What do you think?
Rate this book
The Roman Holiday Rule
Not yet published
Expected 4 Aug 26Lexi Walker has finally committed to the Italian adventure that she and her late mother dreamed of for years—complete with a meticulously crafted itinerary, four sealed letters to open at Rome's most romantic sites, and her mother's final painting to present at the art festival Lexi is helping organize. She's ready for the perfect Roman getaway. What she doesn't expect is for her mother's artwork to start manifesting in real life, turning her carefully planned trip into something unpredictable.
Italian-American architect Mark Russo has sworn off American tourists after having his heart broken, and he's certainly not about to let another one distract him from winning the restoration bid that could reunite his estranged father with his grandfather. But when the captivating woman next to him on the flight to Rome proposes a photography challenge—whoever captures the heart of Italy in five days wins—Mark can't resist the bet and her charm.
As Lexi follows the letters from her mother around the city, she encounters Mark everywhere she goes. Their competitive banter turns to undeniable chemistry, but they both know the cardinal rule of holiday romances: You can't fall in love with someone who lives somewhere else and expect a happily-ever-after. Will a little magic—and a lot of mishaps—break the Roman Holiday Rule?
Andra Loy serves up a delightful blend of witty banter, swoon-worthy romance, and sparks of magic in a love story that's as enchanting as Rome itself.
Italian-American architect Mark Russo has sworn off American tourists after having his heart broken, and he's certainly not about to let another one distract him from winning the restoration bid that could reunite his estranged father with his grandfather. But when the captivating woman next to him on the flight to Rome proposes a photography challenge—whoever captures the heart of Italy in five days wins—Mark can't resist the bet and her charm.
As Lexi follows the letters from her mother around the city, she encounters Mark everywhere she goes. Their competitive banter turns to undeniable chemistry, but they both know the cardinal rule of holiday romances: You can't fall in love with someone who lives somewhere else and expect a happily-ever-after. Will a little magic—and a lot of mishaps—break the Roman Holiday Rule?
Andra Loy serves up a delightful blend of witty banter, swoon-worthy romance, and sparks of magic in a love story that's as enchanting as Rome itself.
320 pages, Paperback
Expected publication August 4, 2026
About the author
Andra Loy
1 book33 followersAndra Loy writes hopelessly romantic rom-coms where love bends reality, and her pre-published works have won numerous awards. Andra moved to Europe to teach English, where she hitchhiked, was sworn to secrecy about a secret mushroom hunting spot, and fell in love with the only American man in her small Czech town. Now, she lives in Michigan with her husband and three teens, teaching English, playing piano, and reacquainting herself with the American library system.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 76 reviews
Want to Read
May 30, 2026🍧🌸💕 𝓹𝓻𝓮𝓻𝓮𝓪𝓭
my bae audrey hepburn better be in this
my bae audrey hepburn better be in this
May 30, 2026
Review of advanced copy received from Netgalley
This book was truly okay, in every sense of the word.
Lexi was okay—I almost never wanted to smack her in the face, but I also didn’t really care if she lived or died for most of the book. Mark was okay—nice enough guy, I don’t have much to say about him. I didn’t think I would like either one of them, but by the end of the book, I can say that I genuinely did.
The romance was okay. I’ll admit they were endearing enough to eventually scratch my indifference, but it took a while. And by the time I started to care, I was majorly bored.
My first impression of Mark was that he was very much “not like other girls.” I begrudgingly warmed up to him, and to Lexi. At first, I hated that he called her Lexington. Because Lexi is such a nice name. And Lexington is so... not. It’s very cute that it’s what her mother used to call her, and I warmed up to the nickname over the course of the book. But I fear it didn’t make the name any less unfortunate. I will admit, the one and only moment he called her Lexi did hit as intended, so kudos there.
The side characters were probably the best part of the book, so it’s a shame they weren’t better developed. I really liked Nonno, Luca, and Mr. and Mrs. Gallo. They were a cliche older couple, but they served their purpose. I was even a fan of Katie, who we knew for like five seconds.
Remember when I said I almost never wanted to smack Lexi in the face?
The Katie misunderstanding was a dumb assumption to make. I understand that an obstacle for the romance was necessary, but it truly did not need to go on for as long as it did. Especially when they already had a worthy boulder between them that Lexi could have been harping on. But I wouldn’t say that warrants a smack in the face. Maybe a nice shove.
What really irritated me was the whole “we can’t be together because-“ shit at the end. Like girl, please get a grip. Not only was she severely overreacting, but also very much dragging it.
Oh, and the fact that she and Mark or his family “coincidentally” run into each other l i t e r a l l y everywhere she goes? Are Mark and Mark-adjacent people the only residents of Italy? And the envelope-picture coincidences? Please, there’s only so far I can suspend my disbelief.
Like its characters, this story was corny from start to finish. There were moments that made me smile, parts that made me roll my eyes, and (many) stretches of boredom. I don’t think I would reread it, but I’m glad I did. The epilogue was wonderful.
. ݁₊ ⊹ . ݁ ⟡ ݁ . ⊹ ₊ ݁.
thank you to the publisher for the arc♡
This book was truly okay, in every sense of the word.
Lexi was okay—I almost never wanted to smack her in the face, but I also didn’t really care if she lived or died for most of the book. Mark was okay—nice enough guy, I don’t have much to say about him. I didn’t think I would like either one of them, but by the end of the book, I can say that I genuinely did.
The romance was okay. I’ll admit they were endearing enough to eventually scratch my indifference, but it took a while. And by the time I started to care, I was majorly bored.
My first impression of Mark was that he was very much “not like other girls.” I begrudgingly warmed up to him, and to Lexi. At first, I hated that he called her Lexington. Because Lexi is such a nice name. And Lexington is so... not. It’s very cute that it’s what her mother used to call her, and I warmed up to the nickname over the course of the book. But I fear it didn’t make the name any less unfortunate. I will admit, the one and only moment he called her Lexi did hit as intended, so kudos there.
The side characters were probably the best part of the book, so it’s a shame they weren’t better developed. I really liked Nonno, Luca, and Mr. and Mrs. Gallo. They were a cliche older couple, but they served their purpose. I was even a fan of Katie, who we knew for like five seconds.
Remember when I said I almost never wanted to smack Lexi in the face?
The Katie misunderstanding was a dumb assumption to make. I understand that an obstacle for the romance was necessary, but it truly did not need to go on for as long as it did. Especially when they already had a worthy boulder between them that Lexi could have been harping on. But I wouldn’t say that warrants a smack in the face. Maybe a nice shove.
What really irritated me was the whole “we can’t be together because-“ shit at the end. Like girl, please get a grip. Not only was she severely overreacting, but also very much dragging it.
Oh, and the fact that she and Mark or his family “coincidentally” run into each other l i t e r a l l y everywhere she goes? Are Mark and Mark-adjacent people the only residents of Italy? And the envelope-picture coincidences? Please, there’s only so far I can suspend my disbelief.
Like its characters, this story was corny from start to finish. There were moments that made me smile, parts that made me roll my eyes, and (many) stretches of boredom. I don’t think I would reread it, but I’m glad I did. The epilogue was wonderful.
. ݁₊ ⊹ . ݁ ⟡ ݁ . ⊹ ₊ ݁.
thank you to the publisher for the arc♡
June 23, 2026
I absolutely loved the lush Italian setting! Sights like the Trevi Fountain really came to life in the pages of the story and it was fun to visit them on page. I also loved all the Roman Holiday references, like riding about Rome on a Vespa. The main character loved the movie and talked about it a lot which I enjoyed as well.
However, I didn’t love the romance. Mark was very antagonistic toward Lexi simply because she was a tourist, which seemed like a very minor thing for him to basically become unhinged toward her. I did like seeing their relationship evolve over the course of the story and how Mark became more comfortable with her as the book progressed.
This is a completely clean read and overall a fun debut. The cover is just adorable as well. I will keep an eye out for this author’s next book.
