What do you think?
Don't Look Close: A Novel
From USA Today bestselling author Jaima Fixsen, comes a gripping crime novel perfect for fans of William Kent Kruger, following one man who would do anything for his sister, even if it means catching a serial killer…
If you look closely, you just may catch a killer.
When Peter Simmons calls his sister Edie from the polio rehabilitation ward, he expects to hear that she's on her way to get him. Instead, he learns her ex-husband has been murdered—and whispers around town have turned her into a prime suspect.
Determined to set things right, Peter checks himself out of the hospital and heads to Clairbeck, the rugged mining community Edie calls home. He can't walk or drive unassisted, but armed with his camera and a stubborn streak, he's intent on proving her innocence.
Clairbeck, however, is far from welcoming. Old grudges between miners and the establishment simmer, and even Edie's clinic isn't the safe haven it appears to be. As Peter observes—and then investigates—he starts to wonder … Is someone watching, waiting, and eliminating anyone who steps out of line?
In a town shrouded in secrets, Peter's eye for truth might be the only thing that stops a killer, unless he draws the killer's eye first …
If you look closely, you just may catch a killer.
When Peter Simmons calls his sister Edie from the polio rehabilitation ward, he expects to hear that she's on her way to get him. Instead, he learns her ex-husband has been murdered—and whispers around town have turned her into a prime suspect.
Determined to set things right, Peter checks himself out of the hospital and heads to Clairbeck, the rugged mining community Edie calls home. He can't walk or drive unassisted, but armed with his camera and a stubborn streak, he's intent on proving her innocence.
Clairbeck, however, is far from welcoming. Old grudges between miners and the establishment simmer, and even Edie's clinic isn't the safe haven it appears to be. As Peter observes—and then investigates—he starts to wonder … Is someone watching, waiting, and eliminating anyone who steps out of line?
In a town shrouded in secrets, Peter's eye for truth might be the only thing that stops a killer, unless he draws the killer's eye first …
352 pages, Paperback
Published August 18, 2026
About the author
Jaima Fixsen
15 books238 followersJaima Fixsen is a USA Today and international bestselling author living and writing in Alberta, Canada. Her novel The Girl in His Shadow (co-authored under the pen name Audrey Blake) was selected as Libby's 2022 Big Library Read and has been translated into eight languages.
Jaima studied occupational therapy at the University of Alberta, and her experiences learning anatomy and dissecting cadavers began her fascination with the history of science and medical ethics. She loves reading, snow, mountains, snow, history and snow. And Diet Coke.
Jaima studied occupational therapy at the University of Alberta, and her experiences learning anatomy and dissecting cadavers began her fascination with the history of science and medical ethics. She loves reading, snow, mountains, snow, history and snow. And Diet Coke.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 118 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Some trigger warnings with this book! Drug use, murder and talk of suicides.
This was such a strong emotional read for me and I loved every minute of it
I was pulled in right away by the story of a man leaving a polio rehabilitation ward after learning that his sister’s ex-husband has been murdered and that his sister has become a prime suspect. Despite not being able to walk or drive without assistance, he is determined to get to Clairbeck and prove her innocence, armed with his camera, sharp eye for detail, and plenty of stubborn determination.
I love a good cat-and-mouse game, and this book definitely gave me that feeling! The deeper the investigation went, the more dangerous things became, and I loved the constant tension of wondering who was watching, who could be trusted, and whether the killer was going to strike again.
Clairbeck was such a great setting for this mystery, filled with old grudges, mining-town secrets, and people who seemed to know more than they were willing to admit. I really enjoyed watching the clues come together through the camera and trying to figure out who was hiding something.
The atmosphere, suspense, characters, and mystery all worked so well together. I was completely invested from beginning to end and loved the way everything came together. Definitely a 5-star read for me!
This was such a strong emotional read for me and I loved every minute of it
I was pulled in right away by the story of a man leaving a polio rehabilitation ward after learning that his sister’s ex-husband has been murdered and that his sister has become a prime suspect. Despite not being able to walk or drive without assistance, he is determined to get to Clairbeck and prove her innocence, armed with his camera, sharp eye for detail, and plenty of stubborn determination.
I love a good cat-and-mouse game, and this book definitely gave me that feeling! The deeper the investigation went, the more dangerous things became, and I loved the constant tension of wondering who was watching, who could be trusted, and whether the killer was going to strike again.
Clairbeck was such a great setting for this mystery, filled with old grudges, mining-town secrets, and people who seemed to know more than they were willing to admit. I really enjoyed watching the clues come together through the camera and trying to figure out who was hiding something.
The atmosphere, suspense, characters, and mystery all worked so well together. I was completely invested from beginning to end and loved the way everything came together. Definitely a 5-star read for me!
August 24, 2026
Thank you to Goodreads friends MarilynW and PavS whose excellent reviews piqued my interest in this novel.
When Peter Simmons calls his sister Edie from the polio rehabilitation ward in the 1950s, he expects to hear that she's on her way to get him. Instead, he learns her ex-husband has been murdered and whispers around town have turned her into a prime suspect. Peter checks himself out of the hospital and, with help from his sister's neighbour Leo, heads to Clairbeck, the rugged mining community Edie calls home and also a town shrouded in secrecy.
This story takes place in the 1950s in a small town near Calgary Alberta in Canada. I'm assuming the location was changed from Canmore (a real town) in earlier editions as well as the sister's name, sometimes referred to as Ellie in the reviews. The author's decision to have Peter suffering from polio was unusual and very thought-provoking as we learn how difficult it was for disabled people to get around in those days. It's better now but still far from perfect. I remember going to elementary school with a boy who had polio and had braces on his legs, so awkward and noisy.
This is a good story and I really enjoyed the realistic relationship between Peter and Edie. They're supportive of each other without their interactions being overly sentimental. The other characters are well described and the plot is immersive. The ending wrapped everything up nicely and left things open to another book featuring some of the same characters. I'd read it!
I'm in two minds about the narrator, Libby McKnight. She has some very unusual inflections or intonations in her speech and I found it rather off-putting at first. Once I got used to her voice it was fine but any time I was away from the book for any length of time I was startled all over again.
I don't mean to be nit-picky but isn't the book title poor grammar? I feel like it should be "Closely" or "Too Close" but maybe I'm just being overly fussy.
I've discovered that this author also writes as Audrey Blake and I have some of her books on my To Read list which I plan to take a closer look at.
My thanks to RB Media, via Netgalley, for approving my request to listen to this audiobook. All opinions expressed are my own.
Publication Date: August 18, 2026
When Peter Simmons calls his sister Edie from the polio rehabilitation ward in the 1950s, he expects to hear that she's on her way to get him. Instead, he learns her ex-husband has been murdered and whispers around town have turned her into a prime suspect. Peter checks himself out of the hospital and, with help from his sister's neighbour Leo, heads to Clairbeck, the rugged mining community Edie calls home and also a town shrouded in secrecy.
This story takes place in the 1950s in a small town near Calgary Alberta in Canada. I'm assuming the location was changed from Canmore (a real town) in earlier editions as well as the sister's name, sometimes referred to as Ellie in the reviews. The author's decision to have Peter suffering from polio was unusual and very thought-provoking as we learn how difficult it was for disabled people to get around in those days. It's better now but still far from perfect. I remember going to elementary school with a boy who had polio and had braces on his legs, so awkward and noisy.
This is a good story and I really enjoyed the realistic relationship between Peter and Edie. They're supportive of each other without their interactions being overly sentimental. The other characters are well described and the plot is immersive. The ending wrapped everything up nicely and left things open to another book featuring some of the same characters. I'd read it!
I'm in two minds about the narrator, Libby McKnight. She has some very unusual inflections or intonations in her speech and I found it rather off-putting at first. Once I got used to her voice it was fine but any time I was away from the book for any length of time I was startled all over again.
I don't mean to be nit-picky but isn't the book title poor grammar? I feel like it should be "Closely" or "Too Close" but maybe I'm just being overly fussy.
I've discovered that this author also writes as Audrey Blake and I have some of her books on my To Read list which I plan to take a closer look at.
My thanks to RB Media, via Netgalley, for approving my request to listen to this audiobook. All opinions expressed are my own.
Publication Date: August 18, 2026
August 1, 2026
Don’t Look Close is a gripping and emotional read that kept me invested from start to finish. What stood out most to me was the relationship between siblings Peter and Ellie. Their bond felt authentic and added a strong emotional core to the story, especially as Ellie is accused of killing her ex-husband, Jack, and Peter comes to her aid.
Peter was a particularly unique and compelling character. I’ve never read a story with a main character living with polio, and it added an extra layer of depth and perspective that made his role even more impactful.
I also loved that the story is set in Canada—it gave the book a refreshing sense of place that made it feel even more relatable. Overall, this was a well-written, engaging thriller with strong character dynamics. Definitely worth the read!
Peter was a particularly unique and compelling character. I’ve never read a story with a main character living with polio, and it added an extra layer of depth and perspective that made his role even more impactful.
I also loved that the story is set in Canada—it gave the book a refreshing sense of place that made it feel even more relatable. Overall, this was a well-written, engaging thriller with strong character dynamics. Definitely worth the read!
August 20, 2026
⭐⭐⭐⭐ | Don’t Look Close by Jaima Fixsen
Who did it? 👀
That’s the question that kept me turning the pages.
Don’t Look Close is a true whodunit that had me changing my mind more than once. It didn’t have me gripping my book in panic or sitting on the edge of my seat, but it did keep me guessing & I genuinely wasn’t sure where things were headed until the end.
The writing is beautiful, the story is thoughtfully done, and I especially loved the inclusiveness woven throughout the book. It felt natural and added something meaningful to the story.
This isn’t a lightning fast thriller, so don’t go into it expecting nonstop action. Instead, settle in for a well written mystery that gives you plenty to think about and keeps you playing detective until the final pages. 🔎
Would I recommend it? Absolutely. This is one I’ll be passing along to fellow mystery lovers!
Thank you to Jaima Fixsen, Poisoned Pen Press & NetGalley for allowing me to be an early reader. 🖤📚
Who did it? 👀
That’s the question that kept me turning the pages.
