What do you think?
Rate this book
Tate and Bell Mystery #7
The Carnival Murders
The discovery of a murdered woman sparks a nightmare that may destroy everything for Gemma and Sebastian…
In a respectable London neighborhood, nurse Gemma Tate and her fiancé, Inspector Sebastian Bell, are planning their future together. But their dreams shatter when they discover a murdered young woman, carefully arranged in a darkened alleyway behind her family home.
While Gemma unravels the woman’s final secrets in the post-mortem room, Sebastian hunts among the living. And he soon uncovers reports of similar deaths, linked to a traveling carnival. But what connects those friendless victims to the beloved woman they found?
Refusing to be beaten, Gemma and Sebastian pursue every lead on the killer’s trail, desperate to prevent more deaths. But can they stop him before he destroys not just more lives, but their own hope of happiness?
A gripping and atmospheric Victorian mystery for fans of Andrea Penrose, Anna Lee Huber, and the Lady Sherlock mysteries.
In a respectable London neighborhood, nurse Gemma Tate and her fiancé, Inspector Sebastian Bell, are planning their future together. But their dreams shatter when they discover a murdered young woman, carefully arranged in a darkened alleyway behind her family home.
While Gemma unravels the woman’s final secrets in the post-mortem room, Sebastian hunts among the living. And he soon uncovers reports of similar deaths, linked to a traveling carnival. But what connects those friendless victims to the beloved woman they found?
Refusing to be beaten, Gemma and Sebastian pursue every lead on the killer’s trail, desperate to prevent more deaths. But can they stop him before he destroys not just more lives, but their own hope of happiness?
A gripping and atmospheric Victorian mystery for fans of Andrea Penrose, Anna Lee Huber, and the Lady Sherlock mysteries.
276 pages, Kindle Edition
Published March 10, 2026
About the author
Irina Shapiro
129 books1,385 followersTo write a novel was a dream of mine since I was a child. Life, my practical nature, and self-doubt got in the way, so it was decades later that an opportunity to write finally presented itself. I honestly didn't think I had what it takes to write a full-length novel, but once I faced the blank screen and my fingers touched the keyboard, everything disappeared except my characters and their surroundings, and suddenly I knew that this was what I was born to do.
Since then, I've written many books and have enjoyed some positive reviews, but sometimes, when I stop to reflect, I'm still amazed that I'm living my dream.
Follow me on BookBub for discount deals and new release alerts.
https://www.bookbub.com/authors/irina...
Since then, I've written many books and have enjoyed some positive reviews, but sometimes, when I stop to reflect, I'm still amazed that I'm living my dream.
Follow me on BookBub for discount deals and new release alerts.
https://www.bookbub.com/authors/irina...
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 183 reviews
February 4, 2026
This was the heaviest and most gruesome book in the series. I had to take breaks because it was a lot to digest, and I’m not even sure I would’ve finished it if I weren’t already so invested.
Gemma and Sebastian are about to see their new home for the first time, but unfortunately, they find a body on the way. It’s a young woman, heavily pregnant, and the strangest part is that she seems to have undergone a postmortem. As it turns out, she’s not the only one…
I’m a little disappointed because, even though the idea may have been unique, the mystery itself wasn’t very gripping. It felt like we got gore instead of a puzzle to solve, and that’s really not my jam. Then there were some eye-rolling moments of Gemma being TSTL again, which is getting old and doesn’t really make sense given her intelligence.
Since I’m invested, and the writing still works for me, I’ll probably continue reading the series. Unfortunately, though, I didn’t enjoy this book as much as the others.
Thanks to NetGalley and Storm Publishing for the arc. All opinions are my own.
Pub Date 10 Mar 2026
Gemma and Sebastian are about to see their new home for the first time, but unfortunately, they find a body on the way. It’s a young woman, heavily pregnant, and the strangest part is that she seems to have undergone a postmortem. As it turns out, she’s not the only one…
I’m a little disappointed because, even though the idea may have been unique, the mystery itself wasn’t very gripping. It felt like we got gore instead of a puzzle to solve, and that’s really not my jam. Then there were some eye-rolling moments of Gemma being TSTL again, which is getting old and doesn’t really make sense given her intelligence.
Since I’m invested, and the writing still works for me, I’ll probably continue reading the series. Unfortunately, though, I didn’t enjoy this book as much as the others.
Thanks to NetGalley and Storm Publishing for the arc. All opinions are my own.
Pub Date 10 Mar 2026
March 12, 2026
Gemma and Sebastian are an engaged couple solving murders. There is depth to this series and I appreciate the author’s attention to detail. I was transported back in time and that is done well, too. The murders are always complex when trying to solve. As usual, kept me guessing till the end. The villains got what they deserved in the end. Highly recommend the entire series. In my opinion, you wouldn’t need to read in order it might be more enjoyable though.
I was blessed with an ARC. Thank you NetGalley and Storm Publishing. The opinions expressed are my own and unbiased.
I was blessed with an ARC. Thank you NetGalley and Storm Publishing. The opinions expressed are my own and unbiased.
March 16, 2026
3.5 Stars
One Liner: Darker plot, but getting tired of the FMC
1859, London
Nurse Gemma Tate and her fiancé, Inspector Sebastian Bell, are planning their future together, only for it to come to a halt when a woman is found dead in the alleyway behind her home. Sebastian soon finds out that this and other similar deaths are linked to a traveling carnival. Now, the duo has to find the killer and stop them before more people die.
The story comes in Gemma and Sebastian’s third-person POVs.
My Thoughts
Adding a spoiler here, as it can be a trigger for some readers: pregnant women are killed and autopsied, including the babies inside them. Also, certain characters are called using terms we consider offensive today, but this is true to the setting and the period.
The seventh book in the series can work as a standalone, though it may have some spoilers for the personal/overarching plot. There are some developments too here.
This one is quite grim. It cannot be helped based on the themes chosen. It’s an important one as well. However, the descriptions are not graphic. They are strictly on a need-to-know basis. But yes, the book is darker and heavier.
The cast is huge, though not everyone is important. Still, it will help to make a note of the names to avoid confusion.
The mystery starts with a lot of interest, red herrings, suspects, and theories. However, the resolution is convenient rather than intricate. Anyone who reads mysteries can easily guess it. Moreover, the clues and the way to the resolution aren’t really strong.
Once again, the FMC puts herself in danger because she enjoys the high of danger a bit too much. If she were a real human, things would have ended in the first book itself. I don’t understand why she has to be so TSTL when she has a decent enough brain.
There will be more books in the series, so I will continue to read. However, I hope the FMC will be more sensible and learn to think before she acts.
To summarize, The Carnival Murders is a dark mystery that sheds light on certain events from the past. While the book is still a good read, it is not the best in the series.
Thank you, NetGalley and Storm Publishing, for the eARC. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion about the book.
#NetGalley #TheCarnivalMurders
One Liner: Darker plot, but getting tired of the FMC
1859, London
Nurse Gemma Tate and her fiancé, Inspector Sebastian Bell, are planning their future together, only for it to come to a halt when a woman is found dead in the alleyway behind her home. Sebastian soon finds out that this and other similar deaths are linked to a traveling carnival. Now, the duo has to find the killer and stop them before more people die.
The story comes in Gemma and Sebastian’s third-person POVs.
My Thoughts
Adding a spoiler here, as it can be a trigger for some readers: pregnant women are killed and autopsied, including the babies inside them. Also, certain characters are called using terms we consider offensive today, but this is true to the setting and the period.
The seventh book in the series can work as a standalone, though it may have some spoilers for the personal/overarching plot. There are some developments too here.
This one is quite grim. It cannot be helped based on the themes chosen. It’s an important one as well. However, the descriptions are not graphic. They are strictly on a need-to-know basis. But yes, the book is darker and heavier.
The cast is huge, though not everyone is important. Still, it will help to make a note of the names to avoid confusion.
The mystery starts with a lot of interest, red herrings, suspects, and theories. However, the resolution is convenient rather than intricate. Anyone who reads mysteries can easily guess it. Moreover, the clues and the way to the resolution aren’t really strong.
Once again, the FMC puts herself in danger because she enjoys the high of danger a bit too much. If she were a real human, things would have ended in the first book itself. I don’t understand why she has to be so TSTL when she has a decent enough brain.
There will be more books in the series, so I will continue to read. However, I hope the FMC will be more sensible and learn to think before she acts.
To summarize, The Carnival Murders is a dark mystery that sheds light on certain events from the past. While the book is still a good read, it is not the best in the series.
Thank you, NetGalley and Storm Publishing, for the eARC. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion about the book.