Thank you to the publisher, Haven, for providing this book for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
However, I didn’t love the romance. Mark was very antagonistic toward Lexi simply because she was a tourist, which seemed like a very minor thing for him to basically become unhinged toward her. I did like seeing their relationship evolve over the course of the story and how Mark became more comfortable with her as the book progressed.
This is a completely clean read and overall a fun debut. The cover is just adorable as well. I will keep an eye out for this author’s next book.
Thank you to the publisher, Haven, for providing this book for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
June 1, 2026
The Roman Holiday Rule by Andra Loy
Upcoming Release | Pub Date: August 4, 2026
Published by Haven
I received a complimentary copy and was under no obligation to leave a positive review.
The Roman Holiday Rule made me want to book a flight to Rome.
One of the strongest aspects of this book was the immersive setting. Andra Loy truly painted Rome beautifully. The food, culture, architecture, and atmosphere made the city feel vibrant and alive, and I loved getting swept into the experience alongside the characters.
Mark’s family was a standout part of the story for me. Their presence added warmth, depth, and emotional weight beyond the romance, and I appreciated how important those relationships were throughout the book.
The witty banter, chemistry, and touches of magic added charm to the story, and the Roman backdrop gave everything a wonderfully cinematic feel.
Lexi was a more complicated character for me. While I appreciated her emotional journey and the connection to her mother’s dream, I personally found some of her choices and behavior frustrating at times, which made it harder for me to fully connect with her.
I also enjoyed seeing the book club discussion questions included at the end.
Upcoming Release | Pub Date: August 4, 2026
Published by Haven
I received a complimentary copy and was under no obligation to leave a positive review.
The Roman Holiday Rule made me want to book a flight to Rome.
One of the strongest aspects of this book was the immersive setting. Andra Loy truly painted Rome beautifully. The food, culture, architecture, and atmosphere made the city feel vibrant and alive, and I loved getting swept into the experience alongside the characters.
Mark’s family was a standout part of the story for me. Their presence added warmth, depth, and emotional weight beyond the romance, and I appreciated how important those relationships were throughout the book.
The witty banter, chemistry, and touches of magic added charm to the story, and the Roman backdrop gave everything a wonderfully cinematic feel.
Lexi was a more complicated character for me. While I appreciated her emotional journey and the connection to her mother’s dream, I personally found some of her choices and behavior frustrating at times, which made it harder for me to fully connect with her.
I also enjoyed seeing the book club discussion questions included at the end.
Read
June 1, 2026Thank you NetGalley and the publisher for the arc☆
June 19, 2026
I received an advance review copy of this book. I was under no obligation to leave a positive review, and all opinions expressed are my own.
This was such a delightful read! Here are the things that stood out to me:
1 The strong sense of place. I felt like I truly got to know Rome—the food, the neighborhoods, the people—all through the lens of one wonderfully lovable family. The setting became a character of its own.
2 The touch of magical realism. I loved how Lexi processed the grief of losing her mom. While this isn't really a book about grief, it beautifully captures the feeling of remaining close to someone you've lost, especially while visiting a city that meant so much to them. That thread added so much heart to the story.
3 The memorable side characters. They brought so much humor and warmth, especially with all the playful pranks woven throughout the book. Those moments weren't just entertaining—they also introduced readers to Rome's culture and traditions in such a fun way.
4 It's completely clean and closed-door. I always appreciate finding a well-written romance that I can confidently recommend to my teen daughter. It's proof that a story doesn't need explicit content to be heartfelt, funny, and deeply romantic.
5 It's a true rom-com with a satisfying happy ending. Yes, there's some angst along the way, but it's balanced with hope, laughter, and all the things I love about the genre. One of my favorite author notes is Katherine Center's preface to The Shippers, where she talks about why she loves romantic comedies. Rom-coms are magical because they remind us that love is worth rooting for and that hope is never a bad thing. This book absolutely captured that same magic for me.
If you're looking for a heartfelt, funny, clean romance that will transport you to Rome while leaving you smiling, this one is well worth picking up.
This was such a delightful read! Here are the things that stood out to me:
1 The strong sense of place. I felt like I truly got to know Rome—the food, the neighborhoods, the people—all through the lens of one wonderfully lovable family. The setting became a character of its own.
2 The touch of magical realism. I loved how Lexi processed the grief of losing her mom. While this isn't really a book about grief, it beautifully captures the feeling of remaining close to someone you've lost, especially while visiting a city that meant so much to them. That thread added so much heart to the story.
3 The memorable side characters. They brought so much humor and warmth, especially with all the playful pranks woven throughout the book. Those moments weren't just entertaining—they also introduced readers to Rome's culture and traditions in such a fun way.
4 It's completely clean and closed-door. I always appreciate finding a well-written romance that I can confidently recommend to my teen daughter. It's proof that a story doesn't need explicit content to be heartfelt, funny, and deeply romantic.
5 It's a true rom-com with a satisfying happy ending. Yes, there's some angst along the way, but it's balanced with hope, laughter, and all the things I love about the genre. One of my favorite author notes is Katherine Center's preface to The Shippers, where she talks about why she loves romantic comedies. Rom-coms are magical because they remind us that love is worth rooting for and that hope is never a bad thing. This book absolutely captured that same magic for me.
If you're looking for a heartfelt, funny, clean romance that will transport you to Rome while leaving you smiling, this one is well worth picking up.
June 14, 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
- Vacation Romcom with magical realism
- Closed door, just kissing
- Dual POV
- Serendipitous happenings
- Punny jokes and misquoted movie quotes
- Picturesque setting and details that make the settings vivid
- Pranks and mishaps
✨ a few of my favorite things:
- The book is just so whimsical and fun
- their easy banter and their similar sense of humor
- The meetcute
- The book
- The bet
- The big Italian family
- All of their adventures and run ins
- The sweet letters
- The ending 🥹
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Ahhh I can’t even with this book. If you need a wholesome good time, read this book immediately. I immensely enjoyed myself and could not put the book down.
All of the characters felt like real people. They didn’t feel like copy and paste. They had layers and struggled but found joy. They were just so real. The setting sounds absolutely dreamy and stunning, making me even more obsessed with Italy. I adored the family so much and all the side characters were great honestly.
The MCs both struggled and grew in the book. Mark struggled greatly with hurt from past relationships and overcoming his reluctance to open up. Lexi was fighting her own grief and desperately trying to keep a tight hold on controlling her life. They softened each other and lit each other up. The MCs brought the best out in one another and made amends when they messed up. Their dorky jokes and inside jokes made me smile so big.
It was seriously the sweetest story and I had THE BEST time.
This is a closed door romcom with no cursing and just kissing.
**Thank you so much to Andra for letting me read this gifted ARC via NetGalley. No positive review was required. All thoughts are my own.**
Song :
Until I found you by Stephen Sanchez
Anyone by Justine Bieber
Rest by Dean Lewis & Sasha Alex Sloane
Dreams by The Cranberries
God Knew by Michal Leah
- Vacation Romcom with magical realism
- Closed door, just kissing
- Dual POV
- Serendipitous happenings
- Punny jokes and misquoted movie quotes
- Picturesque setting and details that make the settings vivid
- Pranks and mishaps
✨ a few of my favorite things:
- The book is just so whimsical and fun
- their easy banter and their similar sense of humor
- The meetcute
- The book
- The bet
- The big Italian family
- All of their adventures and run ins
- The sweet letters
- The ending 🥹
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Ahhh I can’t even with this book. If you need a wholesome good time, read this book immediately. I immensely enjoyed myself and could not put the book down.
All of the characters felt like real people. They didn’t feel like copy and paste. They had layers and struggled but found joy. They were just so real. The setting sounds absolutely dreamy and stunning, making me even more obsessed with Italy. I adored the family so much and all the side characters were great honestly.
The MCs both struggled and grew in the book. Mark struggled greatly with hurt from past relationships and overcoming his reluctance to open up. Lexi was fighting her own grief and desperately trying to keep a tight hold on controlling her life. They softened each other and lit each other up. The MCs brought the best out in one another and made amends when they messed up. Their dorky jokes and inside jokes made me smile so big.
It was seriously the sweetest story and I had THE BEST time.
