I'd only recommend this one to anyone who has already read Roeder's "The Soccer Field is Empty."
It took place during the same time as Mark and Taylor's double suicide. Julian was on their soccer team, but not in their inner circle of friends, so I enjoyed getting another perspective as all of that was going down.
The big reveal of Julian's secret admirer was kind of funny, but the admirer's "huge secret" felt pretty strange, with the scene coming off as a bit stiff, formal and slightly corny.
Some of the dialogue came across as pretty young and slightly repetitive, but if you're a fan of the series and its insane level of world building (20+ books in the series,) then I'm sure you'll enjoy this one, too.
3.5 stars, but rounding down, because I *HATED* the cover of the book, which did *not* represent Julian, who was a six foot tall high school student and *not* the boy-child on the cover.