Doctors Are Not Murderers

by Debraj Shome, Arti Heda

Doctors Are Not Murderers is a deeply moving collection of true stories that casts a compassionate light on the fragile, sacred bond between doctors and their patients. Through intimate and heartfelt narratives, the book reveals the profound humanity at the heart of medical care where every decision holds the weight of life, hope, and, at times, heartbreaking loss. These stories confront a sobering reality: doctors often face impossible choices, walking a razor’s edge between preserving life and honoring the dignity of those who suffer. In a world quick to judge and misunderstand, the book powerfully dismantles the harmful myth that doctors are agents of harm. Instead, it portrays them as dedicated healers grappling with complex ethical dilemmas, guided by empathy, and committed to their solemn oath to do no harm. At its core, the book is a testament to trust—the fragile trust patients place in their physicians and the steadfast commitment doctors make to honor that trust even amid uncertainty and fear. It lays bare the emotional toll borne by those who must balance science, compassion, and morality while facing public suspicion and personal doubt.

Genres: Medical, Nonfiction

271 pages, Paperback

Published September 18, 2025

Reviews

[Srujan · Rating 4 out of 5]

There is a thin line one needs to walk when framing our opinion of the medical fraternity as a unit. We grapple with two ends of a spectrum: we either think of doctors as Gods or Superheroes, holding them to an unnaturally high standard of professional competence and unwavering ethics. Or, we look at them through a thick lens of suspicion bordering paranoia, mistrusting them and their medical opinion to the point of dismissing it completely. ​This book endeavours to change that. It hopes that maybe, if we could see episodes of their lives by standing in their shoes, the doctors of today and tomorrow can foster a trust dynamic with patients and their loved ones that is healthy instead of being toxic.


​In 'Let Live, Let Live: A Journey Of Acceptance', the reader is led to explore the nuances of gender identity. It highlights that it takes conscious intention on a doctor's part to learn that their role is not to judge identity, but to honour it.​ In 'A Tooth in the Eye', one realizes that although humankind has made giant strides that make medicine seem futuristic and science-like, sometimes there is no happily ever after. Doctors are human too and often helpless. The biggest dose of reality is something that they have to swallow frequently. ​In 'You All Are Just Greedy For Money', one explores the tears, big and small, in the fabric of trust that patients place in doctors. The recent meteoric rise in skepticism and cynicism in how we perceive the medical advice we receive from doctors is undoubtedly alarming. Going to the extent of accusing them all of being in this solely for monetary benefits is not accurate. ​As someone who placed a lot of faith in my obstetrician at the time of my high-risk pregnancy, this chapter brought back all the memories, emotions, and a stronger appreciation for what they do for us. The book successfully invited me into the world of doctors, enabling me to look beyond fears and sensational headlines.

[Abu Rafaan · Rating 5 out of 5]

'Doctors Are Not Murderers' is, in a way, a sequel to the book Dear People, with Love and Care, Your Doctors, which is also a collection of stories and letters from doctors and patients across the globe.

The book begins by explaining why we need this book in the first place. There are many violent acts against doctors and other medical professionals occurring, not only in India, but in most of the countries. So, the doctors themselves have to explain their struggles and their efforts, to make the people understand, and that is where this book was born, to bond the trust between the doctors and the patients.

It explains the need of doctor-patient relationship, to bridge the gap between them. Through stories, told by doctors, as well as, patients, this book shows the reality and offers hope to rebuild trust between them.

The stories like, Dr. Roy's amazing recovery, a young girl's battle against Retinoblastoma, which made her one eye to be removed, then to her becoming a national swimming champion, and many more make us appreciate the ones who made this recovery, this life, possible, the Doctors.

One more thing I loved about this book is, that the proceeds of this book is going to the DAF Foundation, which is named after Dr. Debraj Shome’s parents, which helps the people in need of surgical reconstruction and supporting cancer survivors, and many. That alone should make the people to read this book.

Thanks to the editors and contributors for these heartfelt stories.

[Nadia Masood · Rating 4 out of 5]

This book will change how you see doctors and hospitals. What really stood out to me were the stories of trust, boundaries, and the messy human side of medicine.

There’s a chapter about a man with a very unusual request involving a wig, a burn patient whose little girl handed the doctor her piggy bank and asked him to cure her mom…stories that I felt were handled with a lot of care and respect. It makes one realize how much empathy doctors need to have, even for the strangest requests.

In India, many people have begun to lose faith in healthcare providers, feeling they’re treated more like customers than patients. This book aims to be a reminder that doctors are neither miracle workers nor murderers…just people doing their best under pressure.

It’s thoughtful, sometimes uncomfortable, and will change how you see healthcare, medical decisions, and the humans behind them.

The personal stories and challenges the doctors face are honestly the book’s beating heart. I like how the author included experiences of doctors from other countries and has also done an incredible job in highlighting the innovations and breakthroughs in various fields of medicine. Imagine surgical procedures without having to cut through skin and muscle! The author himself is an experienced facial plastic surgeon and runs an organization dedicated to treating survivors of burns, especially those who can not afford treatment. That said, some chapters wander into pretty technical territory with medical jargon and clinical details that might have non-medical readers doing a bit of skimming.

If you love human, ethically messy medical reads (think real-life memoirs meets case files), you’ll love this book. If you need something breezy and layperson-friendly throughout, you might skip some denser chapters. Still, this is a moving, necessary read.

[Geethanjali · Rating 5 out of 5]

When I first read the title of this book, it reminded me of a movie I saw when I was a child where a doctor treats a dead patient and scams a huge amount of bills from their parents after declaring an already dead patient dead which is portrayed as the dark side of doctors … That memory ignited my interest in reading this book and once I completed reading this I couldn't imagine the pain felt by the medical practitioners who saw that movie portraying them as scammers and murderers…


“Healing isn't about getting what you lost…it's about becoming whole….”


This book takes you into the stories of different people whose treatments have not just happened with pills or surgeries but with the sense of duty who cared for them with their whole heart and supported them through their each phase like heroes wearing white coats even though they themselves are carrying the weights of stereotypes… This book not just told about the struggles of doctors dealing with their patients, it explained the complete story on both patient’s and doctor’s side making us understand the dilemmas faced by the both…


Each story has different emotional weightage and the way each doctor handles their patients makes us understand how the bond between a doctor and his patient should be and how trust plays an important role in this process… It definitely took me time to go through these stories. Some stories felt so close to the situations I saw in my life that I could feel the pain in my heart… This book is really something I needed to read and I'm happy that I read this…


Once people read this book I'm sure they'll feel more confident around their doctors and trust them to cure despite all the rumours on the white coat… This book is a must read..