Don’t Look Close is a true whodunit that had me changing my mind more than once. It didn’t have me gripping my book in panic or sitting on the edge of my seat, but it did keep me guessing & I genuinely wasn’t sure where things were headed until the end.
The writing is beautiful, the story is thoughtfully done, and I especially loved the inclusiveness woven throughout the book. It felt natural and added something meaningful to the story.
This isn’t a lightning fast thriller, so don’t go into it expecting nonstop action. Instead, settle in for a well written mystery that gives you plenty to think about and keeps you playing detective until the final pages. 🔎
Would I recommend it? Absolutely. This is one I’ll be passing along to fellow mystery lovers!
Thank you to Jaima Fixsen, Poisoned Pen Press & NetGalley for allowing me to be an early reader. 🖤📚
Read
May 4, 20263 ⭐
The cover and the setting caught my attention and the author’s use of clues in her mystery was fantastic. She pulled me closer to the truth with some and then pushed me away with others; I was definitely kept guessing. Fantastic misdirection. Wonderful 1950s immersion.
However, the wonderful cover, the small town Canadian setting, the spotlight on polio, and the well-developed pacing weren’t enough to win me over. I felt this story lacked a final race toward the big moment. The deliver didn’t pay off.
I was gifted this copy and was under no obligation to provide a review.
The cover and the setting caught my attention and the author’s use of clues in her mystery was fantastic. She pulled me closer to the truth with some and then pushed me away with others; I was definitely kept guessing. Fantastic misdirection. Wonderful 1950s immersion.
However, the wonderful cover, the small town Canadian setting, the spotlight on polio, and the well-developed pacing weren’t enough to win me over. I felt this story lacked a final race toward the big moment. The deliver didn’t pay off.
I was gifted this copy and was under no obligation to provide a review.
July 26, 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Cancel your plans when this book comes out August 18, 2026 because you won’t be able to put it down! This is a small-town, atmospheric mystery will have you flipping the pages as fast as you can.
The main characters, bother and sister Peter and Edie, are likeable making you root for them at every turn when Edie’s husband is found murdered. The setting in a Canadian small down in the 1950’s also plays an interesting part of the puzzle. There is also a medical aspect involved which I ate right up!
I loved it and I hope you pick it up! Thanks to Netgalley and Poison Pen Press for the eARC!
Cancel your plans when this book comes out August 18, 2026 because you won’t be able to put it down! This is a small-town, atmospheric mystery will have you flipping the pages as fast as you can.
The main characters, bother and sister Peter and Edie, are likeable making you root for them at every turn when Edie’s husband is found murdered. The setting in a Canadian small down in the 1950’s also plays an interesting part of the puzzle. There is also a medical aspect involved which I ate right up!
I loved it and I hope you pick it up! Thanks to Netgalley and Poison Pen Press for the eARC!
August 20, 2026
Peter Simmons is finally being released from hospital after contracting polio and enduring a long rehabilitation. Unsure of what the future holds, he's looking forward to a fresh start in the quaint mining town where his sister Edie lives and works as a nurse. However, instead of picking him up, Edie calls to say she’s been taken in for questioning after her ex-husband was found murdered.
Peter’s a likeable kind of underdog hero. Dealing with mobility issues and adjusting to a new life, he finds himself trying to solve a murder and clear his sister's name. As a newcomer to town, he has to tread carefully while questioning Edie's friends and workmates. The police seem convinced they already have their culprit. Peter's photography skills prove surprisingly useful, helping both with the investigation and providing alibis as the body count continues to rise.
I liked both Peter and Edie, although I did think some of their decisions were a little haphazard at times. Edie is a strong character, especially for the era, having the courage to leave an emotionally abusive husband. Her nursing background also comes in handy throughout the story. Peter feels somewhat adrift at the beginning, but the situation he's thrown into gives him a renewed sense of purpose and something to work toward.
I really enjoyed Don't Look Close, a murder mystery set in the 1950s. It has the feel of a classic whodunit, with no shortage of suspects that kept me guessing. While this case is solved, the ending makes me wonder if there are more mysteries ahead for Peter.
I listened to an audio version and thought Libby McKnight did a good job bringing the characters to life.
I voluntarily listened to a copy courtesy of the publisher. These are my thoughts and opinions.
Peter’s a likeable kind of underdog hero. Dealing with mobility issues and adjusting to a new life, he finds himself trying to solve a murder and clear his sister's name. As a newcomer to town, he has to tread carefully while questioning Edie's friends and workmates. The police seem convinced they already have their culprit. Peter's photography skills prove surprisingly useful, helping both with the investigation and providing alibis as the body count continues to rise.
I liked both Peter and Edie, although I did think some of their decisions were a little haphazard at times. Edie is a strong character, especially for the era, having the courage to leave an emotionally abusive husband. Her nursing background also comes in handy throughout the story. Peter feels somewhat adrift at the beginning, but the situation he's thrown into gives him a renewed sense of purpose and something to work toward.
I really enjoyed Don't Look Close, a murder mystery set in the 1950s. It has the feel of a classic whodunit, with no shortage of suspects that kept me guessing. While this case is solved, the ending makes me wonder if there are more mysteries ahead for Peter.
I listened to an audio version and thought Libby McKnight did a good job bringing the characters to life.
I voluntarily listened to a copy courtesy of the publisher. These are my thoughts and opinions.
Read
July 31, 2026⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 4/5
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the advance audiobook copy in exchange for an honest review.
Don’t Look Close pulled me in right away and kept me guessing until the very end. The mystery was layered with plenty of twists, and I found myself constantly changing my mind about who I could trust. Just when I thought I had everything figured out, the story managed to surprise me again.
I also appreciated that the book tackled difficult topics like racism, medical malpractice, domestic abuse, and controlling relationships. These themes added emotional weight to the story without taking away from the suspense, and the diverse cast felt authentic and well-developed.
The audiobook narration kept the tension high and made it easy to stay invested in the story. It was an engaging listening experience that matched the fast-paced mystery.
Overall, this was a solid, suspenseful thriller with memorable twists and important themes woven into the plot. If you enjoy mysteries that keep you second-guessing everyone until the final pages, this one is definitely worth picking up.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the advance audiobook copy in exchange for an honest review.
Don’t Look Close pulled me in right away and kept me guessing until the very end. The mystery was layered with plenty of twists, and I found myself constantly changing my mind about who I could trust. Just when I thought I had everything figured out, the story managed to surprise me again.
I also appreciated that the book tackled difficult topics like racism, medical malpractice, domestic abuse, and controlling relationships. These themes added emotional weight to the story without taking away from the suspense, and the diverse cast felt authentic and well-developed.
The audiobook narration kept the tension high and made it easy to stay invested in the story. It was an engaging listening experience that matched the fast-paced mystery.
Overall, this was a solid, suspenseful thriller with memorable twists and important themes woven into the plot. If you enjoy mysteries that keep you second-guessing everyone until the final pages, this one is definitely worth picking up.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
4.5 stars!
This story is a must-read for fans of historical murder mysteries set firmly in their time! As I was reading, I found myself delving into various details. I love when a narrative prompts me to question historical contexts and discover intriguing facts; it feels like reading a history book but so much more engaging!
The hook was strong, and I couldn't put this book down until I reached the end. Set in the 50s, a time when certain illnesses still loomed large, this murder mystery captivated me. For those familiar with polio and its progression, it was fascinating to learn that some individuals were able to recover from the iron lung to lead relatively "normal" lives. Peter is one of the fortunate few who managed to recover, and the story follows his journey as he navigates this new reality. His sister Edie is steadfast in her support for Peter during this transition, as he relies on a wheelchair or crutches due to the toll the disease has taken on his body. Just as Peter is finally discharged from the hospital after two long years, his sister finds herself entangled in a murder investigation regarding her ex-husband, Jack. This unexpected twist gives Peter a much-needed purpose, pushing him to be more courageous and step out of the house rather than wallow in self-pity over his condition. It serves as the perfect distraction he needed!
The author did an exceptional job of immersing me in the era, capturing both its challenges and charm. The relationship between Peter and Edie is kind, genuine, and extremely respectful. Throughout the story, there's a sense of careful navigation of sensitive situations, as Edie strives to ensure Peter doesn't feel diminished or appear weak. Her unwavering support deepens the bond they share as siblings, a rarity in today’s world where people often treat each other harshly and speak without regard. The dynamics reminded me of how I grew up in my home country, where there was an unspoken understanding of what could be discussed openly and what remained unsaid but fully acknowledged. I felt fully immersed in their world, watching everything unfold.
The audiobook truly brought this story to life! I could feel the energy, excitement, and dread that the characters were experiencing. It was clear that they couldn't have chosen a better narrator. The atmosphere was just perfect! If I had to suggest one thing, I’d say go for both—the book is great, but the real magic lies in the audiobook, thanks to the narrator’s fantastic performance!
This is not your typical murder mystery! The story is infused with heart and direction, featuring an array of characters that make you question their intentions. If you enjoy tales filled with small-town secrets that read like true crime, along with recent murders and plenty of twists to keep you guessing, this book is for you. It’s a timely cinematic piece that examines the truth behind medical ethics and the power imbalance between men and women – Edie's divorce from her husband is particularly groundbreaking for that era! Themes of stalking, emotional abuse, and the unsettling reality that evil often lurks unnoticed among us add depth to the narrative. This was a stunning read, and if you’re a fan of historical fiction, it absolutely deserves a spot on your TBR list. The ending took me by surprise, and the main twist blew my mind! This book is perfect for anyone who appreciates strong female characters fighting for their place in a difficult world. Bravo!
Thank you, Recorded Books, Poisoned Pen Press, and NetGalley, for the DRC copies. I am leaving this review voluntarily.
This story is a must-read for fans of historical murder mysteries set firmly in their time! As I was reading, I found myself delving into various details. I love when a narrative prompts me to question historical contexts and discover intriguing facts; it feels like reading a history book but so much more engaging!