#NetGalley #TheCarnivalMurders
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
London, 1859. Looking for your first home together is an exciting adventure but unfortunately for Inspector Sebastian Bell and his fiancee Gemma Tate they don't get across the threshold before being drawn into a new case. A body, horrifically mutilated, is discovered in an alley and leads the shocked couple to more deaths linked to practices Gemma thought were used only for good. Determined to get justice for those who have died Sebastian and Gemma begin an investigation which could shatter all their future plans.
I was able to read an advanced copy of this thanks to NetGalley and the publishers, Storm Publishing, but the opinions expressed are my own. This is my first book by this author but it definitely won't be my last. Beautifully written and, despite the subject matter, easy to read, I thoroughly enjoyed this and happily read deep into the night. The crimes were described in just enough detail to chill and the main protagonists were all sympathetically drawn, especially Sebastian and Gemma who I liked immediately. There were a few spoilers but nothing which would prevent me reading earlier stories in this series. Highly recommended.
I was able to read an advanced copy of this thanks to NetGalley and the publishers, Storm Publishing, but the opinions expressed are my own. This is my first book by this author but it definitely won't be my last. Beautifully written and, despite the subject matter, easy to read, I thoroughly enjoyed this and happily read deep into the night. The crimes were described in just enough detail to chill and the main protagonists were all sympathetically drawn, especially Sebastian and Gemma who I liked immediately. There were a few spoilers but nothing which would prevent me reading earlier stories in this series. Highly recommended.
May 17, 2026
Monstrous!
I think this was one of the more wretched cases Gemma Tate and Sebastian Bell become involved in. Someone is desecrating the bodies of those who society view as different, in a thoroughly scientific manner.
Gemma first becomes aware of this when a young, heavily pregnant woman, Tamzin Norris, is left near to her father’s pub. Tamzin has post mortem scars. Not only that but her unborn child has been autopsied too!
As Bell investigates along with Gemma, they discover more bodies of people who have been killed and then autopsied.
A gruesome tale, that strikes close to home for Sebastian and Gemma.
A Storm Pub. ARC via NetGalley.
Many thanks to the author and publisher.
I think this was one of the more wretched cases Gemma Tate and Sebastian Bell become involved in. Someone is desecrating the bodies of those who society view as different, in a thoroughly scientific manner.
Gemma first becomes aware of this when a young, heavily pregnant woman, Tamzin Norris, is left near to her father’s pub. Tamzin has post mortem scars. Not only that but her unborn child has been autopsied too!
As Bell investigates along with Gemma, they discover more bodies of people who have been killed and then autopsied.
A gruesome tale, that strikes close to home for Sebastian and Gemma.
A Storm Pub. ARC via NetGalley.
Many thanks to the author and publisher.
August 13, 2026
The Carnival Murders was a good read. I was struck by the murders and I was on the edge of my seat until they were solved
At the seventh book in the Tate and Bell series Irina Shapiro still manages to write a satisfying and intriguing mystery, never forgetting the trying historical time and the characters growth.
Gemma and Sebastian wedding is approaching, they are looking for a new house in Pimlico when they come across a lifeless body behind a tavern. That's how their new investigation to bring the culprit to justice begins.
We already knew that Sebastian and Gemma worked well together, but now we also see more of their feelings for each other. She is still too impulsive, and often she puts herself at risk, fortunately Sebastian is never too far and he keeps her safe.
I highly recommend to read this story, and I can't wait to get to the next one.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for kindly giving me an advanced copy of this book to read.
February 9, 2026
While searching for their first home, Gemma Tate and Inspector Sebastian Bell stumble upon the body of a young, pregnant woman. There is evidence that the woman and her unborn child were autopsied before their bodies were dumped in an alley near her father’s tavern. Sebastian’s investigation leads him to similar bodies that were autopsied prior to disposal. The murders of a pregnant dwarf and conjoined twins and the attack on a faux wolfman convince Sebastian that someone is killing carnival “freaks” to study their anatomy while their first victim was murdered as a comparison.
THE CARNIVAL MURDERS is a bit of a misnomer since there are no scenes that take place at a carnival or freak show. Some of the victims were current or former carnival workers. I must admit that I was disappointed that neither Sebastian nor Gemma got to visit a Victorian era carnival since I’m sure it would have made an interesting scene. Aside from the slight disappointment, I’ve mostly enjoyed THE CARNIVAL MURDERS. I am a huge fan of Gemma and Sebastian, and I’ve been following their investigations since the beginning of the series. I’ve enjoyed the progression of their personal relationship as well as Gemma’s growth—though she takes several unnecessary risks in this book. This book was darker than the previous ones. That, combined with Gemma’s recklessness, made for a difficult read at times.
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC.
THE CARNIVAL MURDERS is a bit of a misnomer since there are no scenes that take place at a carnival or freak show. Some of the victims were current or former carnival workers. I must admit that I was disappointed that neither Sebastian nor Gemma got to visit a Victorian era carnival since I’m sure it would have made an interesting scene. Aside from the slight disappointment, I’ve mostly enjoyed THE CARNIVAL MURDERS. I am a huge fan of Gemma and Sebastian, and I’ve been following their investigations since the beginning of the series. I’ve enjoyed the progression of their personal relationship as well as Gemma’s growth—though she takes several unnecessary risks in this book. This book was darker than the previous ones. That, combined with Gemma’s recklessness, made for a difficult read at times.
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC.
April 15, 2026
Sebastian and Gemma are at it again in this new murder mystery series. They find a corpse that has been autopsied and abandoned in an alley. The details are awful and disturbing, inspiring Sebastian and Gemma to solve the case. One murder leads to another and then to another and then to another. As Sebastian and Gemma race to find the murderers, they put themselves and their friends in harm’s way.
Shapiro is great at research. The medical knowledge of the time is spot on. The historical tidbits add flavor. Such strong writing! The characters continue to grow and change over multiple novels. The plot is thrilling with twists and red herrings.
Great for fans of Veronica Speedwell, Lady Darby and Lady Julia mysteries.
Shapiro is great at research. The medical knowledge of the time is spot on. The historical tidbits add flavor. Such strong writing! The characters continue to grow and change over multiple novels. The plot is thrilling with twists and red herrings.
Great for fans of Veronica Speedwell, Lady Darby and Lady Julia mysteries.
March 15, 2026
The romance part of the story was wonderful, as always. The mystery got bogged down a little by too many characters.
April 4, 2026
This series has gone down in quality for me. The characters are becoming increasingly erratic and the stories strange. Like this exchange, for example, seems representative of where the writing is headed:
“Despite his unwelcome advances to Poppy, Mr. Evans had impressed her as a decent man. He had seemed genuinely worried about her, and Gemma thought he was sincerely interested in Poppy.”
So which is it? Other spots in the narrative imply that the unwelcome advances were more than just uncomfortable flirtation or interest. Contradictions like this abound. Gemma is the only emotional center in the household, but she stews all night on the regular, melts down, takes days off from her live in employer more often than she works, internally criticizes her dementia patient…
At another point she asserts to herself that she will stay put if it makes the men happy because she recognizes she is in danger. But when she sits she figures out part of the case and decides to leave the house, which has patients she is supposed to be in charge of, doesn’t tell anyone where she is headed, and fully expects to google around about a murderer. That isn’t smart or brave. It is dumb and selfish.
The thing is, Shapiro is using stories ripped from the pages of a penny dreadful, very Victorian Gothic, with a modern sensibility, sometimes, for how distasteful such things are. This leads to contradictions in characterization, and didacticism that feels kind of heavy at times.
I’ll try the next if only to get these two married…I quite like Sebastian. But the macabre stories are getting to be a little grotesque for my taste, not to mention the uneven writing.
“Despite his unwelcome advances to Poppy, Mr. Evans had impressed her as a decent man. He had seemed genuinely worried about her, and Gemma thought he was sincerely interested in Poppy.”
So which is it? Other spots in the narrative imply that the unwelcome advances were more than just uncomfortable flirtation or interest. Contradictions like this abound. Gemma is the only emotional center in the household, but she stews all night on the regular, melts down, takes days off from her live in employer more often than she works, internally criticizes her dementia patient…
At another point she asserts to herself that she will stay put if it makes the men happy because she recognizes she is in danger. But when she sits she figures out part of the case and decides to leave the house, which has patients she is supposed to be in charge of, doesn’t tell anyone where she is headed, and fully expects to google around about a murderer. That isn’t smart or brave. It is dumb and selfish.
