Who’s Lovin You is a cozy, nostalgic slow-burn set against the backdrop of Christmas 1976 , and it completely transported me. Lula White blends romance, history, family legacy, and community into a story that feels warm, intimate, and deeply rooted in Black culture and tradition.
A’Lelia (Al) Cesaire is such an easy heroine to root for. Despite the heavy expectations attached to her family name, and the resentment some people have toward it, she comes across as a genuinely good person trying to honor her history while still figuring out who she is. Watching her grapple with family secrets, community pressure, and her own vulnerability added such richness to her character.
And then there’s Dr. Emeric MacPherson. (What a man, what a man, what a mighty good man!) Such an absolute gem of a hero. His southern charm and gentlemanly presence brought so much softness and joy to the story. He’s sharp, funny, kind, a smooth dresser, and the type of man who moves with intention. His energy grounded the book in the best way, and the chemistry between him and Al was undeniable. Even though their relationship unfolds quickly within the story’s timeline, it still felt like a slow burn—the tension simmered for so long before finally breaking open into a beautiful, tender love story.
One of my favorite elements was the setting. The late ’70s details: the 8-tracks, the afro picks, the slang, took me back to memories from my early childhood. The atmosphere is vivid and nostalgic, and the holiday backdrop adds an extra layer of warmth. Lula White’s writing is clear and engaging, and she weaves in legacy, community traditions, and long-buried family truths in a way that feels so meaningful.
The pacing is mostly solid, though the ending did feel a little drawn out. Still, the themes of family, legacy, community, secrets, romance, and the magic of NYC at Christmastime, all come together to create a story that’s bigger than a love story. It’s about history and healing, connection and courage, and finding your place in the lineage that raised you.
If you want a cozy, nostalgic, tender holiday love story with a little dose of family drama, this book is for you!
Thank you Lula White for an e-ARC of Who’s Lovin You.