Pioneering forensic scientist, anatomist and anthropologist, Professor Dame Sue Black takes the reader into our criminal courts’ witness box from the perspective of an expert witness, the forensic scientist, explaining exactly what that job is, what it demands, how the role evolved, and its likely future.
The expert witness sits at the crux of the relationship between law enforcement, science and the legal system. When that relationship works well, it makes for compelling fiction, television and movies. When it works less well, it makes for compelling and explosive news headlines.
In An Expert Witness, Sue Black puts the relationship between these different institutions, and how they affect and are affected by the expert witness, under the microscope. Using shocking landmark cases that expose both the strengths and weaknesses of the interconnection between disciplines - she In which cases did we get it right? In which did we get it wrong? And if we had done it differently, might the pendulum of justice have swung another way?
Incisive and compelling, following the impact of advances in technology to changes in funding and the effect of our gladiatorial system, Sue Black tracks the journey of this most intriguing of sciences through to its inevitable conclusion - and the toll it may take not only on experts but ultimately how justice plays out.
Professor Dame Sue Black is one of the world's leading anatomists and forensic anthropologists. She is also the Pro-Vice Chancellor for Engagement at Lancaster University. She was the lead anthropologist for the British Forensic Team's work in the war crimes investigations in Kosovo and one of the first forensic scientists to travel to Thailand following the Indian Ocean tsunami to provide assistance in identifying the dead. Sue is a familiar face in the media, where documentaries have been filmed about her work, and she led the highly successful BBC 2 series History Cold Case.
DNF'd at 60%. It's not a bad book, but it was definitely not what I expected. I expected Dr. Sue Black to regale readers with fascinating anecdotes about how her knowledge as a forensic anthropologist helped to solve criminal court cases (and there is a little bit of this). I was expecting C.S.I. Instead, it is a VERY dense book that instructs potential expert witnesses in how to be a good expert witnesses. It does this through examining expert witness testimony in historical court cases and analyzing what was done well or not so well, with a lot of history of criminal investigative procedures. Unfortunately, I found it to be really dry and boring! I just couldn't keep my mind on what I was reading and finally gave up.
In the year ending September 2025, police in England and Wales recorded more than two million serious crimes. Most of these cases required some form of forensic involvement, whether from crime scene officers, forensic scientists, or other specialist experts, each contributing to the investigation from the crime scene to the courtroom.
In An Expert Witness: Forensic Science on Trial, Dame Sue Black, an internationally renowned forensic anthropologist with more than thirty-five years of experience giving expert evidence in UK and international criminal courts, explores the evolution of the forensic expert witness and their vital role within the justice system.
A forensic expert witness is a specialist who applies scientific expertise to legal investigations, analysing evidence and providing objective, evidence-based opinions for the courts. Their work spans several disciplines including forensic pathology, anthropology, toxicology, and digital forensics.
Drawing on fascinating historical and contemporary cases, Black examines both the strengths and limitations of forensic science and those who practise it. She explains the distinction between investigative evidence and probative evidence, showing how forensic science can eliminate suspects without necessarily identifying the offender. She also discusses the dangers of pseudoscience or “junk” science, and considers the opportunities and challenges that emerging technologies, including AI, may present for the future of the discipline.
Given the significant influence expert testimony can have on the outcome of a trial, forensic scientists must provide contextual, reasoned, and scientifically defensible interpretations of the evidence. Black reflects candidly on her own experiences in the witness box, describing the stress and frustration of enduring rigorous cross-examination that can challenge not only an expert’s qualifications and methodology, but also their personal credibility.
Taking a tone somewhere between a university lecture and an impassioned conversation, An Expert Witness is an interesting and thought-provoking read for anyone curious about forensic science and the law. I also think it would be a valuable resource for students entering the field, such as my daughter, who is currently completing her Master’s in forensic science.