The hook was strong, and I couldn't put this book down until I reached the end. Set in the 50s, a time when certain illnesses still loomed large, this murder mystery captivated me. For those familiar with polio and its progression, it was fascinating to learn that some individuals were able to recover from the iron lung to lead relatively "normal" lives. Peter is one of the fortunate few who managed to recover, and the story follows his journey as he navigates this new reality. His sister Edie is steadfast in her support for Peter during this transition, as he relies on a wheelchair or crutches due to the toll the disease has taken on his body. Just as Peter is finally discharged from the hospital after two long years, his sister finds herself entangled in a murder investigation regarding her ex-husband, Jack. This unexpected twist gives Peter a much-needed purpose, pushing him to be more courageous and step out of the house rather than wallow in self-pity over his condition. It serves as the perfect distraction he needed!
The author did an exceptional job of immersing me in the era, capturing both its challenges and charm. The relationship between Peter and Edie is kind, genuine, and extremely respectful. Throughout the story, there's a sense of careful navigation of sensitive situations, as Edie strives to ensure Peter doesn't feel diminished or appear weak. Her unwavering support deepens the bond they share as siblings, a rarity in today’s world where people often treat each other harshly and speak without regard. The dynamics reminded me of how I grew up in my home country, where there was an unspoken understanding of what could be discussed openly and what remained unsaid but fully acknowledged. I felt fully immersed in their world, watching everything unfold.
The audiobook truly brought this story to life! I could feel the energy, excitement, and dread that the characters were experiencing. It was clear that they couldn't have chosen a better narrator. The atmosphere was just perfect! If I had to suggest one thing, I’d say go for both—the book is great, but the real magic lies in the audiobook, thanks to the narrator’s fantastic performance!
This is not your typical murder mystery! The story is infused with heart and direction, featuring an array of characters that make you question their intentions. If you enjoy tales filled with small-town secrets that read like true crime, along with recent murders and plenty of twists to keep you guessing, this book is for you. It’s a timely cinematic piece that examines the truth behind medical ethics and the power imbalance between men and women – Edie's divorce from her husband is particularly groundbreaking for that era! Themes of stalking, emotional abuse, and the unsettling reality that evil often lurks unnoticed among us add depth to the narrative. This was a stunning read, and if you’re a fan of historical fiction, it absolutely deserves a spot on your TBR list. The ending took me by surprise, and the main twist blew my mind! This book is perfect for anyone who appreciates strong female characters fighting for their place in a difficult world. Bravo!
Thank you, Recorded Books, Poisoned Pen Press, and NetGalley, for the DRC copies. I am leaving this review voluntarily.
August 11, 2026
This one was working up until the halfway point……
Great atmosphere, it’s set in the 1950s; and you’re following a brother and sister who are trying to help each other through different situations…. One has an illness and the other is being framed for murder….
My biggest struggle was with the decisions the characters were making and the ending was really underwhelming.
Peter the brother was the only intelligent individual. I rolled my eyes too many times at various characters and the detectives. At some point, I thought this was meant to be comical because the decision-making was extremely juvenile. Edie the sister, lacked zero urgency around her being suspect number one… it was just wild how dumb the thought process was.
I made it to the end mainly because of Peter, he was the only good part of this book.
Thank you, NetGalley for the ARC in return for my honest review.
Great atmosphere, it’s set in the 1950s; and you’re following a brother and sister who are trying to help each other through different situations…. One has an illness and the other is being framed for murder….
My biggest struggle was with the decisions the characters were making and the ending was really underwhelming.
Peter the brother was the only intelligent individual. I rolled my eyes too many times at various characters and the detectives. At some point, I thought this was meant to be comical because the decision-making was extremely juvenile. Edie the sister, lacked zero urgency around her being suspect number one… it was just wild how dumb the thought process was.
I made it to the end mainly because of Peter, he was the only good part of this book.
Thank you, NetGalley for the ARC in return for my honest review.
August 5, 2026
Don't Look Close was a little more of a slow burn than I was expecting, and I would probably rate this one at a 3.5 stars more than a 4.
I think others have said this, and I am going to say this as well, Peter was my favorite. His attitude and character in general contributed to a sense of hope throughout the book. I also loved the relationship that he had with his sister and that added a lot to the story.
There were a couple things I struggled with. The historical accuracy may not have been on point 100%, but that is probably more of a me issue. Women getting divorced in the 50s was a huge stigma and women had a very difficult time basically doing a lot on their own if they weren't married. (or that is my understanding based on my knowledge of history) I also struggled with the narration. This wasn't my first choice of narrators and sometimes it felt more methodical than enjoyable.
The plot moved at a pretty good pace, and I was interested in who ultimately had done what, but I wouldn't say it had me on the edge of my seat. This is for you if you like a small town vibe, a bit of mystery, and a little history thrown in the mix.
Thanks to Netgalley and RBmedia | Recorded Books for the advanced audio copy of this book. All my opinions are my own.
I think others have said this, and I am going to say this as well, Peter was my favorite. His attitude and character in general contributed to a sense of hope throughout the book. I also loved the relationship that he had with his sister and that added a lot to the story.
There were a couple things I struggled with. The historical accuracy may not have been on point 100%, but that is probably more of a me issue. Women getting divorced in the 50s was a huge stigma and women had a very difficult time basically doing a lot on their own if they weren't married. (or that is my understanding based on my knowledge of history) I also struggled with the narration. This wasn't my first choice of narrators and sometimes it felt more methodical than enjoyable.
The plot moved at a pretty good pace, and I was interested in who ultimately had done what, but I wouldn't say it had me on the edge of my seat. This is for you if you like a small town vibe, a bit of mystery, and a little history thrown in the mix.
Thanks to Netgalley and RBmedia | Recorded Books for the advanced audio copy of this book. All my opinions are my own.
August 19, 2026
Having read and absolutely loved The Specimen, I jumped at the chance to read this one!! While not set in my favorite Victorian era, it’s still an enjoyable historical mystery that kept me engaged all the way to the end! 👏
Thank you partner Poisoned Pen Press for the gifted eARC in exchange for my honest review! ❤️
Thank you partner Poisoned Pen Press for the gifted eARC in exchange for my honest review! ❤️
August 18, 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️½ — An Interesting Premise That Lost Steam
Thank you to NetGalley, Jaima Fixsen, and RBmedia for the advance copy of this audiobook.
Look Close started out with a lot of promise. The story follows a man whose loyalty to his sister pulls him into a complicated and increasingly dangerous situation. I liked having a male main character at the center of the story, particularly because so much of his motivation is tied to his relationship with his sister and how far he is willing to go for her.
The characters were intriguing at first, especially as questions began to emerge about their motivations and how much they could be trusted. There is a sense that there is more happening beneath the surface, and early in the book I was curious to see how everything would come together. Unfortunately, as the story progressed, some of the characters’ actions and decisions became harder for me to believe. Instead of becoming more invested in them, I found myself questioning whether people would realistically behave the way they did.
That was also where the story began to lose steam for me. The beginning pulled me in, but the further I got, the more the plot seemed to stretch believability. There were several situations where I had difficulty buying into what was happening, which took away some of the tension.
Libby McKnight did a good job with the narration and was easy to listen to. However, the narration wasn’t quite enough to make some of the less believable parts of the story feel convincing or create the additional tension I wanted. As an audiobook, this also felt like a fairly slow listen, particularly once the momentum from the beginning started to fade.
Overall, Look Close had an interesting premise, a different perspective, and a family relationship that initially gave the story some emotional depth. There were definitely moments I enjoyed, but I kept waiting for the story to regain the momentum it had at the beginning, and it never completely did.
3.5 stars. An okay mystery/thriller with a promising start, but the increasingly unbelievable plot and slower pacing kept it from reaching four stars for me.
Thank you to NetGalley, Jaima Fixsen, and RBmedia for the advance copy of this audiobook.
Look Close started out with a lot of promise. The story follows a man whose loyalty to his sister pulls him into a complicated and increasingly dangerous situation. I liked having a male main character at the center of the story, particularly because so much of his motivation is tied to his relationship with his sister and how far he is willing to go for her.
The characters were intriguing at first, especially as questions began to emerge about their motivations and how much they could be trusted. There is a sense that there is more happening beneath the surface, and early in the book I was curious to see how everything would come together. Unfortunately, as the story progressed, some of the characters’ actions and decisions became harder for me to believe. Instead of becoming more invested in them, I found myself questioning whether people would realistically behave the way they did.
That was also where the story began to lose steam for me. The beginning pulled me in, but the further I got, the more the plot seemed to stretch believability. There were several situations where I had difficulty buying into what was happening, which took away some of the tension.
Libby McKnight did a good job with the narration and was easy to listen to. However, the narration wasn’t quite enough to make some of the less believable parts of the story feel convincing or create the additional tension I wanted. As an audiobook, this also felt like a fairly slow listen, particularly once the momentum from the beginning started to fade.
Overall, Look Close had an interesting premise, a different perspective, and a family relationship that initially gave the story some emotional depth. There were definitely moments I enjoyed, but I kept waiting for the story to regain the momentum it had at the beginning, and it never completely did.
3.5 stars. An okay mystery/thriller with a promising start, but the increasingly unbelievable plot and slower pacing kept it from reaching four stars for me.
August 26, 2026
I listened to the audiobook.
The audio was good, with some expression and a voice that's easy to listen to. The story takes place in Alberta, Canada - which I LOVE. It's so nice to read/listen to a book set in places I know and have visited. This thriller mystery focuses on the MC and her crippled brother as they try to figure out who killed her ex-husband, and then subsequent murders... I love that it has dual POVs (including the killer's) because that always strengthens the storytelling. I guessed the killer very early in the book because the author does a good job laying out clues and facts. The characters are likeable; it was a solid story that kept me entertained. I wouldn't mind a sequel/series that continues with Peter's new job... Lots of potential there. 4.25⭐️
Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for a complimentary advanced copy of this book. All opinions expressed are my own and are in no way influenced by the author, publisher or NetGalley.
The audio was good, with some expression and a voice that's easy to listen to. The story takes place in Alberta, Canada - which I LOVE. It's so nice to read/listen to a book set in places I know and have visited. This thriller mystery focuses on the MC and her crippled brother as they try to figure out who killed her ex-husband, and then subsequent murders... I love that it has dual POVs (including the killer's) because that always strengthens the storytelling. I guessed the killer very early in the book because the author does a good job laying out clues and facts. The characters are likeable; it was a solid story that kept me entertained. I wouldn't mind a sequel/series that continues with Peter's new job... Lots of potential there. 4.25⭐️
Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for a complimentary advanced copy of this book. All opinions expressed are my own and are in no way influenced by the author, publisher or NetGalley.