The thing is, Shapiro is using stories ripped from the pages of a penny dreadful, very Victorian Gothic, with a modern sensibility, sometimes, for how distasteful such things are. This leads to contradictions in characterization, and didacticism that feels kind of heavy at times.
I’ll try the next if only to get these two married…I quite like Sebastian. But the macabre stories are getting to be a little grotesque for my taste, not to mention the uneven writing.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
February 8, 2026
Good gracious, Gemma. I struggled to keep reading after that.
A lot of telling, even though I liked the grittier, higher stakes plot. Gemma wasn’t an equal narrative partner. She’s a nurse, but we never see her really nursing. Gemma being underutilized and acting ridiculously stupid frustrated me. You can’t even leave a note? I’m ok with characters making mistakes and having consequences, but she was unbelievably, uncharacteristically stupid here.
I looked at my reviews for the other books and I always say good plot, likable characters, but too much telling, not enough interiority, Gemma is underused, and conveniently timed, out of the blue realizations or withholdings for plot reasons. Any one of these wouldn’t be enough to make me roll my eyes, but all of them together take me out of the story.
CW Slurs for people with intellectual/developmental disabilities, dwarfism, and Black people. Used as period correct language from characters you’d expect to talk that way, but still jarring.
I received an arc from NetGalley
A lot of telling, even though I liked the grittier, higher stakes plot. Gemma wasn’t an equal narrative partner. She’s a nurse, but we never see her really nursing. Gemma being underutilized and acting ridiculously stupid frustrated me. You can’t even leave a note? I’m ok with characters making mistakes and having consequences, but she was unbelievably, uncharacteristically stupid here.
I looked at my reviews for the other books and I always say good plot, likable characters, but too much telling, not enough interiority, Gemma is underused, and conveniently timed, out of the blue realizations or withholdings for plot reasons. Any one of these wouldn’t be enough to make me roll my eyes, but all of them together take me out of the story.
CW Slurs for people with intellectual/developmental disabilities, dwarfism, and Black people. Used as period correct language from characters you’d expect to talk that way, but still jarring.
I received an arc from NetGalley
March 29, 2026
Oh! This was so much better than #6 was [for me]!
Even with Gemma going off half-cocked into danger [the yell I yelled when she was being dumb could have awakened the dead; I do think that she has actually learned her lesson this time, which is refreshing, this was an excellent [but very sad AND V E R Y gruesome] story/mystery and I was left guessing right until the end [part of which just broke my heart into a billion little pieces]. I also really enjoyed how the "supporting" characters really come into play in this book; they truly were a great addition to the overall story.
I am so glad this was a better read for me; I have loved this series from the beginning and book #6 was such a disappointment - I am glad that I didn't give up and decided to give the series another chance; I am now very much looking forward to #8!!
Thank you to NetGalley, Irina Shapiro, and Storm Publishing for providing this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Even with Gemma going off half-cocked into danger [the yell I yelled when she was being dumb could have awakened the dead; I do think that she has actually learned her lesson this time, which is refreshing, this was an excellent [but very sad AND V E R Y gruesome] story/mystery and I was left guessing right until the end [part of which just broke my heart into a billion little pieces]. I also really enjoyed how the "supporting" characters really come into play in this book; they truly were a great addition to the overall story.
I am so glad this was a better read for me; I have loved this series from the beginning and book #6 was such a disappointment - I am glad that I didn't give up and decided to give the series another chance; I am now very much looking forward to #8!!
Thank you to NetGalley, Irina Shapiro, and Storm Publishing for providing this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
March 31, 2026
I’m always here for murder mysteries with 19th-century anatomists, surgeons, resurrection men etc., so I had a great time with this installment, even if the mystery was more gory than genuinely puzzling and its resolution came down to sheer luck. I really loved the characters’ interactions and can’t wait for the next book in the series.
March 24, 2026
I love my real life personal friends Gemma and Sebastian but omg Gemma felt all together stupid as hell in this one (and she’s not a stupid person so that was disappointing)
March 11, 2026
You know i love this series and i think this might be one of the best books so far, fast pace, interesting storyline and good mystery !
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Dark Secrets Beneath the Big Top
The Carnival Murders by Irana Shapiro is another fantastic addition to the series. I love the rich carnival atmosphere, and the characters I have come to know so well across the books. The mystery is gripping with plenty of twists, making the book hard to put down. A must-read for fans of the series. The story is gripping, layered, and full of intrigue and just when you think you’ve worked it out, another twist pulls you deeper under the big top. Thanks to NetGalley and to the publishers of this book for giving me a free advance copy of the book to preview and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
The Carnival Murders by Irana Shapiro is another fantastic addition to the series. I love the rich carnival atmosphere, and the characters I have come to know so well across the books. The mystery is gripping with plenty of twists, making the book hard to put down. A must-read for fans of the series. The story is gripping, layered, and full of intrigue and just when you think you’ve worked it out, another twist pulls you deeper under the big top. Thanks to NetGalley and to the publishers of this book for giving me a free advance copy of the book to preview and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
The Carnival Murders by Irina Shapiro
Synopsis /
In a respectable London neighbourhood, nurse Gemma Tate and her fiancé, Inspector Sebastian Bell, are planning their future together. But their dreams shatter when they discover a murdered young woman, carefully arranged in a darkened alleyway behind her family home.
While Gemma unravels the woman’s final secrets in the post-mortem room, Sebastian hunts among the living. And he soon uncovers reports of similar deaths, linked to a traveling carnival. But what connects those friendless victims to the beloved woman they found?
Refusing to be beaten, Gemma and Sebastian pursue every lead on the killer’s trail, desperate to prevent more deaths. But can they stop him before he destroys not just more lives, but their own hope of happiness?
My Thoughts /
First and foremost, a huge THANK YOU to NetGalley, Storm Publishing and author, Irina Shapiro for providing me with a copy of this publication, which allows me to provide you with an unbiased review.
The Carnival Murders will be the seventh book in the Tate and Bell Mystery novels, and I'm firmly entrenched in this series now.
Set in 1850's Victorian London, this series focuses on the lives of protagonists, Inspector Sebastian Bell of Scotland Yard, and his (now) fiancée, nurse Gemma Tate.
If you enjoy reading historical mysteries I can highly recommend this series. Although best read in order, it is possible to read this series as a stand alone. Author, Irina Shapiro has again nailed the detailed descriptions of life in 1859. The attention to both the physical details of Victorian London, and the more nuanced details of what is considered the social etiquette of the time are meticulous and the reader will have no difficulty picturing the scene.
When the story opens, the newly engaged couple Sebastian and Gemma are out looking for places to live after they marry. However, their morning plans are interrupted when the pair make a grim discovery. The body of a young woman, Tamzin Norris, is found in a darkened alleyway behind her father's house in a respectable London neighbourhood. Upon closer inspection the body revealed no obvious cause of death, but strangely, there were outward signs that Tamzin's body had already been autopsied. Even more worrying was that there appeared to be indications that there were organs missing from her body. While Sebastian could have easily left this case in the hands of the local Metropolitan Police Service, he knew that as Gemma had also been the one to come across Tamzin's lifeless body, she would want him to be the one to investigate her death.
As Sebastian begins his investigation, he uncovers a series of seemingly related murders. The commonality between them is that all of the bodies had already been autopsied when they were first found, and all of the bodies appeared to have organs missing. Another worrying commonality is that the further cases all appear to be related to people with some sort of congenital defect. Apart from Tamzin, there was Holly, a young pregnant woman who suffered from dwarfism; and conjoined male twins, Elias and Silas Pruitt. In order to solve this mystery Sebastian must first work out what it is that connects all of these murders.
As we've come to expect, Gemma follows her own trail of leads. When her friend Poppy is brutally attacked while wearing Gemma's cape, the realisation that the beating was meant for her hits her hard. It became glaringly obvious that she was getting too close to the truth.
I love how this series is progressing with the side stories of Colin, his mother Anne, their maidservant Mabel, nurse Poppy and others. I'm already looking forward to the next instalment.
With thanks to NetGalley and especially to one of my favourite publishers, Storm Publishing 💗 for the much appreciated arc in return for an honest review. All opinions expressed in this review are my own. The publication date is currently set for March 10, 2026.
Synopsis /
In a respectable London neighbourhood, nurse Gemma Tate and her fiancé, Inspector Sebastian Bell, are planning their future together. But their dreams shatter when they discover a murdered young woman, carefully arranged in a darkened alleyway behind her family home.
While Gemma unravels the woman’s final secrets in the post-mortem room, Sebastian hunts among the living. And he soon uncovers reports of similar deaths, linked to a traveling carnival. But what connects those friendless victims to the beloved woman they found?
