A boy discovers a magical deck of wizard cards… but will they spell chaos for his school talent show? Two siblings believe that the best way to beat their bullies is to become monsters… but what happens when they can’t change back? A boy gets a strange call on his second-hand cell phone… but when the creatures on the other end of the line find him, he gets much more than he bargained for. And each story comes with a personal introduction from Stine himself, adding even more chills.
Laced with Stine’s signature humor and a hefty dose of nightmarish fun, Stinetinglers 5 is perfect for fans of Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark and Stine’s own Goosebumps books who want even more scares. These chilling tales prove that Stine’s epic legacy in the horror genre is justly earned. Dive in, and beware: you'll be sleeping with the lights on tonight.
Robert Lawrence Stine known as R. L. Stine and Jovial Bob Stine, is an American novelist and writer, well known for targeting younger audiences. Stine, who is often called the Stephen King of children's literature, is the author of dozens of popular horror fiction novellas, including the books in the Goosebumps, Rotten School, Mostly Ghostly, The Nightmare Room and Fear Street series.
R. L. Stine began his writing career when he was nine years old, and today he has achieved the position of the bestselling children's author in history. In the early 1990s, Stine was catapulted to fame when he wrote the unprecedented, bestselling Goosebumps® series, which sold more than 250 million copies and became a worldwide multimedia phenomenon. His other major series, Fear Street, has over 80 million copies sold.
Stine has received numerous awards of recognition, including several Nickelodeon Kids' Choice Awards and Disney Adventures Kids' Choice Awards, and he has been selected by kids as one of their favorite authors in the NEA's Read Across America program. He lives in New York, NY.
*The Ping Pong Game Of Death*: 7.8/10 Pretty Good *How To Be A Monster*: 7.5/10 Pretty Good *Ride The Dragon*: 7.3/10 Decent *The Mwa Mwa*: 6/10 Okay *Happy Birthday Jack*: 5.5/10 Okay *The Bad Sleepover*: 5/10 Meh *The Swim Party*: 4.5/10 Pretty Bad *Wizard Cards*: 4/10 Bad *Is That You, Marlon?*: 3/10 Very Bad *Clown Are Not Scary*: 2/10 Awful
Overall, another mid read from the short story collection series. The two highest rated stories ended up being overall good, with an EC Comics schlocky ghost story and then Stine doing his own version of Robert McCammon’s *Makeup* short story (but the ending to this one kind of felt cliche). The other stories are mostly forgettable, rehashing old stuff and all the 7 other lower ranked stories being random for no reason.
The two lowest ranked stories are terrible though even for Stine. *Is That You, Marlon* makes zero sense at all throughout and especially by the twist, and the protagonist does a drowning suicide stunt like Camp Cold Lake. *Clowns Are Not Scary* is one of his worst stories having one of the most random climaxes ever in kids horror, no “horror” at all present, and a shitty gag ending.
Full review to come. This was typical RL Stine, though I’m not sure how well Stine translates into 2026. Even with modern references, this feels very dated as far as how kids actually behave.
Huge thanks to Macmillan Audio, Feiwel & Friends, and Netgalley for the audio ARC. The narrations by Johnny Heller, Katherine Chin, & Torian Brackett were all solid. I love the idea of someone being “the voice” of R. L. Stine as he introduces every story.
“10 New Stories from America’s Scare Master.” That’s a pretty hefty tagline, and one hell of a thing to live up to. Now I’ve been reading Stine since I was little. I absolutely loved the original TV series as well, and I think the Disney+ ones are pretty cool too. So as much as I go into each read just looking to have a good time, there’s still pretty high expectations. One thing I always try to remember … I am not the middle grade audience. That said, I mostly enjoy shutting my brain off and keeping an ear or eye out for those little Stine-touches—you know, those one or two sentence twists at the end of stories that change everything you thought previously. And I’m glad to report there’s certainly still some of those herein.