July 26, 2026
Don’t Look Close is an absolute page-turner! I binged this book in just two days and couldn’t put it down. This small-town murder mystery, inspired by the stunning setting of Canmore, Alberta, had me completely hooked from the start. It gave me major William Kent Krueger vibes, with its atmospheric setting, intriguing characters, and gripping mystery.
One of my favourite parts was getting occasional chapters from the killer’s perspective. Every time one appeared, I found myself desperately trying to piece together the clues, figure out who the killer was, and what their motive could be.
If you love atmospheric small-town mysteries with plenty of suspense and a mystery that keeps you guessing, Don’t Look Close is definitely one to add to your TBR.
Thank you to @netgalley , @byjaimafixsen and @poisonedpenpress for this ARC in exchange for an honest review. 🙏🏻🥰
September 5, 2026
2.5 ⭐️ rounded up
RTC.
RTC.
August 18, 2026
3.5/5
Review originally appearing on FanFiAddict.com
Hello again dear reader or listener, as always, I hope you’re reading good books and, I’m here to suggest yet another one that you should add to your ranks!
With thanks to Poisoned Pen Press for approving my NetGalley request, please come along for my honest thoughts. In fact, this is one of three Poisoned Pen arcs that I’ll be reviewing in a row cause they’ve been killing it this summer! Frankly, it’s a problem since they derailed so much of my TBR. Oh well!!
Don’t Look Close is my first book from author Jaima Fixsen but it definitely won’t be my last! Inspired by some true events/people, Fixsen takes the small town murder mystery and makes it a nuanced yet brutally honest snapshot of the 50s. It “reminds” people of the polio epidemics – because in our Interesting Times(tm) it seems necessary unfortunately – and of the severity of the disease and the ensuing disabilities its survivors were left with. It sheds a light on the state of workers’ rights and miner lives of the time, while also educating on the treatment of Chinese immigrants in Canada. And finally, it very deliberately provokes the modern idea that certain people have of the 50s housewife by presenting us with a protagonists who openly challenges her “role” and duties, and the consequences of such actions.
From the moment I started the book the strongest comparison that came to mind was the TV series Why Women Kill (one of the more superb and criminally underrated anthology series out there in my humble opinion) and while you might think I am giving the game away, worry not, dear reader, I promise I am not. My comparison is partly in the aesthetics, given that they share a similar setting time frame, but mainly because of the themes. Truly, Fixsen tackles topics of spousal abuse, various types of oppression and/or discrimination, class struggle, and abuse of power/ neglect of responsibility. Moreover, she doesn’t shy away from the unsavory side of women who do harm to their own gender so long as the system works in their favor. It would be easy to villainize those who don’t challenge the system or act through denial out of self-preservation but Fixsen avoids that pitfall and instead gives the reader the opportunity to empathize and understand without forgiving or condoning. Something I personally find very important with the concerning growing trend of readers demanding moralities spelled out very clearly and flatly. Humans are complex and complicated, and written characters need to reflect the grey areas we live in otherwise we risk losing what empathy and emotional intelligence we have.
As for the main mystery, the author keeps you guessing and even if the victim might not be someone whose death you care to see avenged you’re still fully invested in figuring out who did it and how many others might be in danger. And the main reason behind that is the sibling duo at the heart of this story, Peter and Eddie, who show a bond that is so genuine and realistic that you can’t help but root for them. Aided by a secondary cast of characters that is suitably fleshed out enough to be interesting but not overshadowing the main duo, the two siblings alternating povs really drive in the aforementioned themes and topics by giving us a full 360 of how each gender experienced the world and how that colored their understanding of various situations.
You might think I am stating the obvious but it’s not always that way with multiple povs in stories. Or, often times, you’ll have an author who (through no malice or ignorance), simply overlooks the fact that two characters is a specific time period might understand a situation differently because of who they are, be it because their protagonists are outside of the norm themselves or because they want to tell the reader to think or feel something specific for their story to work.
Finally, I really appreciated Fixsen’s mastery of tension, which she wrote in expertly and built up steadily, sometimes without me even noticing at first! All I knew was my reading got faster, my need to keep reading just one more chapter ever stronger. Until she’d break said tension with an excellent turn of phrase or plot reveal that got me excited to keep going until the very end. Not to mention the added layer of anxiety that comes with the disability rep in Peter, who needs crutches or a wheelchair to move around and, sometimes, neither are available!
Don’t Look Close just came out yesterday and if anything I’ve mentioned caught your eye or you want to broaden your reading with something different than your usual, Fixsen’s work should definitely be on your radar, even if murder mysteries aren’t your common fare.
It is a study in many things but also in the bittersweet acceptance that life always changes, if not soon, eventually, and what matters is our drive being strong enough to keep going and to relearn different ways of living with what it may bring us. Even if it’s completely different and new and hard. Don’t know about you dear reader, but I find that a message worth passing on.
Until next time,
Eleni A.E.
Review originally appearing on FanFiAddict.com
Hello again dear reader or listener, as always, I hope you’re reading good books and, I’m here to suggest yet another one that you should add to your ranks!
With thanks to Poisoned Pen Press for approving my NetGalley request, please come along for my honest thoughts. In fact, this is one of three Poisoned Pen arcs that I’ll be reviewing in a row cause they’ve been killing it this summer! Frankly, it’s a problem since they derailed so much of my TBR. Oh well!!
Don’t Look Close is my first book from author Jaima Fixsen but it definitely won’t be my last! Inspired by some true events/people, Fixsen takes the small town murder mystery and makes it a nuanced yet brutally honest snapshot of the 50s. It “reminds” people of the polio epidemics – because in our Interesting Times(tm) it seems necessary unfortunately – and of the severity of the disease and the ensuing disabilities its survivors were left with. It sheds a light on the state of workers’ rights and miner lives of the time, while also educating on the treatment of Chinese immigrants in Canada. And finally, it very deliberately provokes the modern idea that certain people have of the 50s housewife by presenting us with a protagonists who openly challenges her “role” and duties, and the consequences of such actions.
From the moment I started the book the strongest comparison that came to mind was the TV series Why Women Kill (one of the more superb and criminally underrated anthology series out there in my humble opinion) and while you might think I am giving the game away, worry not, dear reader, I promise I am not. My comparison is partly in the aesthetics, given that they share a similar setting time frame, but mainly because of the themes. Truly, Fixsen tackles topics of spousal abuse, various types of oppression and/or discrimination, class struggle, and abuse of power/ neglect of responsibility. Moreover, she doesn’t shy away from the unsavory side of women who do harm to their own gender so long as the system works in their favor. It would be easy to villainize those who don’t challenge the system or act through denial out of self-preservation but Fixsen avoids that pitfall and instead gives the reader the opportunity to empathize and understand without forgiving or condoning. Something I personally find very important with the concerning growing trend of readers demanding moralities spelled out very clearly and flatly. Humans are complex and complicated, and written characters need to reflect the grey areas we live in otherwise we risk losing what empathy and emotional intelligence we have.
As for the main mystery, the author keeps you guessing and even if the victim might not be someone whose death you care to see avenged you’re still fully invested in figuring out who did it and how many others might be in danger. And the main reason behind that is the sibling duo at the heart of this story, Peter and Eddie, who show a bond that is so genuine and realistic that you can’t help but root for them. Aided by a secondary cast of characters that is suitably fleshed out enough to be interesting but not overshadowing the main duo, the two siblings alternating povs really drive in the aforementioned themes and topics by giving us a full 360 of how each gender experienced the world and how that colored their understanding of various situations.
You might think I am stating the obvious but it’s not always that way with multiple povs in stories. Or, often times, you’ll have an author who (through no malice or ignorance), simply overlooks the fact that two characters is a specific time period might understand a situation differently because of who they are, be it because their protagonists are outside of the norm themselves or because they want to tell the reader to think or feel something specific for their story to work.
Finally, I really appreciated Fixsen’s mastery of tension, which she wrote in expertly and built up steadily, sometimes without me even noticing at first! All I knew was my reading got faster, my need to keep reading just one more chapter ever stronger. Until she’d break said tension with an excellent turn of phrase or plot reveal that got me excited to keep going until the very end. Not to mention the added layer of anxiety that comes with the disability rep in Peter, who needs crutches or a wheelchair to move around and, sometimes, neither are available!
Don’t Look Close just came out yesterday and if anything I’ve mentioned caught your eye or you want to broaden your reading with something different than your usual, Fixsen’s work should definitely be on your radar, even if murder mysteries aren’t your common fare.
It is a study in many things but also in the bittersweet acceptance that life always changes, if not soon, eventually, and what matters is our drive being strong enough to keep going and to relearn different ways of living with what it may bring us. Even if it’s completely different and new and hard. Don’t know about you dear reader, but I find that a message worth passing on.
Until next time,
Eleni A.E.
September 13, 2026
My coffee definitely got colder than planned while I was reading Jaima Fixsen’s Don’t Look Close, because apparently putting a murder in a secret-filled 1950s mining town is a pretty effective way to keep me sitting on the patio longer than I intended. Thank you to Poisoned Pen Press for the gifted copy. Does anyone else immediately become suspicious of EVERYONE when a mystery takes place in a small town, or is that just me?
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Peter Simmons is finally leaving a polio rehabilitation ward when he discovers his sister Edie has a much bigger problem than picking him up—her ex-husband has been murdered, and people are already looking at her as the obvious suspect.
So Peter heads to Clairbeck determined to clear her name, armed with his camera, a sharp eye for details, and enough stubbornness to make questioning him basically pointless.
Peter was easily my favorite part of this story. He’s adjusting to a body that no longer lets him move through the world the way he once did, but Fixsen never turns him into someone we’re simply supposed to feel sorry for. He’s frustrated, funny, determined, occasionally reckless, and completely devoted to Edie. I loved watching him realize that the skills he used as a photographer—looking closely, noticing what other people miss—might be exactly what he needs now.
And Peter and Edie together? Their sibling relationship gave this mystery its heart. They support each other without becoming overly sentimental, and their banter made them feel like actual siblings instead of characters conveniently paired together for an investigation.
