An exhilarating, darkly funny debut novel about the absurd and fleeting nature of childhood fame, and the ever-evolving desire for family and forgiveness.
Lucy Gardiner felt like she was put on earth to dance.
Amid the chaos of her Massachusetts upbringing—her loving, erratic brothers; her overburdened mother—twelve-year-old Lucy is discovered and cast on a new dance reality show. When its popstar judge, Bruise, takes an obsessive interest in Lucy’s raw talent, Lucy’s life suddenly becomes what she’s always wanted—or has it? In the whirlwind of talk shows, movie sets, and extravagant Hollywood parties of her teenage years, Lucy slowly grows more alienated from her family. And when a series of youthful mistakes comes back to haunt her, she finds she must free herself from Bruise’s world of fame and all its trappings, and decide where her home truly is.
With lively prose and a rich cast of supporting characters—including a retired parrot actor traumatized by his former career—Lucky Girl is an unparalleled coming-of-age story that explores the sparkling highs and heartbreaking lows of ambition, infamy, and the determination to follow a dream, wherever it might lead.
ARC for review. To be published November 11, 2025.
3.5 stars.
Lucy Gardiner started dancing as a young girl and excelled, winning a major juniors competition at age 12. Soon after she was cast on a dance reality show opposite judge Bruise, a famous pop singer.
Bruise becomes enthralled with Lucy and convinces her to leave the show to become Bruise’s full time muse (a rhyme.). Lucy grows up fast in Hollywood and becomes generally estranged from her decidedly odd family. She also learns that most shiny things don’t last.
So, the plot is basically ripped from “Dance Moms,” up to and including star Maddie becoming Sia’s muse. I really enjoy the trashy drama of it all, though, so I was fine with that, plus there’s some nice stuff with her oldest brother. A lot of the supports characters are strong, and it’s nice to see Lucy acting just like a young girl would…she’s left to her own devices and doesn’t know anything about anything, so of course she’s not going to make the best choices. Who would, in her situation?
This is a debut, so I’m interested to see where this author goes next, when she has to plot the whole thing herself. I would definitely read her again.
I simply could not put this book down! I read the first 75% in one sitting and then realized I was getting closer to the end and had to force myself to slow down so I could enjoy it more.
I'm shocked that this is a DEBUT novel, given the richness of the characters (I love that they all have flaws and complications) and the way that the story sucked me in. I love reality TV for the exact reason mentioned in this book about searching for the truth behind the curated "reality", and this story elicits those same feelings of leaning in closer to try to see between the cracks.
This book was a delight from start to finish, and I cannot recommend it enough!!
Edit: I received an early reader’s copy of this book
Lucky enough to get a chance to read this book a little early. A captivating journey from start to finish. The author explores the complexities of navigating childhood fame and the loss of innocence. Would recommend to anyone who wants to be thoroughly entertained for 368 pages!
Sia and Maddie Ziegler fan fiction that pretends to be otherwise. The most miscalibrated balance of sincerity and satire I’ve ever encountered. The first time reading a book where I genuinely wondered if it was written by chat GPT.
Paclitaxel doesn’t come in tablet form, let alone in a 10mg dose. Neglecting to do even the most basic research on something as serious as chemo drugs—something that many readers will be knowledgeable about or intimately familiar with—feels like willful disregard for the fact that audiences are made up of people.
I rarely write reviews here, and never mean ones, but this book insulted me in a way that most things I read don’t.
I read Lucky Girl for one reason – an African Grey Parrot on the cover and in the book. (More on the parrot later.) I’m very glad I did. It’s hard to believe this is a debut novel. The writing is assured and the characters are well written. The setting and the story are very believable. (Except for the parrot; more on that later.)
Lucy is a preteen who wants to dance. She lives in a messy, dysfunctional family with her depressed father, her hardworking mom, and her two brothers. Micah is the one who caretakes and tries to fix things; Joel is an artist and an addict.
