What do you think?
Rate this book
The Lucy Lawrence Mysteries #5
The Carver Affair
When Peggy O'Reilly steps off the Wexford train, she dreams of a fresh start. Within days, she's vanished into Dublin's shadows, and soon the search for a missing girl has become a hunt for a killer...
Dublin, 1894. Lucy Lawrence arrives in Ireland expecting a pleasant summer holiday while her husband Phineas investigates security at Dublin Castle. But when her maid's young cousin disappears and is found murdered in the notorious Monto red-light district, Lucy cannot stand idly by, especially when the girl's sister is still missing.
In Merrion Square, banker Myles Carver grieves his dying wife with his beautiful daughter-in-law Olivia. In the Monto's brothels, madam Celine Burton rules through violence and fear. Between these two worlds stands Detective Inspector Fergus Ryan, hunting a killer while the powerful protect their secrets. As bodies mount and time runs out, Lucy must decide who to trust in a city full of contradictions.
From sumptuous drawing rooms to squalid brothels the police dare not enter, this is a gripping Victorian mystery and a thrilling addition to the bestselling Lucy Lawrence series.
Dublin, 1894. Lucy Lawrence arrives in Ireland expecting a pleasant summer holiday while her husband Phineas investigates security at Dublin Castle. But when her maid's young cousin disappears and is found murdered in the notorious Monto red-light district, Lucy cannot stand idly by, especially when the girl's sister is still missing.
In Merrion Square, banker Myles Carver grieves his dying wife with his beautiful daughter-in-law Olivia. In the Monto's brothels, madam Celine Burton rules through violence and fear. Between these two worlds stands Detective Inspector Fergus Ryan, hunting a killer while the powerful protect their secrets. As bodies mount and time runs out, Lucy must decide who to trust in a city full of contradictions.
From sumptuous drawing rooms to squalid brothels the police dare not enter, this is a gripping Victorian mystery and a thrilling addition to the bestselling Lucy Lawrence series.
294 pages, Kindle Edition
Published January 22, 2026
24 people are currently reading
44 people want to read
About the author
Pam Lecky
18 books300 followersPam Lecky is an Irish historical fiction author, represented by Susanna Lea & Associates, London. She is a member of the Historical Novel Society, the Crime Writers Association, and the Society of Authors.
Since 2020, Pam has been writing for Avon Books UK, and in January 2024, she signed a 4 book deal with Storm Publishing.
Her debut novel, The Bowes Inheritance, was awarded the B.R.A.G Medallion; shortlisted for the Carousel Aware Prize 2016; and long-listed for the Historical Novel Society 2016 Indie Award.
Pam lives in north county Dublin, close to the sea, where she loves to walk the beach, garden and herd her three PAs (2 cats and a dog!).
Since 2020, Pam has been writing for Avon Books UK, and in January 2024, she signed a 4 book deal with Storm Publishing.
Her debut novel, The Bowes Inheritance, was awarded the B.R.A.G Medallion; shortlisted for the Carousel Aware Prize 2016; and long-listed for the Historical Novel Society 2016 Indie Award.
Pam lives in north county Dublin, close to the sea, where she loves to walk the beach, garden and herd her three PAs (2 cats and a dog!).
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 30 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
The Carver Affair by Pam Lecky
Synopsis /
Dublin, 1894. Lucy Lawrence arrives in Ireland expecting a pleasant summer holiday while her husband Phineas investigates security at Dublin Castle. But when her maid's young cousin disappears and is found murdered in the notorious Monto red-light district, Lucy cannot stand idly by, especially when the girl's sister is still missing.
In Merrion Square, banker Myles Carver grieves his dying wife with his beautiful daughter-in-law Olivia. In the Monto's brothels, madam Celine Burton rules through violence and fear. Between these two worlds stands Detective Inspector Fergus Ryan, hunting a killer while the powerful protect their secrets. As bodies mount and time runs out, Lucy must decide who to trust in a city full of contradictions.
My Thoughts /
First and foremost, a huge THANK YOU to NetGalley, Storm Publishing and author, Pam Lecky for providing me with a copy of this publication, which allows me to provide you with an unbiased review.
The Carver Affair – Book 5 of the Lucy Lawrence Mysteries
Like wine and cheese, this series keeps getting better with age.
It seems like forever and a day since I read No Stone Unturned, where author, Pam Lecky, introduced the reader to her MC, Lucy Lawrence. In the interests of transparency, I loved everything about the book – setting, plot and writing; but the character of Lucy Lawrence? Hmm, not so much. For an intelligent, capable woman, there were occasions where I found her decision making a little reckless and far, far too spontaneous.
That was July 2024. Fast forward to December 2025, and at the end of The Carver Affair, author Pam Lecky has gifted Lucy Lawrence with personal and emotional growth – happiness and well-being, self-confidence and authenticity, and more importantly (and this one's a biggie), emotional intelligence. Ding, Ding, Ding – we have a winner!!!!!!!!!!
This reader looks for the following components in a story.
📚 Events (chronology and narrative);
📚 Storylines (plots and subplots);
📚 Characters (protagonist, antagonist and their relationships).
In the preceding books in this series, Lecky never had any trouble excelling with the first two points, but I always had issues with the characters. The Carver Affair changes that and is why I can easily (and happily) rate this book 5 sparkling stars.
The Carver Affair begins a few years after the end of book #4. No longer "newly weds", Phin and Lucy are now "parents" to two rambunctious children. Phineas is continuing in his role as an investigator for an insurance company, and it's this role that takes the young family to Dublin. With the children no longer "babies", Lucy is keen to get more involved in investigative work. So when Lucy's maid, Mary, comes to her employer with news that her two teenage cousins are missing – and Mary's aunt thinks something untoward has happened, Lucy is keen to help.
