William, Earl of Ashford, and Violet Hayes had known each other since childhood—he, heir to a great title, and she, the daughter of his father’s stable master and the cook. What began as innocent friendship blossomed into stolen kisses and whispered vows. William swore their love would cross every boundary of class, that nothing—not family, nor duty, nor the rigid rules of society—would keep them apart.
But when William returns from London in the midst of the Season, it is not to claim Violet’s hand as he had promised—it is to announce his engagement to a woman of wealth and pedigree. Violet’s pleas shatter against his cold this is his duty, and nothing will change it. Worse still, his mother ensures Violet’s disappearance, warning that if she does not leave at once, her parents will lose their livelihoods. Lady Ashford will not allow a servant’s daughter—carrying her son’s child—to remain when his new bride is soon to arrive.
To Violet, it is not only her love William has cast aside—but their unborn child as well. Shattered and alone, she is sent away, banished from the man she once trusted with her entire heart and soul.
Years pass. William’s glittering marriage ends in ashes when his wife dies childless, leaving him with nothing but regret. Seeking Violet at last, he finds not the trusting girl who once believed in his promises, but a woman carved by heartbreak and hardened by loss.
Violet lives only for her daughter—the child William rejected long ago. Her heart is withered, her trust broken, and she no longer believes in the promises of men.
When it mattered most, William did not choose her. And Violet Hayes has vowed never again to be that girl who chose him. Content Referenced suicide (off-page), child choking incidents (resolved), emotional cruelty/manipulation, abandonment of a pregnant heroine, loveless duty marriage, grief/loss, class power imbalance, and secret baby (father unaware).
This is a story of forbidden love and obligation to a title. No one was a winner, and everyone lost. He traded love for obligation.
The premise:
William, the son of an Earl, and Violet, the daughter of the stable master, were best friends and each other’s great loves. At 17, William proposed to Violet, both naively believed marriage was realistic despite their different stations in life.😬
William’s mother, the Countess, sends him to London to attend the season and find a wife with a dowry because the estate is struggling. She is asking him to choose tradition and obligation over love, which he reluctantly does.
Violet keeps sending him letters, only to wait for responses that never come. When she discovers she is pregnant, she writes to him once again, but to no avail.
When the season is over, William returns home with his new wife, Victoria. He cruelly rejects Violet to drive her away, breaking both of their hearts in the process.
His mother sends Violet away under a new name, and William doesn’t know where she is.
Heartbroken, he rejects his new wife entirely. He takes a post in Vienna and leaves her behind, in isolation as he banned her and his mother to the country estate. He was hoping to atone for his own choices by serving the crown in misery. Until one day his wife’s utter heartbreak cracks the facade he is hiding behind. By then, his cowardice has ruined three lives.
Violet is living in a a small village in a cottage purchased by William’s mother. Hmm🙄 She leads a quiet life with her daughter and her parents.
We are shown different POVs, and I loved that. But I went from having a great time to absolutely hating this story.
The setting would have worked better had it been more contemporary. The class difference between them is barely important to the characters, yet somehow becomes the central conflict. It made no sense.
There were so many historical errors that they became hard to disregard. So many things simply could not have happened in that era. I am not a stickler for historical accuracy, but it became ridiculous.
Violet became an utter shrew once William returned to claim her and their daughter. She was constantly hissing and sneering at him, and I get that the writer wanted her to be angry, but anger is only skin deep, and hurt lies underneath. Show me vulnerability instead.
Violet then decided to sleep with William when he came for her, completely out of the blue, and continued to hiss at him while getting dressed. I was so confused.
I wanted more fleshed-out characters. I really disliked Violet, and somehow felt more empathy with Victoria’s heartbreak. (Ouch) Violet was the original unreasonable black cat. I wanted him to move on.
They were both victims, yet somehow her victimhood was treated as more important. He ultimately made the decision to marry someone else, but he was under a lot of pressure. He didn’t know she was pregnant. He genuinely thought he was doing the right thing.
Listen, this isn’t really a romance, and that’s okay. The beginning read more like Lady Tremaine with a historical fiction vibe.
The last 30’% was pure telling and wrapping it up, it was in an incredible hurry and forgot its characters.
Should you read it? No. Violet needed anger management, and William was a weak man understandably so, given his circumstances.
Chance of divorce? 80%. Once she throws another hissy fit and sneers at him, I hope he skedaddles.
P.S. It was labeled for mature listeners, but it’s a clean book. 😂
To say that I was impatient to read this book feels like an euphemism. I was eyeing it ever since I read the first chapters on Wattpad and hoped the author would quickly publish the completed version. All this because the promised tropes were the absolute bomb for the betrayal/grovel enthusiast that I am - add to that that this was going to be a HR story... Mamma mia 🤩!
And now, after reading, I absolutely loved that AMK did not shy from making use of these tropes frank and direct, with no sugar coating: he did reject her, he did consciously choose his duty over love (no matter whether he was manipulated), he did use the most cruel words to push her away, he was indeed a coward and he never sought her out even just to ensure she was safe. Very often, in similar stories, there would always be a third party explanation that would downplay horribly the betrayal to the point of soggy dilution e.g. he was drugged/ enchanted, OW had planned a whole set up to mislead him, he was threatened, she was threatened... Not so here, so thank you for that AMK. Yes, of course, there was some other external factors at play, but at the core of it, he made the choices, he was too inactive, he failed to investigate and fight, he abandoned the scene. And she suffered through it all. I would not say the angst was the best (see below) but the suffering was centerstage.
