What do you think?
Rate this book
The Highland Bookshop Murders #2
Poison at the Wild Haggis Bookshop
A deliciously twisty Highland mystery that will keep you guessing until the very last page. Perfect for fans of cozy crime with a bite!
Beth Cunningham's clever book subscription service is the talk of Oban, complete with local treats and hand-picked reads. But when elderly customer Nora Kelly is found dead in her armchair, Beth's book boxes are identified as the murder weapon. It seems a vengeful killer has the Wild Haggis Bookshop in their sights...
Detective Sergeant Logan Hunter insists on round-the-clock protection for Beth, which means close quarters with the infuriating – and increasingly attractive – officer. As spring approaches and the bookshop fills with bountiful blooms and excited children, Beth's investigation uncovers secrets that someone has spent decades trying to bury. With time running out, Beth must untangle a twisted web of lies that stretches far beyond this quaint Highland town. But when the killer strikes again, even Logan's protection may not be enough to save her...
An unputdownable cozy mystery for fans of Paige Shelton and Dee MacDonald!
Beth Cunningham's clever book subscription service is the talk of Oban, complete with local treats and hand-picked reads. But when elderly customer Nora Kelly is found dead in her armchair, Beth's book boxes are identified as the murder weapon. It seems a vengeful killer has the Wild Haggis Bookshop in their sights...
Detective Sergeant Logan Hunter insists on round-the-clock protection for Beth, which means close quarters with the infuriating – and increasingly attractive – officer. As spring approaches and the bookshop fills with bountiful blooms and excited children, Beth's investigation uncovers secrets that someone has spent decades trying to bury. With time running out, Beth must untangle a twisted web of lies that stretches far beyond this quaint Highland town. But when the killer strikes again, even Logan's protection may not be enough to save her...
An unputdownable cozy mystery for fans of Paige Shelton and Dee MacDonald!
272 pages, Kindle Edition
First published January 1, 2026
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 154 reviews
June 10, 2026
Let’s see, what does this book offer?
* Cozy mystery
* Fun characters
* Bookstore setting
* Cats
* Discovery of a body
* Lots of suspects
* Blooming romance
I don’t often give this genre 5 stars, but I feel it’s appropriate to rate compared to others in its genre, and I thoroughly enjoyed this. Beth is a newer resident with a troubled past (which was explored in the 1st book). Now in her new home, she loves her bookshop and her employees/friends, as well as getting to know her customers. She discovers a customer dead in her home, and its determined to be murder. Beth is once again a suspect due to the connection with the bookstore.
There are many mysterious events that cause Beth and others to question who could have wanted her dead. As they probe, Beth finds her own life in danger… and Detective Logan may have more than professional reasons to protect her. A quick and fun read that will have you wanting to solve the mystery with our characters.
* Cozy mystery
* Fun characters
* Bookstore setting
* Cats
* Discovery of a body
* Lots of suspects
* Blooming romance
I don’t often give this genre 5 stars, but I feel it’s appropriate to rate compared to others in its genre, and I thoroughly enjoyed this. Beth is a newer resident with a troubled past (which was explored in the 1st book). Now in her new home, she loves her bookshop and her employees/friends, as well as getting to know her customers. She discovers a customer dead in her home, and its determined to be murder. Beth is once again a suspect due to the connection with the bookstore.
There are many mysterious events that cause Beth and others to question who could have wanted her dead. As they probe, Beth finds her own life in danger… and Detective Logan may have more than professional reasons to protect her. A quick and fun read that will have you wanting to solve the mystery with our characters.
February 26, 2026
Local village Wild Haggis Bookshop owner Beth finds herself in the center of a murder investigation. When Beth discovers a customer's dead body when delivering a book subscription box, she is quickly drawn into the mysterious life of quiet Nora.
Baldwin created a cozy mystery that checks all of my boxes
- cozy village
- found family work crew
- cats
- awkward new love
- hijinks
This is the second in a series, however, new readers can easily jump in and be caught up quickly.
Thank you Storm Books and Love Book Tours for a copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
Baldwin created a cozy mystery that checks all of my boxes
- cozy village
- found family work crew
- cats
- awkward new love
- hijinks
This is the second in a series, however, new readers can easily jump in and be caught up quickly.
Thank you Storm Books and Love Book Tours for a copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Title: Poison At The Wild Haggis Bookshop
Author: Jackie Baldwin
Synopsis: A deliciously twisty Highland mystery that will keep you guessing until the very last page. Perfect for fans of cozy crime with a bite!
Beth Cunningham's clever book subscription service is the talk of Oban, complete with local treats and hand-picked reads. But when elderly customer Nora Kelly is found dead in her armchair, Beth's book boxes are identified as the murder weapon. It seems a vengeful killer has the Wild Haggis Bookshop in their sights...
Detective Sergeant Logan Hunter insists on round-the-clock protection for Beth, which means close quarters with the infuriating – and increasingly attractive – officer. As spring approaches and the bookshop fills with bountiful blooms and excited children, Beth's investigation uncovers secrets that someone has spent decades trying to bury. With time running out, Beth must untangle a twisted web of lies that stretches far beyond this quaint Highland town. But when the killer strikes again, even Logan's protection may not be enough to save her...
An unputdownable cozy mystery for fans of Paige Shelton and Dee MacDonald!
Review: I had even more fun with this book than I did with the first book! The mystery was well done and I can tell the author truly has it all thought out! While reading there were time I didn’t wan to put the book down but life happens and you get interruptions! I have such an appreciation for this very slow burn romance that unravels a little more in this book! It was perfect! I’m very excited to read the next book in this warm and inviting mystery series!
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for giving me the opportunity to read this book in advance!
Author: Jackie Baldwin
Synopsis: A deliciously twisty Highland mystery that will keep you guessing until the very last page. Perfect for fans of cozy crime with a bite!
Beth Cunningham's clever book subscription service is the talk of Oban, complete with local treats and hand-picked reads. But when elderly customer Nora Kelly is found dead in her armchair, Beth's book boxes are identified as the murder weapon. It seems a vengeful killer has the Wild Haggis Bookshop in their sights...
Detective Sergeant Logan Hunter insists on round-the-clock protection for Beth, which means close quarters with the infuriating – and increasingly attractive – officer. As spring approaches and the bookshop fills with bountiful blooms and excited children, Beth's investigation uncovers secrets that someone has spent decades trying to bury. With time running out, Beth must untangle a twisted web of lies that stretches far beyond this quaint Highland town. But when the killer strikes again, even Logan's protection may not be enough to save her...
An unputdownable cozy mystery for fans of Paige Shelton and Dee MacDonald!
Review: I had even more fun with this book than I did with the first book! The mystery was well done and I can tell the author truly has it all thought out! While reading there were time I didn’t wan to put the book down but life happens and you get interruptions! I have such an appreciation for this very slow burn romance that unravels a little more in this book! It was perfect! I’m very excited to read the next book in this warm and inviting mystery series!
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for giving me the opportunity to read this book in advance!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I discovered this author and series at the end of last year and enjoyed the first book a lot, so I was very excited to see book two coming out in February. Beth has settled in to her new home, and with the help of her interesting and diverse staff, she is making a success of the bookstore. With new ideas like a monthly bookbox, containing samples and small treats offered by neighboring businesses, an Easter egg hunt, and live baby chicks, business is good, and Beth is as happy as she can remember. Unfortunately one afternoon as she delivers one of her bookboxes she finds her customer dead in her chair and an unknown young man with her that goes a little crazy and won't explain who he is and why he is there until the police take him in. The next day, Beth remembers that Nora had a cat, so she goes back to the house to rescue Marmalade and take him home. Everything proceeds normally until it is discovered that Nora was murdered by poisoning. The poison was in the mushroom tea packets included in Beth's bookboxes. Not only that, a will is discovered leaving Beth, Marmalade, and all of Nora's estate. What is going on? While Beth and Nora were friendly, Beth can't believe the will, but the police are taking it seriously, and the provider of the teabags has now disappeared. Who wants to put Beth back in the police sights? How could this be happening again? Will it cost her the business this time? Come along as Beth and her trusty employees try to find answers. Another adventure that was hard to put down! Thanks to #Netgally, #StormPublishing, and the author for an opportunity to read! #PoisonattheWildHaggisBookshop #HighlandBookshopMurders #JackieBaldwin #bookreview #bookideas #retiredreader
February 25, 2026
I absolutely flew through this one! 🥰 It was such a fun, cosy and engaging mystery that kept me turning the pages without even realising how quickly I was getting through it.
