What do you think?
Rate this book
Roman Republic #2
The Savage
In an electrifying return to the dark world of Roman Republic, a ruthless emperor contends with an enemy within, whose connection to his family’s past pushes him—and his heart—to new limits.
The city of Taormina calls to me—but Constantine possesses me, body and soul. Not just because of those chiseled abs and glorious tattoos my photographer’s eye can’t help but admire. Or the man’s utter devotion to his dog. But because he always stands up for me.
He saved my life once. And he’d do it again.
His ruthless brand of justice inspires terror on the streets of Rome. But in his arms, I shiver for a different reason. So when he asks me to move in after just six weeks, I’m ecstatic.
And conflicted.
I worry I’m a distraction. An obstacle to his duties as emperor. And when his nemesis, the Skull King—that merciless bastard who killed Constantine’s twin—reappears, I fear I’m right.
Whatever went down between them, Constantine loved his brother with all his heart. Now he has a choice to avenge his brother’s death and protect Rome…or save me again.
The city of Taormina calls to me—but Constantine possesses me, body and soul. Not just because of those chiseled abs and glorious tattoos my photographer’s eye can’t help but admire. Or the man’s utter devotion to his dog. But because he always stands up for me.
He saved my life once. And he’d do it again.
His ruthless brand of justice inspires terror on the streets of Rome. But in his arms, I shiver for a different reason. So when he asks me to move in after just six weeks, I’m ecstatic.
And conflicted.
I worry I’m a distraction. An obstacle to his duties as emperor. And when his nemesis, the Skull King—that merciless bastard who killed Constantine’s twin—reappears, I fear I’m right.
Whatever went down between them, Constantine loved his brother with all his heart. Now he has a choice to avenge his brother’s death and protect Rome…or save me again.
257 pages, Kindle Edition
Published May 5, 2026
About the author
Penelope Sky
76 books7,383 followersA New York Times and USA Today Bestselling Author, Penelope Sky is known for her dark romance that makes you fall for her characters….no matter how dark they seem. Her books are being translated into several languages around the world, and she’s sold more than a million books worldwide. She lives in a small town in California with her husband, where she spends most of her time writing on the back porch.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 445 reviews
June 12, 2026
2.5 Stars
This felt like a very one-dimensional filler book. It was very focused on Constantine, to the point that Aurelia felt like a side character. There also was no forward development of their relationship. The plot was okay, it just didn’t offset those things. I enjoyed it well enough, but not as much as I usually love these style books by this author.
This felt like a very one-dimensional filler book. It was very focused on Constantine, to the point that Aurelia felt like a side character. There also was no forward development of their relationship. The plot was okay, it just didn’t offset those things. I enjoyed it well enough, but not as much as I usually love these style books by this author.
August 13, 2026
“And there's nothing that makes me feel more powerful than you.”
WOW WOWOWOWOWOWOWOOW NOW THAT IS A MAN TO ADMIRE, JUST WOW!!! Constantine has stolen my whole entire heart in The Savage, and I think I just fell in love with him even more!
I am still completely reeling over that ending! Constantine literally walked away from his life's work and gave up his entire empire just to keep Aurelia safe from the Skull King’s vengeance. Like, he folded so fast for love and completely sacrificed his crown for her!
The only reason this is a 4 / 5 STARS read instead of a five is because he gave up his throne a little too easily, don't get me wrong that was hot as hell but it was kinda disappointing and I desperately wanted a few more scenes of them acting like a couple before the massive cliffhanger dropped! 💔
The book has a tight pacing, top-tier angst, and incredible character growth make this an absolute page-turner though.
WOW WOWOWOWOWOWOWOOW NOW THAT IS A MAN TO ADMIRE, JUST WOW!!! Constantine has stolen my whole entire heart in The Savage, and I think I just fell in love with him even more!
I am still completely reeling over that ending! Constantine literally walked away from his life's work and gave up his entire empire just to keep Aurelia safe from the Skull King’s vengeance. Like, he folded so fast for love and completely sacrificed his crown for her!
The only reason this is a 4 / 5 STARS read instead of a five is because he gave up his throne a little too easily, don't get me wrong that was hot as hell but it was kinda disappointing and I desperately wanted a few more scenes of them acting like a couple before the massive cliffhanger dropped! 💔
The book has a tight pacing, top-tier angst, and incredible character growth make this an absolute page-turner though.
May 17, 2026
Honestly disappointed cause expectations were high.
After the fifth republic , I went down a rabbit hole of reading her entire catalogue but man, the Roman Republic was just meh.
I stand by what I said that for me, the MMC just does give Roman Emperor. I’m sorry but he doesn’t give off that vibe. As for Aurelia, she’s just okay.
After the fifth republic , I went down a rabbit hole of reading her entire catalogue but man, the Roman Republic was just meh.
I stand by what I said that for me, the MMC just does give Roman Emperor. I’m sorry but he doesn’t give off that vibe. As for Aurelia, she’s just okay.
May 9, 2026
I really liked how the chapters were structured and that we got the first-person POV from Constantine about his past. The plot really picks up and immediately grabbed my attention.
However, Constantine’s personality wasn’t exactly all that appealing for the most part. The OnlyFans support is the first thing that comes to mind.
The spicy scenes were also a lot more rushed than the first book. This one definitely focused much more on the plot. Which was cool, but I mean, I’m pretty sure most of us read mafia romances for heavy smut?? I could be wrong…
Not to mention the amount of times Aurelia talked about how tall her and Constantine were and how big his…member was, was really getting old quick.
I am very picky when it comes to mafia romances because I feel like they often become super cringey and unfortunately, this installment of the series had more cringeworthy moments than the first one.
Overall though, I had a fun time and enjoyed it enough to want to read the third book.
However, Constantine’s personality wasn’t exactly all that appealing for the most part. The OnlyFans support is the first thing that comes to mind.
