into twenty-two languages. Her new novel, WHALE HARBOR, is forthcoming November 3, 2026.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
2,262 (51%)
4 stars
1,678 (38%)
3 stars
357 (8%)
2 stars
49 (1%)
1 star
40 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 630 reviews
Profile Image for Shelley's Book Nook.
671 reviews2,631 followers
October 26, 2026
My Reviews Can Also Be Found On:
The Book Review Crew Blog


Whale Harbor by Mary Beth Keane
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Whale Harbor
Mary Beth Keane
Publication Date: October 20th, 2026
Simon & Schuster Canada | Scribner
352 Pages
Amazon | Barnes & Noble | Bookshop.org
Genre: General Fiction | New Adult

This book was epic. I love multigenerational stories so much—there is lots of family dramarama in this one, and it is inspired by Mary Beth Keane's own family. The book is set in 1960s Ireland. It starts off with the devastating death of the mother of a family with eleven boys. The father is left to make the difficult choice of sending the older kids to England to work, while he keeps the younger ones with him. The second oldest is Macdara, and he is essentially the main character. Macdara decides to get a job on a ranch in Montana, and before he leaves, his younger brother, Rian, asks to go along. Macdara decides he will send for his younger brother when he is a bit older, but that promise never gets a chance to come true because Rian mysteriously disappears.

The story is told over a fifty-year span and goes from Ireland to England, Montana, and Whale Harbor, New York, in America. In a word, I would call this book a masterpiece. What I took away from it all was that no matter how far away we are from our family, they are still the ties that bind. The characters in this book were written so well—they were clear and defined, and I never once mixed them up. I think that's because the author had real-life individuals to base them on. They're so authentic and their personalities shine through. The atmosphere of the different locations was not lost on me either; I could picture them all in my head very clearly in minute detail.

When I give a book five stars, it is usually because of the feeling the book brought out in me, and this was no different. From the loss of the mother to the dad having those tough decisions to make, the boys leaving, and then Rian disappearing, I was so emotional while reading this. There was so much loss, but I could also feel the love. I have Ask Again, Yes on my shelf, and I cannot wait to get to it. I also can't recommend this book enough. If you enjoy literary works of fiction with heart and soul, this is the book to get. I won't soon forget it because it was poignant, deeply moving, and beautifully written. All. The. Stars.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC.



Goodreads ratings reflect reader demographics and
popular enthusiasm rather than objective literary merit.
Profile Image for Canadian Jen.
728 reviews3,899 followers
November 10, 2026
A family splintered as a tragedy befalls them in a small village in Ireland in the 1960's. 11 close brothers scattered. The two oldest sent abroad to locate work. Leaving them behind is a hardship for Macdara, the 3rd eldest. The thought of his 9 year old brother broke his heart when he left. Hoping to have him travel to the U.S in a couple of years to join him was the plan. Instead, Rian, ran away at 13. Now years later, all the brothers continue to try to find out through their Irish connections what happened to him.
The experiences of family so vastly different - from the older group to the younger. A father whose behaviour was difficult to reconcile.

Keane establishes an Irish brotherhood so dense with love for each other and the grief that comes with loss and regret. Her writing is compelling as it spans across decades, countries and these flawed characters. A story that takes us from Dublin, to Montana, to NY.
Whales being the Irish connection. 🍀
5⭐️
My first by Keane and need to get to her back list!
Profile Image for Karen.
821 reviews2,222 followers
September 6, 2026
This was a story inspired by the author’s own family.
A beautiful and epic story that starts in 1963, Ireland…and we follow an Irish family with 11 brothers.
When tragedy befalls them, the family falls apart and big decisions are made, with consequences that last for decades.
This book follows all of them until 2002.
350 pages and I wish it had been even that much longer.
It’s a character driven story and emotional.
I really loved it.
Profile Image for Angela M .
1,536 reviews2,099 followers
November 7, 2026
“All happy families are alike; each unhappy family is unhappy in its own way." Tolstoy from Anna Karenina

This is a moving story of eleven Irish brothers over nearly five decades shaped by the hard life in the small town where they are born, by grief, grudges and choices made for them by their father. Tolstoy might have said the same thing about them. But even in their unique unhappiness and happiness, these brothers know the meaning of family and love even if not spoken of to each other. They are brothers and that’s what matters.