One of the key conclusions I drew from An Expert Witness is that while forensic science is an invaluable tool in both criminal and civil investigations, no one should ever be convicted, or exonerated, on the basis of a single piece of scientific evidence. As Black demonstrates throughout the book, the use of forensic science in the courtroom is at its most powerful when it forms part of a broader body of evidence, interpreted with rigour, integrity, and appropriate caution.
I don’t know what it was about this latest book from Lady Sue Black that didn’t captivate me, but unlike her previous books, I found it a little boring if I’m honest. I’ve had it on my TBR ever since the release date was announced, excited to download it the moment I could, because I am so fascinated with this incredible woman and her phenomenal work In the field of forensic anthropology. However, I felt the emphasis was lost on facts about law, court cases, rules and regulations - when I’m sure the many more life experiences she could have shared with us would have been better received. As a Welsh woman, the section about the April Jones case was a revelation and very interesting, but the rest of the book was just lacking something for me. I still think this lady is an incredibly intelligent and inspiring woman, and she writes extremely well. I look forward to more from her in the future, but just hope it’s grittier.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I have always been fascinated with forensic science, the mystery behind crimes from analysis of corpses, evidence, the science behind every particular traces left behind in each crime scenes to piece together into a complete reconstruction of how, why, what and who in a criminal case. Probably because I was exposed to tv shows like CSI, Law and Order SVU, NCIS and other crime shows which have made me at some point wanting to go into the field of forensic science but alas I didnt for various reasons so I was excited for this one. I have heard a lot rave review on Sue Black's All that remains as she an expert im forensic anthropology lend her insight and depth into the field so I was expecting the same for this one
However, this turns out to be so dense and complex, very factual kind of book on the Expert witness in terms of being the expert present in the criminal trials and courts bringing their expertise combined with law enforcement to help cases. The book is very thick packef with a lot of information that at some point it dulls the reading since most of the books pointed out on the law aspect of an Expert witness rather than what I was expecting of understanding the science behind crimes so I found myself struggling the most to read this. It does deter my reading pace but I think now I have read this, I might go look for her first book cuz I think that will align to my interest more
Simply excellent! Everything you want to know about the what, the why and the how of forensic evidence can be found in the entertaining and well researched book by a renowned Scottish forensic scientist, Sue Black.
I confess I bought this book after finishing watching twenty-nine seasons of Silent Witness on BritBox. Love that show and its amazing characters. While my favorite character, Nikki Alexander, is a pathologist and the author is an anatomist and forensic anthropologist - you learn so much by reading books - they both want truth to prevail.
Black’s book rigorously follows a pattern - explaining the United Kingdom’s legal system and defining “expert” testimony to explaining the evolution of ways certain scientific - and pseudoscientific - techniques that advanced forensics. In explaining these, Black includes cases from the UK, US and Europe. These are especially interesting and show, for example, how blood spatter or finger prints evolved. I especially found the case where a young man in defending himself over a picture of his male genitalia not being his (he had to have pictures of his “at attention” - I love the British phrases - which proved he was innocent). Other cases like the Crippen and Dreyfus (document forgery) were more prominent in their day.
My one criticism was not giving credit for the discovery of the “double helix” (DNA) with Rosalind Franklin who saw it first before Crick and Watson. But in fairness on everything else this author was precise, clear and unfathomably truthful in her history, observations and concerns for the future of forensic science.
This is book for lovers of true crime or crime fiction. It takes you behind the scenes of how crimes can be solved. Reading this book with make a reader appreciate their crime book reads better.
*Thank you to Grove Atlantic for a complimentary copy of An Expert Witness. All opinions expressed are my own.*
Despite the amount of true crime and forensic non-fiction I’ve consumed over the years, I’ve somehow never come across any of Lady Sue Black’s writing before. And after finishing An Expert Witness, I find that fact slightly wild.
While the book starts off a little slowly, and I initially thought I was about to read a guide on how to be a good witness in court, it quickly turned into something that captivated my interest and held it right through to the final page. What I expected and what I ended up getting were two rather different things, and I’m very glad I stuck with it.