The spicy scenes were also a lot more rushed than the first book. This one definitely focused much more on the plot. Which was cool, but I mean, I’m pretty sure most of us read mafia romances for heavy smut?? I could be wrong…
Not to mention the amount of times Aurelia talked about how tall her and Constantine were and how big his…member was, was really getting old quick.
I am very picky when it comes to mafia romances because I feel like they often become super cringey and unfortunately, this installment of the series had more cringeworthy moments than the first one.
Overall though, I had a fun time and enjoyed it enough to want to read the third book.
July 7, 2026
Intrigued
Book 2 was very intriguing because most of it was from Constantine’s perspective. There is a lot of insightful information that was brought up in book 1 that wasn’t covered. I appreciated that we got answers about his brother and how he became the emperor. Aurelia came across much more deserving and confident in this book. We get to see the progression of their relationship through the various stages. I loved how they worked through conflict. Once again healthy balance between spice and the plot. The ending has me anticipating book 3. I would recommend this book to anyone who loves a MMC that cares strongly for the FMC. I gave this book 4 stars because while I was interested in Constantine POVs I wanted to see more of both characters as a couple. I believe book 3 will deliver that aspect. I’m choosing to trust the process.
Book 2 was very intriguing because most of it was from Constantine’s perspective. There is a lot of insightful information that was brought up in book 1 that wasn’t covered. I appreciated that we got answers about his brother and how he became the emperor. Aurelia came across much more deserving and confident in this book. We get to see the progression of their relationship through the various stages. I loved how they worked through conflict. Once again healthy balance between spice and the plot. The ending has me anticipating book 3. I would recommend this book to anyone who loves a MMC that cares strongly for the FMC. I gave this book 4 stars because while I was interested in Constantine POVs I wanted to see more of both characters as a couple. I believe book 3 will deliver that aspect. I’m choosing to trust the process.
April 22, 2026
2.5 stars. Normally I’m a huge fan of dual timeline stories but in this case it seemed to take away from any relationship growth between Con and Aurelia. This would’ve worked better as an entire prequel novella.
May 16, 2026
I know you lying…
The Savage gets 2 stars from me because this book somehow managed to move along at a snail’s pace, then completely hit the gas and slam on the brakes at the same time. The past tension between Constantine and Darius was well laid out. The present-day tension came flying in, smashed the gas, and then slammed the brakes on the whole book.
So in the end, I was frustrated. After spending so much time building Constantine into this ruthless, unwavering man who would never bend for anyone or anything (including love, marriage, or kids…his words, not mine), he folded way too easily for me. Instead of swooning, I just sat there staring at my Kindle like 😒.
It’s funny how they labeled the brother as impulsive, but every time Constantine faced Darius it was “name your price.” Sounds a bit impulsive to me. He backed himself into a corner both times.
The structure also drove me crazy. The endless “Prologue I, II, III…” sections felt more distracting than immersive and made the story feel choppy instead of layered.
This book gave me “might as well keep reading” vibes, which is honestly the only reason this isn’t a 1-star review for me. Because despite all my complaints…here I am still about to read the next book. 🙄
The Savage gets 2 stars from me because this book somehow managed to move along at a snail’s pace, then completely hit the gas and slam on the brakes at the same time. The past tension between Constantine and Darius was well laid out. The present-day tension came flying in, smashed the gas, and then slammed the brakes on the whole book.
So in the end, I was frustrated. After spending so much time building Constantine into this ruthless, unwavering man who would never bend for anyone or anything (including love, marriage, or kids…his words, not mine), he folded way too easily for me. Instead of swooning, I just sat there staring at my Kindle like 😒.
It’s funny how they labeled the brother as impulsive, but every time Constantine faced Darius it was “name your price.” Sounds a bit impulsive to me. He backed himself into a corner both times.
The structure also drove me crazy. The endless “Prologue I, II, III…” sections felt more distracting than immersive and made the story feel choppy instead of layered.
This book gave me “might as well keep reading” vibes, which is honestly the only reason this isn’t a 1-star review for me. Because despite all my complaints…here I am still about to read the next book. 🙄
May 14, 2026
THE SAVAGE BY PENELOPE SKY
ROMAN REPUBLIC
BOOK 2.
5✨ ✨ ✨ ✨✨s
Oh Constantine , Constantine, Constantine 😉
Absolutely brilliant second book of this series.
I literally started this book this afternoon and I've finished it already.
Just amazing.
I have the ARC for book 3 so I'm jumping on that immediately. I can't wait to see what on earth will happen next.
Oh and Medusa is just amazing I love her 🐶
ROMAN REPUBLIC
BOOK 2.
5✨ ✨ ✨ ✨✨s
Oh Constantine , Constantine, Constantine 😉
Absolutely brilliant second book of this series.
I literally started this book this afternoon and I've finished it already.
Just amazing.
I have the ARC for book 3 so I'm jumping on that immediately. I can't wait to see what on earth will happen next.
Oh and Medusa is just amazing I love her 🐶
August 4, 2026
This one was just okay for me. I did like getting the back story on Constantine. It answered a lot of questions from book one. But Aurelia was like an afterthought. I didn’t feel the same connection as in book one. This one just lacked something for me. The ending fell weak for me. I may read the final book some other time.
May 5, 2026
This second installment of the Roman Republic series kept me on the edge of my seat, and losing sleep. I am completely invested in Constantine and Aurelia’s story, and this book filled in so many lives of their pasts and how their futures will ultimately lead. I am living for the intrigue,the Romance, and the tale of revenge and retribution only makes me yearn for more.
I’m hooked.
5⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
I’m hooked.
5⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
June 1, 2026
**audio**
MUCH better than the first book! I really enjoyed the background “prologues” in this book. It really rounded the MMC out for me & put a lot into perspective.