I highly recommend all my bookish friends to give this book a try for sure… Happy Reading… 

[NAGA KOUSHIK PASUPULETI · Rating 5 out of 5]

This book is truly an eye-opener, at least for me. It offers a deep look into the real experiences of doctors. The title is bold, but it is necessary. The preface itself shares some facts that are genuinely shocking. Even though I couldn’t fully understand a few medical terms in some chapters, they were still clear enough to convey the meaning and emotion behind them.

I was personally moved by the piece Let Love, Let Live. Through this book, I learned so much about areas like cosmetology, rare medical conditions, and even some sensitive topics that we rarely discuss in our regular conversations. That is exactly what makes this book stand out. This book makes us think beyond our comfort zone and view the medical world with more empathy and openness.

Some quotes within the chapters stayed with me long after reading. Doctors Are Not Murderers serves as a sequel to Dear People, With Love and Care, Your Doctors, but it can easily be read first, as I did. After finishing this one, I now genuinely want to read that book too. In my opinion, this is not just a book for doctors but this book is especially for regular readers like us who wish to understand their compassion, struggles, and human side in a better way.

[Sanjeev Kumar · Rating 3 out of 5]

It's an easy read at one go, with inspiring stories from medical fraternity. Worth reading once.

[Debabrata Mishra · Rating 4 out of 5]

There are books that inform, books that console, and books that defend a stance. "Doctors Are Not Murderers" sits at an interesting crossroad, it is not a defence manifesto, not a glorified tribute to the medical fraternity, and certainly not a sugar-coated public-relations pamphlet. Rather, it is a narrative mosaic stitched from lived medical encounters across contexts, identities, and countries, attempting to restore the sacred but severely injured thread of trust between doctors and the society they serve.

The central theme here is not that “doctors are good,” but that they are humans operating inside morally claustrophobic spaces. The narratives reveal the invisible emotional architecture behind clinical decision-making, uncertainty, fear of judgement, moral injury, compassion fatigue, and survivor’s guilt. This moves the book beyond anecdotal memoir into ethical philosophy grounded in reality.

Indian society, especially, oscillates between two extremes -

“Doctor is God” — demanded perfection

“Doctors are greedy” — assumed corruption

The book identifies how dangerous this binary is and invites readers to sit with the messiness of medicine: even correct actions can produce tragic outcomes, and even wrong outcomes are not inherently immoral.

The inclusion of stories involving gender-affirming care, bodily autonomy, medical stigma, and neuro-degenerative trauma demonstrates a deliberate thematic widening. The book attempts to decentralize the stereotypical patient and highlight those historically misdiagnosed, dismissed, or medicalized incorrectly.

The book repeatedly raises a silent question, "Is medical progress outpacing emotional comprehension?" We witness how advanced procedures still cannot erase existential ambiguity, how brilliant doctors still cry in silence, and how healing is never merely scientific, but relational.

One of the most relatable and recent undercurrents that addressed in the book I mob violence, online character assassination, and collapse of faith in institutions. Without speaking about it, the stories reveal how fear weaponizes grief, converting relatives into attackers, hospitals into battlegrounds, and doctors into suspects or murderers.

✍️ Strengths

🔸The book has no academic grandstanding or no jargon showmanship.
🔸Each story unfolds like a lively documentary rather than a case report.
🔸Complex medical procedures explained with emotional clarity and simpler way.
🔸Here stories breathe, pause, and resonate with reflective silence and make them relatable.
🔸The strongest point of this book is the transmission of empathy which is not forced, not sentimental, but earned through honesty.

✒️ Areas For Improvement :

▪️While the authors argued for understanding, the voice of patients who actually faced genuine malpractice, negligence in treatment, or systemic exploitation is minimally explored and ignored. Some chapters offering dual-narrative or dual perspective could have further amplifies the ethical landscape.

▪️The stories are emotionally powerful, but occasionally leave policy-level adaptations or implications such as,
✨ Medical burnout solutions
✨ Legal reforms around violence
✨ Hospital transparency systems

▪️Although framed as global or projected as for larger audience, the Indian emotional and cultural context of the book dominates, which is powerful but slightly narrows the universality promised.

In conclusion, it is not merely a book, it is a cultural intervention. It arrives at a moment when doctors are simultaneously worshipped and lynched, celebrated and sued, trusted and doubted. This book will not erase all misconceptions, but it opens a door that has been sealed shut for too long.
It offers no heroes, no villains, only humans navigating impossible terrain with a stethoscope in one hand and trembling hope in the other.

[Rishma Bora · Rating 4 out of 5]

"Doctors Are Not Murderers" is a compelling and deeply human exploration of the real world of medicine, one that lies far beyond hospital corridors and popular misconceptions. Through an engaging collection of case studies spanning cancer care, skin grafting, dementia, dermatology, trauma, gynaecology and mental health, the authors reveal the emotional, ethical and intellectual challenges that shape a doctor’s life.

At a time when misinformation is rampant and violence against doctors is on the rise, this book delivers a timely and powerful reminder that doctors are neither miracle workers nor villains rather they are human beings. The authors highlight how medical professionals are often unfairly blamed when outcomes don’t match expectations, despite giving everything they have to save a life.The book also addresses how the doctor-patient relationship has eroded in recent years, especially during the COVID-19 pandemic, when mistrust and hostility reached alarming levels.


Across 23 unforgettable real-life narratives, sometimes humorous and often heartbreaking, the book paints a raw and honest portrait of the medical profession. These stories illuminate the burden of impossible medical decisions, the grief that follows the loss of a patient ,compassion required to support families through trauma, bravery needed to stand up for patients in legal and ethical battles and the hidden vulnerability of doctors behind closed doors.

A central message of the book is that doctors experience the same fear, frustration, grief and fatigue as anyone else. They lose sleep over their patients, carry the weight of their failures and show up every day despite emotional exhaustion and societal judgment. The authors remind us that healing is not merely clinical rather it is emotional, spiritual and profoundly human. Stories of doctors becoming advocates, counsellors, innovators and fighters for justice illustrate how far they go beyond the boundaries of their profession.


