4🌟 ig I mean I like the novel. And Wali Ahmed’s chr… OMGGG😭😭 And the plot and story line were also amazing💙 The way she portrayed Wali’s life. And the ending… loveddd ittt. Especially Hashim and his father’s end.
I am also kinda rooting for Asghar and Kanita’s couple. And Zain, Kanita’s son, OMG.. cutiieee😭
And ofc, Amal. Her character was also a strong and nice one. I like the novel overall. But it still wasn’t a five cause a few things just didn’t hit. I mean, Bakhtiyar(Amal’s brother) and his wife (Hashim’s sister) were there throughout the story. Whereas, Ameena and Amal’s other brother, they kinda disappered and then appeared at the end again. I mean the way Bakhtiyar reacted. She should have also shown Amal’s other brother’s reaction and his life if she was showing Bakhtiyar’s. And there were a few spots where he should ‘ve been mentioned but he wasn’t. So I think there were a few drawbacks like this.
Overall, the story was good. The plot, the setting. And everything.
I finished it in such a short time. I mean I finished it in a day. I started it yesterday night. (I mean I had read a few pages a few days ago but yeah officially started it last night.) And read a few pages last night. And then slept early. And just finished it. And I think it fills the time when I didn’t read it this morning. I mean I started reading after 1 or 2 pm ig. But whatever.
I am going to be brutally honest: Hisaare Yaar was another childish, immature, and deeply disappointing reading experience. Although I found Carpe Diem even more childish than this one, I have reached a point where I genuinely question whether Rabia Khan has any creativity left to offer.
After reading several of her novels, I have come to believe that she has written one story and keeps rewriting it under different titles. The characters change their names, the circumstances are slightly modified, but the fundamental storyline remains almost identical.
Let me explain.
1. The Same Family Drama Almost every story revolves around two brothers from the same family. One brother is wicked, cruel, and evil, while the other is kind, polite, and sympathetic. Naturally, the children of the wicked brother inherit his wickedness, while the children of the kind brother become their victims. The evil aunt and cousins are always there to torment the innocent characters.
2. The Same Love Story The romantic relationship follows a familiar pattern as well. The heroine's lover is always someone from within the extended family, often the son of her father's sister. The romance feels less like an original creation and more like a repeated formula.
3. The Mafia Is Always Essential The hero is almost always connected to the mafia. It has become such an essential element of Rabia Khan's storytelling that I wonder whether she can write a novel without introducing a criminal underworld.
4. The Same Traumatised Hero The male protagonist has suffered immensely during his childhood. He has been abused, mistreated, and rejected by society. Eventually, he joins the mafia, becomes ruthless, and seeks revenge against those who wronged him.
5. The Same Climactic Rescue And, of course, the heroine is eventually kidnapped by the wicked characters, only for the hero to arrive and rescue her. from out of nowhere. I genuinely challenge anyone who has read all these novels to tell me that these are not the same recurring storylines. If you can find a genuinely different story among them, feel free to correct me.
Fiction or Fantasy? Coming specifically to Hisaare Yaar, I could not understand whether I was reading a work of fiction or some inexplicable fantasy. At one point, the hero suffers an accident, and the author introduces an unusual concept: whenever someone is about to die, a mark appears on the heroine's hand. Seriously? What kind of fantasy is this? And the funniest part? Nobody dies. The concept itself felt completely out of place, and its execution did nothing to make it meaningful.
The Scene Transitions Are Absolutely Terrible One of the most frustrating flaws in this book is the way scenes suddenly change without any proper transition. The author creates a scene, begins describing the characters and their actions, and then, within the same paragraph, the entire setting changes. For example, a character enters Nafis's room angrily and slams the door. On the very next line, the character is suddenly standing in front of a mirror, washing their face, and looking at their reflection.
How did we get there? When did the scene change? There is no transition, no explanation, and no sense of continuity. It feels as though entire portions of the story have been skipped.