Black offers insight into aspects of both forensic science and the courtroom that I hadn’t previously considered, presenting them in a way that educates while still leaving room for the reader to reflect and form their own opinions. Her writing is wonderfully clear without ever feeling patronising or as though she’s simplifying the subject just to make it accessible. She trusts the reader to follow along, and I appreciated that immensely.
I was particularly captivated by the way Black doesn’t shy away from critiquing the systems she discusses. Rather than simply presenting information, she encourages you to question your own perceptions and form your own opinions as you contemplate the different topics. Her observations and concerns about the state and future of forensic science felt both truthful and important, and I found myself appreciating the depth and thought behind all she had to say.
For anyone looking to pick up a new true crime non-fiction read, I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend this one, especially if you’re interested in the academic side of the field. It’s an incredibly worthwhile read for anyone with an interest in forensics and the law, and I can’t wait to explore more of Sue Black’s work.
I really enjoy Sue Black's books. She doesn't patronise the reader and educates as we go. I thought it was a slow start - telling us all about the history of the expert witness which maybe was a bit more extensive than was necessary - but it was a fantastic read. There were things that I had never considered about being an expert witness - how difficult it is, how some legal teams are trying to catch you out and, even if you really are an expert, you can start questioning your own knowledge. She tells a story about a court experience that made her question her role in court and, actually, is no longer an expert witness. Court shouldn't be like that. She also discussed things that I found very interesting; if an 'expert' approaches the defence offering their services should that be entertained? Does that suggest that they aren't going to be neutral? Should an expert have been working in that field or 'expertise' relatively recently? Is ten years out of practise making them a current expert?
This one is different from other true crime books I have read, which tend to be less academic. I hadn't heard of this author before (perhaps I'm too into American TC content), but her style is captivating and very professional. She's a doctor so that's what I would expect. I learned a few things that were surprising to me and now I want to read her other books.
A great combination of science, criminal cases, history...and humor! Sue Black is a forensic anthropologist at Lancaster University. She knows what she is talking about, having had significant experience appearing in court in criminal cases in Great Britain and also working internationally on issues like the war crimes in Kosovo or to help identify the dead after a tsunami in Thailand. I had never heard of forensic anthropology before I read this book, but we have become accustomed to scientific experts in many fields appearing in court, so why not? Author Black does an excellent job of explaining what forensic anthropology is and giving fascinating examples of how it is used, most of them cases in which she herself participated. It was interesting to hear about both the cooperation and the conflicts among the various experts in a case and others involved such as the police or the judge. Since few readers would be familiar with her field, Black gives a lot of the science that is used, and I cannot remember the last time I read a book with so many new-to-me terms, like anthropometry or trichology, but she defines them for lay readers. This is a serious book, often a sad one as Black discusses criminal cases, but it gave me a lot of smiles, such as when she refers to the ‘f’ word--- forensic. There is even humor in some of the excellent quotes that are at the beginning of each chapter, like Mark Twain’s definition of an expert as someone from another town or science-fiction author Arthur C Clarke’s statement that, “For every expert, there is an equal and opposite expert.” I enjoyed the humor, and it made me wonder what her style is like on the stand! Black is from Great Britian, so the emphasis is on the legal system in England and Scotland, although she mentions other countries, including the United States. I learned some interesting information about similarities and differences, such as how court procedures work or the fact that juries in Scotland (but not England) have 15 members. Based on my reading of this book, I will be looking forward to reading her previous works and hope they will be equally enjoyable and informative! I received an advance review copy of this book from NetGalley and Grove Atlantic.
ARC review I don’t normally like to give ratings to non fiction just because of the nature of the book, so rating this one is purely based on the expansive knowledge given. This book is not about personal accounts of forensic medicine per se, but rather how forensic medicine fits in a courtroom. A British courtroom. Being non-British this was a full work up of knowledge for me since I am not familiar with the Crown or traditions or ways the UK court system works. Sue Black explains every portion of it. She explains her own use of forensic medicine in cases tried and in which she was an expert witness. She explains the full trial, the way suggestions by slick lawyers could impact a trail or result, as well as all the nuances of being an expert witness. It was not at all what I was expecting. This book should be a text book, it reads so packed with information that if you go in blind you are overwhelmed. I have zero doubts to Black’s brilliance, as it’s shown throughout, and the superior amount of information as well as backing stories and scientific support makes this a bit hard to absorb, though is a case study for future students of both forensics and law
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC!