The book challenges society’s extreme perceptions of doctors being Gods and greedy and argues that both are damaging. Instead, it invites readers to see the nuanced reality of medicine, where even correct decisions can lead to painful outcomes. Ultimately, it reinforces that the true enemy is disease, not the doctor


The book is written in an emotionally rich, yet simple and accessible language. It provides honest, unfiltered insights from decades of practice, balanced discussions on stigma, ethics, and evolving medical science. Whether it’s a surgeon restoring someone’s confidence or a doctor fighting for a patient’s autonomy, each chapter showcases strength, empathy, and resilience.


By the end, the reader gains a renewed respect for the medical profession and a deeper appreciation for health, humanity and the people who work tirelessly to protect both. "Doctors Are Not Murderers" is not merely a book rather its a tribute, a wake-up call and a heartfelt invitation to restore faith in the noble art of healing.

[Priyanka · Rating 5 out of 5]

Doctors Are Not Murderers is a compelling collection of real-life stories that explores the delicate, often misunderstood relationship between doctors and their patients. Through deeply personal narratives, the book sheds light on the ethical dilemmas, emotional struggles, and unwavering commitment that define the medical profession. It challenges stereotypes and invites readers to see doctors not as infallible beings or villains, but as humans striving to heal amid uncertainty and immense pressure.

Reading this book felt like stepping into the heart of medicine - not the sanitized version we often imagine, but the raw, human reality. Each story pulled me into the emotional whirlwind doctors face daily: the weight of decisions, the fear of judgment, and the relentless pursuit of compassion in a world quick to condemn. I found myself pausing often, reflecting on how easily we forget the humanity behind the white coat.

While reading the different stories of people battling severe health crises and the doctors striving to navigate these situations with empathy, I was struck by the delicate balance they maintain - providing necessary therapies without offering false hope, yet never sounding abrasive. They constantly consider the mental and emotional state of patients and their families, which adds an extraordinary layer of humanity to their work.

With each chapter, I felt an overwhelming sense of gratitude for not having faced such major crises myself or among my loved ones. It made me pause and see life in a new light, reminding me not to take things for granted - because not everyone is as fortunate. Beyond the doctors’ dedication, the resilience and inner strength displayed by patients as they clung to even a single ray of hope was truly inspiring and humbling.

What struck me most was the honesty. The authors don’t glorify doctors; they present them as individuals navigating impossible choices with empathy and integrity. The writing is intimate yet powerful, making me feel the tension, the quiet despair and the fragile hope in various situations. It’s not just a book - it’s a mirror held up to society’s misconceptions and a plea for trust and understanding.

The authors have done a commendable job of minimizing medical jargon and explaining complex concepts wherever possible. However, I found myself wishing I had a deeper understanding of certain breakthroughs to fully appreciate their significance and the magnitude of what they represent.

Overall, Doctors Are Not Murderers is more than a collection of stories; it’s a call to rebuild faith in a profession under siege. If you’ve ever judged a doctor harshly or wondered what goes on behind the scenes, this book will change your perspective. It left me humbled and deeply appreciative of those who choose healing as their life’s work.

[anya · Rating 5 out of 5]

Usually, when I write a book review, I start with a line or two that really caught my attention, or with a fancy sentence that carries a string of adjectives.

I don’t know why, but I don’t feel like either format can bring justice to this one.

In short, Doctors Are Not Murderers is a collection of real-life stories by doctors all over the world, sharing various incidents throughout their career- the various challenges they come across, the emotional weight their job carries, and so much more. In this review, however, I’d like to focus on two particular stories from the collection, the ones by the team themselves- Dr. Debraj Shome and Dr. Aarti Heda.

“A doctor’s role is not to judge identity, but honour it.”

In a world that has been made to suit cis-heterosexual human beings, what happens when you find yourself in a situation with a person whose existence and beliefs align otherwise? You try to learn where they come from, try to understand why this means so much to them, empathize with them. As I type all this, I understand that I’m doing a very terrible job at truly describing the rush of emotions I felt as I read this section, but all I want to say is, as doctors, they want to help you. They want to be able to help you feel better, help lessen your pain in whatever ways work best for you.

Similarly, for Dr. Heda’s entry, which was about spending time in Africa (which is already a place that’s terribly misunderstood on the internet and people don’t speak very well of) as an ophthalmologist, learning about their cultures and helping improve the healthcare facilities there. Her entry, I must say, nearly moved me to tears with how she described the rush of emotions she felt as she saw her patients, who had once walked into her room with deteriorating eyesight and poor vision, beam at her with restored hope in their eyes as they take in the world around them once again (one of them even wrote her a letter explaining how it felt seeing the world after fifteen long years, and if that doesn’t make you emotional, I don’t know what will).

In a country like India where attacks on doctors are becoming more common and publicly accepted, I feel like reading this book is truly essential. I truly have no words left to say, and this is already my longest book review of the year, so I’ll wind this up by sharing one last thought: we know how terribly unsafe this country is for women, but I know doctors who have had to carry safety equipments before any woman in their family had to. Please, give this book a try. Give our doctors a try. They’re only here to help you.

[Jayasoorya K E · Rating 5 out of 5]

from this very provocative title and the recent harrowing news about how doctors are being treated, I expected a collection of stories on how the doctors helped the patients and an attempt at rebuilding the relations, but this goes beyond that. These stories are heartfelt not just because they helped the patients, but because they lived through their own struggles and gained knowledge beyond medicine and treatments and used that to enhance their service. Some of these accounts- not just doctors but from various fields of healthcare, gives so much insights into their work and the connection they build with the patients.
From an outsider perspective, invention of pain medication with less side effects helps patients all over rthe world. But when we take a closer look, one of the factors that acted as driving force was the struggles that they saw in their loved ones. It's a testament to how medicine make life happy again and their empathy driving the researches which led to a much happier outcomes to the patients

We often commend on the profound impact plastic surgery can have on an individual's life, not only in terms of physical transformation but also in the realm of emotional well being and self acceptance, we also see the connections that held even after the transformations, the trust that built up between them helping the patients through what could have been a harrowing time.

