What do you think?
Rate this book
Shadow Reaper
Not yet published
Expected 2 Jun 26NEVER BARGAIN WITH A REAPER.
The city of Aravell is in peril, plagued by a deadly blackmist that kills all it touches, and reapers who roam the streets, stealing magic from innocent children in their thirst for power. Seventeen-year-old Viridia Solace has trained for years to hunt these reapers but their ranks keep growing, led by the man who murdered her parents: the Reaper Priest.
When the Priest's most loyal follower, Reeve Ashton, is captured, he offers Viri a chance to avenge her parents . . . for a price. She knows better than to bargain with a reaper, let alone this reaper, but his offer is too good to resist.
Soon she's breaking him out of prison, colluding with his crew of magic thieves, and following him deep into the blackmist forest in search of an ancient legend, all so they can stop the Reaper Priest’s plot to doom the city. Viri is staking her life on Reeve's plan, but how can she trust a silver-tongued criminal to keep his word? And how can she trust her own heart when a buried secret could shatter everything?
The city of Aravell is in peril, plagued by a deadly blackmist that kills all it touches, and reapers who roam the streets, stealing magic from innocent children in their thirst for power. Seventeen-year-old Viridia Solace has trained for years to hunt these reapers but their ranks keep growing, led by the man who murdered her parents: the Reaper Priest.
When the Priest's most loyal follower, Reeve Ashton, is captured, he offers Viri a chance to avenge her parents . . . for a price. She knows better than to bargain with a reaper, let alone this reaper, but his offer is too good to resist.
Soon she's breaking him out of prison, colluding with his crew of magic thieves, and following him deep into the blackmist forest in search of an ancient legend, all so they can stop the Reaper Priest’s plot to doom the city. Viri is staking her life on Reeve's plan, but how can she trust a silver-tongued criminal to keep his word? And how can she trust her own heart when a buried secret could shatter everything?
Trade Paperback
Expected publication June 16, 2026
31 people are currently reading
2256 people want to read
About the author
Lynette Noni
33 books8,849 followersAustralian author Lynette Noni studied journalism, academic writing, and human behaviour at university before venturing into the world of fiction. She is the #1 bestselling and award-winning author of THE PRISON HEALER series, THE MEDORAN CHRONICLES, and the WHISPER duology. To date, her books have sold more than one million copies in over 20 countries across the globe.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 50 reviews
January 18, 2026
update: ITS CHILDHOOD FRIENDS TO LOVERS WTHH 😭😭😭💔💔💔
—————
ignore me while i scream into the void real quick.
AAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHH
—————
ignore me while i scream into the void real quick.
AAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHH
unreleased
August 1, 2025🚨 NEW LYNETTE NONI FANTASY SERIES ALERT 🚨
i am beyond hyped, folks! give it to me now!
i am beyond hyped, folks! give it to me now!
Want to read
July 22, 2025Lynette Noni can probably hear me screaming my excitement for this book all the way in Australia (I live on the other side of the planet)🫶
arc-tbr
January 7, 2026Ahhhh! Need this now!
“dark YA pitched as SHADOW AND BONE meets The Vampire Diaries (sans vampires), about a young reaper hunter who must conspire with her childhood friend-turned-mortal enemy and his crew of illegal magic thieves to stop a deadly foe from a plot to steal untold power-and doom their world”
“dark YA pitched as SHADOW AND BONE meets The Vampire Diaries (sans vampires), about a young reaper hunter who must conspire with her childhood friend-turned-mortal enemy and his crew of illegal magic thieves to stop a deadly foe from a plot to steal untold power-and doom their world”
January 18, 2026
OH. MY. GOSH.
You would think that after reading 12, TWELVE, books by Lynette Noni then I couldn’t be surprised by her plot twists. Well you are wrong, BECAUSE I WAS SURPRISED. IN FACT IM IN DISBELIEF. BECAUSE WHAT?! I honestly feel so stupid and now I absolutely NEED to reread this book and see the foreshadowing moments because I KNOW THEY ARE THERE. Okay now time for the actual review, but first we have to back this up.
When Shadow Reaper was announced it quickly became my most anticipated read of 2026. Not only because Lynette Noni is my favorite author but also because it sounded SO INTERESTING. So I am not kidding when I say that I CRIED getting an email saying I got approved for the arc and I am also not kidding when I say that I dropped absolutely everything for this book and I am so glad I did BECAUSE OH MY GOSH.
This book not only met my very high expectations but it EXCEEDED THEM. I was so immersed into the world of Elverdine Isle to the point where time actually had no meaning. When I say that I was obsessed, I WAS OBSESSED. Every waking moment for the past three days has been spent reading this book. In addition to the world, Lynette Noni also delivered on the characters that you just can’t help but loving. Like tell me why I knew Reeve for one page but I already loved him as if I had known him for 100 pages. I EVEN LOVED A FREAKING BUNNY(dare I say the best part of the book). Lastly, as I said previously, this book did not HOLD BACK WITH THE PLOT TWISTS. The ending shook me to my core and I don’t think I’ll ever be the same. I might even dare to say that this plot twist was crazier than the one in the prison healer(and trust me, that is saying something). I should probably stop yapping now but just remember
“Never Bargain with a Reaper.”
THANK YOU SO MUCH TO NETGALLEY AND THE PUBLISHERS FOR GIFTING ME THIS ARC! It truly meant the world to me😭
You would think that after reading 12, TWELVE, books by Lynette Noni then I couldn’t be surprised by her plot twists. Well you are wrong, BECAUSE I WAS SURPRISED. IN FACT IM IN DISBELIEF. BECAUSE WHAT?! I honestly feel so stupid and now I absolutely NEED to reread this book and see the foreshadowing moments because I KNOW THEY ARE THERE. Okay now time for the actual review, but first we have to back this up.
When Shadow Reaper was announced it quickly became my most anticipated read of 2026. Not only because Lynette Noni is my favorite author but also because it sounded SO INTERESTING. So I am not kidding when I say that I CRIED getting an email saying I got approved for the arc and I am also not kidding when I say that I dropped absolutely everything for this book and I am so glad I did BECAUSE OH MY GOSH.
This book not only met my very high expectations but it EXCEEDED THEM. I was so immersed into the world of Elverdine Isle to the point where time actually had no meaning. When I say that I was obsessed, I WAS OBSESSED. Every waking moment for the past three days has been spent reading this book. In addition to the world, Lynette Noni also delivered on the characters that you just can’t help but loving. Like tell me why I knew Reeve for one page but I already loved him as if I had known him for 100 pages. I EVEN LOVED A FREAKING BUNNY(dare I say the best part of the book). Lastly, as I said previously, this book did not HOLD BACK WITH THE PLOT TWISTS. The ending shook me to my core and I don’t think I’ll ever be the same. I might even dare to say that this plot twist was crazier than the one in the prison healer(and trust me, that is saying something). I should probably stop yapping now but just remember
“Never Bargain with a Reaper.”
