Piccoli inganni crudeli

by Sulmi Bak, Mary Lou Emberti Gialloreti (Translator)

Due famiglie travolte da un piccolo, tragico evento. Una storia di onore e vendetta, di giustizia e di colpa da cui non si salva nessuno.
Un mosaico di confessioni, accuse e mezze verità che irretisce il lettore fino allo sconcertante finale.

La vita di Mira è andata in frantumi quando è rimasta orfana. Un anno dopo il terribile evento che l'ha privata della madre e del fratellino, Mira inizia a lavorare come insegnante di ripetizioni di Yujae, un adolescente schivo e problematico, che abita nel suo stesso quartiere ma in una casa infinitamente più lussuosa della sua. Yujae ha un fratello maggiore, Yuchan, che all'opposto è geniale e proiettato verso una brillante carriera accademica, spinto dall'ambiziosa madre Jiwon. Ma il più piccolo dei fratelli è davvero il più fragile? Mira è davvero soltanto un'insegnante di ripetizioni? E Jiwon è solo una madre ansiosa e protettiva? In un romanzo in cui nulla è come sembra, e in cui a condurre il gioco non è mai chi all'apparenza lo guida, la verità emerge a frammenti taglienti, spiazzanti, fatali. Una verità fatta di onore tradito, di dignità spezzata, di ambizione e rancore. Pagina dopo pagina dilaga tutto il gelo di una forza inesorabile: la vendetta. Il lettore ne è a poco a poco pervaso, poi braccato. E non ne può uscire.

Genres: Horror, Thriller, Mystery, Fiction, Mystery Thriller, Novella, Crime

201 pages, Paperback

First published November 19, 2013

About the author

Sulmi Bak, born in 1984, majored in journalism and chose to become a novelist while preparing for examination for a top gaming company in Korea. Petty Lies is her debut novel, followed by two other stand-alone novels, The Silence of the Swan and Dalwhinnie Hotel.

Reviews

[TheConnieFox · Rating 1 out of 5]

This book heavily discusses animal cruelty. I cannot read about children murdering animals! This book is disgusting and disturbing on a whole other level! I give this a zero out of 5 stars! I did not finish this book.

Thank you NetGalley, author Sulmi Bak and Little, Brown and Company | Mulholland Books for this digital advanced reader’s copy in exchange for my honest review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

[Erin · Rating 1 out of 5]

ARC for review. To be published November 11, 2025.

1 star - DNF at 60% but I feel like I read enough to give it a rating.

I chose to read this book because it was compared to one of my all-time favorites, WE NEED TO TALK ABOUT KEVIN and I see why the publisher or whomever thought he/she could make the comparison, this is an epistolary novel about a bad seed, but that’s where are likeness between the two stops.

Here we have Mina, who is hired by Jiwon to tutor her son Yuchan. Mira is haunted by the death of her mother and sibling and wants to get even. Mira believes Yuchan was cruel to her mother, but comes to realize that may not be true. We also get to know Yuchan’s younger brother, Yujae as each of these four characters writes their own section of the book as a journal.

I was concerned when the book started with a reference to animal torture, but it was used to show how people don’t get punished so I soldiered on…but I stopped for good when the author returned to the animal cruelty and was clearly going to go all in on the details. I can’t read that stuff, so I was done.

That would be enough to make me dislike the book, but it also read to me as the work of some for whom English is not a first language, perhaps? It’s often very stilted and words don’t quite seem to fit. Taking on something like writing a book is a really admirable effort if English is not your strongest language, but you probably should seek some help with the finished product before sending it out to the masses.

The plot just seemed a bit tired and Jiwon’s failure to act was frustrating. So, overall, just not a good read.

[Chiara Carotina · Rating 1 out of 5]

Portare all'interno di un romanzo tematiche come violenza su donne/animali/bambini e ricreare nel testo scene disturbanti non l'ho mai trovato esagerato o sbagliato, ma è corretto farlo solo quando aggiungono qualcosa al racconto e sono funzionali all'evoluzione dei personaggi; altrimenti è solo dolore gratuito che si vuole infliggere al lettore. In un libro di solo 120 pagine mettere tantissime scene di violenza sugli animali non è servito a nulla, ha tolto solo spazio alla costruzione della storia, che infatti risulta piatta e inconcludente.

[Jessie ツ]

SELF NOTE ❌ - Excessive animal cruelty. (see other reviews). Will not be reading, not for me.

