A civil servant discovers his breaking point when the Trump administration’s cruelty and indifference threaten to violate the oath he swore to uphold.
Nicholas Enrich had finally achieved his lifelong dream: becoming USAID’s lead official for global health. But that dream turned out to be a nightmare in the tumultuous time after President Trump’s second inauguration.
In the months that followed, USAID became the first target of Elon Musk’s newly created Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE). The mission to which Enrich had dedicated his career was being dismantled before his eyes—even the name of the agency was removed from the building’s facade. Enrich witnessed firsthand the Trump administration’s lies, how it systematically prevented USAID from providing lifesaving foreign aid, and the death and suffering around the world that resulted from careless decisions. Finally determining he could no longer keep quiet, and risking the career that he loved deeply, Enrich released a set of whistleblowing memos exposing the administration’s illegal and destructive actions.
Enrich was put on administrative leave, yet his memos went viral and had a sustained impact. In the days following their release, hundreds of canceled aid projects were revived, and the documents were cited in a Supreme Court case on the legality of USAID’s dissolution. While his memos were too late to save USAID, Enrich was one of the first government officials to publicly blow the whistle on DOGE’s reckless destruction, sounding an early alarm bell for other federal agencies that would soon find themselves in the crosshairs.
Urgent and profoundly human, Enrich’s story offers an astonishing behind-the-scenes look at a federal agency under siege, from the early days when Enrich and his team were unaware of what was to come to the shockingly ignorant, callous, and bigoted conversations they witnessed. Enrich reveals in this detailed, no-holds-barred account what was truly at stake when DOGE set out to dismantle one of America’s most effective humanitarian institutions, and how millions of lives hung in the balance.
Hard for me to rate it since I was a USAID contractor during this time and it’s all very painful still but I’m glad the story of what happened is being told.
240 pages of why Doge, Elon Musk, Marco Rubio, and others should be in jail for humanitarian atrocities. Their actions will continue to cause so many needless deaths for years to come.
It happens to show why the current Ebola outbreak is entirely their fault, because it was exactly the kind of work USAID did before it was gutted.
"The story of USAID's destruction is important because saving lives matters but also as a symbol of where this administration is heading."
The foreword is provided by Atul Gawande former Assistant Administrator of United States Agency for International Development USAID. An example he uses to highlight the dedication of the USAID staff is to describe their assistance to Kiev when the Russian's invaded Ukraine and their health system collapsed. "The personnel in [Washington] D.C. and Europe and worked around the clock. They solved problems of every dimension. They followed the law and they delivered at a scale and with an impact like I'd never experienced. During my time in office that would prove to be my experience again and again."
The speed at which the agency was dismantled by the Trump administration and the cavalier way that support for vital programs was dismissed is truly horrifying. One example: "Just like that it was decided without even a cursory nod to data or expertise USAID's [political] leadership had determined purely on a whim that lifesaving maternal health services were not a priority for this administration."
Finally, after much back and forth, Joel Borkert told us where things now stood, "As I said, the decision has been made to draw down USAID," he said. "My job is to make sure it goes smoothly and I need your help with that..." Can you imagine being asked to help to destroy an agency that enables vital world health services that you have spent your life building?
Even legal rulings failed to revive USAID. Enrich writes, "It had not occurred to me that this administration would simply ignore the binding legal order of a court but that is exactly what happened. USAID's political leaders did not lift the pause on funding as the judge had ordered nor did they rescind the stop work orders or contract terminations."
Activities such as monitoring diseases in order to be prepared for future health events were not supported by the Trump administration. "If we couldn't conduct surveillance or monitoring activities, how would we be able to respond to future outbreaks? Ignoring infectious diseases like bird flu until significant clusters of human deaths were reported was a catastrophic approach."