Lecky has a gift for making this time period authentic. The writing is atmospheric, making this story compelling and hard to put down. The plot does not try to persuade or impress; but rather, entertain and inform the reader - vintage Lecky.
I'm already counting down the days until I can get my hands on book #6. Let's hope the wait is not too long.
With thanks to NetGalley and especially to one of my favourite publishers, Storm Publishing 💗 for the much appreciated arc in return for an honest review. All opinions expressed in this review are my own. The publication date is currently set for January 22, 2026.
Synopsis /
Dublin, 1894. Lucy Lawrence arrives in Ireland expecting a pleasant summer holiday while her husband Phineas investigates security at Dublin Castle. But when her maid's young cousin disappears and is found murdered in the notorious Monto red-light district, Lucy cannot stand idly by, especially when the girl's sister is still missing.
In Merrion Square, banker Myles Carver grieves his dying wife with his beautiful daughter-in-law Olivia. In the Monto's brothels, madam Celine Burton rules through violence and fear. Between these two worlds stands Detective Inspector Fergus Ryan, hunting a killer while the powerful protect their secrets. As bodies mount and time runs out, Lucy must decide who to trust in a city full of contradictions.
My Thoughts /
First and foremost, a huge THANK YOU to NetGalley, Storm Publishing and author, Pam Lecky for providing me with a copy of this publication, which allows me to provide you with an unbiased review.
The Carver Affair – Book 5 of the Lucy Lawrence Mysteries
Like wine and cheese, this series keeps getting better with age.
It seems like forever and a day since I read No Stone Unturned, where author, Pam Lecky, introduced the reader to her MC, Lucy Lawrence. In the interests of transparency, I loved everything about the book – setting, plot and writing; but the character of Lucy Lawrence? Hmm, not so much. For an intelligent, capable woman, there were occasions where I found her decision making a little reckless and far, far too spontaneous.
That was July 2024. Fast forward to December 2025, and at the end of The Carver Affair, author Pam Lecky has gifted Lucy Lawrence with personal and emotional growth – happiness and well-being, self-confidence and authenticity, and more importantly (and this one's a biggie), emotional intelligence. Ding, Ding, Ding – we have a winner!!!!!!!!!!
This reader looks for the following components in a story.
📚 Events (chronology and narrative);
📚 Storylines (plots and subplots);
📚 Characters (protagonist, antagonist and their relationships).
In the preceding books in this series, Lecky never had any trouble excelling with the first two points, but I always had issues with the characters. The Carver Affair changes that and is why I can easily (and happily) rate this book 5 sparkling stars.
The Carver Affair begins a few years after the end of book #4. No longer "newly weds", Phin and Lucy are now "parents" to two rambunctious children. Phineas is continuing in his role as an investigator for an insurance company, and it's this role that takes the young family to Dublin. With the children no longer "babies", Lucy is keen to get more involved in investigative work. So when Lucy's maid, Mary, comes to her employer with news that her two teenage cousins are missing – and Mary's aunt thinks something untoward has happened, Lucy is keen to help.
Lecky has a gift for making this time period authentic. The writing is atmospheric, making this story compelling and hard to put down. The plot does not try to persuade or impress; but rather, entertain and inform the reader - vintage Lecky.
I'm already counting down the days until I can get my hands on book #6. Let's hope the wait is not too long.
With thanks to NetGalley and especially to one of my favourite publishers, Storm Publishing 💗 for the much appreciated arc in return for an honest review. All opinions expressed in this review are my own. The publication date is currently set for January 22, 2026.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Fantastic read! I loved the tricky plot and all the characters!!! Very well structured, the storyline as well as the plot were gripping, always leaving you guessing.... It seems the series is getting better and better!! I have enjoyed all the books and cannot wait for the next one in the series!
I received a digital copy of this novel from NetGalley and I have voluntarily written an honest review.
I received a digital copy of this novel from NetGalley and I have voluntarily written an honest review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Pam Lecky has a gift for making Victorian London—and now, Victorian Dublin—feel both atmospheric and deeply personal, and The Carver Affair is a example of her mastery. This latest installment is a rich, rewarding journey that manages to satisfy long-time fans while introducing fresh, vibrant energy into a beloved world. It is a triumph of a sequel that proves some couples only get better with time.
The most striking aspect of The Carver Affair is how it handles the passage of time. The story picks up several years after the events of the previous book, finding Phineas “Phin” and Lucy established in their lives. Often in romance, we leave a couple at their "happily ever after" and never see the reality of their "ever after." Lecky avoids this trope by showing us a version of Phin and Lucy that is mature, settled, and deeply in sync.
The shift in setting to Dublin provides a fresh backdrop for this evolution. Their relationship has transitioned from the initial sparks of a new romance into a formidable partnership. They are a team in every sense of the word, and seeing them navigate new mysteries with such a solid foundation of trust is incredibly satisfying. This time jump allows the world to feel lived-in; the stakes aren’t just about falling in love, but about protecting the life and the family they have built together.
While Phin and Lucy are the heart of the series, The Carver Affair excels in its expansion of the supporting cast. The introduction of Fergus is a highlight of the novel. Fergus, a Dublin police officer, brings a rugged, grounded energy that contrasts beautifully with the more polished elements of Lucy and Phin's life. In a compelling twist for the series, Lucy has the opportunity to partner directly with Fergus to address the central murder mystery, while Phin is occupied with his own professional responsibilities.
However, a standout in terms of character development is Mary. In previous books, Mary was a steady presence, but here she steps into a much more significant and active role. We see her grow as she navigates her own challenges and contributions to the central mystery. Lecky gives her the space to be more than just a background player.