Now when there is betrayal, I do expect grovel. While I am realistic enough to not expect 'grovel and all its trimmings' in most books, I do expect substantial and satisfactory grovel. Was it satisfactory here? Hmm, I guess my jury is still out on this one. He did regret, he did half-live and pine away during their separation (5 years) and he did show up penitent and acted (a bit too gently?) to show he had changed. But I do feel all his efforts were not written in the most emotionally impactful way it could have been. Even Violet in all her deserved anger, eventually seemed to cede too easily (5 years lost is not a little thing!). I think it all stemmed from the writing style. This new author shows great promises (just sticking to this plot without flinching deserves a thumbs up) but there was a kind of emotional distance between the narration and the events happening on page - result of which, I felt removed from the proceedings. There was some viscerality missing imho.
So in a nutshell, great idea, good bones, yes for not backing and seeking easy ways out, sincere efforts but more passion and lyricality would push the story higher. I do look forward to what AMK will publish next.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
William and Violet are in love and promises of marriage are made when he’s pressured to marry another woman to save his family’s finances. He doesn’t know Violet is pregnant and she’s sent away to live as a “widow”.
I love the gut punch of betrayal in books (that can be forgiven 😂) but sadly, I wasn’t that connected to their romance.
The good news is William never entertains his marriage. He barely speaks to his wife and they never kiss, sleep together, or really spend time together. He heads off to Vienna for four years before she dies.
The bad news is his wife was a victim of the time period too. She wanted to marry for love and couldn’t and he’s pretty cold to her despite her being in bad circumstances also, and then she hangs herself because her first love did too and she’s so lonely. So sad!!
I didn’t love that William and Violet don’t reunite until about 70% into the book. There wasn’t a lot of grovel per se…it’s more that he shows up, fixes stuff around the town, and then legitimizes their daughter.
He wasn’t aware of their child and was not all at fault, but I was hoping for a slower burn reconciliation and more getting to know them as a couple.
I did like his moments as a father, how Violet’s new townspeople rallied around her, and her family and friendships.
Overall, the romance wasn’t as deep as I hoped it would be but it was an easy read!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
The blurb pretty much gives away the whole plot: William and Violet fell in love as kids despite her being the daughter of his stable master. He came back from the Season and destroyed her by announcing he was engaged to a woman of society after making promises to her. She flees pregnant, they’re separated for years, until the wife dies, then he goes to find her. I mean that is the entire plot.
I love betrayal and grovel books. This one was well-written. The long separation sort of dimmed the angst for me, though. I did believe William was remorseful and I liked his character growth.
If we’re rating strictly within the betrayal + secret child + grovel category, this is one of the better executions of the trope and earns 4 stars. Taken as a complete book, though, it lands closer to 3 stars for me.
Tropes included: • MMC → FMC betrayal (no cheating) • Secret child • Grovel
Plot Summary
The story is set in the 1840s (presumably England, though it’s not clearly stated). The MMC comes from a wealthy, titled family. The FMC, Violet, is the daughter of a stable worker and five years younger than him.
They grow up as childhood friends who eventually fall in love. The MMC is devoted to Violet and genuinely intends to marry her. When the FMC is 17 and the MMC 22, they consummate their relationship. The next day, he leaves for London for the Season as he does every year promising to return and marry her.
While in London, however, he is pressured into becoming engaged to (and later marrying) a woman from a powerful family. His parents are truly despicable and manipulate the situation heavily.
When he returns home, he breaks things off with Violet and tells her he is engaged. She sends him a letter telling him she is pregnant, but he never receives it his mother intercepts it. He says cruel things to Violet, and she runs away. A few days later, his mother follows, forces Violet off the estate, and relocates her to a small cottage in another town.
Devastated, Violet slowly builds a new life. The people in this town are kind and supportive, and eventually her parents join her. She gives birth to a daughter and finds stability.
Meanwhile, the MMC is miserable. He marries but never consummates the marriage and soon leaves for Vienna on official business, cutting ties with both his family and his wife.
Five years later, he receives a letter informing him that his wife has taken her own life after being in love with another man who also died. His mother finally confesses everything, the pregnancy, the letter, and her manipulation. Devastated, the MMC goes in search of Violet.
The FMC does not forgive him easily, and the grovel is extensive. Eventually, they reach their HEA.
Thoughts
The betrayal was entertaining, and the writing was serviceable, though quite repetitive. If I had to read “her long black curls” one more time, I might have screamed.
The FMC was fine but a bit plain and one-dimensional. The MMC was also okay neither especially compelling nor terrible.
Ironically, I found myself bored once the grovel began. I feel like I’ve read this exact grovel sequence many times: • FMC tells MMC to go to hell • MMC insists he won’t leave • He fixes things around her house • He seeks forgiveness from her family • Rinse and repeat
Some authors do it better than others, but structurally it’s almost always the same.
Honestly, once the grovel starts, I tend to lose interest because the ending becomes entirely predictable. I think I’d enjoy these stories more if the betrayal, separation, and forgiveness weren’t so linear, if the narrative moved back and forth between hurt and healing, misunderstandings and partial forgiveness. That kind of structure would keep me more engaged.
Unfortunately, betrayal romances tend to be very formulaic. Some are written better than others, but you usually know exactly what will happen and when.
Final Thoughts
I’m not sure if I’d recommend this wholeheartedly. It wasn’t bad, and it’s certainly not the worst in the genre, but it’s also not a reread for me. This may very much be a me problem, I want to be surprised and engaged for most of the book, and this one played things a little too safely.