Then, there was the delay in responding to an actual disease outbreak in progress. "The [Ebola] outbreak was now in its third week and still the PPE sat idly in the warehouse in Kenya. The problem was that the warehouse was owned and operated by the World Health Organization [WHO] from which the Trump administration was in the process of withdrawing."
State approval was required for the PPE, which had already been paid for, to be moved from the warehouse in Kenya to Uganda where it was needed, which required engaging with and paying a nominal fee to WHO. Enrich repeatedly tried to get this approval. Finally, during a conversation with Joel Borkert, Enrich learned that Pete Marocco [tasked with dismantling USAID] was never going to provide approval for this.
Instead, Joel said, "On behalf of Pete Marocco I'm going to issue you an order right after this call. You will need to go get the PPE from the warehouse without engaging with WHO and get it to Uganda." The issue was ordered within minutes of this call. How did the administration imagine Enrich was going to complete this assignment without being able to work with WHO and without the funds to purchase PPE from another source?
"The chaos unfolding at USAID was coming from many other federal agencies as well. We had the unfortunate distinction of being the first agency on DOGE's hit list but the callousness, dishonesty, and ineptitude we experienced offered a preview of how the rest of the Trump presidency was likely to unspool."
The Trump administration used their experiences dismantling USAID to "build a manual to which they've referred repeatedly to decimate other federal agencies: Step one - Fabricate and spread false stories of waste and abuse to turn public opinion against the work the agency is doing. Step two - Infiltrate and immobilize financial systems to prevent the provision of services. Step three - Terminate contracts to ensure that the damage cannot be reversed. Step four - Vilify, demoralize and ultimately eliminate the staff. Rinse, repeat."
Acknowledgements: "This book began as an attempt to make sense of an experience that upended my professional life and shook my understanding of public service. It could not have been completed without the dedication, integrity and courage of thousands of public servants at USAID who served honorably during the darkest hour of the agency's history. Many of them endured great personal risk to uphold the last vestiges of USAID's mission even after being unfairly relieved of duty, so many of them have continued their efforts to address the world's inequities in new and amazing ways."
honestly, this book is unbearable. Because of DOGE, not USAID (of course) - just DOGE's wanton disregard of anything good. The banality of their evil. The lying, which is part and parcel of the 2nd Trump administration. The self satisfaction - even glee - in tearing down - and not even knowing what they tear down.
Enrich's account is of a civil servant who becomes more aware and self-aware. He himself is a Kafka-esque figure -powerless and ineffective against an entirely indifferent - and evil - authority ... I pity his - and all his colleagues - going through this. It was not pleasant to hear the details of the sweeps I heard from our global health friends and the papers.
You could just as well read Nabokov's Invitation to a Beheading, and you will have gotten the picture. Glad to have read Enrich's important account. I hope he finds somewhere to land, and that the rest of us remember how critical USAID's mission was - and is.
This is an audible book that is read by the author, which is always a good thing I think. This is the behind the scene story of an event that I followed quite closely as it was happening, the shutting down of USAID. But has become the normal case for me. I have left the synopsis and review to Claude AI.
Synopsis Into the Wood Chipper: A Whistleblower’s Account of How the Trump Administration Shredded USAID by Nicholas Enrich tells the story of a career civil servant who served as USAID’s lead official for global health. After Trump’s second inauguration, USAID became the first target of Elon Musk’s Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), and Enrich watched helplessly as the agency he’d devoted his career to was systematically dismantled. He eventually released a set of whistleblowing memos exposing what he characterized as illegal and dangerous actions — and was promptly placed on administrative leave. His memos went viral, were cited in a Supreme Court case on the legality of USAID’s dissolution, and led to hundreds of canceled aid projects being temporarily revived.  The book includes a foreword by surgeon and author Atul Gawande.