I wasn’t madly in move with this set of stories, but I also didn’t mind my listening whatsoever. I just think when I mentally stack them up with the four other sets out so far, these were a little less fleshed out. And keep in mind that preferring these less doesn’t mean I think they’re bad. Now, will a middle grade reader notice or feel the same? No, definitely not! Other adults reading this might disagree with it too, that’s the beauty of reading.
My personal favorite was a spin on a tale as old as time, or rather a popular item (the doll/collectible craze here) as old as time. Raggedy Ann, Cabbage Patch Kids, Beanie Babies, Furby, even things like Tamagotchi and whatever the heck a Labubu is. Now, Stine has brought us the latest iteration with his own creation, one that’s flying off tables and shelves, forcing people to resort to shoving and shouts. When there’s only one left on the table, without the box(!) no less, well, beggars can’t really be choosers. I seriously doubt that the 2-per-person rule was strictly followed here though. What follows is anything other than the expected. This latest iteration is supposed to talk, but the things this one is saying, the things it’s doing, just don’t seem right! It immediately made me think of E. Reyes’ Scurry Furries, although if a middle grade student read that, it’d give them some premature hair on their chest. This is a fun story with elements of Gremlins for a younger generation.
My runner up would have to be the collection’s first story. A young boy is made king after the unexpected death of his father. He’s far younger than he’s meant to be when taking the crown, too green, too untaught. This has caused some obvious friction as his father’s lead advisor—no, his advisor now—is unhappy with this development. In a grab for power or simply in outright anger, the advisor tells the young king he must ride a dragon for all to see. It’s the rite of passage for all kings, and his age certainly shouldn’t be enough to change the rules, right? Sadly, the advisor is far more nefarious than he lets on. This dynamic, as well as the cool and calm demeanor of the young king, reminded me of Tom Dumbrell’s Cyrus in The Look of a King, though admittedly sans dragons. That one’s for young adult though, so there’s something there young readers can enjoy. It was nice to see Stine integrate some fantasy into his scares, or perhaps it’s his signature scares into some fantasy?
The book proves something that I have always felt, and it’s that Stine can turn pretty much anything into a creepy story. So again, this is another success. Perfect for fans of Stine (you know who you are), and a great entry point for young readers that want to get into something a little more scary.
Another mediocre (actually, mediocre is nice - pretty forgettable would be more accurate) collection of short stories from Stine. *Sigh* Think I just need to go back and reread Tales to Give You Goosebumps and Nightmare / Haunting Hour. Stine was on point with his short stories back in the day. Not so much now.
1. Ride the Dragon - 2.25⭐
2. The Ping Pong Game of Death - 3⭐
3. Happy Birthday Jack! - 2.25⭐
4. The Mwa-Mwa - 2.5⭐
5. The Bad Sleepover - 2⭐
6. The Swim Party - 1.5⭐
7. How to Be A Monster - 2.5⭐
8. Clowns Are Not Scary - 2.25⭐
9. Wizard Cards - 2.25⭐
10. Is That You, Marlon? - 1.75⭐
Not recommended. Just lots of rehashed ideas that Stine has done already, and done much, much better in previous stories and collections.
Ride the Dragon: A classic, medieval testing of one's mettle. A bit unnerving there for a little while, but our boy-king has the guts to take on this dragon!
The Ping-pong Game of Death: OOOOOooooOOOOOooo! BOO! Grady only has one fear in the whole world... GHOSTS! And he's about to face his fear. But what if his fate is worse than he could have imagined?
Happy Birthday Jack: A secret door that must never be opened. And a secret that has been kept from Jack all his life. But he's 13 now, and that secret is being unleashed.
The Mwah Mwah: The next new toy craze that everyone has to collect? Mwah Mwahs. Ugly little creature dolls that are kinda... terrifying. Especially since... it talks.
The Bad Sleepover: It's one crazy sleepover... plans of revenge... turn into something more sinister?