What I imagine would be an irreplaceable text for those who engage in any kind of forensic science or expert witness work, this is a fascinating book that takes a lot of time to examine the courtroom context of forensics as well as the scientific backing.
Is it dense? Yes. Is it dense by design and with purpose? Absolutely yes. I was constantly excited by small titbits that I’d not previously known, and the information was presented in an excellent way that made for compelling reading. I do have a legal background so perhaps that fed into it for me, but I found the subject matter riveting.
I do think some of the text could have been laid out a little better, with a few more sections dedicated to explaining the material to the layman. With that said, I think this book has great value from the evidentiary perspective, and that is an excellent thing to have.
All in all, this was a wonderful read with a couple of small flaws, and I managed to enjoy a family gathering telling everyone about ear prints and their use in criminal cases in detail. What more could you want?
This is the third book and possibly the final one. This one is slightly different and is a mix of landmark cases where good and bad forensic science has been used and also her experiences of being a forensic witness. We hear of Sue Black’s own legacy to the field with her work on the defining marks of hands which has been widely accepted and instrumental in many cases. You can have a pictures of much scarred hands any time Sue!
It is a call of arms to the younger generation for more anatomists over forensic science graduates, and better science embracing new technologies, rigorous testing, better use of statistics, and more balanced expert witnesses and better court environments for them to discuss their findings.
Who knew that the life of an expert witness was so fraught? Holy cow! The abuse they suffer is astonishing and can ruin your career as well as shatter your nerves. Black does an excellent job of explaining the history and evolution of what we, today, think of as forensics. While occasionally a bit tedious, it is full of juicy mayhem. Well worth a read if you have any interest in this fascinating subject.
Fab ending but the start lacked what makes Sue Blacks other books so interesting/amazing which is a shame as I was super excited! (her first 2 would be an easy 5 star rating)
In An Expert Witness, forensic anthropologist Sue Black explores the evolving role of expert witnesses in the UK criminal justice system, drawing on her own experiences as forensic anthropology developed into a recognized field of expertise within the courtroom.
Rather than delving straight into the science of forensic evidence and the history of expert testimony, Black begins by exploring the challenges of establishing credibility as an expert witness. While they may have extensive knowledge and research behind their conclusions, that doesn’t necessarily mean their testimony will be accepted at face value. Black’s descriptions of the ways lawyers can attempt to undermine an expert’s credibility are cutthroat, making it clear that the job requires more than simply knowing the science. An expert witness must also be prepared to anticipate lines of questioning, navigate the expectations of the courtroom, and communicate their findings in a way that can withstand scrutiny.
I particularly enjoyed Black’s comparison of a court case to a theatrical production, with different stages of proceedings represented as acts and scenes and the various courtroom professionals as actors tackling their own roles. She balances historical accounts of notable expert witness cases with anecdotes from her own experiences on the stand, which gives the book a nice combination of historical context and personal insight.
However, I did find the book somewhat challenging to get through at times, though not necessarily because of the forensic terminology itself. Black generally does a good job explaining specialized terms and the science behind them, but the writing also incorporates a considerable amount of higher-level vocabulary that may be less familiar to readers outside of academia. Additionally, while each chapter is organized around a particular type of evidence, the individual case studies and narratives are sometimes overshadowed by lengthy explanations of the scientific principles and methods behind their analysis. This information is undoubtedly valuable, and Black’s decades of experience make her an incredibly knowledgeable guide, but the presentation occasionally feels more like a textbook than a pop history book. I suspect the book would be particularly well suited to an academic library or readers with an existing interest in forensic science and the criminal justice system rather than the general public library user.
Thank you to NetGalley, Grove Atlantic, and Sue Black for this advanced copy!