Lucy’s mom wants her to achieve her dreams, so despite the lack of money and other obstacles, Lucy enters dance competitions. The book takes us behind the scenes of junior reality TV dance competitions. Then Lucy falls into the orbit of Bruise, an obscenely wealthy, fading singer. The book shines a spotlight on young fame and its price. (Note, I have not watched any reality TV dance shows and I do not know anything about dance competitions or real life competitors.)
Lucy felt so real I wondered if the book is autobiographical. As the narrator, she is looking back on your youth from the age of 22, and I found the voice very believable and compelling. There are some really uncomfortable parts (it opens with Lucy ghosting her best friend on her 11th birthday) but they all work.
Lucky Girl reminds me of another remarkable first novel, Kitchens of the Great Midwest by J. Ryan Stradal. Also, it has an amazing cover. If you like heartfelt fictional stories set in the near past, you might enjoy Lucky Girl.
Very minor gripe: Lucy’s brother Joel has a cast of a skull that he was given in rehab. Reciting Hamlet’s Yorick speech was meant to help addicts confront their ultimate fate if they kept using. When Joel is later reciting the speech for Lucy, he makes the classic mistake of saying “Alas, poor Yorick, I knew him well” instead of the actual line of “Alas, poor Yorick, I knew him, Horatio….” (p. 190 of the ARC) I guess you could make the argument that Joel no longer remembers the actual speech from his rehab but it would have more impressive if Joel had started the speech correctly (to me, anyway).
I read an advance reader copy of Lucky Girl.
As an owner of African Grey Parrots, I have some notes on the depiction of Mercury Blues in the book, but they are long and rambly so I am hiding them behind a spoiler tag. Read at your own peril.
3 Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for providing me with an advanced readers copy in exchange for an honest review. I have suchhhh mixed opinions on this book. On the one hand this is very clearly a dance moms/ maddie ziegler fanfiction which rubbed me the wrong way a bit. There was a recreation of direct scenes from dance moms and dialogue stripped almpst directly from maddie ziegler interviews. There was also description of dances from tiktok down to the song and dance moves and coronavirus made a huge impact. The story tackles real life events in a way that I can’t tell if i loved or hated. As someone who grew up as a huge dance mom/ Maddie ziegler fan then references were super obvious and clear to me and they weren’t done in a super tasteful way in my opinion. The novel also tackles a relationship between two characters meant to mimic maddie and sias relationship which made me kind of uncomfortable. This book although enjoyable tried to handle too many topics at once and honestly I wasn’t a huge fan of it. I would say pick it up if you are interested in seeing the simalirties of maddie’s real life and the character but the story doesn’t hold its own super well.
What a whirlwind! I feel like I got a peak into a world so few are privy to. Lucy’s story is heartbreaking, touching, and eye opening. There were many times I wondered if Allie Tagle-Dokus was an industry insider with the specificity she was able to achieve. Excited to see what she writes next!!
I would rate it 1 star but it was so ridiculously bad that I started enjoying how bad it was. Somehow this is legit Maddie Ziegler x Sia fan fiction mixed with current events like Covid I’m so confused but I laughed reading it
Thank you @tin_house for my beautiful copy! Kinda low key obsessed with the cover, and it goes SO perfectly with the story. Well done!
Before I tell you my thoughts, I must admit I had no idea this was “loosely” based on Dance Moms/ Sia or Maddie Ziegler. I didn’t even know who Maddie was until I googled it. Not that any of that changed my thoughts on the book. Also, this has one of the best animal sidekicks I have ever read. Mercury Blues (an “almost” Oscar winning Parrot) was wonderful. I absolutely adored him and the tragic comic relief he added to the story.
All of the characters in this novel are fleshed out and have some major flaws ( I mean showbiz right?!) but it really brought to life the reality of childhood performance and fame. It gave a deep dive into the lives behind the star as well. It shows the tragedy one is left with when the cameras are off and you are no longer relevant.