Review The book has landed to strong notices. The New York Times called it a skillful piece of storytelling that serves as a propulsive firsthand account of the agency’s destruction, with an appealingly candid authorial voice, predicting it will be a vivid historical source.  Kirkus Reviews described it as a righteously aggrieved account of the destruction of one of America’s best ideas.  Their review highlights some striking details — DOGE’s early demand was to cease shipping medicine and food even if already in transit, and the annual per-capita cost to Americans of USAID’s work was just $24.  An excerpt published ahead of release gives a flavor of the book’s tone: Enrich describes meeting with new political appointees who had no relevant health expertise, with one official suggesting disease-spread maps styled after the movie Outbreak and another reportedly believing USAID’s work consisted mainly of funding abortions.  It’s the kind of detail that makes the book both enraging and darkly comic. Overall, this reads as a timely, insider-driven account that will appeal to anyone following the DOGE story or interested in how foreign aid actually works. It’s clearly written from a strong point of view, so readers looking for a neutral assessment of USAID’s dismantling should seek additional perspectives — but as a whistleblower memoir, it sounds gripping and well-executed.
A captivating read and I say that as someone who experienced it from the implementing partner side of things. Nick does a great job of capturing both the insanity of the moment (from the inside) and the combination of cluelessness and callousness of those involved from the Trump administration side. I’m feeling the PTSD of it all over again…
A few things struck me:
1) even up until the bitter end, so many within USAID continued to be the upstanding Boy Scouts that they were… trying to find the middle road to keep foreign aid (global health) programs going. This was always a rule following bunch. (We partners were too.) And it is SUCH a contrast to the corruption we are seeing even since USAID was shuttered. 2) so little attention was paid to the implementing partners in this book. I guess- as in life, also in death. While I appreciate that Nick could not tell the implementing partner side of things because he did not experience it (and that is fair), so little concern seemed to be paid to the partners on the ground who were dealing with their own shitstorms of stopped programming, beneficiaries not getting services, partners not being paid, project staff not getting pay checks. There was minor mention of the “partners unwilling to do work for free.” It makes us sound so money grubbing when in fact people were not getting salaries, had land lords and vendors threatening them for past due payments, major banks dropping us due to government failing to pay their multi-hundred million dollar balances, and angry partners who had upheld their end of the work. Things got scary and I am grateful to the few USAID staff who secretly broke protocol to communicate and to tell us what was happening. 3) there was a lot of inside baseball in this book. I have a feeling if I sent it to my sister, she would not fully comprehend the minutia. We still fail to tell the story of aid in the simplest of terms so all Americans can understand.
But my criticisms aside, I am grateful for the story getting out and I applaud him for the courage to do it. I sincerely hope it spurs others to do the same. I know the implementing partner story is harder to tell because no one wants to upend the struggles of organizations that continue to try (emphasis on the word “try”) to do impactful work in the world by airing their inner struggles and dirty secrets.
What we really need is a Catch 22 version of this with our own General Dreedle and General Peckham (Marocco and Lewin??) and Colonel Scheisskopf (Musk).
A surprisingly dispassionate account of the systematic dismantling and closure of the U.S. Agency for International Development. The author was a highly placed official within the Global Health section of USAID and recounts the main activity in the weeks following Trump's inauguration.
Some of the early chapters are a little dry and formulaic but as the chaos at USAID grows the book steadily improves. The main takeaway is that Musk & Trump lied (yes, I know, shocker! Water is wet and all that) to the public about cutting off life saving aid while DOGE and the Trump appointees actively shut off said aid. Enrich contrasts the actions within the agency to the public statements to convincingly illustrate the appalling mendacity of the administration.
I recall following USAID's demise in real time and found it very upsetting. I thought for sure I'd rage read this account but the author's muted style kept me from boiling over. Part of me appreciated the mostly just-the-facts approach but part of me just wanted to hear the author lay out his Trump boosting pal Steve, his colleague Julie Wallace, Russell Vought, the Trump appointees, the DOGE bros, Musk, Rubio and Trump.
So while the book isn't a potboiler it succeeds as a chronicle of the lies and misdeeds of the Trump administration.