The writing was good and I was engaged with the book (only light skimming at 80%). I do like the everyone acknowledged, even the H, that he was just a cowardly man and didn’t really have it in him not to go against his parents. I loved that he was wracked with guilt and still loved violet and didn’t just try to make it work with his wife who he was upfront with before they even married that he was in love with somebody else. Five year separation between him and Violet. William did follow through with the arranged marriage, but didn’t consummate it and avoided his wife pretty much from the beginning. On a sidenote, I felt bad for his wife Victoria. She was also trapped in circumstance and having no power because she was a woman. She wasn’t able to marry who she truly loved, and once her true love took his life and she found out then she took her own life. Pretty tragic. Two things that weren’t my fave: 1. William completely destroyed violet. She believed he abandoned her and the baby and just used her. How does someone hold onto loving a person like that especially five years later? I could definitely see a new relationship being built and her starting with her feelings from the ground up, but to be holding onto that love when he decimated her came off as a bit weak. 2. I think violet gave in pretty quickly after two weeks of Williams mending fences and helping around the town. Part of the reason that I think violet allowed herself to forgive William so easily was that their daughter was immediately taken with him. Lily has plenty of male figures around her, why would she suddenly attach herself to a random man - remember, she didn’t know William was her dad.
It seems as though neither one was with anyone else during their separation. Again, there wasn’t a lot of grovel, but I think that’s kind of hard to do during this era. William did fix the legitimacy of his eldest daughter Lily, which I loved. But he could’ve told Violet what he was doing so that she didn’t think he left again, like come on man! There are so many societal rules during historical times that you kind of have to work within the confines of it. I truly believe in their happy ending. I’m just petty and wanted violet to hold out a little longer, but again…it’s the Victorian era.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
This was just too clean and I don’t mean just because it’s a closed door book. The H is heir to an earldom and the fmc is the stable masters daughter. They are friends from 10 years old. They have sex at 17- then the H’s parents make him go to London for the season to find a wife. He had promised the fmc he would marry her whe he returns. Of course his mommy and daddy make him marry ow. It’s meant to be angsty but it’s not because all of the problems were created by the H’s Mummy.
What a beautifully written story of love, betrayal, and healing. I genuinely loved William and Violet’s story. It spoke to the demands of society at the time and how it tore apart their young love. Seeing Violet at her lowest and slowly healing as she made a place for herself in a new town with a found family was so cathartic. Contrasting that with the agony, tension, and regret of William’s life gave this romance a balance that worked so well. His grovel was so well-written because it came from a place of love and desperation to do right for Violet and Lily.
And while I loved how their story ended, I would’ve been just as content if Violet had found a second love in Nathaniel. It speaks to how well these side characters are written that I felt so much for the OM. I hope he gets his own story because that man deserves an HEA too.
This is the second book I’ve read by this author and have with it some of the same issues I’ve had with "The Heather Wife". We are mainly told and not shown what happens.
I keep giving her chances because she seems to prefer to write angsty stories that are the ones I crave to read the most. ANGST is my absolute favorite element in a romance, together with the forbidden and the pregnancy tropes. The premise of "Ashes of Forever" promised to make me a very happy satisfied reader but in the end I was again disappointed. I want to feel in a whirlpool of emotions when I read a book and above all an angsty one where my heart must be smashed and mended and give me all the feels.
In this case instead the story is flat, there’s no pathos. I don’t know how to better explain it but it’s all too much calm, quiet, composed and even the supposed angsty moments that should make your heart ache so good are without momentum. It’s a lightening without the thunder.
An issue I have is the characters spend most time separated during their own love story. The problem here is not even that they are far away from each other for 5 years but that through the story they are together on-page too little.
I counted the scenes they are both present. I really did. The book has a prologue, 40 chapters and two epilogues.
Hero and heroine spent 13 scenes together on-page in the whole book (and some of those are very short and others are made of few lines).
1) Prologue - There’s an opening scene when Violet is 10 years old and William 15 years old. It seems like they already knew each other since she is the servants' daughter and he the earl's son and heir, but you only see this interaction as their first meeting.
2) CHAPTER 1 - They are seen together on page after 7 years when they have grown up. At this point you are told they are already deeply in love, they confess their feelings, are intimate for the first time (no description at all, just fade to black) and plan to marry. You don’t know how, why and when they fell in love. It happened OFF PAGE. I get it that the story might be about the ashes of a heartbreak you build a forever on. But you have the ashes of a love that is not being shown to grow or be solid to the point it might still leave embers that will fuel the forever. I must believe this love may conquer and fight against all the odds just because I’m told so.
3) CHAPTER 2 - William gives Violet a silver locket as a gift under the oak tree they always met before leaving for the London season and promises her that was the last time they’d have been separated before marrying at his return.
From CHAPTER 3 to 5...they are not together and this greatest love that should have defied class, prejudices and expectations starts to crumble. It was nonexistent to start with so the grounds where to build their future and wedding bliss on were shaky and muddy at best.
4) CHAPTER 6 - William, that was sooo ready to fight anyone to be with Violet, needs very little convincing to break up with her. And since admitting to her that he was a spineless man would have made him appear weak, he accused her of not being enough for his mighty lordship instead. I'd have loved the angst if it were built up in a convincing way. From love to hate in a nanosecond.
The breaking up scene consisted of few lines, and if they both would have asked the right questions about the letters not received from both of them the book would have ended there I guess, because all would have been explained in no time with few aimed clarifications.
This moment that should have been one of great pathos and intensity showed the power of words, or the lack of that in writing a pivotal moment. Instead of having my heart in pieces I was annoyed with the characters’ idiocy and cowardice.
From CHAPTER 7 to 27... THEY ARE SEPARATED. 21 chapters apart this time.
But to compensate this we have whining, pining and inner monologues ad infinitum. Same thoughts again and again. And more inner thoughts for good measure. Enough is not enough in this case.