The plot itself is a vintage Lecky blend of high-stakes intrigue and emotional depth. The "Carver Affair" of the title pulls the characters into a web of secrets that tests their wits and their loyalties and there happens to be more than one mystery to solve. I won't go into any details here as I don't want to give anything away but there are plenty of twists and turns that will keep you turning the pages. The pacing is well done, the historical detail of Dublin is as meticulous as ever, and the dialogue crackles with the intelligence we’ve come to expect from this author.
Also, from a romance perspective, because Phin and Lucy are already so well-established, the tension doesn't come from "will they/won't they" misunderstandings, but from how they face external threats as a united front. This is a joy to read; there is something uniquely romantic about a husband and wife who truly know and respect each other's capabilities.
The Carver Affair is a great continuation of the series. It was such a pleasure to see Phin and Lucy pick up so established; their growth feels earned, and their love feels permanent. Pam Lecky has created a world that feels as real as it is romantic, and this book only deepens my investment in these characters.
I finished this book with a sense of immense satisfaction, but also a lingering curiosity. The ending leaves just enough threads for the future that I can’t wait to see what happens next for Phin and Lucy. Whether you are here for the well-researched history, the gripping mystery, or the enduring romance, The Carver Affair delivers on every front. Highly recommended.
Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the copy in exchange for an honest review.
The most striking aspect of The Carver Affair is how it handles the passage of time. The story picks up several years after the events of the previous book, finding Phineas “Phin” and Lucy established in their lives. Often in romance, we leave a couple at their "happily ever after" and never see the reality of their "ever after." Lecky avoids this trope by showing us a version of Phin and Lucy that is mature, settled, and deeply in sync.
The shift in setting to Dublin provides a fresh backdrop for this evolution. Their relationship has transitioned from the initial sparks of a new romance into a formidable partnership. They are a team in every sense of the word, and seeing them navigate new mysteries with such a solid foundation of trust is incredibly satisfying. This time jump allows the world to feel lived-in; the stakes aren’t just about falling in love, but about protecting the life and the family they have built together.
While Phin and Lucy are the heart of the series, The Carver Affair excels in its expansion of the supporting cast. The introduction of Fergus is a highlight of the novel. Fergus, a Dublin police officer, brings a rugged, grounded energy that contrasts beautifully with the more polished elements of Lucy and Phin's life. In a compelling twist for the series, Lucy has the opportunity to partner directly with Fergus to address the central murder mystery, while Phin is occupied with his own professional responsibilities.
However, a standout in terms of character development is Mary. In previous books, Mary was a steady presence, but here she steps into a much more significant and active role. We see her grow as she navigates her own challenges and contributions to the central mystery. Lecky gives her the space to be more than just a background player.
The plot itself is a vintage Lecky blend of high-stakes intrigue and emotional depth. The "Carver Affair" of the title pulls the characters into a web of secrets that tests their wits and their loyalties and there happens to be more than one mystery to solve. I won't go into any details here as I don't want to give anything away but there are plenty of twists and turns that will keep you turning the pages. The pacing is well done, the historical detail of Dublin is as meticulous as ever, and the dialogue crackles with the intelligence we’ve come to expect from this author.
Also, from a romance perspective, because Phin and Lucy are already so well-established, the tension doesn't come from "will they/won't they" misunderstandings, but from how they face external threats as a united front. This is a joy to read; there is something uniquely romantic about a husband and wife who truly know and respect each other's capabilities.
The Carver Affair is a great continuation of the series. It was such a pleasure to see Phin and Lucy pick up so established; their growth feels earned, and their love feels permanent. Pam Lecky has created a world that feels as real as it is romantic, and this book only deepens my investment in these characters.
I finished this book with a sense of immense satisfaction, but also a lingering curiosity. The ending leaves just enough threads for the future that I can’t wait to see what happens next for Phin and Lucy. Whether you are here for the well-researched history, the gripping mystery, or the enduring romance, The Carver Affair delivers on every front. Highly recommended.
Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the copy in exchange for an honest review.
January 2, 2026
The time jumps in the Lucy Lawrence series are such a fun surprise! As you start each book, you wonder "when" you've landed. Years can pass between books.
This book has Lucy and Phineas (now with two children in tow) in Victorian-era Dublin. There are two mysteries that unexpectedly weave together in an interesting way. Phin has the family in Ireland for an assignment to inspect security measures at Dublin Castle for the insurance company he works for.
The first mystery involves the cousins of Lucy's maid, Mary. The cousins came to Dublin to find work in service and disappeared. Lucy and Mary decide to investigate and they meet local police inspector Fergus, who has a connection to organized crime that he both uses and hides during his police work. The second mystery involves Myles Carver, who was present at a brothel when a young woman died, his sick wife, and wife of his late son. The villain label moves around in this one in an unexpected way!
The pace is fast and the stories weave together beautifully in the third act. Fergus is such an appealing character that I hope we see him again - maybe his connections will mean he has to seek employment away from Dublin? We shall see...
The two children, twins, are the little scene-stealers in this one. They are mini versions of their parents, full of energy and curiosity. I hope we continue to see them in the books!
This book has Lucy and Phineas (now with two children in tow) in Victorian-era Dublin. There are two mysteries that unexpectedly weave together in an interesting way. Phin has the family in Ireland for an assignment to inspect security measures at Dublin Castle for the insurance company he works for.
The first mystery involves the cousins of Lucy's maid, Mary. The cousins came to Dublin to find work in service and disappeared. Lucy and Mary decide to investigate and they meet local police inspector Fergus, who has a connection to organized crime that he both uses and hides during his police work. The second mystery involves Myles Carver, who was present at a brothel when a young woman died, his sick wife, and wife of his late son. The villain label moves around in this one in an unexpected way!