This is a closed door romcom with no cursing and just kissing.
**Thank you so much to Andra for letting me read this gifted ARC via NetGalley. No positive review was required. All thoughts are my own.**
Song :
Until I found you by Stephen Sanchez
Anyone by Justine Bieber
Rest by Dean Lewis & Sasha Alex Sloane
Dreams by The Cranberries
God Knew by Michal Leah
May 31, 2026
This book will stay with me for a long time - it was so beautifully written and it made me feel everything.
Lexi is the most wonderful lead character, from the opening in the airport to the way she carries herself through the emotional journey she faces in Italy, to her final decision, she’s so inspiring and brave, I loved every minute of her journey and though the decisions she made at times were heart wrenching, I completely agreed with her and felt so much for her when she returned from Italy.
For someone who’s always dreamed of a close loving family, seeing this on the pages was bittersweet, but it made me love Mark’s family so much more. Mark’s family is introduced in the most organic and simply stunning way, especially Nonno, what a character!
Mark is the most perfect love interest, he’s a little jaded after having his heart broken by another tourist American so he’s reluctant to jump into anything with Lexington (swoon), but fate has another plan, the pair are continuously in each others orbit, when Lexi thinks she’s experiencing things alone (the Spanish Steps), Mark is watching from a window.. it’s just so perfect.
I loved each side character, Julie is the perfect BFF for our lead, slightly overstepping when the meets Mark but knowing it comes from a place of love, and then to Mark’s family, from Luca in his restaurant to Marielle and her instant friendship with Lexi, so Kathryn, Katie, and her wonderful scheming ways. I really hope there’s more to come from the Russo family, as I’d drop everything to read more about this beautiful family
Lexi is the most wonderful lead character, from the opening in the airport to the way she carries herself through the emotional journey she faces in Italy, to her final decision, she’s so inspiring and brave, I loved every minute of her journey and though the decisions she made at times were heart wrenching, I completely agreed with her and felt so much for her when she returned from Italy.
For someone who’s always dreamed of a close loving family, seeing this on the pages was bittersweet, but it made me love Mark’s family so much more. Mark’s family is introduced in the most organic and simply stunning way, especially Nonno, what a character!
Mark is the most perfect love interest, he’s a little jaded after having his heart broken by another tourist American so he’s reluctant to jump into anything with Lexington (swoon), but fate has another plan, the pair are continuously in each others orbit, when Lexi thinks she’s experiencing things alone (the Spanish Steps), Mark is watching from a window.. it’s just so perfect.
I loved each side character, Julie is the perfect BFF for our lead, slightly overstepping when the meets Mark but knowing it comes from a place of love, and then to Mark’s family, from Luca in his restaurant to Marielle and her instant friendship with Lexi, so Kathryn, Katie, and her wonderful scheming ways. I really hope there’s more to come from the Russo family, as I’d drop everything to read more about this beautiful family
June 1, 2026
2★
Thank you to NetGalley for this Arc !!
I read this book because of the description: summer travel, Italy, romcom, the banter.. but honestly I struggled to get to the end….
Sadly I didn’t really get attached to the characters through the books…
I felt like the author tried to deliver way to much information too quickly at the start to directly set it up, and then it was slow and then rushed again…kind set me off during the whole book…
Netherless, I loved the cute and funny relation between Lexi and Mark and their chemistry. It’s still was a cute and easy read.
Thank you to NetGalley for this Arc !!
I read this book because of the description: summer travel, Italy, romcom, the banter.. but honestly I struggled to get to the end….
Sadly I didn’t really get attached to the characters through the books…
I felt like the author tried to deliver way to much information too quickly at the start to directly set it up, and then it was slow and then rushed again…kind set me off during the whole book…
Netherless, I loved the cute and funny relation between Lexi and Mark and their chemistry. It’s still was a cute and easy read.
June 26, 2026
The Roman Holiday Rule… OH. MY. GOSH. I don’t have enough good things to say about this book! Lexi and Mark are absolutely perfect, and somehow even more perfect for each other. The found family, the swoony romance, and all the little moments had me completely hooked. The lira necklace in the fountain, the movie quotes, the palazzo job, and then the lira necklace at the END?! 😭 If you know, you know. Every piece of this story came together so beautifully. I absolutely loved this book and couldn’t put it down.
Thank you to Haven and Andra Loy for this ARC! ❤️📚
Thank you to Haven and Andra Loy for this ARC! ❤️📚
May 31, 2026
4 stars⭐️ I was looking for a cute rom-com to kick off my summer reading, and this one definitely delivered! The story follows Lexi as she embarks on a new adventure while navigating themes of grief, healing, and unexpected connection. One of my favorite aspects of the book was the banter and chemistry between Lexi and Mark. Their competitive dynamic and pranks they played on each other added to the story and made it feel fun. Overall this was a entertaining romance with lovable characters and plenty of laughs to balance out the lighter moments. There was also a Vespa mentioned I was secretly hoping it would be included🤭
I received an advanced review copy of this book from Netgalley. All opinions are my own.
I received an advanced review copy of this book from Netgalley. All opinions are my own.
June 1, 2026
I received an advanced copy from NetGalley of this book.
This spice free romance is definitely a cute story following Lexi and Mark through the historic sites of Rome. I enjoyed reading this book, however there is some predictability in the novel.
The novel reminds me of a Sarah Adams book with a touch of PS I Love You. I think it was very sweet and I loved watching Mark’s character soften up throughout the book.
Tropes include: found family, grumpy sunshine, and a touch of miscommunication.
This spice free romance is definitely a cute story following Lexi and Mark through the historic sites of Rome. I enjoyed reading this book, however there is some predictability in the novel.
The novel reminds me of a Sarah Adams book with a touch of PS I Love You. I think it was very sweet and I loved watching Mark’s character soften up throughout the book.
Tropes include: found family, grumpy sunshine, and a touch of miscommunication.
June 19, 2026
I really enjoyed reading the Roman Holiday Rule. It made me want to book a flight to Rome just to experience being in the city and maybe finding love myself. I loved all of the FMC’s and MMC’s jokes and puns and Star Wars references. I couldn’t put it down. I did give it a 4.5 star rating mostly because it had no spice. I thought it was just a really slow burn, but there is 1 almost kiss and 2 actual kissing scenes. But overall, it’s a really cute, feel good book.
May 28, 2026
The Roman Holiday Rule by Andra Loy is a dual POV, fast-paced novel with a very touching tale.
Lexi flies to Rome to solve the mystery of her parents’ romance with the help of her late mother’s letters. She encounters mystical “coincidences” and wishes at Trevi Fountain that seem to guide her as if led by her mom. A chance meeting with Mark at the airport opens a fun, friendly rivalry between the two, and their witty banter is a major highlight.
I loved the humor shared by Lexi and Mark, Mark's lovely family and Lexi's best friend Julie. This is the right balance of emotional depth, playful romance and Roman charm!
Lexi flies to Rome to solve the mystery of her parents’ romance with the help of her late mother’s letters. She encounters mystical “coincidences” and wishes at Trevi Fountain that seem to guide her as if led by her mom. A chance meeting with Mark at the airport opens a fun, friendly rivalry between the two, and their witty banter is a major highlight.
I loved the humor shared by Lexi and Mark, Mark's lovely family and Lexi's best friend Julie. This is the right balance of emotional depth, playful romance and Roman charm!
May 29, 2026
Only One Vespa!! I adored this story of two strangers meeting at the Boston airport and then continuing to magically run into each other in Rome. The story kept me entertained and on my toes. It was a sweet/clean romance and I cannot wait to read more from this author in the future. Recommend if you enjoy clean/sweet romance, meet-cute, found family. Trigger - the main character is grieving the recent loss of her mother.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Haven via NetGalley. All opinions expressed are my own.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Haven via NetGalley. All opinions expressed are my own.
May 27, 2026
Such a cute romantic comedy— cute puns & banter, gorgeous setting details in Rome, and the concept of letting go of the past while also embracing its purpose is so well done! The little bits of magic and fate are so fun and interned in cute ways that remind of life’s whispers to keep us focusing on what’s really important. It’s a no spice, joy—filled read, with cute Italian family members intervening along Lexi’s Rome trip to say goodbye to her beloved mom.
