What do you think?
What Pay Costs: The Science of Pay, Incentives, Bonuses, Salaries, Equity Compensation, Motivation, and Performance: Moving Compensation Forward. Without Holding People Back
224 pages, Paperback
Published October 7, 2025
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 1 of 1 review
April 21, 2026
First off, James A. Seechurn delivers a tremendous amount of value to the compensation field. If you're not following him on LinkedIn or listening to his podcast, stop what you're doing and follow him. Additionally, this review is on the audiobook and not the printed version. However, if you have never heard James speak before, you are in for a treat. He does an excellent job narrating his own work, which made the experience even more engaging.
Now for the actual review. There are a few reasons I stopped short of giving it five stars, but I can easily see why many readers would.
First, if you are new to compensation, this book is a must-read. It provides a strong overview of the field and pulls together an impressive range of studies that have shaped compensation practice and will likely continue to influence it in the future. This is the kind of book you keep nearby and return to throughout your career.
Second, there are not many books that tackle compensation the way this one does. What makes it stand out is its focus on incentives, psychology, and how pay actually influences motivation and performance. Even experienced compensation practitioners will likely find themselves challenged by the ideas in this book and pushed to think differently about how pay is designed within their own organizations.
At the same time, that strength is also part of why this was not quite a five-star read for me. While listening to the audiobook, I sometimes felt like I was moving quickly from one study to the next. Maybe I would have experienced it differently in print. Given James’s depth of experience, I found myself wanting more of his personal stories and practical reflections from the field. Research and lab experiments can point in one direction, but applying those ideas in real organizations is often far more complex.
That said, this book absolutely succeeds in making you think. It pushes you to reflect on a deeper question: are we treating people like cogs in a machine, or are we designing compensation in a way that supports both performance and intrinsic motivation?
Overall, this is a highly valuable book and one I would recommend to anyone serious about compensation.
Now for the actual review. There are a few reasons I stopped short of giving it five stars, but I can easily see why many readers would.
First, if you are new to compensation, this book is a must-read. It provides a strong overview of the field and pulls together an impressive range of studies that have shaped compensation practice and will likely continue to influence it in the future. This is the kind of book you keep nearby and return to throughout your career.
Second, there are not many books that tackle compensation the way this one does. What makes it stand out is its focus on incentives, psychology, and how pay actually influences motivation and performance. Even experienced compensation practitioners will likely find themselves challenged by the ideas in this book and pushed to think differently about how pay is designed within their own organizations.
At the same time, that strength is also part of why this was not quite a five-star read for me. While listening to the audiobook, I sometimes felt like I was moving quickly from one study to the next. Maybe I would have experienced it differently in print. Given James’s depth of experience, I found myself wanting more of his personal stories and practical reflections from the field. Research and lab experiments can point in one direction, but applying those ideas in real organizations is often far more complex.
That said, this book absolutely succeeds in making you think. It pushes you to reflect on a deeper question: are we treating people like cogs in a machine, or are we designing compensation in a way that supports both performance and intrinsic motivation?
Overall, this is a highly valuable book and one I would recommend to anyone serious about compensation.
Displaying 1 - 1 of 1 review