Even though this is part of a series, I didn’t feel like I needed to have read the first book to enjoy it. There were a few references to previous events, but nothing that made me feel lost, it worked perfectly well as a standalone for me.
One of my favourite parts was the relationship development between Beth and Logan. Their dynamic adds that little extra spark alongside the investigation, and I really enjoyed seeing that progress as the story unfolded.
The setting, the bookshop theme, the twists. It all came together into such an enjoyable cosy mystery. If you love crime with warmth, charm and a hint of romance, this is definitely one to pick up.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ — a completely addictive read for me!
Even though this is part of a series, I didn’t feel like I needed to have read the first book to enjoy it. There were a few references to previous events, but nothing that made me feel lost, it worked perfectly well as a standalone for me.
One of my favourite parts was the relationship development between Beth and Logan. Their dynamic adds that little extra spark alongside the investigation, and I really enjoyed seeing that progress as the story unfolded.
The setting, the bookshop theme, the twists. It all came together into such an enjoyable cosy mystery. If you love crime with warmth, charm and a hint of romance, this is definitely one to pick up.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ — a completely addictive read for me!
March 12, 2026
#PoisonattheWildHaggisBookshop #NetGalley
I have become quite captivated this series, and Beth is quickly becoming one of my favorite characters.
In this story, Beth's book subscription service may be responsible for the death of a local resident.
When Beth is once again considered a suspect, she refuses to take the blame for something she did not do.
When she starts to investigate she finds buried secrets, revenge plans and so much more.
I loved this bookand hope to see more in this bright, exciting series.
I have become quite captivated this series, and Beth is quickly becoming one of my favorite characters.
In this story, Beth's book subscription service may be responsible for the death of a local resident.
When Beth is once again considered a suspect, she refuses to take the blame for something she did not do.
When she starts to investigate she finds buried secrets, revenge plans and so much more.
I loved this bookand hope to see more in this bright, exciting series.
February 17, 2026
Thank you to NetGalley for being able to read this book for review. I had read the second and was so glad to jump back in with the characters again. It picks up on a new mystery and the continued yearning of a relationship between Beth and Sergeant Logan as once again there’s a mystery to solve and Beth seems to be the main culprit once again. I really like this series and now am patiently awaiting the third.
March 8, 2026
A very enjoyable follow up book to the first one but it can very much be read as a standalone. Good to see all the characters back from the first book so it was just the ones for this book you needed to get used to. An enjoyable storyline with some good twists and turns to keep you engaged with reading the book.
March 13, 2026
Such a hoot of a book!
I loved reading it. Truly - cosy, lots happening and such relatable characters.
I do wish some themes and side stories would be explored a little more, but that’s ok.
Will most definitely follow this series and the author!
A great introduction to her writing!
I loved reading it. Truly - cosy, lots happening and such relatable characters.
I do wish some themes and side stories would be explored a little more, but that’s ok.
Will most definitely follow this series and the author!
A great introduction to her writing!
January 8, 2026
Poison at the Wild Haggis Bookshop is such a charming and cozy mystery that completely swept me away.
Beth has fulfilled her dream by running a wonderfully creative bookshop in a small Highland village where everyone seems to know everyone. When one of her customers is suddenly poisoned, Beth finds herself right at the top of the suspect list, all because of her book box subscription. From that moment on, the story becomes an engaging mix of mystery, village life, and quiet personal moments.
The setting is incredibly sweet. I loved how the bookshop isn’t just about books: Beth bakes, hosts seasonal activities, and creates a real sense of community that makes you want to step right into the Highlands yourself.
Even though the story partly builds on events from the first book, I never felt lost. Important details are woven in naturally, so it still works perfectly as a standalone. There are many characters and connections to keep track of, but the narrative stays clear and enjoyable, offering a nice balance between suspects, friendships, workplace dynamics, and even a gentle hint of romance.
What stood out most to me was the balance between excitement and comfort. The mystery is intriguing and adventurous without ever becoming too dark or graphic, which makes it a perfect cozy read.
A lovely recommendation for anyone looking for an entertaining, feel-good mystery, especially for rainy days curled up by the fire.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher Storm Publishing for providing me with an advance reading copy of Poison at the Wild Haggis Bookshop. All thoughts and opinions are my own and were not influenced in any way by receiving this copy.
Beth has fulfilled her dream by running a wonderfully creative bookshop in a small Highland village where everyone seems to know everyone. When one of her customers is suddenly poisoned, Beth finds herself right at the top of the suspect list, all because of her book box subscription. From that moment on, the story becomes an engaging mix of mystery, village life, and quiet personal moments.
The setting is incredibly sweet. I loved how the bookshop isn’t just about books: Beth bakes, hosts seasonal activities, and creates a real sense of community that makes you want to step right into the Highlands yourself.
Even though the story partly builds on events from the first book, I never felt lost. Important details are woven in naturally, so it still works perfectly as a standalone. There are many characters and connections to keep track of, but the narrative stays clear and enjoyable, offering a nice balance between suspects, friendships, workplace dynamics, and even a gentle hint of romance.
What stood out most to me was the balance between excitement and comfort. The mystery is intriguing and adventurous without ever becoming too dark or graphic, which makes it a perfect cozy read.
A lovely recommendation for anyone looking for an entertaining, feel-good mystery, especially for rainy days curled up by the fire.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher Storm Publishing for providing me with an advance reading copy of Poison at the Wild Haggis Bookshop. All thoughts and opinions are my own and were not influenced in any way by receiving this copy.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Poison at the Wild Haggis Bookshop by Jackie Baldwin
Synopsis /
Beth Cunningham's clever book subscription service is the talk of Oban, complete with local treats and hand-picked reads. But when elderly customer Nora Kelly is found dead in her armchair, Beth's book boxes are identified as the murder weapon. It seems a vengeful killer has the Wild Haggis Bookshop in their sights...
Detective Sergeant Logan Hunter insists on round-the-clock protection for Beth, which means close quarters with the infuriating – and increasingly attractive – officer. As spring approaches and the bookshop fills with bountiful blooms and excited children, Beth's investigation uncovers secrets that someone has spent decades trying to bury. With time running out, Beth must untangle a twisted web of lies that stretches far beyond this quaint Highland town. But when the killer strikes again, even Logan's protection may not be enough to save her...
My Thoughts /
First and foremost, a huge THANK YOU to NetGalley, Storm Publishing and author, Jackie Baldwin for providing me with a copy of this publication, which allows me to provide you with an unbiased review.
Poison at the Wild Haggis Bookshop is book #2 in the series The Highland Bookshop Murders and this instalment has protagonist and bookshop owner, Beth Cunningham recovering from the aftermath of being considered the prime suspect of a murder in the Wild Haggis Bookstore – which occurred in the previous story.
Full disclosure – I have book #1 Murder at the Wild Haggis Bookshop on my tbr but my inability to be patient meant that I've read this series out of order. However, because of Baldwin's exceptional talent to write a sequel that slays [my children will be rolling their eyes at the use of this term] I didn't feel lost in the story at any time. And here's why: — The author referred to the first book as if it were backstory. She can, and did, mention occurrences that happened in the past — because if she didn't, our current story would make less sense. The goal here is to make sure any reader who picks up the novel is able to read it without confusion.
Baldwin has set this series in Oban, Scotland – another reason I wanted to read this. The Highlands, lochs, castles, and all it's wild natural beauty. I love a Scottish setting, it never fails to amaze.
At the story's beginning, Beth and her loyal staff at the Wild Haggis Bookstore — Chloe, Morna and Lachlan are putting together the final touches on the store's subscription boxes which are due to go out shortly. These have proved a big hit with their customers and this time around Beth has sourced some lovely samples from local businesses to add to the boxes. Beth likes to go the extra mile by choosing to deliver the boxes personally to her customers and the last delivery for the day is Nora Kelly. One of Beth's more favourite customers, Nora lives alone but likes nothing more than coming into the shop at least once a week to make a purchase and have a chat. When Beth arrives at the house to find Nora asleep in her lounge, she realises something is wrong, very wrong. Nora is not asleep but dead.
Initial police investigations uncovered Nora had died of poisoning and, again, the finger is pointed straight at Beth – as Nora's subscription box had contained packets of tea which were thought to be contaminated with poison. Frustrated at again being made to look like the perpetrator, Beth works to find out what really happened to her friend and, clear her name.
A well written and cleverly plotted mystery which left no unresolved plotlines, apart from the hint of a continuing/beginning romantic relationship between our protagonist and the good police detective DS Logan Hunter.
