What do you think?
Rate this book
Highland Guard #12
Hayalet
Joan Comyn, annesi Bella MacDuff’un İngiliz kralının zulmüne uğradığına tanık olduğu gün, İskoçya’nın özgürlüğü için Kral Robert Bruce’un yanında yer almaya karar verir. Güzelliğiyle büyüler, sırları çalar, bu bilgileri kralıyla paylaşır. Highland Muhafızları arasında bile yalnızca “Hayalet” olarak bilinen Joan, artık İngiltere’de en çok aranan hainlerden biri haline gelmiştir.
İngilizlerin tarafına geçen ama hala İskoçya’nın geleceğini önemseyen eski Highland Muhafızı Alex Seton, Joan’in görevini tehlikeye atan tek kişidir. Joan, bu yakışıklı savaşçıdan uzak durması gerektiğini bilse de Alex’in şövalyelere özgü asaleti, onun uzun zaman önce gömdüğü bir yanına dokunur.
Büyük savaş yaklaşırken, Joan ve Alex kendilerini sadece düşmanlara karşı değil, içlerindeki korkulara ve geçmişin hayaletlerine karşı da savaşırken bulurlar. İhanetle sadakat, görevle arzu, onurla aşk arasındaki çizgiler silinirken ikisinin de kaderini belirleyecek bir seçim onları beklemektedir.
İngilizlerin tarafına geçen ama hala İskoçya’nın geleceğini önemseyen eski Highland Muhafızı Alex Seton, Joan’in görevini tehlikeye atan tek kişidir. Joan, bu yakışıklı savaşçıdan uzak durması gerektiğini bilse de Alex’in şövalyelere özgü asaleti, onun uzun zaman önce gömdüğü bir yanına dokunur.
Büyük savaş yaklaşırken, Joan ve Alex kendilerini sadece düşmanlara karşı değil, içlerindeki korkulara ve geçmişin hayaletlerine karşı da savaşırken bulurlar. İhanetle sadakat, görevle arzu, onurla aşk arasındaki çizgiler silinirken ikisinin de kaderini belirleyecek bir seçim onları beklemektedir.
Paperback
First published June 1, 2016
208 people are currently reading
2017 people want to read
About the author
Monica McCarty
61 books2,970 followersWhat do you get when you mix a legal career, a baseball career, motherhood, and a love of history with a voracious reader? In my case, a Historical Romance Author.
Like most writers, I’ve always loved to read. Growing up in California there was always plenty to do outside, but all too often I could be found inside curled up with a book (or two or three). I started with the usual fare: The Little House on the Prairie series, The Chronicles of Narnia, The Hobbit, Watership Down, Nancy Drew, and everything by Judy Blume. Once I cleared off my bookshelf, I started swiping books from my mom. Some, like Sidney Sheldon’s The Other Side of Midnight, probably weren’t the most appropriate choice for a pre-adolescent—although they were definitely illuminating. I can still remember the look of abject horror on my mom’s Catholic-girl-face when I asked her what a virgin was. After that rather brief conversation, she paid a little closer attention to what had disappeared off her book shelf, and steered me in the direction of Harlequin and Barbara Cartland romances. I was hooked. I quickly read through the inventory of the local library and was soon buying bags of romances at garage sales.
In high school, with the encouragement of my father (who I think was a little concerned about the steady diet of romances), I read over eighty of the Franklin Library’s One Hundred Greatest Books ever written—including Tolstoy, Confucius, Plato, and the entire works of Shakespeare. Some of them were tough going for a teenager, but the experience would prove an invaluable foundation for college. After reading War and Peace, I wasn’t easily intimidated.
For some reason Monica decided to go into writing and not fashion.
After graduation, I loaded up the VW (Jetta not Bus) and trekked down I-5 to attend the University of Southern California, majoring in Political Science and minoring in English (see why all that reading helped!). I joined the Kappa Kappa Gamma sorority, and when I wasn’t studying or at football games, did my best to support the local bartending industry. Ah, the good old days.
With that kind of fun, four years of college wasn’t quite enough. So leaving Tommy Trojan behind, I traveled back up north to Palo Alto for three more years of study at Stanford Law School. Once I survived the stress of the first semester, law school proved to be one of the best times of my life—garnering me a JD, life-long friends, a husband, and an unexpectedly intimate knowledge of baseball. (See “The Baseball Odyssey” below).
Law School was also where I fell in love with Scotland. In my third year, I took a Comparative Legal History class, and wrote a paper on the Scottish Clan System and Feudalism. So I immediately dropped out of law school and went on to write Scottish Historical Romances…well no, not quite. You see, I always knew I wanted to be a lawyer. My father was a lawyer, I was a “poet” (i.e., not into math), and I love to argue. It seemed natural.
So I finished law school, got married, passed the CA bar, moved to Minnesota (with a few stops along the way), waived into the MN bar, worked as a litigator for a few satisfying years, moved back to CA, had a couple of kids, realized that a legal career and being a single parent for most of the year (due to husband's career) would be extremely difficult, and THEN decided to sit down and write.
And how did I end up writing romance? It’s not as divergent as it seems. What I loved about being a lawyer are the same things I love about being a writer—research and writing. The only thing missing is the arguing, but that’s what a husband and kids are for, right?
Like most writers, I’ve always loved to read. Growing up in California there was always plenty to do outside, but all too often I could be found inside curled up with a book (or two or three). I started with the usual fare: The Little House on the Prairie series, The Chronicles of Narnia, The Hobbit, Watership Down, Nancy Drew, and everything by Judy Blume. Once I cleared off my bookshelf, I started swiping books from my mom. Some, like Sidney Sheldon’s The Other Side of Midnight, probably weren’t the most appropriate choice for a pre-adolescent—although they were definitely illuminating. I can still remember the look of abject horror on my mom’s Catholic-girl-face when I asked her what a virgin was. After that rather brief conversation, she paid a little closer attention to what had disappeared off her book shelf, and steered me in the direction of Harlequin and Barbara Cartland romances. I was hooked. I quickly read through the inventory of the local library and was soon buying bags of romances at garage sales.
In high school, with the encouragement of my father (who I think was a little concerned about the steady diet of romances), I read over eighty of the Franklin Library’s One Hundred Greatest Books ever written—including Tolstoy, Confucius, Plato, and the entire works of Shakespeare. Some of them were tough going for a teenager, but the experience would prove an invaluable foundation for college. After reading War and Peace, I wasn’t easily intimidated.
For some reason Monica decided to go into writing and not fashion.
After graduation, I loaded up the VW (Jetta not Bus) and trekked down I-5 to attend the University of Southern California, majoring in Political Science and minoring in English (see why all that reading helped!). I joined the Kappa Kappa Gamma sorority, and when I wasn’t studying or at football games, did my best to support the local bartending industry. Ah, the good old days.
With that kind of fun, four years of college wasn’t quite enough. So leaving Tommy Trojan behind, I traveled back up north to Palo Alto for three more years of study at Stanford Law School. Once I survived the stress of the first semester, law school proved to be one of the best times of my life—garnering me a JD, life-long friends, a husband, and an unexpectedly intimate knowledge of baseball. (See “The Baseball Odyssey” below).
Law School was also where I fell in love with Scotland. In my third year, I took a Comparative Legal History class, and wrote a paper on the Scottish Clan System and Feudalism. So I immediately dropped out of law school and went on to write Scottish Historical Romances…well no, not quite. You see, I always knew I wanted to be a lawyer. My father was a lawyer, I was a “poet” (i.e., not into math), and I love to argue. It seemed natural.
So I finished law school, got married, passed the CA bar, moved to Minnesota (with a few stops along the way), waived into the MN bar, worked as a litigator for a few satisfying years, moved back to CA, had a couple of kids, realized that a legal career and being a single parent for most of the year (due to husband's career) would be extremely difficult, and THEN decided to sit down and write.
And how did I end up writing romance? It’s not as divergent as it seems. What I loved about being a lawyer are the same things I love about being a writer—research and writing. The only thing missing is the arguing, but that’s what a husband and kids are for, right?
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 289 reviews
February 7, 2017
When she witnessed the inhumane treatment of her mother at the hands of the English, Joan Comyn silently vowed her allegiance to the king of Scotland. As soon as she was old enough, she used her wiles to extract vital information from powerful men and delivered it to Robert Bruce and his Highland Guard. She became known only to them as the Ghost, her identity secreted. But she was infamous to all as the effect of her treachery was damaging. Alex Seaton, formerly a member of the Guard before her time, is now working on behalf of King Edward and is committed to squirreling out the spy. However, he's beguiled by Joan and she with him.
This series is ending on the highest note as the story returned to its roots in history. There's high intrigue, suspense and action with the developing romance as more of a backdrop. The war strategies of both sides were shared so I felt like I was part of the adventure. Alex's internal conflict regarding his ill-advised decision to leave the Guard made the story even more interesting as it illustrated the pertinent issues of the period.
I really enjoyed Antony Ferguson's narration as he mastered all of those Scottish names and words I have only guessed at in the past (who knew McKay was pronounced Ma-kīe). His performance was skillful even if the female voices were a little strange as he captured the emotions perfectly for each scene.
I loved this story with the poignant twist of having the final member of the featured Guard be a woman. It has every element that drew me to the series and kept me coming back. I loved the ending and am satisfied with how the series concluded. Very well done. 4.5 stars
(I received an ARC from the publisher in exchange for an honest review)
This series is ending on the highest note as the story returned to its roots in history. There's high intrigue, suspense and action with the developing romance as more of a backdrop. The war strategies of both sides were shared so I felt like I was part of the adventure. Alex's internal conflict regarding his ill-advised decision to leave the Guard made the story even more interesting as it illustrated the pertinent issues of the period.
I really enjoyed Antony Ferguson's narration as he mastered all of those Scottish names and words I have only guessed at in the past (who knew McKay was pronounced Ma-kīe). His performance was skillful even if the female voices were a little strange as he captured the emotions perfectly for each scene.
I loved this story with the poignant twist of having the final member of the featured Guard be a woman. It has every element that drew me to the series and kept me coming back. I loved the ending and am satisfied with how the series concluded. Very well done. 4.5 stars
(I received an ARC from the publisher in exchange for an honest review)
August 16, 2016
The Ghost ended much like the rest of Monica McCarty's Highland Guard series. Me in tears with a profound appreciation of historical literature. No matter how you look at it, Alex Seton is a traitor!