MUCH better than the first book! I really enjoyed the background “prologues” in this book. It really rounded the MMC out for me & put a lot into perspective.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
The Savage pulled me in straight away with its mix of drama, tension, and those little moments that just make the characters feel real.
Thank you to the publisher for giving me the opportunity to read this ARC and provide an honest review.
I absolutely loved how dramatised the mum was — her saying she’d basically drop dead if he didn’t take the money, buy a ring, and propose immediately had me laughing. It added such a chaotic, over-the-top energy that made those scenes so entertaining.
There were also small moments that stuck with me, like: “Are you a girl on vacation?” “I like the fruity drinks here. Makes me feel like I’m in Turks and Caicos.” It just gave such a fun, light vibe and made the characters feel more natural and real.
The story follows a guy working in a pizza shop, and early on there’s already this underlying tension — especially at the party with his girlfriend Isabella and his brother Edric. The way they kept looking at each other definitely gave me weird vibes, and I was immediately suspicious about where that was heading.
As part of a series, this book did a great job of answering some of my questions from the previous installment… but at the same time, it left me with even more. I’m definitely going to need the next book because that ending had me like what is about to happen?!
I also really enjoy the author’s writing style — the books aren’t super long, but they’re still packed with emotion and keep you fully entertained the whole way through. It really gives all the feels without dragging anything out.
I finally got answers about Timothee (which I’d been waiting for 👀), and I loved seeing familiar characters like Bastin from the Fifth Republic series. Constantine will always be one of my favourites, so I was happy to see that connection.
The flashbacks and prologues throughout the book added a lot to the story and helped build everything up in a really engaging way. And the Skull King reveal? I genuinely thought I had it figured out — I was completely wrong and honestly shocked.
The FMC did still annoy me at times with her insecurities, but she’s definitely starting to grow on me and you can see her development coming through more in this book.
Overall, this was such an entertaining read with drama, twists, and a cliffhanger ending that has me desperate for the next installment.
Thank you to the publisher for giving me the opportunity to read this ARC and provide an honest review.
I absolutely loved how dramatised the mum was — her saying she’d basically drop dead if he didn’t take the money, buy a ring, and propose immediately had me laughing. It added such a chaotic, over-the-top energy that made those scenes so entertaining.
There were also small moments that stuck with me, like: “Are you a girl on vacation?” “I like the fruity drinks here. Makes me feel like I’m in Turks and Caicos.” It just gave such a fun, light vibe and made the characters feel more natural and real.
The story follows a guy working in a pizza shop, and early on there’s already this underlying tension — especially at the party with his girlfriend Isabella and his brother Edric. The way they kept looking at each other definitely gave me weird vibes, and I was immediately suspicious about where that was heading.
As part of a series, this book did a great job of answering some of my questions from the previous installment… but at the same time, it left me with even more. I’m definitely going to need the next book because that ending had me like what is about to happen?!
I also really enjoy the author’s writing style — the books aren’t super long, but they’re still packed with emotion and keep you fully entertained the whole way through. It really gives all the feels without dragging anything out.
I finally got answers about Timothee (which I’d been waiting for 👀), and I loved seeing familiar characters like Bastin from the Fifth Republic series. Constantine will always be one of my favourites, so I was happy to see that connection.
The flashbacks and prologues throughout the book added a lot to the story and helped build everything up in a really engaging way. And the Skull King reveal? I genuinely thought I had it figured out — I was completely wrong and honestly shocked.
The FMC did still annoy me at times with her insecurities, but she’s definitely starting to grow on me and you can see her development coming through more in this book.
Overall, this was such an entertaining read with drama, twists, and a cliffhanger ending that has me desperate for the next installment.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
June 2, 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️.5
Thank you to the publisher for providing me with an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
This installment had plenty of drama, twists, and unanswered questions, but unfortunately it didn’t connect with me as strongly as I’d hoped.
One of my biggest struggles was the dual timeline. While the flashbacks and glimpses into the past added context to the overall story, I found myself feeling disconnected from the characters. The narrative seemed to focus much more heavily on Constantine, leaving Aurelia feeling somewhat underdeveloped in comparison. Because of that, I never fully connected with their relationship or became as emotionally invested as I wanted to be.
That said, there were definitely things I enjoyed. The author’s writing style remains engaging and easy to read, packing plenty of emotion into a relatively quick read. The over-the-top antics from Constantine’s mother provided some much-needed humor, and several smaller character interactions helped bring the story to life. I also appreciated finally getting answers to some lingering questions from previous books and seeing familiar faces return.
The twists were entertaining, particularly the Skull King reveal, which genuinely surprised me. The ending also delivers a strong cliffhanger that leaves plenty of intrigue for what’s to come.
While Aurelia’s insecurities occasionally frustrated me, there are clear signs of growth in her character, and I’m interested to see where her journey goes next. Overall, this was an entertaining read with plenty of drama and suspense, but the lack of connection to the characters and imbalance in the character development kept it from being a higher-rated read for me.
Thank you to the publisher for providing me with an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
This installment had plenty of drama, twists, and unanswered questions, but unfortunately it didn’t connect with me as strongly as I’d hoped.
One of my biggest struggles was the dual timeline. While the flashbacks and glimpses into the past added context to the overall story, I found myself feeling disconnected from the characters. The narrative seemed to focus much more heavily on Constantine, leaving Aurelia feeling somewhat underdeveloped in comparison. Because of that, I never fully connected with their relationship or became as emotionally invested as I wanted to be.
That said, there were definitely things I enjoyed. The author’s writing style remains engaging and easy to read, packing plenty of emotion into a relatively quick read. The over-the-top antics from Constantine’s mother provided some much-needed humor, and several smaller character interactions helped bring the story to life. I also appreciated finally getting answers to some lingering questions from previous books and seeing familiar faces return.
The twists were entertaining, particularly the Skull King reveal, which genuinely surprised me. The ending also delivers a strong cliffhanger that leaves plenty of intrigue for what’s to come.