THANK YOU SO MUCH TO NETGALLEY AND THE PUBLISHERS FOR GIFTING ME THIS ARC! It truly meant the world to me😭
January 18, 2026
4.5⭐️
thank you so much netgalley for this arc!!
this book was one of, if not my #1, most anticipated read of 2026 and let me tell you, IT DID NOT DISAPPOINT 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
prison healer is one of my favorite trilogies ever so i have been SOOOO excited for new book by her!!!!
there were so many genuinely good plot twists, and the banter between viri and reeve was chef's kiss 🤌🏻
this book had my jaw on the floor one minute and then had me tearing up the next
i CAN'T WAIT for book 2
thank you so much netgalley for this arc!!
this book was one of, if not my #1, most anticipated read of 2026 and let me tell you, IT DID NOT DISAPPOINT 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
prison healer is one of my favorite trilogies ever so i have been SOOOO excited for new book by her!!!!
there were so many genuinely good plot twists, and the banter between viri and reeve was chef's kiss 🤌🏻
this book had my jaw on the floor one minute and then had me tearing up the next
i CAN'T WAIT for book 2
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Lynette Noni does it again! 𝘚𝘩𝘢𝘥𝘰𝘸 𝘙𝘦𝘢𝘱𝘦𝘳 is an explosive young adult duology opener full of twists and turns, magical adventure, and charming romance.
Viridia hunts reapers in her quest for revenge, desperate to locate the Reaper Priest responsible for her parents' deaths. When his comrade, Reeve, is captured, she risks a dangerous bargain to gain access to the murderer. As conflicting feelings develop for Reeve, her former childhood friend, and a world-ending conspiracy is discovered, she'll have to decide who to trust - and learn how to trust herself.
Noni is the queen of crafting charming young adult fantasy with characters so lovely and full of life that they jump out of the pages. I instantly adored the cast of characters, and the found family elements are beautifully penned.
Viri is a compelling character whose backstory is tragic and plays a large role in her empowering growth. Reeve's confidence is rather endearing, especially as his body language reveals care for Viri. He's alluring and fierce yet sweet and gentle, and his sense of humor had me laughing out loud. Viri and Reeve's dynamic was addictive, and their story should be the blueprint for the he falls first trope! The friendships are heartwarming, and there's even an adorable fluffy sidekick!
𝘚𝘩𝘢𝘥𝘰𝘸 𝘙𝘦𝘢𝘱𝘦𝘳 is magical and filled to the brim with addictive wanderlust. It's a book you'll stay up all night devouring because you can't put it down, and once you finish, you'll be up all night pondering the gut-wrenching cliffhanger. Lynette Noni will be holding me captive until the sequel is in my hands - I am desperate to see what happens next!
Thank you to NetGalley and Random House for the advance reading copy!
Viridia hunts reapers in her quest for revenge, desperate to locate the Reaper Priest responsible for her parents' deaths. When his comrade, Reeve, is captured, she risks a dangerous bargain to gain access to the murderer. As conflicting feelings develop for Reeve, her former childhood friend, and a world-ending conspiracy is discovered, she'll have to decide who to trust - and learn how to trust herself.
Noni is the queen of crafting charming young adult fantasy with characters so lovely and full of life that they jump out of the pages. I instantly adored the cast of characters, and the found family elements are beautifully penned.
Viri is a compelling character whose backstory is tragic and plays a large role in her empowering growth. Reeve's confidence is rather endearing, especially as his body language reveals care for Viri. He's alluring and fierce yet sweet and gentle, and his sense of humor had me laughing out loud. Viri and Reeve's dynamic was addictive, and their story should be the blueprint for the he falls first trope! The friendships are heartwarming, and there's even an adorable fluffy sidekick!
𝘚𝘩𝘢𝘥𝘰𝘸 𝘙𝘦𝘢𝘱𝘦𝘳 is magical and filled to the brim with addictive wanderlust. It's a book you'll stay up all night devouring because you can't put it down, and once you finish, you'll be up all night pondering the gut-wrenching cliffhanger. Lynette Noni will be holding me captive until the sequel is in my hands - I am desperate to see what happens next!
Thank you to NetGalley and Random House for the advance reading copy!
Want to read
July 25, 2025A whole new ya fantasy series by Lynette Noni?? Oh I am SO ready
"The story follows a young reaper hunter who must conspire with her childhood friend turned mortal enemy and his crew of illegal magic thieves to stop a deadly foe from steaing untold power ─ and dooming their World!"
"The story follows a young reaper hunter who must conspire with her childhood friend turned mortal enemy and his crew of illegal magic thieves to stop a deadly foe from steaing untold power ─ and dooming their World!"
November 27, 2025
I never review things but I managed to snag a proof at YALC. So it deserves a review.
friends-> enemies -> lovers
It was really easy to read, the world building was really compelling but easy to understand and follow. kinda gave me RWBY vibes with the hunters and the artifacts.
There are so many lovable characters and I will be honest for the first half of the book I definitely prefer some of the side characters to the main protag, but she found her feet as the book went along.
Also would die for walnut just saying.
The story kept me engaged and the more I read the harder it was to put down. I did not expect the ending...well.. did one bit but not the reveal at the end. usually, I am pretty good at guessing, so it did catch me off guard.
now I need to wait like 2 years for the next one 😭😭
friends-> enemies -> lovers
It was really easy to read, the world building was really compelling but easy to understand and follow. kinda gave me RWBY vibes with the hunters and the artifacts.
There are so many lovable characters and I will be honest for the first half of the book I definitely prefer some of the side characters to the main protag, but she found her feet as the book went along.
Also would die for walnut just saying.
The story kept me engaged and the more I read the harder it was to put down. I did not expect the ending...well.. did one bit but not the reveal at the end. usually, I am pretty good at guessing, so it did catch me off guard.
now I need to wait like 2 years for the next one 😭😭
January 21, 2026
Shadow Reaper by Lynette Noni
Release Date:June 2nd
Rating:⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Age rating:15+
Spice:none
Thank you Netgalley and Lynette Noni for this arc! YALL. Oh. My. Gosh. This book was absolutely insane. The world and magic system is so unique, and kept me captivated the whole time. I read this book in three sittings, it just completely took over my mind, and I had to know what happened next. Viri is such a good fmc. I fully enjoyed my time in her pov. I wanted to learn everything about her, and just love her so much. And Reeve *giggles like a mad woman*, Reeve is such a good mmc. I fell in love instantly, and every time he was in the page I was falling more for him. The banter between the two of them was SO GOOD! And the tension was just magnificent. I also loved how they both have so many layers, they’re like onions in a way, and each layer we peeled back had me connecting to them even more. And the PLOT WAS SUCH A PLOT! And THE TURNS AND TWISTS AND JUST EVERYTHING! The ending truly had me staring at the acknowledgments, as if waiting for more to magically appear. I most definitely recommend this book, and look forward to the sequel.