I wanted his hide boiled in oil, good thing I don't always get what I want. Think the author was sending subliminal messages on forgiveness and maybe in times of war, when brother is turning against brother everything isn't so black and white.
Regardless this was a hell of a five star read and the perfect conclusion to one of the best stories ever told.
Monica I was with you from the beginning and can't wait to see where you take us next! Enjoy, happy reading
I wanted his hide boiled in oil, good thing I don't always get what I want. Think the author was sending subliminal messages on forgiveness and maybe in times of war, when brother is turning against brother everything isn't so black and white.
Regardless this was a hell of a five star read and the perfect conclusion to one of the best stories ever told.
Monica I was with you from the beginning and can't wait to see where you take us next! Enjoy, happy reading
May 6, 2016
This is sadly the last book in the Highland Guard series but what a way to end this remarkable look at what is an important piece of history. This author has researched and given her own romantic slant to actual events and in doing so has brought to life such fantastical characters. Now with this book everything converges until this reader feels like I've been along on this journey and we finally get to what's arguably the most important battle in Scottish history, the famed Battle of Bannockburn!
Yet I'm getting slightly ahead of myself and must admit I've often wondered what became of the daughter of Bella MacDuff who played such a large part in the fourth book Viper. Now we see first hand that Joan has grown up with hate in her heart and a fierce need to set the rightful King on Scotland's throne. Called the Ghost Joan seduces information out of besotted English suitors but there's one who she really needs to keep a much closer eye on.
Once Alex Seton was a member of Robert the Bruce's most trusted and secret Highland Guard but he sought a more peaceful ending to the conflict and returned to England to help those he previously considered the enemy. Now considered a traitor by the Scots and distrusted by his English allies he fervently hopes to discover just who is the spy amidst them. Yet increasingly Joan infuriates him with her coquettish ways, flirting outrageously but try as he might Alex cannot want but to try to protect her. As Joan grows more determined to get intel for Bruce she's in danger from the very man who just might have stolen her heart!
This author writes such passionate romance stories. Such a rush as we watch her characters fight, squirm and ultimately fall deeply in love. Each book seems to have an intensity about it that plunges the reader headlong into the action. The fact that so much is based on actual characters and events is mind boggling. I love the interpretation, the twists and turns and its brought so much history to life. If you enjoy romance whether historical or not then this series is a must read and I cannot praise it highly enough. As for the epilogue it's everything this reader wanted and more besides. A sincere thank you Ms McCarty for this wonderful journey
I was gifted a copy via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review
Yet I'm getting slightly ahead of myself and must admit I've often wondered what became of the daughter of Bella MacDuff who played such a large part in the fourth book Viper. Now we see first hand that Joan has grown up with hate in her heart and a fierce need to set the rightful King on Scotland's throne. Called the Ghost Joan seduces information out of besotted English suitors but there's one who she really needs to keep a much closer eye on.
Once Alex Seton was a member of Robert the Bruce's most trusted and secret Highland Guard but he sought a more peaceful ending to the conflict and returned to England to help those he previously considered the enemy. Now considered a traitor by the Scots and distrusted by his English allies he fervently hopes to discover just who is the spy amidst them. Yet increasingly Joan infuriates him with her coquettish ways, flirting outrageously but try as he might Alex cannot want but to try to protect her. As Joan grows more determined to get intel for Bruce she's in danger from the very man who just might have stolen her heart!
This author writes such passionate romance stories. Such a rush as we watch her characters fight, squirm and ultimately fall deeply in love. Each book seems to have an intensity about it that plunges the reader headlong into the action. The fact that so much is based on actual characters and events is mind boggling. I love the interpretation, the twists and turns and its brought so much history to life. If you enjoy romance whether historical or not then this series is a must read and I cannot praise it highly enough. As for the epilogue it's everything this reader wanted and more besides. A sincere thank you Ms McCarty for this wonderful journey
I was gifted a copy via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review
June 5, 2019
5 'Airson an Leòmhann' stars
I almost can't believe, I finished this series. With long series, I usually lose interest or cease to like the story and give up before I reach the end. Truthfully, Highland Guard had a few 'missed' books, especially the previous one was undoubtedly lame. But still, I immensely enjoyed the very last book of the series and it managed to erase all the bad taste from before.
I was dying to read Alex and Joan's story since The Viper. More correctly since the epilogue of book 4. I remember how concerned I was when the title of the last book was announced and it was Ghost, not Dragon. I was very worried that we would be kind of cheated for Alex's book. However, after eleven books and two novellas, I finally got what I anticipated so much. Ok, enough of babbling but it's hard to contain all this enthusiasm.
Alex and Joan were a perfect couple. I can't say they are my most beloved one (Lachlan and Isabella still hold that honor) but I can certainly say they are the most unique one. After so many books, some things became pretty repetitive. Seriously, while reading I was sometimes able to guess exactly what people would say. Yeah, in every book we eventually came to this sentence "Keep looking at me like that lass and this won't take long." Apparently, Alex had more stamina because he never said that, haha. Anyway, I found Alex and Joan's love story rather refreshing and special.
As for their characters... I hopelessly fell in love with Alex. I've always liked him, you know like you love some adorable, little puppy. He was so different from the rest of the Guard - so young, so idealistic, so full of hopes and dreams, a true knight-in-a-shining-armor-on-a-white-horse kind of man. When he changed sides, I was really mad at him but it was clearly understandable why he did what he did. Having been raised on crossroads of two cultures and being torn between to nations for his whole life, I can imagine it must have been hard for him, always feeling like he doesn't belong anywhere.
I also like the development of his character. When the series started, I think he was barely twenty, and after more than ten years of war, he matured a lot. The horrors of war changed some of his idealistic views on the world and some only turned out stronger. He was a good soldier before but the war has made him a seasoned warrior. It was amazing to watch him - like many of his fellow guardsmen as well - trying to hide this fact. He always seemed so serious to me and it was enjoyable to see his cocky side. So mischievous.
I liked Joan too. I admired how she was portrayed in her role as a spy. Much more convincing than Janet was. What I liked about her characters the most was that despite her being a very independent woman who knew how to take care of herself, she wasn't afraid to ask for help when she needed it. And she never put herself in danger for foolishly trying to 'protect' Alex. What I really hate are heroines who think they need to - for any price, usually their lives - protect their love interest who just happened to be some ruthless warriors. No, they don't need protection, geez! Fortunately, Joan was not like that. I also like that she pretty quickly agreed to the marriage. I never get why in medieval romances, women are always so opposed to the marriage. They didn't have much choice then, and not wanting to marry, especially if they've been ruined, just make them stupid.
Ok, I seem to lose my track of thoughts again. Nevermind, I only want to add that this was one amazing series and I will definitely re-read some of the books.
I almost can't believe, I finished this series. With long series, I usually lose interest or cease to like the story and give up before I reach the end. Truthfully, Highland Guard had a few 'missed' books, especially the previous one was undoubtedly lame. But still, I immensely enjoyed the very last book of the series and it managed to erase all the bad taste from before.
I was dying to read Alex and Joan's story since The Viper. More correctly since the epilogue of book 4. I remember how concerned I was when the title of the last book was announced and it was Ghost, not Dragon. I was very worried that we would be kind of cheated for Alex's book. However, after eleven books and two novellas, I finally got what I anticipated so much. Ok, enough of babbling but it's hard to contain all this enthusiasm.
Alex and Joan were a perfect couple. I can't say they are my most beloved one (Lachlan and Isabella still hold that honor) but I can certainly say they are the most unique one. After so many books, some things became pretty repetitive. Seriously, while reading I was sometimes able to guess exactly what people would say. Yeah, in every book we eventually came to this sentence "Keep looking at me like that lass and this won't take long." Apparently, Alex had more stamina because he never said that, haha. Anyway, I found Alex and Joan's love story rather refreshing and special.
As for their characters... I hopelessly fell in love with Alex. I've always liked him, you know like you love some adorable, little puppy. He was so different from the rest of the Guard - so young, so idealistic, so full of hopes and dreams, a true knight-in-a-shining-armor-on-a-white-horse kind of man. When he changed sides, I was really mad at him but it was clearly understandable why he did what he did. Having been raised on crossroads of two cultures and being torn between to nations for his whole life, I can imagine it must have been hard for him, always feeling like he doesn't belong anywhere.
I also like the development of his character. When the series started, I think he was barely twenty, and after more than ten years of war, he matured a lot. The horrors of war changed some of his idealistic views on the world and some only turned out stronger. He was a good soldier before but the war has made him a seasoned warrior. It was amazing to watch him - like many of his fellow guardsmen as well - trying to hide this fact. He always seemed so serious to me and it was enjoyable to see his cocky side. So mischievous.
I liked Joan too. I admired how she was portrayed in her role as a spy. Much more convincing than Janet was. What I liked about her characters the most was that despite her being a very independent woman who knew how to take care of herself, she wasn't afraid to ask for help when she needed it. And she never put herself in danger for foolishly trying to 'protect' Alex. What I really hate are heroines who think they need to - for any price, usually their lives - protect their love interest who just happened to be some ruthless warriors. No, they don't need protection, geez! Fortunately, Joan was not like that. I also like that she pretty quickly agreed to the marriage. I never get why in medieval romances, women are always so opposed to the marriage. They didn't have much choice then, and not wanting to marry, especially if they've been ruined, just make them stupid.
Ok, I seem to lose my track of thoughts again. Nevermind, I only want to add that this was one amazing series and I will definitely re-read some of the books.
May 12, 2016
I was sad when I opened this book and read the forward from the author saying that this was going to be the final installment in this series. This author has a way of blending history into her stories that keeps you entertained, learning, involved, engaged, plus whatever other verb you want to use. She certainly was able to do that with me and I didn’t even start from the beginning of the series.
This is the 12th book in the Highlander series and it’s just as good if not the best of the stories. I have to say I fell in love with Alex. He is so sweet!! I love his gallantry, loyalty, and caring character. I don’t think an author could have nailed this guy better.
The author has a beautiful way with words that allows you to get just sucked into the story and whisked away into the thirteen hundreds. With some suspense and intrigue, there’s plenty going on on every single page and never a dull moment. You can honestly lose yourself for several hours at a time and enjoy every bit of the story.
I am sad to see the ending of this series but excited to see what else Monica McCarty will be bringing to us.
This is the 12th book in the Highlander series and it’s just as good if not the best of the stories. I have to say I fell in love with Alex. He is so sweet!! I love his gallantry, loyalty, and caring character. I don’t think an author could have nailed this guy better.