Unresolved Plotlines and Forgotten Characters Another major flaw is the author's apparent inability—or unwillingness—to properly resolve the events she introduces. Hussain Chacha, the wicked uncle, is sitting directly in front of the hero. The hero is supposed to take revenge for all the abuse he has suffered. Yet the story fails to properly explain how Hero captured him, and how Hussain Chacha ended up handicapped. It feels as though the author either forgot these details or simply decided that they were not worth explaining. the same problem occurs when the heroine's wicked cousin hires a servant to take revenge on her. The servant is introduced as part of an important plotline, but what does the servant actually do? What happens afterward? Nothing meaningful is explained. The entire subplot simply disappears.
A Story That Feels Like a School Assignment Honestly, the writing reminded me of a story written by a seventh-grade student who has been asked to create a dramatic romantic novel. The ideas are introduced without proper development, the scenes lack continuity, the characters behave inconsistently, and important plotlines are abandoned without explanation. It is not merely a matter of disliking the author's style. The fundamental problem is that the story itself feels poorly constructed.
Final Thoughts I have now read five novels by Rabia Khan: Azazil, Kahaf, Dhannak, Carpe Diem, and *Hisaare Yaar. And I am done. I genuinely cannot justify spending more money on novels that repeatedly present the same family conflicts, the same mafia-driven heroes, the same romantic formulas, and the same predictable kidnappings and rescues. Hisaare Yaar was, for me, an exercise in frustration. It lacked originality, logical consistency, proper scene transitions, and satisfactory resolutions. I know that some readers may enjoy these familiar romantic and dramatic tropes, but personally, I have had enough.
2.8/5 - mixed reviews honestly, i picked it up cos i had heard that its a cute romcom which i didnt see as true sadly & therefore i skimmed through this book for most part :( so i was a bit disappointed. & i really wanted them to get together asappp, agh. was reading in hopes of finally them getting together!!! but the book was just them yearning for each other all along, not confronting their feelings and maybe i wasnt in the mood for that so i was frustrated a bit. but wali was such a gentleman, ooof!!! genuinely loved his character for his aura. his relationship especially with zaman baba & bee jaan was soooo cute man <3 i also felt it being minutely inspired by namal wrt some characters & their stories (mohsin as ahmar shafi & hashim as hashim kardaar 🤪) kuch points py plot seemed very immature, unrealistic sa, which i don’t enjoy in books
the last scene of them finally getting together and that cute confrontation was the best scene of the book, i wish we had gotten more of their scenes together :(
also, i guess i have read other rabia khan books which i liked better especially kahaf so iss liye i had better expectations from this one too
This man, ughhhhhhhhhhhh 😩 Lord help me. I mean, he is so masculine, so handsome, so kind, so gentle, so perfect 🤌🏼✨
Khair, let’s move on to the review.
Such a good book. I loved it. From beginning to end, I enjoyed almost everything, though I didn’t like the part where Wali just left Amal for that son of a—— uh, control freak, Nafees. But I get it. If we look at things from Wali’s POV, he simply felt so undeserving of Amal that he thought everyone else was better for her than him. My Shayla. 🥺
But the major topic this book covered so beautifully was the hatred towards children born outside the bond of marriage. We can brag about so many things about our culture, but the reality is that we have a lot of issues deeply rooted in our society and mindsets that desperately need to be addressed. The disgust and hatred our society shows towards these children is something you would hardly ever see directed towards a rapist or a molester. And the cherry on top? If that person happens to belong to a respectable family or is wealthy, then you can just forget about justice. People will say, “Oh, it’s just a mistake,” or, even worse, start victim-blaming.
Wali’s childhood literally haunted me. He was just a little kid. And that bloody Hasham! He could have let things be and simply moved on with his life, but no. He had a thief in him, and he did everything possible to make Wali’s life horrible and insufferable. I really liked how he finally got what he deserved at the end, though. That was satisfying. But oh, did I cry rivers while reading about Wali’s childhood 🤧😭😭 I can’t even imagine how painful it must be to constantly hear such horrible things about yourself, especially when you’re just a child.