5) CHAPTER 28 - Violet and William meet again after 5 years apart, see each other and exchange 2 lines in total for a sum of 8 words.
More inner monologues, they are a necessity one cannot do without by now.
6) CHAPTER 30 - they have a confrontation that should be one of the most heated and tormented moment of the story, the climax you are waiting for the whole book and even if Violet tried our William was an absolutely delusion, the scene lacked impact. I was not moved by it.
7) CHAPTER 32 - our tragicomic lovers have another confrontation but if the first one lacked impact this second talk was just a sum of explanations. Where is my heart breaking and crying for this couple? I keep waiting for that punch in my stomach but it never comes. It’s all too controlled and composed to be a story where the angst involving two separated lovers should have been the main element. The pinnacle is elusive and slippery.
CHAPTER 33 - not a Violet and William scene together but the solution to the problems is given in this chapter
William has a confrontation with Violet’s father Thomas in another civilized and respectful exchange of words. It’s not like I expect a fist fight between the father and the hero but again there’s no pathos. I want to be punched, have my throat constricted, feel butterflies in my stomach, I want to feel something that is not the nothingness I’m experiencing. By the way Thomas delivers better than William in this scene. But again I like Thomas more than Willy. It seems I like anyone more than the hero.
Back to the solution... Thomas has told William he owed the village people for helping Violet in her moment of need and being there for her during the years he was not, so he must fix their leaning fences, leaking roofs and broken gates if he wants to start making amends. Great way to obtain forgiveness. I might follow this advice if it's so easy and effortless to be forgiven.
8) CHAPTER 34 - Our diligent William starts fixing the leaning fence of Violet’s cottage in his restoration era, they see each other, William the clumsy hurts his hand obviously and they share a moment together with their daughter Lily worrying over William injured body part. Sweet child Lily.
9) CHAPTER 36 - William fixes the bakery leaking roof this time, all is going according to the plan to walk the path toward the surrender and reconquer of Violet’s heart through manual labor. He meets with her and they exchange few civilized words in various moment of the chapter.
10) CHAPTER 37 - they have a sex scene but honestly I was not invested in it. Nothing is resolved and William leaves and Violet thinks he has abandoned her again. But he has a plan.
11) CHAPTER 40 - they are reunited and thanks to their great love that never died, BUT THAT I DIDN’T EVEN SEE BEING BORN IN THE FIRST PLACE, they forgive each other.
12) EPILOGUE 1 – They marry near their oak tree.
13) EPILOGUE 2 – A glimpse in the future and they are together for a moment. I liked the epilogues, above all the second one because I love to see what happens after years.
The second epilogue is set in 1866. But the dates are wrong, the ages wrong. They don’t line up. Lily is correctly 18 years old in 1866 since she was born in 1848. Violet and William reunite in 1853 so their next daughter should be 13 years old and not 16 yo. It’s not important in the grand scheme of things really, I guess it was just an oversight.
These are the scenes they are shown together in total. It’s not like they have to be always together but the contrary is not desirable either.
The slices of life moments with the village people are heartwarming, the scenes with Lily were really cute but they were too many compared to the on-page time between hero and heroine.
There's this storyline about a possible OM but it's just thrown there and eliminated in the blink of an eye. What's the point? You have this Sir Nathaniel Hawthorne that one moment wanted to court and marry Violet but as always you don’t know why...could it be because Violet is a lovely girl who saved one of his daughters from suffocating? I didn’t know this might have been enough to fall in love with someone and receive a marriage proposal from a Sir...or was he a Baron at one time?
Even in this case we don’t see any courting or any feelings take root in the suitor’s case. Just dinners and interactions that as typical by now happen off-page. We have to imagine most things a lot. Violet has not even the time to take in consideration his offer that as soon as you are made aware of his intentions and finish reading those lines of intent he just steps back after William's reappearance in the next scene.
The story is set during the Victorian era but the only references that makes it clear are the mention and then a meeting with Queen Victoria and the use of a telegram that William receives.
The story is a closed-door book. A kiss (more a peck) in the beginning and a little bit detailed sex scene near almost the end. And this was not even my problem with the story because as far as I prefer steamy romances I’ve loved clean stories as well. It felt out of place to be honest and I’d have preferred another fade to black scene and I never say this lightly because I love steamy romances with love as a backbone.
I’d have wanted to read more about his wife Victoria and Edward if things would have been different. The only time I was moved was when reading Victoria hanged herself (off-page) after knowing Edward killed himself after her marriage to William. I wanted for him to be alive and reach out to Victoria after she sends her letter. I wanted Victoria to be happy…more than I wanted it for William and Violet to say the truth.
William treated his wife abominably. He was a coward without a backbone that was so weak-willed he let the others have the lead knowing what would have happened, and later gave to anyone but himself the fault for his spinelessness and pusillanimity. He whined endlessly about his lost love…but he is no victim!!! He did nothing to change the events, quick to bend because he was too lazy to act!
He never once thought of going looking for Violet. Not once. A young sheltered girl that disappears leaving her only family behind. Never once he worried of how she might survive all alone in the world without her family, money and means. He was too busy with being petty with mummy and wifey, and being a whiner about a path he willingly decided to walk.
At one point, he admits he was a coward and does it endlessly but his groveling is empty. He took Violet’s accusations, admitted he was a fool and followed Thomas’ advice to fix stuff for the villagers to get in Violet’s graces. He does the bare minimum, disappears again for a while and Violet’s stone walls (that she spent most of her time and inner monologues ad infinitum to build up) fall apart without second thoughts.