The author has a beautiful way with words that allows you to get just sucked into the story and whisked away into the thirteen hundreds. With some suspense and intrigue, there’s plenty going on on every single page and never a dull moment. You can honestly lose yourself for several hours at a time and enjoy every bit of the story.
I am sad to see the ending of this series but excited to see what else Monica McCarty will be bringing to us.
January 3, 2018
How I waited 1.5 years to read this book is evidence of how I loved this series. I have read many historical romances. If I have to pick one series to be my favorite, this would be it. I didn't want to end. So I kept postponing reading this book. It makes me so sad that this is the last book.
Alas I cannot say that this series ended with a great story, at least not for me. Monica McCarty excels at storytelling. When she has the right characters, I am led on an emotional journey and cannot put the book down. But I did not love all books in the series, this is not about Monica McCarty. It is just me not always liking the characters.
And the final entry in this series is a disappointment for me in that regard. I was not impressed by Alex's gallantry, nor was I moved by Joan's resolve and courage. I am sure that there are people who could make connections to Alex and Joan. Much to my own disappointment, I couldn't and the book was done for for me because of that.
Alex, having left his highland guard brethren behind and joined the English in book 8, the Raider, gets his own story with Bella MacDuff's daughter Joan Comyn. I loved the book the Raider, and I wondered what was going to happen to Alex. When I realized that he would be with Joan, I thought oh that is smart. Both Alex and Joan were in the middle of this English and Scottish feud, both had connections to both sides, and both were wrestling with their loyalty. It was a great idea. But other than that the relationship development and plots were lackluster. Naturally there was danger and quite some possessiveness and protectiveness going on. But in the Raider I had this image of Prince on the white horse and Knight in the shining armor for Alex. It seemed somehow comical that Alex should become this fierce warrior when my mental image for him resembled Charming in one of the Shrek movies, sauntering in on his white horse with a rose in his mouth for the lady.
And Joan was a little too jaded for my taste. It makes perfect sense that she was written the way she was. She had witnessed and experienced atrocities in life that would make anyone take off their rosy glasses. I cannot fault her character. But that did not endear her to me. I respect this character but she isn't my kind of heroine.
And the relationship, or the lack thereof, I had to sigh when I read about their "attraction". I can only say that Monica McCarty has done much better in her other books when it comes to showing the chemistry between lead characters. Suffice it to say that I was not convinced and found their courtship wanting.
The best part of the story for me, was the history. Monica McCarty has gone to great length in incorporating historical elements into this series, and this is something that I greatly appreciate. I read the author's notes at the end of every story almost as eagerly as I gobbled down the stories. The Scottish fight for independence and their way of life came to life under her pen. If you have a little knowledge about the period of Scottish history, you would find the historical elements she has woven in the characters and stories intriguing and imaginative. The real Robert the Bruce was just a man, with human failings and faults, like most historical figures. But this series gave this monumental figure in Scottish history an air of romance and this fictional band of brothers benefited from his pursuit of crown, each finding their own pieces of romance and heroism in this series. I enjoyed that as much I did the stories.
Since this story is close on the heels of the Raider in plot lines, we got to see quite a bit of Robert Boyd and his wife Rosalin Clifford, now Boyd. Since they are my favorite couple in the series, I loved it. Alex's unresolved loyalty conflict meant that we saw his return to his brethren and finally made peace with his sense of right and wrong. And since this is the last book in the series, all the characters made a brief appearance in the epilogue, with an aging Bruce, his end near. I did not like the romance in this book. But in a way I felt that this was a closure, the end of a journey, 6 years in the making. Monica McCarty has built these characters, some of them so authentic in their quest of love, their sufferings and losses, their struggles for doing the right things and their final triumphs in finding their hearts' desires. I am sad that this is the last we will be seeing of the highland guards, and that I didn't like the last story more than I do. But I have met some characters I know I will remember for a very long time. For a book lover, that is one precious thing.
And if I could humbly make one suggestion to this series or to Monica McCarty's future stories, the dialogues in her stories are sometimes too modern. This is the 13th and 14th centuries we are talking about. Monica McCarty was brilliant in incorporating historical details into her stories. But her characters sometimes sound too modern. For me, this is rather distracting. I wish their speech would be a little more, well, contemporary of their time period.
For the last time, in case you did not deduce from my long speech above, I loved the idea of this series. There are 2 - 3 books that I absolutely loved in this series. I have reread them many times. The Ghost is not one of them. That does not change my opinion of the series. I hope Monica McCarty returns to the Historical Romance genre soon and I look forward to being swept away into the past with her characters again.
Alas I cannot say that this series ended with a great story, at least not for me. Monica McCarty excels at storytelling. When she has the right characters, I am led on an emotional journey and cannot put the book down. But I did not love all books in the series, this is not about Monica McCarty. It is just me not always liking the characters.
And the final entry in this series is a disappointment for me in that regard. I was not impressed by Alex's gallantry, nor was I moved by Joan's resolve and courage. I am sure that there are people who could make connections to Alex and Joan. Much to my own disappointment, I couldn't and the book was done for for me because of that.
Alex, having left his highland guard brethren behind and joined the English in book 8, the Raider, gets his own story with Bella MacDuff's daughter Joan Comyn. I loved the book the Raider, and I wondered what was going to happen to Alex. When I realized that he would be with Joan, I thought oh that is smart. Both Alex and Joan were in the middle of this English and Scottish feud, both had connections to both sides, and both were wrestling with their loyalty. It was a great idea. But other than that the relationship development and plots were lackluster. Naturally there was danger and quite some possessiveness and protectiveness going on. But in the Raider I had this image of Prince on the white horse and Knight in the shining armor for Alex. It seemed somehow comical that Alex should become this fierce warrior when my mental image for him resembled Charming in one of the Shrek movies, sauntering in on his white horse with a rose in his mouth for the lady.
And Joan was a little too jaded for my taste. It makes perfect sense that she was written the way she was. She had witnessed and experienced atrocities in life that would make anyone take off their rosy glasses. I cannot fault her character. But that did not endear her to me. I respect this character but she isn't my kind of heroine.
And the relationship, or the lack thereof, I had to sigh when I read about their "attraction". I can only say that Monica McCarty has done much better in her other books when it comes to showing the chemistry between lead characters. Suffice it to say that I was not convinced and found their courtship wanting.
The best part of the story for me, was the history. Monica McCarty has gone to great length in incorporating historical elements into this series, and this is something that I greatly appreciate. I read the author's notes at the end of every story almost as eagerly as I gobbled down the stories. The Scottish fight for independence and their way of life came to life under her pen. If you have a little knowledge about the period of Scottish history, you would find the historical elements she has woven in the characters and stories intriguing and imaginative. The real Robert the Bruce was just a man, with human failings and faults, like most historical figures. But this series gave this monumental figure in Scottish history an air of romance and this fictional band of brothers benefited from his pursuit of crown, each finding their own pieces of romance and heroism in this series. I enjoyed that as much I did the stories.
Since this story is close on the heels of the Raider in plot lines, we got to see quite a bit of Robert Boyd and his wife Rosalin Clifford, now Boyd. Since they are my favorite couple in the series, I loved it. Alex's unresolved loyalty conflict meant that we saw his return to his brethren and finally made peace with his sense of right and wrong. And since this is the last book in the series, all the characters made a brief appearance in the epilogue, with an aging Bruce, his end near. I did not like the romance in this book. But in a way I felt that this was a closure, the end of a journey, 6 years in the making. Monica McCarty has built these characters, some of them so authentic in their quest of love, their sufferings and losses, their struggles for doing the right things and their final triumphs in finding their hearts' desires. I am sad that this is the last we will be seeing of the highland guards, and that I didn't like the last story more than I do. But I have met some characters I know I will remember for a very long time. For a book lover, that is one precious thing.
And if I could humbly make one suggestion to this series or to Monica McCarty's future stories, the dialogues in her stories are sometimes too modern. This is the 13th and 14th centuries we are talking about. Monica McCarty was brilliant in incorporating historical details into her stories. But her characters sometimes sound too modern. For me, this is rather distracting. I wish their speech would be a little more, well, contemporary of their time period.
For the last time, in case you did not deduce from my long speech above, I loved the idea of this series. There are 2 - 3 books that I absolutely loved in this series. I have reread them many times. The Ghost is not one of them. That does not change my opinion of the series. I hope Monica McCarty returns to the Historical Romance genre soon and I look forward to being swept away into the past with her characters again.
October 13, 2016
1.5 stars
Unpopular opinion alert. I'm really, really sorry.
The end of a series that had an interesting premise, covering a part of history stupidly distorted by the film Braveheart, with enough background information provided by the author to give the reader not only romance stories but a broader picture of the difficult entanglements of the British and Scottish aristocracy that lead to the ever-changing loyalties during this long war.
I think I started losing interest after book 6 or 7 because the author, whilst setting up the scenes perfectly, was unable to create more than 2-3 stereotypical sets of heroines and heroes; not to forget the constant repetition of certain phrases ("Keep looking at me like that, and I won't last long." This came up in one form or the other in almost every book), and heroines who reminded me more of the The Black Widow or Superwoman . Of course I acknowledge that women played a role in the war, as they always do in any conflict, and not a minor one either. But please, pretty please, let them show reason in regards to the danger they put themselves in as well as in how they approach the men they love. And in many of the Highland Guard books that's what was missing for me. I have mentioned all this in a few reviews for previous books.
If an author sets up a story line that tries to be historically accurate, than she should also be able to create realistic characters, or at least attempt it. I'm not reading a fluffy Regency novel here. Sadly though, character development is not Ms McCarty's strongest talent.
Nonetheless, as this was Alex Seton's story who has always been the most interesting character to me, being the only Englishman in the Highland Guard, always conflicted, thoroughly chivalrous, I was hoping, I could finish this series on a positive note.
Alas, it was not meant to be and - oh wonder - the heroine, Joan, did a good job at giving me the hives. Joan's own story had so much potential and I was looking forward to seeing her paired with Alex. But knowing Ms. McCarty's shortcomings in the character department, I wasn't really surprised how disappointing The Ghost turned out to be.
What a waste of a good story and interesting characters.
Unpopular opinion alert. I'm really, really sorry.
The end of a series that had an interesting premise, covering a part of history stupidly distorted by the film Braveheart, with enough background information provided by the author to give the reader not only romance stories but a broader picture of the difficult entanglements of the British and Scottish aristocracy that lead to the ever-changing loyalties during this long war.