Refusing to be beaten, Gemma and Sebastian pursue every lead on the killer’s trail, desperate to prevent more deaths. But can they stop him before he destroys not just more lives, but their own hope of happiness?
My Thoughts /
First and foremost, a huge THANK YOU to NetGalley, Storm Publishing and author, Irina Shapiro for providing me with a copy of this publication, which allows me to provide you with an unbiased review.
The Carnival Murders will be the seventh book in the Tate and Bell Mystery novels, and I'm firmly entrenched in this series now.
Set in 1850's Victorian London, this series focuses on the lives of protagonists, Inspector Sebastian Bell of Scotland Yard, and his (now) fiancée, nurse Gemma Tate.
If you enjoy reading historical mysteries I can highly recommend this series. Although best read in order, it is possible to read this series as a stand alone. Author, Irina Shapiro has again nailed the detailed descriptions of life in 1859. The attention to both the physical details of Victorian London, and the more nuanced details of what is considered the social etiquette of the time are meticulous and the reader will have no difficulty picturing the scene.
When the story opens, the newly engaged couple Sebastian and Gemma are out looking for places to live after they marry. However, their morning plans are interrupted when the pair make a grim discovery. The body of a young woman, Tamzin Norris, is found in a darkened alleyway behind her father's house in a respectable London neighbourhood. Upon closer inspection the body revealed no obvious cause of death, but strangely, there were outward signs that Tamzin's body had already been autopsied. Even more worrying was that there appeared to be indications that there were organs missing from her body. While Sebastian could have easily left this case in the hands of the local Metropolitan Police Service, he knew that as Gemma had also been the one to come across Tamzin's lifeless body, she would want him to be the one to investigate her death.
As Sebastian begins his investigation, he uncovers a series of seemingly related murders. The commonality between them is that all of the bodies had already been autopsied when they were first found, and all of the bodies appeared to have organs missing. Another worrying commonality is that the further cases all appear to be related to people with some sort of congenital defect. Apart from Tamzin, there was Holly, a young pregnant woman who suffered from dwarfism; and conjoined male twins, Elias and Silas Pruitt. In order to solve this mystery Sebastian must first work out what it is that connects all of these murders.
As we've come to expect, Gemma follows her own trail of leads. When her friend Poppy is brutally attacked while wearing Gemma's cape, the realisation that the beating was meant for her hits her hard. It became glaringly obvious that she was getting too close to the truth.
I love how this series is progressing with the side stories of Colin, his mother Anne, their maidservant Mabel, nurse Poppy and others. I'm already looking forward to the next instalment.
With thanks to NetGalley and especially to one of my favourite publishers, Storm Publishing 💗 for the much appreciated arc in return for an honest review. All opinions expressed in this review are my own. The publication date is currently set for March 10, 2026.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
In her latest addition to the Tate and Bell mysteries, The Carnival Murders, Irina Shapiro delivers a chilling historical thriller that proves why this series has become a staple for fans of Victorian noir. As the seventh installment, the book offers a grisly standalone mystery while deepening the complex emotional lives of characters we have grown to love. However, readers should be cautioned: while the central crime is solved within these pages, the character arcs are a rich continuation of six previous books. If you haven’t followed Gemma and Sebastian from the beginning, you will undoubtedly miss the history that informs their every decision here.
The mystery itself is one of Shapiro’s darkest yet. It centers on a series of disturbing crimes where victims—all of whom possess various physical birth defects—have been subjected to clinical, post-mortem "autopsies." This clinical cruelty is set against the backdrop of a traveling carnival, highlighting the era's exploitation of those deemed "different." The tension spikes when Sebastian and Gemma are brought to a body at the very onset of the story that breaks the pattern they eventually establish. Unlike the other friendless victims, this woman’s connection to the others is elusive. Much of the book’s drive comes from the duo trying to figure out how these disparate souls are connected and, crucially, to whom they were truly expendable.
Beyond the procedural elements, the heart of The Carnival Murders lies in the shift in Sebastian and Gemma’s relationship. After books of slow-burn tension and professional boundaries, seeing where they end up by the final chapter was incredibly satisfying. I was super excited to see their relationship progress to this point, but even more intrigued by how this new status quo will feed into the next book. it will be interesting to see if ttheir situation will create a new dynamic and whether their professional partnership can withstand the shift in their personal lives. Their chemistry remains the series' greatest strength, and this book feels like a long-awaited reward for loyal readers.
Meanwhile, the secondary characters continue to shine. A particularly compelling subplot involves Poppy, who has lost her job at the hospital and with Gemma marrying, is hoping to potentially work for Colin. Their friendship and mutual respect have always hinted at something more, but they remain wonderfully, frustratingly human in their hesitation. Watching them navigate their potential future while struggling with their reserved and shy natures adds a layer of sweet, grounded realism to an otherwise macabre story. One can't help but wonder if they will finally find the courage to take the next step or if their own reticence will keep them at a standstill.
In short, The Carnival Murders is a must-read. It manages to be both a page-turning mystery and a moving character study. I cannot wait to see how the progress from this book impacts the team going forward as they adjust to their new lives. I definitely recommend this to any historical mystery fan and will absolutely continue reading this series. If you haven't started the Tate and Bell mysteries yet, go back to The Highgate Cemetery Murder and start there—you won’t want to miss a single step of this journey.
Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the copy in exchange for an honest review.
The mystery itself is one of Shapiro’s darkest yet. It centers on a series of disturbing crimes where victims—all of whom possess various physical birth defects—have been subjected to clinical, post-mortem "autopsies." This clinical cruelty is set against the backdrop of a traveling carnival, highlighting the era's exploitation of those deemed "different." The tension spikes when Sebastian and Gemma are brought to a body at the very onset of the story that breaks the pattern they eventually establish. Unlike the other friendless victims, this woman’s connection to the others is elusive. Much of the book’s drive comes from the duo trying to figure out how these disparate souls are connected and, crucially, to whom they were truly expendable.
Beyond the procedural elements, the heart of The Carnival Murders lies in the shift in Sebastian and Gemma’s relationship. After books of slow-burn tension and professional boundaries, seeing where they end up by the final chapter was incredibly satisfying. I was super excited to see their relationship progress to this point, but even more intrigued by how this new status quo will feed into the next book. it will be interesting to see if ttheir situation will create a new dynamic and whether their professional partnership can withstand the shift in their personal lives. Their chemistry remains the series' greatest strength, and this book feels like a long-awaited reward for loyal readers.
Meanwhile, the secondary characters continue to shine. A particularly compelling subplot involves Poppy, who has lost her job at the hospital and with Gemma marrying, is hoping to potentially work for Colin. Their friendship and mutual respect have always hinted at something more, but they remain wonderfully, frustratingly human in their hesitation. Watching them navigate their potential future while struggling with their reserved and shy natures adds a layer of sweet, grounded realism to an otherwise macabre story. One can't help but wonder if they will finally find the courage to take the next step or if their own reticence will keep them at a standstill.
In short, The Carnival Murders is a must-read. It manages to be both a page-turning mystery and a moving character study. I cannot wait to see how the progress from this book impacts the team going forward as they adjust to their new lives. I definitely recommend this to any historical mystery fan and will absolutely continue reading this series. If you haven't started the Tate and Bell mysteries yet, go back to The Highgate Cemetery Murder and start there—you won’t want to miss a single step of this journey.
Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the copy in exchange for an honest review.
March 11, 2026
My thanks to NetGalley and Storm for an advance readers’ copy of this novel.
This is the 7th in Irina Shapiro’s Tate and Bell mystery series. Once again, the author wonderfully evokes Victorian London, in both its sunny and shady aspects. Nurse Gemma Tait and Scotland Yard Inspector Sebastian Bell have a foot in both worlds. As the story begins, Gemma is about to leave her position as nurse-companion to an elderly woman with dementia to prepare for her wedding to Sebastian, whom she also assists in investigations. She is all set to meet Sebastian to look at a house in the London suburb of Pimlico. They are happy and hoping to find their first home together.
As it happens, Gemma’s arrival at the property, only minutes after his, sends their momentary contentment entirely askew. A panicked young constable dashing toward the nearby police station takes them to the site of a gruesome murder. In his daily rounds, the Constable had found a young woman in an alley near a popular working-class pub. What particularly rattled him, Gemma and Sebastian in turn were the details given away by her body: she was young, heavily pregnant, and had visible rough stitches from her forehead through her torso indicating where she had been deliberately cut. The two immediately recognized that she had been autopsied.