Clairbeck itself also had me suspicious from the beginning. Between the mining-town grudges, medical questions, people protecting their own secrets, and the feeling that everyone knows everyone else’s business, my suspect list got ridiculous. At one point I had basically convicted half the town. 😂
I especially enjoyed that this is a mystery without modern shortcuts—no cell phones, DNA databases, or quick internet searches. Peter has to watch, listen, photograph, and actually connect the pieces. The middle slowed a little for me, and I wanted a bit more from the final reveal, but I still really enjoyed getting there.
And yes…I absolutely guessed wrong more than once.
What’s your favorite kind of amateur sleuth—the person who notices everything, the nosy neighbor, or the character who absolutely should mind their own business but refuses?
#DontLookClose #JaimaFixsen #PoisonedPenPress #HistoricalMystery #MysteryBooks #Bookstagram #BookReview #SmallTownMystery #MysteryReader
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Peter Simmons is finally leaving a polio rehabilitation ward when he discovers his sister Edie has a much bigger problem than picking him up—her ex-husband has been murdered, and people are already looking at her as the obvious suspect.
So Peter heads to Clairbeck determined to clear her name, armed with his camera, a sharp eye for details, and enough stubbornness to make questioning him basically pointless.
Peter was easily my favorite part of this story. He’s adjusting to a body that no longer lets him move through the world the way he once did, but Fixsen never turns him into someone we’re simply supposed to feel sorry for. He’s frustrated, funny, determined, occasionally reckless, and completely devoted to Edie. I loved watching him realize that the skills he used as a photographer—looking closely, noticing what other people miss—might be exactly what he needs now.
And Peter and Edie together? Their sibling relationship gave this mystery its heart. They support each other without becoming overly sentimental, and their banter made them feel like actual siblings instead of characters conveniently paired together for an investigation.
Clairbeck itself also had me suspicious from the beginning. Between the mining-town grudges, medical questions, people protecting their own secrets, and the feeling that everyone knows everyone else’s business, my suspect list got ridiculous. At one point I had basically convicted half the town. 😂
I especially enjoyed that this is a mystery without modern shortcuts—no cell phones, DNA databases, or quick internet searches. Peter has to watch, listen, photograph, and actually connect the pieces. The middle slowed a little for me, and I wanted a bit more from the final reveal, but I still really enjoyed getting there.
And yes…I absolutely guessed wrong more than once.
What’s your favorite kind of amateur sleuth—the person who notices everything, the nosy neighbor, or the character who absolutely should mind their own business but refuses?
#DontLookClose #JaimaFixsen #PoisonedPenPress #HistoricalMystery #MysteryBooks #Bookstagram #BookReview #SmallTownMystery #MysteryReader
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Not all mysteries need relentless pacing and shocking twists to leave an impact. Some quietly unfold like an old photograph developing in a darkroom — rich with detail, humanity, and emotion. Don't Look Close was exactly that kind of read for me.
Set in the 1950s, this novel absolutely transported me. I loved the nostalgic atmosphere and the way the mystery had to be solved through observation, intuition, persistence, and genuine detective work — no modern technology, no shortcuts, just people relying on their minds and instincts. As someone who loves photography myself, I especially adored how Peter’s passion for photography became woven into the investigation. It added such a unique layer to the storytelling and made the mystery feel even more immersive.
What truly elevated this book for me, though, was Peter himself. It is still incredibly rare to find a protagonist living with physical limitations written with this level of authenticity and care. Peter’s experience after surviving polio felt deeply human — not reduced to inspiration, but explored honestly through both the physical and emotional realities of losing access to the life he once had, particularly his love of climbing. The grief, frustration, adaptation, and resilience throughout his journey rang so true to experiences I’ve witnessed supporting my own brother, and that authenticity hit me hard in the best possible way.
I also loved the relationship between Peter and his sister. Their dynamic — the support, dependence, protectiveness, and occasional tension — felt incredibly real and refreshing to see represented with such nuance. Combined with a strong female presence and the medically and culturally authentic backdrop of the era, this book managed to explore so many meaningful themes while still delivering a compelling murder mystery.
The entire cast felt vivid and believable, which makes perfect sense given how much of the story draws from the author’s own life experiences. There’s a sincerity running through this novel that makes every interaction feel lived-in and genuine.
This was such a thoughtful, layered, beautifully human mystery — one that balances suspense with heart exceptionally well. If you enjoy historical mysteries with strong characterization, emotional depth, and an atmospheric setting, absolutely keep this one on your radar. A very easy 4.5 stars for me.
Set in the 1950s, this novel absolutely transported me. I loved the nostalgic atmosphere and the way the mystery had to be solved through observation, intuition, persistence, and genuine detective work — no modern technology, no shortcuts, just people relying on their minds and instincts. As someone who loves photography myself, I especially adored how Peter’s passion for photography became woven into the investigation. It added such a unique layer to the storytelling and made the mystery feel even more immersive.
What truly elevated this book for me, though, was Peter himself. It is still incredibly rare to find a protagonist living with physical limitations written with this level of authenticity and care. Peter’s experience after surviving polio felt deeply human — not reduced to inspiration, but explored honestly through both the physical and emotional realities of losing access to the life he once had, particularly his love of climbing. The grief, frustration, adaptation, and resilience throughout his journey rang so true to experiences I’ve witnessed supporting my own brother, and that authenticity hit me hard in the best possible way.
I also loved the relationship between Peter and his sister. Their dynamic — the support, dependence, protectiveness, and occasional tension — felt incredibly real and refreshing to see represented with such nuance. Combined with a strong female presence and the medically and culturally authentic backdrop of the era, this book managed to explore so many meaningful themes while still delivering a compelling murder mystery.
The entire cast felt vivid and believable, which makes perfect sense given how much of the story draws from the author’s own life experiences. There’s a sincerity running through this novel that makes every interaction feel lived-in and genuine.
This was such a thoughtful, layered, beautifully human mystery — one that balances suspense with heart exceptionally well. If you enjoy historical mysteries with strong characterization, emotional depth, and an atmospheric setting, absolutely keep this one on your radar. A very easy 4.5 stars for me.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
*Thank you to Poisoned Pen Press and RB Media for a complimentary arc and alc of Don’t Look Close. All opinions expressed are my own.*
There was so much about Don’t Look Close that I wanted to love. Fixsen creates such a compelling atmosphere with this small town in the 1950s, where tension and drama simmer beneath the surface before a mystery is piled on top. It has exactly the kind of dark and moody setup that I can usually devour in one sitting from desperation to uncover the clues to the mystery.
What stood out most to me, though, was the lead characters. Peter, especially, and his journey to clear his sister’s name while also finding his way back to himself after recovering form polio - provided so much depth and an emotional layer behind the mystery, that you just couldn’t help get invested in his character, and in Edie by association. His relationship with Edie and the sibling bond they share throughout the story was beautiful, and Peter became what was holding my interest in the story.
The pacing was quite slow, but I think that worked well for the atmosphere and helped build the tension. Unfortunately, despite all the slow buildup, I found myself missing that final spark that would have me invested in the story itself. By the time I reached the ending, I was left with the feeling that I had somehow missed out on something, even though I can’t put my finger on what that something was.
That’s probably what frustrates me most about this book. The writing and prose are genuinely good, and there was so much here that should have worked for me. I just never found myself hooked by the story like I wanted to be.
Unfortunately, the audiobook dint really help. Libby McKnight has a lovely narration voice, but something about her delivery brightened the story in a way that worked against the darker atmosphere. It took some of the tension and suspense out of the story for me and made it even harder to stay immersed.
Overall, Don’t Look Close had so many ingredients I should have devoured and adored - dark small-town mystery, a fascinating period setting, strong character relationships, and a personal journey at its center. I appreciated all of those elements, but somehow it just didn’t come together for me. I’ll probably return to it one day in the future and find that the timing was simply wrong the first time around.
There was so much about Don’t Look Close that I wanted to love. Fixsen creates such a compelling atmosphere with this small town in the 1950s, where tension and drama simmer beneath the surface before a mystery is piled on top. It has exactly the kind of dark and moody setup that I can usually devour in one sitting from desperation to uncover the clues to the mystery.
What stood out most to me, though, was the lead characters. Peter, especially, and his journey to clear his sister’s name while also finding his way back to himself after recovering form polio - provided so much depth and an emotional layer behind the mystery, that you just couldn’t help get invested in his character, and in Edie by association. His relationship with Edie and the sibling bond they share throughout the story was beautiful, and Peter became what was holding my interest in the story.
The pacing was quite slow, but I think that worked well for the atmosphere and helped build the tension. Unfortunately, despite all the slow buildup, I found myself missing that final spark that would have me invested in the story itself. By the time I reached the ending, I was left with the feeling that I had somehow missed out on something, even though I can’t put my finger on what that something was.
That’s probably what frustrates me most about this book. The writing and prose are genuinely good, and there was so much here that should have worked for me. I just never found myself hooked by the story like I wanted to be.
Unfortunately, the audiobook dint really help. Libby McKnight has a lovely narration voice, but something about her delivery brightened the story in a way that worked against the darker atmosphere. It took some of the tension and suspense out of the story for me and made it even harder to stay immersed.
Overall, Don’t Look Close had so many ingredients I should have devoured and adored - dark small-town mystery, a fascinating period setting, strong character relationships, and a personal journey at its center. I appreciated all of those elements, but somehow it just didn’t come together for me. I’ll probably return to it one day in the future and find that the timing was simply wrong the first time around.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Interesting read, and first I’ve read from this author! (Well, actually I just checked and she co-authored another great book I’ve read!)
So this one opens with Edie, a nurse, in the 1950’s. She’s at home by herself when the doorbell rings. It’s none other than her ex-husband… Leo, coming to give her a hard time… again. She is so tired of this, but she’s also home… alone. So she puts up with his nonsense for a short time… and then locks the door immediately after he leaves.
She needs to stop 🛑 this! But what can she do? She’s still so afraid of him…
And then she learns that he’s engaged. She’s worried for the new girl too now! Should she warn her? ? ?
And then, the next day, her husband is dead! (No kidding!) First couple of pages of the book! 😮😳
And guess who the prime suspect is???