I think I started losing interest after book 6 or 7 because the author, whilst setting up the scenes perfectly, was unable to create more than 2-3 stereotypical sets of heroines and heroes; not to forget the constant repetition of certain phrases ("Keep looking at me like that, and I won't last long." This came up in one form or the other in almost every book), and heroines who reminded me more of the The Black Widow or Superwoman . Of course I acknowledge that women played a role in the war, as they always do in any conflict, and not a minor one either. But please, pretty please, let them show reason in regards to the danger they put themselves in as well as in how they approach the men they love. And in many of the Highland Guard books that's what was missing for me. I have mentioned all this in a few reviews for previous books.
If an author sets up a story line that tries to be historically accurate, than she should also be able to create realistic characters, or at least attempt it. I'm not reading a fluffy Regency novel here. Sadly though, character development is not Ms McCarty's strongest talent.
Nonetheless, as this was Alex Seton's story who has always been the most interesting character to me, being the only Englishman in the Highland Guard, always conflicted, thoroughly chivalrous, I was hoping, I could finish this series on a positive note.
Alas, it was not meant to be and - oh wonder - the heroine, Joan, did a good job at giving me the hives. Joan's own story had so much potential and I was looking forward to seeing her paired with Alex. But knowing Ms. McCarty's shortcomings in the character department, I wasn't really surprised how disappointing The Ghost turned out to be.
What a waste of a good story and interesting characters.
Want to read
August 17, 2016The fact that my friend Esther DNFed this is enough to make me extremely nervous about starting this book.
Oh, dear.
Oh, dear.
Read
May 11, 2016Not going to rate this. Wouldn't be fair.
DNF....Great writing and love this author...BUT....
I just couldn't finish due to a trigger issue and contradiction (from my viewpoint anyways) of what happened with the heroine and what she presented herself as a spy (acting a certain way to gain info).
DNF....Great writing and love this author...BUT....
I just couldn't finish due to a trigger issue and contradiction (from my viewpoint anyways) of what happened with the heroine and what she presented herself as a spy (acting a certain way to gain info).
August 19, 2016
The Ghost by Monica McCarty is a 2016 Pocket Books publication. I was provided a copy of this book by the publisher and Edelweiss in exchange for an honest review.
I have had this book for a little while, but I’ve put off reading it because it is the final book in the “Highland Guard’ series, and I really hate to see this series end.
This twelfth installment features Joan Cromyn, a spy for the Scots, living in England with her cousins after she is stripped of her inheritance. She does her job so well, she had been dubbed, “The Ghost.”
Alex Seton was once in the guard, loyal to Bruce, but the war has dragged on for so long, he lost faith, believing that unless he could convince the English to work on a truce, the war would never end. To that end, Alex switches sides, hoping to find a way to end the war.
He has been commissioned to flush out the ‘The Ghost’, but he never anticipated running into Joan, Bella MacDuff’s beautiful daughter. He is shocked at how he reacts to Joan, but of course the couple can never have a life together, because her step-father would never allow her to marry a traitor. Can Joan convince Alex to rejoin ‘The Guard’, and fight once more for his own country?
Alex is perhaps the gentlest member of ‘The Guard’, and melted my heart. He is known for his gallantry and is teasingly referred to as “Sir Galahad”. What he tries to do here is something that has happened in all wars, when weariness settles in and no solution seems forthcoming. However, the English are just as mulish and he soon finds his heart and loyalties are torn more than ever before.
Joan, is an outstanding spy, and her boldness has only grown over time. But, it’s possible she is being watched and could be in grave danger. But, falling in love with Alex was never her intention, and it certainly complicates matters for her. What will Alex think if he ever discovers the truth?
I really enjoyed this last installment as it has a sentimental tone to it. The story highlights the strain and long term agony of war, and the toll it takes, but was also one of the most romantic and sensual stories of the series. I think Joan helped Alex find his way back, and Alex proved to Joan that there really are good, honorable men in this world.
I will really will miss this series. It is one of the very few that actually incorporated authentic historical detail, proving that historical accuracy enhances the romantic elements, and paints a realistic depiction of medieval days, the harshness of war, the grand love affairs, and the intense passions of the Scottish people.
Overall, the series closes on a high note with a special happily ever after.
I have had this book for a little while, but I’ve put off reading it because it is the final book in the “Highland Guard’ series, and I really hate to see this series end.
This twelfth installment features Joan Cromyn, a spy for the Scots, living in England with her cousins after she is stripped of her inheritance. She does her job so well, she had been dubbed, “The Ghost.”
Alex Seton was once in the guard, loyal to Bruce, but the war has dragged on for so long, he lost faith, believing that unless he could convince the English to work on a truce, the war would never end. To that end, Alex switches sides, hoping to find a way to end the war.
He has been commissioned to flush out the ‘The Ghost’, but he never anticipated running into Joan, Bella MacDuff’s beautiful daughter. He is shocked at how he reacts to Joan, but of course the couple can never have a life together, because her step-father would never allow her to marry a traitor. Can Joan convince Alex to rejoin ‘The Guard’, and fight once more for his own country?
Alex is perhaps the gentlest member of ‘The Guard’, and melted my heart. He is known for his gallantry and is teasingly referred to as “Sir Galahad”. What he tries to do here is something that has happened in all wars, when weariness settles in and no solution seems forthcoming. However, the English are just as mulish and he soon finds his heart and loyalties are torn more than ever before.
Joan, is an outstanding spy, and her boldness has only grown over time. But, it’s possible she is being watched and could be in grave danger. But, falling in love with Alex was never her intention, and it certainly complicates matters for her. What will Alex think if he ever discovers the truth?
I really enjoyed this last installment as it has a sentimental tone to it. The story highlights the strain and long term agony of war, and the toll it takes, but was also one of the most romantic and sensual stories of the series. I think Joan helped Alex find his way back, and Alex proved to Joan that there really are good, honorable men in this world.
I will really will miss this series. It is one of the very few that actually incorporated authentic historical detail, proving that historical accuracy enhances the romantic elements, and paints a realistic depiction of medieval days, the harshness of war, the grand love affairs, and the intense passions of the Scottish people.
Overall, the series closes on a high note with a special happily ever after.
September 26, 2016
I received an eARC, from NetGalley and the publisher, in exchange for an honest review.
'The Ghost' by Monica McCarty is book is book 15 in the "Highland Guard" series. This is the story of Joan Comyn and Alex Seton. Joan is the daughter of Bella MacDuff who story was told in book 4 of 'Highland Guard' series called "The Viper". With that said I will say this can be a standalone book.
Joan's mother Bella was taken from her at a early age and her father was an harsh if not evil man. At the age of 14 she went to help with the cause that her mother had been fighting for. Joan is an undercover spy that is called the "Ghost" in the Highland Guard group.
Alex once was a Highland Guard but since he is half English he is able to go between the Scots and English. After fight with the Highland Guards for several years which had conflicted with his English Knight honor he decide to try to work with the English to try and stop the war.
Joan has made a name for herself as being somewhat loose with her self. Which when Alex meets her again he is great attracted to her but when he finds out she gives her self out he tries to stop his feelings. Alex wants a 'pure' women when he does take one just as high as his standards.
So we find Joan struggling to keep her emotions down as she had learn when she was younger but finding it hard now...but she has to for her cover.
Will Alex find out what Joan is up to? Will he change his mind about Joan? Will Joan every learn to trust someone?
Another great book in this series!!
Please follow more reviews at the below sites:
https://www.goodreads.com/user/show/1... http://sissymaereads.blogspot.com/
https://www.facebook.com/sally.mae.39...
http://booklikes.com/
https://romancebookreviewforyou.wordp...
https://www.facebook.com/groups/17091...
https://twitter.com/soapsrus68
https://www.pinterest.com/u2soapsrus/
'The Ghost' by Monica McCarty is book is book 15 in the "Highland Guard" series. This is the story of Joan Comyn and Alex Seton. Joan is the daughter of Bella MacDuff who story was told in book 4 of 'Highland Guard' series called "The Viper". With that said I will say this can be a standalone book.
Joan's mother Bella was taken from her at a early age and her father was an harsh if not evil man. At the age of 14 she went to help with the cause that her mother had been fighting for. Joan is an undercover spy that is called the "Ghost" in the Highland Guard group.
Alex once was a Highland Guard but since he is half English he is able to go between the Scots and English. After fight with the Highland Guards for several years which had conflicted with his English Knight honor he decide to try to work with the English to try and stop the war.
Joan has made a name for herself as being somewhat loose with her self. Which when Alex meets her again he is great attracted to her but when he finds out she gives her self out he tries to stop his feelings. Alex wants a 'pure' women when he does take one just as high as his standards.
So we find Joan struggling to keep her emotions down as she had learn when she was younger but finding it hard now...but she has to for her cover.
Will Alex find out what Joan is up to? Will he change his mind about Joan? Will Joan every learn to trust someone?
Another great book in this series!!
Please follow more reviews at the below sites:
https://www.goodreads.com/user/show/1... http://sissymaereads.blogspot.com/
https://www.facebook.com/sally.mae.39...
http://booklikes.com/
https://romancebookreviewforyou.wordp...
https://www.facebook.com/groups/17091...
https://twitter.com/soapsrus68
https://www.pinterest.com/u2soapsrus/
June 1, 2016
It's LIVE!!!
Amazon
B&N
For me Joan was the star of this book. It was such a pleasure to read how a woman, during this period, was able to wield such power over these men by taking advantage of their own weaknesses. Her characterization was great and I was able to connect with her and really empathize during those tough moments. I’m not going to lie and say she was perfect because she was not. There were instances where I wanted to shake some sense into her, but I guess that’s all part of being human.
I went into this book already not liking Alex Seton very much. The Raider was my favorite book of the series and for those that have read it know that Alex was not the best in that book. I just didn’t agree with what he did in that book and I definitely didn’t support some of his actions in his book either. As a character he wasn’t the strongest and it frustrated me greatly how much he waffled with his decision to pick a side. It made him weak in my eyes, especially when his actions had an effect on Joan and her entire situation.
As a couple I think that Joan and Alex had great chemistry and I loved the scenes between them. Overall, it was an enjoyable read and I was so glad when we were able to see the other Phantoms and how they interacted with each other at the end. I have to admit that it was bittersweet because this is the last book but I can’t wait to see what other things Monica McCarty has in store for us!