The story is timely and yes…its another freaking debut! Super excited to see what Tagle-Dokus has for us next! I was sucked in from start to finish.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily. A thoroughly entertaining read that shows the chaos of fame as a kid while Lucy, the main character navigates her family issues. I was captivated as I read and saw how things from Lucy’s past came back to haunt her as her life went on. The characters in this book were so interesting the more I read and got to know them. This is a great coming of age book and the beginning started out so well that it really set the stage for what was to come, no pun intended.
This book blew me away in the most unexpected way.
Lucky Girl chronicles Lucy Gardiner’s rise to notoriety as a teen competition dancer, and her subsequent skyrocket to fame when a famous singer, Bruise, chooses her to be the face of her musical comeback.
In the author’s note, Tagle-Dokus addresses that the novel was inspired by Dance Moms, and it’s easy to see the link between the inspiration and the final product, especially the relationship between a dancer and a famous musician. And as someone who’s been in the dance world, I appreciated the references to popular dance competitions, choreographers, and even Lucy’s relationship with dance and how it changes alongside her as she grows and her body changes.
Ultimately, this is a commentary on fame, child stars, the consequences of growing up in a spotlight, and what happens when an adult with life-changing power forms a very, very inappropriate relationship with a child, all set against a backdrop of hotel ballrooms, dance competitions, social media, and Los Angeles. This book also depicted how easily child stars can become exploited and sexualized by those around them, even with legal protections in place.
And even writing-wise, Tagle-Dokus does some really interesting things with style throughout the story that hammers home just how absurd--yet plausible--the story is. Some scenes were written like scripts, and others used perspective changes to signify a loss of Lucy’s connection to herself.
Something else I loved was how imperfect each character and their relationships with those around them were. As the protagonist, Lucy makes so many decisions that had me wishing for a different outcome, and yet they’re compelling and make her feel all the more real. She’s a child who’s making mistakes and trying to figure herself and her life out in front of millions of people consuming her content, and Tagle-Dokus conveys this so honestly. I also enjoyed the interactions Lucy had with characters like Bruise, Charley, Joel, Rey, Alice, Mercury Blues, and Denise. Nobody is even close to perfect in this story, and I found it quite refreshing!
Also, I managed to finish this book in a day because I just couldn’t put it down, and I think Lucky Girl might be my favorite literary fiction book now!
Thank you to Tin House and Netgalley for providing an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
A highly enjoyable and well written debut about the perils of childhood stardom and of celebrity in general. Anyone familiar with Sia and Dance Moms/Maddie will find a similar tale rendered here. I found that it skewered fame and the superficiality of the music and movie biz shrewdly and well.
I wished there had been more descriptions of Lucy's dancing itself; what did it look like, feel like, how did it evolve? Also, the parrot character, Mercury Blue, who I generally love, is portrayed somewhat inauthentically in his language use. The author has him converse like a toddler when what parrots do is learn phrases and their context and then repeat them in those contexts. But generally I appreciated his presence in the book and how Lucy and Alice care for him.
A delightful and enjoyable book that seems like it's pure entertainment on the surface but which holds deeper and more meaningful subtexts.
➵ If the world was ending, where would you go? Lucky Girl’s story follows a young and driven Lucy, taking inspiration from Dance Moms, Sia, the Hype House, and everywhere in between. Watching her childhood end on the Hollywood Hills, Lucy learns about her craft and herself all while under the thumb of a bigger star who refuses to burn. What is luck? Fame? A mother’s love? Sometimes you just have to continue life like there’s a tomorrow.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC! °❀⋆.ೃ࿔*:・ Rating: 5/5
Probably 3.75 stars...this was propulsive and entertaining. I heard it was loosely based on the Sia and Maddie Ziegler story, and if you know Dance Moms, you will get that reference.
Spectacular. Give me 15 more of them. I love the genre of women going through something and what made this one especially fantastic in my opinion was the thread of young enough to make mistakes yet old enough to know better woven throughout the story.