Release Date:June 2nd
Rating:⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Age rating:15+
Spice:none
Thank you Netgalley and Lynette Noni for this arc! YALL. Oh. My. Gosh. This book was absolutely insane. The world and magic system is so unique, and kept me captivated the whole time. I read this book in three sittings, it just completely took over my mind, and I had to know what happened next. Viri is such a good fmc. I fully enjoyed my time in her pov. I wanted to learn everything about her, and just love her so much. And Reeve *giggles like a mad woman*, Reeve is such a good mmc. I fell in love instantly, and every time he was in the page I was falling more for him. The banter between the two of them was SO GOOD! And the tension was just magnificent. I also loved how they both have so many layers, they’re like onions in a way, and each layer we peeled back had me connecting to them even more. And the PLOT WAS SUCH A PLOT! And THE TURNS AND TWISTS AND JUST EVERYTHING! The ending truly had me staring at the acknowledgments, as if waiting for more to magically appear. I most definitely recommend this book, and look forward to the sequel.
January 5, 2026
Shadow Reaper by Lynette Noni
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 4 stars
This was such a fun read! From the very first page, I was hooked. Viri is the kind of FMC who immediately pulls you in; her story is captivating and her spirit is impossible not to root for. The world Lynette Noni has built is both fun and intriguing, with fierce hunters, mysterious reapers, a while host of magical lore that left me desperate to know more.
🥹 Found Family:
The best part of this story, the bit that truly stole my heart, was the found family vibe. Viri’s unexpected gang of friends and reluctant allies is the kind of crew you’d give anything to be part of- loyal, chaotic, and endlessly endearing.
👏 Plot:
This book is a rollercoaster of twists and turns. Some I smugly thought I saw coming… others blindsided me completely. And that ending? Lynette, how could you?? The first book isn’t even officially out yet and I already need my hands on book two!
❤️ Romance:
Then there’s Viri and Reeve. The perfect duo. Their banter sparkles with attraction, wit, and charm. I fell hard for Reeve's cocky charisma (as did Viri, though she’ll never admit it). I’ve already saved so many of their quotes because they’re just that good.
Verdict: Shadow Reaper is everything I want in a YA fantasy- immersive worldbuilding, a heroine you can’t help but cheer for, a found family you can't help smile around, and a duo whose chemistry lights up every page. This is a series I’ll be obsessing over for a long time.
A big thank you to House of YA and Lynette Noni for providing me an ARC of this book!
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 4 stars
This was such a fun read! From the very first page, I was hooked. Viri is the kind of FMC who immediately pulls you in; her story is captivating and her spirit is impossible not to root for. The world Lynette Noni has built is both fun and intriguing, with fierce hunters, mysterious reapers, a while host of magical lore that left me desperate to know more.
🥹 Found Family:
The best part of this story, the bit that truly stole my heart, was the found family vibe. Viri’s unexpected gang of friends and reluctant allies is the kind of crew you’d give anything to be part of- loyal, chaotic, and endlessly endearing.
👏 Plot:
This book is a rollercoaster of twists and turns. Some I smugly thought I saw coming… others blindsided me completely. And that ending? Lynette, how could you?? The first book isn’t even officially out yet and I already need my hands on book two!
❤️ Romance:
Then there’s Viri and Reeve. The perfect duo. Their banter sparkles with attraction, wit, and charm. I fell hard for Reeve's cocky charisma (as did Viri, though she’ll never admit it). I’ve already saved so many of their quotes because they’re just that good.
Verdict: Shadow Reaper is everything I want in a YA fantasy- immersive worldbuilding, a heroine you can’t help but cheer for, a found family you can't help smile around, and a duo whose chemistry lights up every page. This is a series I’ll be obsessing over for a long time.
A big thank you to House of YA and Lynette Noni for providing me an ARC of this book!
January 19, 2026
ARC Reader Book Review 🤍
⭐️⭐️⭐️
The first half wasn’t my fave. I felt like it just dragged so long and I wasn’t connecting w/ any of the characters as much…
But there was def a turn around in the second half. Was it a substantial turn around? So-So.
I do think the plot has potential though. I just wasn’t super immersed as I wanted to be.
Overall, if the first half isn’t for you (like me), def try to push through to the second half ‘cause I def felt like it picked up more and the ending!!
I love a good twist.
⭐️⭐️⭐️
The first half wasn’t my fave. I felt like it just dragged so long and I wasn’t connecting w/ any of the characters as much…
But there was def a turn around in the second half. Was it a substantial turn around? So-So.
I do think the plot has potential though. I just wasn’t super immersed as I wanted to be.
Overall, if the first half isn’t for you (like me), def try to push through to the second half ‘cause I def felt like it picked up more and the ending!!
I love a good twist.
Want to read
July 31, 2025I’d sell my best friend(s) to read this book NOW
Want to read
August 1, 2025Has me on chokehold 🤪
Want to read
January 15, 2026A VERY exciting ARC!!!
Want to read
January 18, 2026waiting impatiently for the release date.
arcs
January 15, 2026just got the arc, this is the best day ever
Want to read
July 28, 2025*fell to my knees* I'm so excited!!
December 22, 2025
MY JAW IS ON THE FLOOR!!!!!
The most captivating, magically charged, chemistry infused, banter filled, gut wrenching YA Fantasy that I've read in a long time!!!
Topped with a cliff hanger that will set your teeth on edge with so many twists and turns that you are glued to the page!!!
" No matter how dark the shadows seem, you'll never be alone in them. I promise. "
I was thrown head first into this world from the get go, the pacing - perfect! The characters, the plot, the magic system!!! All completely spot on!! I had such a hard time putting this down, that for days I was up till the early hours of the morning reading - pfft sleep .. not needed.
It was clear to me from the very start that this was going to be one of my favourite reads this year. The world building and unique magic system were both key elements that I found highly enjoyable and very easy to get lost in the world Lynette has created.
This is a YA Fantasy ( first in a duology ) - BUT its definitely on the darker and more mature side in terms of the creatures and magic used. No spice - which I love! Don't get me wrong, I have nothing against spice in a book. The way Lynette writes though, there is just no need for it. The story line is incredibly strong and unique on its own and she has a beautiful way of weaving pure chemistry between characters that doesn't feel the need to rely on any spicy romance especially since the main characters are between 17yrs - 22yrs. The entire story is clean, well executed and packed full of tension both between characters and storyline. The pacing between each scene is so fluid, it doesn't feel rushed nor does it feel dragging. I was captivated the entire time, chasing each new revelation.
" You can lie to yourself all you want, Little Shadow, but the next time you ask me to kiss you, we both know it'll be because you want it as much as I do."