Amazon
B&N
For me Joan was the star of this book. It was such a pleasure to read how a woman, during this period, was able to wield such power over these men by taking advantage of their own weaknesses. Her characterization was great and I was able to connect with her and really empathize during those tough moments. I’m not going to lie and say she was perfect because she was not. There were instances where I wanted to shake some sense into her, but I guess that’s all part of being human.
I went into this book already not liking Alex Seton very much. The Raider was my favorite book of the series and for those that have read it know that Alex was not the best in that book. I just didn’t agree with what he did in that book and I definitely didn’t support some of his actions in his book either. As a character he wasn’t the strongest and it frustrated me greatly how much he waffled with his decision to pick a side. It made him weak in my eyes, especially when his actions had an effect on Joan and her entire situation.
As a couple I think that Joan and Alex had great chemistry and I loved the scenes between them. Overall, it was an enjoyable read and I was so glad when we were able to see the other Phantoms and how they interacted with each other at the end. I have to admit that it was bittersweet because this is the last book but I can’t wait to see what other things Monica McCarty has in store for us!
May 22, 2016
If this is about The Ghost, which is a girl, why isn't there a bad-ass warrior chick on the cover. :( I was really hoping that when her story came around, she'd get her own cover.
February 18, 2019
There is no other way to say it; but this H was a beta character ... and a traitor to boot ... the h was better; she had a tragic backstory and tried her best to do what she had started ... I also liked the relationship she had built with her step-father ...
But I loved the conclusion MM gave this series ... she managed to bring the series to an end and closed the loopholes adequately ...
Also, kudos to the research she has done and the amazing notes she gives at the end of each book ... All in all, I am glad I decided to read this series in its entirety ...
But I loved the conclusion MM gave this series ... she managed to bring the series to an end and closed the loopholes adequately ...
Also, kudos to the research she has done and the amazing notes she gives at the end of each book ... All in all, I am glad I decided to read this series in its entirety ...
June 5, 2016
The conclusion of a tale six years in the making, The Ghost is the final chapter in Robert Bruce's fight for Scottish independence. So far, the Highland Guard have fought and won smaller, tactical skirmishes to strike at the heart of King Edward II's army and to spread fear. Now, the time is ripe for a decisive victory on the battlefield , to legitimize Robert Bruce's claim as rightful ruler.
The Ghost is thus set in the final days leading upto the Battle of Bannockburn, behind enemy lines. Joan Comyn (Isabella McDuff's daughter who insisted in staying back with her English cousins), has been acting as Robert Bruce's eyes and ears for all these years. Declared a bastard, her former position reduced to her cousin's companion; she makes use of this new found freedom to coax important information out of Edward's young lieutenants and passes it onto Robert.
She crosses paths with a man who she recognizes from the past, Alex Seton. Alex, once The Dragon of the Highland Guard, is now fighting on the side of the English. Disheartened and disillusioned by the never- ending War, under suspicion and alienated by Edward's commanders, Alex is a conflicted man. Vowing to clear his name, Alex volunteers to unearth the spy. Despite his chivalrous intentions, he is intrigued and drawn to Joan, reputed an infamous flirt by the Court.
With such a potentially explosive setup, and the protagonists who have been acting on the sidelines for the entire series, this final book could have been much, much more. The Ghost ultimately falls short of my expectations, by precisely not delivering what has been a trademark of this successful series.
With its past-proven ability to unflinchingly incorporate the brutality and realism of 13th century Scotland (The Viper), The Ghost is much tamer by comparison. Joan who uses tried-and-tested tactics of charming and seducing the truth out of her targets, cannot stomach being kissed or fondled by them. She relies of chance rather than cunning, takes stupid risks and leaves behind an obvious trail.
Alex - well, he was written all wrong. I can get on board with someone who clings onto the notion of honour and chivalry - but, who can harbour such fanciful notions after a stint with the Highland Guard. He should have known too well that the English were not aboveboard. It also didn't help that his loyalty and motivations were always in question. Hell, even Lachlan had an admirable motivation behind risking his life. Ms. McCarty could have done a better job as identifying himself to be a Borderlands' man, rather than dilly-dallying between the English and the Scots.
The romance too, I found to be lukewarm. I have been treated in the past to some scorching love scenes and tender emotional moments, I felt a bit let down.
Faults apart, this has been one of my favorite series for all times. Ms.McCarty has got such a talent for effortlessly combining gritty historical detailing with passionate, unforgettable romances - I can't wait to see what she would try her hand at next.
The Ghost is thus set in the final days leading upto the Battle of Bannockburn, behind enemy lines. Joan Comyn (Isabella McDuff's daughter who insisted in staying back with her English cousins), has been acting as Robert Bruce's eyes and ears for all these years. Declared a bastard, her former position reduced to her cousin's companion; she makes use of this new found freedom to coax important information out of Edward's young lieutenants and passes it onto Robert.
She crosses paths with a man who she recognizes from the past, Alex Seton. Alex, once The Dragon of the Highland Guard, is now fighting on the side of the English. Disheartened and disillusioned by the never- ending War, under suspicion and alienated by Edward's commanders, Alex is a conflicted man. Vowing to clear his name, Alex volunteers to unearth the spy. Despite his chivalrous intentions, he is intrigued and drawn to Joan, reputed an infamous flirt by the Court.
With such a potentially explosive setup, and the protagonists who have been acting on the sidelines for the entire series, this final book could have been much, much more. The Ghost ultimately falls short of my expectations, by precisely not delivering what has been a trademark of this successful series.
With its past-proven ability to unflinchingly incorporate the brutality and realism of 13th century Scotland (The Viper), The Ghost is much tamer by comparison. Joan who uses tried-and-tested tactics of charming and seducing the truth out of her targets, cannot stomach being kissed or fondled by them. She relies of chance rather than cunning, takes stupid risks and leaves behind an obvious trail.
Alex - well, he was written all wrong. I can get on board with someone who clings onto the notion of honour and chivalry - but, who can harbour such fanciful notions after a stint with the Highland Guard. He should have known too well that the English were not aboveboard. It also didn't help that his loyalty and motivations were always in question. Hell, even Lachlan had an admirable motivation behind risking his life. Ms. McCarty could have done a better job as identifying himself to be a Borderlands' man, rather than dilly-dallying between the English and the Scots.
The romance too, I found to be lukewarm. I have been treated in the past to some scorching love scenes and tender emotional moments, I felt a bit let down.
Faults apart, this has been one of my favorite series for all times. Ms.McCarty has got such a talent for effortlessly combining gritty historical detailing with passionate, unforgettable romances - I can't wait to see what she would try her hand at next.
July 5, 2016
Update - 01/31/16
And I was right, and I know I wasn't the only one. Monica McCarty shared, via her FB page, the identity of the heroine we suspected was The Ghost, and I'm thrilled! I can't wait to read Joan and Alex's story, although I'll be sad to say goodbye to the Highland Guard.
April 2015
I had an epiphany about who "The Ghost" really is...and I'm ridiculously excited about the possibility that I'm right! OMG! And seeing as how MM hasn't even finished writing the book, I have a long time to wait until I can test my theory. *sigh*
And I was right, and I know I wasn't the only one. Monica McCarty shared, via her FB page, the identity of the heroine we suspected was The Ghost, and I'm thrilled! I can't wait to read Joan and Alex's story, although I'll be sad to say goodbye to the Highland Guard.
April 2015
I had an epiphany about who "The Ghost" really is...and I'm ridiculously excited about the possibility that I'm right! OMG! And seeing as how MM hasn't even finished writing the book, I have a long time to wait until I can test my theory. *sigh*
November 5, 2021
Honestly I didn't expect to get emotional at the end of the series. But I did. The story itself is good. Not my favorite tho. For some reason, I excepted more for Seton's story.
Still, I was so happy and giggly when they got their dynamic back with the Guard.
Joan as a heroine was okay. I love reading about fierce women who would do anything for what they believe in. Even more interesting when she has to face a man who refuses to do anything and respects certain values and principles.
What truly got me emotional is the epilogue. It is Bruce's pov at the end of the war where everybody is reunited finally. Wondering if it was worth it at last...I loved reading a little recap for each member of the Guard and how they still pay tribute to William.
I probably will read the series again at some point.
Still, I was so happy and giggly when they got their dynamic back with the Guard.
Joan as a heroine was okay. I love reading about fierce women who would do anything for what they believe in. Even more interesting when she has to face a man who refuses to do anything and respects certain values and principles.
What truly got me emotional is the epilogue. It is Bruce's pov at the end of the war where everybody is reunited finally. Wondering if it was worth it at last...I loved reading a little recap for each member of the Guard and how they still pay tribute to William.
I probably will read the series again at some point.
November 24, 2016
C'est fini :'( Nannn j'étais pas prête à les quitter !
Punaise on peut dire que je l'aurai attendu le tome sur Alex, depuis le premier, et il ne m'a absolument pas déçue. Alex aura été mon chouchou jusqu'au bout, mon chevalier, mon dragon. Et quel plaisir de retrouver tous les autres, voir ce qu'ils sont devenus, ce lien qui les unit si fort. L'humour, les émotions, la qualité historique, une des meilleures séries du genre !
Punaise on peut dire que je l'aurai attendu le tome sur Alex, depuis le premier, et il ne m'a absolument pas déçue. Alex aura été mon chouchou jusqu'au bout, mon chevalier, mon dragon. Et quel plaisir de retrouver tous les autres, voir ce qu'ils sont devenus, ce lien qui les unit si fort. L'humour, les émotions, la qualité historique, une des meilleures séries du genre !
October 19, 2016
3.5 stars
October 15, 2025
***SPOILERS POR TODOS LADOS **
¡Qué manera de cerrar una saga, de verdad!
Este libro me dio TODO lo que necesitaba: romance, drama, aventura y el cierre del drama de Escocia vs Inglaterra que me tuvo tensa, tensa.
-“El impulso de tomarla en sus brazos y cubrir su boca con la suya era primordial e innegable.”
Porque claro, horny as hell estos protas jajaja, pero...
-“Tal vez sos quien tiene mucho que aprender de los hombres honorables, mi señora.”
Alex Seton, un caballero que nos demostró que el honor es algo duro de quebrantar.
“Nunca la había forzado y nunca se había mostrado reacia... pero mientras permanecía allí, mirando a sus ojos salvajes y llorosos, también sabía que había algo de cierto en sus palabras. Podría quererlo físicamente y hasta sentir algo más, pero no quería tener nada que ver con él. ¿Realmente importaba cuáles eran sus razones? Eran sus razones y, como caballero... ¿no debería mostrarle lo mismo y respetarlas?”