The meaning of home, the dark side of fame, the loss of innocence, and how we find our way back from all of that. And how everything is really just luck.
Thank you Netgalley and Tin House Books for an e-arc of this book! The cover of this book sold me and synopsis of Lucky Girl was even more intriguing. Plus, I love finding debut authors! Lucky Girl follows our main character, Lucy Gardiner, who started dancing from a young age and goes on to win a major juniors' competition. She’s then cast on a dance reality show (very much inspired by Dance Moms!!). A famous pop star, Bruise, is one of the judges, and she becomes enthralled with Lucy and convinces her to leave the show to become her full time muse. Lucy grows up fast in this new Hollywood life and becomes estranged from her family. She begins to learn that fame is not all it’s cracked up to be.
Allie Tagle-Dokus expertly dives into the absurdities of childhood fame, the loss of innocence, and the so-called truth of reality TV. I enjoyed how Lucy narrates the novel as if she's looking back on mistakes she's made, and there are a lot of them. She is an impressionable child star after all! I also liked how all the side characters had a lot of depth too, and I liked learning about how they came to be in Hollywood too. The story feels a bit disjointed bat times but that was maybe purposeful to add to the messiness of the characters and the drama of their lives.
I really couldn't put it down, and while I did rate this 3.75 stars, I absolutely can’t wait to see what Allie Tagle-Dokus does next!
I read the synopsis and was so excited. As someone who was equally obsessed with Dance Moms I loved this premise until I realized that this is a Sia and Maddie fanfic. It felt like a trauma dump that could’ve been on Wattpad (not in a good way for once)
This was one of the weirder reading experiences I’ve had in a while. In its depiction of a young dancer plucked from obscurity by an enigmatic singer, Lucky Girl is very clearly inspired by the (admittedly weird) dynamic between Sia and young Maddie Ziegler. I’ve seen a few reviewers dismiss this as misguided fanfic, but if you can get past the obvious real-world parallels, there’s a real, gritty novel here.
I wasn’t sure what I was getting into at first; some parts read as satire, while others feel incredibly heavy. There’s a talking parrot with PTSD. The cover blurbs bill it as “funny” and “fabulous” but I found it quite dark, even haunting. There is an undercurrent of malaise running through the entire story, and somehow I think this is what makes it work.
Even in the midst of wild plot points and offbeat Hollywood hijinks, Tagle-Dorkus sneaks in quiet insights and frequent gut punches. Even as I questioned some of the more absurd elements, I found that I simply couldn’t put this book down. It was compelling and upsetting and incredibly well-assured for a debut. I’ll be sitting with it for a while.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the advanced reader copy.
I'm really surprised this is a debut novel. I've been in a bit of a reading slump lately and this pulled me right out of it. I couldn't stop thinking about this book for the entirety of it, and it was so hard to put down.
At the end of the book, I find myself still wondering about some of the characters and where they end up (hmmm a second book maybe?). I love seeing Lucy's journey from just an ordinary girl who wants to dance and eventually to a famous dancer, actor, etc. The book explores her relationship with Bruise which starts to become very uncomfortable and confusing for Lucy.
Things I wish happened: -Lucy and Kimberly reconnecting -Lucy and Charley reconnecting -Lucy FINALLY calling out the strange dynamic with Bruise -Lucy and Rey reconnecting
Lucy was so quick to cling to unhealthy, toxic relationships (Bruise) and cut off others (family and friends) for the sake of fame. This book shows you the downsides that come with that, and it makes me glad I am not famous :-)
Anyway - I can tell this author will be one of my new favorites.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
What an amazing debut novel! This book took me a little bit to get through and not because I didn’t enjoy it! The drama, the supporting cast, the structure of this book are all so very enticing and addicting. If you like reality tv shows, this is the book for you! The technique reminded me a lot of one of my favorite books I’ve read this year, The Favorites, in the way it jumps from story telling, to interviews, to the filming of the show and I will EATTT up books structured like this all the time!! Lucy’s story is one of highs and lows, drama, success, and suprisingly relatable at moments of flashbacks to her youth. I can’t wait to see what this author does next!!! Thank you to NetGalley for this ARC :)
This is a coming of age story following Lucy who turns dance prodigy. This girl is messssyy and pretty unlikable most of the book-which is one reason I liked it 🤣 the pacing of this book was off pretty much the entire time. I loved how we jumped into the story, but then it dragged for a bit. I wish it could have kept that fast pace.