STORYLINE
At 17years old, Viri is one of the youngest and most revered Hunters in the city. She along with other Hunters and city gaurds called the Nox, protect the city from Reapers - A person who siphons magic from another, enhancing their senses, speed, strength, healing and longer lifespans with their stolen magic. After the most reknown Reaper Priest kills her parents when she was just 11, Viri vows to hunt him down and exact her revenge.. but when his right hand man gets himself caught and thrown in the Noxs magically warded underground jail cell - the one and only person he will agree to talk to is Viri. Breaking almost every rule known to Hunter and Nox alike, Viri knows this could be her one shot at getting close to the Reaper Priest she has been hunting for 7 years, and she has a lot of questions. But when she finally sees the Reaper Priests second in charge, he offers her a bargain she knows she shouldn't take - His freedom for the answers she so desperately craves.
Characters
FMC - Viridia Solace ( Viri )
I found it very easy to love and admire the stength Viri exuded. Surviving such a broken past, she wasn't the kind of girl to be a victim. She had strengths AND weaknesses. There is nothing worse that having a female main character that is perfect at everything, there needs to be some grit and flaws that grounds them as a person, things they can overcome on multiple different levels and this is exactly what Viri offered. I appreciated the way I was privy to her internal struggles and her thought process, how she came to decisions and not every decision was correct. I also loved her relationship with her bestfriend Wynter. It felt fun and light with the under current of seriousness. Pure acceptance of each other and even with a difference of opinion, the respect and complete trust they both shared.
I find a lot of Lynette Nonis side characters offer very unique, loveable and relatable qualities that speak to very strong found family connections that you can't help but fall in love with.
MMC - Reeve
I loved this character the moment he came into the story. His overly confident attitude that held just a hint of cockiness with the full effect of knowing he was in complete control of every room he occupied. That sureness of himself that just exuded clarity without being overbearing in a suffocating kind of way. The familiarity that he toyed with Viri and the banter he so easily pulled from her, coupled with the fierceness in which he protected her. From the very start he has been my favorite character and I can't wait to see where book two fleshes out his story a bit more!!! That cliffhanger had me gagged!!
Side Character - Jonas
Another side character that I just LOVE!!! And yes I know I say that a lot! I did tell you already, all of Lynettes Side characters are top tier. When I picture Jonas, I envision him like a younger Milo from the Disney movie Atlantis, except he has an adorable bunny he takes with him everywhere! More so the personality characteristics than the physical appearance. Jonas is incredibly smart, equal parts eager and humble to learn and explore magic, a bit timid and fiercely loyal. We loveeeeee Jonas and of course his bunny Walnut!
I don't want to go to much further into more side characters or villains as I don't want to give away any spoilers !! And trust me.. you want to ride this roller-coaster!!
The Magic System -
This was very intriguing and highly captivating, yet easy to understand. Babies are born with a kernal of magic that grows then peaks around the age of 14, children are then encouraged to surrender their magic to one of 4 Obelisk's in the corners of the city of Aravell which fuel the magic into warding the city, stopping the life threatening Blackmist from seeping across the boarders. After sacrificing their magic for the greater good, people are left with a small kernal of magic that is tied to their life force, if children don't sacrifice their magic by the age of 14 they risk their magic growing too much and causing a burn out resulting in death or mindless existence. Because of the large amounts of magic flowing through the children's bodies, they have become the largest target for the Reapers who are addicted to syphoning magic. When children start disappearing without a trace Viri knows undoubtedly its the Reaper Priest she has been hunting and vows to do whatever it takes, whatever the price to stop him.
Tropes include -
• Strong Found Family
• Childhood friends to Enemys to something not defined but the chemistry is scorching!
• He falls first
• So much banter!
• Jail Breaks / Heists and a dangerous forbidden forest style Journey.
• Forced Proximity
Thank you so very much to Lynette Noni, Bec & Penguin Books Australia for sending me this incredible book!! It really has been one of my favourite reads all year and I am very excited to see it on shelves for its release in June!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
“Time to choose, Little Shadow. Will you bargain with a reaper?”
︵‿︵‿୨✧₊⊹☆⊹₊✧୧‿︵‿︵
~ 𝒇𝒆𝒂𝒕𝒖𝒓𝒆𝒔 ~
✨ third person pov
✨ forbidden romance
✨ childhood friends to enemies
︵‿︵‿୨✧₊⊹☆⊹₊✧୧‿︵‿︵
~ 𝒐𝒗𝒆𝒓𝒂𝒍𝒍 𝒕𝒉𝒐𝒖𝒈𝒉𝒕𝒔 ~
I loved every second of Shadow Reaper, it just might be my new obsession and I was already pretty hyped about it going in. The way in which Lynette Noni writes is just downright addictive. The cast of characters are instant favorites with lovable personalities and riveting backstories. The turns are extra twisty in that it absolutely sent me spiraling with just how downright heart-stopping dramatic they can be. It’s truly a whirlwind that really takes the story to the next level and shifting dynamics; it has me dying for the sequel.
~ 𝒕𝒉𝒆 𝒘𝒓𝒊𝒕𝒊𝒏𝒈 + 𝒔𝒕𝒐𝒓𝒚 ~
The plot is incredibly well-paced and balanced throughout. It never really hits a lull nor does it feel like too much is happening all at once. While the story does have slightly familiar elements, it wouldn’t be too farfetched to swap in reapers for vampires for instance, but Noni adds her own unique spin on common tropes that really elevated them.
Without a doubt Lynette Noni knows how to craft an insane clever twist, it will have readers just eating it up because of how well she subverts expectations. The cliff-hanger and the tension of the very last page is so crazy that it’s almost criminal in which Noni leaves the reader hanging for more.
~ 𝒕𝒉𝒆 𝒄𝒉𝒂𝒓𝒂𝒄𝒕𝒆𝒓𝒔 ~
⟢ viridia solace ⟢
I found Viri to be such a fascinating heroine with her determined and fierce attitude. Plus her weapon is reminiscent of Wonder Woman’s lasso of truth which definitely adds some cool points. She goes through so much that if I was in her shoes I would just need a very long break, but Viri instead pushes forward. At the start she’s in her very much justified female rage mindset that was fueled by her grief to her slowly discovering that her beliefs and what she thinks she knows are now being challenged. Viri is far from perfect, but she’s ever evolving as she unpacks all her trauma and while she can be strong-headed, it’s not to point where’s unable to admit when she has made mistakes and her heart is always in the right place.
⟢ reeve ashton ⟢
Reeve is definitely one of the highlights, he’s (very) confident and oh so charming that you can’t help but fall for him as a character. He has such a twinkle in the eye kind of humor, that makes almost all his lines golden. Technically he’s presented as a red flag, but as the layers are slowly being peeled back he’s very sweet and has a lot of hidden green flags. There’s still a lot to puzzle out about him and I look forward to learning more about him in the sequel.