The pace is fast and the stories weave together beautifully in the third act. Fergus is such an appealing character that I hope we see him again - maybe his connections will mean he has to seek employment away from Dublin? We shall see...
The two children, twins, are the little scene-stealers in this one. They are mini versions of their parents, full of energy and curiosity. I hope we continue to see them in the books!
December 24, 2025
Another excellent Lucy Stone mystery, with many twists and turns and red herrings. While it may have run a bit long, it was thoroughly engaging from start to finish. Thanks to Storm Publishing for the ARC.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
ARC-Review
A nice and gripping read for anyone who likes to encounter several twisting moments. As I did not read the four books before this, I was a bit worried but just like many other murder mystery series this can be read on it's own. I am curious about the other cases in the past that were hinted at now though.
Lucy Lawrence goes with her husband Phineas to Dublin, with their two children in tow. There he has to determine if the Crown Jewels are protected enough or not, investigating and advising the people there, to make sure they stay safe from an apparent plot to steal them. But Lucy is this time not part of that particular case and she is itching to do something. Her maid Mary asks her to help find her lost cousins, Peggy and Bridget. The two girls should have arrived at her mothers house in Dublin a while ago, but never did. To find two lost girls turns gruesomely into hunting one murderer and the underbelly of Dublin, a dark place where violence is the norm and genuine help is hard to come by. And not all seems to be going well at their neighbors house, the Carver Residence, either. It all seems rather straight forward - but is it really?
I enjoyed the book very much, especially as someone who did not know Lucy and Phineas at all. I found them easy to like and be intrigued by their ways. Personally I was a bit disappointed at the Prologue. I love it when I can sleuth along with the characters and it felt as if I had been given the answer from the start. But with reading further along the intricate woven net certainly still gave me this sleuthing along to find the needed evidence and be shocked by the on going twists and the tension kept rising. Making it obvious that a lot of work went into this to make sure all things would be connected in some way and that the motivations made sense. Though I do feel as if some things were rushed or given out to easily in retrospect.
For the Characters: Lucy is a charming Main Character that is twirling around, while Phineas is (in this book) more the calm presence in the background. A nice couple for certain, and their love that is shown feels natural and earnest.
Ryan is the inspector in Dublin and a character I would personally love to hear more from. If Lucy ever returns to Dublin, I will certainly try to be by her side, just to check up on that man! He deserves his library for himself and his father. Give that man his books and let him keep them, I beg of you!
The other characters are certainly intriguing and I could feel the discomfort and even fear some of them caused.
All in all definitely a book I enjoyed and would recommend for anyone that wishes to read a Murder Mystery in the historical Dublin of 1894 with a sympathetic character of Inspector Ryan as the one that stood out to me specifically. Who would not love a man that dreams of owning a library?
"His chances of befriending Olivia were as unrealistic as his hopes of owning a library."
A nice and gripping read for anyone who likes to encounter several twisting moments. As I did not read the four books before this, I was a bit worried but just like many other murder mystery series this can be read on it's own. I am curious about the other cases in the past that were hinted at now though.
Lucy Lawrence goes with her husband Phineas to Dublin, with their two children in tow. There he has to determine if the Crown Jewels are protected enough or not, investigating and advising the people there, to make sure they stay safe from an apparent plot to steal them. But Lucy is this time not part of that particular case and she is itching to do something. Her maid Mary asks her to help find her lost cousins, Peggy and Bridget. The two girls should have arrived at her mothers house in Dublin a while ago, but never did. To find two lost girls turns gruesomely into hunting one murderer and the underbelly of Dublin, a dark place where violence is the norm and genuine help is hard to come by. And not all seems to be going well at their neighbors house, the Carver Residence, either. It all seems rather straight forward - but is it really?
I enjoyed the book very much, especially as someone who did not know Lucy and Phineas at all. I found them easy to like and be intrigued by their ways. Personally I was a bit disappointed at the Prologue. I love it when I can sleuth along with the characters and it felt as if I had been given the answer from the start. But with reading further along the intricate woven net certainly still gave me this sleuthing along to find the needed evidence and be shocked by the on going twists and the tension kept rising. Making it obvious that a lot of work went into this to make sure all things would be connected in some way and that the motivations made sense. Though I do feel as if some things were rushed or given out to easily in retrospect.
For the Characters: Lucy is a charming Main Character that is twirling around, while Phineas is (in this book) more the calm presence in the background. A nice couple for certain, and their love that is shown feels natural and earnest.
Ryan is the inspector in Dublin and a character I would personally love to hear more from. If Lucy ever returns to Dublin, I will certainly try to be by her side, just to check up on that man! He deserves his library for himself and his father. Give that man his books and let him keep them, I beg of you!
The other characters are certainly intriguing and I could feel the discomfort and even fear some of them caused.
All in all definitely a book I enjoyed and would recommend for anyone that wishes to read a Murder Mystery in the historical Dublin of 1894 with a sympathetic character of Inspector Ryan as the one that stood out to me specifically. Who would not love a man that dreams of owning a library?
"His chances of befriending Olivia were as unrealistic as his hopes of owning a library."
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Thank you to NetGalley and to Storm Publishing for the ARC of The Carver Affair by Pam Lecky.
In my last review of the 4th book in the series, A Pocketful of Diamonds, I wrote, "The way this one ended felt like it could be the end of the series - and if it is, the characters are in a good place with a strong ending." And, so, I was pleasantly surprised there is a new book, but also pleasantly surprised that there is a roughly 5 year time jump into the future, where Lucy and Phin are still happily together and their twins are growing up happily. When Phin is taken to Dublin for a case, Lucy convinces him to bring the family along for the summer, and then finds a fresh case of her own when Mary's two teenage cousins go missing upon their arrival in Dublin to find work.