There are conversations around white privilege, child stars, the dance and acting industry, familial ties etc.
I really wanted this to get weirder and sadly it didn’t.. but the real star of the show is 🦜 blue mercury!!
Thank you Tin House for the gifted book. All opinions are my own!
This was an impressive debut novel. Lucy is a child who just loves to dance and feels like she was put on this earth to dance through some lucky breaks, she wins a dance competition, gets cast in a reality TV show, and then gets noticed and hired by one of the famous judges. To everyone around her she seems like such a lucky girl, but the story explores the price of childhood fame. The characters in the story were very well developed, and I really connected with them, and felt for them. This was a really dark story, but very beautifully told. I received an ARC and this is my honest review.
Lucky Girl is an emotionally honest, sharply observed coming-of-age story that blends humor, heartache, and resilience into a compelling narrative. Allie Tagle-Dokus writes with an immediacy that pulls the reader straight into the protagonist’s inner world—one shaped by complicated family dynamics, unexpected challenges, and the fragile hope of redefining what it means to be “lucky.”
The strength of the novel lies in its deeply human voice. Tagle-Dokus captures the messy, nonlinear nature of healing and self-discovery without ever slipping into melodrama. The relationships—especially the ones strained by misunderstanding or silence—feel authentic and layered. Even secondary characters add texture and emotional weight to the story.
While the book tackles difficult themes, it balances them with moments of warmth and wry humor. The pacing is steady, the dialogue feels lived-in, and the emotional arc is satisfying without being overly neat.
Perfect for readers who enjoy character-driven fiction, stories about reclaiming identity, and novels that don’t shy away from the complexities of real life.
A heartfelt, introspective read that lingers long after the final page.
a super well written and enticing debut!!! i got sucked into this crazy world with lucy and went along for the ride until its crash and (literal?) burn. children just shouldn't be famous in any capacity, man. and i'm glad the author wasn't afraid to explore the deeply weird and wild and fucked up parts of that. all around a good end of summer read for me.
DRC from Netgalley and Tin House Books Coming of age story about Lucy, who feels she was born to dance. Growing up in a somewhat dysfunctional family, Lucy is the daughter of Denise, a former actress, and the step-sister to two older brothers. She loves to dance, enters contests, and is discovered. When she is cast on a new reality dance show, Bruise, one of the judges, takes her under her wing. Life is changing quickly and Lucy is going along for the ride. She basically moves out to LA leaving her family in MA, and spends years living the life. It all comes to a halt when her past catches up. A heartwarming story with an interesting set of characters.
Clearly inspired by some real-life pop culture items, Lucky Girl takes a deep dive into how childhood fame can sink its claws into a life. Introspective and intimate.
I know nothing about Dance Moms...nor do I really care, but, weirdly, this is supposedly just like someone's story from that show. It honestly felt like it was trying too hard and getting nowhere.
Lucky Girl by Allie Tagle-Dokus was gifted to me through NetGalley for early reading. I breezed through this book in just a few days as the storyline kept me hooked on Lucy's story as she grows up thrust in the spotlight. Although this is a work of fiction, the author states that she was inspired from shows like Dance Moms. This is VERY obvious if you have watched the show or followed people like Maddie Zegler who, like Lucy, was taken under the wing of a popular singer as a muse and dancer for her music videos. The story was fast paced and overall I enjoyed it. My only gripe is how obvious the inspiration is and how closely it seems to be followed. 4 Stars