Lessons: - no one except a statistician should be allowed to give statistical advice or interpretation in court; - when looking for similarities in a pattern, always look for differences as well; - only large data sets can show whether your new sexy tool actually works - never claim 100% certainty - never go beyond your lane (I regularly see this on non fiction--books that begin with a history of something when the author knows very little about history; historians who start applying their ideas to periods and places beyond their specialism--fine if they have done the work, but often it's casual comments that make you go 'huh?') - the police want to solve a crime; the prosecution want a conviction, and the defence want an acquittal: none of them are actually focussed on truth. - the appeals court is rigged against the poor, the working class, the non white, the female.
I have no idea whether Sue Black wanted me to take these ideas away. The book is very complex.
One thing that did make me laugh was the many comments on the medical profession. I think it's becoming more and more of an open secret that doctors are absolutely crap at analysis, and aren't scientists. Those of us with chronic conditions regularly find ourselves dealing with ignorance and arrogance.
So here is my doctor + statistics story: In 1997, after years of illness variously misdiagnosed, and a rapid decline that year, a friend who had seen it before suggested I might have coeliac. I found a medical dictionary (no wikipedia in those days) and checked off the entire list, including things I hadn't even realised weren't normal.
I trotted along to the GP and requested a test. This is a quote, I will never forget it.
"Oh, you can't possibly have Coeliac, it's very rare." Followed by a comment about how it's hereditary and if no one else in the family had it, I couldn't possibly.
Me, in Historian: "You do realise that means someone has to have it?"
It won't surprise anyone reading today that the test came back positive because we now know it's not all that rare. Also that it turned out to be very common on one side of my family,
*Review of an ARC copy received from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review*
This book has pleasantly surprised me, in the best way possible. An Expert Witness is written and told by Sue Black, an outstanding forensic anatomist, a professor and at its core, a scientist. Through this book, Black communicated the history of forensic sciences, how forensic sciences are qualified as such and what it feels like to be in the courtroom, against people who are trying to undermine your professionalism, amongst other topics my fellow true crime and forensics enthusiasts will enjoy. Black told history of how forensics was built through past cases and quite... outstanding people who qualified themselves as professionals, shining a light on old cases with explanations of how each field progressed through centuries. One thing is very true - Black's writing can make you understand the topics in this book very well. I enjoyed how in detail she went, with credible sources and a sprinkle of humor in the placed where it felt right. She showed us that working in such field as hers is definitely not for the faint of heart and truly makes you think of not only the victims and injustice they can face in the courtroom, but of the professionals who can be attacked and harassed for simply doing their job. My respect for Sue Black goes a very long way for the work she has done for forensics and new methods she introduced for future scientists to fully adapt. She also showed us how human everyone is at the end of the day, and what toll it can take on you. Overall, this book was very informative, but easy to understand and very well communicated. Truly a great experience to dive into if youre trying to learn about the justice system, forensic sciences and all matters related.
I'm a fan of true crime and I like courtroom novels, so I thought this would be a great book for me. I liked the insight into what the traps are in testifying as an expert. It seems like a very difficult process where it is easy to make a mistake. I learned how the English court system works in a similar way to American courts, but is a little different. Sue Black is clearly very experienced in her field and this book was very comprehensive about the topic.
This is a well-written book, but it is very dense with instructions on how to be a good expert witness and also the history of all the types of evidence and how they became (or didn't become) usable in the British court system as evidence. I found that I needed to focus quite a lot while reading it. I really wanted to read this book because it seemed right up my alley, but in the end it was too technical and focused on old trials and evidence that didn't keep my interest. I tried to muddle through, but it was a DNF at 34%.
The court cases that were used as precedents for all different types of forensic evidence weren't interesting enough for me. Black goes back and describes each crime that led to the type of evidence, like hair analysis or proving that a person was poisoned by arsenic. The author describes cases going back centuries and very thoroughly details all the ways that the scientists and medical practitioners figured out how to make (or failed to make) their cases in court. This was all a bit too dull for me. I tried putting the book down and taking breaks, but I just didn't want to read any more because it required too much concentration and not enough enjoyment for my time spent.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me with an eARC in exchange for an honest review.