May 28, 2026
Cute, easy read about a fun vacation friendship that turns into a relationship.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
I loved the Rome setting, the mention of so many iconic landmarks and places there and the Italian verbiage. Unfortunately this got very boring quickly though. The insta love between the main characters even by the first flight scene just was too much for me. I actually really didn't get the chemistry between them, it felt a bit forced. Them pretending to not know each other, the back and forth of "do we like each other or don't we" just got old, especially for people of their age and what they have accomplished. To add in all the coincidences throughout of her mom and how she stumbled upon all these people and places to coincide with the letters... Just a bit too much for me.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
To preface, I would like to think Andra Loy and Haven for allowing ARC readers to come in and review The Roman Holiday Rule, and NetGalley for having an amazing platform for these books. Thank you!
The Roman Holiday Rule is a dual POV contemporary romance that follows the perspectives of Lexi Walker and Mark Russo as they discover the true heart of Italy. Through seemingly random happenstances, these two begin to heal from their previous heartbreaks as they share more than just a row on an airplane. Fate becomes quite a stubborn thing as it begins to alter their versions of the future as they move on from their pasts, culminating in a swoon worthy picture-perfect story.
One of the genres of this book, at least on Goodreads, was Christian fiction. I only recall maybe one or two moments in the book that lightly suggest any sort of spiritual belief so I would not necessarily consider this specifically Christian. That being said, the heavier magical realism elements may be hinting at a more deeper fate like message which could be attributed to believing in a greater power but that is a loose relation.
That being said, do not expect a story with specific mentions of Jesus or anything like that. It is a clean romance story however so that could be what that tag means as well? I am not too sure.
As the title suggests, the majority of the book takes place within the picturesque scenery of Rome, Italy. Where modern conveniences collide with the cobblestones and ancient remains of this iconic country. One of my favorite aspects of this book was the immersion I felt while following the characters on their daily adventures in Italy. Everything from the food, tourist attractions, to the very people, dragged me into this new culture and way of life. Traveling to Italy has always been on my bucket list so I found myself excited for each new day Lexi was wandering the streets.
The use of different artistic mediums such as photography, painting, cooking and architecture further added to the splendor of the scenery as well.
The overarching theme of family added yet another layer of enjoyment for me. The juxtaposition between Lexi’s deep rooted struggle with loneliness and the tight knit nature of Mark’s family, was beautiful. The quick acceptance of Lexi showed the beauty of found family.
One small disappointment for me was Mark’s subplot of reconciling part of his family that had not spoken in years. While I am glad this seemingly gets solved off page by the end, I was hoping to get to experience that reunion first hand. These plots of coming back together regardless of how much time goes by, are some of my favorites.
I found both main characters quite enjoyable once they began losing some of those misconceptions they were holding onto. In the beginning, I was struggling a bit with the cringey dialogue between Lexi and Mark. I thought the movie puns were coming off a bit too strong and forced since they had literally just met. Lexi started off quite childish in my opinion so it took longer for me to connect with her. Both characters did have some pretty great development and growth throughout the story which made them feel like such genuine people, which is always what I desire in a great story.
As far as the romance, there are some assumptions that both Lexi and Mark make that could have destroyed their relationship from the beginning. There is one particular misunderstanding Lexi has about Mark when they first meet that carries too far through the book in my opinion. There was absolutely no reason for her to have held on to that belief, other than a plot device to stave off the romance for a while. I am not a big fan of misunderstandings being used this way, which is the main reason for the four-star rating.
That being said, once the truth of each situation came out, both Lexi and Mark admitted their initial closed mindedness and worked at opening their hearts. That epilogue was a great addition and ending to the story!
All in all, if you enjoy a good scenic contemporary romance story with elements of magical realism, I would highly recommend marking your calendars for this release on August 4th!
Once again thank you to Andra Loy, Haven and NetGalley for the ARC read 🙂
The Roman Holiday Rule is a dual POV contemporary romance that follows the perspectives of Lexi Walker and Mark Russo as they discover the true heart of Italy. Through seemingly random happenstances, these two begin to heal from their previous heartbreaks as they share more than just a row on an airplane. Fate becomes quite a stubborn thing as it begins to alter their versions of the future as they move on from their pasts, culminating in a swoon worthy picture-perfect story.
One of the genres of this book, at least on Goodreads, was Christian fiction. I only recall maybe one or two moments in the book that lightly suggest any sort of spiritual belief so I would not necessarily consider this specifically Christian. That being said, the heavier magical realism elements may be hinting at a more deeper fate like message which could be attributed to believing in a greater power but that is a loose relation.
That being said, do not expect a story with specific mentions of Jesus or anything like that. It is a clean romance story however so that could be what that tag means as well? I am not too sure.
As the title suggests, the majority of the book takes place within the picturesque scenery of Rome, Italy. Where modern conveniences collide with the cobblestones and ancient remains of this iconic country. One of my favorite aspects of this book was the immersion I felt while following the characters on their daily adventures in Italy. Everything from the food, tourist attractions, to the very people, dragged me into this new culture and way of life. Traveling to Italy has always been on my bucket list so I found myself excited for each new day Lexi was wandering the streets.
The use of different artistic mediums such as photography, painting, cooking and architecture further added to the splendor of the scenery as well.
The overarching theme of family added yet another layer of enjoyment for me. The juxtaposition between Lexi’s deep rooted struggle with loneliness and the tight knit nature of Mark’s family, was beautiful. The quick acceptance of Lexi showed the beauty of found family.
One small disappointment for me was Mark’s subplot of reconciling part of his family that had not spoken in years. While I am glad this seemingly gets solved off page by the end, I was hoping to get to experience that reunion first hand. These plots of coming back together regardless of how much time goes by, are some of my favorites.
I found both main characters quite enjoyable once they began losing some of those misconceptions they were holding onto. In the beginning, I was struggling a bit with the cringey dialogue between Lexi and Mark. I thought the movie puns were coming off a bit too strong and forced since they had literally just met. Lexi started off quite childish in my opinion so it took longer for me to connect with her. Both characters did have some pretty great development and growth throughout the story which made them feel like such genuine people, which is always what I desire in a great story.
As far as the romance, there are some assumptions that both Lexi and Mark make that could have destroyed their relationship from the beginning. There is one particular misunderstanding Lexi has about Mark when they first meet that carries too far through the book in my opinion. There was absolutely no reason for her to have held on to that belief, other than a plot device to stave off the romance for a while. I am not a big fan of misunderstandings being used this way, which is the main reason for the four-star rating.
That being said, once the truth of each situation came out, both Lexi and Mark admitted their initial closed mindedness and worked at opening their hearts. That epilogue was a great addition and ending to the story!
All in all, if you enjoy a good scenic contemporary romance story with elements of magical realism, I would highly recommend marking your calendars for this release on August 4th!
Once again thank you to Andra Loy, Haven and NetGalley for the ARC read 🙂
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Well.... the beginning was definitely better than ending.
Both of them were so pretentious about art, italy, tourism and vacations. They were fine for the most part.
Reactions out of context:
- Why are you judging her for only wanting to have beach vacations??? What people like to do on vacation is literally none of your business! Also what is wrong with just wanting to relax on a beach and party in the night?
- so you favorite vacations are sightseeing famous architecture but people who go to rome and to go sightseeing famous architecture and landmarks are dumb shallow tourist who don't appreciate rome enough? A bit of a hypocrite, huh?
- this bet is the dumbest thing ive ever heard. Why the fuck do you care so much how a stranger spends her vacation in rome. Its her money and her time. Thats awfully presumptuous of you.
- these coincidence are getting put of hand.
- no way In hell is you're Italian so good after a year. Especially in a regional dialect. Even if you did your research and have a Italy loving mother, you still are a pretty clueless tourist.