From there, my feelings on this one are a bit more muddled. Lucy definitely has her time to shine and return to crime solving for the first time since her pregnancy, and Mary gets the opportunity to steal the show as she is a direct relation to one of the murder victims and is intent upon the crime being solved.
Phin is barely in this book - he has his own investigation occurring, but we seem to rarely interact with him at all. Whole chapters are also given to the perspective of Dublin detective Fergus Ryan, which, while interesting, really made this seem like more the Lucy and Fergus duo vs her and Phin. Perspectives were also given to other characters as well, and while Mary's made sense given how integral she is to Lucy, we spend time with some minor characters in ways that didn't engage me as much as previous stories.
I also didn't love the narrative structure of the novel -- I guessed the end twist, but then I was frustrated by the start of the book and being given perspectives of so many characters outside of Lucy and Phin because then the beginning actions don't match the ending actions (I'm trying to be vague to avoid spoilers, but it honestly just kind of seemed like a bait and switch for readers that didn't totally line-up).
While I do appreciate this series and I did enjoy the story generally, I think this one just wasn't a match in the series for me.
In my last review of the 4th book in the series, A Pocketful of Diamonds, I wrote, "The way this one ended felt like it could be the end of the series - and if it is, the characters are in a good place with a strong ending." And, so, I was pleasantly surprised there is a new book, but also pleasantly surprised that there is a roughly 5 year time jump into the future, where Lucy and Phin are still happily together and their twins are growing up happily. When Phin is taken to Dublin for a case, Lucy convinces him to bring the family along for the summer, and then finds a fresh case of her own when Mary's two teenage cousins go missing upon their arrival in Dublin to find work.
From there, my feelings on this one are a bit more muddled. Lucy definitely has her time to shine and return to crime solving for the first time since her pregnancy, and Mary gets the opportunity to steal the show as she is a direct relation to one of the murder victims and is intent upon the crime being solved.
Phin is barely in this book - he has his own investigation occurring, but we seem to rarely interact with him at all. Whole chapters are also given to the perspective of Dublin detective Fergus Ryan, which, while interesting, really made this seem like more the Lucy and Fergus duo vs her and Phin. Perspectives were also given to other characters as well, and while Mary's made sense given how integral she is to Lucy, we spend time with some minor characters in ways that didn't engage me as much as previous stories.
I also didn't love the narrative structure of the novel -- I guessed the end twist, but then I was frustrated by the start of the book and being given perspectives of so many characters outside of Lucy and Phin because then the beginning actions don't match the ending actions (I'm trying to be vague to avoid spoilers, but it honestly just kind of seemed like a bait and switch for readers that didn't totally line-up).
While I do appreciate this series and I did enjoy the story generally, I think this one just wasn't a match in the series for me.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
It was Dublin, 1894, when Lucy Stone (nee Lawrence), her husband Phineas and children arrived from London. Phin was there to investigate security at Dublin Castle, with the threat of theft of the Crown Jewels hovering. Lucy and the children were to have a holiday, until Lucy's maid, Mary, discovered her cousins, sisters Peggy & Bridget, had headed to Dublin for jobs, and had vanished after getting off the train. Lucy immediately began to investigate, and when Detective Inspector Fergus Ryan became involved with a murder at one of the brothels in the Monto area, a red-light district, it was discovered Peggy had been brutally murdered.
Meanwhile Myles Carver, a banker, was waiting for his wife to pass on. Her heart was failing and the household, including daughter-in-law Olivia, were ready for the mourning period. Olivia cared for Edith daily, doing all she could for her. It was a sad state of affairs, and when Olivia met Lucy, they connected quickly, becoming friendly. But Lucy was desperate to find Bridget, and also Peggy's killer. Would they manage to do that, in the dark underworld of 1890s Dublin?
The Carver Affair is the 5th in The Lucy Lawrence Mysteries by Pam Lecky and I loved it! Each of these mysteries has been a 5* read for me, and this one was no different. The dark and dank streets of Dublin, in the old district, were quite terrifying; even the pubs with the underground and no one wanting anything to do with the "polis". Lucy is a strong character, and great sleuth, and Phin is a charm. Highly recommended. (But I would read from the beginning)
With thanks to NetGalley & Storm Publishing for my digital ARC to read and review.
Meanwhile Myles Carver, a banker, was waiting for his wife to pass on. Her heart was failing and the household, including daughter-in-law Olivia, were ready for the mourning period. Olivia cared for Edith daily, doing all she could for her. It was a sad state of affairs, and when Olivia met Lucy, they connected quickly, becoming friendly. But Lucy was desperate to find Bridget, and also Peggy's killer. Would they manage to do that, in the dark underworld of 1890s Dublin?
The Carver Affair is the 5th in The Lucy Lawrence Mysteries by Pam Lecky and I loved it! Each of these mysteries has been a 5* read for me, and this one was no different. The dark and dank streets of Dublin, in the old district, were quite terrifying; even the pubs with the underground and no one wanting anything to do with the "polis". Lucy is a strong character, and great sleuth, and Phin is a charm. Highly recommended. (But I would read from the beginning)
With thanks to NetGalley & Storm Publishing for my digital ARC to read and review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
The Carver Affair is a beautifully crafted historical mystery that plunges the reader straight into the contrasts and contradictions of 1894 Dublin. Pam Lecky once again proves her talent for blending meticulous historical detail with a plot that moves with purpose, tension, and emotional depth.