Despite the singular details of the murder, soon a number of others, all imitating the murder method, show up. Except for that of Tamzin, a recently married young woman whose father owned the pub near where she was found, the others are linked by their victims’ connection to a visiting carnival, where they perform for an enthusiastic paying audience in the so-called Freak Show.
It is difficult to read about the murders, considering their details, but also about these poor people who would likely be discarded at very young ages if they were not sold, usually by their own parents, into the demeaning indenture that gave them the status of performing animals. This, of course, is not fiction and neither is the covert medical experimentation that gave rise to the grave-robbing phenomenon. It’s no stretch to think that some humans, considered inferior, might well be murdered for the brutal scientific abuse of their bodies. For all that this is difficult reading, it is not gratuitous. Shapiro shows us a society deeply conflicted about science and ethics.
The mystery is, as usual, smartly paced with just enough revealing information to move it along without making the resolution obvious. Once again, Gemma and Sebastian are sympathetic characters, and their tenderness toward each other and compassion for the abused and victimized are evident. Sebastian is as solid as ever, but I found Gemma occasionally taking risks that can only be called ill-considered and potentially dangerous. Still, characters can’t be unchanging over 7 volumes without making the story predictable and unchallenging, and I’m interested to see where these two and their relationship go.
This is the 7th in Irina Shapiro’s Tate and Bell mystery series. Once again, the author wonderfully evokes Victorian London, in both its sunny and shady aspects. Nurse Gemma Tait and Scotland Yard Inspector Sebastian Bell have a foot in both worlds. As the story begins, Gemma is about to leave her position as nurse-companion to an elderly woman with dementia to prepare for her wedding to Sebastian, whom she also assists in investigations. She is all set to meet Sebastian to look at a house in the London suburb of Pimlico. They are happy and hoping to find their first home together.
As it happens, Gemma’s arrival at the property, only minutes after his, sends their momentary contentment entirely askew. A panicked young constable dashing toward the nearby police station takes them to the site of a gruesome murder. In his daily rounds, the Constable had found a young woman in an alley near a popular working-class pub. What particularly rattled him, Gemma and Sebastian in turn were the details given away by her body: she was young, heavily pregnant, and had visible rough stitches from her forehead through her torso indicating where she had been deliberately cut. The two immediately recognized that she had been autopsied.
Despite the singular details of the murder, soon a number of others, all imitating the murder method, show up. Except for that of Tamzin, a recently married young woman whose father owned the pub near where she was found, the others are linked by their victims’ connection to a visiting carnival, where they perform for an enthusiastic paying audience in the so-called Freak Show.
It is difficult to read about the murders, considering their details, but also about these poor people who would likely be discarded at very young ages if they were not sold, usually by their own parents, into the demeaning indenture that gave them the status of performing animals. This, of course, is not fiction and neither is the covert medical experimentation that gave rise to the grave-robbing phenomenon. It’s no stretch to think that some humans, considered inferior, might well be murdered for the brutal scientific abuse of their bodies. For all that this is difficult reading, it is not gratuitous. Shapiro shows us a society deeply conflicted about science and ethics.
The mystery is, as usual, smartly paced with just enough revealing information to move it along without making the resolution obvious. Once again, Gemma and Sebastian are sympathetic characters, and their tenderness toward each other and compassion for the abused and victimized are evident. Sebastian is as solid as ever, but I found Gemma occasionally taking risks that can only be called ill-considered and potentially dangerous. Still, characters can’t be unchanging over 7 volumes without making the story predictable and unchallenging, and I’m interested to see where these two and their relationship go.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I read this book as a NetGalley ARC and this review is my honest opinion about the book based on my reading it. NB-The story depicts violent crime.
This is my first book in the Tate and Bell historical mystery series and considering that the series is several books old this was a solid entry for me and Irina an author whose works I would look out for in the future.
4.5 stars for the book which would be a perfect five but Gemma's idiosyncrasies brought it down a bit.
Gemma who is a nurse and Inspector Sebastian Bell are preparing for their wedding and hoping for a quieter stretch after the events of their previous investigations. That peace does not last long. The discovery of a young woman’s body near Gemma’s home quickly draws Sebastian into another disturbing case. What initially appears to be a single murder soon reveals deeper and more troubling connections. Evidence begins to suggest that the death may be tied to a travelling carnival and possibly to other victims.
The partnership and relationship between Gemma and Sebastian feels natural and supportive, with each bringing different skills to the investigation. Sebastian works through official police channels while Gemma contributes insight from her medical training and observations from the postmortem room. The balance between the two perspectives keeps the story moving and gives the investigation a fuller picture.
The Victorian setting is handled with confidence. The details of London life, medical practices and the realities of policing during the period add texture to the story without overwhelming the mystery. The author clearly understands the time period and uses those details to strengthen the atmosphere rather than distract from the plot.
The mystery itself unfolds steadily. As the investigation progresses, more pieces of the puzzle appear and the scope of the crimes becomes clearer. The carnival element adds an unsettling tone to the story and provides a backdrop that feels both mysterious and slightly sinister.
This is a dark case and the subject matter is at times uncomfortable. This also raises the stakes and makes the investigation feel more urgent. Readers who have followed Gemma and Sebastian from earlier books will likely appreciate seeing their characters continue to develop as they face another difficult case.
Overall this was an absorbing historical mystery with strong characters and a solid central investigation. A very enjoyable addition to the series and an easy recommendation for readers who enjoy Victorian crime fiction.
This is my first book in the Tate and Bell historical mystery series and considering that the series is several books old this was a solid entry for me and Irina an author whose works I would look out for in the future.
4.5 stars for the book which would be a perfect five but Gemma's idiosyncrasies brought it down a bit.
Gemma who is a nurse and Inspector Sebastian Bell are preparing for their wedding and hoping for a quieter stretch after the events of their previous investigations. That peace does not last long. The discovery of a young woman’s body near Gemma’s home quickly draws Sebastian into another disturbing case. What initially appears to be a single murder soon reveals deeper and more troubling connections. Evidence begins to suggest that the death may be tied to a travelling carnival and possibly to other victims.
The partnership and relationship between Gemma and Sebastian feels natural and supportive, with each bringing different skills to the investigation. Sebastian works through official police channels while Gemma contributes insight from her medical training and observations from the postmortem room. The balance between the two perspectives keeps the story moving and gives the investigation a fuller picture.
The Victorian setting is handled with confidence. The details of London life, medical practices and the realities of policing during the period add texture to the story without overwhelming the mystery. The author clearly understands the time period and uses those details to strengthen the atmosphere rather than distract from the plot.
The mystery itself unfolds steadily. As the investigation progresses, more pieces of the puzzle appear and the scope of the crimes becomes clearer. The carnival element adds an unsettling tone to the story and provides a backdrop that feels both mysterious and slightly sinister.
This is a dark case and the subject matter is at times uncomfortable. This also raises the stakes and makes the investigation feel more urgent. Readers who have followed Gemma and Sebastian from earlier books will likely appreciate seeing their characters continue to develop as they face another difficult case.
Overall this was an absorbing historical mystery with strong characters and a solid central investigation. A very enjoyable addition to the series and an easy recommendation for readers who enjoy Victorian crime fiction.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
What can I say? I love this series. I admit that I am still mourning the demise of Victoria Thompson and her Gaslight Mystery series (GMs), but fortunately I have discovered the Tate and Bell Mystery series by Irina Shapiro, which has the added benefit of narration by one of my favorite narrators, Imogene Church – that is when I can wait for publication. I did not have to wait this time, as I nabbed an ARC from NetGalley and loved it (that doesn't mean I won't listen for a second "read" on publication date). I see two more books in the series are due out this year…This is exciting news for me as both GMs and KBs (noted below) have published out only single volumes a year, not including novellas and stories, and I pine all year yearning the next new publication!
The Carnival Murders, Book Seven in the series, takes place circa 1850s, half a century earlier that GMs and half a century more gruesome. Gemma Tate one of Florence Nightingale's Crimean War nurses, and Inspector Sebastian Bell of Scotland Yard, have teamed up again to solve a mystery where pregnant women, dangerous psychopaths, and carnival "freaks" (excuse the misnomer but I believe "freak show" to be the correct Victorian carnival terminology of the period) are murdered for what appears to the singularly bizarre purpose of conducting autopsies on their bodies. Who is targeting these victims and to what purpose? – Have no fear, Gemma and Sebastion (with the aid of the unwitting Colin and Poppy, pathologist and Crimean War colleague, accordingly) will get to the bottom of the affair.
My only reservation (I won't say criticism because I love these series too much) is that, just as in the case of Linda Castillo's Kate Burkholder Series (KBs), another one of my absolute favorites – the heroines tend to throw caution to the wind and rush off into danger without proper back-up????