To be fair, most of us don’t meet the moment. In this current day, Zelensky is probably our best example. Churchill would be another. It’s rare, because it requires so much.
To expect a career bureaucrat to be more than what he always has been is an unrealistic expectation. So let’s discuss what he gets right. DOGE had no plan, and no understanding of what USAID did. Their process of determining what to be eliminated would be embarrassing for a first year accounting major. The horrific consequences are fully explained.
But you can’t help but cringe at the cluelessness of someone in charge of such an important agency to decide taking a vacation the first two weeks of the new administration would be fine. With each affront, he is shocked each time. There is little strategic thinking; he just reacts. At one point, he takes the time to pat himself on the back for not wishing a Trump appointee a happy birthday. His idea of pushing back is a sternly written memo, which I’m sure Chuck Schumer celebrated.
Most of us wouldn’t know what to do at first, but I’m guessing we would have figured it out sooner than Enrich did. It’s Monday morning quarterbacking at best to imagine that a full assault against the administration would have made a difference, but what this book celebrates is a memo decrying what happened. You can’t read this and wish someone else had been in charge at USAID who would have had the courage to fight earlier and harder.
It’s an important book because it documents what happened. It’s not a well written book, and at the end you can’t help to feel both sorry for him and disappointed that he didn’t rise to the occasion. It’s hard to do, and that is why it is so rare.
Although as a federal employee I never want to live through 2025 again, Enrich’s account of the capricious destruction of USAID was far worse than anything I experienced.
I just finished Into the Woodchipper, and I’m comfortable calling this a must-read. That’s not something I say lightly. This isn’t a great work of literature, it’s not a page-turner, and it’s definitely not a beach read. But it is something more important than that—it’s a historical document—a firsthand account of a major and deeply consequential event in very recent history that has, just a year later, directly cost the lives of some 800,000 people.
The book walks through the dismantling of USAID in the early days of the second Trump administration, with a central role played by Elon Musk. And one of the most disturbing elements in the author’s account is the degree to which this process appears to have been influenced by Musk’s belief in conspiracy claims that USAID was effectively operating as a front for the CIA. Those claims are not grounded in credible evidence, yet the book shows how they seem to have shaped both the tone and direction of the dismantling. At the same time, Musk was posting late-night social media rants that echoed these ideas—often disconnected from the actual work being done on the ground—while real decisions were being made that affected millions of people.
This wasn’t an abstract policy shift. It was a rapid and sweeping dismantling of programs, particularly in global health, with consequences that are already measurable in human lives. The author, a senior leader within USAID’s global health bureau, takes you inside that process almost day by day—how it unfolded, how quickly things broke down, and how little regard there seemed to be for the downstream impact. He ultimately steps into a temporary leadership role himself before being terminated, which only adds to the weight of the account.
I’m not a neutral reader here. My own company had a USAID contract that was terminated during this period, so I felt some of the ripple effects. But what’s described in this book goes far beyond any one organization. That’s exactly why it matters—it captures the scale and human cost of what happened in a way that headlines simply can’t.
This is not an enjoyable read, but it’s an important one. If you don’t read the book, then find the author in an interview or on a podcast. However you engage it, this is something worth understanding.
Having been affected by the global aid cuts, this seemed like a must read. A couple positives: It does explain the worth of USAID rather well. And it illustrates the senselessness of USAID’s dismantling. BUT this book should be thrown into the wood chipper itself as it came off as rather self aggrandizing for an individual who touts Acting Deputy Administrator when it really was who was left standing without the experience to handle the role. Along with that Nick does a fine job portraying himself as a savior and towards the end forgets the cast of colleagues that supported him. I’d be surprised if he would have hit send without them….seeing that they wrote a good portion of the memo. Another unfortunate overstatement was the author’s claim of being a global health expert for which he neither has the degrees nor the field experience to claim.