Amid all of this, her brother, Peter, is leaving the hospital. He’s been diagnosed with Polio.
And, he’s now confined to a wheelchair…. And is going to need a lot of help. Of course Edie will help him!
So this is the setup… but this is only just the beginning! There’s suspicion everywhere! And they live in a small mining town… and there have been a lot of suicides lately…. And everyone knows everyone else’s business!
You are led along on a path, but just when you think you have it all figured out? Well… you’d be completely wrong!
And this happened multiple times!
And you might just find yourself constantly looking over your shoulder…
#DontLookClose by @JaimaFixsen and narrated nicely by @LibbyMcKnight.
It has not been released yet, but look 👀 for it soon! Release date is August 18, 2026!
4 bold, bright, charming, Canadian, transformative stars for me! 🌟🌟🌟🌟
Thanks so much to #NetGalley, @RBMedia and @RecordedBooks for an ALC of the audiobook in exchange for an honest review.
You can also find my reviews on: Goodreads,
Instagram: @BookReviews_with_emsr and/or
My Facebook Book Club: Book Reviews With Elaine
Thanks so much for reading! And if you ‘liked’ my review, please share with your friends, & click ‘LIKE’ below… And, let me know YOUR thoughts if you read it!!
And as always, thanks for reading along with me! 📚⭐️📖🩷
So this one opens with Edie, a nurse, in the 1950’s. She’s at home by herself when the doorbell rings. It’s none other than her ex-husband… Leo, coming to give her a hard time… again. She is so tired of this, but she’s also home… alone. So she puts up with his nonsense for a short time… and then locks the door immediately after he leaves.
She needs to stop 🛑 this! But what can she do? She’s still so afraid of him…
And then she learns that he’s engaged. She’s worried for the new girl too now! Should she warn her? ? ?
And then, the next day, her husband is dead! (No kidding!) First couple of pages of the book! 😮😳
And guess who the prime suspect is???
Amid all of this, her brother, Peter, is leaving the hospital. He’s been diagnosed with Polio.
And, he’s now confined to a wheelchair…. And is going to need a lot of help. Of course Edie will help him!
So this is the setup… but this is only just the beginning! There’s suspicion everywhere! And they live in a small mining town… and there have been a lot of suicides lately…. And everyone knows everyone else’s business!
You are led along on a path, but just when you think you have it all figured out? Well… you’d be completely wrong!
And this happened multiple times!
And you might just find yourself constantly looking over your shoulder…
#DontLookClose by @JaimaFixsen and narrated nicely by @LibbyMcKnight.
It has not been released yet, but look 👀 for it soon! Release date is August 18, 2026!
4 bold, bright, charming, Canadian, transformative stars for me! 🌟🌟🌟🌟
Thanks so much to #NetGalley, @RBMedia and @RecordedBooks for an ALC of the audiobook in exchange for an honest review.
You can also find my reviews on: Goodreads,
Instagram: @BookReviews_with_emsr and/or
My Facebook Book Club: Book Reviews With Elaine
Thanks so much for reading! And if you ‘liked’ my review, please share with your friends, & click ‘LIKE’ below… And, let me know YOUR thoughts if you read it!!
And as always, thanks for reading along with me! 📚⭐️📖🩷
September 11, 2026
BOOK REVIEW — DON'T LOOK CLOSE
Title: Don't Look Close by Jaima Fixsen
⭐⭐⭐⭐ Star Rating: 4
Vibe Check: came for the serial-killer investigation, stayed for the small-town mystery, disabled photographer protagonist, and the immediate suspicion that the local clinic is definitely not what it looks like.
A disabled photographer moves to a small mining town expecting a quiet life.
Instead, he starts noticing something wrong at the local clinic.
Very wrong.
And rather than minding his own business like a sensible person, he starts investigating.
Naturally.
The premise immediately gave me a Rear Window meets small-town crime vibe, and I really liked the idea of the protagonist using his camera and observational skills to uncover what's happening.
The serial killer element also adds a strong sense of danger because this isn't just someone doing shady things.
Someone is targeting people who won't fall in line.
And that gives the mystery a larger social element beyond simply catching a murderer.
Tropes included: small-town crime, serial killer, disabled protagonist, photographer detective, suspicious clinic, mining town, hidden conspiracy, investigation, and thriller suspense.
Did they deliver?
Yes.
The central mystery is intriguing, and I liked having a protagonist whose skills aren't based on being physically unstoppable.
Observation becomes the weapon.
I did want a little more development in the supporting characters, but the premise kept me engaged.
Petty Complaint: He moved to a small mining town for peace and quiet.
Sir.
You should have known better.
Nobody moves to a small town in a thriller for peace and quiet.
Overall, Don't Look Close is a gripping small-town crime story with an interesting protagonist, serial-killer mystery, and a creepy local clinic hiding something much darker.
Four stars.
Would I recommend it?
Yes, especially if you like small-town thrillers, serial killers, investigative protagonists, conspiracy, and stories where looking closely is apparently a terrible life decision.
Title: Don't Look Close by Jaima Fixsen
⭐⭐⭐⭐ Star Rating: 4
Vibe Check: came for the serial-killer investigation, stayed for the small-town mystery, disabled photographer protagonist, and the immediate suspicion that the local clinic is definitely not what it looks like.
A disabled photographer moves to a small mining town expecting a quiet life.
Instead, he starts noticing something wrong at the local clinic.
Very wrong.
And rather than minding his own business like a sensible person, he starts investigating.
Naturally.
The premise immediately gave me a Rear Window meets small-town crime vibe, and I really liked the idea of the protagonist using his camera and observational skills to uncover what's happening.
The serial killer element also adds a strong sense of danger because this isn't just someone doing shady things.
Someone is targeting people who won't fall in line.
And that gives the mystery a larger social element beyond simply catching a murderer.
Tropes included: small-town crime, serial killer, disabled protagonist, photographer detective, suspicious clinic, mining town, hidden conspiracy, investigation, and thriller suspense.
Did they deliver?
Yes.
The central mystery is intriguing, and I liked having a protagonist whose skills aren't based on being physically unstoppable.
Observation becomes the weapon.
I did want a little more development in the supporting characters, but the premise kept me engaged.
Petty Complaint: He moved to a small mining town for peace and quiet.
Sir.
You should have known better.
Nobody moves to a small town in a thriller for peace and quiet.
Overall, Don't Look Close is a gripping small-town crime story with an interesting protagonist, serial-killer mystery, and a creepy local clinic hiding something much darker.
Four stars.
Would I recommend it?
Yes, especially if you like small-town thrillers, serial killers, investigative protagonists, conspiracy, and stories where looking closely is apparently a terrible life decision.
August 19, 2026
This story pulled me right in from the beginning! An historical murder mystery!!
Set in the 1950's, Peter is recovering from the iron lung. On the day that he is set to leave the hospital he calls his sister, Edie, to make sure she would be there to pick him up. However, Edie is being questioned by the police because her ex- husband, Jack, was murdered the night before. Pete frantically calls Edie's neighbor, who is willing to give Jack a ride to Edie's house. Jack and Edie have always been close. Edie supported him during the two years that he was on the iron lung. He used to be a climber and photographer, but is at a loose end wondering what his life will be now. With Edie being suspected by the police, Peter is determined to help her and discover what really happened.
I found this story so interesting in a couple of ways. First, the hero being a survivor of polio and the iron lung. You learn a lot about this, and it was so interesting. Edie!! What a strong woman, even for the 1950's. The mystery is a major player in the story, with multiple characters and lots of red herrings. But what made this stand out to me was the relationship between Edie and Peter. Their resilience, faith in each other, and persistence in helping the other see through the rough times really added an extra depth.
You will find that you question everyone with this story. You will question the medical practices of the day. You will also see the struggles women faced to be taken seriously. And you will probably really enjoy this!
I don't want to say more, because I might slip and give a spoiler! And this book is too good to be spoiled!
Thank you to NetGalley and Poisoned Pen Press for the ARC. This is my honest and voluntary review.
Set in the 1950's, Peter is recovering from the iron lung. On the day that he is set to leave the hospital he calls his sister, Edie, to make sure she would be there to pick him up. However, Edie is being questioned by the police because her ex- husband, Jack, was murdered the night before. Pete frantically calls Edie's neighbor, who is willing to give Jack a ride to Edie's house. Jack and Edie have always been close. Edie supported him during the two years that he was on the iron lung. He used to be a climber and photographer, but is at a loose end wondering what his life will be now. With Edie being suspected by the police, Peter is determined to help her and discover what really happened.
I found this story so interesting in a couple of ways. First, the hero being a survivor of polio and the iron lung. You learn a lot about this, and it was so interesting. Edie!! What a strong woman, even for the 1950's. The mystery is a major player in the story, with multiple characters and lots of red herrings. But what made this stand out to me was the relationship between Edie and Peter. Their resilience, faith in each other, and persistence in helping the other see through the rough times really added an extra depth.
You will find that you question everyone with this story. You will question the medical practices of the day. You will also see the struggles women faced to be taken seriously. And you will probably really enjoy this!
I don't want to say more, because I might slip and give a spoiler! And this book is too good to be spoiled!
Thank you to NetGalley and Poisoned Pen Press for the ARC. This is my honest and voluntary review.
Read
August 21, 2026First of all, I would like to thank NetGalley and Poisoned Pen Press for the ARC.
Personally I have never read anything by this author before, but both the synopsis and the cover immediately caught my attention.
I can say that I thought it was an okay book, but for me, it could have been just a little bit more.
The story is set in the 1950s, in an old mining town, and I have to admit that, although this was touched upon here and there, I would have liked to see it explored in more depth.
The time period and setting do come through in the characters and their actions, but still, I felt that the story could as easily have taken place the decades just after.
I really liked how the main characters were developed though.
The brother/sister relationship in particular felt very relatable.
The other characters, however, occasionally lacked some depth for me, especially as we got closer to the solution.
I ultimately found the resolution rather underwhelming, especially considering the rather slow build-up towards the climax.
That said, from the very first page I was intrigued and invested in Peter and Edie.
Peter in particular was an interesting character and I really enjoyed his storyline.
I also really liked the author's writing style, it's smooth and pleasant to read, making it easy to fly through the pages.