Overall the writing style is not really so bad but the flow moves in circles and is too much slow. There’s no development of characters. The story is full of inner monologues that are not bad per se but here they are overused and there are the same thoughts and events repeated again and again to the point that more than once I thought I was wrongly rereading a previous scene and not a new one.
I will read her other historical romance, TANGLED FATES…maybe the third is the charm
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I like grovel and angsty stories. This book was so well-written that I flew through it despite struggling with a reading slump.
The story revolves around a class divide—the heroine is a poor maid, the daughter of the stablehand working for the hero's arrogant father. The hero, however, isn't like his father. A childhood friendship developed between him and the stablehand's daughter, which eventually blossomed into love. Yet, his sense of duty toward his family made him stumble, leading him to sacrifice himself and his love, breaking the heroine's heart by telling her he was going to marry a high-society woman of status and noble lineage. What he didn't realize as he shattered Violet's heart was that she was pregnant with his child.
I loved the heroine, Violet, so much especially how she built a new life for herself far away from her past, finding warmth and kindness among strangers who embraced her without caring about her history. Her relationship with her father was also so heartwarming.
I really liked the hero, William, as well, particularly his character development and how he atoned for the mistakes he made due to his youth and overwhelming pressure from his family (who were terrible role models, unlike the heroine's family). I also loved that he remained loyal to Violet even after his marriage, and what he ultimately did to secure a future for her and their daughter. Even if she refused to take him back and marry him officially, he ensured they had a future where they would never be humiliated or badmouthed because of his mistake.
The only downside was that their separation in the first half of the book felt a bit dragged out. Having them apart for so long in the first half caused the emotional weight of grief and pain to dull a little bit.
This starts as a tender young love story that feels pure and inevitable. Then it breaks your heart completely—before offering a hard-earned, beautiful redemption that stays with you long after the last page.
I love Historical Romances because of the complexity of Society when it comes to Titled Peers. Obligation and duty to family are at the forefront of their lives.
This book had it all. Duty and obligation which led to the heartbreak of William (MMC) and Violet (FMC). Manipulative parents and an OW who gets what she wants, but it comes at a heavy price. There are twist and turns throughout the book involving the betrayal and OW which had me like OMG! I started to feel sorry for William, Violet, and the OW.
Violet is a resilient FMC who becomes strong to protect her and their daughter. When William comes back, she doesn’t fall at his feet and I love that. I love the found family she had and her supportive/loving parents.
In the end, you see William humbling and redeeming himself exceptionally well. He went to great lengths to right the injustice bestowed upon Violet and their daughter. I loved that their futures were shown in the epilogues.
Overall, this was a very well written book that brought about a lot of emotions. The plot was awesome. It truly represented what a Historical Romance is. I loved it!
For the most part, this was an enjoyable historic romance, even if some of the plot was not particularly accurate to the time period. The characters were well developed and the settings described in great detail. Unfortunately, the author wasted a lot of time with repetitive inner monologues and having characters repeat letters and dialogue verbatim when apprising other characters of the current situation. It bogged down the narrative and caused the story to lag over several chapters throughout the book. 2.5 stars.
William has to marry someone he doesn’t want to bc of duty. He knocks up the stable hand’s daughter but totalllyyyy loves her and promises her they’ll be together then shows up married to someone else. Of course the fmc is now a ruined piece of garbage so she must run and live in shame because, yes, let’s perpetuate antiquated misogynistic ideals and call it romance. William is so cruel to his forced wife - who gave up her own love to marry him - that she actually kills herself. And he couldn’t care less that he drove this poor woman to commit suicide in his own home. Because he’s a piece of shit. Of course Violet falls panting at his feet bc she just loves him so much and he found her despite her hiding in shame and isn’t it so romantic they can be together now? No. It’s disgusting. Stop trying to pass garbage like this off as romance and tell women it’s ok.
William (22) is the son of the Earl of Ashford. He was a childhood friend with Violet (17). Her mother is the cook, and her father is the stablemaster. William and Violet are now in love. William goes to London for a Season because his parents expect him to. But he promises to return with a ring to marry Violet, and they make love under their special oak tree.
While William is in London, they write letters to each other, but neither of them receives the letters. He tells his parents he will marry Violet and asks for the family heirloom ring for her. His parents pressure him to marry an heiress named Victoria. His father eventually tells him they are on the verge of financial ruin, and he needs to marry someone with a family fortune. It's his duty to the family since he will be the next Earl. So, he has to choose between love and duty, and he chooses duty.
In the meantime, Violet misses her period and writes William a letter that she is pregnant, but he never receives the letter.
When he returns to the country estate, he tells Violet he won't marry her. She doesn’t ask about their baby directly, but she asks indirectly, what about what she said in her letters? He doesn't tell her the truth, that he never received the letters. He tells her she was just a plaything, and he is now engaged to a suitable lady.
His mother (Lady Eleanor) was the one stealing the letters, and she knows Violet is pregnant. Lady Eleanor sets Violet up in a cottage in another town with the fake backstory that she is a widow named Mrs. Grey. Violet just leaves a note for her parents saying she left because she couldn't stand to watch William marry another woman. She doesn’t mention the baby.
William's bride, Victoria, already knows about his relationship with Violet and doesn't care that the marriage will just be a business arrangement.
Violet has the baby (Lily) in the fall. She writes a letter to her parents telling them the truth about the baby. When they read about how William discarded their pregnant daughter, they leave the country estate immediately and move in with Violet. Violet had been so worried about them losing their jobs over this, but her parents didn’t care about their jobs. They didn’t want to serve in William’s household when he could treat their daughter so badly.