Unfortunately, it was a waste of time for something that I hoped would bring a moment of closure.
If we are to take the author seriously, Trump's cuts will result in a death toll of 140 MILLION Africans over the next several years. As an empowered liberal, these figures were crushing, and I moaned in general anguish, "WHO WILL PAY OUR PENSIONS?"
Once I had finished crying, I tried my best to put a positive spin on the situation. Loss of so many people, tragic though it may be, means less carbon emissions, and perhaps a healthier planet.
Simultaneously, the anti-racist in me worries that our children will be robbed of so much valuable melanin, and the chance to fortify the RICH TAPESTRY of human existence.
I appreciate any sympathy available from other readers as my heart yearns eternal for Mombasa.
I never write reviews, and as a matter of fact, this is my first one. I was interested in reading Nicholas Enrich’s whistleblower account of the dismantling and shredding of USAID for several reasons but most importantly, I spent the first 14 years of my life overseas in Africa and Southeast Asia because my dad was one of the first USAID civil service employees hired when the agency started. USAID was a part of my life and I was very proud of the work my dad did. I always knew that this branch of the State Department did so much good to help Third World countries. When I heard that this was the first organization that Elon Musk, DOGE and the Trump administration placed on the chopping block, I was completely heartbroken. If my dad were still alive today, I just cannot imagine what he would be saying about it. So many emotions for me especially sadness and anger for the total disregard of human life. I borrowed this from the library and listened to it on audiobook. It’s excellent. It’s a must read for everyone. So whether you buy it, borrow it, or listen to it just don’t let it be placed on the back burner.
In case you weren't convinced of the ineptness, callousness and ignorance of the Trump administration and specifically DOGE, this detailed account will leave no doubt. The book left me with feeling of sadness, anger, nausea, and yet hope--as "Rebellions are built on hope." Read by the author, he chronologically explains the struggles in trying to save USAID, and expose how fucked up the closing process was, and the devastating effects and deaths as a result.
Enrich was an a ski trip in Canada in January 2025 when the first Executive Orders related to USAID were issued. The EOs were confusing and concerning. Certainly USAID expected a review with the new president and even some difficult guidance to follow but USAID managed to run fairly well under his first administration. Also Rubio had a history of strong bipartisonship and support for USAID. As a congressman, he co-led to put the Reinforcing Education Accountability in Development Act (READ Act) into law in 2017. He had regularly spoken on behalf of the work done by USAID and the worth of the US's investment in development. Yet this second term would be different.
Enrich shares how after the USAID automated payment system issued payments as usual at the end of January, just days after the Stop Work Order, much of USAID leadership was suspended and Enrich became acting head of the health work, informed by email blast, and as he claims, not the most qualified person to take the position having focused more on operations in his work than the technical programming. This story is his personal story of interacting with the political appointees at USAID and his remaining team trying to justify the need to continue the life saving work done and yet asked to cross personal and professional lines each day trading up some projects and colleagues in an attempt to save others. Yet the ask kept changing until he and co-workers shared a whistleblower report, lasting only about a month in the position.
Working most of my career as an implementer of USAID funding (in the education sector), I had to read this book. In fact, I attended his first ever author talk at Politics and Prose in DC which was a standing room only event with many emotions and tears and love and camradarie in the room. Enrich was the first to truly share the story of the end of USAID in a memoir of that the difficult times when review and optimism became termination and dispair. I appreciated the confirmation of how little those in charge understood or the little interest that they had in trying to understand this 60+ year agency of soft diplomacy and a lifeline to many. Those in charge had some odd personal baggage with USAID (thought USAID had killed his dog...) or really thought all the money went to abortions (none did because that would have been illegal). They were interested in cutting by numbers and not criteria. They wanted to consider 5 projects out of hundreds, not based on a criteria of impact but because they were told 5 (or whatever the small number was). It was a bit soul crushing as someone who dedicated my career but also much of my identity and personal life in serving, trying to improve teaching and learning across the globe.