- babe he is helping fill out the forms because you were standing around staring into space not because he assumed you don't know any Italian. And then when he gave you the first hint, because again you weren't doing anything at all, you still didn't do anything and just stared at him like you didn't know what the fuck he was talking about. At this point of course he is going to assume you don't know any Italian, you're not doing anything or saying anything. By god help me jesus.
- why did the assumption about him being engaged take so long to resolve? You couldn't have subtlety hinted at it at any point.of your interactions?? A brief mention? Because you are awfully flirty with a suppose engaged man? Also no engaged man would get arrest for someone else like that for this fucking coin after knowing them for 4 days max. 😒
Spoilers:
- babe, lexi my girl this is the hill you want to die on? A pavilion that is going to be destroyed anyway? You wanted him to give up a contractor job he has working hard towards that also mind you employs basically his whole ass family and is their income and livelihood?? Because you didn't want him to be the one to destroy it. Are you fucking kidding me? Talk about selfish holy shit. She is acting like he is maliciously deciding to destroy this already unsafe and decaying pavilion to build a mall or some shit instead of it. He was going to restore the historic building attached to it and save the property from being turned into yet another tourist trap hotel. But the shit pavilion is more important to you?
- he makes her the "heart of rome" which swoon. Predictable but swoon. And you still want to die on your hill??? You literally got the opportunity to work in rome (a dream come true) that should have been the last hurdle you have to face as a couple, but nooooooo you care about how he is going to destroy this shitty pavilion (even though it is going to be destroy no matter what, it's unsafe and everyone working constructive and permit safety says that's the only thing to be done)
-also you tell him he stuck in the past and doesn't look into his future and you do that even worse? The pavilion is your mother's past and you want that to destroy your chance of a fairy tale love story?? Your mother would have been delighted for you find the love of your life on your trip to rome like she did with her husband!! She is rolling in her grave with refusal to look further than your own ego.
- Mark wtf are you doing? Why the fuck didn't you just take the job omg. Now there is a shitty hotel there holy shit
- omg mark she is literally not that special holy shit
Both of them were so pretentious about art, italy, tourism and vacations. They were fine for the most part.
Reactions out of context:
- Why are you judging her for only wanting to have beach vacations??? What people like to do on vacation is literally none of your business! Also what is wrong with just wanting to relax on a beach and party in the night?
- so you favorite vacations are sightseeing famous architecture but people who go to rome and to go sightseeing famous architecture and landmarks are dumb shallow tourist who don't appreciate rome enough? A bit of a hypocrite, huh?
- this bet is the dumbest thing ive ever heard. Why the fuck do you care so much how a stranger spends her vacation in rome. Its her money and her time. Thats awfully presumptuous of you.
- these coincidence are getting put of hand.
- no way In hell is you're Italian so good after a year. Especially in a regional dialect. Even if you did your research and have a Italy loving mother, you still are a pretty clueless tourist.
- babe he is helping fill out the forms because you were standing around staring into space not because he assumed you don't know any Italian. And then when he gave you the first hint, because again you weren't doing anything at all, you still didn't do anything and just stared at him like you didn't know what the fuck he was talking about. At this point of course he is going to assume you don't know any Italian, you're not doing anything or saying anything. By god help me jesus.
- why did the assumption about him being engaged take so long to resolve? You couldn't have subtlety hinted at it at any point.of your interactions?? A brief mention? Because you are awfully flirty with a suppose engaged man? Also no engaged man would get arrest for someone else like that for this fucking coin after knowing them for 4 days max. 😒
Spoilers:
- babe, lexi my girl this is the hill you want to die on? A pavilion that is going to be destroyed anyway? You wanted him to give up a contractor job he has working hard towards that also mind you employs basically his whole ass family and is their income and livelihood?? Because you didn't want him to be the one to destroy it. Are you fucking kidding me? Talk about selfish holy shit. She is acting like he is maliciously deciding to destroy this already unsafe and decaying pavilion to build a mall or some shit instead of it. He was going to restore the historic building attached to it and save the property from being turned into yet another tourist trap hotel. But the shit pavilion is more important to you?
- he makes her the "heart of rome" which swoon. Predictable but swoon. And you still want to die on your hill??? You literally got the opportunity to work in rome (a dream come true) that should have been the last hurdle you have to face as a couple, but nooooooo you care about how he is going to destroy this shitty pavilion (even though it is going to be destroy no matter what, it's unsafe and everyone working constructive and permit safety says that's the only thing to be done)
-also you tell him he stuck in the past and doesn't look into his future and you do that even worse? The pavilion is your mother's past and you want that to destroy your chance of a fairy tale love story?? Your mother would have been delighted for you find the love of your life on your trip to rome like she did with her husband!! She is rolling in her grave with refusal to look further than your own ego.
- Mark wtf are you doing? Why the fuck didn't you just take the job omg. Now there is a shitty hotel there holy shit
- omg mark she is literally not that special holy shit
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
I absolutely loved this book, although I might have not been sold right from the get go. I initially took issue with Mark… I know we’re meant to assume that he has some issues and some deep hurt in his past that we’d eventually find out about (we do)… but his anti-tourist stance seemed to be a bit much. Living close to a major city myself, I find tourists just as annoying as the next local, but someone who is obviously originally American having lived in Italy for 6 years… seems like a bit of a reach for him to be acting like a curmudgeonly local? As we, along with Lexi, peel back his layers and get to know Rome, Andra Loy skillfully navigates us into the territory of reflecting on the best strategy while on vacation in Rome, or any other major tourist destination. Lexi’s initial plans to see as much of Rome as she can, while understandable given the history with her mother, leaves no time to appreciate the actual heart of the city. And although most of us won’t necessarily have a hunky ex-pat touring us around our vacation destination, I very much enjoyed living vicariously through Lexi.
Lexi and Mark’s relationship is a whirlwind in every sense of the word, definitely including literal, as Lexi’s trip to Rome takes place over ten days. Normally, this sense of insta-love would annoy me, but somehow here it works. Two people who are slightly lost and damaged, initially at odds with each other, yet gradually peeling back each other’s layers and realizing that they might be what each other needs. I had some feelings around the third act conflict, and definitely had some frustration at some of the lines drawn there, but ultimately I do understand the emotions behind what happened there.
Rome as a setting was perfect, and having read this during a bit of a heat wave where I live made me feel like I was experiencing the same hot Roman summer they were. Overall, this whole book gave great summer vacation vibes, and one of the better summer reads that I’ve read ARCs for this year so far. Definitely a great vacation read, or something you would want to throw in your beach bag. An absolutely excellent debut novel. I can’t wait for Andra Loy’s next book!
Read if you love:
Enemies to lovers
Italy
Large Italian families
Found family
The slightest hint of magical realism
Thank you to Haven and NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Lexi and Mark’s relationship is a whirlwind in every sense of the word, definitely including literal, as Lexi’s trip to Rome takes place over ten days. Normally, this sense of insta-love would annoy me, but somehow here it works. Two people who are slightly lost and damaged, initially at odds with each other, yet gradually peeling back each other’s layers and realizing that they might be what each other needs. I had some feelings around the third act conflict, and definitely had some frustration at some of the lines drawn there, but ultimately I do understand the emotions behind what happened there.
Rome as a setting was perfect, and having read this during a bit of a heat wave where I live made me feel like I was experiencing the same hot Roman summer they were. Overall, this whole book gave great summer vacation vibes, and one of the better summer reads that I’ve read ARCs for this year so far. Definitely a great vacation read, or something you would want to throw in your beach bag. An absolutely excellent debut novel. I can’t wait for Andra Loy’s next book!
Read if you love:
Enemies to lovers
Italy
Large Italian families
Found family
The slightest hint of magical realism
Thank you to Haven and NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
The kind of book that can make you all warm inside in the middle of winter.
If you need a simple story with some charming, magical twists and nice chemistry between the main characters, I'd recommend this. It's easy to read, has the ability to transport you to its setting, and doesn't overcomplicate anything. I needed a light read and this was exactly that. A perfect beach read or something to warm your heart during the more freezing months.