While Aurelia’s insecurities occasionally frustrated me, there are clear signs of growth in her character, and I’m interested to see where her journey goes next. Overall, this was an entertaining read with plenty of drama and suspense, but the lack of connection to the characters and imbalance in the character development kept it from being a higher-rated read for me.
May 10, 2026
Emperor Constantine
adventurous emotional informative medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Loveable characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes
The Savage, book 2 in the Roman Republic series, was a page-turner. It gives so much more insight into the man, Constantine. Yes, he is obsessively in love with Aurelia. Even more so now that she wants to spend more time with him and his dog, Medusa.
Constantine has vowed never to stop his work as the Roman Emperor, and Aurelia will need to accept him as he is. Aurelia has accepted him, introducing him to her friends, and even decided to move in with him. Yes, the relationship is moving fast, but they love each other.
As much as he loves Aurelia, he is still battling his feelings and emotions towards the Skull King for his hand in his twin brother's death. In defending Rome, Constantine must meet with the Skull King to discuss certain matters. Will that meeting go peacefully, or will the Skull King continue on his evil trend?
Will Constantine choose his loyalty to his people, or will he have to make a choice regarding Rome and his love for Aurelia? What will he do?
The Savage is definitely a wonderful read. There is steam, but the love between the two MCs is a read, and the action is, of course, dark but page-turning. Learning more about Con helps one better understand him and his intensity.
adventurous emotional informative medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Loveable characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes
The Savage, book 2 in the Roman Republic series, was a page-turner. It gives so much more insight into the man, Constantine. Yes, he is obsessively in love with Aurelia. Even more so now that she wants to spend more time with him and his dog, Medusa.
Constantine has vowed never to stop his work as the Roman Emperor, and Aurelia will need to accept him as he is. Aurelia has accepted him, introducing him to her friends, and even decided to move in with him. Yes, the relationship is moving fast, but they love each other.
As much as he loves Aurelia, he is still battling his feelings and emotions towards the Skull King for his hand in his twin brother's death. In defending Rome, Constantine must meet with the Skull King to discuss certain matters. Will that meeting go peacefully, or will the Skull King continue on his evil trend?
Will Constantine choose his loyalty to his people, or will he have to make a choice regarding Rome and his love for Aurelia? What will he do?
The Savage is definitely a wonderful read. There is steam, but the love between the two MCs is a read, and the action is, of course, dark but page-turning. Learning more about Con helps one better understand him and his intensity.
May 24, 2026
"...but you're my Roman Empire. I fight for you before I fight for anyone else."
SWOON
Constantine has me on my knees🙈 He is everything a woman would ever need. Constantine and Aurelia's relationship developed extremely quick. Most of Penelope's books are very fast paced which I really love. She writes in a way where things keep moving but you don't feel like you're missing anything. I love her writing style and will continue to read everything she writes.
Let's talk about Constantine and Medusa's relationship for a second. I LOVE a man that loves his pets. Medusa is a queen and is definitely treated like one.
Aurelia had some growth throughout this book. She is a very real and raw character. When things happen and her trauma responses come out you can't help but feel for her. She is a strong woman and even she breaks down from time to time. I love everything about her.
We learn a lot about Constantine's past in this book. We get a glimpse into the trauma he's experienced in not only his past relationship but also with the relationship with his brother. It provides some clarity about why he is the way he is.
The last 25% of this book was action packed. I didn't want to put it down. Things were happening so quick, I felt like my eyes were going to fall out because I was reading so fast 😆 I cannot wait to dive into book 3 and find out what comes next for these two and The Roman Republic.
SWOON
Constantine has me on my knees🙈 He is everything a woman would ever need. Constantine and Aurelia's relationship developed extremely quick. Most of Penelope's books are very fast paced which I really love. She writes in a way where things keep moving but you don't feel like you're missing anything. I love her writing style and will continue to read everything she writes.
Let's talk about Constantine and Medusa's relationship for a second. I LOVE a man that loves his pets. Medusa is a queen and is definitely treated like one.
Aurelia had some growth throughout this book. She is a very real and raw character. When things happen and her trauma responses come out you can't help but feel for her. She is a strong woman and even she breaks down from time to time. I love everything about her.
We learn a lot about Constantine's past in this book. We get a glimpse into the trauma he's experienced in not only his past relationship but also with the relationship with his brother. It provides some clarity about why he is the way he is.
The last 25% of this book was action packed. I didn't want to put it down. Things were happening so quick, I felt like my eyes were going to fall out because I was reading so fast 😆 I cannot wait to dive into book 3 and find out what comes next for these two and The Roman Republic.
July 16, 2026
I had mixed feelings about this one. The first half felt quite slow, and for a while I wasn’t really sure where the story was heading. It took me a while to get invested, and I found myself waiting for something to really pull me in.
The second half was much stronger. I really enjoyed finally getting Constantine’s backstory and learning more about his past. Understanding how he became the man he is added a lot of depth to his character and made me much more invested in the story.
The ending, though, felt a little flat. It didn’t leave me with the impact I was expecting, but it did leave me curious enough to see how everything will be wrapped up in the final book of the series. Overall, it was an okay read with a slow start but a much more engaging second half.
The second half was much stronger. I really enjoyed finally getting Constantine’s backstory and learning more about his past. Understanding how he became the man he is added a lot of depth to his character and made me much more invested in the story.
The ending, though, felt a little flat. It didn’t leave me with the impact I was expecting, but it did leave me curious enough to see how everything will be wrapped up in the final book of the series. Overall, it was an okay read with a slow start but a much more engaging second half.
July 7, 2026
I couldn’t stop after book two to review so books two & three are together. I just love Penelope’s mafia stories! We get to travel to beautiful countries, crazy shit happens, they hump like bunnies, and the men are down BAD for their women!