How the additional depth when the doctors themselves are cancer survivors, they understand the emotional struggles on a deeper level, the experience have them a renewed sense of purpose and a deeper appreciation for life's fragility and beauty, they set out to provide the help beyond medical care - to restore a sense of wholeness and hope and help them regain their identity.
One is the interesting chapters is immortality, the scientific developments and findings are fascinating.
How to be a surgeon is not just a informed and knowledge based decision but one that caters to unique demands shared by the patient's unique lives.
The hospitals and clinics might arise frustration and confusion when they become the reminders if their sufferings. But they might seem solace when their doctor's role transcends beyonds healer- a confidante and someone to guide them through their darkest hours.
Some of the incidents really humanize them at a closer level, they are not merely service providers, they are also humans who empathize with their patients and their plight despite what the law suggests and they actually take interest in the rights of the patients and betterment of society.

[Bibliophile · Rating 5 out of 5]

“Doctors Are Not Murderers” is one of those rare books that make you stop, think, and feel deeply. Through a series of real stories, it takes you inside the lives of doctors not as distant professionals in white coats, but as human beings who carry immense responsibility, emotion, and sometimes, unbearable guilt.

Each story in this collection shows the delicate balance doctors must hold between science and compassion, between saving lives and accepting that not every life can be saved. What touched me most was how honestly the book captures their emotional struggles, the late-night doubts, the moments of helplessness, and the quiet tears after a patient is lost. These stories remind us that medicine isn’t just about diagnosis and treatment, it’s about empathy, trust, and the moral courage to make impossible choices.

The authors believe that we as doctors must also consider focusing on a more holistic, spiritual, and functional approach to beauty in our practice so that our patients may experience a new phase of being beautiful by accepting themselves with grace and confidence. There is no doubt that the advancements in aesthetic medicine will continue to change our societal structure, heavily influencing how we see ourselves and how others perceive us.

Our innate qualities of curiosity and ambition will always keep driving this innovation, but it is the greater character traits of restraint and reason that brings us to a place of balance when exploring new territories like this. Doctors must therefore pause as ethical providers and define at each stage of this evolution of their profession if they are freeing the patients from their insecurities or adding to their enslavement instead. The authors believe that it is their mission as a key opinion leader to be a voice of reason and indeed remind myself and others in our industry that our reason for being is to be reasonable and they believe that is where true beauty lies.

The book also challenges a painful misconception that when a treatment fails, it is somehow the doctor’s fault. It beautifully shows that doctors are not miracle workers, they are people who try their best within the limits of medicine and fate. The writing is simple, emotional, and full of sincerity, allowing readers to feel the weight of every decision made in a hospital room.

[ThaTha · Rating 5 out of 5]

On Defence Of Doctors

When love happens, life comes, and when life comes, love follows… these two terms are inevitably inseparable; when we treasure one, we accept the other. 23 stories come together inside this book, and I have handpicked a few to construct this review.

VOICES OF THE EXPERTS
Our medical experts are not God, and each one of us comes with an expiry date. In other words, Doctors are not gods and they are not murderers either. Amidst fear of losing a loved one, people let out their frustration on those whose only service is to save lives as many as they can, by all means and wits. Well, not everyone is saved from greed and corruption, but we cannot use this scepticism that comes from rare, unfortunate encounters and hold it against all of them who have nothing but good intentions, doing their best in their jobs. Our demand can be overwhelming when the case is a difficult one, yet they have our backs; they attempt to salvage situations that would have been impossible one a decade back. They are rapidly evolving, yet they are no God. It would be inhumane of us to expect them to worship a Neglecting Greedy God. This book is a testament to “the side of the stories of the accused ones”

Customised treatments designed exclusively for the concerned individual under the custody of healthcare breathe life back. This story would have been only a wishful dream in 1950. Back then, the patients would have given up hope or hope of mercy, and miracles would have haunted them until their end.

The Bravest and Kindest Art of Letting Go-
There is an immense love in “letting go” and accepting to find peace in living with the legacy left behind, we underestimate. I have learned that there is a special service to deal with inevitable, unfortunate events where both the patients and the loved ones are spiritually and mentally guided to handle the new chapter, which no one is prepared for and no one finds pleasant.
This compilation of 23 stories is an awareness campaign through the voices of experienced, Documentary of doctors and Experts. It was an emotional yet enlightening reading.

“One of the greatest riddles that medical science faces is death… Our efforts have been successful to quite an extent, too… And yet, despite all our progress, nobody can evade death.”

[thebookaliciousgirl · Rating 4 out of 5]

This book was full of emotions, emotions that everyone won't understand. We often come to a conclusion without knowing the full story and blame everything. But this book will tell you why you shouldn't always blame what you think is right, when in reality it's not. I'm not someone who's into medical stuff, but I loved reading this book. I often wondered what happens in a medical room, how a doctor feels in real when someone dies, someone they couldn't save. I'm not talking about the ones who are actually negligent, but those who are genuine. I've often wondered about the relationship between a patient and a doctor. And this book answered my curiosity. The book gives a glimpse into the world of doctors and their struggles, emotions, and personal experiences.

I loved how the stories were not overly written, but were authentic. They weren't dry but were raw, honest, and heartbreaking. The book shows the reality of the huge pressure, fear, and emotional rollercoaster that doctors face every day. As I said, I'm not a fan of medical stuff or understand any of it, but this book made me understand many difficult concepts in a very easy way. The writing style is really easy to understand, and the doctors share their stories in a way that's easy to follow. You'll end up learning so many new things from this one. The book is not just about medicine, but about the people behind the white coats. I loved seeing their humanity, compassion, and commitment to healing others.

I couldn't control myself and it made me emotional because of their purity. It shows that doctors are not different creatures, but they're just like us, with their own struggles and fears. But the only difference is that they're driven by a desire to help others. The book describes doctors who are not just medical professionals, but human beings who care deeply about their patients. Not everyone can be a doctor, it needs real courage, tough responsibilities, power, guts, and strength to be one, which is not everyone's cup of tea. The book also gave me nostalgia of the COVID times. So, if you're looking for a book that will make you think, feel, and appreciate the work of doctors, then this is the one. Trust me, you won't regret reading it.

[that_mallu_bookworm · Rating 4 out of 5]

Doctors are not Murderers by Dr. Debraj Shome and Dr. Aarti Heda is a call to action letter to be aware of all the atrocities faced by doctors worldwide. This book is a collection of stories spun to make the masses know how doctors are struggling to save lives and make them better for the patients that come to them.