From Cuan An Mhil, Mhoir, to Montana, and New York , the complicated lives of these complex characters had a hold on me . Heartbreaking decisions made by their father in the face of loss separating the brothers drive them to move forward with their lives, bringing them together, with the exception of one who runs away at nine years old and is estranged from the family for decades . His disappearance will haunt them, but their lives go on until they face the loss and remorse over taking decades to find him as well as a way to see their father in a different light. In spite of so many characters, Mary Beth Keane brilliantly allows the reader to know all of them. A captivating story based on the author’s own family. One of my favorites of the year.


Profile Image for Melissa (Always Behind).
5,314 reviews3,312 followers
October 29, 2026
This is a deeply moving family saga focusing on Macdara, the second oldest of eleven boys in the Joyce family. Keane's prose and characterization is top notch. She knows how to write characters with emotional depth and make them seem real and alive, flaws and all. I was immersed in this story and could relate to it as my maternal grandfather went through some similar situations with his family while growing up in Kansas.

The story begins in 1960s Ireland, in a very small town where most people speak Irish and it feels as if it is long ago. The Joyce family is getting ready to welcome their 11th child. Once this child is born, it's almost time for Macdara to leave home, as his oldest brother did before him. Yet tragedy strikes and this causes changes no one could have predicted. Over the next years, we follow Macdara to the US to Montana, then to New York as he makes a life for himself in America.

It is so difficult to capture the essence of this book in a short paragraph. There's so much depth to this story. The family ties, the broken and hurting people, and the ways that they can overcome or sadly succumb to the loss and setbacks in life. It's a story of true resilience and overcoming obstacles. The ending of this story left me a bit unsettled, but it was so realistic rather than tying things up into a nice neat bow. I have to give the author props for leaving a bit open ended.

This isn't an easy read, but it's definitely a worthwhile read. Keane has really established herself as a master storyteller with this novel.

I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book, all opinions are my own.
Profile Image for DeAnn.
1,912 reviews
October 21, 2026
5 Engrossing Family Stars

I loved this family-centered story, based on the author’s own family story. Set in Ireland, Montana, and New York and spanning several generations, this is the kind of story I love.

A poor Irish family with 11 sons faces tragedy in the 1960s. The sons are sent in different directions: some to England for work, some to the US, and some to a Catholic boarding school.

I really liked the second oldest son, Macdara, and his journey. He’s invited to join a friend on a ranch in Montana. His affinity with horses makes him a good fit for the ranch. Mac hates leaving his younger brother, Rian, behind. At only 9, Rian couldn’t leave home yet. Mac plans to save enough money to bring all of his brothers over for better opportunities and a better life.

Mac eventually joins some other brothers in New York. I loved how they built family connections in a new country, and of course, New York has a huge Irish community. Later, Mac learns that Rian ran away, and no one has known where he’s been for years. Mac is plagued by guilt.

This one has strong themes of family, loyalty, and faith, and I loved getting to know Mac and later his wife and daughters. It was fascinating when various family members would return to Ireland. Everything seemed so different after years away, but it also felt like coming home. I loved reading about traditional Irish life in coastal Connemara. And whales play a part in the story!

This is my third book by author Mary Beth Keane, and I’ve rated each one five stars. She clearly works for me! I can’t wait to read what she writes next.

My thanks to Scribner for the opportunity to read this one and provide an honest review. This one is now available.
Profile Image for Liana Gold.
631 reviews595 followers
November 10, 2026
There is a fine line between living and surviving. Forgiveness is the string that holds them in place.

This is a poignant, reflective novel about the choices we make in life and the lasting consequences of broken promises.

1963. Ireland.
A large family of 11 sons is trying to stay afloat. The mother dies post last birth and the son's father makes some decisions that scatters the entire family. At the heart of the novel, we have Mac, a sixteen year old son who leads the narrative.

This book easily turned into one of my favorites. No wonder I had a hard time voting in the historical fiction section because all the books were amazing. I have so much to say! I couldn’t put this down. I loved the literary parts of this family saga and the symbolism of 'whale' in the story. Emotional complexity is top notch and this book feels like a real family. I was blown away by the emotional attachment I formed to the Irish brothers. The writing is superb. Keane writes with such quiet, psychological sophistication. It's tender yet feels like a calm before the storm. The way Keane draws out the emotional restraints, its one of the novels greatest strengths in my opinion. This is a first for me by this author and I will be sure to read some of her previous novels.