Con is a bit different from the other men I’ve read in her stories before though. I kind of liked it. Usually the men stay and fight. Not just for power but for pride and ego, which with mafia men it’s expected. But for Con he literally said fuck Rome and took Aurelia to safety. He does go back to help end the shit going on, but his whole focus shifted when Aurelia was put in danger again. I loved it!
The only thing with the last two books was it was more Con focused and I felt like Aurelia at times became a side character? But I really loved getting Con’s flash backs so it’s cool. I loved the flash backs and to see what happened with his brother, his ex and how he became the emperor.
Read: Audible 🎧
MMC: Constantine
FMC: Aurelia
Spice: 2🌶️
Tropes: Mafia, Touch Her and Die, O/P H, Golden Retriever MMC, Billionaire
Con is a bit different from the other men I’ve read in her stories before though. I kind of liked it. Usually the men stay and fight. Not just for power but for pride and ego, which with mafia men it’s expected. But for Con he literally said fuck Rome and took Aurelia to safety. He does go back to help end the shit going on, but his whole focus shifted when Aurelia was put in danger again. I loved it!
The only thing with the last two books was it was more Con focused and I felt like Aurelia at times became a side character? But I really loved getting Con’s flash backs so it’s cool. I loved the flash backs and to see what happened with his brother, his ex and how he became the emperor.
Read: Audible 🎧
MMC: Constantine
FMC: Aurelia
Spice: 2🌶️
Tropes: Mafia, Touch Her and Die, O/P H, Golden Retriever MMC, Billionaire
July 27, 2026
3.5⭐️
Ugh, I knew this was bound to happen. It’s tough to keep the same glow across three books in a trilogy.
The first one was definitely better. And honestly, it felt a bit silly that Aurelia told Constantine “I love you forever” just six weeks after breaking up with her ex and meeting him.
Everything was so rushed, even though there were three books to stretch the story out — plenty of time for confessions!
Still, I enjoyed it overall. It’s a quick, entertaining read that keeps you hooked despite the flaws.
Ugh, I knew this was bound to happen. It’s tough to keep the same glow across three books in a trilogy.
The first one was definitely better. And honestly, it felt a bit silly that Aurelia told Constantine “I love you forever” just six weeks after breaking up with her ex and meeting him.
Everything was so rushed, even though there were three books to stretch the story out — plenty of time for confessions!
Still, I enjoyed it overall. It’s a quick, entertaining read that keeps you hooked despite the flaws.
May 5, 2026
What?? I don't know how Penelope does it, but she sucks you in, and there is no way out ( you don't want to get out TRUST ME!! ) Con and Aurelia story is phenomenal. You understand more of the past and present of how Con becomes the Roman Republic Emperor and then how he is not... You won't be disappointed! I encourage you to read!!!
May 22, 2026
This book starts pretty much where the last one ended. Constantine and Aurelia are still dating and doing their thing. While we watch their relationship move forward, we also go back in time to see how Constantine became who he is today.
The ending was unsatisfying to me but I hope the next book fixes it.
Overall, a quick and fun read!
The ending was unsatisfying to me but I hope the next book fixes it.
Overall, a quick and fun read!
June 22, 2026
Anything by Penelope Sky is near and dear to my heart but it still amazes me how she manages to create so many amazing characters that have you rooting for them from the edge of your seat. Aurelia and Constantine are no different and I’m more than ready to get my hands on the next chapter in their story!!
May 5, 2026
{3.5🌟}
June 11, 2026
I’m literally obsessed with Constantine.
June 15, 2026
3.5 stars
I didn’t like this one as much as the first. But I did like it enough to continue the series.
I didn’t like this one as much as the first. But I did like it enough to continue the series.
June 27, 2026
This book was eh, but I did enjoy it at different parts. It felt kinda all over the place. The flash backs through me off by the chapters being called Prologues. Used to them being in the beginning of books not sandwiched in between chapters. There are 10 of them. Will be reading the last book. Need to know how it ends.
May 11, 2026
If you've read the Fifth Republic series, this series is essentially the same story. Bastien and Constantine are the same character. The FMC’s are very similar. I honestly thought I was re-reading The Butcher.
So this was disappointing to say the least. I like most books by this author. But this was a waste of time.
So this was disappointing to say the least. I like most books by this author. But this was a waste of time.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
July 15, 2026
Romance Reader Report Card
❤️ Chemistry: 5/5
🔥 Tension: 4/5
🌶️ Spice: 4/5
😭 Emotional Impact: 4/5
👨 Book Boyfriend Status: Certified
📚 Reread Worthy? Yes
Tropes
* Mafia Romance
* Established Couple
* Criminal Empire
* Protective Hero
* Healthy Communication
* Touch Her and Die
* Ride or Die Romance
* Political Intrigue
* Found Loyalty
* Cliffhanger Ending
What I Loved
One of my biggest fears going into the sequel was that Penelope Sky would manufacture unnecessary relationship drama.
She didn’t.
Instead, she let Constantine and Aurelia actually be a couple.
They’re about six weeks into their relationship, and they’re completely committed to each other. There’s no manufactured “will they, won’t they,” no endless misunderstandings, and no hero suddenly acting out of character just to create conflict.
Constantine continues to be one of my favorite mafia heroes because he actually trusts Aurelia.
When another man enters the picture, he asks about it instead of accusing her. When she tells him exactly what happened, he believes her. That’s…refreshing.
I also loved finally getting Constantine’s backstory. Learning about his brother, his rise to power, and the heartbreak that shaped him added so much depth to his character. Normally, extended flashbacks slow a story down for me, but these felt worthwhile because they explained why Constantine became the man he is.
His vulnerability with Aurelia was another highlight.
When he’s struggling with everything surrounding the Skull King, he doesn’t shut her out forever or lash out. He eventually admits that he’s hurting, and Aurelia simply sits with him in that pain instead of trying to fix it.
It felt mature.
What Didn’t Work for Me
This book shifts noticeably toward expanding the larger series mythology.