When William reads the note Violet’s parents left him about “what you did to our daughter,” he’s ashamed of himself and has finally had enough of this arranged marriage. He gets a post abroad with Her Majesty’s Diplomatic Service. His father died around this same time. He tells his wife and his mother that they can remain at the country estate together alone. This is about a year after he broke up with Violet.
We see a little slice of life. Lily is growing up in the village. Violet is working in a bakery (which seems dangerous in the Victorian era, but whatever). Her parents work for the local Baron, who is much friendlier and welcoming compared to the Ashfords. The Baron (Nathaniel) is a widower and eventually asks Violet to marry him to be a mother to his children. She doesn’t say yes right away, but she’s considering it. First, she has to tell Nathaniel that she really isn’t a widow and that her daughter is illegitimate, because she doesn’t want to lie.
Lady Victoria and Lady Eleanor are living alone in the Ashford country house. William never comes home or answers letters.
It turns out that Victoria also married William out of duty, when she actually loved a man who was not going to inherit anything. Her parents made her marry William instead.
Now four years have passed since William went abroad, five years since he last saw Violet. His wife Victoria is lonely, but her lost love Edward is already dead. She feels hopeless and kills herself. She mails a suicide note to William. He returns to England.
He talks to his mother, and she admits that William’s father made up the debts to force William to marry Victoria. She gives William the letters that she had intercepted and admits that Violet was pregnant.
William travels to Nathaniel’s estate to see if he can find Violet. He sees her there as soon as they answer the door, and her daughter is with her. Both Nathaniel and Violet accuse him of only coming here for his child five years after the fact because his wife just died childless, only to find out he had a daughter and not a son.
He explains to her that when he didn't get a letter from her that Season, he still wanted to marry her but he started to think she had changed her mind about him. So he had his own doubts when his parents started pressuring him.
This is at about 70% of the way through the book. Can he win her back in the last 30%?
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Where to begin… Firstly, thank you, A. M. Kray for the opportunity to read in advance. Every time I see one of these up for grabs to review, I gobble it up, because I know it’s going to be an amazing read.
Check your triggers as there are a few key ones that may be particularly distressing
This story delivered. What an emotional journey! You will get a little background which makes the story all the more heartbreaking. The first and subsequent meetings of William (future Earl of Ashford) and Violet (daughter of the stablemaster and cook) set it up, and even though you know what will happen due to the rigid rules of Victorian society, you can’t help but want something different.
William, after making promises that we know he can’t deliver, shoulders the weight of family duty, abandoning Violet to marry a woman of ‘breeding’. He is open about the fact that he does not want the marriage, and has absolutely zero relationship at all with the wife (the ONLY thing making him redeemable to me). However, in the meantime, he abandoned Violet and his unborn child… His mother works behind the scenes and sets Violet up as a widow and she exiles her to another location.
This was broken into 4 parts… and honestly, each section pulls you in a different direction. It’s an emotional journey where you will feel heartbreak, rage, joy and pure happiness. Violet is understandably closed off, and oh my… made the hard decisions based on Lily’s happiness and not hers. She’s such a beautiful soul… Lily was a delight, a sweet little girl and absolutely adorable. William… I struggled. Even though we had his thoughts throughout the story, I couldn’t help but wonder what was truly going through his head, because he seemed to react to everything rather than plan. He was redeemable (reasons above), and his actions to make reparations and to make things right were truly astounding. The acceptance from everyone regarding the circumstances was beautiful, highlighting the nature of the family that had been formed. Despite the challenges, she/they had gained a wonderful extended family…
A quick read, it's very easy to immerse yourself. I only stopped because it was 1am and I needed sleep. Needless to say, I may have neglected a few chores in the morning to finish it off….
Rating System (as of 8/14/2025): ⭐: It was a struggle to read. I almost DNF ⭐⭐: This could have been so much better. ⭐⭐⭐: Good/Average ⭐⭐⭐⭐: Great book. I will probably reread it. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐: I absolutely loved this book. *********************************************************************** Triggers: 🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩
Tropes: 💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕
Spice Level: 🔥🔥
Spice Level Rating System (as of 9/4/25) 🔥: Clean. Handholding. Kissing. 🔥🔥: Non-Descriptive/Implied on Page Sex 🔥🔥🔥: Hot-Descriptive on Page Sex 🔥🔥🔥🔥: So Hot—Do Not Read in Public 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥: Oh My-BDSM. Blood Play. Smut. ************************************************************************ Quote: "You are my new beginning, little one. My proof that even shattered things can be mended into something beautiful. You are my Lily-my hope."
Summary: MMC and FMC developed a childhood friendship that turned into romance as they grew older. MMC has promised that nothing will come between them. He will marry her. However, he gives into family pressure. The FMC leaves after she finds out he is to be married and also that she is pregnant.
Many years later secrets are revealed and the MMC realizes the terrible mistake he has made. The FMC has rebuilt her life along with the life of her daughter. This is a story of the MMC making amends and seeking out the FMC for a second chance. HEA.
Review: This book is broken down into parts, and I think it was done really well. The writing keeps you engaged and makes you want to read until the end. I always like a strong FMC and, in this book, we have one. I loved the twists and turns as well. There were a few curve balls that had me shaking my head. All in all, I think the book is really well written and the story is amazing. ***************************************************************************** FOLLOW ME ON: INSTAGRAM📢 https://www.instagram.com/bibliodarling/
This feels like an actual new author with few plot holes and dialogue that makes sense. I think it’s a decent second chance romance from a new author and would normally give it 3-3.5 stars, but it deserves more to drown out the AI junk stories.
With more time and experience, this writer will only get better. I hope they are able to form a beta or ARC team to catch the little things so that they can build a wide audience (in turn encourage more stories) as they publish.