As a biochemist, I was particularly excited to read An Expert Witness. Forensic science was one of my favorite subjects at university and I was looking forward to reading about real cases and learning more about the practical application of forensic science in criminal investigations.
I anticipated more first-hand accounts from Sue Black's own career as a forensic anthropologist. While there are some fascinating glimpses into her work, the book focuses much more heavily on the history of forensic science and on analyzing the testimony and methods of expert witnesses involved in historical cases. Readers interested in the development of forensic science and the legal role of expert witnesses may find this aspect fascinating, but it wasn't what I had hoped for. Because Sue Black is often evaluating the work and decisions of other experts, the tone occasionally came across as more critical and judgmental than informative, which made it harder for me to stay engaged.
That said, there were definitely highlights. The book is thoroughly researched, and I learned a great deal about how forensic methods were developed, challenged, and ultimately accepted within the justice system. The discussions around the limitations of forensic evidence and the potential consequences of mistakes were particularly thought-provoking.
I came looking for something closer to a behind-the-scenes forensic memoir and found instead a detailed exploration of the history and practice of expert witness testimony. While I appreciate what the book set out to accomplish, it was not quite the forensic science experience I was hoping for.
A personal history of forensic medicine in which Professor Lady Sue Black gives us the benefit of her vast experience as an expert witness and forensic anatomist. She’s not shy of admitting, even for someone so eminent, how terrified she was, at times, in court when barristers tried to undermine her. “Would you say that you are an expert”? Her answer, “That’s for the jury to decide.” Very clever. This is a useful read for anyone who has had to give their opinion in court. I had to a few times as a GP, and mighty scary it was I can tell you — and it wasn’t me on trial. As Sue Black states, the expert witness is the only person under oath who is able to theorise rather than state bald facts. She gives an excellent account of the history of the specialty, the pioneering scientists (and a few pseudoscientists) are given their due and there are gruesome details of wicked murders and staggering miscarriages of justice. This reads rather like a textbook, but I have a liking for these so that’s fine. I was impressed by her candour in discussing her more trying experiences. I used to read a GP magazine that contained a weekly column called My Worst Moment in which doctors wrote about their mistakes. Human nature being what it is they never actually admitted to making any error and the cock-up was therefore a positive learning process, admittedly a highly stressful one. Incidentally, if I’d sent some of mine in unvarnished I would have been (quite rightly) slaughtered and my Defence Union would have washed their hands. I enjoyed her opinion on some recent well-publicised cases and will therefore not be astonished if Lucy Letby is eventually confirmed to be not guilty.
I absolutely loved this book. What stood out most was the incredible depth Sue Black brings to the history and evolution of forensic science. Rather than simply discussing modern forensic techniques, she takes readers through the discoveries, landmark cases, and individuals who helped establish the methods we rely on today.
The historical aspect was particularly fascinating. I really enjoyed learning how different forensic techniques were developed, challenged, and eventually accepted as legitimate evidence in court. Black does an excellent job of explaining not only the science itself but also the legal processes surrounding it, including the consequences when forensic evidence is misunderstood or incorrectly applied.
Coming from a U.S. perspective, another aspect I found especially interesting was learning how the legal systems and court proceedings work in other countries. Black does a remarkable job of using the written word to explain these processes in a way that's both detailed and accessible. Even when discussing complicated scientific concepts or courtroom procedures, I never felt lost in the material.
I also appreciated that the book doesn't present forensic science as infallible. Black explores both its successes and failures, demonstrating how advances in science have helped deliver justice while also acknowledging the devastating consequences of flawed evidence and wrongful convictions.
Overall, this was an outstanding read. The combination of forensic science, history, real criminal cases, and insight into different legal systems made it incredibly engaging from beginning to end. I came away with a much greater understanding of how forensic science has evolved and how closely it is tied to the justice system. An easy five stars and a book I'd highly recommend to anyone interested in true crime, forensic science, or legal history.