There’s more political maneuvering, more criminal empire logistics, and more setup for future books. None of it is bad—in fact, it’s interesting—but it means the romance occasionally shares the spotlight with the overarching plot.
I preferred the tighter romance focus of The Ruler, but I understand why this sequel needed to broaden the scope.
Favorite Moment
Constantine making the impossible choice.
After insisting in the first book that nothing would ever come before his duty as Emperor, he’s forced to choose between his empire and Aurelia’s life.
And without hesitation…
He chooses Aurelia.
That moment completely reframed everything we’d learned about him. For someone who built his identity around responsibility and duty, choosing love wasn’t weakness—it was growth.
Final Thoughts
I don’t think I enjoyed this one quite as much as The Ruler, but that’s mostly because the romance is already established and the series naturally begins focusing on the larger conflict.
The relationship itself remains one of the healthiest I’ve read in this subgenre.
Constantine listens.
Aurelia communicates.
They trust each other.
They solve problems together instead of creating unnecessary ones.
That’s surprisingly uncommon in mafia romance.
The ending left me genuinely excited for the next book, which is exactly what a middle installment should do.
If You Like…
* Mafia Romance
* Established Couples
* Healthy Communication
* Criminal Empire Politics
* Protective Heroes
* Emotionally Mature Relationships
* Strong Partnerships
* Cliffhanger Endings
Recommended For
Readers who enjoy mafia romances where the couple stays solid while the external conflicts escalate. If your favorite part of romance is watching two people choose each other over and over again instead of constantly breaking up, this sequel delivers that beautifully.
❤️ Chemistry: 5/5
🔥 Tension: 4/5
🌶️ Spice: 4/5
😭 Emotional Impact: 4/5
👨 Book Boyfriend Status: Certified
📚 Reread Worthy? Yes
Tropes
* Mafia Romance
* Established Couple
* Criminal Empire
* Protective Hero
* Healthy Communication
* Touch Her and Die
* Ride or Die Romance
* Political Intrigue
* Found Loyalty
* Cliffhanger Ending
What I Loved
One of my biggest fears going into the sequel was that Penelope Sky would manufacture unnecessary relationship drama.
She didn’t.
Instead, she let Constantine and Aurelia actually be a couple.
They’re about six weeks into their relationship, and they’re completely committed to each other. There’s no manufactured “will they, won’t they,” no endless misunderstandings, and no hero suddenly acting out of character just to create conflict.
Constantine continues to be one of my favorite mafia heroes because he actually trusts Aurelia.
When another man enters the picture, he asks about it instead of accusing her. When she tells him exactly what happened, he believes her. That’s…refreshing.
I also loved finally getting Constantine’s backstory. Learning about his brother, his rise to power, and the heartbreak that shaped him added so much depth to his character. Normally, extended flashbacks slow a story down for me, but these felt worthwhile because they explained why Constantine became the man he is.
His vulnerability with Aurelia was another highlight.
When he’s struggling with everything surrounding the Skull King, he doesn’t shut her out forever or lash out. He eventually admits that he’s hurting, and Aurelia simply sits with him in that pain instead of trying to fix it.
It felt mature.
What Didn’t Work for Me
This book shifts noticeably toward expanding the larger series mythology.
There’s more political maneuvering, more criminal empire logistics, and more setup for future books. None of it is bad—in fact, it’s interesting—but it means the romance occasionally shares the spotlight with the overarching plot.
I preferred the tighter romance focus of The Ruler, but I understand why this sequel needed to broaden the scope.
Favorite Moment
Constantine making the impossible choice.
After insisting in the first book that nothing would ever come before his duty as Emperor, he’s forced to choose between his empire and Aurelia’s life.
And without hesitation…
He chooses Aurelia.
That moment completely reframed everything we’d learned about him. For someone who built his identity around responsibility and duty, choosing love wasn’t weakness—it was growth.
Final Thoughts
I don’t think I enjoyed this one quite as much as The Ruler, but that’s mostly because the romance is already established and the series naturally begins focusing on the larger conflict.
The relationship itself remains one of the healthiest I’ve read in this subgenre.
Constantine listens.
Aurelia communicates.
They trust each other.
They solve problems together instead of creating unnecessary ones.
That’s surprisingly uncommon in mafia romance.
The ending left me genuinely excited for the next book, which is exactly what a middle installment should do.
If You Like…
* Mafia Romance
* Established Couples
* Healthy Communication
* Criminal Empire Politics
* Protective Heroes
* Emotionally Mature Relationships
* Strong Partnerships
* Cliffhanger Endings
Recommended For
Readers who enjoy mafia romances where the couple stays solid while the external conflicts escalate. If your favorite part of romance is watching two people choose each other over and over again instead of constantly breaking up, this sequel delivers that beautifully.
June 22, 2026
THE KING WHO GAVE AWAY HIS CROWN
I don’t even know where to begin with this book because I am still sitting here trying to process that ending.
What started as a continuation of Constantine and Aurelia’s story became so much more than a romance. This book gave us the man behind the legend. It peeled back every layer of Constantine’s past and showed us exactly how he became the ruler, protector, and feared leader we met in the first book.
One of the most brilliant things Penelope Sky did was the structure of this story. Instead of simply continuing where the first book left off, she wove Constantine’s history throughout the present timeline. We watched his childhood, his losses, his sacrifices, and the heartbreak that shaped him. The storyline involving his brother was especially devastating and added so much emotional depth to his character. Every painful moment helped explain the choices he makes as an adult and the burden he has carried for years.
What truly elevated this book for me was the way the timelines eventually collided. The story slowly caught up to the exact moment Constantine and Aurelia first met, tying the events of this book directly into the first one. Suddenly scenes from the previous book carried entirely new meaning because we finally understood what was happening from Constantine’s perspective. It was masterful storytelling and one of the most satisfying narrative payoffs I’ve read in a long time.