There was recent news where a patient's relative murdered a doctor stating the fact that the treatment failed and the patient died due to the doctor not providing correct treatment. I think this book was written to address issues similar to this incident. Dr. Shome highlights how the doctor-patient relationships have frayed in the last few years to so much degree and how patients are beginning to trust the doctors less and less. How Covid resurged this hatred between doctors and patients to new heights and increased the abuse towards doctors and healthcare practitioners. Dr Shome presents this book as a way to reflect that feeling of mistrust, by providing us with a collection of stories from different doctors and their hopeful stories about the patients.

Each chapter is a different experience of different doctors and the way they helped the patients. But that's not all, since they also provide readers with information about different types of cures, symptoms, surgery and medical technology pertaining to the condition in that chapter. In a way I learned a lot of informative things about different methods of treating a patient and also the inner working of what doctors go through.

My favourite is "My Fight for Her Right to Choose". It shows how women do not even have control over one's own body due to laws and how others get to dictate what they should do with their reproductive organs. It also shows how a brave doctor stood with the patient and fought against the very law that restricted her bodily rights. A reminder that's relevant through the book that the doctor- patient relationship is not enmity but rather strength in unity.

The main key takeaway, as brilliantly highlighted by Dr. Shome, is that doctors and patients are not enemies but rather they are allies against the enemy - diseases. A daily reminder that doctors do not wake up wondering how to profit from pain but rather how to relieve it.

[EVA GEORGE · Rating 4 out of 5]

Doctors Are Not Murderers is an inspiring collection of real-life stories shared by doctors themselves. This reveal not just the compassion, but the dedication, and human connection in medical profession, through the voices of doctors. The book is a rare insight into the world behind hospital walls where healing is not just about medicine, but about empathy, courage, and perseverance.

Each story captures a unique side of what it means to care for another human being. Doctors go beyond their limits to ensure patient well-being, to patients who rediscover hope and identity through treatment, every page is a testament to the power of healing.

One particularly touching story is that of a woman who wanted to change herself in order to better understand who she truly was.

Equally moving is the story of a patient who regained their eyesight after years of darkness, a moment that encapsulates the miracle of modern medicine.

The story of a person who suffered dementia also moved me equally.

Among the most inspiring figures in the book is Dr. Aarti, who traveled to Africa with her father’s support to learn, serve, and grow as a healer. Her journey beautifully highlights how love, mentorship, and family shape a doctor’s calling. Indeed, the book reminds us how much of who we become depends on the support of those who believe in us.

Another doctor I would love to mention is @drdebrajshome the effort he has put in to create a bond with his patients and create something new for them is just another commendable job.

The book also takes a forward-looking turn, exploring the new inventions and innovations doctors anticipate in the future technologies that promise to change the face of healthcare.
Apart from all of this the doctor patient relationship, the way doctors are in a journey to find more to serve their patients is commendable. It is this bond of trust, care, and mutual respect that defines true healing.

Doctors Are Not Murderers is more than a collection of medical anecdotes it is a celebration of humanity, compassion, and the tireless efforts of those who dedicate their lives to saving others.

I've fallen in love with doctors even more...

[Neer · Rating 5 out of 5]

DANM brings together many real stories written by doctors themselves. These stories are not meant to shock the reader. Instead, they acts as a gateway into the world of medicine where every decision has an impact. The book reminds us that doctors are human beings who feel fear, hope, and doubt just like the rest of us.

Moving from one chapter to another, I could sense how varied the experiences are within the same profession. Some stories are tense while others are quiet. Together, they reveal the wide and complex landscape of the medical world. The book also highlights the immense responsibility a doctor carries. Many people assume that doctors are greedy and only want to make money. The book acknowledges that some misuse their position, but it clearly shows that this is a small group compared to the many who give far more than what is expected of them.

The book talks about cancer, infertility, the effect of child abuse on married life, the idea of passing peacefully, the search for immortality, and rare conditions I had never heard of before. I felt as if I was learning something with every story. At times the medical terms felt unfamiliar, but they were necessary to the narrative. These stories show how unpredictable the medical field can be. Doctors deal with familiar illnesses as well as situations they may be facing for the first time.

For a general reader like me, DANM expands understanding. We usually meet doctors only when we are unwell or worried. It never occurs to us what they are going through. After reading these stories one begins to see doctors not as distant figures but as people who carry their own struggles and fears while guiding others through illness. It becomes clear that people often demand too much from them without considering the emotional and mental toll this work takes.

In conclusion, I would recommend DANM to aspiring medical students and anyone who wants to understand what a doctor’s life is truly like and what the profession involves. It is a meaningful read for anyone who wishes to gain a clearer and more thoughtful view of the medical world.

[Poonam Dangi · Rating 4 out of 5]

Author of the book ‘Dear People, with Love and care, Your Doctors’, Debraj Shome has now come out with a second book, ‘Doctors are Not Murderers’. A title, intentionally kept provocative and triggering to address the issue of trust deficit between doctors and patients, head on. The title specifically is reminiscent of famous dialogue, “My name is Khan, and I am not a terrorist”.
The author states that the need to write this book arose from varied life circumstances post Covid and AI, where doctors earlier seen as mortal epitome of God on earth, were now doubted upon their morals and intentions. Where doctors in popular culture were stereotyped as greedy emotionless sociopaths, sometimes even called out ‘Murderers’ and other times even attacked by mob. Several such instances provoked the author to finally bridge this gap between Doctor and Patient relationship by elaborating on real life stories where Doctors went beyond their usual charter of duties to help their patients, and they could do so only because of the trust and confidence that patients had restored in them. I loved the chapters where Author himself a doctor performed ‘Gender Transformative Surgery’ on LGBT individual and thereby experienced a transformation and evolution of his own.
The book is a collection of true stories written by varied doctors, Indian and foreign, which is why I can not comment too much on the writing style since it changes as per the author of that particular story, however it is all bound in one linear narrative aimed to bridge this trust deficit between Doctor and Patient. I was overwhelmed with some stories wherein the little girl gives her lifetime piggybank savings to the doctor to treat his mother and another time when a patient suffering from almost lifelong blindness gets back his vision. Though some stories do use a heavy medical jargon in its writing, the book on the larger part remains accessible to anyone wanting to read it, even if not a doctor or medical student themselves.