I like the main couple - their dynamic is fun to follow, the puns are adorably cringy, and their feelings are well-written. You can actually believe they fell deeply for each other during this short time, and that they fit together. I especially loved chapter 34, there was just something so charming in the way they behaved.
The miscommunication is there, but it's believable. I'd have assumed the same thing with the way it was told. Even when she tried to clear things up subtly, it still sounded like the assumption made sense.
The family parts and the side plots connected to them made everything that much brighter and more compelling. I loved the little details falling together (which I won't describe, because spoilers).
Also, I'm not sure if I've ever read magical realism done so well. It was mesmerizing without being overblown. Just the right amount to make it fascinating and easy to buy.
I could be picky and deliberately look for things which weren't perfect just to have something bad to say, but I have no desire to do that. If nothing comes up naturally, no need to force it. It made me feel good and forget about the world, which is exactly what I've been looking for. No notes.
It's a great debut and I think this author has a lot of potential. I can't wait to see what's next if this is the level she's starting from. I highly recommend anyone who needs a break and likes warm, light, punny writing.
Thank you to NetGalley, the publisher, and the author for letting me read the ARC!
If you need a simple story with some charming, magical twists and nice chemistry between the main characters, I'd recommend this. It's easy to read, has the ability to transport you to its setting, and doesn't overcomplicate anything. I needed a light read and this was exactly that. A perfect beach read or something to warm your heart during the more freezing months.
I like the main couple - their dynamic is fun to follow, the puns are adorably cringy, and their feelings are well-written. You can actually believe they fell deeply for each other during this short time, and that they fit together. I especially loved chapter 34, there was just something so charming in the way they behaved.
The miscommunication is there, but it's believable. I'd have assumed the same thing with the way it was told. Even when she tried to clear things up subtly, it still sounded like the assumption made sense.
The family parts and the side plots connected to them made everything that much brighter and more compelling. I loved the little details falling together (which I won't describe, because spoilers).
Also, I'm not sure if I've ever read magical realism done so well. It was mesmerizing without being overblown. Just the right amount to make it fascinating and easy to buy.
I could be picky and deliberately look for things which weren't perfect just to have something bad to say, but I have no desire to do that. If nothing comes up naturally, no need to force it. It made me feel good and forget about the world, which is exactly what I've been looking for. No notes.
It's a great debut and I think this author has a lot of potential. I can't wait to see what's next if this is the level she's starting from. I highly recommend anyone who needs a break and likes warm, light, punny writing.
Thank you to NetGalley, the publisher, and the author for letting me read the ARC!
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
4.5/5 Stars (because Goodreads won't let me do the half!)
The Roman Holiday Rule is by debut author Andra Loy and I was able to read it as an ARC through Netgalley and Haven Fiction.
I wasn't sure if this book was for me when I started because I found out after requesting it that it was "no spice". Pretty much everything I read has some elevated level of spice and I don't always get the warm fuzzy feeling in my chest when there isn't a lot of romantic/sexual tension. Well - Andra Loy proved me very wrong, y'all.
The story follows Lexi Walker, an event planner, on her dream trip to Rome to honor her mother (who died the year before) and hopefully feel closer to her, and Mark Russo, an architect that doesn't think much of tourists. We get dual POVs from our characters through the different chapters and it is done very well - it doesn't flip-flop between them every chapter so the flow of the story stays intact.
The meet-cute between our two characters happens very early in the story and you can definitely feel some initial attraction between them but it isn't unrealistic. As the story goes on, you see the magical realism take charge - pushing our characters together into situations one after the other and helping Lexi Walker find the heart of Italy. We also see them both struggle with the Roman Holiday Rule - you can't fall in love with someone who lives somewhere else and expect a happily-ever-after.
Now - to the important part: how did this No Spice book make me feel the warm and fuzzies: it was the absolutely wonderful yearning and tension and magnetism that Lexi and Mark start to fell for each other. It was so well done. I was giggling and kicking my feet and I was absolutely sucked in.
If you want a light read that makes you smile, laugh, and feel the romance build between two people - then this is the book for you.
The Roman Holiday Rule is by debut author Andra Loy and I was able to read it as an ARC through Netgalley and Haven Fiction.
I wasn't sure if this book was for me when I started because I found out after requesting it that it was "no spice". Pretty much everything I read has some elevated level of spice and I don't always get the warm fuzzy feeling in my chest when there isn't a lot of romantic/sexual tension. Well - Andra Loy proved me very wrong, y'all.
The story follows Lexi Walker, an event planner, on her dream trip to Rome to honor her mother (who died the year before) and hopefully feel closer to her, and Mark Russo, an architect that doesn't think much of tourists. We get dual POVs from our characters through the different chapters and it is done very well - it doesn't flip-flop between them every chapter so the flow of the story stays intact.
The meet-cute between our two characters happens very early in the story and you can definitely feel some initial attraction between them but it isn't unrealistic. As the story goes on, you see the magical realism take charge - pushing our characters together into situations one after the other and helping Lexi Walker find the heart of Italy. We also see them both struggle with the Roman Holiday Rule - you can't fall in love with someone who lives somewhere else and expect a happily-ever-after.
Now - to the important part: how did this No Spice book make me feel the warm and fuzzies: it was the absolutely wonderful yearning and tension and magnetism that Lexi and Mark start to fell for each other. It was so well done. I was giggling and kicking my feet and I was absolutely sucked in.
If you want a light read that makes you smile, laugh, and feel the romance build between two people - then this is the book for you.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
*The Roman Holiday Rule* by Andra Loy was an absolute delight from beginning to end. This is the kind of romance that completely sweeps you away and makes you wish you could book the next flight to Rome.
One of my favorite things about this book was how vividly Rome came to life on the page. The descriptions were so immersive that I felt like I was walking alongside Lexi through the city's beautiful streets, discovering hidden corners, historic landmarks, and romantic spots. It wasn't just a romance—it felt like a love letter to Rome itself.
Lexi was such an easy character to root for. Her journey, fueled by her late mother's wishes and the letters left behind for her, was both emotional and heartwarming. The magical elements woven throughout the story added a wonderful sense of wonder and made the experience even more enchanting.
And then there was Mark. What a fantastic hero. Charming, thoughtful, and impossible not to fall for. The chemistry between Lexi and Mark was absolutely swoon-worthy. Their playful competition, witty banter, and growing connection had me smiling throughout the book. Every interaction felt natural and full of spark.
What touched me most was the contrast between Lexi and Mark's lives. Lexi begins the story feeling so alone, carrying the weight of her loss, while Mark is surrounded by a warm, loving family. Watching Lexi slowly become part of that world was incredibly moving and added so much depth to the romance.
This book had everything I love in a contemporary romance—heart, humor, travel, family, emotional growth, and a love story that felt both magical and believable. I was captivated from the first page to the last and enjoyed every second of the journey.
A truly enchanting romance that left me smiling long after I turned the final page.
One of my favorite things about this book was how vividly Rome came to life on the page. The descriptions were so immersive that I felt like I was walking alongside Lexi through the city's beautiful streets, discovering hidden corners, historic landmarks, and romantic spots. It wasn't just a romance—it felt like a love letter to Rome itself.
Lexi was such an easy character to root for. Her journey, fueled by her late mother's wishes and the letters left behind for her, was both emotional and heartwarming. The magical elements woven throughout the story added a wonderful sense of wonder and made the experience even more enchanting.
And then there was Mark. What a fantastic hero. Charming, thoughtful, and impossible not to fall for. The chemistry between Lexi and Mark was absolutely swoon-worthy. Their playful competition, witty banter, and growing connection had me smiling throughout the book. Every interaction felt natural and full of spark.
What touched me most was the contrast between Lexi and Mark's lives. Lexi begins the story feeling so alone, carrying the weight of her loss, while Mark is surrounded by a warm, loving family. Watching Lexi slowly become part of that world was incredibly moving and added so much depth to the romance.
This book had everything I love in a contemporary romance—heart, humor, travel, family, emotional growth, and a love story that felt both magical and believable. I was captivated from the first page to the last and enjoyed every second of the journey.