Expanded review to follow. 💛
Profile Image for Tracy Hansen.
855 reviews54 followers
November 3, 2026
Whale Harbor will be my 2026 Book of the Year!

My 97th read of the year and it held everything I could possibly want from a book. Irish, family drama, emotive.

It starts in Ireland with a band of 11 brothers. An emotional family saga that pulls you in right from the first chapter, it is told from the perspective by one of the sons, Macdara Joyce. The book begins with the chaos brought on when that many ruly boys live in a small house; but then a tragedy befalls them that sets them all on different courses. The setting eventually takes us to Montana and New York, when some of the older brothers emigrate. The struggle with immigration and the starting of the new life comes with its own complexities. The pull between the home you were born to, and the home you now have, is something that I relate to all too well.

There were moments that made me emotional and nostalgic. In the next chapter there would be something that would make me laugh and think …my Granda and Gran said those exact words. You can tell that the author based this on her own parents true story, that were from West Ireland.

This may not hit everyone the same way that it hit me, however I foresee it being one that many will enjoy, and grow to love the characters.

“One little decision, one single choice, and you end up with a completely different life.”
Profile Image for Jill.
470 reviews120 followers
October 30, 2026
WHALE HARBOR
By Mary Beth Keane

A Moving Story of Family, Loss, and Brotherhood

Whale Harbor is an insightful look at eleven brothers growing up in a rural area of western Ireland in the 1960s and what happens when tragedy strikes their family. Loosely based on the author’s father’s family, the story explores the bonds of brotherhood, family, and the lasting impact of loss.

As the older siblings leave for the States, the younger brothers remain in Ireland. Thirteen-year-old Rian struggles with being left behind by Mac, the older brother he looks up to. When Rian disappears, the family is left haunted by what happened, but it is Mac who carries the greatest guilt.

The writing is beautifully descriptive and emotionally engaging, bringing the Irish setting and characters to life. This is a character-driven story focused on family relationships, told at a leisurely pace as we follow the brothers through decades of changes, hardships, and personal struggles.

I loved the journey of this family over the years and was genuinely moved by the lives of these very ordinary people.
Profile Image for Liz.
3,088 reviews3,965 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 1, 2026
Mary Beth Keane uses her own family’s story as the basis for Whale Harbor. It’s the 1960s in rural Ireland. When their mother dies, their father makes arrangements for how to take care of his 11 sons, from older teens down to 5 weeks old. We follow them down the various paths their lives take them.
The story is told primarily through the eyes of Mac, the second oldest boy and still at home. The area holds no job prospects, so it’s a given each boy will leave when he comes of age. He, at least, finds a way to go to Montana where he has a close friend.
The heartbreak surrounds 9 year old Rian. Old enough to truly remember his mother and not willing to accept his father’s new wife, he’s too young to go elsewhere. Mac had promised Rian he wouldn’t leave him, but he does. Rian disappears at age 13 and can’t be found. Throughout the decades, this haunts Mac, who continues to try and find Rian.
Given the story starts with 11 brothers and they go on to marry and have children, there are a lot of characters to keep track of. At times, various social events become prominent in the story. I developed a special fondness for Mac’s daughter, Mary, a true renegade.
It was an interesting story but it never quite gripped me. I always felt at a bit of a remove, maybe because of the large time period covered and the sheer number of characters.
My thanks to Netgalley and Scribner for an advance copy of this book.
Profile Image for Dorie  - Cats&Books :) .
1,242 reviews3,947 followers
November 8, 2026
I really enjoyed this family drama but I’d describe it more as character studies of Macdara and his father, Cathal.

The novel is told from the POV of the second oldest of the 11 brothers, Macdara. I thought the novel started off strong with its description of the small town in rural Ireland. Mac’s father is the postman in the town so the family always had enough to eat and a roof over their heads. He also supplemented his income with his own version of “moonshine”.

The beginning is quite happy as the brothers grow up without many constraints and surrounded by the beautiful sea. Their mother works hard and manages to keep them fed and clothed. I was amazed to find that the time was 1960 as it felt decades earlier in the telling when I compared it with 1960 in the US!! The town still had no electricity; turf was burned for cooking and heating and education wasn’t the main priority for children.