The Swim Party: TWINS! But how many is too many??? (Hint: When you are twins, then any number over two.)
How to Be a Monster: Another twin story -- but far, far different! This brother and sister would do anything to get the school bullies to leave them alone. They would even turn into furry, scary... monsters.
Clowns Are Not Scary: Harry's dad is a circus clown and he's coming to Harry's school to show the students that clowns are NOT scary. Well, guess what? This clown is!
Wizard Cards: A boy named Wizard finds a deck of cards -- a very dangerous deck of cards!
Is That You, Marlin?: A creepy, one might say, alien, scary story! A good finale for this collection.
Some of the stories seem a bit so-so. But I'm always interested in Stine's new books, and this made for a fun read!
I enjoyed the audiobook experience. There are several different narrators who contributed, so each story has its own unique voice, so that we can really hear the individual personalities of each main character. Excellent job on the audio.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Netgalley, but was not required to leave a positive review.
Thank you to NetGalley and Macmillan Audio for the ALC in exchange for an honest review.
3.5 rounded up I thought this was a pretty decent collection of short stories. It's a bit nostalgic for me to be reading and listening to RL Stine books in 2026. I've recently started rereading the classic Goosebumps books, so when I saw he had a new book of short stories, I felt compelled to check it out. As is the case with most short story collections, I enjoyed some of them more than others. Some are a bit silly, and I don't think will actually be scary to its intended audience, but I still think kids will find it entertaining.
As far as the audio production is concerned, I liked that it had multiple narrators and thought they did a good job. I'm not sure I enjoyed the main person narrating RL Stine's thoughts at the beginning of each story, but overall, it was a good production.
I'm just a millennial who will never stop chasing the feeling of growing up reading Goosebumps! 👻
This brought back ALL of that nostalgia. The creepy stories, weird twists, and spooky fun immediately transported me back to being a kid devouring R. L. Stine books. 🥹
I listened to the audiobook, and the multicast narration was so much fun! 🎧
If you grew up on Goosebumps too, I highly recommend the audiobook!
📅 Pub Date: August 25, 2026 💛 Thank you to Macmillan Audio, Macmillan Young Listeners, and NetGalley for the advanced listening copy. All thoughts are my own.
For these ten stories, I listened to the first three with my 10 year old nephew, the next three with my 9 year old niece, and the last four like the adult child I am. We all enjoyed these stories, with my nephew's rankings being #3, #2, #1. My niece enjoyed all of them equally. I think I was partial to the clown one personally. These are easy, fluffy light horror stories. Certainly nothing revolutionary or jaw dropping, but kind of cozy and maybe new and interesting to young kids. I will say that I kind of felt like the first story was the weakest, which is so rarely the case for me when reading short stories. Also, there was nothing here to traumatize the kids for life, which is good.
The narrators were all capable and there were no weak links.
Thank you to NetGalley and Macmillan Audio for the ALC.
I enjoyed reading the previous four books in this series. So, I was excited to see a new collection was coming out. My son was also really excited. He’s become a huge Goosebumps fan! I’m not sure if it’s the fact I’m getting older or R. L. Stine is or both, but his newer stories just don’t hit the same way as his older stories do! My seven year old son said, “why aren’t these scary like the others?”
As with any story collection, some were better than others. My son’s favorite was the one with the cell phone! I enjoyed the fact that R.L Stine personally explained his motivations behind each story in the audiobook. I thought the narration was well done.
Overall, it’s an engaging collection of stories. I just didn’t think it was as good as previous stories Stine has written!
Stinetinglers is not for the faint of heart, or rather for the easily scared (especially or clowns!) mom. However it was perfect for a 6yo who adores creepy, spooky, and scary tales. I grew up reading Stine in the 80’s/90’s and it was so much fun to share this author and his work with my youngest. He has now requested we listen to the previous Stinetingler books!
Thank you Netgalley and Macmillan Audio for the ALC.