One of my only hard stop triggers is animal cruelty, especially to the level it appears in this book (per other reviews).

[STEPH · Rating 3 out of 5]

Vile. This is vile, heartless, and abominable. I went in blind with this one, and it left my mouth gaping, my tears falling, my rage boiling. WTF.

Animal abuse is heavily depicted, so please tread lightly. Even I, who usually doesn’t need trigger warnings, had a hard time getting through some chapters because of the level of cruelty. Truly, humans are the most dangerous and wicked creatures ever. Damn.

On a different note, I liked how the story unraveled. The writing style built anticipation, and I enjoyed it down to the last page.

If you ever decide to pick this up, take a few minutes to breathe beforehand. This is not an easy read.

[Kurryreads (Kerry) · Rating 4 out of 5]

Dark twisted little story. Lots of animal cruelty

https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZTM3347n7/

[Jessica Woodbury · Rating 2 out of 5]

This starts off strong, it reminded me a lot of Kanae Minato's Confessions, a subversive novel that has lots of twists, switches in POV, and is really smart in how it uses shock value. But while this one starts strong, halfway through it loses focus and surprises, turning into something much more limp. When you're going to deploy violence to the extent that Bak does (the animal cruelty here is particularly intense) you need to take the reader somewhere worthwhile so it isn't simply gratuitous. But here it never moves past gratuitous, the shock doesn't serve a purpose.

It isn't nothing to build something up the way Bak does in the first half. But build up doesn't have a point if you don't have somewhere to go.

[Ilaria_ws · Rating 1 out of 5]

Doveva essere un thriller psicologico, una storia di vendetta, ma in realtà si è rivelato una lettura inutile.
Poco approfondito, scritto in modo eccessivamente semplice, pieno zeppo di scene di violenza gratuite che non aggiungono nulla alla storia.
Insomma, una vera delusione.

[Michela · Rating 5 out of 5]

Unpopular opinion alert! ‼️

I bought this exclusively because of the low ratings and joked that I would raise the avg rating once I read it, and I was correct 😅

I read it in one sitting and it got me out of the worst reading slump. I don’t have expectations for thrillers, I don’t really think the genre can blow my mind or surprise me, but I love Korean thrillers, I love the smooth prose, I love the creative structure, and this just kept me interested the whole way through.

Give it a chance if you love Korean lit!

[hans · Rating 4 out of 5]

Bold, wicked and so unsettling. The short blurb really intrigued me and I liked how it was structured in an epistolary style; of letters and journals written from the characters’ POVs uncovering a confession with one’s hidden motive, resentment and the whole backstories of how everything started— from a heinous and triggering crime involving animal cruelty (TW: a warn cause the abuse was explicit and too graphic) to an unexpected incident ended with death that was crafted in a dark and thrilling tale of siblings rivalry, familial dynamics, on revenge, moral ambiguity, guilt and one’s deceit.

The writing was simple and easy to grasp and I liked how its hue of madness and disturbing tone progressed in those compelling annoyance, suspicions and lies thoughout. A full backstory from the tutor and a follow-up twist from the mother to the boy’s revelation; I was too engrossed with their villain-ish and unapologetic characterization that each psycho loathsome felt too twisted and did not falter an inch to make it sounds less unsettling.

Appreciate those insights on animal cruelty part which I get in between the tutor’s POV on her first letter and how both society and law seen and treated most cases with a light punishment. Its lingering aftermath was distressing, none reliable that I could foreseen the ending— felt so absurd to love the read but somehow the idea of ‘if I want to be bad, I should be the worst’ kind of inviting overall. 4.2/5*

(thank you Pansing Distribution for the gifted review copy!)

[Amy ☁️ (tinycl0ud) · Rating 5 out of 5]

I love books where each change in perspective completely alters what we know to be the truth. Each chapter has the narrator asserting a contrasting version of the story. The premise is simple but compelling: a woman enters the home of a wealthy family as a private tutor for the younger of two brothers. She's there to seek revenge for the death of her family, which she believes one of them is responsible for. I'm not going to spoil it so just trust me when I say that I was sat.