After tragedy strikes, Cathal makes some decisions as to what will become of the family. The decisions he makes will mark the beginning of the exodus of the brothers to the United States.

As in all of Ms. Keane’s novels, the writing is poetic. Speaking to his future wife : “His whole history, and hers, and everyone who came before them was there in the room with them for a moment, he could feel it. It often felt as if a chasm existed between his old life and this one and yet a square of lace had brought them right next to each other for a moment.”

I did feel that the middle slowed down and took a while to get going again. I was glad that I continued - I enjoyed how the family comes back together which is testament to brotherly love and the ties that bind you to “home”.

This is a great read just be prepared for some slow going at times. The descriptions of Ireland, Montana and New York city are great and I could picture it all!!

I received an ARC of this novel from the publisher through Edelweiss. It was my pleasure to read and review this title.


Profile Image for Stephanie.
547 reviews210 followers
October 23, 2026
A story that spans decades about an Irish family, the Joyce’s, growing up in a world of 11 boys, through immigration, new families, lost loved ones, and answered and unanswered questions.
I can already see why people will not like this book, especially the ending. I have to see why the author chose to go this route as it’s completely not what you’re going to expect.

I really enjoyed this family literary drama.
Profile Image for Mary Keane.
Author 5 books3,861 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
December 15, 2025
Unbiased review
Profile Image for Debbie H.
270 reviews105 followers
November 13, 2026
5⭐️

I loved this multigenerational story of family, love, loss, and choices. It spans the 1960’s to present starting in Ireland to Montana to NY.

The Joyces are a large family with 11 sons in Connemara. When tragedy strikes, the 11 sons are each given a different path chosen by Cathal their grieving father.

Macdara immigrates to Montana and leaves behind a younger brother, 9 year old Rian,who begs to go with him. Mac’s choice to leave him behind haunts him for the next several decades. The entire family yearns for their missing brother.

Focusing on Mac and his choices and family, we see glimpses into the brother’s lives and struggles as they navigate the world in the US.

Based loosely on the author’s own family history, I really loved the character driven story, the settings and the perfect ending.
Profile Image for Lisa (NY).
2,378 reviews885 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
May 8, 2026
[4+] I fell under the spell of Keane's new novel about a large Irish family from the opening page to the last line. Told from the perspective of Macdara Joyce, the second eldest of 11 brothers, it spans several decades and moves from Ireland to Montana to New York. I loved the way the relationships between the brothers informs and enriches and complicates their lives. Wonderful.
Thank you to Scribner Books for sending me the ARC.
Profile Image for Katie B.
1,913 reviews3,212 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
September 28, 2026
Thank you Scribner for the free copy!

This summer I finally got around to reading ASK AGAIN, YES by Mary Beth Keane and loved it. So my hopes were high for her newest book, WHALE HARBOR. Thankfully, it did not disappoint. Both novels share some similar themes but they both stand on their own feet. Each one left an emotional imprint.

I don’t want to give away too much of the plot. It’s a family saga that begins in 1960s Ireland. Eleven sons in one family. That’s a lot of mouths to feed. The older brothers are sent off to work while the younger ones stay behind. The story spans decades as the family deals with loss, grief, love, trauma, regret, you name it.

The way things are setup you form an emotional attachment to these kids early on. You feel their hurt and pain. The tough choices break your heart. A story like this works because you follow this family for so many years, and see the highs and lows. Being a witness to their journey was special and the final chapters remained true to these characters.

Add this one to your tbr list if you love family sagas.
Profile Image for Liz Hein.
550 reviews711 followers
July 12, 2026
Welp, thought I was making it through without 😭 but that dang last page 😭🥹🐳
Profile Image for Lee-Ann.
366 reviews35 followers
Review of advance copy
November 2, 2026
I have been a fan of this author since she captivated me with Ask Again, Yes. This is a multigenerational family drama that spans about 50 years, loosely based on Mary Beth Keane’s own family history, which she delves into in the afterword. Eleven brothers are fighting to make a life for themselves in Ireland at a time when work is scarce and the economy is in shambles. A tragedy scatters them across Ireland, England and America, and one brother eventually goes missing, running away from a home life he can no longer tolerate. The others look for him for decades, hoping he is ok, and wallowing in their guilt.

