Romance is in the air at a wedding in Tuscany. Roman and Niilo meet at the bar, and embark on an adventure together. Hitting the road, they find themselves falling for Italy, and each other, amid beautiful scenery, stunning historical landmarks, and delicious food.
It’s Italy, Not Love was previously published in the Love in Tuscany charity anthology benefiting TransLifeline. Expanded and re-released with a few new additions, it’s a 23k word novella featuring holiday vibes, a single bed, and a pair of strangers falling in love.
This was part of an anthology - three stories centered around one wedding in a nice, posh villa in Tuscany. Story 1 and 2 were by other authors (Maia Kinley and Hannah Henry) and both were a bit on the short side, too short for me anyway, but I am usually a sucker for getting to know the characters which is always a challange in a novella with its short length.
However, story 3 by JJ was great, very atmospheric. Even though due to the short format we don't have enough space to learn enough about the MCs, they feel like real people nevertheless, so it's 4,4 stars for me.
What it's about: Colleague of bride meets bartender, a Finn on work&travel following graduation. What follows feels a bit like a fairy tale which feels a bit unrealistic, but very atmospheric - not much time is spent on the wedding, but on their travels around Italy, well, actually mostly Firenze and Roma. They had little time and covered a lot. Slow burn, sort of, which I prefer to insta-love (insta-attraction I have no problems with), so really really lovely.
Would have liked for the main event and people (the bride and groom) to have a better connected role, sigh, but the novella was like a mini-vacation, especially since I can picture both cities they visited from prior holidays.
3.5* This is a quick, sweet, romantic novella. The story really makes you feel like you're in Italy, basking in the sun. While not my favourite from this author, it still will leave you with a smile and a hankering for a summer vacation.
I love anything J.J. Mulder writes. There is something about the way the stories are written that makes them easy to fly through while still packing so much emotion into a relatively short book.
This is very much an insta-love story, which is normally something I can be picky about, but it completely worked for these two.
Niilo is spending his time traveling, picking up odd jobs along the way, and just enjoying life. A chance opportunity has him bartending for Roman, and from that moment everything changes. Niilo is sweet, confident in who he is, and completely unapologetic about expressing himself through crop tops, short shorts, and makeup. I absolutely adored him. And can we take a moment to appreciate a small top? Because I certainly did.
Roman is the complete opposite. He is a big, shy guy visiting Italy for a wedding. I loved how he gets served by Niilo once and then spends the rest of the evening completely captivated by him. Watching Roman stumble through his nerves and eventually work up the courage to ask Niilo to join him for the rest of his trip was incredibly sweet.
These two just worked together. Their connection felt natural, even with the quick timeline, and it was impossible not to root for them.
The spice is not over the top, but there is plenty of tension leading up to it, which made those moments feel earned. More than anything, this story is about connection, taking chances, and finding someone when you least expect it.
J.J. Mulder somehow managed to make me want to book a trip to Italy while falling in love with these characters.
A sweet, heartwarming romance that left me smiling by the end.
This book felt like a love letter to Italy almost as much as it was a romance between two people who met by chance and fell in love along the way. Roman and Niilo’s story was so soft and sweet but filled with adventure. I adored this entire book it may have been short but the characters were well written and the pacing was perfect. I loved joining Roman and Niilo on their adventures as well as seeing inside their heads as they admire one another. I am just as happy as they are that they took a chance to spend two weeks in Italy together. Roman is a gentle giant who’s just so lovely and sweet. Niilo is fun and flirty but equally sweet and I loved his fondness for watching Roman be excited over everything. This is a perfect example of a short book that manages to do everything it’s intended to. I fell in love with the characters and the story and I just love every that happened here.
This was very cute- an enjoyable quick read, and I liked the characters a lot.
One thing really bugged me tho- 2 gay men who are attracted to each other and have no reason not to hook up are traveling together for a WEEK before they actually do hook up? And they aren’t even sharing hotel rooms? Why? Felt weirdly heteronormative in a way that took me out of the gay story. Like, if there was any explainable reason at all for them to not be hooking up, fine, but just avoiding it FOR NO REASON?!? That is puritanical and/or straight people behavior.
IT'S ITALY, NOT LOVE was a quick and sweet novella about two men who fall in love while vacationing through Italy. This was a low angst, low spice read focused on a quiet and gentle love story. Roman and Niilo were opposites in a lot of ways, including their physical appearances but they were both smitten from the start. I liked both characters but because this was under 100 pages and focused a lot on the setting it was missing some emotional depth. Still a cute romance and I'm glad I read it but I don't think it will linger in my mind the way this author's other books have.
Seriously, I have read all but one of JJ Mulder's books and I have loved every single one! Niilonand Roman were such great characters. I loved how even though there was chemistry and definitely interest, their friendship really grew. Roman was such a gentleman and Niilo was cool with enjoying the slow pace. Because I just read Facing Leeward, I felt like this could have been Oliver and Nil, in a different life, especially the end of the book.
If you’ve liked JJ’s other books, skip this one. It was soooo boring and so little happened in 84 pages 🥱
This story follows Roman, an American vacationing in Italy for his coworkers wedding. There, he meets Niilo, a Finnish guy working in Italy for the time being. They end up spending a few weeks traveling Italy together and… that’s it. 🥴
Wouldn’t recommend. Not spicy like their other books.
I loved this when I read it in an anthology but this version is so much better! I loved the ending the most because it differs from the anthology version and it just felt so warm and fuzzy. I do wish there was an epilogue of sorts though to wrap it up as a HEA instead of a HFN.
This was TOO CUTE! It was so sweet and adorable and I died over Roman and Niilo going on this adventure together when they hardly knew each other and how they spent all day together and never got tired of one another. I loved how close they grew and how they didn't want to let go of what was forming between them. This was a sweet little story about a vacation romance that leads to more. I loved the Corwin/Nigel cameo!
“It takes a lot to put an Italian sunset to shame, but he’s managing just fine.”
I love how quick and easy this read is, but also how sweet the story is and how a lot of emotion is packed into so few pages. It’s pretty much insta love but it actually seriously works for these two.
Niilo is spending time travelling and working odds jobs and I love how it was just a chance meet to be bartending for Roman but it worked perfectly. He’s so sweet and tiny but I love how he ends up being the top. Small tops for the win. I love how he’s able to express himself through his crop tops, short shorts and makeup. He’s a sweetie pie.
Roman is the big, shy guy who’s in Italy for a wedding. I love how he gets served by Niilo once and then spends the whole watching him at the bar. I love how, even if he stumbles, he gets the courage to ask him to join the rest of his trip with him.
These two are sweet. Not overly spicy but a fair bit of tension before hand. They’ll make you wish you were in Italy yourself. 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
“What an incredible act of fortune that, among the thousands of travellers in Italy, I found my person.”