I loved this story and all of the POVs we get to see how the MCs have affected the people around them. I wish that we got to see more grovel — this is listed as second chance so it shouldn’t be a spoiler— and how they settled into their official public relationship/reconciliation.
Spoilers follow— beware! My biggest grievance is that timelines don’t match up, which is frustrating because they are specifically placed as Chapter Headers to move the story forward intentionally. The baby was born fall/winter 1848 and Spring 1849 the grandmother is watching her grandchild giggle during a play date, speak in sentences, and play with ribbons. So, the baby went from newborn to 3-4 years old in less than 6 months. It wasn’t well thought out, but was also intentional because then the MMC POV is him recognizing that a year to the day has passed since he saw the FMC and broke it off. Maybe the chapters are out of order and that chapter from the grandmother POV is meant to be later in the book and it was moved but not adjusted to account for age and correct the timeline inconsistencies such as her observations on the FMC behaviors and healing journey after so much time. I dunno, either way— it happens a few times. And they got a special license to marry, I get that, but they married so fast and they hadn’t spent much time together in reality. I don’t know if he even bother to find where his arranged wife had been buried before he had sought this out and that has to be a scandal on its own.
I digress. This is a good story with great feeling and emotions. You feel the youth in the early chapters and watch the MCs slowly grow— more William than Violet—-to get their HEA.
What I ended up loving most about this book wasn't actually the second chance romance:- it was everything that happened because there wasn't one.... at least not for a very long time.
A.M. Kray lets life happen. Years pass. People change. Pain settles instead of shouting. Violet doesn't spend her life frozen in the moment she was abandoned, and I loved that about her. She builds a life around love rather than loss, and every choice she makes feels shaped by experience instead of bitterness. There is such a quiet maturity to her character that I found myself admiring her more with every chapter. William, on the other hand, frustrated me exactly as he was supposed to. What made him compelling wasn't perfection or charm; it was watching him slowly understand that regret, by itself, changes nothing. The story allows him to sit with the consequences of his choices before asking whether he deserves another chance, and I appreciated that honesty.🪞
One of my favourite parts, though, was everything outside the romance. The gentle moments of everyday life,you know, the people who became family without sharing blood, and the simple scenes that showed Violet and Lily creating a home gave the story so much heart. Those quieter chapters made the emotional moments land even harder because there was something real at stake beyond the romance. By the end, I wasn't simply happy that two people found each other again- I was happy that they had both become people capable of building something healthier than what they had lost. That made the ending feel genuinely earned.🌷
A beautiful, thoughtful historical romance that understands love is not just about finding your way back to someone - it's also about becoming someone worth coming back to. 🌿❤️
This is a beautifully written story of heartache and redemption. I'm torn to pick a favorite part of the book between the support and friendship Violet found in the distant village she was sent to or William's arrival and efforts to win a place in her heart again.
So much happens in their lives while together and apart which we get to watch. William learns to stand his ground in his cold and lonely life as he rejects the false role he was dragged into. Violet and Lily, their daughter, on the other hand are protected and nurtured in a new home however humble it was. The details of their simple life and the growing friendships with the secondary characters were a joy to read and gave this story so much warmth. My compliments to the author for taking the time to share these small but essential scenes. I think they were my favorite.
We also had William facing the truth about himself which showed us a man in great pain. I was so happy when he finally went after his family, but I was also happy that Violet didn't make things easy at the same time. They had so many things to work out and overcome but in the end they got their HEA.
I love a good betrayal and we definitely got that here too. His parent's actions were despicable, his words to Violet during the betrayal scene brought me to tears and left me wondering if I could ever forgive him. But, that is what the rest of the story is for and I definitely changed my mind about him.
Enjoy the read, this will be an definite re-read for me when I want both heartache and warmth.
I thought that this book was written really well. The reason for William and Violet’s break up was a bit of miscommunication as well as William being manipulated by his family to do his duty and save them from ruin . While William does end up marrying another woman, he makes it clear to her from the beginning that he loves someone else and he’ll never be a real husband to her. Eventually, William returns to England from Vienna after his wife commits suicide and goes looking for Violet when his mother finally reveals that Violet was pregnant when she got rid of her.
I liked this book and how the emotional parts were written, but I wanted to see more of the other characters – people in the town Violet was living in, Violet’s parents, Lily and her getting to know her father. Also, I’m hoping Nathaniel has his own book. I wanted to see more of William and Violet’s relationship development too because the beginning was a lot of time passing and it just mentioning that they became friends and that slowly turned into more while the present is Violet being mad, William trying to be in her life any way he can and then them just being together after .
Setting: England MC names: William Ashford, Violet Hayes POV: both, 3rd person
The story had no cheating, which I liked. It was the kind of story you can read once and easily move on from. Both main characters felt quite simple and not very extraordinary.
One thing I really appreciated was that William never built a real relationship with Victoria. He did not spend time with her as a husband, nor did they have a child together. I usually dislike stories where the hero has a child with someone else and the heroine has to live with that situation for the rest of her life. William stayed emotionally loyal to Violet even while he was married, which I liked.
However, I wish William’s mother had faced stronger consequences. Because she was unhappy in her own marriage and never had freedom, she intentionally repeated the same suffering in her son’s life. I felt she deserved more karma instead of a peaceful death.
Nathaniel was also a very good character. If William had truly accepted his marriage with Victoria and had a child with her, I would have preferred Nathaniel as Violet’s partner. But since William remained faithful in his own way, I accepted their ending together.
Although William’s character felt somewhat flat and passive, I still felt sympathy for him and was happy when he and Violet finally got their happy ending.
I normally do not enjoy stories with children involved, but I liked Lily. She was sweet, polite, and not overly demanding, which made her character enjoyable.