[Aakriti · Rating 3 out of 5]

If there’s one book that really made me pause and think about what it means to be a cog in the wheel of India’s medical system, it’s Doctors Are Not Murderers by Dr. Debraj Shome and Dr. Aarti Heda

This anthology brings together real stories from doctors, patients, and people across the healthcare world. Through these voices, you start to see the medical ecosystem from every side- its pressures, its heartbreaks, and its quiet triumphs. The book’s goal is simple but powerful: to replace the fear and blame that often surround doctors with a more honest picture of what it actually means to care for another human being.

Don’t let the title intimidate you! The pages within are full of empathy and the writing is simple and effective and that’s what makes it special. One essay puts you in the shoes of a surgeon faced with an impossible late-night decision. Another captures the way grief shapes how families see clinical choices. Some stories show doctors wrestling with their own biases, only to emerge more compassionate in the end. This portrayal of small, human moments- a tired hand on a bedrail, the silence after a prognosis- stays with you long after you close the book.

The range of contributors keeps things fresh and real. From ICU doctors to pediatricians to general practitioners, and even CEOs of pharma giants, each story feels like a different window into the same deeply human experience of care.

I also loved the thoughtful touches in each chapter- the “call outs” that highlight the key takeaway, and the “innovation scale” that shows how far medicine has come in that area.

The thing that didn’t work for me was that since it’s an anthology, a few chapters could have been longer to give a sense of a neat ending to the story…some chapters left me wanting more.

Would I recommend it? Yes. Especially if you want to understand medicine not as headlines or hospital drama, but as the daily act of trying to do good in an imperfect world. It’s definitely not a weekend read or something that you can read without giving it its due time. It’s a book to read slowly, to remind you that empathy is at the heart of healing.

[Sanvi Speaks · Rating 5 out of 5]

It's actually disheartening to see how doctors are proving that they are here to save lives, that they are not our enemies but allies. It's easy for us to make accusations of "their negligence led to this" time and again. But going physical on them, hurting them, and enraging on them??? We do sometimes need a reminder that THEY ARE NO GODS, doctors are human too. They do everything in their power, trying every way possible to keep you healthy and alive. From the beginning of the book, it caught me, and while reading the book, I am speechless.

Though this book has a lot of medical jargon and details, I actually liked it. I was learning so many new things and understanding a lot of things about medicines, treatments, and most importantly, human anatomy. I am not nerdy enough to remember everything, but I do now understand the process or the way the doctors analyse the situations and deal with them.

Every story is different, every setting is different, and every chapter made my respect for doctors rise more and more. I understand the emotional weight they carry behind the scenes and how every consequence and action is measured, and unfortunately, it makes them villains.

Respect them. Trust them. Hear them. Doctors deserve our recognition, not our anger. They merit our trust, not our suspicion, and they need their voices to be heard rather than silenced by accusations.

Another good thing I liked about the book is the way it gave the R&D in a few chapters, representing how far we have come through and how far we can go in the future with timelines.

With its real-time stories and struggles, this book already won my heart, even though if you are not in such a profession, I suggest you pick this book up, and you will feel empathy towards the doctors. If you are someone who believes doctors are bad, I recommend you read to reevaluate your decision. Lastly, all I want to say is yes, there may be a few doctors who aren't good, who might have not made the wrong judgment, but they are bad humans too. But we don't generalize the latter....

[Monica · Rating 4 out of 5]

"Healing isn't about getting back what you lost – it's about becoming whole."
"Even when names fade, love remembers."
"Alzheimer's steals memory, not meaning."
"Sex education isn't dirty. Silence is."

These quotes from the book remind us of the emotional and healing power of medicine and the human experience.

Doctors aren’t magicians. Patients need to have realistic expectations. We should appreciate the progress doctors and science have made and stay hopeful for future improvements. The book includes a section called the “Innovation Scale,” which compares medical treatments from the 1950s and 1970s to those in 2020, and even looks ahead to 2070. This scale shows how medical treatments have gone from being painful and complicated to more effective and easier to get.
Healthcare today faces challenges all over the world.
Each story in the book reminds us of one key idea: trust must be built and maintained. The stories show that the best way to improve the doctor-patient relationship is through clear communication, honesty, and care. This book calls on us to act and realize that while doctors are trusted with our lives, many are also afraid for their own safety. There are stories from various fields of the medical line such as sexologists, ENT specialists, psychiatrists, oncologists, surgeons, and more. These doctors share their experiences of care, sacrifice, and hope, showing the true spirit of medicine.It’s also a way to challenge the wrong idea that doctors are harmful or dangerous. Instead, this book shows them as dedicated professionals who take their oath seriously – to “do no harm.” The stories in this book are real, and they give us a chance to see the hard work that doctors do every day.
To be clear, this book isn’t about medical crimes or doctors harming patients. It’s not a thriller or mystery. It’s meant to help us understand that while doctors may be misunderstood or feared, they are committed to helping their patients and doing everything they can to heal. This book is here to remove that fear and show what medicine is truly about.

[sahaneeya · Rating 5 out of 5]

"Doctors Are Not Murderers" by Dr. Debraj Shome and Dr. Arti Heda is one of the books that captures the realities of medical life, especially on the doctor-patient relationships. This book was especially special to me as a medstudent myself, especially in today's world where due to the lack of trust, doctors often find themselves in difficult positions. Through emotional writing, based on real experiences, the authors depict issues of medical ethics, personal vulnerability, and the difficulty of making decisions made under difficult circumstances. Each chapter presents is an unique view of the emotional demands placed upon doctors, of the moments of heartbreak, sacrifice, and humanity. The stories illustrate not just the medical cases, but also the hidden emotional and ethical challenges that a doctor has to deal with in hospital corridors. The book does a good job of showing howmedical professionals balance personal life, patient expectations, and the misunderstood outcomes of clinical decisions. The writing succeeds in making complex topics easier to understand, making it easy even for a non-medico to understand the world of medicine using crisp language and relatable examples. The authors address the misconceptions perpetuated by social media, showing how sensationalism can downplay the dedication and sacrifice of doctors, especially during the COVID-19 crisis, which has claimed the lives of many medical workers. The book is a plea for empathy trying to bring back societal trust in those wearing white coats. It does not come across as if we are justifying ourselves, but instead highlights the experiences that humanize this profession. The confessions, struggles, and stories, make the book feel more authentic. I would recommend "Doctors Are Not Murderers" to anyone who wants to see the challenges faced by healthcare workers and the life that they live outside of medicine. It forces us to reconsider our assumptions about medicine and to see the courage that is the daily lives of doctors.