How long must Tate and Bell restrain their passions before all the stars are aligned for their betrothal to finally culminate into marital bliss. No spoilers here!
Thank you NetGalley and Storm Publishing for the ARC – My views are my own and they are echoed in all my reviews of the previous books in the series!
The Carnival Murders, Book Seven in the series, takes place circa 1850s, half a century earlier that GMs and half a century more gruesome. Gemma Tate one of Florence Nightingale's Crimean War nurses, and Inspector Sebastian Bell of Scotland Yard, have teamed up again to solve a mystery where pregnant women, dangerous psychopaths, and carnival "freaks" (excuse the misnomer but I believe "freak show" to be the correct Victorian carnival terminology of the period) are murdered for what appears to the singularly bizarre purpose of conducting autopsies on their bodies. Who is targeting these victims and to what purpose? – Have no fear, Gemma and Sebastion (with the aid of the unwitting Colin and Poppy, pathologist and Crimean War colleague, accordingly) will get to the bottom of the affair.
My only reservation (I won't say criticism because I love these series too much) is that, just as in the case of Linda Castillo's Kate Burkholder Series (KBs), another one of my absolute favorites – the heroines tend to throw caution to the wind and rush off into danger without proper back-up????
How long must Tate and Bell restrain their passions before all the stars are aligned for their betrothal to finally culminate into marital bliss. No spoilers here!
Thank you NetGalley and Storm Publishing for the ARC – My views are my own and they are echoed in all my reviews of the previous books in the series!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
REVIEW
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for this ARC. I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
STORYLINE :
Another great addition in the Tate and Bell series! This is book number seven in the series, and each book can be read alone and unique on its own.
In this book, we have gruesome murders of victims who have had autopsies done after they died and before they were dumped. Some of the victims were pregnant women and people living with congenital abnormalities. This book is quite emotional because of the gruesome cases.
As usual, Bell and Tate got on the case and started turning all stones. My favourite thing about this book and this series is how at first, you know nothing, obviously. But, everything starts unfolding as the book progresses, and each witness, evidence reveals something new.
I loved what happened to the brains behind the operation. Otherwise, they wouldn't have been punished.
CHARACTERS:
Phenomenal as usual! From the indomitable, fearless nurse, Gemma. I love what's going on with her and how she's naturally curious, especially about ways to increase her medical knowledge. She might be the pioneer forensic nurse. But, I hope she doesn't stop being a nurse.
Sebastian is always an amazing character and a dogged inspector who does it all for his victims. I hope to see a promotion for him in the near future.
I loved the romance between Gemma and Sebastian. It was enough to be felt, but not too much to be overpowering. Their chemistry is wonderful! But, I was so disappointed with the epilogue, I would have loved to read a ceremony.
I also liked the recurring characters like Colin, Gustav, Anne, Mabel, and Poppy. Amazing people.
WRITING STYLE:
Perfect! There is no room for confusion despite the fact that it's part of a series. I liked the chapters, the pace. I have no complaints.
SETTINGS:
The various settings were well described too, you can get a hint of the places, and I liked that.
OVERALL:
A very good book and even better series. No book is the same as the other hand you don't have to read accordingly. I would definitely recommend
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for this ARC. I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
STORYLINE :
Another great addition in the Tate and Bell series! This is book number seven in the series, and each book can be read alone and unique on its own.
In this book, we have gruesome murders of victims who have had autopsies done after they died and before they were dumped. Some of the victims were pregnant women and people living with congenital abnormalities. This book is quite emotional because of the gruesome cases.
As usual, Bell and Tate got on the case and started turning all stones. My favourite thing about this book and this series is how at first, you know nothing, obviously. But, everything starts unfolding as the book progresses, and each witness, evidence reveals something new.
I loved what happened to the brains behind the operation. Otherwise, they wouldn't have been punished.
CHARACTERS:
Phenomenal as usual! From the indomitable, fearless nurse, Gemma. I love what's going on with her and how she's naturally curious, especially about ways to increase her medical knowledge. She might be the pioneer forensic nurse. But, I hope she doesn't stop being a nurse.
Sebastian is always an amazing character and a dogged inspector who does it all for his victims. I hope to see a promotion for him in the near future.
I loved the romance between Gemma and Sebastian. It was enough to be felt, but not too much to be overpowering. Their chemistry is wonderful! But, I was so disappointed with the epilogue, I would have loved to read a ceremony.
I also liked the recurring characters like Colin, Gustav, Anne, Mabel, and Poppy. Amazing people.
WRITING STYLE:
Perfect! There is no room for confusion despite the fact that it's part of a series. I liked the chapters, the pace. I have no complaints.
SETTINGS:
The various settings were well described too, you can get a hint of the places, and I liked that.
OVERALL:
A very good book and even better series. No book is the same as the other hand you don't have to read accordingly. I would definitely recommend
April 2, 2026
The Carnival Murders by Irina Shapiro is another absolutely gripping installment in the Tate and Bell mystery series—and one that completely pulled me in from the very first page. I’ve been loving this series more with every book, and this one might be one of the most compelling yet.
Set in vividly rendered Victorian London, the atmosphere is dark, immersive, and incredibly well done. The author has such a talent for bringing the time period to life, blending historical detail seamlessly into a fast-paced and engaging mystery. I felt completely transported into the narrow alleys, bustling streets, and shadowy corners of the city.
The mystery itself is intense, layered, and at times quite gruesome—but in a way that adds depth and realism rather than feeling gratuitous. The investigation into the murders is fascinating, with just the right balance of clues, red herrings, and reveals to keep me guessing right up until the end. I genuinely didn’t see the full picture coming, and the final reveal was both shocking and satisfying.
As always, Gemma and Sebastian are at the heart of what makes this series so special. Their partnership continues to shine, blending intelligence, compassion, and determination. I love how they complement each other—Sebastian’s steady resolve paired with Gemma’s curiosity and courage makes them such a compelling team. Their relationship also adds a warm emotional layer that balances the darker elements of the story beautifully.
The supporting cast continues to feel like a community, adding richness and familiarity that makes returning to this series such a joy. These characters truly feel like old friends at this point, and I’m always excited to see where their journeys go next.
If you enjoy historical mysteries with strong characters, atmospheric settings, and a touch of romance, this series is an absolute must-read. The Carnival Murders is a dark, twisty, and completely addictive read that kept me hooked until the very last page—and I’m already looking forward to the next installment.
✨ Thank you to NetGalley, Storm Publishing, and the author for the ARC. All opinions are my own.
Set in vividly rendered Victorian London, the atmosphere is dark, immersive, and incredibly well done. The author has such a talent for bringing the time period to life, blending historical detail seamlessly into a fast-paced and engaging mystery. I felt completely transported into the narrow alleys, bustling streets, and shadowy corners of the city.
The mystery itself is intense, layered, and at times quite gruesome—but in a way that adds depth and realism rather than feeling gratuitous. The investigation into the murders is fascinating, with just the right balance of clues, red herrings, and reveals to keep me guessing right up until the end. I genuinely didn’t see the full picture coming, and the final reveal was both shocking and satisfying.
As always, Gemma and Sebastian are at the heart of what makes this series so special. Their partnership continues to shine, blending intelligence, compassion, and determination. I love how they complement each other—Sebastian’s steady resolve paired with Gemma’s curiosity and courage makes them such a compelling team. Their relationship also adds a warm emotional layer that balances the darker elements of the story beautifully.
The supporting cast continues to feel like a community, adding richness and familiarity that makes returning to this series such a joy. These characters truly feel like old friends at this point, and I’m always excited to see where their journeys go next.
If you enjoy historical mysteries with strong characters, atmospheric settings, and a touch of romance, this series is an absolute must-read. The Carnival Murders is a dark, twisty, and completely addictive read that kept me hooked until the very last page—and I’m already looking forward to the next installment.
✨ Thank you to NetGalley, Storm Publishing, and the author for the ARC. All opinions are my own.
March 13, 2026
The Carnival Murders by Irina Shapiro is part of a series and this is the first I’ve read. That being said, this is a supremely readable book. The protagonists are Sebastian Bell and his betrothed, Gemma. Sebastian is a police detective and Gemma is a caregiver for a woman with dementia. The draw was her son who was a doctor and conducted autopsies. She had been a nurse in the Crimea during the war and her interest was keen and pretty much forbidden. Simon’s wife had been murdered and with her their child. All because of a case he had worked. He was over it now, but worried. One of the things about Gemma that attracted him was her independence. Both a good and bad trait. The murder was an odd one. A pregnant woman whose body had been autopsied and her brain stolen. When Sebastian went back to the station to request this case, he found their had been another nearby, unidentified. All but the latest had been carnival sideshow workers. As that a clue? Each conversation he had added a detail or two to the picture until it all came together, with Gemma’s help.