With thanks to NetGalley and especially to one of my favourite publishers, Storm Publishing 💗 for the much appreciated arc in return for an honest review. All opinions expressed in this review are my own. The publication date is currently set for February 17, 2026.
Synopsis /
Beth Cunningham's clever book subscription service is the talk of Oban, complete with local treats and hand-picked reads. But when elderly customer Nora Kelly is found dead in her armchair, Beth's book boxes are identified as the murder weapon. It seems a vengeful killer has the Wild Haggis Bookshop in their sights...
Detective Sergeant Logan Hunter insists on round-the-clock protection for Beth, which means close quarters with the infuriating – and increasingly attractive – officer. As spring approaches and the bookshop fills with bountiful blooms and excited children, Beth's investigation uncovers secrets that someone has spent decades trying to bury. With time running out, Beth must untangle a twisted web of lies that stretches far beyond this quaint Highland town. But when the killer strikes again, even Logan's protection may not be enough to save her...
My Thoughts /
First and foremost, a huge THANK YOU to NetGalley, Storm Publishing and author, Jackie Baldwin for providing me with a copy of this publication, which allows me to provide you with an unbiased review.
Poison at the Wild Haggis Bookshop is book #2 in the series The Highland Bookshop Murders and this instalment has protagonist and bookshop owner, Beth Cunningham recovering from the aftermath of being considered the prime suspect of a murder in the Wild Haggis Bookstore – which occurred in the previous story.
Full disclosure – I have book #1 Murder at the Wild Haggis Bookshop on my tbr but my inability to be patient meant that I've read this series out of order. However, because of Baldwin's exceptional talent to write a sequel that slays [my children will be rolling their eyes at the use of this term] I didn't feel lost in the story at any time. And here's why: — The author referred to the first book as if it were backstory. She can, and did, mention occurrences that happened in the past — because if she didn't, our current story would make less sense. The goal here is to make sure any reader who picks up the novel is able to read it without confusion.
Baldwin has set this series in Oban, Scotland – another reason I wanted to read this. The Highlands, lochs, castles, and all it's wild natural beauty. I love a Scottish setting, it never fails to amaze.
At the story's beginning, Beth and her loyal staff at the Wild Haggis Bookstore — Chloe, Morna and Lachlan are putting together the final touches on the store's subscription boxes which are due to go out shortly. These have proved a big hit with their customers and this time around Beth has sourced some lovely samples from local businesses to add to the boxes. Beth likes to go the extra mile by choosing to deliver the boxes personally to her customers and the last delivery for the day is Nora Kelly. One of Beth's more favourite customers, Nora lives alone but likes nothing more than coming into the shop at least once a week to make a purchase and have a chat. When Beth arrives at the house to find Nora asleep in her lounge, she realises something is wrong, very wrong. Nora is not asleep but dead.
Initial police investigations uncovered Nora had died of poisoning and, again, the finger is pointed straight at Beth – as Nora's subscription box had contained packets of tea which were thought to be contaminated with poison. Frustrated at again being made to look like the perpetrator, Beth works to find out what really happened to her friend and, clear her name.
A well written and cleverly plotted mystery which left no unresolved plotlines, apart from the hint of a continuing/beginning romantic relationship between our protagonist and the good police detective DS Logan Hunter.
With thanks to NetGalley and especially to one of my favourite publishers, Storm Publishing 💗 for the much appreciated arc in return for an honest review. All opinions expressed in this review are my own. The publication date is currently set for February 17, 2026.
April 10, 2026
'Beth Cunningham's clever book subscription service is the talk of Oban, complete with local treats and hand-picked reads. But when elderly customer Nora Kelly is found dead in her armchair, Beth's book boxes are identified as the murder weapon.' This is a very promising book since it takes place in Oban (Scotland), and it is a very cosy and warm read. We will get to know Beth and those surrounding her. She sees herself once again in the middle of an investigation, and as hard as she tries, she doesn't seem to be able to stay away from it and starts to investigate herself.
This is the perfect book to read on a rainy day with a nice cup of tea. It is quite addictive, and you will soon start to have your own ideas of who might be the person responsible for Nora's death.
Involving books, murder, twists and turns, this is a very good book to be read in one sitting. The story is full of twists and turns, and even though I enjoyed reading it, there are a few points I would like to highlight:
In terms of characters, I felt that it was quite easy to get lost since there are too many characters involved in the story. I found that some of them were irrelevant, which added to the plot's confusion, and sometimes I had to stop and try to remember who the character was.
Another point I would like to highlight is the fact that the action seemed to be too fast-paced at some point: it felt that there was a rush to solve the crime, and I had a feeling that some characters could have been more explored and could have been given more depth of character, as well as being more present in the story.
Even though this is the second book of the Highland Bookshop Murders, I didn't feel that I had to read the first book to get into the story, but there is a clear reference to the plot of the first book. This only means that even though the book can be read as a first book, the reader will quickly understand that there is another book or books from the same 'saga'.
In spite of some things, I did enjoy the book. It is a very easy read, and for those who like Agatha Christie, this is a very good book. This is the first book that I have read by Jackie Baldwin, but I will definitely read more from the same author.
Many Thanks to Netgalley for sharing this ARC in exchange for my honest opinion/review.
This is the perfect book to read on a rainy day with a nice cup of tea. It is quite addictive, and you will soon start to have your own ideas of who might be the person responsible for Nora's death.
Involving books, murder, twists and turns, this is a very good book to be read in one sitting. The story is full of twists and turns, and even though I enjoyed reading it, there are a few points I would like to highlight:
In terms of characters, I felt that it was quite easy to get lost since there are too many characters involved in the story. I found that some of them were irrelevant, which added to the plot's confusion, and sometimes I had to stop and try to remember who the character was.
Another point I would like to highlight is the fact that the action seemed to be too fast-paced at some point: it felt that there was a rush to solve the crime, and I had a feeling that some characters could have been more explored and could have been given more depth of character, as well as being more present in the story.
Even though this is the second book of the Highland Bookshop Murders, I didn't feel that I had to read the first book to get into the story, but there is a clear reference to the plot of the first book. This only means that even though the book can be read as a first book, the reader will quickly understand that there is another book or books from the same 'saga'.
In spite of some things, I did enjoy the book. It is a very easy read, and for those who like Agatha Christie, this is a very good book. This is the first book that I have read by Jackie Baldwin, but I will definitely read more from the same author.
Many Thanks to Netgalley for sharing this ARC in exchange for my honest opinion/review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Beth Cunningham lives in the small Scottish town of Oban, where she runs a bookshop. Last year she was implicated in a murder, but that's all behind her...until she discovers the body of one of her regular customers while making a delivery. Initially dismissed as death by natural causes, Beth is certain there's more to the story - and before long she's once again in the eye of the storm.
As with the first book in this series, the thing which really impressed me was the genuinely dark history of the characters, and the equally dark motives - while still being a cozy murder mystery, this can and does take the reader to some surprising and controversial (for the genre) places. There were definitely points in the text which had me saying 'oh...wow' out loud, and I really respect that.
The key characters from the first book are with us again in the second and they have their own gentle arcs which carry you along with them - and I really like that although Beth is the central character, the book is definitely not all about her and you do come to care about the rest of the gang just as much.
Frustrations with this are fairly similar to the frustrations you'll find in many of this kind of book. The thing which grated on me most were the dropped plot points. Had they been red herrings designed to throw off the reader then I'd have understood but there are definitely a couple of things in this book which were meant to be significant and were just never followed up on. The dialogue isn't always that strong, and Beth has a habit of knowingly making decisions against her own interest as well as wild mood swings within the same breath.
Definitely worth a read, this is really enjoyable and good fun - especially if you're looking for a set of characters and a world you can buy into.
- Thanks you to NetGalley for the ARC in return for an honest review -
As with the first book in this series, the thing which really impressed me was the genuinely dark history of the characters, and the equally dark motives - while still being a cozy murder mystery, this can and does take the reader to some surprising and controversial (for the genre) places. There were definitely points in the text which had me saying 'oh...wow' out loud, and I really respect that.
The key characters from the first book are with us again in the second and they have their own gentle arcs which carry you along with them - and I really like that although Beth is the central character, the book is definitely not all about her and you do come to care about the rest of the gang just as much.
Frustrations with this are fairly similar to the frustrations you'll find in many of this kind of book. The thing which grated on me most were the dropped plot points. Had they been red herrings designed to throw off the reader then I'd have understood but there are definitely a couple of things in this book which were meant to be significant and were just never followed up on. The dialogue isn't always that strong, and Beth has a habit of knowingly making decisions against her own interest as well as wild mood swings within the same breath.