[Alfiza Azam · Rating 4 out of 5]

For someone who tries everything in her power to avoid visiting doctors, this book could very well have changed my life.

Doctors Are Not Murderers is an effort to improve the increasingly strained relationship between doctors and patients. It is a collection of stories narrated by doctors themselves, accounting their extraordinary encounters with patients, of how they arrived at solutions that changed lives, and how innovative, breakthrough treatments not only transformed patients’ futures but also contributed to progress in the medical field.

These stories are deeply inspiring and moving. They bring tears to your eyes as you realise just how much doctors care for their patients, perhaps more than what we usually see or acknowledge.

At the same time, the book is highly informative. It introduces you to different diseases and sheds light on possible paths to treatment, making complex medical realities easier to understand.

What I loved most is that this is not a technical book filled with intimidating jargon. The prose flows smoothly, keeping you engaged, and focuses more on the human aspects of medicine. I also loved how the book subtly comments on societal stigmas and gender-related issues, such as child abuse, and works towards normalising conversations around them.

One of my favourite chapters is From Hope to Healing, which tells the story of a young girl battling retinoblastoma, a rare and aggressive form of cancer. Through a prosthetic eye solution, Dr Kuldeep Raizada helped her reclaim her identity, and through swimming, she discovered a new passion for life.

This journey also inspired him to establish Akriti Pvt. Ltd., an initiative aimed at helping patients not just physically, but emotionally as well.

Most importantly, this book helped me overcome my fear of hospitals and doctors. It encouraged me to take better care of myself. With this shift in mindset, I have come to realise how compassionate and supportive doctors really are and I now share a much healthier relationship with them.

[Padmajha [PJ] Me and My Bookshelf · Rating 5 out of 5]

Having worked in healthcare for some time, I’ve seen how things operate behind the scenes and what truly goes on between patients and doctors. Having experienced both sides gives me a deeper understanding of the system.
For those unfamiliar with the other side, this book offers a broader glimpse into the world of doctors. It reveals their human side, something patients often tend to miss.
I really enjoyed reading it. Many times, I found myself nodding in agreement or feeling emotional. The book beautifully captures both the emotional and scientific sides of a hospital. It acts as a bridge between caregivers and patients, helping us understand each other better. These stories also highlight the risks, effort, and sacrifices doctors make for their patients every day.
Each story feels real and personal, told through the doctor’s own voice. Every story starts with the challenges they face, then moves into how they and their colleagues work together, and ends with the outcome of their dedication, a patient’s life transformed.
The book breaks the stereotype that doctors only care about money or power. Instead, it reminds us that they are human beings who deal with life-and-death decisions daily.
What I loved most is how open and heartfelt the stories are. Each chapter shows a different side of medicine, the compassion, the ethical dilemmas, and the heartbreak that come with the profession.. It will make you truly appreciate the courage and empathy this profession demands.
I also liked how clearly the doctors explained complex medical topics. They use simple language, making it easy for non-medical readers to understand.
This book is a must-read for doctors, healthcare workers, and patients alike. Doctors Are Not Murderers is a powerful reminder that true healing begins with empathy and understanding, something that brings deeper joy and connection to both patients and doctors.

[Samikhya Aleman · Rating 5 out of 5]

Book - Doctors Are Not Murderers

When I first picked this book, I never thought that this book would leave such a beautiful imprint on my heart. Debraj Shome and Aarti Heda's - "Doctors Are Not Murderers" is a collection of stories which made me realise the true meaning of courage, compassion and resilience in the world of doctors, revealing the human side of medicine. With each page I felt more and more connected to the people who heal us. Addressing so many important issues, this book made me realise the societal pressures doctors face each and every day in silence. We should also understand that, at the end of the day, the doctor-patient relationship is not transactional but transformational.

Through the heartfelt narratives, this book explores the emotional, ethical and spiritual dimensions of healing - where the world of science meets compassion and ultimately, every decision carries the heavy weight of life and loss. Each chapter analyses real cases of doctor-patient conflict, commentary from healthcare policy and ethics and comparative perspectives from other countries that have tackled similiar challenges. The collection is exceptional because it honestly presented everything with the simple aim to replace speculation with understanding. This book also reminds us how much efforts, sacrifice and compassion go into doctors' work, helping to break the stereotype that doctors only care about money.

Overall, this book beautifully captures the true reality of humanity behind medicine, showing that doctors deeply care and give selflessly. Though, it took me a while to absorb everything, but it was definitely worth it. The authors explained the medical terms clearly, making the book easy to follow for everyone. The stories encourages readers to look at doctor's with gratitude and respect. The language used is simple and easy to understand. A must read for everyone.

[Maanya Rathore · Rating 5 out of 5]

"Doctors Are Not Murderers" is one of those books you don't really expect anything from, and then suddenly it's 2 a.m. and you're sitting there thinking about life in a way you haven't before. I honestly picked it up thinking it might be too heavy or too serious for me, because I usually stick to romance or sometimes maybe thrillers, or fantasy, but it surprised me in the gentlest, most unexpected way.

What hit me the hardest was how *real* everything felt. The book doesn't try to make doctors look like superheroes, and it doesn't make patients look like statistics. It simply shows them as human being, flawed, scared, hopeful, exhausted, trying their best. As you read, you don't just see what doctors go through, you actually feel the pressure they carry, the guilt that stays with them, the emotional choices they're forced to make. And equally, you feel the fear and confusion of the patients who are trying to hold themselves together while their whole world is falling apart.

Somewhere while reading, I realized how much pain people silently live with. We see people smiling, going to work, doing their daily routines, and we assume everything is normal, but you never really know what storms someone is carrying inside them. We all know suffering exists, but we don't really *look at it* until it hits someone we love. This book makes you slow down. It makes you think. Not in a dramatic way, just in a very honest, very gentle way.
By the time I finished it, I couldn't even think of it as "just a book." It felt like an experience, like someone had opened a door I didn't know existed and asked me to walk through it for a while. It teaches empathy without even trying. It makes you more aware, more sensitive, more grateful for the people who work silently behind hospital doors.