I also loved how Aurelia and Constantine’s relationship continued to evolve. Their connection felt deeper because we finally understood what he had been carrying all along. Watching him allow someone into the walls he built around himself made every interaction feel more meaningful.
The introduction and expansion of the Skull King’s role was another highlight. It never felt forced. Instead, it felt like the author was carefully laying the groundwork for something much bigger that will undoubtedly explode in the next book. Every scene involving him left me wanting more.
And then there was that ending.
I am still not over it.
After everything Constantine built, after everything he sacrificed, after everything he endured, he gave up the entire Republic. Not because he was weak. Not because he was defeated. But because he chose the people he loved over power. That decision broke my heart and somehow made me respect him even more.
The cliffhanger was absolutely brutal. I am convinced that Constantine’s story is far from over. A man like him doesn’t simply walk away forever. I have a feeling the next book will bring a reckoning, and I desperately hope Aurelia helps him see that he is still the leader his people need. If anyone can bring him back to reclaim what was taken, it’s her.
Penelope Sky once again proved why she remains one of my favorite authors. She didn’t just write a romance. She wrote a story about sacrifice, loyalty, grief, love, leadership, and the impossible choices that come with power.
This was emotional, heartbreaking, beautifully structured, and completely unforgettable.
If you love powerful leaders, emotionally layered heroes, strong heroines, rich worldbuilding, heartbreaking sacrifice, and endings that leave you staring at the wall wondering what just happened, this book is a must-read.
Now excuse me while I impatiently wait for Book 3 because I need answers immediately.
😏🔥 And honestly? “The King Who Gave Away His Crown” feels like the perfect title because that’s exactly what wrecked you. Not the spice. Not even the romance.
The sacrifice. The fact that he chose people over power. And now you’re sitting there hoping he’ll take it all back. 🖤📚🔥
I don’t even know where to begin with this book because I am still sitting here trying to process that ending.
What started as a continuation of Constantine and Aurelia’s story became so much more than a romance. This book gave us the man behind the legend. It peeled back every layer of Constantine’s past and showed us exactly how he became the ruler, protector, and feared leader we met in the first book.
One of the most brilliant things Penelope Sky did was the structure of this story. Instead of simply continuing where the first book left off, she wove Constantine’s history throughout the present timeline. We watched his childhood, his losses, his sacrifices, and the heartbreak that shaped him. The storyline involving his brother was especially devastating and added so much emotional depth to his character. Every painful moment helped explain the choices he makes as an adult and the burden he has carried for years.
What truly elevated this book for me was the way the timelines eventually collided. The story slowly caught up to the exact moment Constantine and Aurelia first met, tying the events of this book directly into the first one. Suddenly scenes from the previous book carried entirely new meaning because we finally understood what was happening from Constantine’s perspective. It was masterful storytelling and one of the most satisfying narrative payoffs I’ve read in a long time.
I also loved how Aurelia and Constantine’s relationship continued to evolve. Their connection felt deeper because we finally understood what he had been carrying all along. Watching him allow someone into the walls he built around himself made every interaction feel more meaningful.
The introduction and expansion of the Skull King’s role was another highlight. It never felt forced. Instead, it felt like the author was carefully laying the groundwork for something much bigger that will undoubtedly explode in the next book. Every scene involving him left me wanting more.
And then there was that ending.
I am still not over it.
After everything Constantine built, after everything he sacrificed, after everything he endured, he gave up the entire Republic. Not because he was weak. Not because he was defeated. But because he chose the people he loved over power. That decision broke my heart and somehow made me respect him even more.
The cliffhanger was absolutely brutal. I am convinced that Constantine’s story is far from over. A man like him doesn’t simply walk away forever. I have a feeling the next book will bring a reckoning, and I desperately hope Aurelia helps him see that he is still the leader his people need. If anyone can bring him back to reclaim what was taken, it’s her.
Penelope Sky once again proved why she remains one of my favorite authors. She didn’t just write a romance. She wrote a story about sacrifice, loyalty, grief, love, leadership, and the impossible choices that come with power.
This was emotional, heartbreaking, beautifully structured, and completely unforgettable.
If you love powerful leaders, emotionally layered heroes, strong heroines, rich worldbuilding, heartbreaking sacrifice, and endings that leave you staring at the wall wondering what just happened, this book is a must-read.
Now excuse me while I impatiently wait for Book 3 because I need answers immediately.
😏🔥 And honestly? “The King Who Gave Away His Crown” feels like the perfect title because that’s exactly what wrecked you. Not the spice. Not even the romance.
The sacrifice. The fact that he chose people over power. And now you’re sitting there hoping he’ll take it all back. 🖤📚🔥
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
⭐ 3.75 | ❤️ 3/5
If you read The Ruler and liked Constantine, I recommend that you read the sequel. The Savage is the stronger book, though it is meaningfully different.
The romance takes a backseat in this sequel; as does the heat. What you get instead is Constantine’s mafia origin story across a dual timeline, and I found myself more engaged with his past timeline than the present across either book. Part of that is due to it being in his POV; he’s just more inhabited and fleshed out than Aurelia is. The past timeline includes how things came to unravel between him and his twin Edric, the fallout with his ex Isabella, and how he rose up. Watching this build up to the present storyline, including the first time he laid eyes on Aurelia, was very satisfying. I came away from this book understanding Constantine as a person much better. The secondary characters get their moments too, and some of the highlights of the book include quips from Aurelia and Constantine’s social circles, which bring levity with good comedic timing.
Some of the craft patterns that I mentioned in my review of The Ruler persist in this book. The dialogue occasionally veers into corny territory, typically from Constantine. There were moments where the dialogue undercut an otherwise solid scene. The story also had some inconsistency around the central betrayal that drives the backstory, where I felt that the narrative didn’t quite commit to what actually happened. This led it to feel unresolved. Like The Ruler, telling instead of showing remains a pattern especially in the handling of emotions.