Definitely worth a read, this is really enjoyable and good fun - especially if you're looking for a set of characters and a world you can buy into.
- Thanks you to NetGalley for the ARC in return for an honest review -
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Poison at the Wild Haggis Bookshop is exactly the kind of cozy crime novel that feels like a treat from the very first chapter. With its mix of bookish charm, small‑town secrets, and a heroine you can’t help rooting for, this story delivers a delightful blend of warmth and intrigue.
Beth Cunningham is such an easy character to spend time with. Her book subscription service—complete with local goodies—adds a lovely, tactile touch to the story, and the bookshop setting is as inviting as you’d hope. That’s why the shock of discovering her beloved book boxes have been used as a murder weapon hits so hard. It’s a clever hook, and it sets the tone for a mystery that’s both playful and surprisingly layered.
The dynamic between Beth and DS Logan Hunter is another highlight. Their forced proximity brings plenty of gentle humour and slow‑burn tension, and it balances the darker elements of the plot beautifully. Logan’s protective streak and Beth’s stubborn independence make for a fun pairing, especially as the danger creeps closer.
The mystery itself is twisty without ever feeling overcomplicated. As Beth digs deeper into Nora Kelly’s past, the story opens up into decades‑old secrets, long‑buried grudges, and a community that’s far more tangled than it first appears. The pacing is spot on, and the Highland setting adds a lovely sense of atmosphere—fresh blooms, lively children in the shop, and that unmistakable small‑town buzz.
By the time the killer strikes again, the stakes feel genuinely high, and the final reveal is satisfying and well earned.
Overall, this is a warm, engaging cozy with just enough bite to keep you turning the pages. Fans of Paige Shelton, Dee MacDonald, and anyone who loves a bookshop‑based mystery will have a great time with this one.
With thanks to Jackie Baldwin, the publisher and netgalley for the ARC
Beth Cunningham is such an easy character to spend time with. Her book subscription service—complete with local goodies—adds a lovely, tactile touch to the story, and the bookshop setting is as inviting as you’d hope. That’s why the shock of discovering her beloved book boxes have been used as a murder weapon hits so hard. It’s a clever hook, and it sets the tone for a mystery that’s both playful and surprisingly layered.
The dynamic between Beth and DS Logan Hunter is another highlight. Their forced proximity brings plenty of gentle humour and slow‑burn tension, and it balances the darker elements of the plot beautifully. Logan’s protective streak and Beth’s stubborn independence make for a fun pairing, especially as the danger creeps closer.
The mystery itself is twisty without ever feeling overcomplicated. As Beth digs deeper into Nora Kelly’s past, the story opens up into decades‑old secrets, long‑buried grudges, and a community that’s far more tangled than it first appears. The pacing is spot on, and the Highland setting adds a lovely sense of atmosphere—fresh blooms, lively children in the shop, and that unmistakable small‑town buzz.
By the time the killer strikes again, the stakes feel genuinely high, and the final reveal is satisfying and well earned.
Overall, this is a warm, engaging cozy with just enough bite to keep you turning the pages. Fans of Paige Shelton, Dee MacDonald, and anyone who loves a bookshop‑based mystery will have a great time with this one.
With thanks to Jackie Baldwin, the publisher and netgalley for the ARC
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Oban, Scotland is now comfortably home to Beth Cunningham. She loves her cottage and most especially her Wild Haggis Bookshop. She and her staff are curating subscription boxes. When she heads off to deliver the latest one to her elderly client, Nora Kelly, she finds the woman dead in her chair. When the police determine she was poisoned, presumably by tea from earlier boxes and find a will leaving everything to Beth, she immediately becomes the prime suspect. If you read book one in the series you know how traumatic this is for her and why. If you didn't, the author gives you enough information to understand. She immediately begins looking for other suspects. As the police investigation moves along, it becomes apparent that she is being framed and is a possible target as well. Detective Sargent Logan Hunter insists she needs round-the-clock protection until the killer is found. This intensifies the slow-burning romance between the two of them. Will they act on the attraction? read on to find out!
This is book two in a series and while it can be read as a stand-alone, I would recommend reading Murder at the Wild Haggis Bookshop first. Many of the references to Beth's previous life will be richer for it.
I heartily recommend this book. The characters are genuine and fun with moments of heartache and self-doubt thrown in, much like real life without dragging the reader down. I love the character growth, especially of some of the supporting characters. The plot clips right along with plenty of surprises and turns in the road. If you are a fan of Paige Shelton's Scottish Bookshop series you will love this one! You may find yourself planning a trip to Scotland sooner than you think!
My thanks to Storm Publishing and NetGalley for the opportunity to read an early copy of this in exchange for my honest thoughts.
This is book two in a series and while it can be read as a stand-alone, I would recommend reading Murder at the Wild Haggis Bookshop first. Many of the references to Beth's previous life will be richer for it.
I heartily recommend this book. The characters are genuine and fun with moments of heartache and self-doubt thrown in, much like real life without dragging the reader down. I love the character growth, especially of some of the supporting characters. The plot clips right along with plenty of surprises and turns in the road. If you are a fan of Paige Shelton's Scottish Bookshop series you will love this one! You may find yourself planning a trip to Scotland sooner than you think!
My thanks to Storm Publishing and NetGalley for the opportunity to read an early copy of this in exchange for my honest thoughts.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
This is the second book that I have read by Jackie Baldwin and I must admit that I am really enjoying this series.
The Wild Haggis Bookshop was nestled in the beautiful town of Oban, in the stunning Scottish Highlands, the owner is Beth Cunningham, she and her assistants Lachlan, Morna and Chloe were always staging events to encourage more customers, events that the townsfolk loved.
Until she settled in Oban, Beth's life had been one tragedy after another, recent events had also taken their toll, but Beth loved Oban, she loved her shop and her circle of friends.
One of the services that the bookshop provided was to deliver book subscription boxes to the elderly and people who could not get to the shop, these boxes also contained small promotional gifts from local businesses, a little treat for the subscribers.
One such lady was retired school teacher, Nora Kelly, little did Beth know that her visit to Nora would be another tragedy to add to her long list.
Nora was dead. it was Beth who found her and Beth became suspect number one, she had the means and she had the motive.
Once more Beth's love hate relationship with the handsome DS Logan Hunter, the same Logan whose delightful six year old daughter, Poppy, had taken a shine to Beth, the same Logan Hunter who looked at her emotionless across the interview table.
This complicated plot unfolds with multiple suspects all with their own agenda. Gentle, and sometimes naïve, Beth and her little band of helpers once again put their heads together to help solve the mystery much to the annoyance of DS Hunter.
This is a great cosy mystery with wonderful characters.......which way will the pendulum swing in Beth and Logan's relationship.
Thank you Storm Publishing and Net Gallery for this ARC, my review is totally voluntary.
The Wild Haggis Bookshop was nestled in the beautiful town of Oban, in the stunning Scottish Highlands, the owner is Beth Cunningham, she and her assistants Lachlan, Morna and Chloe were always staging events to encourage more customers, events that the townsfolk loved.
Until she settled in Oban, Beth's life had been one tragedy after another, recent events had also taken their toll, but Beth loved Oban, she loved her shop and her circle of friends.
One of the services that the bookshop provided was to deliver book subscription boxes to the elderly and people who could not get to the shop, these boxes also contained small promotional gifts from local businesses, a little treat for the subscribers.
One such lady was retired school teacher, Nora Kelly, little did Beth know that her visit to Nora would be another tragedy to add to her long list.
Nora was dead. it was Beth who found her and Beth became suspect number one, she had the means and she had the motive.
Once more Beth's love hate relationship with the handsome DS Logan Hunter, the same Logan whose delightful six year old daughter, Poppy, had taken a shine to Beth, the same Logan Hunter who looked at her emotionless across the interview table.
This complicated plot unfolds with multiple suspects all with their own agenda. Gentle, and sometimes naïve, Beth and her little band of helpers once again put their heads together to help solve the mystery much to the annoyance of DS Hunter.
This is a great cosy mystery with wonderful characters.......which way will the pendulum swing in Beth and Logan's relationship.
Thank you Storm Publishing and Net Gallery for this ARC, my review is totally voluntary.
August 26, 2026
Originally posted on my blog: Nonstop Reader.
Poison at the Wild Haggis Bookshop is a Scottish cozy shopfront mystery and the second book in the series by Jackie Baldwin. Released on 17th Feb 2026 by Storm publishing, it's 272 pages and is available in paperback, audio, and ebook formats. It's worth noting that the ebook format has a handy interactive table of contents as well as interactive links and references throughout. For Kindle Unlimited subscribers, this book is currently included in the KU subscription library to borrow and read for free. The first book in the series is also currently available on KU, and there's a third book due out in Dec 2026.