I do think a lot about nature vs nurture because I have a toddler and I've heard from both camps. Some people say that psychopaths are born that way, that no amount of correction or parental affection can change a child who is naturally predisposed to torturing and killing small animals or others. I'm not familiar with the science of it, and perhaps yes there is a portion of a person that is fixed/ genetic from the moment they are born, but my sensing is that how a child is socialised has the greatest impact on their behaviour. Not that mothers are 100% responsible for the harm their sons inflict on the world because there are other factors too (the fathers, school environment, peers, legal system), but boy-moms are definitely complicit and we've seen some very recent cases of how they played a role in enabling violence.

[Paul Fulcher · Rating 2 out of 5]

He couldn’t have expected this, either. That his petty lie would become a lethal poisoned needle that would snatch away people’s lives. And more than that, he could never have imagined that the same needle would veer around and hurtle toward himself.

Petty Lies is the translation by Sarah Lyo of 사소한 거짓말 by 박설미 (Sulmi Bak). [The Korean original does not appear to be on Goodreads]

The novel begins with a letter, the chapter titled "I am a Bad Tutor (Mira's letter)" - "나는 나쁜 가정교사입니다(미라의 편지)" - which starts

안녕하세요， 유재 군 어머니
제가 왜 갑자기 어머니께 편지를 썼는지 궁금하실 거라 생각됩니다． 그 이유를 차차 써내려가기 전에， 이 편지의 팔 할은 과외 전에 미리 써놓은 글이라는 걸 알고 계셨으면 합니다．
지금부터는 집중해서 제가 하는 말들을 읽어 내려가야 하실 거예요． 1년 전에 일어났던 일에 대한 얘기를 꺼낼 예정이기 때문입니다．
네， 압니다．
아득히 먼 옛날 일을 지금 와서 굳이 언급하는 이유가 뭘까 생각하고 계시겠죠． 하지만 어제 일처럼 또렷이 기억날 만큼 제게는 무엇보다 중요한 사건이니 아무쪼록 끝까지 이 편지를 읽어주셨으면 합니다.

Hello, Yujae’s mother. I expect you’re wondering why I’ve suddenly written you a letter. Before I give my reasons, I’d like you to know that four-fifths of this letter had already been written by the time I started tutoring your son.
You may need to pay attention from now on as you read my letter, as I’m about to discuss events that happened one year ago.
Yes, I know.
Why now bring up the far-distant past? you’re thinking. But since those events matter more to me than anything else, so much so that I remember them as clearly as if they happened yesterday, I hope you’ll read this letter to the end.

I have deliberately stopped quoting the letter there, as the next paragraph Mira, the tutor, reminds Jiwon, Yujae's mother, of an incident last year where a dog was mutilated, something which seems to have been triggering for many English-language readers judging from reviews. And this may actually speak to a cultural difference which underpins the text, since here two different characters in the novel lament how animal cruelty or even striking a child are regarded as much less seriously that striking an elderly person - I'd say it is the opposite in the UK, where elderly abuse is the forgotten, and underfunded, topic.

Mira reveals in her letter that: the abused dog belonged to her family; the consequences of that abuse extended beyond the animal; her suspect is one of Jiwon's sons; and hence she wormed her way into their home as a tutor planning revenge.

What follows is a series of letters and diary entries and a twisted story involving: Mira; Jiwon and her sons Yujae and Yuchan; some of Yujae's classmates; and Yujae's original tutor, a university alumni of Mira, who helped secure her position.

And however much person A thought they had tricked person B, it turned out that with C's help it was actually B manipulating A to think they'd tricked B. Except in reality C was helping A who knew that B knew they had tricked them ....

It's all a bit reminscent of the my link textBattle of Wits in the Princess Bride, and indeed even involves an odourless, tasteless, deadly poison - although Vizzini in the movie brilliantly managed to have the battle entirely with himself.

VIZZINI: Now, a clever man would put the poison into his own goblet, because he would know that only a great fool would reach for what he was given. I'm not a great fool, so I can clearly not choose the wine in front of you. But you must have known I was not a great fool; you would have counted on it, so I can clearly not choose the wine in front of me.
MAN IN BLACK: You've made your decision then?
VIZZINI: Not remotely. Because iocaine comes from Australia, as everyone knows. And Australia is entirely peopled with criminals. And criminals are used to having people not trust them, as you are not trusted by me. So I can clearly not choose the wine in front of you.
MAN IN BLACK: Truly, you have a dizzying intellect.
VIZZINI: Wait till I get going! Where was I?

And, that scene lasting only a few minutes, this is a similarly quick read.

It's all rather contrived - and the logic of some of the final twists, particularly Jiwon's last card, rather escaped me, which is a problem as a novel like this, so carefully (contrivedly) constructed, does depend heavily on the final revelations.