~ 𝒕𝒉𝒆 𝒓𝒐𝒎𝒂𝒏𝒄𝒆 ~
The dynamics between Viri and Reeve is so deeply complicated with them being childhood friends to them now being enemies given their respective reputations as hunter and reaper. The building romantic tension and angst between the pair is just sooo satisfying with forced proximity thrown in the mix as they find themselves working together. Plus their banter was just so much fun to read and I can feel the sparkles flying with every interaction.
What really made the romance shine is that Reeve and Viri are often going through different situations together and while they’re no longer the kids they were seven years ago, their shared moments show that sparks of that bond still haven't fizzled out. There's some inst-attraction with them not seeing each other after years, but it doesn’t overpower or render their chemistry to being just shallow and revolving around lust. This is in part thanks to their shared history that further adds some layers to their relationship.
While it's not the slowest of burns out there, there’s some build-up with Viri slowly warming up to Reeve as she finds herself second-guessing herself and trying to compartmentalize what she thinks she knows about the current Reeve and the actions she is actually seeing with her own eyes. Their relationship doesn’t suddenly just jump to them confessing their undying love for each, it’s very much about Viri learning to trust again. There are subtle moments where I can see their romantic connection starting to blossom as it takes root with them growing closer again on a deeper level.
˚ʚ♡ɞ˚𝑡ℎ𝑎𝑛𝑘 𝑦𝑜𝑢 𝑡𝑜 𝑅𝑎𝑛𝑑𝑜𝑚 𝐻𝑜𝑢𝑠𝑒 𝐶ℎ𝑖𝑙𝑑𝑟𝑒𝑛'𝑠 𝐵𝑜𝑜𝑘𝑠 𝑓𝑜𝑟 𝑡ℎ𝑒 𝑎𝑟𝑐˚ʚ♡ɞ˚
︵‿︵‿୨✧₊⊹☆⊹₊✧୧‿︵‿︵
~ 𝒇𝒆𝒂𝒕𝒖𝒓𝒆𝒔 ~
✨ third person pov
✨ forbidden romance
✨ childhood friends to enemies
︵‿︵‿୨✧₊⊹☆⊹₊✧୧‿︵‿︵
~ 𝒐𝒗𝒆𝒓𝒂𝒍𝒍 𝒕𝒉𝒐𝒖𝒈𝒉𝒕𝒔 ~
I loved every second of Shadow Reaper, it just might be my new obsession and I was already pretty hyped about it going in. The way in which Lynette Noni writes is just downright addictive. The cast of characters are instant favorites with lovable personalities and riveting backstories. The turns are extra twisty in that it absolutely sent me spiraling with just how downright heart-stopping dramatic they can be. It’s truly a whirlwind that really takes the story to the next level and shifting dynamics; it has me dying for the sequel.
~ 𝒕𝒉𝒆 𝒘𝒓𝒊𝒕𝒊𝒏𝒈 + 𝒔𝒕𝒐𝒓𝒚 ~
The plot is incredibly well-paced and balanced throughout. It never really hits a lull nor does it feel like too much is happening all at once. While the story does have slightly familiar elements, it wouldn’t be too farfetched to swap in reapers for vampires for instance, but Noni adds her own unique spin on common tropes that really elevated them.
Without a doubt Lynette Noni knows how to craft an insane clever twist, it will have readers just eating it up because of how well she subverts expectations. The cliff-hanger and the tension of the very last page is so crazy that it’s almost criminal in which Noni leaves the reader hanging for more.
~ 𝒕𝒉𝒆 𝒄𝒉𝒂𝒓𝒂𝒄𝒕𝒆𝒓𝒔 ~
⟢ viridia solace ⟢
I found Viri to be such a fascinating heroine with her determined and fierce attitude. Plus her weapon is reminiscent of Wonder Woman’s lasso of truth which definitely adds some cool points. She goes through so much that if I was in her shoes I would just need a very long break, but Viri instead pushes forward. At the start she’s in her very much justified female rage mindset that was fueled by her grief to her slowly discovering that her beliefs and what she thinks she knows are now being challenged. Viri is far from perfect, but she’s ever evolving as she unpacks all her trauma and while she can be strong-headed, it’s not to point where’s unable to admit when she has made mistakes and her heart is always in the right place.
⟢ reeve ashton ⟢
Reeve is definitely one of the highlights, he’s (very) confident and oh so charming that you can’t help but fall for him as a character. He has such a twinkle in the eye kind of humor, that makes almost all his lines golden. Technically he’s presented as a red flag, but as the layers are slowly being peeled back he’s very sweet and has a lot of hidden green flags. There’s still a lot to puzzle out about him and I look forward to learning more about him in the sequel.
~ 𝒕𝒉𝒆 𝒓𝒐𝒎𝒂𝒏𝒄𝒆 ~
The dynamics between Viri and Reeve is so deeply complicated with them being childhood friends to them now being enemies given their respective reputations as hunter and reaper. The building romantic tension and angst between the pair is just sooo satisfying with forced proximity thrown in the mix as they find themselves working together. Plus their banter was just so much fun to read and I can feel the sparkles flying with every interaction.
What really made the romance shine is that Reeve and Viri are often going through different situations together and while they’re no longer the kids they were seven years ago, their shared moments show that sparks of that bond still haven't fizzled out. There's some inst-attraction with them not seeing each other after years, but it doesn’t overpower or render their chemistry to being just shallow and revolving around lust. This is in part thanks to their shared history that further adds some layers to their relationship.
While it's not the slowest of burns out there, there’s some build-up with Viri slowly warming up to Reeve as she finds herself second-guessing herself and trying to compartmentalize what she thinks she knows about the current Reeve and the actions she is actually seeing with her own eyes. Their relationship doesn’t suddenly just jump to them confessing their undying love for each, it’s very much about Viri learning to trust again. There are subtle moments where I can see their romantic connection starting to blossom as it takes root with them growing closer again on a deeper level.
˚ʚ♡ɞ˚𝑡ℎ𝑎𝑛𝑘 𝑦𝑜𝑢 𝑡𝑜 𝑅𝑎𝑛𝑑𝑜𝑚 𝐻𝑜𝑢𝑠𝑒 𝐶ℎ𝑖𝑙𝑑𝑟𝑒𝑛'𝑠 𝐵𝑜𝑜𝑘𝑠 𝑓𝑜𝑟 𝑡ℎ𝑒 𝑎𝑟𝑐˚ʚ♡ɞ˚
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Shadow Reaper by Lynette Noni reminded me exactly why I fell in love with her writing in the first place. After finishing my ARC through NetGalley, I can honestly say I missed her storytelling more than I realized. I adored The Prison Healer trilogy, and this book gave me that same feeling—sharp twists, layered characters, and a plot that never stops moving. Shadow Reaper absolutely did not disappoint.