A truly enchanting romance that left me smiling long after I turned the final page.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Oh how much I LOVED this book! It's worth a whole galaxy of stars!
I loved the humour, wit and competition. I loved the random 'not quite movie' quotes. I loved the comments on fonts! I absolutely loved it all and it's my favourite fiction read of the year to date.
There's a little nod to P.S. I Love You in this story of Lexi Walker, who embarks on the Italian adventure which she and her artist mother had planned for so many years - but which her mother dies before being able to make. Setting off with a carefully constructed itinerary and four sealed letters from her mother, it's not long before her carefully planned trip starts to unravel - yet with touches of her mother's artwork mysteriously appearing in unexpected ways.
Rashly, on the long trans-Atlantic flight to Italy, Lexi challenged architect Mark Russo, the man in the seat alongside her, to a photography challenge: whoever captures the heart of Italy in five days wins. Following her mother's letters, and her photographic challenge around Rome, Lexi runs into Mark time and again - sometimes literally. They both have reservations about romance, especially holiday romance, but can the magic - the heart - of Italy weave its way to their own hearts?
As already mentioned, there is SO much to love in this story. As well as being genuinely hilarious in several places (Lexi re-telling at dinner with Mark's family the story of what happened by the Trevi Fountain without giving away that it involved Mark and herself is laugh-out-loud funny and one of the best written scenes in the book), there is a lot of gentle depth here. You could see it as just a brilliantly written, clever, witty read, but it's so much more. Between the nods to Star Wars, Sense and Sensibility et al, there is plenty of quiet wisdom you might not expect. This is a perfect holiday/vacation read. Light yet with depth enough to give some points to ponder, entertaining, funny in a way which keeps the reader chuckling frequently, easy to read either in a good solid reading session (perhaps under an olive tree in Italy with a nice cool drink to hand?) or in mini-bites - picking it up and putting it down between on-tour activities.
Astoundingly, this is the debut published novel from author Andra Loy, whose earlier unpublished work has clearly honed her outstanding storytelling skills. The Roman Holiday Rule reads like a book from an author with a long-established track record. She is an amazing find for Haven, and her name has gone straight onto my must-read authors list.
NOTE: I read a pre-publication version supplied by the publisher. No review was required. All comments and opinions above are entirely my own.
I loved the humour, wit and competition. I loved the random 'not quite movie' quotes. I loved the comments on fonts! I absolutely loved it all and it's my favourite fiction read of the year to date.
There's a little nod to P.S. I Love You in this story of Lexi Walker, who embarks on the Italian adventure which she and her artist mother had planned for so many years - but which her mother dies before being able to make. Setting off with a carefully constructed itinerary and four sealed letters from her mother, it's not long before her carefully planned trip starts to unravel - yet with touches of her mother's artwork mysteriously appearing in unexpected ways.
Rashly, on the long trans-Atlantic flight to Italy, Lexi challenged architect Mark Russo, the man in the seat alongside her, to a photography challenge: whoever captures the heart of Italy in five days wins. Following her mother's letters, and her photographic challenge around Rome, Lexi runs into Mark time and again - sometimes literally. They both have reservations about romance, especially holiday romance, but can the magic - the heart - of Italy weave its way to their own hearts?
As already mentioned, there is SO much to love in this story. As well as being genuinely hilarious in several places (Lexi re-telling at dinner with Mark's family the story of what happened by the Trevi Fountain without giving away that it involved Mark and herself is laugh-out-loud funny and one of the best written scenes in the book), there is a lot of gentle depth here. You could see it as just a brilliantly written, clever, witty read, but it's so much more. Between the nods to Star Wars, Sense and Sensibility et al, there is plenty of quiet wisdom you might not expect. This is a perfect holiday/vacation read. Light yet with depth enough to give some points to ponder, entertaining, funny in a way which keeps the reader chuckling frequently, easy to read either in a good solid reading session (perhaps under an olive tree in Italy with a nice cool drink to hand?) or in mini-bites - picking it up and putting it down between on-tour activities.
Astoundingly, this is the debut published novel from author Andra Loy, whose earlier unpublished work has clearly honed her outstanding storytelling skills. The Roman Holiday Rule reads like a book from an author with a long-established track record. She is an amazing find for Haven, and her name has gone straight onto my must-read authors list.
NOTE: I read a pre-publication version supplied by the publisher. No review was required. All comments and opinions above are entirely my own.
June 15, 2026
⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ I was able to read an advanced copy of this book from NetGalley and absolutely LOVED it!!
This book was so cute and romantic without being too cheesy. I adored the chemistry between the two characters, Lexi and Mark. The story felt unique and fun, but at the same time had to delightful predictability of a great romance novel.
The writing was fabulous and I really felt transported to whichever location she was talking about. The Italian landscapes, buildings and food descriptions had me truly wanting to get on a plane immediately for Italy. And the Boston references were just so spot on and charming it made me so nostalgic for my old home in Boston!!
Highly, highly recommend for a fun, cute romantic read that will make you giggle and swoon by the end!
Sorta spoilers below, proceed with caution:
Things that I loved -
Favorite Quotes :
- “ Love doesn’t wait until nothing else is happening in life. It happens when it happens. While you’re grieving, while you’re lonely, while you’re far from home. Even while you’re wondering who you are. Fight love, and it makes things worse. Open yourself up to it, and it might heal everything else.”
- “Throw a coin in, Lexi. No matter the cost. No matter who’s watching. Mark my words, you’ll be glad you let go.”
- Ok super cute how mark writes Star Wars quotes next to the lines she underlines in her Jane Austen novel. His quotes totally hit the mark as a Jane Austen and Star Wars fan and I am giggling
- LOVED their game they made up - Bet Shot! He calls bet shot and she has to guess what he wanted to take a picture of. Simple and sorta dumb but it’s exactly the type of game my hubs would invent while out and about in Europe
- The proposal!!!! It’s SO FUCKING CUTE
This book was so cute and romantic without being too cheesy. I adored the chemistry between the two characters, Lexi and Mark. The story felt unique and fun, but at the same time had to delightful predictability of a great romance novel.
The writing was fabulous and I really felt transported to whichever location she was talking about. The Italian landscapes, buildings and food descriptions had me truly wanting to get on a plane immediately for Italy. And the Boston references were just so spot on and charming it made me so nostalgic for my old home in Boston!!
Highly, highly recommend for a fun, cute romantic read that will make you giggle and swoon by the end!
Sorta spoilers below, proceed with caution:
Things that I loved -
Favorite Quotes :
- “ Love doesn’t wait until nothing else is happening in life. It happens when it happens. While you’re grieving, while you’re lonely, while you’re far from home. Even while you’re wondering who you are. Fight love, and it makes things worse. Open yourself up to it, and it might heal everything else.”
- “Throw a coin in, Lexi. No matter the cost. No matter who’s watching. Mark my words, you’ll be glad you let go.”
- Ok super cute how mark writes Star Wars quotes next to the lines she underlines in her Jane Austen novel. His quotes totally hit the mark as a Jane Austen and Star Wars fan and I am giggling
- LOVED their game they made up - Bet Shot! He calls bet shot and she has to guess what he wanted to take a picture of. Simple and sorta dumb but it’s exactly the type of game my hubs would invent while out and about in Europe
- The proposal!!!! It’s SO FUCKING CUTE
June 12, 2026
Thank you to author Andra Loy, NetGalley, and Haven Fiction for allowing me to read a digital ARC of The Roman Holiday Rule.
📋Publishing: August 4th, 2026
4.75⭐️ | 💖 No Spice Romance
Lexi and Mark have the cutest and most relatable airport meet-cute (😂) on a trip to Rome that begins their competition of “who really knows the heart of Italy?” 🇮🇹
Lexi, an American, is traveling to Italy for an art exhibition honoring her late mother and famous artist, Reena Brooke… while Mark, an American/Italian, is an architect and photographer, and determined to secure a restoration project that could change his career.
One of my favorite parts about this book was how REAL Rome felt in this book. The descriptions were so picturesque that I genuinely felt like I was walking there with Lexi. I also loved the short, fast-paced chapters, the fun competition & banter, the Star Wars references, the Audrey Hepburn & The Roman Holiday movie nods, and the thoughtful beautiful words.