As a doctor with a deeply-rooted true crime obsession and an interest in the legal system, I expected to love this book, but sadly didn’t. I understand what Professor Black was trying to do - framing the role of the expert witness with a description of the various fields within forensic science and the history behind them - but the lack of personal connection, for me, made the majority of the book a bit dull. From being gripped by the first chapter, I struggled through the meat of the book thinking that it must get better eventually, “And finally…” in the last chapter, our author shared a heartfelt story which was compelling to read. I found it heavy on legal legislation and scientific principles and lacking in anecdote to capture the reader’s interest. Even the historical criminal case stories used to contextualise the science were a bit bland. If the author had managed to pepper the whole book with more human connection from her own experiences, this book could have been better. Although perhaps this speaks to Professor Black’s thesis that the expert witness communicates the facts and probabilities, providing opinion only within their scope and field. I think this is a book that will appeal to a limited audience - those working in the criminal justice system or scientific fields that contribute to it - in my opinion, it doesn’t have enough grip or intrigue for the average non-fiction reader.
An Expert Witness by Sue Black is an informative and, to the extent the topic can be, an entertaining read.
I enjoyed the other book of hers that I read, All That Remains, a little bit more. That isn't because this is a lesser book but I think I just preferred the focus of that book a bit more. That said, this volume made explicit a few things about the differences between various legal parameters and definitions between jurisdictions. I had casually picked up a rough idea of the differences, for example, between US legal structures and the structures throughout the UK, but Black explained these things so I could read future books, whether fiction or nonfiction, with a better foundational understanding of what is permitted and discouraged.
The use of stories, whether her own or ones from other expert witnesses, help to make the concepts more understandable while also providing most of the enjoyment/entertainment. Real life examples really do make a difference in any subject but I think when you're dealing with systems that seem to be dynamic rather than static, such as justice systems, they are essential.
Highly recommended for anyone wanting a better understanding of what an expert witness is, and is not. While focused on forensic science the general principles are largely applicable across other areas where an expert witness might be called to testify and/or examine evidence.
Reviewed from a copy made available by the publisher via NetGalley.
If you want to wake up to the reality of the underpinnings of modern forensic science, An Expert Witness is a great place to start!
Sue Black expertly traces the history of forensic science to the present in a way that feels much like sitting on the couch with a good friend! It is superlatively casual and highly enjoyable. I think that anyone looking to expand their horizons and learn a bit more about the science inside the courtroom will enjoy this book.
Although some may find pieces of the narrative to be a textbook-like recitation, I think that the majority of the text is about building a foundational understanding. I am quite accustomed to reading scientific and academic papers, so the tone and structure did not bother me at all. I found it quite enjoyable. Much of the course of study for forensic science is centered on what has come before. Therefore, it is important to understand the foundation before going further.
Readers who are lovers of CSI-type entertainment content may find pause with this book. It is much more of a biography and science book. Therefore, it may leave some readers disappointed by its focus on the "reality" of the science portrayed in the media. It is very much a "behind the curtain" type read, where you will learn what goes on behind the glitz and glam!
Thank you to NetGalley, Sue Black, and Grove Atlantic for sending me this advance review copy for free. I am leaving this review voluntarily and with joy in my heart!
Forensic anatomist Sue Black gives the reader an overview of forensic science in the courtroom. No case is gone into any depth, so it feels like a lot is thrown at the reader in a somewhat scattered way. Sure, each chapter tries to come at the topic with a slightly different lens, but it feels like more organization within the narrative would help with imparting concepts.
The reader can easily see that Black, as a forensic anatomist and a PhD, is treated with less deference than her medical forensic pathologist counterpart (MD) in the courtroom and the field, and she feels some kind of way about that.
As a reader, I would have appreciated going into a little more depth on fewer cases. Many times there wasn’t much information given on a case, and Sue Black focused on ripping apart the forensic “expert.” There were so many instances where the wrong person was convicted or a later expert came to a different finding than the first expert that I started questioning the whole field. I don’t think that was Black’s intention by any means; it’s just the byproduct of how she structured the narrative.