Lucy Lawrence arrives expecting a quiet summer, but the disappearance of her maid’s young cousin — and the brutal discovery that follows — pulls her into a world far darker than the drawing rooms she’s accustomed to. Lucy remains a wonderfully compelling heroine: intelligent, compassionate, and unwilling to look away when others would prefer she stay silent. Her determination gives the story its heart, even as the danger around her escalates.
The novel’s strength lies in its vivid sense of place. Lecky moves effortlessly between the elegance of Merrion Square and the grim, dangerous streets of the Monto red‑light district, painting a city divided by class, power, and secrets. The supporting cast is equally engaging: grieving banker Myles Carver, enigmatic Olivia, ruthless madam Celine Burton, and the steady, quietly burdened Detective Inspector Fergus Ryan. Each brings their own shadows and motives, creating a web of intrigue that tightens with every chapter.
As the body count rises and the truth becomes harder to untangle, the tension builds beautifully. The mystery is layered, the stakes feel real, and the final revelations land with satisfying weight.
Atmospheric, immersive, and expertly plotted, The Carver Affair is a standout addition to the Lucy Lawrence series — perfect for readers who love their historical mysteries with rich character work, sharp suspense, and a heroine who refuses to back down.
With thanks to Pam Lecky, the publisher and netgalley for the ARC
Lucy Lawrence arrives expecting a quiet summer, but the disappearance of her maid’s young cousin — and the brutal discovery that follows — pulls her into a world far darker than the drawing rooms she’s accustomed to. Lucy remains a wonderfully compelling heroine: intelligent, compassionate, and unwilling to look away when others would prefer she stay silent. Her determination gives the story its heart, even as the danger around her escalates.
The novel’s strength lies in its vivid sense of place. Lecky moves effortlessly between the elegance of Merrion Square and the grim, dangerous streets of the Monto red‑light district, painting a city divided by class, power, and secrets. The supporting cast is equally engaging: grieving banker Myles Carver, enigmatic Olivia, ruthless madam Celine Burton, and the steady, quietly burdened Detective Inspector Fergus Ryan. Each brings their own shadows and motives, creating a web of intrigue that tightens with every chapter.
As the body count rises and the truth becomes harder to untangle, the tension builds beautifully. The mystery is layered, the stakes feel real, and the final revelations land with satisfying weight.
Atmospheric, immersive, and expertly plotted, The Carver Affair is a standout addition to the Lucy Lawrence series — perfect for readers who love their historical mysteries with rich character work, sharp suspense, and a heroine who refuses to back down.
With thanks to Pam Lecky, the publisher and netgalley for the ARC
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
*I received a free ARC from the publisher through NetGalley in exchange for my honest review*
I have loved this series from book 1 and am always excited for the next installment! I really liked that the author made the decision to jump ahead in time a bit and have the twins be a little older. This allowed for Lucy to be away from them every now and again. The story here is a good one - it worked to have the victim be related to Mary because it explained how and why Lucy would get involved in an investigation in Ireland. I would have loved to have Lucy and Phin work more together on the investigation, but it was nice to see her slowly get back into the investigation game - it is clear that she has stepped back from this world when the twins were younger. I really liked the character of Fergus and would love to see him pop up in either future books or in his own series. That being said, I could have done without the romance element of his story - he barely knew the woman so I did not fully buy that part. The author also does a great job here of putting the facts in front of you if you are paying attention - when thinking back on how events and people were initially described it is clear that there is more going on than initially thought by the police or Lucy. There are plenty of good twists here to keep you on your toes as well. The reveal of the second killers identify and personality was well executed. I am very much looking forward to book 6!
I have loved this series from book 1 and am always excited for the next installment! I really liked that the author made the decision to jump ahead in time a bit and have the twins be a little older. This allowed for Lucy to be away from them every now and again. The story here is a good one - it worked to have the victim be related to Mary because it explained how and why Lucy would get involved in an investigation in Ireland. I would have loved to have Lucy and Phin work more together on the investigation, but it was nice to see her slowly get back into the investigation game - it is clear that she has stepped back from this world when the twins were younger. I really liked the character of Fergus and would love to see him pop up in either future books or in his own series. That being said, I could have done without the romance element of his story - he barely knew the woman so I did not fully buy that part. The author also does a great job here of putting the facts in front of you if you are paying attention - when thinking back on how events and people were initially described it is clear that there is more going on than initially thought by the police or Lucy. There are plenty of good twists here to keep you on your toes as well. The reveal of the second killers identify and personality was well executed. I am very much looking forward to book 6!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Thank you to NetGalley and Storm Publishing for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
This is the fifth book in The Lucy Lawrence Mysteries series, but it can easily be read as a standalone.
Set in Dublin in 1894, this Victorian mystery follows Lucy Lawrence as she arrives in Ireland for a summer holiday while her husband, Phineas, investigates security matters at Dublin Castle. The trip takes a dark turn when her maid’s young cousins mysteriously disappears. Unable to ignore the injustice, Lucy launches her own investigation, teaming up with Dublin detective Inspector Fergus Ryan.
This is a gripping and cleverly plotted mystery that kept me guessing right until the end—I truly did not see the resolution coming. The atmospheric setting, strong pacing, and intricate plot made it hard to put down.
What I loved most was Lucy’s resilience and imaginative approach to solving mysteries. She is a wonderfully engaging heroine, and her dynamic with Fergus Ryan is a highlight of the book. Both characters are richly drawn and memorable, and I found myself deeply invested in their partnership.
A highly enjoyable Victorian mystery with a strong sense of place, compelling characters, and a satisfying, unexpected conclusion.
This is the fifth book in The Lucy Lawrence Mysteries series, but it can easily be read as a standalone.