For readers who love small-town cozies, mysteries, and light UK crime fiction, this one ticks a lot of boxes. It's capably written with an intelligent and appealing bookstore owner drawn into a murder which she stumbles into when she's delivering books to a shut in customer. The action does move resolutely forward, and it never drags, so although simple, it's an enjoyable and engaging read. There is no bad language or triggering content and the climax and denouement were satisfying and included a few twists.
It works well as a standalone, and it's not necessary to read the books in order for continuity.
Four stars. This is an enjoyable bookshop cozy. Fans of the genre will find a lot to like here. The second book is out and it's a continuing series. It would make a good short binge/buddy read.
Disclosure: I received an ARC at no cost from the author/publisher for review purposes.
Poison at the Wild Haggis Bookshop is a Scottish cozy shopfront mystery and the second book in the series by Jackie Baldwin. Released on 17th Feb 2026 by Storm publishing, it's 272 pages and is available in paperback, audio, and ebook formats. It's worth noting that the ebook format has a handy interactive table of contents as well as interactive links and references throughout. For Kindle Unlimited subscribers, this book is currently included in the KU subscription library to borrow and read for free. The first book in the series is also currently available on KU, and there's a third book due out in Dec 2026.
For readers who love small-town cozies, mysteries, and light UK crime fiction, this one ticks a lot of boxes. It's capably written with an intelligent and appealing bookstore owner drawn into a murder which she stumbles into when she's delivering books to a shut in customer. The action does move resolutely forward, and it never drags, so although simple, it's an enjoyable and engaging read. There is no bad language or triggering content and the climax and denouement were satisfying and included a few twists.
It works well as a standalone, and it's not necessary to read the books in order for continuity.
Four stars. This is an enjoyable bookshop cozy. Fans of the genre will find a lot to like here. The second book is out and it's a continuing series. It would make a good short binge/buddy read.
Disclosure: I received an ARC at no cost from the author/publisher for review purposes.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Poison at the Wild Haggis Bookshop by Jackie Baldwin was a thoroughly enjoyable, fast-paced cozy mystery that I flew through in just three days. It was exactly the kind of read I needed: engaging, easy to follow, and entertaining without being too heavy.
Beth is a strong and likeable main character with a big heart. I loved how determined she was to help everyone around her, even when that tendency landed her in trouble. Yes, she makes some questionable decisions—like meeting suspects on her own—but that impulsiveness also adds to the tension and keeps the story moving. It’s easy to root for her, especially as she tries to clear her name once again.
The mystery itself was a lot of fun, with plenty of suspects and twists to keep me guessing. I really enjoyed the concept of the book subscription boxes and how they tied into the crime—it’s a clever and very “bookish” touch that suits the setting perfectly. While a few clues felt a little too convenient, appearing rather than being actively discovered, the overall plot was still engaging and well paced.
Logan was a slightly mixed character for me. His sudden shifts in mood—from shouting to calm—felt a bit jarring at times, but his dynamic with Beth still added interest and a hint of slow-burn tension. The police work leaned more toward conversations than action, but in a cozy mystery setting, that didn’t take away too much from my enjoyment.
Overall, this was a fun, quick, and comforting read with a charming bookshop setting, an appealing cast of characters, and a mystery that kept me turning the pages. I’ll definitely continue with the series.
Thanks to NetGalley and Storm Publishing for the ARC in exchange for an honest review. 📚✨
Beth is a strong and likeable main character with a big heart. I loved how determined she was to help everyone around her, even when that tendency landed her in trouble. Yes, she makes some questionable decisions—like meeting suspects on her own—but that impulsiveness also adds to the tension and keeps the story moving. It’s easy to root for her, especially as she tries to clear her name once again.
The mystery itself was a lot of fun, with plenty of suspects and twists to keep me guessing. I really enjoyed the concept of the book subscription boxes and how they tied into the crime—it’s a clever and very “bookish” touch that suits the setting perfectly. While a few clues felt a little too convenient, appearing rather than being actively discovered, the overall plot was still engaging and well paced.
Logan was a slightly mixed character for me. His sudden shifts in mood—from shouting to calm—felt a bit jarring at times, but his dynamic with Beth still added interest and a hint of slow-burn tension. The police work leaned more toward conversations than action, but in a cozy mystery setting, that didn’t take away too much from my enjoyment.
Overall, this was a fun, quick, and comforting read with a charming bookshop setting, an appealing cast of characters, and a mystery that kept me turning the pages. I’ll definitely continue with the series.
Thanks to NetGalley and Storm Publishing for the ARC in exchange for an honest review. 📚✨
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
When Beth Cunningham, owner/operator of the Wild Haggis Bookshop, delivered one of her subscription boxes to the elderly Nora Kelly, she was horrified to discover her dead in her home. It was soon said that her special boxes were to blame, with the mushroom tea laced with poison. Samples supplied by locals; a book from Beth's bookshop - she had nothing to do with it. But of course, Detective Sergeant Logan Hunter didn't believe a word of it, and once more she was being interrogated for murder. Beth's staff, Chloe, Lachlan and Morna, all stood by her, along with her cat Toby, plus Marmalade, who'd belonged to Nora and Beth gave him a home.
The strangeness of what was happening, the lack of motive, the two people who declared they were Nora's children, when she had none - Detective Hunter had his work cut out. Beth was determined to find the answers to prove she was innocent - which put her in danger. There were secrets from the past; did they connect to Nora's death? Could Beth work it out before someone else lost their life?
Poison at the Wild Haggis Bookshop is the 2nd in The Highland Bookshop Murders series by Jackie Baldwin and I thoroughly enjoyed it. Beth couldn't believe it when she was suddenly mixed up in murder again - was she jinxed? With gritty, well written characters, an interesting plot and some intense situations, I'm really looking forward to #3. Highly recommended.
With thanks to NetGalley & Storm Publishing for my digital ARC to read and review.
The strangeness of what was happening, the lack of motive, the two people who declared they were Nora's children, when she had none - Detective Hunter had his work cut out. Beth was determined to find the answers to prove she was innocent - which put her in danger. There were secrets from the past; did they connect to Nora's death? Could Beth work it out before someone else lost their life?
Poison at the Wild Haggis Bookshop is the 2nd in The Highland Bookshop Murders series by Jackie Baldwin and I thoroughly enjoyed it. Beth couldn't believe it when she was suddenly mixed up in murder again - was she jinxed? With gritty, well written characters, an interesting plot and some intense situations, I'm really looking forward to #3. Highly recommended.
With thanks to NetGalley & Storm Publishing for my digital ARC to read and review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
4.5 rounded up
Beth has started a new initiative with the bookstore to bring in additional community value by offering book boxes with cute wares from businesses around town. Off to deliver to an elderly buyer she hasn't seen in awhile, she stumbles across vandalism, a strange man, and a dead body, yet all signs point to her and her book boxes as the murder weapon.
*****
We're back in Oban for the second book in the Wild Haggis Bookshop Murder series! I was wondering where they would go with this one, as the first novel was based partly in Beth's past being dragged up with the murder being in her shop, and unraveling each new character and their intentions. I was delighted by how quickly we were tossed into the murder mystery, and that Beth's shop was still involved tangentially as she was swept up in the undercurrent.
This one has multiple twists, some side storylines that deepen a few of the other characters, as well as various moment's where you'll want to yell at Beth to call the bloody police and let them do their jobs! Which honestly, was half the fun. I love that Beth is genuine, naive and a little under experienced despite her age, and she truly wants the best for everyone. That atmosphere made the book cozy even while eerie vibes existed as people fell to violence, suspicion and crises around her. I also loved that with her life going up in flame, we got a bit more of her and the detective coming closer together and tying in a bit of the potential romance we saw at the end of book one.
All in all, I loved this one. It was fun, interesting and cozy, and exactly what I love about the series.
*****
Thank you to NetGalley and Storm Publishing for the advanced reader copy. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Beth has started a new initiative with the bookstore to bring in additional community value by offering book boxes with cute wares from businesses around town. Off to deliver to an elderly buyer she hasn't seen in awhile, she stumbles across vandalism, a strange man, and a dead body, yet all signs point to her and her book boxes as the murder weapon.
*****
We're back in Oban for the second book in the Wild Haggis Bookshop Murder series! I was wondering where they would go with this one, as the first novel was based partly in Beth's past being dragged up with the murder being in her shop, and unraveling each new character and their intentions. I was delighted by how quickly we were tossed into the murder mystery, and that Beth's shop was still involved tangentially as she was swept up in the undercurrent.