These are wonderful, well-written characters, well-rounded with plenty of detail regarding their personalities. This story took place in a time when doctors were mostly ignorant of the human body. There were grave robbers out there who delivered recently deceased to often unscrupulous doctors. Gemma was fortunate that the doctor she worked for was opened minder and allowed her to assist and even go to listen to speakers on a variety of topics, normally closed to women. This story is a glimpse into that world. Sebastian discovered other similar murders and an attempted murder. All these things drew an interesting picture. People were in danger. Sebastian found the guilty party and saved some lives, but there were other doctors out there. Good read.
I was invited to read The Carnival Murders by Storm Publishing. All thoughts and opinions are mine. #Netgalley #StormPublishing #IrinaShapiro #TheCarnivalMurders
These are wonderful, well-written characters, well-rounded with plenty of detail regarding their personalities. This story took place in a time when doctors were mostly ignorant of the human body. There were grave robbers out there who delivered recently deceased to often unscrupulous doctors. Gemma was fortunate that the doctor she worked for was opened minder and allowed her to assist and even go to listen to speakers on a variety of topics, normally closed to women. This story is a glimpse into that world. Sebastian discovered other similar murders and an attempted murder. All these things drew an interesting picture. People were in danger. Sebastian found the guilty party and saved some lives, but there were other doctors out there. Good read.
I was invited to read The Carnival Murders by Storm Publishing. All thoughts and opinions are mine. #Netgalley #StormPublishing #IrinaShapiro #TheCarnivalMurders
February 27, 2026
Thank you to Storm Publishing and NetGalley for the ARC of The Carnival Murders in exchange for an honest review.
The Tate and Bell Mystery series is hands down one of my all time favorite series I’ve ever had the pleasure of devouring. I’ve been on this ride since the prerelease of book one and I cannot believe that we are already on book seven! What’s even crazier might you ask?? These books just keep getting better and better as the series progresses. Irina Shapiro’s writing is honestly masterful in the way she transports her readers to the very heart of 1859 London.
This installment was especially exciting as Gemma and Sebastian navigate their pending nuptials (it’s about freaking time) alongside their most recent peculiar murder investigations. I found this series of murders especially interesting as someone who lives and works in the medical community. It becomes evident that the most recent string of murders are directly tied to some of the first medical research done on developmental and physical abnormalities. In a time where science was crudely understood and only just beginning to explore anatomy and physiology traits, it was incredibly interesting to explore how doctors (and criminals) approached learning about the human body and what we know of today as genetics and the building blocks of DNA / inheritance patterns.
As always, Gemma’s independent nature and vivacious personality draws me to her character time and time again. She is the perfect counterbalance for Sebastian. It’s so exciting to see their relationship finally moving forward as they both deserve a second chance at love and happiness. I for one am especially excited for a future baby Bell! Could we see the same for Colin and Poppy in the near future? As long as Irina keeps blessing us with future installments of this series, she has a fan for life in me! Another 5 stars for the Tate and Bell Mystery Series!
The Tate and Bell Mystery series is hands down one of my all time favorite series I’ve ever had the pleasure of devouring. I’ve been on this ride since the prerelease of book one and I cannot believe that we are already on book seven! What’s even crazier might you ask?? These books just keep getting better and better as the series progresses. Irina Shapiro’s writing is honestly masterful in the way she transports her readers to the very heart of 1859 London.
This installment was especially exciting as Gemma and Sebastian navigate their pending nuptials (it’s about freaking time) alongside their most recent peculiar murder investigations. I found this series of murders especially interesting as someone who lives and works in the medical community. It becomes evident that the most recent string of murders are directly tied to some of the first medical research done on developmental and physical abnormalities. In a time where science was crudely understood and only just beginning to explore anatomy and physiology traits, it was incredibly interesting to explore how doctors (and criminals) approached learning about the human body and what we know of today as genetics and the building blocks of DNA / inheritance patterns.
As always, Gemma’s independent nature and vivacious personality draws me to her character time and time again. She is the perfect counterbalance for Sebastian. It’s so exciting to see their relationship finally moving forward as they both deserve a second chance at love and happiness. I for one am especially excited for a future baby Bell! Could we see the same for Colin and Poppy in the near future? As long as Irina keeps blessing us with future installments of this series, she has a fan for life in me! Another 5 stars for the Tate and Bell Mystery Series!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
The Carnival Murders is a wonderfully crafted blend of intrigue, tenderness, and that unmistakable Victorian mood that makes the era feel both haunting and full of quiet hope. From the opening discovery of a young woman posed in a darkened London alley, the story pulls you into a world where danger and compassion walk side by side.
Gemma Tate and Inspector Sebastian Bell make a truly compelling duo—not just professionally, but emotionally. Their relationship adds a lovely warmth to the book, grounding the investigation in something deeply human. Gemma’s scenes in the postmortem room are filled with empathy and quiet strength, while Sebastian’s search among the living brings grit and urgency to the narrative. They complement each other so naturally that you can’t help rooting for their future together.
The mystery itself is richly layered. The connection to a traveling carnival gives the story a wonderfully eerie, almost gothic tension, and the contrast between the beloved young woman found near Gemma’s home and the lonely, forgotten victims on the carnival’s path adds heartbreaking depth. Each clue unfolds with satisfying pacing, building to a sense of urgency that keeps the pages turning.
What I especially enjoyed is the emotional undertone running beneath the crime—grief, compassion, fear, and the fragile threads of hope. You feel the personal stakes for Gemma and Sebastian, not just in solving the case, but in protecting the life they’re trying to build together.
With its evocative setting, engaging mystery, and heartfelt character work, The Carnival Murders is a standout read for fans of Andrea Penrose, Anna Lee Huber, and the Lady Sherlock series. Atmospheric, warm, and wonderfully immersive.
A gripping and tender Victorian mystery I thoroughly enjoyed.
With thanks to Irina Shapiro, the publisher and netgalley for the ARC
Gemma Tate and Inspector Sebastian Bell make a truly compelling duo—not just professionally, but emotionally. Their relationship adds a lovely warmth to the book, grounding the investigation in something deeply human. Gemma’s scenes in the postmortem room are filled with empathy and quiet strength, while Sebastian’s search among the living brings grit and urgency to the narrative. They complement each other so naturally that you can’t help rooting for their future together.
The mystery itself is richly layered. The connection to a traveling carnival gives the story a wonderfully eerie, almost gothic tension, and the contrast between the beloved young woman found near Gemma’s home and the lonely, forgotten victims on the carnival’s path adds heartbreaking depth. Each clue unfolds with satisfying pacing, building to a sense of urgency that keeps the pages turning.
What I especially enjoyed is the emotional undertone running beneath the crime—grief, compassion, fear, and the fragile threads of hope. You feel the personal stakes for Gemma and Sebastian, not just in solving the case, but in protecting the life they’re trying to build together.
With its evocative setting, engaging mystery, and heartfelt character work, The Carnival Murders is a standout read for fans of Andrea Penrose, Anna Lee Huber, and the Lady Sherlock series. Atmospheric, warm, and wonderfully immersive.
A gripping and tender Victorian mystery I thoroughly enjoyed.
With thanks to Irina Shapiro, the publisher and netgalley for the ARC
March 12, 2026
Gemma Tate and Sebastian Bell were about to view a house that they hoped would soon become their home, their wedding was only a short time away, but fate stepped in when they came across the body of a heavily pregnant woman who had been mutilated in the most heinous way.
This story is set in Victorian London, Gemma is a nurse who had seen atrocities whilst tending injured soldiers in the Crimea that no person should have to see, it made her determined to study medicine but sadly that was a door that was firmly closed to women, being a nurse was the next best thing and she was employed by surgeon, Colin Ramsey, to care for his rapidly declining mother, this suited Gemma because she was able to observe Colin's work and she was a keen student.
Sebastian was an inspector at Scotland Yard, when he saw the poor woman's body he knew that house hunting with his beloved Gemma would have to wait, he had a murder to solve.
The body count started to escalate and a pattern was appearing, they were all either pregnant or at some time had belonged to the travelling carnival's freak show, all had been violated in the same hideous way.
With Gemma's input, Sebastian started putting the pieces together, what was the common denominator ? why were the bodies left where they were ? what connected a beautiful pregnant wife to the poor unfortunates from the freak show ?