Enrich was fairly defensive throughout his account, trying to justify every thought and decision made during this month period, to the point that it was a bit off putting. YET I understand as I am still so defensive and senstive to the term "waste, fraud and abuse". I am not sure I will ever get over the trauma of the thoughtless shut down of USAID. Was it perfect? No. Did it need review and restructuring? Yes. This was something else. Disagreeing with the programs or how implementing partners and projects were structured is fine but none of it was fraud, waste nor abuse.
Anyhow I appreciated Enrich telling his story. I do wish it was a larger story but respect his limiting it to only the pieces that he was personally involved in. I hope people read and are able to get the general gist of what actually happened (the exact opposite of the current claims in the news). On the almost anniversary of USAID's formal dismantling, I salute the incredible work, service and sacrifice of the officers of USAID and all the implementing partners and especially the amazing staff we worked with overseas. Go and listen to his book talk if you can: https://www.simonandschuster.com/book...
This is the story of the undoing of USAID by the Trump administration and should be read by anyone who has an interest in our government outreach. Whether you support USAID or not, it is a lesson in how not to dismantle an agency, department, business, whatever it is you are assigned to dismantle. Whistleblower Nicholas Enrich writes of the intent of the Trump administration and DOGE to dismantle USAID with no consideration of the consequences either for the employees at any level or the countries and recipients of the agencies' benefits. The approach seemed to be driven with animosity and venom. Since some of the agency's responsibilities were to be assumed by the State Dept, Sec Rubio issued a waiver to continue life-saving programs. This order was ignored completely and the definition of life-saving grew narrower and narrower until USAID was eliminated. It's a difficult read, at least for those who might support the US efforts in global health. However, I still think it's a must read for anyone with a compassionate approach to foreign aid and global health as part of our foreign outreach. It illustrates what we were capable of and what is possible when nothing is done.
similarly axed former civil servant (in a similarly politicized humanitarian realm) who is grieving and certainly biased (the quantity of tears shed whilst reading are evidence), BUT NEVERTHELESS this is pretty essential reading, the Banality of Evil updated for 2025. yes, it’s bureaucratic. it’s also a tremendous reflection of the VERY careful and considered actions of deeply committed civil servants whose expertise and compassion spans administrations, and how difficult it can be to know when to walk away from The Work (even as your agency and your work are being dismantled and cannibalized). the trauma is very real, the body count of these actions is significant, and solidarity really matters.
This book is amazing. It only discusses facts about what happened, to the extent that the author left some part out because he didn't have access to his emails anymore and didn't want to misquote or misremember. It is disgusting that people who knew nothing about USAID came in and gutted it, even after admitting that they didn't understand what they did and that they had misunderstood what they helped with. It is a staggering number of people, especially children, that have died since the dismantling of USAID. Shame on them.
Capitalism is killing people. Elon and Trump are killing people. This was awful. Without reading this book, no matter what else you know, you cannot understand how terrible and ruthless these people are. I can’t say I quite enjoyed it because I found it infuriating, but I absolutely recommend it. How terrible. They need to go to jail. 4.1 stars
An insider’s recounting of the demise of USAID at the beginning of 2025 undertaken by Elon Musk and his tech bros at the start of Donald Trump’s second term in office. This is a read it and weep story of complete disregard for an agency created by Congress in the 1960s that was destroyed after more than 50 years of saving lives and doing good works around the world. A big thank you to Nicholas Enrich, the author, and all the dedicated civil servants at USAID for their service and commitment.
This book will leave you boiling with rage. Kafka, Orwell, and Lewis Carroll between them couldn't have cooked up the kind of nightmare visited by some of the most evil people in the world on some of the neediest, just for the hell of it.
Just when I thought I’d plumbed the depths of my capacity for fury- I read this book and am incandescent with rage. As is stated multiple times in this book: it is important to bear witness.