DIOS SANTO, creo que desde ahí dije: ok, IM IN!
Porque lo dije desde el inicio de la saga y lo diré siempre: el consentimiento ES IMPORTANTE, y este libro te lo demuestra.
Se paga con sangre —¿a quién no le gusta ver JUSTICIAAAA?— así que feliz que se le diera justicia a quien violó a Joan.
Y bueno, cómo olvidar los momentos de comedia, donde las descripciones:
-“Podía sentir la dura columna de su virilidad contra ella. Recordar cómo se sentía en su interior la volvía inquieta... ansiosa.”
O de:
-“(Había perdido la cuenta después de siete u ocho de cuántas veces la hacía llorar)”
Haciendo mención de cuántas veces se dieron pasión EN UNA NOCHE.
Amigo mío, para ser célibe, Ud. tiene mucho aguante jajajaja.
Por último, la aparición de toda la tropa de los highlanders, un súper plus.
Víbora, dando las palabras justas para que Alex finalmente entendiera que él era un highlander... pufff, épico. Aunque he de decir que aquí, el discurso de Joan se lo lleva todo.
Esa frase sobre cómo “esta lucha no es blanca o negra, son grises” fue perfecta, porque tenía toda la razón:
Alex ya no pertenecía a Inglaterra, y su verdadera lucha por la justicia estaba con Escocia. 💥
Cerrar esta saga es un sentimiento agridulce porque aunque 12 libros me pareció excesivo (sobretodo por la cantidad de spicy épico, como olvidar los desafíos a la gravedad de Halcón para su ultimo revolcón en altamar cubierto por una manta jajajaj), me disfrute tanto tanto todo! y me enamore de esos caballeros for sure
Mi raiting va: Vibora, Halcon, Ghost y Santo (se quedan conmigo estos libros)
¡Excelente lectura, gracias por este cierre tan épico!
¡Qué manera de cerrar una saga, de verdad!
Este libro me dio TODO lo que necesitaba: romance, drama, aventura y el cierre del drama de Escocia vs Inglaterra que me tuvo tensa, tensa.
-“El impulso de tomarla en sus brazos y cubrir su boca con la suya era primordial e innegable.”
Porque claro, horny as hell estos protas jajaja, pero...
-“Tal vez sos quien tiene mucho que aprender de los hombres honorables, mi señora.”
Alex Seton, un caballero que nos demostró que el honor es algo duro de quebrantar.
“Nunca la había forzado y nunca se había mostrado reacia... pero mientras permanecía allí, mirando a sus ojos salvajes y llorosos, también sabía que había algo de cierto en sus palabras. Podría quererlo físicamente y hasta sentir algo más, pero no quería tener nada que ver con él. ¿Realmente importaba cuáles eran sus razones? Eran sus razones y, como caballero... ¿no debería mostrarle lo mismo y respetarlas?”
DIOS SANTO, creo que desde ahí dije: ok, IM IN!
Porque lo dije desde el inicio de la saga y lo diré siempre: el consentimiento ES IMPORTANTE, y este libro te lo demuestra.
Se paga con sangre —¿a quién no le gusta ver JUSTICIAAAA?— así que feliz que se le diera justicia a quien violó a Joan.
Y bueno, cómo olvidar los momentos de comedia, donde las descripciones:
-“Podía sentir la dura columna de su virilidad contra ella. Recordar cómo se sentía en su interior la volvía inquieta... ansiosa.”
O de:
-“(Había perdido la cuenta después de siete u ocho de cuántas veces la hacía llorar)”
Haciendo mención de cuántas veces se dieron pasión EN UNA NOCHE.
Amigo mío, para ser célibe, Ud. tiene mucho aguante jajajaja.
Por último, la aparición de toda la tropa de los highlanders, un súper plus.
Víbora, dando las palabras justas para que Alex finalmente entendiera que él era un highlander... pufff, épico. Aunque he de decir que aquí, el discurso de Joan se lo lleva todo.
Esa frase sobre cómo “esta lucha no es blanca o negra, son grises” fue perfecta, porque tenía toda la razón:
Alex ya no pertenecía a Inglaterra, y su verdadera lucha por la justicia estaba con Escocia. 💥
Cerrar esta saga es un sentimiento agridulce porque aunque 12 libros me pareció excesivo (sobretodo por la cantidad de spicy épico, como olvidar los desafíos a la gravedad de Halcón para su ultimo revolcón en altamar cubierto por una manta jajajaj), me disfrute tanto tanto todo! y me enamore de esos caballeros for sure
Mi raiting va: Vibora, Halcon, Ghost y Santo (se quedan conmigo estos libros)
¡Excelente lectura, gracias por este cierre tan épico!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 28, 2016
Last book in the series. After waiting for the last few books to come out, I went back and re-read the series to catch up on the past 6 years. Since I knew Joan was the heroine and spy, I read The Viper with a different viewpoint. My absolute favorite scene in the whole series is the epilogue in The Viper. Bella and Lachlan are at their home and her daughter/Joan arrives by boat with a man who is obviously her husband. When I read that I was SO excited because I knew it was Joan with Seton/Dragon. I followed the next few books up until Raider watching Seton differently knowing where he was going to end up. I feel a little cheated. That scene is never revisited. In fact, I don't remember there being a scene in The Ghost where Bella and Joan are reunited.
I never really connected with Joan. She's a do anything at any cost type of heroine to get the information for Bruce/Scotland. All of McCarty's heroines are strong, but this one was a little more brash. There was something missing that I never felt the connection between her and Seton. So when we jump to love and forever, I was indifferent. Maybe because I read 14 books back to back over a month I was ready for the series to be over? Maybe I had too high of expectations for Joan/Seton? They definitely went a direction I didn't care for and never clicked with me. Around The Raider, I believe I read where McCarty changed publishers from Random House to St. Martin's. Coincidentally, the series seemed to stray a bit for me around that time.
Overall, there were parts of the book I really liked, but for the most part I felt underwhelmed and that makes me sad. The first several books - LOVE. The last half of the series - Meh. :(
I received a copy of this book through NetGalley from the publisher for an honest review.
I never really connected with Joan. She's a do anything at any cost type of heroine to get the information for Bruce/Scotland. All of McCarty's heroines are strong, but this one was a little more brash. There was something missing that I never felt the connection between her and Seton. So when we jump to love and forever, I was indifferent. Maybe because I read 14 books back to back over a month I was ready for the series to be over? Maybe I had too high of expectations for Joan/Seton? They definitely went a direction I didn't care for and never clicked with me. Around The Raider, I believe I read where McCarty changed publishers from Random House to St. Martin's. Coincidentally, the series seemed to stray a bit for me around that time.
Overall, there were parts of the book I really liked, but for the most part I felt underwhelmed and that makes me sad. The first several books - LOVE. The last half of the series - Meh. :(
I received a copy of this book through NetGalley from the publisher for an honest review.
May 27, 2016
What an amazing series! The Ghost, sadly, is the last installment within the Highland Guard series. The author, Monica McCarty, has taken her readers on a magnificent journey and she ended it with a wonderful story. Not to mention, I’ve been anticipating Alex “Dragon” Seton’s book for some time now. He appeared in previous works and I always enjoyed his chivalric character.
Two year prior, Alex left the mysterious Highland Guard and returned to England. Viewed as a traitor by the Scottish he once aided and untrusted by his fellow Englishmen, he struggles to find a common ground and peace. He is also interested in discovering the identity of the spy within the English camp that has been feeding intel to Bruce.
Joan Comyn is the daughter of previously mentioned character within the series. She is cynical, wary when it comes to men, and wants nothing more than to see the rightful ruler on the Scottish throne. She uses whatever means necessary to gain information, though she isn’t thrilled by it. But when her next assignment is to chisel away at the honorable, caring knight that tries to protect her, she ends up falling for him – making the plot complicated and so much fun since Alex tries to distance himself from Joan, but can’t.
The romance and tension is spectacular even though this book isn’t as emotionally charged as some of the previous installments. The battle between the English and Scottish comes to a head in arguably one of the most important battles in British Isles history.
The ending of the series is just as fabulous as the beginning and I can’t wait to read from this author. I hope she has another series in the works.
Two year prior, Alex left the mysterious Highland Guard and returned to England. Viewed as a traitor by the Scottish he once aided and untrusted by his fellow Englishmen, he struggles to find a common ground and peace. He is also interested in discovering the identity of the spy within the English camp that has been feeding intel to Bruce.
Joan Comyn is the daughter of previously mentioned character within the series. She is cynical, wary when it comes to men, and wants nothing more than to see the rightful ruler on the Scottish throne. She uses whatever means necessary to gain information, though she isn’t thrilled by it. But when her next assignment is to chisel away at the honorable, caring knight that tries to protect her, she ends up falling for him – making the plot complicated and so much fun since Alex tries to distance himself from Joan, but can’t.
The romance and tension is spectacular even though this book isn’t as emotionally charged as some of the previous installments. The battle between the English and Scottish comes to a head in arguably one of the most important battles in British Isles history.
The ending of the series is just as fabulous as the beginning and I can’t wait to read from this author. I hope she has another series in the works.
June 10, 2016
Copyright Night Owl Reviews
3.5 Stars
The Ghost is the twelfth and final book in the Highland Guard series. This is the first book I have read of the Highland Guards, so it can be read as a standalone title. However, I would have preferred to read all the other books in order simply because that is the way I like to do things. I feel like you get more background information and develop a bond with the characters when you start at the beginning of the series.
It took me longer than usual to finish this book. The book itself wasn't at fault, rather my concentration and the fact that I didn't read the series in order was to blame. One thing I feel I should point out is the dialogue. It didn't seem to fit the time period. Sure, there were a few words here and there that were used back then but I felt like there needed to be more dialect. It was almost like reading a modern Scottish/English romance instead of one taking place in the 1300's.
To see my full review, please click the link below:
https://www.nightowlreviews.com/v5/Re...
3.5 Stars
The Ghost is the twelfth and final book in the Highland Guard series. This is the first book I have read of the Highland Guards, so it can be read as a standalone title. However, I would have preferred to read all the other books in order simply because that is the way I like to do things. I feel like you get more background information and develop a bond with the characters when you start at the beginning of the series.