All in all I thought this was a book worth reading and finishing, but it probably isn't one that will linger and therefore the author will be off my radar for the future.
Of course don't let my review put you off giving this book a chance yourself, because my opinion is only one of many!
Personally I have never read anything by this author before, but both the synopsis and the cover immediately caught my attention.
I can say that I thought it was an okay book, but for me, it could have been just a little bit more.
The story is set in the 1950s, in an old mining town, and I have to admit that, although this was touched upon here and there, I would have liked to see it explored in more depth.
The time period and setting do come through in the characters and their actions, but still, I felt that the story could as easily have taken place the decades just after.
I really liked how the main characters were developed though.
The brother/sister relationship in particular felt very relatable.
The other characters, however, occasionally lacked some depth for me, especially as we got closer to the solution.
I ultimately found the resolution rather underwhelming, especially considering the rather slow build-up towards the climax.
That said, from the very first page I was intrigued and invested in Peter and Edie.
Peter in particular was an interesting character and I really enjoyed his storyline.
I also really liked the author's writing style, it's smooth and pleasant to read, making it easy to fly through the pages.
All in all I thought this was a book worth reading and finishing, but it probably isn't one that will linger and therefore the author will be off my radar for the future.
Of course don't let my review put you off giving this book a chance yourself, because my opinion is only one of many!
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Okay… I fully judged this book by the cover 😂 And honestly, I’m glad I did because the cover and title were exactly what made me want to pick this one up in the first place. It had that dark small-town mystery feel that I’m always drawn to.
I really liked the atmosphere of this book. The 1950s setting, the mining town drama, the tension between everyone in town… it all felt very immersive. You could feel that something bad was sitting underneath the surface the entire time.
Peter was probably my favorite part of the story. Watching him try to clear his sister’s name while also navigating life after polio made him feel different from a lot of thriller characters I’ve read lately. I found myself really rooting for him.
The mystery kept me interested the whole way through too. Every time I thought I had things figured out, the story would shift just enough to make me question myself again. I always appreciate that in a mystery because I hate when the ending feels too obvious.
For me personally though, the ending didn’t hit quite as hard as I wanted it to. It wasn’t bad at all, and everything wrapped up in a way that made sense, but I kept waiting for that final punch that never fully came for me.
Overall, I’d probably give this one around 3. The atmosphere, cover, setting, and slow-building mystery were definitely the strongest parts for me. If you like historical mysteries with family drama, small-town secrets, and a slower suspenseful build, this is worth picking up.
I really liked the atmosphere of this book. The 1950s setting, the mining town drama, the tension between everyone in town… it all felt very immersive. You could feel that something bad was sitting underneath the surface the entire time.
Peter was probably my favorite part of the story. Watching him try to clear his sister’s name while also navigating life after polio made him feel different from a lot of thriller characters I’ve read lately. I found myself really rooting for him.
The mystery kept me interested the whole way through too. Every time I thought I had things figured out, the story would shift just enough to make me question myself again. I always appreciate that in a mystery because I hate when the ending feels too obvious.
For me personally though, the ending didn’t hit quite as hard as I wanted it to. It wasn’t bad at all, and everything wrapped up in a way that made sense, but I kept waiting for that final punch that never fully came for me.
Overall, I’d probably give this one around 3. The atmosphere, cover, setting, and slow-building mystery were definitely the strongest parts for me. If you like historical mysteries with family drama, small-town secrets, and a slower suspenseful build, this is worth picking up.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Check out my fun #LitLiftMiniAuthorChat with Jaima!
A gripping, slow-burning 1950s historical noir masterclass.
"A razor-sharp thriller where the hunter is forced to out-think a hidden monster from the confines of a wheelchair."
In DON'T LOOK CLOSE, bestselling author Jaima Fixsen departs from her usual Victorian medical dramas to deliver a deeply atmospheric, mid-century Canadian Rockies, 1950's historical thriller mystery. The story hinges on an unconventional detective in a wheelchair facing immense physical and social hurdles to protect the only family he has left.
Polio survivor vs. small-town serial killer.
Elevator Pitch
A polio survivor wheels out of his rehab clinic and into a hostile post-war mining town, armed only with a camera and a stubborn streak, to catch a hidden serial killer before his sister is wrongfully convicted of murder.
Setting
The story is set in the 1950s in Clairbeck (Canmore), a rugged, isolated mining community nestled in the shadows of the Canadian Rockies. The town is physically segregated by class and wealth, defined by soot-choked air, dangerous coal shafts, and a cold, unforgiving mountain climate.
Vibe
Tense, claustrophobic, and gritty. It blends the bleakness of mid-century noir with the slow-burning dread of an isolated small-town thriller where everyone is watching, but no one is telling the truth.
Why You Should Read
Read this if you are a fan of slow-burn historical mysteries like those by William Kent Krueger, or if you want an atmospheric thriller with a uniquely capable, neurodivergent, or physically challenged protagonist who wins by out-thinking his opponents rather than out-running them.
My Thoughts
The author builds historical tension beautifully. The 1950s timeline is perfectly captured—not just through aesthetics, but through the medical anxiety of the post-polio era and the systemic labor battles of the time. Peter is an unforgettable lead; his frustration, wit, and stubbornness make him incredibly grounded. A masterfully executed, high-stakes climax.
Verdict 5 / 5 Stars ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
"A gripping, atmospheric historical thriller that pairs a highly unique detective with a genuinely chilling small-town conspiracy. A razor-sharp thriller! Mid-century tension & sibling devotion.”
🎧 Audio Standout
The audiobook production of DON'T LOOK CLOSE is brought to life through a deeply atmospheric narration by Libby McKnight. Narrating a historical suspense novel set in a 1950s Canadian mining town requires a delicate balance of pacing, and McKnight delivers it perfectly. She masterfully navigates the tense, claustrophobic atmosphere of Clairbeck, lending a distinct, nuanced vulnerability to Peter as he investigates his sister's case while grappling with the physical realities of polio. McKnight’s ability to anchor the small-town paranoia with a steady, propulsive cadence makes the audiobook format an absolute must-listen for sophisticated thriller fans who love an immersive, character-driven mystery.
Recs
~Ordinary Grace by William Kent Krueger (for the rich historical atmosphere and emotional depth)
~The Specimen by Jaima Fixsen (for more of the author's signature medical mystery roots)
~Until I Find You by Rea Frey (If you love a twisty thriller featuring a protagonist who relies on unique physical observations/sensory pacing to unmask a criminal)
Special thanks to Poisoned Pen Press. RB Media/Recorded Books and NetGalley for an advanced reading and listening copy in exchange for my honest thoughts.
blog review posted @
JudithDCollins.com
@JudithDCollins | #JDCMustReadBooks
My Rating: 5 Stars
Pub Date: Aug 18, 2026
Aug Newsletter
Aug 2026 Must-Read Books
#LitLiftMiniAuthorChat
A gripping, slow-burning 1950s historical noir masterclass.
"A razor-sharp thriller where the hunter is forced to out-think a hidden monster from the confines of a wheelchair."
In DON'T LOOK CLOSE, bestselling author Jaima Fixsen departs from her usual Victorian medical dramas to deliver a deeply atmospheric, mid-century Canadian Rockies, 1950's historical thriller mystery. The story hinges on an unconventional detective in a wheelchair facing immense physical and social hurdles to protect the only family he has left.
Polio survivor vs. small-town serial killer.
Elevator Pitch
A polio survivor wheels out of his rehab clinic and into a hostile post-war mining town, armed only with a camera and a stubborn streak, to catch a hidden serial killer before his sister is wrongfully convicted of murder.
Setting
The story is set in the 1950s in Clairbeck (Canmore), a rugged, isolated mining community nestled in the shadows of the Canadian Rockies. The town is physically segregated by class and wealth, defined by soot-choked air, dangerous coal shafts, and a cold, unforgiving mountain climate.
Vibe
Tense, claustrophobic, and gritty. It blends the bleakness of mid-century noir with the slow-burning dread of an isolated small-town thriller where everyone is watching, but no one is telling the truth.
Genre: Historical Mystery / Crime Fiction / Serial Killer Thriller.
Themes
~Perception vs. Reality
~Disability and Autonomy
~Class and Corporate Greed
~Sibling Devotion
PETER SIMMONS: THE EYE FOR TRUTH
"Turning vulnerability into an investigative superpower ".
Standout Characters
~Peter Simmons:
The protagonist is a fiercely independent polio survivor who refuses to let his physical limitations or his wheelchair stop him from investigating a murder.
~Edie Simmons:
Peter’s sister, a resilient medical professional running a local clinic, caught in a web of town gossip and legal jeopardy.
Author Writing Standout
Fixsen’s background in occupational therapy shines through in her meticulous, highly empathetic rendering of Peter's physical reality. She avoids making his disability a mere plot device, writing his everyday logistics—from maneuvering a 1950s wheelchair on unpaved mining roads to framing a shot with his camera—with striking, tactile realism.
Takeaway
True sight requires looking past social prejudices and surface-level assumptions; the most dangerous monsters are often the ones hiding in plain sight behind a veneer of ordinary respectability.
Title Significance
Don't Look Close acts as a warning from the killer and the town itself. It represents the community's desire to bury its dark secrets and corporate negligence, while simultaneously hinting that if Peter looks too closely through his camera lens, he will draw the killer’s deadly attention.
What happens when you look too close?
Metaphor
Peter’s camera lens serves as the central metaphor of the novel. It represents a tool that both distances him from a world he can no longer physically run through, while sharply focusing on the microscopic clues that able-bodied townspeople completely overlook.
Why You Should Read
Read this if you are a fan of slow-burn historical mysteries like those by William Kent Krueger, or if you want an atmospheric thriller with a uniquely capable, neurodivergent, or physically challenged protagonist who wins by out-thinking his opponents rather than out-running them.
My Thoughts
The author builds historical tension beautifully. The 1950s timeline is perfectly captured—not just through aesthetics, but through the medical anxiety of the post-polio era and the systemic labor battles of the time. Peter is an unforgettable lead; his frustration, wit, and stubbornness make him incredibly grounded. A masterfully executed, high-stakes climax.