And Amal, oh my godddd, she is such a cutie pie ❤️❤️❤️ The way she always scolds Wali and then gets shy. Ahhh 😩 I blushed and giggled like a maniac 😅😅 I absolutely loved how she stood up for Wali when no one believed him, not even Bee Jaan 🥺 That scene reminded me of Sheriyar Sikander from JBHSSL. My girl just knew that Wali could never, ever do such a thing. He is such a gentleman. THE definition of a gentleman ❤️ And in the end, Amal Bibi got her Wali.
But oh, THE YEARNING. Inject it into my veins, please 😭😭😭😭😭 The way I folded into a chair every time Wali said something to Amal in that soft tone 😩😭 I was on my knees. I NEED to have a conversation with the author because, miss, I ain’t seeing any man like him around me… I can’t blame Najiya for going crazy over him 🌚 But she was SO insufferable, though 😑 The number of misunderstandings she created, ughhhh. I wanted to slap her at one point. How can you say whatever you want about someone, as if it means nothing, and then just go to sleep at night???
And the ending, oh god, I can’t even explain how much I screamed when their nikah happened. That entire proposal scene, and then Wali being so romantic afterwards. Aghhhh 🤌🏼✨ The way he rested his head in Amal’s lap. Oh lord, I was feeling butterflies 🙈🙈
Oh yeah, and a special honourable mention goes to my favourite, Asghar ❤️❤️ He is THE BEST. I absolutely adored their friendship. The way he was always so protective of Wali, their little banter, everything 😭😭 I love him so much, especially in the hospital scene, when he was so angry and protective of Wali.
Actually, I was shipping him with Kaanta. If we could get a book about the two of them, oh my god, I’m going to lose my mind. It would make such a good story! But alas, I have no such hopes, though you never know.
Well, overall, I loved this book. I loved the message it wanted to portray and basically everything about it: the yearning, found family, drama, secrets, everything.
I would have said I loved the characters, but I think it would be more accurate to say that I hated everyone except Wali, Amal, Bee Jaan, Sardar Baba, Asghar, Asghar’s dad, and Shanawaz.
Final verdict: Wali Ahmed, you will always be one of my favourites❤️ and Selena’s too (IYKYK) 🤭🤭
loved the story but i wish writer gave disclosure that the main story id from another writer "Kirdaar by Nabila aziz" Hisar e yaar likhi achi hui hai but not the original work. main story kirdaar se li hui hai. obviously kirdaar was published many years before this novel and it was a short story so hisaar e yaar mein kafi details hain or characters ki stories diffrent hain. but wali and mehrma wali story exact same hai. i wish it was her own work. likha acha hua tha and romance bhi acha tha but the story lacked originality.
This was an amazing novell, i don't know whyy but i like this novel alot... the chemistry between wali and ummul was so cuteee....I also cried while reading this.. it was kinda deep but not that deep.. it portrays the importance of treating good to adopted child... which was not really adopted.. I really like the twist and the vibe of the whole novel.... I enjoyed alot ....must read🤌
Hisaar-e-Yaar by Rabia Khan is a genuinely good, engaging story with strong character-building, you really see the characters grow and become who they are page by page. The ending felt a lot like Namal's ending though, which made it slightly predictable for me. Still, the emotional storytelling and rich character development make it a worthwhile, entertaining read.
جب میں نے یہ کتاب سالوں پہلے پڑھی تھی تو لگتا تھا اِس سے بڑا شاہکار کوئ نہیں ہے۔ لیکن اب پڑھ کہ بہت عام سی لگی جس میں بہت سی جگہوں پر کہانی کے تسلسل میں تضاد تھا۔ مصنفہ کی نئی کہانیوں میں واضح بہتری دیکھی جا سکتی ہے لکھائ کے معاملے میں