Set in the dangerous city of Aravell, where blackmist kills on contact and reapers steal magic from children, the story immediately pulls you into a dark, high-stakes world. Viridia Solace is such a strong, driven main character, fueled by grief, anger, and a desperate need for justice after her parents’ murder. Her tension-filled dynamic with Reeve Ashton is one of the best parts of the book. Their relationship is a perfect example of “never bargain with a reaper,” yet that’s exactly what Viri finds herself doing, with consequences that are both thrilling and emotionally complicated.
What I really appreciated is how this book uses familiar tropes without feeling tired or watered down. Enemies-to-allies-to-friends-to-potential-lovers, hidden powers, alchemy, magic, found family—it’s all here, but handled with care and originality. The story is very plot-forward, and the romance is clearly a subplot. If you’re looking for a steamy romantasy, this isn’t it. But if you love rich worldbuilding, intense action, and emotional tension that builds slowly and naturally, this book delivers.
The pacing is excellent, the twists are relentless, and the emotional beats land beautifully. You can feel how personal this book is, and knowing that writing it helped Lynette Noni heal and find her way back to storytelling makes it even more special. There’s heart behind every page.
Overall, Shadow Reaper was an incredibly enjoyable read. It’s gripping, clever, and full of the kind of storytelling that reminds you why you love fantasy in the first place. The book design is also stunning, and I absolutely cannot wait to get my hands on a physical copy. This is a powerful start to a new duology? trilogy? perhaps either way I’m already counting down until the next book
Set in the dangerous city of Aravell, where blackmist kills on contact and reapers steal magic from children, the story immediately pulls you into a dark, high-stakes world. Viridia Solace is such a strong, driven main character, fueled by grief, anger, and a desperate need for justice after her parents’ murder. Her tension-filled dynamic with Reeve Ashton is one of the best parts of the book. Their relationship is a perfect example of “never bargain with a reaper,” yet that’s exactly what Viri finds herself doing, with consequences that are both thrilling and emotionally complicated.
What I really appreciated is how this book uses familiar tropes without feeling tired or watered down. Enemies-to-allies-to-friends-to-potential-lovers, hidden powers, alchemy, magic, found family—it’s all here, but handled with care and originality. The story is very plot-forward, and the romance is clearly a subplot. If you’re looking for a steamy romantasy, this isn’t it. But if you love rich worldbuilding, intense action, and emotional tension that builds slowly and naturally, this book delivers.
The pacing is excellent, the twists are relentless, and the emotional beats land beautifully. You can feel how personal this book is, and knowing that writing it helped Lynette Noni heal and find her way back to storytelling makes it even more special. There’s heart behind every page.
Overall, Shadow Reaper was an incredibly enjoyable read. It’s gripping, clever, and full of the kind of storytelling that reminds you why you love fantasy in the first place. The book design is also stunning, and I absolutely cannot wait to get my hands on a physical copy. This is a powerful start to a new duology? trilogy? perhaps either way I’m already counting down until the next book
January 20, 2026
4.5⭐️
An absolutely excellent start of new YA fantasy series with found family, TRUE slow burn, and some diabolical twists.
Thank you Random House/Knopf, NetGalley, and Lynette Noni for eARC, all opinions my own.
Viri is hunter on Elverdine Isle, it’s her job to hunt reapers (once human who now siphon magic and kill children in order to gain powers and a high). She is hunter prodigy and with her best friend/adoptive sister Wynter (a secret alchemist) and Soren (part of the city guard; the Nox) they all want to fight the reapers and keep their friends safe. But when the reaper Priest’s second in command (and former childhood friend) Reeve is captured and will only talk to her she must decide whether to listen to him or let him rot in prison. Soon she realizes there is much more going on than single reapers stealing magic and she must embark on quest to stop the reapers leader from damning the entire isle.
This was fantastic start to new YA series and I will absolutely keep reading!!! Viri is a great FMC. While she doesn’t break any new ground character wise that’s not really needed as she is solid heroine. Wynter in particular is found family standout and I hope she Jonas, Sage, and Arron get more time as series continues (also more Walnut 🐇). Soren is fine although bit one dimensional here so hoping his character gets some more too it going forward.
Obviously also want more Reeve. Can’t say too much because of spoilers but I want to know so much more about his training and what happened during his teen years.
There are number of good twists throughout the book but the ending killed me. I thought I had that twist figured out until I didn’t. Some of twists were predictable but they are kinda meant to be as they are hinted or foreshadowed. But I didn’t mind that at all.
Fans of early TOG, Crimson Moth, and other YA fantasies will be right at home here. I can’t wait to learn more about the world, magic, and these characters in future entries!
An absolutely excellent start of new YA fantasy series with found family, TRUE slow burn, and some diabolical twists.
Thank you Random House/Knopf, NetGalley, and Lynette Noni for eARC, all opinions my own.
Viri is hunter on Elverdine Isle, it’s her job to hunt reapers (once human who now siphon magic and kill children in order to gain powers and a high). She is hunter prodigy and with her best friend/adoptive sister Wynter (a secret alchemist) and Soren (part of the city guard; the Nox) they all want to fight the reapers and keep their friends safe. But when the reaper Priest’s second in command (and former childhood friend) Reeve is captured and will only talk to her she must decide whether to listen to him or let him rot in prison. Soon she realizes there is much more going on than single reapers stealing magic and she must embark on quest to stop the reapers leader from damning the entire isle.
This was fantastic start to new YA series and I will absolutely keep reading!!! Viri is a great FMC. While she doesn’t break any new ground character wise that’s not really needed as she is solid heroine. Wynter in particular is found family standout and I hope she Jonas, Sage, and Arron get more time as series continues (also more Walnut 🐇). Soren is fine although bit one dimensional here so hoping his character gets some more too it going forward.
Obviously also want more Reeve. Can’t say too much because of spoilers but I want to know so much more about his training and what happened during his teen years.
There are number of good twists throughout the book but the ending killed me. I thought I had that twist figured out until I didn’t. Some of twists were predictable but they are kinda meant to be as they are hinted or foreshadowed. But I didn’t mind that at all.
Fans of early TOG, Crimson Moth, and other YA fantasies will be right at home here. I can’t wait to learn more about the world, magic, and these characters in future entries!
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Every single book Lynette Noni writes becomes an instant favourite, and Shadow Reaper is no exception.
"You already have everything you need to succeed. Trust yourself. Trust your friends."
Viridia Solace - Viri - has spent her life as a Hunter, hunting Reapers who kill children by siphoning their magic to chase a power high. And for Viri, it's personal. Her own parents had been killed by the leader of the Reapers seven years ago, when everything she ever knew was decimated and she was left alone to grieve and then vow vengeance.
Her chance comes when the right hand to the Reaper Priest is arrested and has the knowledge she needs to find her enemy. But he will only help her in exchange for his freedom. So Viri finds herself working alongside Reeve Ashton who makes her realise there is even more at stake than her personal vendetta.
