I feel like this is somewhere between 3 and 4 stars, maybe 3.5, but I’m going to be generous and go with 4.
Pros: the kids loved it, the callbacks to the original series were fun (the kids whooped at the “everything is a weapon” line getting slipped in there, and they loved the little insight into Helmer’s love of ladybugs), and P.J. and Elias were enjoyable characters. The importance of the virtues of patience, self-control, service, etc. being practiced in tandem with using your strength and energy for good (fighting bad guys, saving the weak, working hard at your vocation) were woven into the story in a way that my sons really embraced and remembered (I’ve heard them telling each other “wait.. and see” pretty often this week 😂), and I really appreciated how the strengths of sons were called out while working to improve on weaknesses as well.
Cons: I felt the momentum of the story for the first half but the final third kind of dragged for me. I figured out the big reveal immediately (though my children who routinely spot twists ahead of time were completely shocked, so it was a well-written plot twist for the intended audience), and the ending felt a bit rushed with everything blowing up and all the extended fight scenes. There is a video game linked to this book and that might have influenced all the extended descriptions of every jump/swipe/kick which is a bit of a trudge to read. 🤪 Again, the kids were riveted, but reading it as an adult I felt like this weakened the power of the story.
In sum, the story starts strong, there’s lots of action, adventure, bravery, loyalty, good-vs-evil soul food in here, and my girls and (especially) boys both loved it, but the extended fight sequences dragged for me. I wanted to LOVE it but it doesn’t have the power of the Green Ember series. If you haven’t read any S.D. Smith books, definitely start with the Green Ember and read all 4 books. This makes a good addition to our home library, my children really enjoyed it, and I love the philosophy behind the game they made to go with it (and my children are chomping at the bit for us to play that together now that we’ve read through the story 😂), but it rates a solid star below the others for me.