Thanks to the publisher via Netgalley for the ARC. But I think I fell victim to one of the classic blunders. The most famous is "Never get involved in a land war in Asia." But only slightly less well known is this: "Never read a Korean translation of a book you wouldn't go near in a English original."

[Alexandra · Rating 3 out of 5]

Ada yang pernah baca novel epistolary mystery thriller pendek yang cuma 160 hal ini?
Pertama trigger warning dulu ya, scene menyiksa binatang diceritakan cukup detail. Jadi pembaca yang sensitif bisa skip saja.

Novel ini dibagi dalam 4 bagian surat menyurat yang mengenalkan pembaca pada Mira seorang guru les, Jiwon seorang ibu dari 2 putra yang jenius, pov para anak. Walau buku ini pendek tapi menurutku isu yang diangkat related dengan masalah nyata, diceritakan dengan sangat menarik walau isinya bikin hati terpelintir.

Sebagai orang tua, di masa sekarang ini dengan banyak paparan media yang mengumbar kekerasan dan perilaku sakit jiwa, deteksi dini sangat penting. Kalau kita melihat perilaku anak kita yang meresahkan, minimnya empati dan perasaan lainya... jangan abai. Please...




Thanks to LTIK

[Katie.dorny · Rating 4 out of 5]

an intense thriller novella with unreliable narrators coming at you from every angle

[Meserah Abdullah · Rating 3 out of 5]

An enjoyable quick read for anyone who enjoys thrillers. I liked the character dynamics and found Yujae and Yuchan's opposing personalities interesting. Yujae's disturbed personality and ability to corrupt others was disturbing but believable. His desperation for his mothers attention was a strange motivator, especially as he didn't even want his mothers love but was obsessed with occupying her attention to such a degree. The mothers willingness to cover up her sons psychopathic behaviour including several murders and extensive animal abuse was shocking, particularly considering that he murdered his father and attempted to murder his brother.
Her negligence is ultimately to blame for all of the suffering that occurs in this story.

[unabloggerdilibri · Rating 2 out of 5]

‼️ c’è veramente tanta violenza sugli animali (sui cani in particolare) se siete sensibili lo sconsiglio assolutamente!

e comunque non vi perdete niente di che, non è un thriller.

[totesintobooks · Rating 4 out of 5]

one of the rare times where i’d say do not trust the rating. the animal cruelty descriptions are important part of the storytelling because it shows how desensitised these assailants are and it’s also for readers to contemplate on these acts deeper and understand that the law do work against animals and their protection!!!

[Dave Musson · Rating 2 out of 5]

I just did not connect with this one. The violence against dogs was horrible to read and didn’t add anything to the story, while the characters just seemed too much like fictional characters! The twists were not that impressive either.

Thanks for the publisher and to NetGalley for a review copy.

[Afi (WhatAfiReads) · Rating 4 out of 5]

"You may have not known it would lead to tragedy, but the act of lying was wrong from the start. No matter how petty the lie might have been."

Don't be fooled by the overall ratings because this book had made me questioning my morals and finding myself being emphatic for all the people for the wrong reasons. And honestly, even then, guilt-ridden, you still feel that whatever that was done was somewhat.... justified, even if there's nothing right about the actions.

Honestly, go into this book as blindly as you can - with the premise of it being very simple. Its an exchange of letters between a mother and a tutor, which will make everything slowly unveil. Besides questioning my morals, what I love is how the author highlighted on animal cruelty and the almost non-existent punishment in the face of the law. The harsh reality in the name of justice, animals were tortured solely for pure entertainment for sick people and it angers me, how there are no stricter laws for it.

"You should never turn a blind eye to a willful act. Yet what are things like in reality? .... That's because society is always on the side of the powerful. It is society that favors adults over children, men over women, the wealthy over the poor, humans over animals, and the able-bodied over disabled persons."

And in some ways, I'm vaguely reminded of The Good Son with this book. Not that the plot is anything similar, but the portrayal of the mother-son relationship in this book, and how I truly believe that psychopaths are made from the environment that they grow up in. What pushed the higher ratings for me? Its the smooth way that the author wrote the story that I finished this book in one seating. You're left wondering what's going on and what had happened. The story builds up especially in the way we're somewhat attached to these characters and the author played the power of perception from the reader's pov.

