“Through his entire godforsaken life, she’d been the source of his strength, and now that they were reunited he could conquer anything. Even the past. Especially the future. Dorian closed his eyes, identifying the space in his soul as peace and—hope. Before sleep took him, he whispered the vow into her ear that he would repeat every night until time claimed its due. I make ye my heart At the rising of the moon. To love and honor, Through all our lives. May we be reborn, May our souls meet and know. And love again. And remember.” Seventeen years ago, there was a boy who loved and protected Farah Leigh even if it cost him his own freedom. Farah and Dougan’s love knows no bounds. Farah was the first person to ever love Dougan, and he was her protector. That’s how it should’ve always been. Until one day, Dougan was taken away from Farah when he was sent to prison…and died seven years later. Now at seven and twenty, Farah is a widow who has never been able to let go of the boy whom she secretly married as a young girl. Dorian Blackwell is a criminal mastermind known for his villainous acts and ruthless ways and he has his eyes set on the lovely widowed Mrs Farah Mackenzie. When he whisks her away to his castle at the Scottish highlands, secrets of the past that have been buried for more than a decade are revealed. Are bonds of the past enough to secure a future together?
The Highwayman is the first book from Kerrigan Byrne’s historical romance series, Victorian Rebels. This one tells the story of Dorian Blackwell and Farah Leigh. I’ve been planning to read a Kerrigan Byrne book for a long time but didn’t know where to start as most of the reviews I’ve read of her books (although rated highly) aren't very encouraging because her books seem to be darker and more emotionally taxing than the usual HR books one would find in the genre. However, thank you to the person who recommended this to me. While I still prefer Devlin Byrne over the hero of this book, this one was a good read and I honestly have nothing much to say which is why it’s been so difficult for me to compose my thoughts and write a somehow comprehensible review.
I knew from the very first chapter of the book that I had to finish reading it. I loved how the first chapter showed how these two young naive kids loved each other in the way they knew how. The moment Farah appeared in the scene, I was charmed. She is all things good in Dougan’s dark life. I like how the very first words they uttered to each other the first time they met had such a nice parallel later on.
I loved the heroine. She was a sweet and innocent girl who turned into a woman who is still kind and has so much love to give and more depth because of her experiences. I think she was an amazing heroine and I liked how she was faithful to Dougan after believing him dead for many years. It is not that I wanted her to be miserable and grieve over her lost love forever, I knew that if the situation is different and her hero is another man, I would want for her to move on. However, in this book, I was glad that she stayed faithful to Dougan’s memories even after seventeen years. I must admit I was worried at first when she said her feelings for her boss were complicated and opaque. I was like, “Oh no! Is she gonna be in love with someone else?” Thankfully, that wasn’t the case. I don’t like reading about other love interests. It is a big pet peeve of mine. As much as possible, I try to avoid it so I am glad that the book did not turn towards that direction. The truth about her birth and who she really was came as a little bit of surprise but somehow it wasn’t surprising at all. I guess I am more surprised by the fact that I was right, but then again it wasn't really difficult to figure out. I kind of already had a hunch as to what her secret would be from the moment she stopped herself from uttering her last name. The reason I mentioned that is because even if she wasn't that lady at all, her character would still be the same. But that was a nice addition, I guess. The heroine had many moments where she was so loveable but there were also moments where she was somewhat irrational. I did not like how she seriously considered taking a lover just to conceive a child, considering she was in love with the hero. I was like, give him some time, space and be patient! No need to consider conceiving a baby with someone else. But of course, all’s well that ends well. I have a very low tolerance for talk of other women / other men in my romance books so forgive me if I come off as too sensitive. It’s just not my thing.