If you want something that changes the way you look at people, something that gently sits with you even after you close the last page, "Doctors Are Not Murderers" is absolutely worth reading

[Madhurika · Rating 5 out of 5]

At the end of the day, the doctor–patient relationship is not transactional but transformational.

This book is exactly that - transformational.

What I loved most about this book is the clarity and compassion in the writing. The authors manage to discuss complex medical realities in a way that feels personal rather than clinical. Their storytelling is full of warmth, vulnerability and insight. It never feels heavy for the sake of being heavy, it feels honest for the sake of being understood.

Through a series of real life doctor–patient experiences, the book opens a window into the unseen emotional labour of medicine: the tough decisions, the small victories, the moments that haunt and the moments that heal.

Takeaways That Stayed With Me
• Doctors aren’t machines they are humans carrying impossible expectations every single day.
• Not all outcomes are in human control, even with skill, dedication, and good intentions.
• Healing is a two-way relationship built on trust, communication, and understanding.
• Society needs to create safer, kinder environments for medical professionals.
• Gratitude and patience can change the entire medical experience for doctors and patients.

The title is bold for a reason. It challenges the harsh, instant judgments society places on doctors whenever something goes wrong. It pushes readers to rethink the narratives shaped by anger, misinformation, or fear.

The book argues that while mistakes and complications do happen because medicine is imperfect and humans are fallible the intent at the heart of this profession is almost always to heal, not harm. And that reminder alone makes the title essential.

Who Should Read This Book
• Patients who want to understand the human side of the medical world
• Anyone who has ever felt frustrated or confused in a hospital setting
• Medical students and young doctors looking for a grounded, humane perspective
• Anyone who appreciates stories that blend emotion and ethics

[Sheetal sahu · Rating 5 out of 5]

The doctor–patient relationship has always intrigued me. We often hear patients narrate their experiences, some good, some bad, in hospitals and clinics, sharing stories of compassion, negligence, or hope. But this book offered something refreshingly different: a look at the other side of the conversation. For the first time, I got to read how doctors truly feel, their personal experiences, struggles, and emotions as they navigate the complexities of healing others while dealing with their own challenges.
The statistics mentioned by the author are a stark reminder of the growing mistrust between doctors and patients. As rightly pointed out, the COVID-19 pandemic pushed this fragile relationship to its very limits, revealing the immense pressure, fear, and emotional toll faced by medical professionals.
What makes this book truly remarkable is its authenticity. We hear directly from doctors, their honest reflections, ethical dilemmas, heartbreaks, and small moments of triumph. It offers a rare, behind-the-scenes glimpse into their world, a world filled with long hours, difficult decisions, and an unwavering commitment to saving lives.
I found it particularly engaging how the doctors describe various health conditions in clear, simple language. It makes complex medical concepts accessible to readers from non-medical backgrounds, turning every chapter into both a story and a lesson. As you read, you not only learn about different ailments and treatments but also begin to understand the immense emotional resilience that defines a doctor’s life.
In essence, this book is much more than a collection of medical experiences, it’s a deeply human narrative. It’s informative, eye-opening, and a powerful reminder of the empathy, sacrifice, and strength that lie at the heart of medicine.

[Sailakshmi · Rating 5 out of 5]

Doctors Are Not Murderers is a collection of thought-provoking and heart-touching memoirs by leading healthcare providers from around the world. There was a time when the common man looked up to doctors as angels sent from heaven to save lives. However, in recent times, certain incidents have caused a rapid shift in the doctor–patient relationship. One is often left wondering whether these experts in white coats are life-givers or life-takers. This change has been challenging for both patients and doctors alike. This book serves as a meaningful attempt to bridge that gap and help both sides of the stethoscope understand each other better.

The book features stories of successes and “sweet failures” from a diverse range of professionals — from sexologists to ophthalmologists. These narratives are not told by doctors alone, but often jointly by doctors and their patients. Through these stories, readers see how ordinary healthcare providers sometimes had to become entrepreneurs, advocates, and even lawyers to ensure a better quality of life for their patients.

I was particularly moved by the anecdotes shared by cosmetic surgeons. It’s a field I once regarded as driven purely by vanity, but my perspective shifted drastically after reading how profoundly cosmetic surgery can improve a person’s confidence and quality of life. Another deeply touching account was by Gauranga Das, who wrote about Bhaktivedanta-based palliative care — a reminder that healthcare is not only about sustaining life, but also about helping people embrace death peacefully and with dignity.

As a reader, I’ve always believed that books open doors to knowledge. But this one felt special — the door was opened by compassionate experts who dedicate their lives to improving the well-being of others, regardless of social or financial background, across the world.

[Anshu · Rating 5 out of 5]

'Doctors Are Not Murderers 'is a thought-provoking and emotionally charged book that dives into the complex world of medical professionals and the moral dilemmas they often face. Through its engaging and honest narrative, it challenges popular misconceptions about doctors, shedding light on the immense pressure, responsibility, and emotional burden that accompany their profession.
From the very first chapter, the book pulls readers into the world of doctors, raising uncomfortable but essential questions. It takes a deeply human approach to a topic that is usually buried under medical jargon, sensational headlines, and emotional outrage.
At its core, the book raises a crucial question.Are doctors truly to be blamed when things go wrong, or is society too quick to pass judgment without understanding the realities of medical practice? The authors present real-life incidents, courtroom cases, and personal reflections that reveal how doctors, despite their dedication and compassion, are often met with suspicion, blame, and even hostility when outcomes don’t meet expectations.

Written by Dr. Debraj Shome, a renowned cosmetic surgeon, and Dr. Aarti Heda, a respected medical professional, the book draws from their deep experience within the healthcare system. Their combined insight lends authenticity and emotional depth to every chapter, offering a rare insider’s perspective on the human side of medicine.

This honest portrayal makes Doctors Are Not Murderers not only timely but essential in today’s world, where sensationalism often overshadows truth. It urges readers to pause before judging, to look beyond mistakes, and to recognize the compassion, sacrifice, and courage that define the medical community. In essence, this powerful book restores faith in the nobility of the healing profession.