Verdict 5 / 5 Stars ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
"A gripping, atmospheric historical thriller that pairs a highly unique detective with a genuinely chilling small-town conspiracy. A razor-sharp thriller! Mid-century tension & sibling devotion.”
🎧 Audio Standout
The audiobook production of DON'T LOOK CLOSE is brought to life through a deeply atmospheric narration by Libby McKnight. Narrating a historical suspense novel set in a 1950s Canadian mining town requires a delicate balance of pacing, and McKnight delivers it perfectly. She masterfully navigates the tense, claustrophobic atmosphere of Clairbeck, lending a distinct, nuanced vulnerability to Peter as he investigates his sister's case while grappling with the physical realities of polio. McKnight’s ability to anchor the small-town paranoia with a steady, propulsive cadence makes the audiobook format an absolute must-listen for sophisticated thriller fans who love an immersive, character-driven mystery.
Recs
~Ordinary Grace by William Kent Krueger (for the rich historical atmosphere and emotional depth)
~The Specimen by Jaima Fixsen (for more of the author's signature medical mystery roots)
~Until I Find You by Rea Frey (If you love a twisty thriller featuring a protagonist who relies on unique physical observations/sensory pacing to unmask a criminal)
Special thanks to Poisoned Pen Press. RB Media/Recorded Books and NetGalley for an advanced reading and listening copy in exchange for my honest thoughts.
blog review posted @
JudithDCollins.com
@JudithDCollins | #JDCMustReadBooks
My Rating: 5 Stars
Pub Date: Aug 18, 2026
Aug Newsletter
Aug 2026 Must-Read Books
#LitLiftMiniAuthorChat
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Quick note: in my ARC copy, the female protagonist is Edie, not Ellie like Goodreads says. I'm going to use my copy in my review 💕
Peter is trying stay hopeful, but the life he loved is over- and that was before his sister is accused of murder! Surprisingly, moving to Canmore to help clear Edie's name gives Peter the motivation he needs to face this new life with focus and determination. He grapples with new physical limitations as he faces mental ones: is he still the kind of man who can protect his sister? How much can he accomplish at a fraction of the abilities he once had? Will his newfound challenges leave him as a liability instead of an asset or wipe him out completely?
Stakes rise immeasurably when an investigator is found dead, leading Peter and Edie the realize this mystery is more convoluted than they first imagined and unsure who they can trust. If the police only investigate one suspect, are they purposefully twisting the case or honestly blinded by tunnel vision? Who would have a motive and the means to commit these murders in a humble mining town without leaving any discernible evidence?
This thriller is an excellent "whodunnit" mystery that effectively balances both suspenseful plot and the protagonist’s psychological struggles and triumphs. I really enjoyed the multi-faceted nature of the story and recommend it!
Troupes: amateur sleuth, premature suspect, confrontational reveal, grand escape
Spice: 0/5 🌶️
Gore: 1/5 🩸 implied
Language: 0/5 👀
Thank you to Poisoned Pen Press and NetGalley for this ARC!
Peter is trying stay hopeful, but the life he loved is over- and that was before his sister is accused of murder! Surprisingly, moving to Canmore to help clear Edie's name gives Peter the motivation he needs to face this new life with focus and determination. He grapples with new physical limitations as he faces mental ones: is he still the kind of man who can protect his sister? How much can he accomplish at a fraction of the abilities he once had? Will his newfound challenges leave him as a liability instead of an asset or wipe him out completely?
Stakes rise immeasurably when an investigator is found dead, leading Peter and Edie the realize this mystery is more convoluted than they first imagined and unsure who they can trust. If the police only investigate one suspect, are they purposefully twisting the case or honestly blinded by tunnel vision? Who would have a motive and the means to commit these murders in a humble mining town without leaving any discernible evidence?
This thriller is an excellent "whodunnit" mystery that effectively balances both suspenseful plot and the protagonist’s psychological struggles and triumphs. I really enjoyed the multi-faceted nature of the story and recommend it!
Troupes: amateur sleuth, premature suspect, confrontational reveal, grand escape
Spice: 0/5 🌶️
Gore: 1/5 🩸 implied
Language: 0/5 👀
Thank you to Poisoned Pen Press and NetGalley for this ARC!
August 2, 2026
3.75 stars, rounded up! This one hooked me from the setup alone: Peter checks himself out of a polio rehab ward, still learning to get around without full use of his legs, to go prove his sister’s innocence after her ex-husband turns up dead. There’s something so compelling about a protagonist who has to work twice as hard just to move through the world, let alone chase down a killer, and the author uses that tension well. The “retro Nancy Drew” vibe comes through in the pacing, old grudges, small-town secrets, a mining community that closes ranks against outsiders, and a mystery that unspools a little at a time.
Libby McKnight’s narration suited the story nicely. She gave Peter a stubborn, wry quality that made him easy to root for, and she handled the shifting cast of locals with enough distinction that I never lost track of who was who, which matters a lot in an audiobook with this many suspects.
Where it lost some steam for me was pacing in the middle section. The small-town intrigue is atmospheric, but a couple of the subplots (the mining tension especially) slowed the momentum right when I wanted the investigation to push forward. Still, the ending pulled the threads together in a satisfying way, and I liked that Peter’s disability was written as a real obstacle he had to problem-solve around rather than something the plot conveniently ignored.
If you’re into slow-burn small-town mysteries with a determined, unconventional amateur sleuth, this book is for you.
Thank you to RBmedia and NetGalley for the ARC.
Libby McKnight’s narration suited the story nicely. She gave Peter a stubborn, wry quality that made him easy to root for, and she handled the shifting cast of locals with enough distinction that I never lost track of who was who, which matters a lot in an audiobook with this many suspects.
Where it lost some steam for me was pacing in the middle section. The small-town intrigue is atmospheric, but a couple of the subplots (the mining tension especially) slowed the momentum right when I wanted the investigation to push forward. Still, the ending pulled the threads together in a satisfying way, and I liked that Peter’s disability was written as a real obstacle he had to problem-solve around rather than something the plot conveniently ignored.
If you’re into slow-burn small-town mysteries with a determined, unconventional amateur sleuth, this book is for you.
Thank you to RBmedia and NetGalley for the ARC.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the advance audiobook copy in exchange for an honest review.
As a lover of crime and thriller novels, I was really looking forward to this title. At its core, it's a whodunit murder mystery, where our main protagonist Edie, finds herself being scrutinised for the murder of her ex-husband.
A standout for me was the atmosphere created. This novel was set in the 1950s and featured a main character who had been diagnosed with polio. You don't often see this kind of representation, so that was really interesting to read about. This book was also very easy to follow and I feel it's relatively simple to follow for readers who might be dipping their toes into this genre.
Unfortunately, the main issues I had with this novel were its characters and more specifically the decisions the characters were making. I found the main character Edie made pretty silly decisions which kept her implicated, over and over again. As well as that, the investigators didn't seem to help with uncovering the killer (or even detaining and questioning the suspects!) This therefore made the storyline quite unbelievable and I found myself losing interest.
The big reveal at the end fell a little flat for me, as there wasn't a whole lot of character development and we didn't really glean much about the killer's motivations.
Overall, this was definitely an atmospheric and fun, fast-paced read. However I struggled to understand most of the characters' motivations throughout the novel.
As a lover of crime and thriller novels, I was really looking forward to this title. At its core, it's a whodunit murder mystery, where our main protagonist Edie, finds herself being scrutinised for the murder of her ex-husband.
A standout for me was the atmosphere created. This novel was set in the 1950s and featured a main character who had been diagnosed with polio. You don't often see this kind of representation, so that was really interesting to read about. This book was also very easy to follow and I feel it's relatively simple to follow for readers who might be dipping their toes into this genre.
Unfortunately, the main issues I had with this novel were its characters and more specifically the decisions the characters were making. I found the main character Edie made pretty silly decisions which kept her implicated, over and over again. As well as that, the investigators didn't seem to help with uncovering the killer (or even detaining and questioning the suspects!) This therefore made the storyline quite unbelievable and I found myself losing interest.
The big reveal at the end fell a little flat for me, as there wasn't a whole lot of character development and we didn't really glean much about the killer's motivations.
Overall, this was definitely an atmospheric and fun, fast-paced read. However I struggled to understand most of the characters' motivations throughout the novel.
Did Not Finish
July 31, 2026DNF 26%
I really enjoyed Fixsen's previous historical mystery, The Specimen, so I was looking forward to checking out Don't Look Close. Unfortunately, this one didn't work for me in the same way. The Specimen's mad scientist/doctor angle made it much more intriguing for my personal taste, as I tend to love stories with medical or biological elements.
This is very much a historical mystery in its execution, with a slower pace and a light, domestic tone. If you pick this up expecting a twisty, high-stakes thriller, you will likely be disappointed. I'm not sure if it's because of the pacing or the tone, but I became bored very quickly. I wasn't feeling much momentum or investigative intrigue, and I didn't find the characters all that interesting. This just wasn't a good fit for me.
I think readers who enjoyed The Vermilion Sea by Megan Chance will have a better time with this. And for readers looking for a historical mystery that is more mystery-forward with slightly higher stakes (and who don't mind a light speculative element in the form of uncomplicated time travel), I'd recommend The Frozen People by Elly Griffiths instead.
Thank you to NetGalley for this advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.
I really enjoyed Fixsen's previous historical mystery, The Specimen, so I was looking forward to checking out Don't Look Close. Unfortunately, this one didn't work for me in the same way. The Specimen's mad scientist/doctor angle made it much more intriguing for my personal taste, as I tend to love stories with medical or biological elements.
This is very much a historical mystery in its execution, with a slower pace and a light, domestic tone. If you pick this up expecting a twisty, high-stakes thriller, you will likely be disappointed. I'm not sure if it's because of the pacing or the tone, but I became bored very quickly. I wasn't feeling much momentum or investigative intrigue, and I didn't find the characters all that interesting. This just wasn't a good fit for me.
I think readers who enjoyed The Vermilion Sea by Megan Chance will have a better time with this. And for readers looking for a historical mystery that is more mystery-forward with slightly higher stakes (and who don't mind a light speculative element in the form of uncomplicated time travel), I'd recommend The Frozen People by Elly Griffiths instead.
Thank you to NetGalley for this advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 118 reviews