Set in Dublin in 1894, this Victorian mystery follows Lucy Lawrence as she arrives in Ireland for a summer holiday while her husband, Phineas, investigates security matters at Dublin Castle. The trip takes a dark turn when her maid’s young cousins mysteriously disappears. Unable to ignore the injustice, Lucy launches her own investigation, teaming up with Dublin detective Inspector Fergus Ryan.
This is a gripping and cleverly plotted mystery that kept me guessing right until the end—I truly did not see the resolution coming. The atmospheric setting, strong pacing, and intricate plot made it hard to put down.
What I loved most was Lucy’s resilience and imaginative approach to solving mysteries. She is a wonderfully engaging heroine, and her dynamic with Fergus Ryan is a highlight of the book. Both characters are richly drawn and memorable, and I found myself deeply invested in their partnership.
A highly enjoyable Victorian mystery with a strong sense of place, compelling characters, and a satisfying, unexpected conclusion.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Several mysteries converge to help Lucy solve as she travels with her husband to Dublin. The murder of a prostitute who happens to be Lucy's maid's missing cousin exposes possible further crimes by various characters who are trying to hide or blame others. It takes Lucy and Inspector Fergus Ryan to piece apart the confusing lies and try to determine who is telling the truth and who is not who they seem. The time jump to Lucy & Phinneas' kids being about 5 was amusing as they create more challenges for the duo. I'm not sure if this focus on Inspector Fergus means a spin-off for him, as Phinneas was barely involved at all. Some of his character development felt rushed and unlikely, particularly in his feelings towards other characters in the book. It was an interesting mystery, but not my favorite in this series.
Thank you to the publisher and Netgalley for selecting me to read an advanced copy of this book.
Thank you to the publisher and Netgalley for selecting me to read an advanced copy of this book.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
The motto of this story is” NEVER judge a book by its cover!” I adore Phin and Lucy’s adventures and this one is one thrill ride. Reading the description was a bit confusing and I wasn’t sure who all these people were, but it was so well written, it was easy to follow. Seeing Lucy get back into the ‘game’ after having the babies was fun. I enjoyed watching her put Fergus in his place, even with him being the Inspector! Phin didn’t get much time in this one, but it was interesting to note he picked up on the one thing that changed the whole trajectory of the story. It is unimaginable what these women went through in that time period and I was touched by their story. The villain(S?) were well hidden and the surprise at the climax was superb. THOROUGHLY enjoyed it!
I received this story for free and these are my own views.
I received this story for free and these are my own views.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This is the fifth book in the Lucy Lawrence mysteries series and the first I have read. The author writes an excellent story with two interesting mysteries and many well-formed characters. I love all the historical detail about Dublin in the 1890s, both the rich and poor sides of society.
Even though I have not read any of the previous books in this series, I was not lost as the author properly introduced all the important characters. She really got me to feel love for the good characters and hatred and fear of the bad ones. There was so much I didn't expect in the intertwined plots that resolved in the end.
I will probably go back and read some of the earlier books in the series, but this one can be read stand-alone and thoroughly enjoyed by everyone liking British historical mysteries.
Thank you to Storm Publishing and Netgalley for the advance copy.
Even though I have not read any of the previous books in this series, I was not lost as the author properly introduced all the important characters. She really got me to feel love for the good characters and hatred and fear of the bad ones. There was so much I didn't expect in the intertwined plots that resolved in the end.
I will probably go back and read some of the earlier books in the series, but this one can be read stand-alone and thoroughly enjoyed by everyone liking British historical mysteries.
Thank you to Storm Publishing and Netgalley for the advance copy.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Another great entry in the Lucy Lawrence mystery series!
This time we follow Lucy and Phin in a new adventure in Dublin, where they become entangled with police Inspector Fergus.
Far from willing to be just the pride mother of twins, Lucy starts her own investigation while Phin is busy on government matters.
A too easy mark and a less then credible witness complicate the investigation but Lucy is not one to be deterred.
As always, the characters are perfectly portraited, the plot well thought out and it makes me want to read more.
I only hope there will be more of Phin in the next book!
I received an advance copy for free and I am leaving this review voluntarily, thanks to the author for it.
This time we follow Lucy and Phin in a new adventure in Dublin, where they become entangled with police Inspector Fergus.
Far from willing to be just the pride mother of twins, Lucy starts her own investigation while Phin is busy on government matters.
A too easy mark and a less then credible witness complicate the investigation but Lucy is not one to be deterred.
As always, the characters are perfectly portraited, the plot well thought out and it makes me want to read more.
I only hope there will be more of Phin in the next book!
I received an advance copy for free and I am leaving this review voluntarily, thanks to the author for it.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
It was fun to revisit these characters. This story is set in Dublin and the issues of poverty and crime run through this. When a young girl is murdered in a brothel it appears that Myles Carver did it. Meanwhile his wife is dying at home, is it possible he was poisoning her? This was a clever plot, with lots of misdirection, showing that it is easy to jump to the wrong conclusions, especially when a pretty woman is involved. Lucy is the main character in this, Phin is more in the background as Fergus Ryan, the police inspector from Dublin takes a major role. All in all, this was a satisfying story and I enjoyed the setting of historical Dublin. Thanks to NetGalley and Storm Publishing for giving me the opportunity to read and review this book. I eagerly await the next instalment.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Another great addition to this series. This one takes place a few years after the last story. Phin has business to attend to in Dublin, and Lucy and the children are along for the ride as well. Mary, Lucy's maid, discovers that her two young cousins were supposed to be in Dublin looking for work. The problem is that noone has seen or heard from them in a few weeks, and Mary asks Lucy for her help in finding them. Well, Lucy ends up falling headfirst into series of events - murder, kidnapping, and poisoning. She'll have to work hard to sort this all out. A fantastic story with a wicked twist towards the end!