"The worst kind of act isn't done out of ignorance; it's an act that is committed knowingly."

Highly recommended for a short read. Would def remember this book for a long time.

Thank you to Pansing Distributions for the review copy! I truly appreciate it.

4.25 stars overall!

[Lilibet Bombshell · Rating 4 out of 5]

Petty Lies is a novella written in four parts, three of which are in epistolary format from three different people and one a dialogue-free scene done in person with another character at the end. Before I go any further I’m going to issue a huge trigger warning, because I know it’s a hard limit for a lot of people: If you have the slightest issue with reading anything regarding the mistreatment of animals, then you won’t want to go near this book. Trust. I’m not even going to beat around the bush about it.

Mira knows Jiwon’s son is responsible for what happened to her family and insists he has a bad mother. Jiwon contends she had to choose between putting her time and energy into either her genius good son or her bad seed son and laments the choices it has led both she and Mira to make but insists it’s better for everyone involved. Yujae, for his part, lays the blame for everything at everyone’s feet but his own. A consummate malignant narcissist and burgeoning psychopath, the only thing Yujae wants to be responsible for is putting people and creatures in their place (rather, the place he has determined they belong). None of them are good people, all of them are liars, and all of them are criminals.

I’m pretty sure there’s some of this story that’s getting lost in cultural translation, especially as it pertains to familial structure, schooling, dating, social life, and culture, but I still found it entertaining and suspenseful. The horror side of things was lacking for me because it seemed like shock and disgust was what the order of the day was in that area and I’m just not that affected by that kind of horror. What it does a great job of is being a thriller. I really appreciated this as a psychological thriller. 4⭐️


Thanks to Mulholland Books for providing me with a finished copy of this book. All thoughts, opinions, views, and ideas expressed herein are mine and mine alone. Thank you.

File Under: Epistolary/Horror/Novella/Own Voices/Psychological Thriller/Suspense Thriller/Thriller/Translation

[Nina The Wandering Reader · Rating 4 out of 5]

This was fun and twisty! While I understand everyone's comparing this novella to We Need to Talk About Kevin, I feel like it's slightly more similar to Kanae Minato's Confessions.

I loved how the mystery's conclusion would morph based on the alternating character perspectives. A quick, clever, compelling murder mystery.

**Trigger Warning: lots of upsetting animal cruelty and animal death.

[Alessandra · Rating 2 out of 5]

Rivoglio indietro i miei soldi!

[Tessa · Rating 2 out of 5]

Interesting read with some twists and interesting to see different perspectives of the same family
Saying that I just don’t think there’s need to be writing about animal abuse the entire way throughout, it is a central story line which is just unnecessary considering there is multiple murders already in the book. Are these not a strong enough topic ?

[Dima · Rating 5 out of 5]

This reads like a long epistolary novella, rather than a full scale novel. The protagonists are two teenage brothers, their mother, and a young woman in her twenties whose life is deeply affected by the family’s behavior. Each character offers a different perspective on pivotal and tragic events. At its core, this is the story of a disturbed young man with borderline tendencies and a penchant for cruelty. Graphic scenes of violence (including instances of animal cruelty) underscore his warped nature and the devastating impact he has on those around him.

What I especially liked about the story is its twisted plotline. The author’s chosen form allows conflicting perspectives to coexist and contradict one another, gradually revealing the “true” picture of events. I also appreciated the steady accumulation of lies and manipulations, which together reflect human nature in its basest form.

I found some of the other reviews rather strange. I understand that certain readers are particularly sensitive to animal cruelty, but it strikes me as inconsistent that depictions of human abuse and debasement are treated as somehow more acceptable. This book is much more than the single scene some may find disturbing, and its literary value should not be reduced to one plot element—which, in fact, serves a clear purpose in exposing a character’s psychology. It feels disingenuous to dismiss an entire book with a one-star review because of this.

I recommend it to fans of horror, true crime, and books that probe what drives and motivates violence.

My thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

[Lavelle · Rating 4 out of 5]

(CW: graphic depictions of animal abuse)

how far will a mother go to protect her kids, and at what point does that protection turn into harm?

this was a very, very dark, albeit intriguing read. I can't recommend this lightly, but it did give me a lot to think about.