Unfortunately, while there are good snippets within this book, I found enough drawbacks that I’m not enthusiastically recommending it.
Thank you to NetGalley and Atlantic Monthly Press for an Advance Reader Copy. My review is completely my own.
I enjoyed this, however it was also not what I fully expected. I thought that I was going to be getting a very through look into how different types of evidence where being presented in courts and their origins and while this was addressed throughly, Sue Black also seemed to approach everything as a cautionary tale. She acknowledges the way in which expert testimony can be helpful, but also harmful to both individual cases and a person's longterm wellbeing. Perhaps this was more geared towards those who are currently working in positions where being called as an expert witness is a very real possibility.
Sue Black is undoubtedly knowledgable and embodies the very traits that are most valuable in an expert witness within the courtroom and has helped pioneer and champion so many advances in science in her career. This is reflected throughout the pages of this book, however she does not dumb herself down and if I'm honest at times I had to pause and reread some sections as the terminology was either very specialised or just explained with little thought of the layman like myself.
Overall, this was an interesting non-fiction read but isn't for the fate of heart as the pages are dense and require you to be engaged in every page for fear of missing out.
I’ve read all of Sue Black’s books about her time as a forensic anthropologist and like her other two books, this one did not disappoint.
A look at the forensic professional as expert witness at trials, An Expert Witness provides both explanation and example of what is required of expert witnesses during court appearances.
Each chapter delves deep into a specific type of forensic science and provides good and bad examples of expert witness testimonies throughout history. If a chapter relates to testimony that Professor Black has given, she provides insight on her own experiences. I especially liked that she dedicated a chapter to the future of forensic science and expert testimony in relation to technology/AI, since there’s no escaping the technology train that has begun rolling.
It seems like her intended audience is more the current and future forensic scientists die to the denseness of he material, but I chalk that up to the scientific nature of the field. However, the inclusion of the “true crime” element from the courtroom helped to add a more “layperson” feeling to the writing so that all audiences can find something they will like.
Overall, another good entry in the Sue Black collection.
As a true crime afficionado, I am fascinated by the role played by forensic science in the courtroom. And, while science does not (yet, anyway) hold all the answers, it clearly plays an important role in establishing possible guilt or innocence. Yes, a qualifier is needed. Forensic science is not always infallible.
In this book, Dame Sue Black writes about the various tools used in forensics and how each was developed and made its way into the courtroom. Dame Sue Black writes about the role of expert witnesses and about cases she has had a role in.
I was fascinated by the evolution of forensics as well as by the criminal cases cited. We are reminded (several examples are provided) that faulty forensics can contribute to wrongful convictions and imprisonment.
Dame Sue Black had forty years of experience as a forensic anthropologist and has developed unique methods for identifying criminals and victims using hand and arm vein pattern analysis and skin-crease recognition.
I finished reading with a more comprehensive understanding of the role and limits of forensic science.
Note: My thanks to NetGalley and Grove Atlantic for providing me with a free electronic copy of this book for review purposes.
I would like to thank the author, Grove Atlantic and NetGalley for providing me with this eARC for review consideration.
The following is my personal perspective on An Expert Witness: The Story of Forensic Science in the Courtroom by Sue Black.
What a fascinating book. Anatomist Sue Black covers the history of forensic sciences, the evolution of studies throughout the years and how it has played a role in criminal cases.
There are sections of this book that were difficult to read due to the nature of the crimes but I found that I was extremely grateful for people like Ms. Black who have made this field their life’s purpose.
Despite the more difficult topics covered in this book, there are lighter moments of humour sprinkled throughout which made it feel as though she was just having a conversation with the reader.
The glimpse into the future and how AI could possibly play a role, quite honestly, is horrifying to me. I don’t know if I would ever lay that much trust in that scenario.
This book was so incredibly enlightening and I would like to thank her for her endless curiosity, her drive, and most importantly, for her service.