I love a book that teaches me something, and while I’ve read plenty of novels set in Ireland, none has given me quite this perspective on life in its more rural communities. The story begins in the 1960s, but honestly, the way the villagers of Cuan live, you’d think we were in 1860. The poverty, the isolation, the traditions, the suffocating influence of the Church - it all paints a picture of a world that feels impossibly far removed from modern life.

It also made me profoundly grateful to be a modern woman, free to live outside the control of religion and the expectation of endless baby-making. As a “good Irish Catholic,” Mary is 44 and about to give birth to her ELEVENTH child. ELEVEN. At 44.

No thank you. No thank you at all. In fact, NO THANK YOU.

All joking aside, this is a fascinating look at family, faith, obligation, and the ways the circumstances we're born into can shape the lives we lead.
Profile Image for Shantha (ShanthasBookEra).
747 reviews141 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
October 9, 2026
"From New York Times bestselling author of the “magnificent” (Fresh Air), “propulsive” (People), and “profound” (Vogue) Ask Again, Yes, a sweeping multigenerational saga inspired by the author's own family history, following eleven brothers as they are set on different paths between Ireland, England, Montana, and New York."

1960s rural Ireland in the wake of tragedy causes the older brothers to leave the house for work and school. Two to England and Macdara to work on a Montana cattle ranch. While in Montana, Macdara receives the news that his younger brother Rian has gone missing. This fracture in the family echoes across generations.

In Whale Harbor, Keane captures the essence of family and the bonds of brotherhood and community. The grief and longing are palpable as are the joyous moments of their lives. The challenges and opportunities of immigration and leaving home are beautifully shown. Forgiveness and unconditional love are my favorite part of the story. Tender, immersive and beautifully written, this is a magnificent family saga with unforgettable characters. Highly recommend this moving novel!

Many thanks to Scribner and Mary Beth Keane for the gifted advance reader's copy. All opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Louis Muñoz.
404 reviews226 followers
May 31, 2026
2.5 stars. So, once upon a time, I discovered Mary Beth Keane, specifically, "Ask Again, Yes." This was during the early days of lockdown, spring of 2020, and I fell in love with that book. Broke me and also gave me so much hope. I ended up re-reading the book about 1.5-2 years later for a book club, and it still resonated deeply. "The Half Moon" came along, and while I thought it was a good book, it didn't really move me much, yet I had high hopes for whatever came along next. And while "Whale Harbor" is in many ways a good book, a solid enough read and one I would recommend to many others, both as a librarian and as a reader, the book honestly didn't say as much to me as I was hoping it would, certainly nowhere near as much as "Ask Again, Yes" shared with me.

I only finished the book last night, less than 12 hours ago, so hopefully I can share more clearly upon further reflection. All I can say for now is that there was no clear drama for me, so I never felt fully invested in the lives of the characters?
Profile Image for Dem.
1,297 reviews1,508 followers
November 16, 2026
I really enjoyed Whale Harbor by Mary Beth Keane.
What stood out to me most was the unmistakable Irishness of the story and how brilliantly the author captured a true sense of time and place.
Starting in a small fishing village in Connemara in 1963, the setting feels completely authentic and lived-in, anchoring the entire novel as a single tragedy scatters a family of eleven brothers across Ireland, England, Montana, and New York. Even as the timeline stretches across decades and continents, that distinct Irish heart and atmosphere never fade.
Despite having a massive cast of characters on paper, the story really only follows a few of the brothers closely throughout the book. This keeps the narrative intimate and makes it very easy to follow, allowing their shared history, guilt, and loyalty to feel deeply moving. While the pacing slows down a little as it winds through the years—keeping it just shy of five stars for me—it is an engrossing, atmospheric read that stays with you long after the final page.
Profile Image for Aardvark Book Club.
96 reviews747 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
November 4, 2026
Whale Harbour is an immigration story that reads like an epic; at once sweeping and specific, it offers little slice-of-life moments alongside a grand intergenerational saga of love, family, and belonging.

The novel offers compelling reflections on language, culture, and experience: how the way you grew up might influence who you are, or “how the way you speak might impact the way a person thought.” For example: in English, you say you’re happy or sad, whereas in Irish, the translation is more like “sadness is upon me.” As a benevolent anthropologist explains, “In Irish you don’t entirely become that emotion…Americans talk about happy as if it’s a country, like it’s a place you can go and decide to stay. But it’s only a feeling. It comes and goes like all feelings.”

