Reread, October 2023 - this was such a good reread, I listened to the audiobook and Karen Cass always does amazing.
The whole web-of-lies thing bugged me a bit this time more than my original read, so I didn’t love it quite as much the second time around, but it’s still one of my favourites by this author.
*****
Original review, July 2022 - Man, I love Christmas. I’m normally a seasonal reader, so I wasn’t sure if I’d really get in the Christmas-y mood as much when it’s still so hot out (honestly, I live in Florida, it’s not like Christmas is cold so I really don’t know what I’m even talking about) but I loved this. My favourite Portia MacIntosh novel to date is Stuck On You, specifically for the Christmas-y elements, and I loved that this had so much of it as well.
I think I just really loved returning to Marram Bay. I haven’t read all of Portia’s backlist, so I know there were references to characters and places that I only recognized from book titles / descriptions that I’ll appreciate more once I’ve read more of her books from Marram Bay. But I have read ‘Love and Lies at the Village Christmas Shop’ and loved seeing those characters again! It’s so sweet that Ivy and Dani were friends, and I still adore Gaz
At first, I didn’t know how much I would care for Rex. His comment to Dani about not seeming shallow to another woman by dating her kind of rubbed me the wrong way, but the way it was said did make it seem like it wasn’t actually about her appearance, it was about him being kind and not flirtatious. Not my favourite phrasing, because it did make me assume negatively about him at first, but it all ended up fine because I really did adore Rex.
I think what I really liked about this was that it honestly all felt quite uncomplicated. I felt like I could see feelings developing on both ends by the way this book was written, and despite some little issues, nothing felt overly dramatic. And that really can happen a lot in books. This was just a fun read about great characters.
There was also something about this book that just felt very positive. Even when things really weren’t going well for Dani, I feel like she remained so hopeful, and that was lovely. Especially around Ivy, and how excited and kind Ivy always was, it seemed like no matter what happened with her love life or career, Dani would have a happy life and had wonderful people in her life.
Total side note, but I feel like I need to count how many of Portia MacIntosh’s novels have a mention of Michael Buble. I feel like it’s a lot, and I love it. Especially for a Christmas book.
Definitely recommend this. I recommend all of Portia MacIntosh’s books, I’ve read quite a few and always enjoy them, but there really is something special about the holiday ones.
Thank you to Boldwood Books & NetGalley for the opportunity to read an advanced copy of this book!