So I LOVE Viri. She's badass and capable, not afraid to bend rules and also is able to admit when she is wrong - eventually.
I also love the rest of the crew, especially Walnut and I hope he gets more page time in the next one!
The banter and humour in this had me smiling and laughing for the first half of the book before it started to get real and then it was all the other emotions hitting hard and fast. There were twists and turns, some more predictable than others, but all made this book a non-stop RIDE right up until the very end and I am sitting here still in shock and disbelief and anguish that I will have to wait so long to find out what happens next.
The plot, the characters, the banter, the freaking twists - everything is a delicious 5 star meal and I am hungry for more!
"You already have everything you need to succeed. Trust yourself. Trust your friends."
Viridia Solace - Viri - has spent her life as a Hunter, hunting Reapers who kill children by siphoning their magic to chase a power high. And for Viri, it's personal. Her own parents had been killed by the leader of the Reapers seven years ago, when everything she ever knew was decimated and she was left alone to grieve and then vow vengeance.
Her chance comes when the right hand to the Reaper Priest is arrested and has the knowledge she needs to find her enemy. But he will only help her in exchange for his freedom. So Viri finds herself working alongside Reeve Ashton who makes her realise there is even more at stake than her personal vendetta.
So I LOVE Viri. She's badass and capable, not afraid to bend rules and also is able to admit when she is wrong - eventually.
I also love the rest of the crew, especially Walnut and I hope he gets more page time in the next one!
The banter and humour in this had me smiling and laughing for the first half of the book before it started to get real and then it was all the other emotions hitting hard and fast. There were twists and turns, some more predictable than others, but all made this book a non-stop RIDE right up until the very end and I am sitting here still in shock and disbelief and anguish that I will have to wait so long to find out what happens next.
The plot, the characters, the banter, the freaking twists - everything is a delicious 5 star meal and I am hungry for more!
January 19, 2026
4.5 ⭐️
Shadow Reaper is the first book in a new YA fantasy series following a young reaper hunter (Viridia) who is forced to work with her childhood friend (Reeve) turned enemy against the reapers who are led by the Reaper Priest, the man that murdered her parents. Left with no other choice to get the answers she has searched years for, Reeve, who is caught and imprisoned, offers a bargain she couldn’t say no to - his freedom for the answers she seeks. However, they say to never bargain with a reaper. Filled with high stakes, quests, unique magic, and some unexpected truths and twists - this is such a fun YA fantasy book coming June 2026!
🧪found family
🧪unique magical system
🧪enemies to lovers
🧪high stakes and quests
🧪murder and mystery
I really enjoyed reading this! Between the world building, an unique magic system, villains that you might can’t quite hate, and plot twists that hurt your soul a little - I enjoyed this book so much and it was all that I was expecting! There is friendship, betrayals, redemption, and twists that make it hard to put down. If you’re looking for an adventure that keeps you on the edge of your seat this will be one to read! I loved the characters, the history that is revealed through old letters providing a background to the current situation, and even a cute little sidekick bunny that’ll you will want to keep. The ending will hurt and leave you aching for book 2! This could easily be the best series of hers yet!
Thank you NetGalley and Random House Children’s Books for the ARC!!
Shadow Reaper is the first book in a new YA fantasy series following a young reaper hunter (Viridia) who is forced to work with her childhood friend (Reeve) turned enemy against the reapers who are led by the Reaper Priest, the man that murdered her parents. Left with no other choice to get the answers she has searched years for, Reeve, who is caught and imprisoned, offers a bargain she couldn’t say no to - his freedom for the answers she seeks. However, they say to never bargain with a reaper. Filled with high stakes, quests, unique magic, and some unexpected truths and twists - this is such a fun YA fantasy book coming June 2026!
🧪found family
🧪unique magical system
🧪enemies to lovers
🧪high stakes and quests
🧪murder and mystery
I really enjoyed reading this! Between the world building, an unique magic system, villains that you might can’t quite hate, and plot twists that hurt your soul a little - I enjoyed this book so much and it was all that I was expecting! There is friendship, betrayals, redemption, and twists that make it hard to put down. If you’re looking for an adventure that keeps you on the edge of your seat this will be one to read! I loved the characters, the history that is revealed through old letters providing a background to the current situation, and even a cute little sidekick bunny that’ll you will want to keep. The ending will hurt and leave you aching for book 2! This could easily be the best series of hers yet!
Thank you NetGalley and Random House Children’s Books for the ARC!!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
4.5 stars
To say that I was excited for this book would be a massive understatement. The Prison Healer series is one of my all-time favorite YA fantasy series and I could not wait to read more from this author. If I could read a new Lynette Noni fantasy novel every day for the rest of my life, I would still want to read more.
I really enjoyed the world-building in this world and I thought that there was a unique magic system. Noni's writing always feels very immersive and it felt like I was walking right next to the characters in this book. I thought that the beginning dragged on a little bit. It felt like the plot was just coasting along and that is a problem I have with a lot of first books of series, so I don't think that this problem is necessarily the author's fault. I understand that in book one, there is a lot of setup which is not necessarily always going to be the most exciting thing to read. However, the latter half of this book was absolutely fantastic. There were so many revelations and twists and turns. Truly, mind the cliff at the end of this book. The end of this book set up what I am sure will be a crazy finale to this duology and I cannot wait to read the finale to Viri and Reeve's story.
To say that I was excited for this book would be a massive understatement. The Prison Healer series is one of my all-time favorite YA fantasy series and I could not wait to read more from this author. If I could read a new Lynette Noni fantasy novel every day for the rest of my life, I would still want to read more.
I really enjoyed the world-building in this world and I thought that there was a unique magic system. Noni's writing always feels very immersive and it felt like I was walking right next to the characters in this book. I thought that the beginning dragged on a little bit. It felt like the plot was just coasting along and that is a problem I have with a lot of first books of series, so I don't think that this problem is necessarily the author's fault. I understand that in book one, there is a lot of setup which is not necessarily always going to be the most exciting thing to read. However, the latter half of this book was absolutely fantastic. There were so many revelations and twists and turns. Truly, mind the cliff at the end of this book. The end of this book set up what I am sure will be a crazy finale to this duology and I cannot wait to read the finale to Viri and Reeve's story.
January 22, 2026
Okay, where to begin… this book was nothing short of amazing. In this book you follow Viri who is a hunter. She hunts reapers, and has a main target to fulfill her revenge plan the Reaper Priest. She’s going about her duties, bringing in reapers, catching them before they can siphon from the children of the island when none other than Reeve is captured. With their history and the fact she hasn’t seen him in 7 years, does she trust him enough to figure out where all the missing children are going?
I had so much fun reading this. The author does a wonderful job with her storytelling. Throughout the whole book you have an underlying tone of there being more going on than what is said, so it’s easy to breeze through to get the answers while also trying to guess for yourself what the answers will be. I found myself thrown around left right and center with the reveals but even through all of that I wasn’t even a little bit prepared for the review at the end. What do you mean?!