Whale Harbour is the gorgeous, gripping story of eleven brothers and their divergent paths: from emigrating to England to moving to America, to one of them disappearing and haunting the family for generations to come. It also considers the paths not taken, the agony of potentiality; Macdara reflects, after moving to Montana to work on a cattle ranch, what it might have been like to remain in Ireland. “Somewhere in his mind, that life existed alongside this one…Was that his real life? Or was this? Or was real life still in the future?”
Profile Image for Meagan (Meagansbookclub).
940 reviews8,381 followers
October 23, 2026
Without doing the audiobook, I can almost guarantee I would have DNF. The first 20% caught my attention and I was almost positive this would be a 5-star book. However, between 30-80% nothing happened. All day to day happenings. It was monotonous and draining. Just dragged and dragged on. The last 15% helped piqued my interest again, but by then, there was just no way to make up for the dragging storyline.

Appreciate her rich writing and ability to handle lots of characters, but the plot was just an absolute dud.
Profile Image for Heather~ Nature.books.and.coffee.
1,314 reviews297 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
May 4, 2026
Mary Beth Keane has such a talent for creating family stories that just really grabs you. I absolutely loved ASK AGAIN YES, and this one is just as good. If you like tender family sagas, you will definitely want to add this to your list. We follow a family of eleven brothers , beginning in 1960’s Ireland, the family struggles through hardships and moves abroad to take care of their needs. This multigenerational story pulled at my heartstrings. Truly interesting and captivating story.

Thank you to the publisher and netgalley for the gifted copy. All opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Flannery Buchanan.
135 reviews13 followers
March 2, 2026
This is my kind of book. Emotional family saga, exploring grief, family and the passage of time. Rich in detail made it atmospheric. I felt the same emotional pull to Ireland while reading & watching Brooklyn. I am so excited for people to read this.
Profile Image for Brenna.
221 reviews
March 29, 2026
I’m not normally one for historical fiction, but this one was superb.
Profile Image for Shannon.
57 reviews
June 13, 2026
This book was a masterpiece in capturing the Irish immigrant experience. It not only showed the story through the eyes of those that left, it also showed the impact on the people left behind, and on the subsequent generations born abroad. This isn’t just a sweeping multi-generational saga. It is the story of the lives those families lived and all of the joy, wonder, hardship, grief and loss that they encountered.

What makes this story so moving is how the author captures so many poignant cultural touchstones that will hit home with anyone who has this experience in their family history. She also eloquently weaves into the story how changing times and newer technologies changed people’s lives and attitudes as well. I flew through this book and was sorry to see it end. I hope there is a next generation sequel when Mary returns to Ireland with her father again and with her own children in tow.

Thank you to NetGalley and Scribner Books for the advanced copy for review consideration. All opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Mary Lins.
1,188 reviews175 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
July 14, 2026
Fans of Mary Beth Keane are going to be thrilled with her new novel, “Whale Harbor”, which is un-put-downable; during the final 40 pages I held my breath - completely immersed in the action.

Set in an Irish-speaking town in Connemara, Ireland, beginning in 1963, Keane tells the story of the Walsh family. Father Cathal is a postman and an illegal whiskey distiller. Mother Mary has just given birth to her eleventh son when a dead whale washes up in the harbor of their costal town. It’s a huge fin whale, attracting scientists from all over.

Our protagonist is Macdara (Mac) the second eldest of the boys. While Mac is smart, he’s had to leave school to help support the family. His older brother is already in England working; Mac and eventually all his brothers will have to leave Ireland to find work.

Mac makes a promise he can’t keep – not to leave his nine-year-old brother Rian behind when he goes. Leaving Rian with his gruff father Cathal has lasting consequences.

What follows is the story of this fascinating family over the course of the next 40 years, and it is completely compelling! Mac first emigrates to a ranch in Montana where he proves to have a talent with horses. Gradually the other brothers find their way to America and attempt to build the kind of hard-working middle-class “American Dream” lives that Keane is so adept at writing about.

Full of incredible sorrow along with heartwarming hope, I think this is Keane’s best work yet! You won’t want to miss it!

Many thanks to Scribner for an advanced look at this unforgettable family novel.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 630 reviews