As for the hero, I felt for him. The part where the hero revealed how Farah was the first person who has ever touched him without any intentions of hurting him was moving. It reminded me of one my favorite songs of all time, especially the lyrics, “if you hold me without hurting me, you'll be the first who ever did.” I loved this hero and how he loved Farah. I loved how he protected her even when he was a kid himself and how he does not regret any of it because the thought of Farah going through pain is something he could not live with. I feel sorry for the child he had been and everything he went through, the trauma he endured and how it affected him. I feel like how he was written is accurate which is why the way he acts, his outbursts and his internal conflict were all completely understandable. I couldn’t be mad at him because I understood his motivations. I am no expert in this type of matter but I think Kerrigan Byrne did a good job when she wrote the hero’s character. He is yet another tortured hero that we encounter so frequently in this genre but the characterization of Dorian Blackwell was well done. It wasn’t shallow and he had reasons and experiences that will truly explain why he is the way he is. Also I love how he has “I would kill for you.” energy. Does that make me a bad person? I am just so into heroes who are faithful and very much in love with the heroine even if they think they are not capable of love.
You see, I really have nothing much to say. This delivered what was needed and I have no complaints. When I read the first chapter, I knew it would be the type that would make me feel many emotions. I was right. By chapter seven, I was already sobbing. When Farah revealed she went to Newgate prison everyday for the whole seven years that Dougan was there and brought him food because she made a promise that she would not let him starve again. Oh it was so heart breaking and wonderfully written. She sent letters and he never received any of it which made me sob even more! The fact that Dorian was taken aback as well. It was a poignant chapter because of the revelations and hints about what Dougan went through during his time in prison. Then I cried again when Farah finally realized the truth and she mirrored the first words she ever uttered to him. That moment in the book broke me! See, I have weakness for scenes that parallel each other, it would 100% make me an emotional mess! Theirs was a love that was and still is. It was an everlasting love. It was not always beautiful, there were separations and ugly moments but in the end it was all worth it. Their love was passionate and ardent that showed both the good and bad of an all-consuming love. They were each other’s weaknesses, but even more, they were each other’s strength.
In conclusion, it is rare to find a book that will claw its way into my heart and make me feel for the characters and everything they’ve gone through. Farah and Dorian’s love was everlasting. Heart-breaking. All-consuming. Bittersweet. A love for all time. I loved the hero and the heroine and I loved them even more as a couple. It is always good to read a book where I can truly feel and believe the love that the main characters have for each other. This was more emotionally taxing than my usual reads which makes the Happily-ever-after even more satisfying. Were there a few things I didn’t enjoy so much? Sure there were but none that are really important enough to be mentioned. Overall, I liked this one! Kerrigan Byrne’s writing style was good and I would most likely look for another book of hers to read but only when I am in the mood. Farah and Dorian’s love story made me cry several times so it deserves nothing less than four stars.
Some quotes:
When she spoke again, her voice was full of tears. “Dear friend…” Her little hand pressed against his hunched back and patted it consolingly. “I shan’t let you starve again, I promise.” → “It wasn’t just that day. I went to Newgate every night for seven years and left Dougan cheese and bread.” “No.” He retreated a step, staggered was more like it, giving her the moment she needed to gather her courage.
“The lass had been the first person to ever touch him in a way that wasn’t meant to hurt. He didn’t know why he’d been so nasty to her.” → “It had been almost twenty years since anyone had touched him in a way not meant to cause pain. To humiliate, incapacitate, and control. It had been just as long since he’d used his hands for a purpose other than defense, violence, or domination.”
Here they were again. A cold storm. A stone wall. A wounded boy. A lonely girl. “Tell me why you’re crying?” She whispered the first words she’d ever spoken to him. And he gave her the same reply, without looking up. “Go. Away.”
“She was alive! She was alive because he was still alive. And if her heart ever stopped beating, his soul would follow her.”
“That such a thing was possible seemed like a miracle. She was a miracle. He’d found her. After all these years. Mine. His body and mind, for once, were in agreement. She could never doubt his claim on her. A claim he’d staked seventeen long years ago. My Fairy.”