This one has multiple twists, some side storylines that deepen a few of the other characters, as well as various moment's where you'll want to yell at Beth to call the bloody police and let them do their jobs! Which honestly, was half the fun. I love that Beth is genuine, naive and a little under experienced despite her age, and she truly wants the best for everyone. That atmosphere made the book cozy even while eerie vibes existed as people fell to violence, suspicion and crises around her. I also loved that with her life going up in flame, we got a bit more of her and the detective coming closer together and tying in a bit of the potential romance we saw at the end of book one.
All in all, I loved this one. It was fun, interesting and cozy, and exactly what I love about the series.
*****
Thank you to NetGalley and Storm Publishing for the advanced reader copy. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
March 2, 2026
This was such a charming cosy mystery with just the right amount of bite.
A Scottish bookshop setting and two gorgeous cats, Toby and Marmalade, and I was completely invested. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, but there’s an underlying tension that keeps the pages turning.
The story begins when one of Beth’s book subscription customers, Nora, is found dead at home. Suspicion quickly circles back to Beth when it appears that the subscription box itself may have been the murder weapon. From that moment on, the stakes feel personal and urgent.
What follows is a cosy mystery with a darker edge as Beth teams up (and clashes) with DS Logan Hunter to uncover secrets that have been buried for decades. As the investigation deepens and the danger escalates, the sense that someone is watching and willing to strike again keeps the tension simmering beneath the bookshop charm.
The dynamic between Beth and Logan was genuinely lovely to read. There’s a definite grumpy x sunshine vibe there, with forced proximity adding an extra layer of slow-burn chemistry. Their interactions bring warmth and to an otherwise unsettling situation.
The cats stole my heart. Toby and Marmalade are true scene-stealers.
I also really enjoyed the sense of found family within the bookshop — Chloe, Morgan and Lachlan add depth to the world, and it’s clear there’s more history to uncover, especially regarding Beth’s past. That lingering sense of backstory has definitely convinced me to go back and read the first book in the series, Murder at the Wild Haggis Bookshop.
If you love cosy crime with a slightly darker thread, a strong female lead, a grumpy detective, and a bookshop full of secrets, this is well worth picking up.
A Scottish bookshop setting and two gorgeous cats, Toby and Marmalade, and I was completely invested. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, but there’s an underlying tension that keeps the pages turning.
The story begins when one of Beth’s book subscription customers, Nora, is found dead at home. Suspicion quickly circles back to Beth when it appears that the subscription box itself may have been the murder weapon. From that moment on, the stakes feel personal and urgent.
What follows is a cosy mystery with a darker edge as Beth teams up (and clashes) with DS Logan Hunter to uncover secrets that have been buried for decades. As the investigation deepens and the danger escalates, the sense that someone is watching and willing to strike again keeps the tension simmering beneath the bookshop charm.
The dynamic between Beth and Logan was genuinely lovely to read. There’s a definite grumpy x sunshine vibe there, with forced proximity adding an extra layer of slow-burn chemistry. Their interactions bring warmth and to an otherwise unsettling situation.
The cats stole my heart. Toby and Marmalade are true scene-stealers.
I also really enjoyed the sense of found family within the bookshop — Chloe, Morgan and Lachlan add depth to the world, and it’s clear there’s more history to uncover, especially regarding Beth’s past. That lingering sense of backstory has definitely convinced me to go back and read the first book in the series, Murder at the Wild Haggis Bookshop.
If you love cosy crime with a slightly darker thread, a strong female lead, a grumpy detective, and a bookshop full of secrets, this is well worth picking up.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This is certainly a darker cosy read than most.
Our main character has a very dark past which was a lovely change. It doesn't shy away from that either. The murders and motives that are scattered throughout this book are just as dark and they touch on very topical, sensitive issues. On the other hand, Beth did annoy me at times with her wild mood swings and... questionable choices. I understand it's her personality but I really wanted to faceplant at some of the dumb things she decided to do without any real thought as to the consequences.
It truly feels like it is set in Scotland rather than that just being a name, the whole book invokes the country brilliantly. There is plenty to enjoy here, a highlight, as with the previous book, being the little found family that she has created within the bookstore. I was very invested in the subplot involving her younger staff, almost as much as I was in the actual murder mystery itself.
I would have loved to have rated it higher, because I did enjoy it. It's just there are so many plot points that either don't make sense or are brought up never to be referred to again. A certain note, a certain disguise, a whole family... those were all intriguing points and they either were never addressed or just didn't serve any purpose.
It's a good read beyond those quibbles however, and they shouldn't be enough to put you off reading it, its just frustrating in the moment for there to be what seems like a clue or a major plot point that you see but the book never truly acknowledges.
~Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC in return for an honest review~
Our main character has a very dark past which was a lovely change. It doesn't shy away from that either. The murders and motives that are scattered throughout this book are just as dark and they touch on very topical, sensitive issues. On the other hand, Beth did annoy me at times with her wild mood swings and... questionable choices. I understand it's her personality but I really wanted to faceplant at some of the dumb things she decided to do without any real thought as to the consequences.
It truly feels like it is set in Scotland rather than that just being a name, the whole book invokes the country brilliantly. There is plenty to enjoy here, a highlight, as with the previous book, being the little found family that she has created within the bookstore. I was very invested in the subplot involving her younger staff, almost as much as I was in the actual murder mystery itself.
I would have loved to have rated it higher, because I did enjoy it. It's just there are so many plot points that either don't make sense or are brought up never to be referred to again. A certain note, a certain disguise, a whole family... those were all intriguing points and they either were never addressed or just didn't serve any purpose.
It's a good read beyond those quibbles however, and they shouldn't be enough to put you off reading it, its just frustrating in the moment for there to be what seems like a clue or a major plot point that you see but the book never truly acknowledges.
~Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC in return for an honest review~
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
The Wild Haggis Bookshop is among my favorite names for bookshops ever!
Although anticipating this book because of the description, my feelings were mixed because of how I felt about book 1. I wasn’t sure the first book fell into the cozy category. Knowing that heading into this second book I was more prepared for the twisty and more suspense like elements of Poison at the Wild Haggis Bookshop. However, I would place book 2 in the cozy category for the pacing and the relational development between characters.
Beth is finally seeing some of the success she wants for the bookshop through the subscription boxes she and the team are pulling together. Then a customer dies and it looks like it was from an addition to the subscription box. Beth falls under the scrutiny of Detective Logan Hunter and DC Quinn again.
The author does a good job of inserting backstory so that the reader can understand why Beth has so much anxiety about even coming to the attention of the police. However, a better understanding is only gained if the first book has been read. Especially some of the finer details that come out in this book. I admit I didn’t remember crucial details that play a role in some of the happenings in the book.
The mystery was a good puzzle for sure. I think my favorite part was seeing the evolution of relationships between bookshop employees, the town members and the police.
The baby chicks in the bookshop, and the antics of the cats add a fun element as well.
I recommend this book for the mystery, the relationships and the fantastic name of the bookshop.
Thanks to Netgalley and Storm Publishing for an early copy of the book to read.
Although anticipating this book because of the description, my feelings were mixed because of how I felt about book 1. I wasn’t sure the first book fell into the cozy category. Knowing that heading into this second book I was more prepared for the twisty and more suspense like elements of Poison at the Wild Haggis Bookshop. However, I would place book 2 in the cozy category for the pacing and the relational development between characters.
Beth is finally seeing some of the success she wants for the bookshop through the subscription boxes she and the team are pulling together. Then a customer dies and it looks like it was from an addition to the subscription box. Beth falls under the scrutiny of Detective Logan Hunter and DC Quinn again.
The author does a good job of inserting backstory so that the reader can understand why Beth has so much anxiety about even coming to the attention of the police. However, a better understanding is only gained if the first book has been read. Especially some of the finer details that come out in this book. I admit I didn’t remember crucial details that play a role in some of the happenings in the book.
The mystery was a good puzzle for sure. I think my favorite part was seeing the evolution of relationships between bookshop employees, the town members and the police.
The baby chicks in the bookshop, and the antics of the cats add a fun element as well.
I recommend this book for the mystery, the relationships and the fantastic name of the bookshop.
Thanks to Netgalley and Storm Publishing for an early copy of the book to read.
March 15, 2026
Actually 3.5 but had round down as good reads still doesn't allow half stars
It's another Baldwin book and this time we are back to the bookshop- Beth' bookshop is booming with business especially with a cultivated subscription service box- but it seems someone is out for the bookshop when Beth discovers an elderly customer dead and her subscription service is the murder weapon. Despite the round the clock protection from the police- courtesy of yummy detective Logan- the killer strikes again- it's going to take all her skills to uncover the truth.