Do yourself a favor and mark your calendar for the release date because you NEED this book in your life.
Thank you NetGalley for the ARC of this title.
I had so much fun reading this. The author does a wonderful job with her storytelling. Throughout the whole book you have an underlying tone of there being more going on than what is said, so it’s easy to breeze through to get the answers while also trying to guess for yourself what the answers will be. I found myself thrown around left right and center with the reveals but even through all of that I wasn’t even a little bit prepared for the review at the end. What do you mean?!
Do yourself a favor and mark your calendar for the release date because you NEED this book in your life.
Thank you NetGalley for the ARC of this title.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
In a world with magic and reapers who steal magic from children, we meet Viri, a reaper hunter. Her story, is part romance, part suspense-filled fantasy, and entirely captivating. Anyone who has read the author's Prison Healer Trilogy knows that she is great at world building and telling a compelling tale and she doesn't disappoint with this first book of her next series. The lore, magic, and characters are well developed and I found myself interested in more than just Viri but her friends and found family. The story unfolds with plenty of curves and twists, some predictable, others surprising but all building up a plot that culminates in a cliffhanger that falls into a "twist of the knife" ending and I'm looking forward to the sequel to see how this twisted end gets untangled.
I received access to this eARC thru NetGalley (for which I want to thank NetGalley and the publisher, Random House Children's Books - Knopf Books for Young Readers) for an honest review. The opinion expressed here is my own.
I received access to this eARC thru NetGalley (for which I want to thank NetGalley and the publisher, Random House Children's Books - Knopf Books for Young Readers) for an honest review. The opinion expressed here is my own.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an early copy of this book! Below is my honest review.
This was a fun read. The world is interesting, but not too complex where you couldn't understand it. All people have magic, but once you hit 14 years old, you have to impart it and give it to these obelisks, which helps protect the area from the blackmist (not a good thing). Our main character Viri is a hunter who hunts reapers, people who steal magic from others as it provides them with extra powers. Her childhood best friend -- aka her enemy who is a reaper -- asks for her help in stopping the Reaper Priest from killing everyone.
I love Lynette Noni and her books, but I will say, this one was not my favorite. I felt like the story suffered from info-dumping. Essentially, anything important to the plot was basically told through a long monologue. While I still enjoyed it, I think some of the information could have been told in some other format. A lot of the times, the main characters spend so much time explaining what happened/the world. There are a lot of twists and turns that sort of makes up for that fact, but some twists and turns felt over the top.
HOWEVER, despite my issues, I will still read the second book because I still enjoyed reading this one.
This was a fun read. The world is interesting, but not too complex where you couldn't understand it. All people have magic, but once you hit 14 years old, you have to impart it and give it to these obelisks, which helps protect the area from the blackmist (not a good thing). Our main character Viri is a hunter who hunts reapers, people who steal magic from others as it provides them with extra powers. Her childhood best friend -- aka her enemy who is a reaper -- asks for her help in stopping the Reaper Priest from killing everyone.
I love Lynette Noni and her books, but I will say, this one was not my favorite. I felt like the story suffered from info-dumping. Essentially, anything important to the plot was basically told through a long monologue. While I still enjoyed it, I think some of the information could have been told in some other format. A lot of the times, the main characters spend so much time explaining what happened/the world. There are a lot of twists and turns that sort of makes up for that fact, but some twists and turns felt over the top.
HOWEVER, despite my issues, I will still read the second book because I still enjoyed reading this one.
January 14, 2026
2.5⭐️
Ugh. I hated having to give that rating, but this was my most disappointing read in a while. Lynette Noni isn’t a one hit wonder. I’ve read plenty of her books and loved them. But this one seemed so shallow.
If you’ve read her before, specifically The Prison Healer series, you know she has twists DOWN. But the difference was that most of the twists in this book were either predictable or just seemed to come out of nowhere. The lack of groundwork made them unbelievable.
On top of this, the first half of the book was simultaneously too long and also not deep enough for me to truly love the characters. It also felt a bit like a teacher who wanted me to learn something.
At about 70% through, the story picked up and I sped through the end, but sadly, it still didn’t hit like her other books.
I don’t mean to turn away all the Noni fans. Maybe you’ll like it. But for me, this was a miss. (Although I still can’t wait for her next book! I think I’ll always be excited for a new book from her.)
Ugh. I hated having to give that rating, but this was my most disappointing read in a while. Lynette Noni isn’t a one hit wonder. I’ve read plenty of her books and loved them. But this one seemed so shallow.
If you’ve read her before, specifically The Prison Healer series, you know she has twists DOWN. But the difference was that most of the twists in this book were either predictable or just seemed to come out of nowhere. The lack of groundwork made them unbelievable.
On top of this, the first half of the book was simultaneously too long and also not deep enough for me to truly love the characters. It also felt a bit like a teacher who wanted me to learn something.
At about 70% through, the story picked up and I sped through the end, but sadly, it still didn’t hit like her other books.
I don’t mean to turn away all the Noni fans. Maybe you’ll like it. But for me, this was a miss. (Although I still can’t wait for her next book! I think I’ll always be excited for a new book from her.)
January 21, 2026
5/5 Stars!! 🌟
Shadow Reaper had me on the edge of my seat! Lynnette Noni has created yet another masterpiece and I loved Shadow Reaper just as much as her Prison Healer series. Book two can’t come fast enough!
Viridia Solace is a powerhouse. She’s a strong, well trained reaper hunter who has a soft spot for her eclectic group of friends and found family (Walnut is my personal favorite). Viri’s character arc and growth throughout this first book kept me invested as I read. Seeing her relationship with Reeve develop as they hunt down the Reaper Priest was definitely the best part!
The magic system feels fresh and interesting while still being easy to understand, especially with the short glossary in the beginning of the book. This book definitely delivers on the tropes of high stakes action, twists, found family, and enemies to lovers.
A huge thank you to Random House Children’s Books and NetGalley for sending me an ARC for review consideration!
Shadow Reaper had me on the edge of my seat! Lynnette Noni has created yet another masterpiece and I loved Shadow Reaper just as much as her Prison Healer series. Book two can’t come fast enough!
Viridia Solace is a powerhouse. She’s a strong, well trained reaper hunter who has a soft spot for her eclectic group of friends and found family (Walnut is my personal favorite). Viri’s character arc and growth throughout this first book kept me invested as I read. Seeing her relationship with Reeve develop as they hunt down the Reaper Priest was definitely the best part!
The magic system feels fresh and interesting while still being easy to understand, especially with the short glossary in the beginning of the book. This book definitely delivers on the tropes of high stakes action, twists, found family, and enemies to lovers.
A huge thank you to Random House Children’s Books and NetGalley for sending me an ARC for review consideration!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 50 reviews