This is a well written story with a unique, if macabre, storyline, the poverty, the filth, the smells, the despair of Victorian London was palpable. I have to admit that I didn't warm to Gemma in this story, she was employed by the lovely Colin to care for his mother but she spends most of her time getting into awkward, dangerous situations, for a seemingly intelligent woman, she was very thoughtless and naïve at times.
Thank you Storm Publishing and Net Gallery for this ARC, my review is totally voluntary.
This story is set in Victorian London, Gemma is a nurse who had seen atrocities whilst tending injured soldiers in the Crimea that no person should have to see, it made her determined to study medicine but sadly that was a door that was firmly closed to women, being a nurse was the next best thing and she was employed by surgeon, Colin Ramsey, to care for his rapidly declining mother, this suited Gemma because she was able to observe Colin's work and she was a keen student.
Sebastian was an inspector at Scotland Yard, when he saw the poor woman's body he knew that house hunting with his beloved Gemma would have to wait, he had a murder to solve.
The body count started to escalate and a pattern was appearing, they were all either pregnant or at some time had belonged to the travelling carnival's freak show, all had been violated in the same hideous way.
With Gemma's input, Sebastian started putting the pieces together, what was the common denominator ? why were the bodies left where they were ? what connected a beautiful pregnant wife to the poor unfortunates from the freak show ?
This is a well written story with a unique, if macabre, storyline, the poverty, the filth, the smells, the despair of Victorian London was palpable. I have to admit that I didn't warm to Gemma in this story, she was employed by the lovely Colin to care for his mother but she spends most of her time getting into awkward, dangerous situations, for a seemingly intelligent woman, she was very thoughtless and naïve at times.
Thank you Storm Publishing and Net Gallery for this ARC, my review is totally voluntary.
March 13, 2026
4/5 stars: This is Shapiro's fourth entry in the Tate and Bell Mystery series, which is a Historical Mystery set in London, England 1859. Featuring an unconventional nurse and her police inspector fiance as they work together to investigate the murder of a pregnant young woman. They soon uncover reports of similar deaths, linked to a traveling carnival. But what connects those friendless victims to the beloved woman they found? Refusing to be beaten, the two pursue every lead on the killer’s trail, desperate to prevent more deaths. But can they stop the killer before more lives are destroyed and their own hope of happiness is crushed.
With plenty of twists and turns, Shapiro has crafted a mystery that deftly balances the suspects and weaves in plenty of clues and red herrings that will leave you pondering the whodunit until the final reveal. Written in dual POV, Shapiro's writing and character work are excellent; the characters are well-rounded and complex while remaining likable with a secondary cast that are well crafted and uniquely voiced. The historical research Shapiro's done is evident and well done without overshadowing the overall mystery plot and providing a sense of time and place perfectly.
Shapiro touches on some sensitive topics; so take care and the CWs. While you could read this as a stand-alone, you'll gain so much more by reading the series from the beginning; so be sure to pick up book one, The Highgate Cemetery Murder.
I received this eARC thanks to NetGalley and Storm Publishing in exchange for an honest review. Publishing dates are subject to change.
With plenty of twists and turns, Shapiro has crafted a mystery that deftly balances the suspects and weaves in plenty of clues and red herrings that will leave you pondering the whodunit until the final reveal. Written in dual POV, Shapiro's writing and character work are excellent; the characters are well-rounded and complex while remaining likable with a secondary cast that are well crafted and uniquely voiced. The historical research Shapiro's done is evident and well done without overshadowing the overall mystery plot and providing a sense of time and place perfectly.
Shapiro touches on some sensitive topics; so take care and the CWs. While you could read this as a stand-alone, you'll gain so much more by reading the series from the beginning; so be sure to pick up book one, The Highgate Cemetery Murder.
I received this eARC thanks to NetGalley and Storm Publishing in exchange for an honest review. Publishing dates are subject to change.
April 8, 2026
There are murder stories that are factual and then there are murder stories with atmospheric backgrounds, complicated characters from varying backgrounds which add so much depth to the story. Ms. Shapiro’s stories are like that. From the first to the last you are swept into Gemma’s and Sebastian’s lives.
Gemma and Detective Sebastian hope to get married as soon as possible. Colin not able to release Gemma from her nursing duties has been a frustrating obstacle to them but now with a date set both of them feel they are moving forward to a joyful period from the very hard and harsh realities they’ve lived through.
With the discovery of a young woman’s body found autopsied and followed by others they know they are looking out for a cold blooded surgeon killer. The killer seems to be fixated on human beings with disabilities and once the investigation starts several hitherto unknown cases keep getting mentioned. The fact that they were poor, disabled and had no family looking out for them, may be one of the reasons the killer did not get any attention. The first body discovered by Gemma and Sebastian was the anomaly. A normal young woman pregnant with her first child.
Apart from the detective work pursuing the killer and knowing that he would have the patronage of a higher class in society made their job harder. What added to the interest was how the background of the victims was woven into the story, sad though those backgrounds were. The inhumane treatment of anyone who was physically different during Victorian times was horrible. And there was no recourse for the victims. There was no social justice at all. The power of birth and money was paramount.
Connecting the victims from the conjoined twins to the dwarf murdered to Tamzin was hard but they got to the villain in the end
Not an easy read but it was a compulsive one.
Gemma and Detective Sebastian hope to get married as soon as possible. Colin not able to release Gemma from her nursing duties has been a frustrating obstacle to them but now with a date set both of them feel they are moving forward to a joyful period from the very hard and harsh realities they’ve lived through.
With the discovery of a young woman’s body found autopsied and followed by others they know they are looking out for a cold blooded surgeon killer. The killer seems to be fixated on human beings with disabilities and once the investigation starts several hitherto unknown cases keep getting mentioned. The fact that they were poor, disabled and had no family looking out for them, may be one of the reasons the killer did not get any attention. The first body discovered by Gemma and Sebastian was the anomaly. A normal young woman pregnant with her first child.
Apart from the detective work pursuing the killer and knowing that he would have the patronage of a higher class in society made their job harder. What added to the interest was how the background of the victims was woven into the story, sad though those backgrounds were. The inhumane treatment of anyone who was physically different during Victorian times was horrible. And there was no recourse for the victims. There was no social justice at all. The power of birth and money was paramount.
Connecting the victims from the conjoined twins to the dwarf murdered to Tamzin was hard but they got to the villain in the end
Not an easy read but it was a compulsive one.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
The Carnival Murders is the latest installment in the Tate and Bell series by Irina Shapiro. With Sebastian Bell and Gemma Tate now engaged, they set out to find a suitable home to begin their life together. Naturally, before they can even view the first house, a body is discovered and any thoughts of house hunting are immediately abandoned.
The victim, a young woman in advanced pregnancy, has been autopsied and expertly sewn back together before being left in a public place. Not only had she been autopsied, but her unborn child had been removed from her womb and autopsied as well. It is one of the most disturbing and intricate cases they have faced, raising questions that feel more complex than anything in their previous investigations. From that moment on, the mystery takes center stage.
Gemma continues to push forward in her medical training, though she is constantly reminded that she is a woman in a profession dominated by men. Her frustration is palpable, and it adds depth to both her character and the era in which the story is set. The slow burn between Gemma and Sebastian continues to develop in a satisfying way. Sebastian respects Gemma’s intelligence and contributions while still reflecting the protective instincts of a Victorian gentleman. That balance has become one of the strengths of this series.
This was a compelling afternoon read and a strong addition to the series. I’m already looking forward to the next installment. Something tells me a wedding may not go off without at least one complication.
Thank you to NetGalley and Storm Publishing for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.
The victim, a young woman in advanced pregnancy, has been autopsied and expertly sewn back together before being left in a public place. Not only had she been autopsied, but her unborn child had been removed from her womb and autopsied as well. It is one of the most disturbing and intricate cases they have faced, raising questions that feel more complex than anything in their previous investigations. From that moment on, the mystery takes center stage.
Gemma continues to push forward in her medical training, though she is constantly reminded that she is a woman in a profession dominated by men. Her frustration is palpable, and it adds depth to both her character and the era in which the story is set. The slow burn between Gemma and Sebastian continues to develop in a satisfying way. Sebastian respects Gemma’s intelligence and contributions while still reflecting the protective instincts of a Victorian gentleman. That balance has become one of the strengths of this series.
This was a compelling afternoon read and a strong addition to the series. I’m already looking forward to the next installment. Something tells me a wedding may not go off without at least one complication.
Thank you to NetGalley and Storm Publishing for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 183 reviews