I love me a good Jackie Baldwin as her murder mysteries are actually more down to earth and less elaborate. This one is do different- my only issue with this series is that our protagonist is a bookshop owner so her investigating anything makes no sense- especially with her last two brushes with the law- if it were me I'd be running for the highland hills to stay out of it.
And I think that's what really took me out as well of this story- as the entire time I was thinking "but why are you investigating?" See the first book made sense as the police were botching the crime and Beth was trying to prove her innocence.
Yes Beth discovers the body in this one but it makes no sense for her to be doing any investigating. Don't get me wrong I love Beth as a character- I love how well the characters are written- but like why is a bookshop team investigating the murder of customers? Like at all?
It's a Jackie Baldwin book so you know the mystery and the characters are fantastic- I can recommend this one if you like nosey amateur crime sleuths.
It's another Baldwin book and this time we are back to the bookshop- Beth' bookshop is booming with business especially with a cultivated subscription service box- but it seems someone is out for the bookshop when Beth discovers an elderly customer dead and her subscription service is the murder weapon. Despite the round the clock protection from the police- courtesy of yummy detective Logan- the killer strikes again- it's going to take all her skills to uncover the truth.
I love me a good Jackie Baldwin as her murder mysteries are actually more down to earth and less elaborate. This one is do different- my only issue with this series is that our protagonist is a bookshop owner so her investigating anything makes no sense- especially with her last two brushes with the law- if it were me I'd be running for the highland hills to stay out of it.
And I think that's what really took me out as well of this story- as the entire time I was thinking "but why are you investigating?" See the first book made sense as the police were botching the crime and Beth was trying to prove her innocence.
Yes Beth discovers the body in this one but it makes no sense for her to be doing any investigating. Don't get me wrong I love Beth as a character- I love how well the characters are written- but like why is a bookshop team investigating the murder of customers? Like at all?
It's a Jackie Baldwin book so you know the mystery and the characters are fantastic- I can recommend this one if you like nosey amateur crime sleuths.
April 22, 2026
This is the 2nd installment in the Highland Bookshop mystery series. Beth is enjoying her bookshop and getting excited for Easter. The bookshop has started a subscription box for homebound and others who want to receive a book and samples of other merchandise from other local businesses. When Beth is delivering the 3rd month subscription box to Nora Kelly she finds a young man who seems disturbed and when she asks to see Nora she finds her dead in her chair. She calls the police and Logan and his partner arrive and everyone but Beth feel it is just a heart attack. Beth thinks something is off about the whole thing. Nora never mentioned any children but Callum the young man at Nora’s house claims that he is her son and then a woman named Jane appears and says she was her daughter. Everyone seems to be going to Beth and then the police bring her in for questioning. Beth is hurt as she felt she was becoming a friend to Logan and his little daughter Poppy and then hard nosed detective shows up again. Beth continues to investigate to clear her name and protect the bookstore. Nora’s ex-husband is killed shortly after Beth talks to him and then Beth is targeted with her getting police protection. It is clear that Logan and Beth are attracted to each other but all this murder business keeps getting in the way. Once again Beth’s co-workers and friends are there for her and are helping each other and the investigation. I like how her bookstore co-workers have become family for each other. This is a good solid mystery and I like how all the characters are developing. Definitely looking forward to the next in this series. Highly recommend.
February 18, 2026
"Poison at the Wild Haggis Bookshop (The Highland Bookshop Murders Book 2)" by Jackie Baldwin is set almost a year after the first book at Easter time. Beth is fairly well established in her bookshop now. She has her employees really helping out and getting along. When she goes to deliver some of the local orders she follows her instincts at an elderly person's house and discovers yet another body.
Things get a bit weird when elder abuse potentially becomes suspected. There's also the topic of undocumented individuals and vigilante justice. There were several moments that made me ask "why didn't you think of that before" when the characters seemingly didn't think about a potential outcome. It also seemed a bit disjointed at times, but that could be because I read a ARC version of the book.
I was also a bit disappointed that there still was a minimal attempt at multiple view points. One chapter from the view points of Beth's employees/friends. Nothing in it worth actually being only a chapter of. The information was provided again by Beth immediately afterwards. So that whole chapter could be tossed.
Overall, an interesting ending and overall story. I was a bit surprised Beth followed through on her promise at the end. Maybe it'll only hold for this book and be a series bridging plot. I hope the author drops the single chapter multiple view points thing since it doesn't add to the story.
Things get a bit weird when elder abuse potentially becomes suspected. There's also the topic of undocumented individuals and vigilante justice. There were several moments that made me ask "why didn't you think of that before" when the characters seemingly didn't think about a potential outcome. It also seemed a bit disjointed at times, but that could be because I read a ARC version of the book.
I was also a bit disappointed that there still was a minimal attempt at multiple view points. One chapter from the view points of Beth's employees/friends. Nothing in it worth actually being only a chapter of. The information was provided again by Beth immediately afterwards. So that whole chapter could be tossed.
Overall, an interesting ending and overall story. I was a bit surprised Beth followed through on her promise at the end. Maybe it'll only hold for this book and be a series bridging plot. I hope the author drops the single chapter multiple view points thing since it doesn't add to the story.
February 19, 2026
I have enjoyed reading all of Jackie Baldwin's books from her first novel, Dead Man's Prayer in the D.I. Frank Farrell series and having read the first book in the Highland Bookshop Murders series, Murder at the Wild Haggis Bookshop,I had no hesitation in pre-ordering this second novel as soon as I'd finished reading it. I am pleased to say that I wasn't disappointed.
When Beth Cunningham the proprietor of the Wild Haggis Bookshop, visits elderly customer Nora Kelly, with one of her shop's book subscription boxes containing the book and local treats, she finds Nora dead in her armchair. The police investigation into Nora's death, quickly identifies that a sample of mushroom tea in the subscription box, was the murder weapon and Beth having found Nora dead, quickly comes under suspicion.
Beth decides to investigate Nora's death, much to the chagrin of Detective Sergeant Logan Hunter who Beth finds both infuriating and at the same time increasingly attractive. Finding out that the proprietor of the pop-up shop which supplied the mushroom tea used in the subscription boxes has disappeared, Beth realises that there are secrets to uncover which stretch far beyond Oban. When the killer strikes again and an attempt is also made on Beth's life, She realises that even the protection that D.S.Hunter has placed her in may not be enough.
An excellent murder mystery that I couldn't put down and which I really enjoyed. Well done Jackie Baldwin for writing another great story and I will certainly be looking forward to the next book in the series.
When Beth Cunningham the proprietor of the Wild Haggis Bookshop, visits elderly customer Nora Kelly, with one of her shop's book subscription boxes containing the book and local treats, she finds Nora dead in her armchair. The police investigation into Nora's death, quickly identifies that a sample of mushroom tea in the subscription box, was the murder weapon and Beth having found Nora dead, quickly comes under suspicion.
Beth decides to investigate Nora's death, much to the chagrin of Detective Sergeant Logan Hunter who Beth finds both infuriating and at the same time increasingly attractive. Finding out that the proprietor of the pop-up shop which supplied the mushroom tea used in the subscription boxes has disappeared, Beth realises that there are secrets to uncover which stretch far beyond Oban. When the killer strikes again and an attempt is also made on Beth's life, She realises that even the protection that D.S.Hunter has placed her in may not be enough.
An excellent murder mystery that I couldn't put down and which I really enjoyed. Well done Jackie Baldwin for writing another great story and I will certainly be looking forward to the next book in the series.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Jackie Baldwin’s Poison at the Wild Haggis Bookshop is the sort of cozy mystery that invites you in with the promise of books, biscuits, and Highland charm, then quietly locks the door behind you and starts asking uncomfortable questions.
Published by Storm Publishing, with many thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for my gifted ARC.
Returning to Oban and the Wild Haggis Bookshop feels like slipping back into a favorite jumper that somehow still fits perfectly. This is book two in The Highland Bookshop Murders series, and it builds confidently on the foundations of the first while raising the stakes in a way that feels earned. Beth Cunningham is back with her clever book subscription service, her earnest determination, and her unfortunate knack for being far too close to murder. When one of her customers is found dead in her armchair and Beth’s own book box is implicated as the murder weapon, the story wastes no time making things personal.