It took me longer than usual to finish this book. The book itself wasn't at fault, rather my concentration and the fact that I didn't read the series in order was to blame. One thing I feel I should point out is the dialogue. It didn't seem to fit the time period. Sure, there were a few words here and there that were used back then but I felt like there needed to be more dialect. It was almost like reading a modern Scottish/English romance instead of one taking place in the 1300's.
To see my full review, please click the link below:
https://www.nightowlreviews.com/v5/Re...
November 28, 2025
Reread
This is a re read. Originally I had rated it 5 stars and most of the way through j was questioning “why” then as I wrapped it up, I remembered. An epic conclusion to probably my all time favorite Scottish Warriors series. Plot 8(1-10) steaminess 7.5(1-10) I encourage you to read every book. They are more enjoyable in order!
This is a re read. Originally I had rated it 5 stars and most of the way through j was questioning “why” then as I wrapped it up, I remembered. An epic conclusion to probably my all time favorite Scottish Warriors series. Plot 8(1-10) steaminess 7.5(1-10) I encourage you to read every book. They are more enjoyable in order!
August 10, 2016
The end of a wonderful series!
February 6, 2019
Interesting twists on historical facts. Both were entertaining. Love that the author gives both. More than your usual romance novel, but there's still plenty of romance.
May 6, 2016
With a heavy heart and tears this will sadly be my last "A Highland Guard Novel" review. Brilliant author, Monica McCarty's finale , The Ghost" is book #12, the last book and finale of the series. I have utterly and absolutely loved all twelve books, each book is a masterpiece in its own rite. Yes Monica McCarty, is one of those rare, gifted authors who lines true, factual history, with a captivating unique and original fictional romance, my in my favorite genres to read about historical Scotland. I am so sad this is the last book in the series, but look forward to her next journey as I love history and I love romance and the combination is icing on the cake for me!
The Ghost" By Monica McCarty
A Highland Guards Novel, Book #12, The Finale to be released on 5/31/2016
Carlisle Castle, Cumbria
England, 1314
Joan Comryn saw how they tortured and put her Scottish patriot mother, Bella MacDuff in a cage at age 12. This was an unheard punishment for a woman. Condemned by her father John and the cruel sadistic brutal English King! From that day on her father was dead to her and swore to the allegiance of Robert the Bruce. From that day on she had to grow up fast and after her father died the King declared her illegitimate and a bastard and gave all her wealth and holding to her cousins who is now her guardians. She finds out men's secrets through seduction but and sabotage making them think they had their wicked ways with her. Funny how flirting, seduction, whiskey and a sleeping draught can loosen a man's tongue! Then she passes her message to the Bruce.
Even most of the Highland Guard know her only as the Ghost and not who she is or that she is even a woman. Luckily her stepfather Lachland "Viper" MacRuairi has taught her how to defend herself and get out of sticky situations. She could live with her family in Scotland in an instant if she chose. Joan is stubborn, has been doing this for the last six years and won't stop in the middle of a mission. Especially now so close to the great war and battle they have been anticipating! It's a dangerous game she is playing and soon she meets her match when she she meets former Highland Guard deserter and traitor Alex "Dragon Seton!
You can feel the chemistry and attraction between the handsome former brethren of the Highland Guard and soon finds out he is suspected of being the spy by the English. This makes Alex furious as he sees he is not trusted again, no matter what side he is on! As the English know the Ghost is among them passing along their information to The Bruce camp. Alex is determined to find this spy he just doesn't think it's the woman he is cares for.....yet!
Joan hasn't really felt for anyone since she was a girl due to her allegiance and mission to The Bruce and a past tragic betrayal. She closes off her emotions, so Alex storming into her heart is some what of a shock and surprise! She knows how Alex believes in honor and honesty over everything and feels they only way they can have a future is for him to change sides. It is the only way she can reveal the truth and where her loyalties truly lie. Can she trust him and give him her heart? Will her Highland Guard brethren even accept him back after Alex's betrayal two years ago? Will he pick love over honor or will he betray her in the worst way of all? To reveal her darkest secret and report that Joan is the spy "The Ghost" who has been helping The Bruce all along? To find out the answers and so much more you will have to read this magnificent book to see for yourself.
Another powerful exhilarating emotional Highland Guard book that I could not put down. It was wonderful how Ms. McCarty pieced and ended the series - is pure perfection if you ask me. Like part of a puzzle that fit in perfectly or a missing link that was discovered.
Of course being that's it the final the last book in the series I found it emotional at times but filled with all the right elements readers love in a Highland Guard novel. Filled with drama, mystery suspense, murder, brutality, torture, capture, manipulation, war, betrayal, seduction, heartbreak, romance, passion, love and so much more! The setting is absolutely breathtaking, heartwarming characters that always seems so real and spectacular dialogue. Another phenomenal read to add to your Highland Guard collection which is a masterpiece in itself!
Yes I loved it and recommending it is an understatement, believe me you don't want to miss this one. You can read in series order or a stand alone book, another great quality in her books. I do recommend reading all 12 satisfying from start to finish in each and every one!
I have enjoyed it so much so thank you Monica McCarty for telling this story it truly touched my heart and warmed my soul! This is of one of my most favorite heroes and royal icons in Scottish history - King Robert, The Bruce, in your fictional tale of his elite warriors "The Highland Guard". It's been an a wonderful journey and I have love, love, loved it so very much, as their aren't enough words to describe how much I have loved all the books, stories and character's in this mega marvelous series!"The Ghost", Joan and Alex's story was no different except maybe I cried a bit more being the last one, but another beautiful story and masterpiece headed to my keeper shelf! I look forward to your next book and series on your next writing journey as I will be waiting with bated breath for its release to read!.......Sláinte Mhath, Celtic Barb
celticbarb.blogspot.com
Tartan Book Reviews
**I was given this ARC review copy by Pocket Books of Simon & Schuster Publishers in exchange for a honest review through netgalley.com**
A Highland Guard Novel Complete Collection by Monica McCarty
1) The Chief
2) The Hawk
3) The Ranger
4) The Viper
5) The Saint
6) The Recruit
7) The Hunter
7.5) The Knight -Ebook Novella
8) The Raider
9) The Arrow
10)The Striker
11) The Rock
11.5) The Rogue - ebook and print book novella only avail online
12) The Ghost - to be released 5/31/2016
The Ghost" By Monica McCarty
A Highland Guards Novel, Book #12, The Finale to be released on 5/31/2016
Carlisle Castle, Cumbria
England, 1314
Joan Comryn saw how they tortured and put her Scottish patriot mother, Bella MacDuff in a cage at age 12. This was an unheard punishment for a woman. Condemned by her father John and the cruel sadistic brutal English King! From that day on her father was dead to her and swore to the allegiance of Robert the Bruce. From that day on she had to grow up fast and after her father died the King declared her illegitimate and a bastard and gave all her wealth and holding to her cousins who is now her guardians. She finds out men's secrets through seduction but and sabotage making them think they had their wicked ways with her. Funny how flirting, seduction, whiskey and a sleeping draught can loosen a man's tongue! Then she passes her message to the Bruce.
Even most of the Highland Guard know her only as the Ghost and not who she is or that she is even a woman. Luckily her stepfather Lachland "Viper" MacRuairi has taught her how to defend herself and get out of sticky situations. She could live with her family in Scotland in an instant if she chose. Joan is stubborn, has been doing this for the last six years and won't stop in the middle of a mission. Especially now so close to the great war and battle they have been anticipating! It's a dangerous game she is playing and soon she meets her match when she she meets former Highland Guard deserter and traitor Alex "Dragon Seton!
You can feel the chemistry and attraction between the handsome former brethren of the Highland Guard and soon finds out he is suspected of being the spy by the English. This makes Alex furious as he sees he is not trusted again, no matter what side he is on! As the English know the Ghost is among them passing along their information to The Bruce camp. Alex is determined to find this spy he just doesn't think it's the woman he is cares for.....yet!
Joan hasn't really felt for anyone since she was a girl due to her allegiance and mission to The Bruce and a past tragic betrayal. She closes off her emotions, so Alex storming into her heart is some what of a shock and surprise! She knows how Alex believes in honor and honesty over everything and feels they only way they can have a future is for him to change sides. It is the only way she can reveal the truth and where her loyalties truly lie. Can she trust him and give him her heart? Will her Highland Guard brethren even accept him back after Alex's betrayal two years ago? Will he pick love over honor or will he betray her in the worst way of all? To reveal her darkest secret and report that Joan is the spy "The Ghost" who has been helping The Bruce all along? To find out the answers and so much more you will have to read this magnificent book to see for yourself.
Another powerful exhilarating emotional Highland Guard book that I could not put down. It was wonderful how Ms. McCarty pieced and ended the series - is pure perfection if you ask me. Like part of a puzzle that fit in perfectly or a missing link that was discovered.
Of course being that's it the final the last book in the series I found it emotional at times but filled with all the right elements readers love in a Highland Guard novel. Filled with drama, mystery suspense, murder, brutality, torture, capture, manipulation, war, betrayal, seduction, heartbreak, romance, passion, love and so much more! The setting is absolutely breathtaking, heartwarming characters that always seems so real and spectacular dialogue. Another phenomenal read to add to your Highland Guard collection which is a masterpiece in itself!
Yes I loved it and recommending it is an understatement, believe me you don't want to miss this one. You can read in series order or a stand alone book, another great quality in her books. I do recommend reading all 12 satisfying from start to finish in each and every one!
I have enjoyed it so much so thank you Monica McCarty for telling this story it truly touched my heart and warmed my soul! This is of one of my most favorite heroes and royal icons in Scottish history - King Robert, The Bruce, in your fictional tale of his elite warriors "The Highland Guard". It's been an a wonderful journey and I have love, love, loved it so very much, as their aren't enough words to describe how much I have loved all the books, stories and character's in this mega marvelous series!"The Ghost", Joan and Alex's story was no different except maybe I cried a bit more being the last one, but another beautiful story and masterpiece headed to my keeper shelf! I look forward to your next book and series on your next writing journey as I will be waiting with bated breath for its release to read!.......Sláinte Mhath, Celtic Barb
celticbarb.blogspot.com
Tartan Book Reviews
**I was given this ARC review copy by Pocket Books of Simon & Schuster Publishers in exchange for a honest review through netgalley.com**
A Highland Guard Novel Complete Collection by Monica McCarty
1) The Chief
2) The Hawk
3) The Ranger
4) The Viper
5) The Saint
6) The Recruit
7) The Hunter
7.5) The Knight -Ebook Novella
8) The Raider
9) The Arrow
10)The Striker
11) The Rock
11.5) The Rogue - ebook and print book novella only avail online
12) The Ghost - to be released 5/31/2016
April 19, 2016
This review is incredibly bittersweet for me, as it marks the end of my favourite series in all of literature. I picked up The Chief- the first book in the Highland Guard series- when I was 19 years old, and here I am six years later, trying to find a way to put all my love for the final book into something resembling a coherent review.