It’s worth noting that the heat is dialed down to a 3/5 versus the 4/5 of The Ruler’s (or what I might typically expect from the author). While there was the addition of more somnophilia and free use, most scenes were brief, low detail, or happened off the page. If heat was a primary draw for you, know this going into this book.
The ending felt anticlimactic and not just because of how suddenly it arrived. The external plot resolves, but the emotional resolution felt unfinished to me as if there would have been a final scene that just got cut off. Part of that feeling came from being told what the characters felt rather than shown it, which felt at odds with the uncertainty that was being conveyed nonverbally. I turned the page expecting more and found the author’s backlist instead. With a third book, The Breaker, on the way, this reads in hindsight as a series pause, but nothing in the ending signaled that.
Overall, it was an entertaining read; just know what you're getting into.
1. The Ruler ⭐ 3.5 | ❤️ 4/5
2. The Savage ⭐ 3.75 | ❤️ 3/5
3. The Breaker - to be released
This review is based on an ARC provided by Montlake via Netgalley. All opinions are my own.
If you read The Ruler and liked Constantine, I recommend that you read the sequel. The Savage is the stronger book, though it is meaningfully different.
The romance takes a backseat in this sequel; as does the heat. What you get instead is Constantine’s mafia origin story across a dual timeline, and I found myself more engaged with his past timeline than the present across either book. Part of that is due to it being in his POV; he’s just more inhabited and fleshed out than Aurelia is. The past timeline includes how things came to unravel between him and his twin Edric, the fallout with his ex Isabella, and how he rose up. Watching this build up to the present storyline, including the first time he laid eyes on Aurelia, was very satisfying. I came away from this book understanding Constantine as a person much better. The secondary characters get their moments too, and some of the highlights of the book include quips from Aurelia and Constantine’s social circles, which bring levity with good comedic timing.
Some of the craft patterns that I mentioned in my review of The Ruler persist in this book. The dialogue occasionally veers into corny territory, typically from Constantine. There were moments where the dialogue undercut an otherwise solid scene. The story also had some inconsistency around the central betrayal that drives the backstory, where I felt that the narrative didn’t quite commit to what actually happened. This led it to feel unresolved. Like The Ruler, telling instead of showing remains a pattern especially in the handling of emotions.
It’s worth noting that the heat is dialed down to a 3/5 versus the 4/5 of The Ruler’s (or what I might typically expect from the author). While there was the addition of more somnophilia and free use, most scenes were brief, low detail, or happened off the page. If heat was a primary draw for you, know this going into this book.
The ending felt anticlimactic and not just because of how suddenly it arrived. The external plot resolves, but the emotional resolution felt unfinished to me as if there would have been a final scene that just got cut off. Part of that feeling came from being told what the characters felt rather than shown it, which felt at odds with the uncertainty that was being conveyed nonverbally. I turned the page expecting more and found the author’s backlist instead. With a third book, The Breaker, on the way, this reads in hindsight as a series pause, but nothing in the ending signaled that.
Overall, it was an entertaining read; just know what you're getting into.
1. The Ruler ⭐ 3.5 | ❤️ 4/5
2. The Savage ⭐ 3.75 | ❤️ 3/5
3. The Breaker - to be released
This review is based on an ARC provided by Montlake via Netgalley. All opinions are my own.
May 10, 2026
The Savage picks up right after The Ruler, so it won't make a lot of sense without reading book 1 first. There is no "recap" explaining what happened in book 1 with Constantine, Aurelia, the Roman Republic, or the plot. The Savage is heavily written in Constantine's POV between current day and past experiences told through several prologues.
In present day, Constantine deals with It sets up the Roman Republic structure: the Pope, the president, the military, and history. It can drag at times explaining the empire around Constantine, stalling the romance into a nearly-forgotten subplot.
Constantine's flashbacks show what happened with Edric and Isabella, how Constantine entered the mafia world, how Edric ended up with Darius, and how Constantine watched his brother die. Constantine's grief makes him rigid and controlled.
The story also has a strange honor code for him. Constantine is obsessed with truth, loyalty, and keeping his word, but he withholds truth all the time. That double standard is a frustrating and hypocritical part of his character. He hates not controlling secrets.
Aurelia is basically a houseplant in this book. Her arc centers on accepting what Constantine’s world requires.
This book is shelved as Dark Romance but honestly there is very little romance, and even less spice. The Ruler had the heat, mystery, and chemistry. The Savage is the dark reality after that fantasy ends.
The ending happens quickly at 500 mph.
I would describe this book as a bridge between 1 and 3 with a lot of "work" narrative. Constantine gets a full backstory, motivations, trauma, and the girl. But as a romance, it’s thin.
Spice 1.5/5.
In present day, Constantine deals with It sets up the Roman Republic structure: the Pope, the president, the military, and history. It can drag at times explaining the empire around Constantine, stalling the romance into a nearly-forgotten subplot.
Constantine's flashbacks show what happened with Edric and Isabella, how Constantine entered the mafia world, how Edric ended up with Darius, and how Constantine watched his brother die. Constantine's grief makes him rigid and controlled.
The story also has a strange honor code for him. Constantine is obsessed with truth, loyalty, and keeping his word, but he withholds truth all the time. That double standard is a frustrating and hypocritical part of his character. He hates not controlling secrets.
Aurelia is basically a houseplant in this book. Her arc centers on accepting what Constantine’s world requires.
This book is shelved as Dark Romance but honestly there is very little romance, and even less spice. The Ruler had the heat, mystery, and chemistry. The Savage is the dark reality after that fantasy ends.
The ending happens quickly at 500 mph.
I would describe this book as a bridge between 1 and 3 with a lot of "work" narrative. Constantine gets a full backstory, motivations, trauma, and the girl. But as a romance, it’s thin.
Spice 1.5/5.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 445 reviews