What really works here is how comfortably the book balances its tones. It is undeniably cozy, full of bookish joy, small-town quirks, and the kind of setting that makes you want to move to Oban immediately or at least book a long weekend. But underneath that warmth is a genuinely engaging mystery with emotional weight. The secrets uncovered are not just convenient plot devices. They feel old, tangled, and human, the sort of things that fester quietly for decades before exploding at exactly the wrong moment.
Beth continues to be a protagonist I enjoy spending time with. She is smart without being infallible, kind without being naïve, and stubborn in a way that feels believable rather than frustrating. Her relationship with Detective Sergeant Logan Hunter remains a slow, simmering delight. The forced proximity and reluctant teamwork add spark and humor, but never overpower the mystery itself. Their banter feels natural, and I appreciated that the romantic tension enhances the story rather than hijacking it.
The pacing is excellent. Clues are layered in thoughtfully, red herrings are placed with a light but confident hand, and the plot kept me guessing far longer than I expected. I had theories. I was wrong. I always enjoy being wrong when it feels fair, and this absolutely did. The final stretch tightens beautifully, delivering both tension and payoff without losing the cozy tone that defines the series.
The setting deserves special mention. The Wild Haggis Bookshop remains the beating heart of the story, and the surrounding town feels alive with personalities, routines, and quiet judgments. This is the kind of fictional place that feels real enough to miss once you leave it. Baldwin has a real talent for making community itself part of the mystery, where everyone knows everyone and that familiarity is both comforting and dangerous.
“This book is like settling in with tea and a blanket, only to realize the room has gone very quiet and someone nearby is hiding something.”
Poison at the Wild Haggis Bookshop is a strong second installment that deepens the characters, sharpens the mystery, and cements this series as one I will happily keep returning to. If you enjoy cozy mysteries with substance, atmosphere, and a bookshop you wish you could visit, this one is an easy recommendation.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 5 stars
#PoisonAtTheWildHaggisBookshop #JackieBaldwin #HighlandBookshopMurders #CozyMystery #BookReview #NetGalley #ARCReview #CozyCrime #MysteryBooks #StormPublishing
Published by Storm Publishing, with many thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for my gifted ARC.
Returning to Oban and the Wild Haggis Bookshop feels like slipping back into a favorite jumper that somehow still fits perfectly. This is book two in The Highland Bookshop Murders series, and it builds confidently on the foundations of the first while raising the stakes in a way that feels earned. Beth Cunningham is back with her clever book subscription service, her earnest determination, and her unfortunate knack for being far too close to murder. When one of her customers is found dead in her armchair and Beth’s own book box is implicated as the murder weapon, the story wastes no time making things personal.
What really works here is how comfortably the book balances its tones. It is undeniably cozy, full of bookish joy, small-town quirks, and the kind of setting that makes you want to move to Oban immediately or at least book a long weekend. But underneath that warmth is a genuinely engaging mystery with emotional weight. The secrets uncovered are not just convenient plot devices. They feel old, tangled, and human, the sort of things that fester quietly for decades before exploding at exactly the wrong moment.
Beth continues to be a protagonist I enjoy spending time with. She is smart without being infallible, kind without being naïve, and stubborn in a way that feels believable rather than frustrating. Her relationship with Detective Sergeant Logan Hunter remains a slow, simmering delight. The forced proximity and reluctant teamwork add spark and humor, but never overpower the mystery itself. Their banter feels natural, and I appreciated that the romantic tension enhances the story rather than hijacking it.
The pacing is excellent. Clues are layered in thoughtfully, red herrings are placed with a light but confident hand, and the plot kept me guessing far longer than I expected. I had theories. I was wrong. I always enjoy being wrong when it feels fair, and this absolutely did. The final stretch tightens beautifully, delivering both tension and payoff without losing the cozy tone that defines the series.
The setting deserves special mention. The Wild Haggis Bookshop remains the beating heart of the story, and the surrounding town feels alive with personalities, routines, and quiet judgments. This is the kind of fictional place that feels real enough to miss once you leave it. Baldwin has a real talent for making community itself part of the mystery, where everyone knows everyone and that familiarity is both comforting and dangerous.
“This book is like settling in with tea and a blanket, only to realize the room has gone very quiet and someone nearby is hiding something.”
Poison at the Wild Haggis Bookshop is a strong second installment that deepens the characters, sharpens the mystery, and cements this series as one I will happily keep returning to. If you enjoy cozy mysteries with substance, atmosphere, and a bookshop you wish you could visit, this one is an easy recommendation.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 5 stars
#PoisonAtTheWildHaggisBookshop #JackieBaldwin #HighlandBookshopMurders #CozyMystery #BookReview #NetGalley #ARCReview #CozyCrime #MysteryBooks #StormPublishing
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Poison at the Wild Haggis Bookshop by Jackie Baldwin is the second book in the Highland Bookshop Murders series and I believe she has another winner in this book.
When Beth Cunningham's book subscription service is used as a weapon in a murder, she steps in to investigate be she and her bookshop’s reputation is on the line. Once again, Beth’s past is being used against her as a killer, and hopefully this will be the last time. As Beth investigates the past of the deceased, she finds interesting information her and decides that maybe her death was an act of revenge.
Detective Sergeant Logan Hunter faces some competition for Beth’s affections as she goes out on her very first date. Will he finally get his act together and ask her out or will she give up and move on? It is challenging for him because he needs to protect her during this time because she may be next on the killer’s list and he cannot really get involved with her until the investigation is resolved.
Beth faces challenges in this investigation, and I think readers will enjoy her investigation, the shop’s fun Easter event with chicks, the breadcrumbs left by the author, and the characters in the town. It is a fun read, and I cannot wait for the next installment of Beth’s life.
Thank you NetGalley and Storm Publishing for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
When Beth Cunningham's book subscription service is used as a weapon in a murder, she steps in to investigate be she and her bookshop’s reputation is on the line. Once again, Beth’s past is being used against her as a killer, and hopefully this will be the last time. As Beth investigates the past of the deceased, she finds interesting information her and decides that maybe her death was an act of revenge.
Detective Sergeant Logan Hunter faces some competition for Beth’s affections as she goes out on her very first date. Will he finally get his act together and ask her out or will she give up and move on? It is challenging for him because he needs to protect her during this time because she may be next on the killer’s list and he cannot really get involved with her until the investigation is resolved.
Beth faces challenges in this investigation, and I think readers will enjoy her investigation, the shop’s fun Easter event with chicks, the breadcrumbs left by the author, and the characters in the town. It is a fun read, and I cannot wait for the next installment of Beth’s life.
Thank you NetGalley and Storm Publishing for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
January 22, 2026
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC. These views are entirely my own.
This is the second book of the Highland Bookshop cosy mysteries, and it‘s definitely a series that promises to just keep getting better.
Everything seems to be settling down for Beth Cunningham after being accused of murder in the first book and her Wild Haggis Bookshop is flourishing.
Then once more Beth becomes the main suspect in the murder of one of the residents of Oban. As Beth and her loyal team of employees set out to ensure she is not charged with murder, Beth plunges headlong into trying to find the real murderer, often disregarding police advice, much to the chagrin of DS Logan Hunter. Beth’s actions did have me screaming ‘don’t be stupid Beth’ internally many times.
I love the way the friendships are developing between all the bookshop staff, particularly between Morna and Chloe and seeing a softer, less buttoned up side to Lachlan.
My one criticism was an error with a timeline at one point. There‘s a particular incident in the book that happens to Beth and in conversation with someone she says it happened ‘last night’ but 2 nights have actually passed since it happened. Although this is no way detracted from the story or my enjoyment of this book.
I look forward to reading more from Jackie Baldwin in this series.
This is the second book of the Highland Bookshop cosy mysteries, and it‘s definitely a series that promises to just keep getting better.
Everything seems to be settling down for Beth Cunningham after being accused of murder in the first book and her Wild Haggis Bookshop is flourishing.
Then once more Beth becomes the main suspect in the murder of one of the residents of Oban. As Beth and her loyal team of employees set out to ensure she is not charged with murder, Beth plunges headlong into trying to find the real murderer, often disregarding police advice, much to the chagrin of DS Logan Hunter. Beth’s actions did have me screaming ‘don’t be stupid Beth’ internally many times.
I love the way the friendships are developing between all the bookshop staff, particularly between Morna and Chloe and seeing a softer, less buttoned up side to Lachlan.
My one criticism was an error with a timeline at one point. There‘s a particular incident in the book that happens to Beth and in conversation with someone she says it happened ‘last night’ but 2 nights have actually passed since it happened. Although this is no way detracted from the story or my enjoyment of this book.
I look forward to reading more from Jackie Baldwin in this series.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 154 reviews