So first of all, I want to say a huge thank you to Monica McCarty. You have given us the kinds of stories that fantasies and dreams are made of. I am so incredibly grateful, and I know the rest of your readers are too. Truly. From the bottom of my heart. Thank you.
"What fantasies and dreams are made of." Nowhere is this more true than in The Ghost, with the absolutely incredible hero that is Alex Seton. I loved him from the very beginning of this series, with his moral compass pointing unwaveringly at due North, his unfailing chivalry and respect for the ladies we see him interact with, and his increasing frustration with the (in his mind) distasteful things he is forced to do as a member of the Highland Guard.
If you are all caught up with the series to this point, then you know that this conflict between right and wrong, pirate warfare and the knightly code, black/white and shades of grey, eventually drove Alex to quit the Highland Guard and join the English instead. He hoped he could bring an end to the war from the other side, while protecting his people in the Borders from the brutal retaliatory warfare he believed the Highland Guard's pirate tactics were only making worse, not better. But he has been frustrated at every turn by his arrogant English compatriots, and is beginning to wonder whether he made the right choice. This is where we find him when the novel begins.
Joan Comyn, on the other hand, knows exactly what she wants, and exactly how far she is willing to go to get it. Ever since witnessing the cruel torture of her mother by the English, she will stop at nothing to help Robert the Bruce to victory, even at the risk of her reputation and her safety. She has no problem playing the harlot to get close enough to King Edward's lieutenants to gain their secrets, and play the harlot she does. And It. Is. Brilliant. Did I cringe and wish she didn't have to go to such lengths to get information? Yes. Did I think she was one kick-ass alpha female for being so brave in the service of her cause? Oh heck yes. I would be gal pals with this woman in a heartbeat.
Joan is strong-minded, bold, seductive, brilliant, and just as tough as her adoptive father, Lachlan "Viper" MacRuairi. A feminine match for any one of the Highland Guard. She is an incredible heroine. She is also vulnerable and uncertain in many ways due to certain events that have happened in her past, but masks these insecurities by playing her role as "femme fatale" with skill.
Enter Alex Seton. Joan, as an experienced woman (well, at least, a woman with an "experienced reputation"), is exactly the opposite of what he would previously have thought himself attracted to. He has some charmingly old-fashioned ideas about love, intimacy, and marriage, and Joan doesn't exactly fit the mould. But he is drawn to her, and she to him, and it is electric and irresistible. His desire and tenderness for Joan battles with what he THOUGHT was his ironclad honour, and by the end of the book, those lines in the sand of his are not nearly as solid as he once thought. It's an amazing, and intelligently written, journey to witness.
And when he decides it's Joan he wants, he pursues her with such charmingly gentlemanly persuasion and single-mindedness (not to mention fan-yourself passion) I swear I was a puddle on the floor just reading it. No woman could say no to this man. I'm warning you now: he will make you wish he was real more than any other hero McCarty has written to date. And THAT is saying a lot. He doesn't just talk the talk when it comes to chivalry and respecting women, as you can see from this sweet exchange with Joan, which tells you all you need to know about why I fell in love with Alex Seton:
"You have much to learn about dishonor, Sir Alex. A kiss hardly qualifies."
"Maybe it is you who have much to learn about honorable men, my lady."
Done. Gone. Seriously. A puddle on the floor. And I only melted more as the book went on.
There is one scene in particular where he finds out about a trauma from Joan's past, and his reaction was truly one for the ages. This man. Oh my goodness. This. Man.
So, in summary, this book was beautiful, and the perfect ending to a perfect series. It literally could not have been better. And, thankfully, we got to see plenty of the Highland Guard in this one. Everything was resolved beautifully, and the epilogue brought tears to my eyes. Again, so bittersweet to know this series is now over.
But what a series it was.
Thank you, Monica McCarty, for The Ghost, and thank you for the Highland Guard. It's been quite a journey, and I'm so glad you brought us along for the ride.
So first of all, I want to say a huge thank you to Monica McCarty. You have given us the kinds of stories that fantasies and dreams are made of. I am so incredibly grateful, and I know the rest of your readers are too. Truly. From the bottom of my heart. Thank you.
"What fantasies and dreams are made of." Nowhere is this more true than in The Ghost, with the absolutely incredible hero that is Alex Seton. I loved him from the very beginning of this series, with his moral compass pointing unwaveringly at due North, his unfailing chivalry and respect for the ladies we see him interact with, and his increasing frustration with the (in his mind) distasteful things he is forced to do as a member of the Highland Guard.
If you are all caught up with the series to this point, then you know that this conflict between right and wrong, pirate warfare and the knightly code, black/white and shades of grey, eventually drove Alex to quit the Highland Guard and join the English instead. He hoped he could bring an end to the war from the other side, while protecting his people in the Borders from the brutal retaliatory warfare he believed the Highland Guard's pirate tactics were only making worse, not better. But he has been frustrated at every turn by his arrogant English compatriots, and is beginning to wonder whether he made the right choice. This is where we find him when the novel begins.
Joan Comyn, on the other hand, knows exactly what she wants, and exactly how far she is willing to go to get it. Ever since witnessing the cruel torture of her mother by the English, she will stop at nothing to help Robert the Bruce to victory, even at the risk of her reputation and her safety. She has no problem playing the harlot to get close enough to King Edward's lieutenants to gain their secrets, and play the harlot she does. And It. Is. Brilliant. Did I cringe and wish she didn't have to go to such lengths to get information? Yes. Did I think she was one kick-ass alpha female for being so brave in the service of her cause? Oh heck yes. I would be gal pals with this woman in a heartbeat.
Joan is strong-minded, bold, seductive, brilliant, and just as tough as her adoptive father, Lachlan "Viper" MacRuairi. A feminine match for any one of the Highland Guard. She is an incredible heroine. She is also vulnerable and uncertain in many ways due to certain events that have happened in her past, but masks these insecurities by playing her role as "femme fatale" with skill.
Enter Alex Seton. Joan, as an experienced woman (well, at least, a woman with an "experienced reputation"), is exactly the opposite of what he would previously have thought himself attracted to. He has some charmingly old-fashioned ideas about love, intimacy, and marriage, and Joan doesn't exactly fit the mould. But he is drawn to her, and she to him, and it is electric and irresistible. His desire and tenderness for Joan battles with what he THOUGHT was his ironclad honour, and by the end of the book, those lines in the sand of his are not nearly as solid as he once thought. It's an amazing, and intelligently written, journey to witness.
And when he decides it's Joan he wants, he pursues her with such charmingly gentlemanly persuasion and single-mindedness (not to mention fan-yourself passion) I swear I was a puddle on the floor just reading it. No woman could say no to this man. I'm warning you now: he will make you wish he was real more than any other hero McCarty has written to date. And THAT is saying a lot. He doesn't just talk the talk when it comes to chivalry and respecting women, as you can see from this sweet exchange with Joan, which tells you all you need to know about why I fell in love with Alex Seton:
"You have much to learn about dishonor, Sir Alex. A kiss hardly qualifies."
"Maybe it is you who have much to learn about honorable men, my lady."
Done. Gone. Seriously. A puddle on the floor. And I only melted more as the book went on.
There is one scene in particular where he finds out about a trauma from Joan's past, and his reaction was truly one for the ages. This man. Oh my goodness. This. Man.
So, in summary, this book was beautiful, and the perfect ending to a perfect series. It literally could not have been better. And, thankfully, we got to see plenty of the Highland Guard in this one. Everything was resolved beautifully, and the epilogue brought tears to my eyes. Again, so bittersweet to know this series is now over.
But what a series it was.
Thank you, Monica McCarty, for The Ghost, and thank you for the Highland Guard. It's been quite a journey, and I'm so glad you brought us along for the ride.
September 26, 2022
4 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
A full 4 fulfilling stars for this book....the last in a series that I really didn't want to end. I put off reading this book because this Highland Guard Series from Monica McCarty really got under my skin and as much as I wanted resolution, I also didn't want it to be over. I am a series reader and this was a beautiful series...set in the ~8 years war for Scottish independence from 1306-1314, McCarty was able to make almost every book action packed. She had a way of integrating the harrowing story of Robert the Bruce and his unlikely 8-years-in-the-making victory over the English with hot fictional love stories. The backdrop of infighting among the Scottish clans, of families torn apart by the choice of allegiances and of pirate warfare that the Scots employed to overcome the much larger and better-supplied English forces was tailor-made for tales of spies and betrayal and love stories that seemed all, but impossible. The best kind.
A full 4 fulfilling stars for this book....the last in a series that I really didn't want to end. I put off reading this book because this Highland Guard Series from Monica McCarty really got under my skin and as much as I wanted resolution, I also didn't want it to be over. I am a series reader and this was a beautiful series...set in the ~8 years war for Scottish independence from 1306-1314, McCarty was able to make almost every book action packed. She had a way of integrating the harrowing story of Robert the Bruce and his unlikely 8-years-in-the-making victory over the English with hot fictional love stories. The backdrop of infighting among the Scottish clans, of families torn apart by the choice of allegiances and of pirate warfare that the Scots employed to overcome the much larger and better-supplied English forces was tailor-made for tales of spies and betrayal and love stories that seemed all, but impossible. The best kind.
September 30, 2025
Que gran FÍNALE.
Este es el mejor libro de toda la saga. Lo que me lleva a pensar que una saga de 12 libros terminando con el mejor es una hazaña enorme.
Que buenos protagonistas fueron Alex y Joan. Que buenas peleas y dilemas morales y físicos.
Se me aguaron los ojos en más de una oportunidad. Ver a toda la guardia unida fue un hermoso plus 🥹😭.
Que buen libro, que buena historia de verdad.
Este es el mejor libro de toda la saga. Lo que me lleva a pensar que una saga de 12 libros terminando con el mejor es una hazaña enorme.
Que buenos protagonistas fueron Alex y Joan. Que buenas peleas y dilemas morales y físicos.
Se me aguaron los ojos en más de una oportunidad. Ver a toda la guardia unida fue un hermoso plus 🥹😭.
Que buen libro, que buena historia de verdad.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 289 reviews