[Nina (Momo)]

I picked this up at an airport book store because grabbing a paperback to entertain one's self while in transit is a time-honored human tradition. Flights are one of the few places nowadays that we are really cut off from the general hubbub of life-post-internet, life-post-smartphone, life-post-5G. During my flight, my airline proudly announced that they would soon have in-flight wifi coverage for all domestic flights, and I realized that very soon -- if not already -- this last little respite will be gone. I suppose there's still long-distance cruises, but I bet they'll have steady wifi soon too. Maybe they already do. I've never been on a cruise.

All this to say, I picked up this book because I was chasing an anachronistic experience, nostalgia not just for an airport book, but for when books were our go-to diversion. When people wrote fretting, concern-trolling screeds about how reading was ruining the youth. When the transit hub was a train station and not an airport. (I suppose it still can be, in countries blessedly lucky enough not to have the extreme car fetish that the US inflicted on itself.)

Unfair as this may be to the author and the translator, the book itself was sort of secondary to the experience. Well, not secondary, no -- the book was definitely central in the "buying and reading a book in transit" experience, but it wasn't central in the way it would be to a regular "picking up a book to read for pleasure" experience. I wanted a book that would be fast, transporting, and perhaps a little bad. Perhaps even very bad, so long as it wasn't so awful that I resented spending money on it. That was another key factor: it had to be cheap enough to feel casual. And it had to be a paperback. I essentially wanted something pulp, something to light up my brain a bit and then make me a bit embarrassed to have read it. Something I could shrug and say, "it was an airport read."

Was this that book? Hard to say. It was a quick read. It was relatively cheap. It was a paperback. It was twisty and punchy enough to be engaging. The violence against animals was a bit more than I wanted from an airport read, though. In fact, it was a lot more. The reflections on motherhood didn't feel fully married to the ideas about cruelty to animals, and (unfair as this may be on my part!) I didn't want to reflect on these themes too much while I was reading. I mostly wanted a diversion. Still, I was interested until the end, and it gave me something to talk about on the car ride home from the airport.

So, would I recommend this book? If you like crime fiction or stories with serial killers, it might be good for you. (There isn't a serial killer in this book, but the cruelty to animals seems like the kind of thing you might get in that sort of crime fiction, so maybe you'd have more of a stomach for it.) It is very short, but I don't know if it was an ideal airport read.

And yet, maybe my vague disappointment after reading it is just right. It was very fun to search for it at the little airport bookshop, to select it out from all the others, and then to hold it, turning these pages and not having to worry about it running out of battery. Next time I have a flight, I'd like to buy another.

[Queralt✨ · Rating 2 out of 5]

Petty Lies is an epistolary novel in which a woman worms her way into a wealthy household because she suspects the son mutilated her dog. The style and overall vibe reminded me of Kanae Minato’s Confessions and Penance: dark, epistolary, full of twists, and driven by vengeance. That said, I didn’t find it as engaging to read. I think I didn’t like the characters very much, so I didn’t care about the kid, the mother, the other mother, etc.

I’ve seen some reviews giving this book a bad rating because of the animal abuse, which is fair. I think there’s a cultural aspect there worth mentioning, because after living in Korea for a few years, I don’t think pets or dogs are regarded in the same way in general (i.e., as family members). What bothered me more, though, were the comments on and depiction of autism. The kid is portrayed as “fucked up,” and this seems to be linked to his possibly being on the spectrum. There are lines like “abnormal people don’t feel guilt” and other similarly brilliant comments (and, really, calling someone who is allegedly on the spectrum “abnormal” is… a choice).

Anyway, the book made me mad, and it was too similar to Kanae Minato’s books for me to be wowed by anything. The elements added to shock the reader didn’t really have much of an effect on me either because at the end of it, I felt the book was just trying to make the reader mad (animal abuse, violence against women, misogynistic shit, ableism…).

[Rainie 🎧 · Rating 4 out of 5]

Actual rating: 3.5 stars

I read this in one sitting. It’s intriguing and sucks you right in with the letters going back and forth, unravelling one plot twist after another. You feel both sick and sorry for the characters, especially the children. Human beings are selfish, twisted, yet fundamentally afraid of not being seen, being alone, and of their loved ones leaving.

Overall, it is heavy and it’s a lot to take in, emotionally. Strongly not recommended if you’re against / squeamish with animal abuse.

[Joe Parsons · Rating 5 out of 5]

Loved this! Moral of the story: nothing good ever comes from killing dogs.

[Julia Lewis · Rating 1 out of 5]

The first few pages made me not want to read any further. Do we really need that many examples of how a person could murder an animal? No thanks.