Ashes of Forever is a deeply emotional story about grief, guilt, and finding your way back after life burns everything down. The writing is atmospheric and evocative, pulling you into the characters’ grief and healing in equal measure.
William and Violet are two broken souls carrying the weight of the same tragedy, even if they carry it in very different ways. William is drowning in responsibility, regret, and the belief that he deserves to suffer. Violet, on the other hand, is quietly unraveling, trying to survive her pain while feeling invisible and forgotten, trying to let a dream die, while learning to be steadfast for her daughter.
Their connection isn’t instant or easy. It’s messy, slow, and filled with unspoken emotions, which makes it feel incredibly real.
What I loved most is how A.M. Kray allows both characters the space to be flawed. There’s no rushing the healing, no pretending love magically fixes everything. Instead, we watch William and Violet learn how to exist again, how to forgive themselves, how to lean on one another, and how to choose love even when it feels terrifying.
This story hurts in the best way. It’s tender, raw, and full of quiet moments that hit hardest. If you enjoy emotional romance with depth, angst, and characters who stay with you long after the book ends, Ashes of Forever is absolutely worth reading. 💚💙🩷
A.M Kray is a new author to me and I just love her writing, I'm so grateful I got the opportunity to read an advanced copy of Ashes of Forever. All of her future releases are going to be an instant download for me now.
Ashes of forever is a historical second chance romance about Betrayal, heartache and the weight of duty and society pressures.
The story follows William an Earls son & Violet the cook & stable master's daughter who fell madly in love and vowed to choose one another above all else. Pressures from family and the weight of the title force William to abandon Violet for a more suitable bride, Williams manipulative evil mother then forces her out and hides her away in a village to prevent scandal when she learns she's carrying his child. Years later he learns the truth of everything he lost and the true consequences of his choices.
I really liked how the story was split into 4 parts so we could see the love blossom between the characters and the fall out of Williams choices which had far reaching heartbreak for all, it took me on such an emotional journey. You truly feel the grief from each of them and how deeply they loved one another.
I devoured this book and I would highly recommend it!
So, I actually don’t have a quibble with the writing. The author writes well - her grammar, painting a scene, building the story. All good. But I had to stop reading around the 35% mark when I realized that the author was going to bring h, Violet, who is lovely, together with the H, William, who is not. *SPOILER* William is presented as a tormented soul who never forgives himself for hurting Violet. But the thing is, he was a grown man when he chose to reject her and let himself be led by his mother and father. Young man, yes, but still fully grown. And he does it cruelly. Then he spends the next five years punishing his mother and the woman he - voluntarily - married, his behaviour in complete denial that it was his decision to reject Violet and marry the other woman. He leaves the country, not only abandoning his mom and wife, but blacklisting them from society and banishing them to a single estate. Sure, his mom is horrid but he is punishing everyone around him for HIS decision. For FIVE years, until his wife kills herself. IRL, this man would be labelled a man-child. NOT someone who inspires admiration or romantic feelings. So I stopped reading.
Just finished this book moments ago as I write this review, and I am smiling brightly with a quiet, contented joy over having read such a deeply moving love story. This is the third book by A.M. Kray that I've read, and she continues to awe me in her storytelling and in her captivating writing style.
There were many moments in this book that either broke my heart or brought it to bursting with giddiness. And there were so many unforgettable lines that I'd highlighted, lines that described moments of truth, of anguish, of regret, of determination. There was one scene, in particular, which I considered such a defining moment in the book, one that brought me to near tears. It was a moment full of hope and longing, a breakthrough moment when the MMC knew that it was going to be his definitive chance at redemption, the end of their years-long suffering, and the beginning of a better, happier life he thought was lost to him forever. My heart went all out in empathy for the hero, for it was a second chance he had earned and deserved.
This had been such a deeply satisfying book to read, and I can't wait for more stories like this from Ms. Kray.
I had the privilege of reading this as a beta reader, and it arrived at a time when my own heart was bruised. Violet’s story felt like a balm to the soul—quietly devastating, deeply tender, and ultimately hopeful in the most earned way.
What stayed with me long after I finished is the reminder that there are loves that still choose you. Violet’s journey is not just about romance, but about survival, motherhood, and reclaiming one’s worth after betrayal. Her strength is forged through loss, and watching her refuse to be the girl who accepts half-love again was incredibly powerful. William’s regret is palpable, and the story never lets him—or the reader—forget the cost of his choices.
This is a second-chance love story done right: painful, patient, and emotionally honest. It doesn’t rush forgiveness or pretend heartbreak disappears with time. Instead, it asks whether love can be rebuilt when trust has been shattered—and whether choosing each other again can mean something deeper than it ever did the first time.
If you believe in love that endures, love that learns, and love that shows up when it matters most, this story will stay with you.
Society during this time period is rigid and marrying to save family estates weren't uncommon.
William is forced to abandon Violet, his childhood sweetheart. His family obligations weighs heavily on his shoulders. He ends up in a loveless marriage and he chooses to spend years apart from his wife and mother. Violet is pregnant with their child and she assumes the identity of a widow.
This a was a tearjerker. I cried for Violet and yes, even William. Their lives were manipulated and destroyed by his mother. I adored Violet and her daughter, Lily. Violet is a strong and resilient woman. William slowly redeems himself. His actions after his marriage and when he reunites with Violet made me like him. His grovel was decent and he finds a solution to Lily's illegitimacy. The entire supporting cast was very likable from Nathaniel, her parents and all the people who became Violet's extended family.
This was an extremely easy read and I finished it in one sitting. The author has given us a wonderful book filled with angst, pain, redemption and enduring love.