Stinetinglers are always fun reads. This one was just as fun. I hope to read more. These are perfect to get ready for spooky season. Each story was creepy and cool. I always have a favorite story or two. The Monster Siblings was mine for this book. Who does not want to scare their bullies? I cannot wait to read more stories. Thank you to NetGalley and Macmillan Audio for the audio arc in exchange for my honest review.
***I was given this book as an ALC to review by NetGalley.***
This book was great! It was a perfect book full of scary short stories. I think any child or tween would really enjoy this book. The voice actors are also very good in this audiobook and change with the stories. I would highly recommend this book to anyone who likes a good scary story! Just another R.L. Stine classic!! #Stinetinglers5 #NetGalley
'Stinetinglers' as a series has got progressively worse from book to book and this entry didn't stop the rot. This collection was infuriating, It's filled with stories that are nonsensical, boring, have terrible twists and lack any fright factor or stakes. Also the writing at times was unforgivable, short choppy sentences and full stops all over the place made it borderline unreadable (especially the final story). Here's a snippet... A car rolled by. Kids waved at them from the back seat. Mickey didn't pay any attention. He was telling Arthur about the argument with his parents. They picked up speed as the turned onto Lakeshore Road. Mickey's hair bounced on his head. I mean, what is that? Drivel, written by a man who's supposed to have nearly half a century's worth of experience behind him. There is one story in here that stuck out 'The Swim Party' not because it was particularly great, although it was intriguing. But because it was written so strangely and having read almost everything Stine has ever released, was most definitely not written by him.
Thank you to NetGalley and Macmillan Audio for giving me this amazing, nostalgic, and fun audio book. If R.L. Stine has no fans, consider me gone! This was a great group of stories, that had you wishing they were longer! I couldn’t pick a favorite if I had to.. although the last one definetly went out with a bang. I think this series would he perfect for kids who don’t have a huge long span. You could read a short story each night before bed.
Stinetinglers 5 was a good selection of short scary stories that absolutely deliver the nostalgic feeling you get from R.L. Stine. Admittedly, the goosebumps fan in me HAD to request this from Netgalley and I was not disappointed- my fav had to do with a never-ending ping pong game.
This was a fun book. It went right along with the other 4 in the series so far. Each story felt complete and followed the stereotypical RL Stine formula. I didn't dislike any of them, but I did like some more than others. Most of them were pretty goofy, but nothing that would really scare anyone. If you ever were or are a Goosebumps fan, this is definitely a series you want to check out. There were several audiobook narrators which I love, especially when there are both female and male POVs. They did a great job and I think would really appeal to the middle grade target audience. Thank you to Netgalley and Macmillan Audio for an advanced copy of this book in exchange for an honest review!
Have to admit that I bought this before I read it. It amazes me that I enjoy Stine's short stories and Fear Street books so much when I am not a fan of Goosebumps!
This was a nostalgic little treat! I overall enjoyed these short spooky tales, and I think kids and adults alike would be entertained! For me, they were a nice horror-lite palette cleanser. After reading these new R.L. Stine stories, I was also inspired to read some of the original Goosebumps books again!
I read this via the audiobook and that really added to the experience I think! The narration was fun, emotional, and engaging. This is perfect for young listeners!
Thank you to Macmillan Audio for the ALC via NetGalley!
Stinetinglers 5 was such a fun collection of creepy stories! R.L. Stine is so good at taking an everyday situation and turning it into something completely unsettling, and I loved the variety of stories in this collection. Some of the stories definitely got under my skin more than others, but that’s part of the fun with a collection like this. There were plenty of creepy twists, weird situations, and those classic “wait… WHAT?!” endings that made me want to keep reading. This was a quick, entertaining read and a great choice for anyone who enjoys spooky short stories without needing to commit to one long storyline. Definitely a fun addition to the Stinetinglers series! I was given an advanced copy of this book in exchange for my review.