Thanks to Netgalley, Storm Publishing, and Pam Lecky for the free ARC. All opinions are my own.
Thanks to Netgalley, Storm Publishing, and Pam Lecky for the free ARC. All opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Thank for giving me the opportunity to review this book, the latest in the series. Lucy Lawrence is a young women who is an amateur sleuthing. Along with her husband Phineas, she shows a interest in untimely deaths when they come within her earshot or group of friends. Set in Victorian times, Lucy achieves much for a married woman. This particular story is set in Dublin, unlike previous books which had been set in London. I have enjoyed the previous books and this one continues to hold my interest. It is good to see the characters develop over time, with Molly and George the couples servants still, present, even the introduction of young children into the family has not changed things. Although this book could be read as a standalone, I would recommend reading the previous books to understood Lucy and Phinn met and she became an amateur sleuth.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Lucy Lawrence and her family arrive in Dublin where they will reside for a time while Lucy's husband, Phineas, scrutinizes security at Dublin Castle. When Lucy's maid learns that her two young cousins have disappeared in the city, she asks for Lucy's help in learning what became of them. They discover one of the girls murdered in the red light district and the other still missing. Lucy and her maid are able to go places and get answers to questions that the police cannot, so they race to find the second girl before she, too, meets a violent end.
I've read other titles in the Lucy Lawrence series and enjoyed them all. The characters are well developed and believable and the writing, practically flawless.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC. All opinions are my own.
I've read other titles in the Lucy Lawrence series and enjoyed them all. The characters are well developed and believable and the writing, practically flawless.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC. All opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This was another engrossing read in this series. This story is set in Dublin and in some of the seedier parts of the city. Phineas Stone had work to do there for the government but Lucy has managed to make it a family holiday, complete with their 5 year old twins. Lucy has missed being part of an investigating team and she just can’t help getting involved with a mystery of missing girls, who are cousins of her maid. I did realise who the culprit was but not all of the story, there are some surprises. There is an inspector, Fergus Ryan, who was very helpful and I do hope to hear more about him in future stories. This had a good amount of action, danger and several villains. I’m really looking forward to the next book. I received a few and have voluntarily reviewed it. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
January 23, 2026
How wonderful it is to read Lucy’s adventures and investigations once again. This time she is in Ireland while now husband Phineas investigates security at Dublin Castle in The Carver Affair by Pam Lecky. Book five of the series has a missing cousin of Lucy’s maid found dead in a questionable area. From there more are to be found, with a killer to be stopped.
As always, I enjoyed the setting, the plot, the characters including the supporting characters and the writing style of Pam Lecky. Like the previous books Lucy is daring, intelligent and determined, so this is another page-turner read.
As always, I enjoyed the setting, the plot, the characters including the supporting characters and the writing style of Pam Lecky. Like the previous books Lucy is daring, intelligent and determined, so this is another page-turner read.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I enjoyed this historical mystery, the 5th in the series. I hand't read any of the previous books in the series, but I didn't feel like I missed anything. Several twists with 2 different investigations going on at the same time, although we didn't hear much about the one. A satisfying conclusion and I'll have to find the time to go back and read the previous books.
Thanks for the ARC Netgalley.
Thanks for the ARC Netgalley.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Lucy and Phineas are in Dublin for the summer. The Royal Irish jewels seem to be at risk. Lucy has accompanied him along with the twins. The summer is full of entertainment. Mary, Lucy’s maid, receives bad news. Her young cousins were sent to Dublin to get jobs and have disappeared. So Lucy now has her own mystery to solve. Lots of puzzles and deception in these mysteries. I highly recommend. #NetGalley
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Intriguing story with quite a few red herrings. Good character development; I'm a little frustrated that I jumped in the middle of a series, but it stands alone well. Definitely curious about going back to the first books and reading them. I enjoyed how Ms. Lecky wove together two different murders and the surrounding mysteries.
I received an ARC; this is my honest review.
I received an ARC; this is my honest review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Gripping Historical Mystery
The Carver Affair by Pam Lecky is another fantastic read that shows her talent for blending history with mystery. I loved Lecky's writing style vivid, engaging, and easy to get lost in. The historical detail adds depth to the story while the plot keeps you hooked. A great choice for fans of historical fiction with suspense. Thanks to NetGalley and to the publishers of this book for giving me a free advance copy of the book to preview and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
The Carver Affair by Pam Lecky is another fantastic read that shows her talent for blending history with mystery. I loved Lecky's writing style vivid, engaging, and easy to get lost in. The historical detail adds depth to the story while the plot keeps you hooked. A great choice for fans of historical fiction with suspense. Thanks to NetGalley and to the publishers of this book for giving me a free advance copy of the book to preview and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
January 23, 2026
Excellent!
Loved this view of Lucy and Phin after several years and their 5 year old twins! What fun! Enjoyed this mystery thoroughly but the finale totally surprised me. What an outstanding final reveal of the " bad guys"!
Loved this view of Lucy and Phin after several years and their 5 year old twins! What fun! Enjoyed this mystery thoroughly but the finale totally surprised me. What an outstanding final reveal of the " bad guys"!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Well written and well paced, but a wee bit predictable. Enjoyed it however. I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
fantastically mysterious throughout with some effective plotting and unique characters. I would recommend this one. 5 stars. tysm for the arc.
January 24, 2026
Book 5 of 5 - This is a great series. A historical thriller and mystery. I enjoyed it a lot. The characters and story are written so well. Highly recommend.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Book 5 in the incredibly popular Victorian mystery series features Lucy Lawrence as a sleuth with her husband Phin, this time in Dublin. Loved the Irish setting, the gripping narrative, and the careful attention to historical details. A winner!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 30 reviews