This book is without a doubt a romance… but at a deeper level, it is about family. It’s about the way parents continue to shape our lives long after they’re gone and how that love is magical. As a mother, these words really pulled my heart-strings. The plotting and writing tied everything together in such a meaningful and beautiful way. 🥹
If you love armchair travel, art & poetic settings, Audrey Hepburn, heartfelt no-spice romance, and books that explore grief with warmth and hope, I highly recommend adding this one to your TBR to read in August!! 🫶🏼
TW: Grief with loss of parent
📋Publishing: August 4th, 2026
4.75⭐️ | 💖 No Spice Romance
Lexi and Mark have the cutest and most relatable airport meet-cute (😂) on a trip to Rome that begins their competition of “who really knows the heart of Italy?” 🇮🇹
Lexi, an American, is traveling to Italy for an art exhibition honoring her late mother and famous artist, Reena Brooke… while Mark, an American/Italian, is an architect and photographer, and determined to secure a restoration project that could change his career.
One of my favorite parts about this book was how REAL Rome felt in this book. The descriptions were so picturesque that I genuinely felt like I was walking there with Lexi. I also loved the short, fast-paced chapters, the fun competition & banter, the Star Wars references, the Audrey Hepburn & The Roman Holiday movie nods, and the thoughtful beautiful words.
This book is without a doubt a romance… but at a deeper level, it is about family. It’s about the way parents continue to shape our lives long after they’re gone and how that love is magical. As a mother, these words really pulled my heart-strings. The plotting and writing tied everything together in such a meaningful and beautiful way. 🥹
If you love armchair travel, art & poetic settings, Audrey Hepburn, heartfelt no-spice romance, and books that explore grief with warmth and hope, I highly recommend adding this one to your TBR to read in August!! 🫶🏼
TW: Grief with loss of parent
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
This book has so much heart, humor, and connection.
Lexi travels on a long overdue and well planned trip to Rome. Her late mother was a world renowned artist and Lexi has helped planned her final painting reveal in the city she met her husband. This trip is also supposed to be healing. Lexi's mom wrote her letters to open at each attraction they were supposed to see together. At each turn in her trip she runs into Mark, the man she can't quite figure out, has a strong attraction to, but claims to distrust tourists. Mark has a complicated family and past. He lives in Rome now, surrounded my his amazing family, but is trying to reconnect his father who lives in Boston with his grandparents in Rome through a project he's bidding on through his family's architect company. We see the sights of Rome through Lexi's eyes and somehow Mark is at every one. Fate keeps bringing them together.
The pranks, witty banter, and found family are so fun and help add levity to some heavier undertones of grief, miscommunication and lack of trust. The added photo competition was a fantastic side plot that held throughout the entire story.
Thank you to NetGalley, the author, and publisher for The Roman Holiday Rule in exchange for an honest review. If you love to travel and meeting new people and forming relationships along those travels this is a perfect read! Add in an exuberant family and a slow-burn romance brewing to round out this story!
Lexi travels on a long overdue and well planned trip to Rome. Her late mother was a world renowned artist and Lexi has helped planned her final painting reveal in the city she met her husband. This trip is also supposed to be healing. Lexi's mom wrote her letters to open at each attraction they were supposed to see together. At each turn in her trip she runs into Mark, the man she can't quite figure out, has a strong attraction to, but claims to distrust tourists. Mark has a complicated family and past. He lives in Rome now, surrounded my his amazing family, but is trying to reconnect his father who lives in Boston with his grandparents in Rome through a project he's bidding on through his family's architect company. We see the sights of Rome through Lexi's eyes and somehow Mark is at every one. Fate keeps bringing them together.
The pranks, witty banter, and found family are so fun and help add levity to some heavier undertones of grief, miscommunication and lack of trust. The added photo competition was a fantastic side plot that held throughout the entire story.
Thank you to NetGalley, the author, and publisher for The Roman Holiday Rule in exchange for an honest review. If you love to travel and meeting new people and forming relationships along those travels this is a perfect read! Add in an exuberant family and a slow-burn romance brewing to round out this story!
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
I really, really enjoyed The Roman Holiday Rule. This was one of those romances that just pulls you in without trying too hard, and before I knew it I was already way too invested in the main characters and their situation.
What I liked most was definitely the chemistry between them. It felt very natural but also messy in a way that made it fun to read. There’s a lot of back-and-forth, a lot of tension, and those moments where you’re kind of like “just communicate already,” but in the best possible way. I actually looked forward to their scenes together because the dynamic just worked so well.
I also liked how easy it was to read. It has that escape-type feeling where you can sit down for a bit and suddenly realize you’ve read way more than you planned. It didn’t feel overly complicated or heavy, but it still kept me emotionally engaged the whole time.
There were a few moments that felt a little predictable, but honestly I didn’t even care because I was having too much fun with the characters and their interactions. The romance itself carried the book for me in the best way.
Overall, this is exactly the kind of romance I enjoy when I just want something fun, a little chaotic, and very relationship-driven. I’d definitely pick up more from this author after reading this
I really, really enjoyed The Roman Holiday Rule. This was one of those romances that just pulls you in without trying too hard, and before I knew it I was already way too invested in the main characters and their situation.
What I liked most was definitely the chemistry between them. It felt very natural but also messy in a way that made it fun to read. There’s a lot of back-and-forth, a lot of tension, and those moments where you’re kind of like “just communicate already,” but in the best possible way. I actually looked forward to their scenes together because the dynamic just worked so well.
I also liked how easy it was to read. It has that escape-type feeling where you can sit down for a bit and suddenly realize you’ve read way more than you planned. It didn’t feel overly complicated or heavy, but it still kept me emotionally engaged the whole time.
There were a few moments that felt a little predictable, but honestly I didn’t even care because I was having too much fun with the characters and their interactions. The romance itself carried the book for me in the best way.
Overall, this is exactly the kind of romance I enjoy when I just want something fun, a little chaotic, and very relationship-driven. I’d definitely pick up more from this author after reading this
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
4🌟
An unexpected slow burn romance in Rome while healing from the loss of her mother. Lexi and her mother had always planned to travel to Italy and follow the path of her parents meeting and falling in love. Her mother passed before the trip could happen, so Lexi is venturing on her own with the plan. She meets Mark, and slowly the plans change.
I really enjoyed this one. The chemistry between the main characters is top tier and full of witty banter and humor. They play pranks on and compete with each other. All while trying to find the heart of Italy. Of course there is a little drama. There is also a fantastic family, great side characters that have there own fun banter and pranks. The mmc's family alone could be it's own story, they were truly a fun addition that I would love to read the group messages of.
I love the whimsical, almost magical addition of them constantly running into each and how it connects the plot with her mother's letters left behind for Lexi. Completely unrealistic in real life, but written well enough that you want fate work that well.
Major Holiday in Rome vibes, and many references to. Great for a light grief summer romance with great chemistry amd found family.
Thanks to Haven and Andra Loy for sending for me an Arc to review.
An unexpected slow burn romance in Rome while healing from the loss of her mother. Lexi and her mother had always planned to travel to Italy and follow the path of her parents meeting and falling in love. Her mother passed before the trip could happen, so Lexi is venturing on her own with the plan. She meets Mark, and slowly the plans change.
I really enjoyed this one. The chemistry between the main characters is top tier and full of witty banter and humor. They play pranks on and compete with each other. All while trying to find the heart of Italy. Of course there is a little drama. There is also a fantastic family, great side characters that have there own fun banter and pranks. The mmc's family alone could be it's own story, they were truly a fun addition that I would love to read the group messages of.
I love the whimsical, almost magical addition of them constantly running into each and how it connects the plot with her mother's letters left behind for Lexi. Completely unrealistic in real life, but written well enough that you want fate work that well.
Major Holiday in Rome vibes, and many references to. Great for a light grief summer romance with great chemistry amd found family.
Thanks to Haven and Andra Loy for sending for me an Arc to review.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 76 reviews