What do you think?
Rate this book
Lilac: A Novel
Five years ago, a man vanished without a trace. When a mysterious note arrives under his daughter’s door, her renewed hope and determination for the truth threatens to unearth secrets long since buried.
Scarred by loss and haunted by the unresolved disappearance of her father, Cosette Emory has spent years burying the past. But when an anonymous message appears under her door, she’s pulled into a reality she has tried desperately to escape.
With a renewed determination and a growing list of questions, Cosette finds herself in the middle of a glamorously deceptive world of Chicago’s social elite—a world built on privilege, power, and secrets.
As she delves deeper into her father’s mysterious case, Cosette must confront painful memories, long-buried secrets, and class divides that threaten to consume her. With each revelation, she questions who she can trust—and whether the truth is worth the price.
Lilac is a story about grief, immense loss, and the dark secrets powerful people will do anything to protect. As one woman searches for the truth, she will uncover a world where silence is currency, and the cost of speaking out is everything.
Scarred by loss and haunted by the unresolved disappearance of her father, Cosette Emory has spent years burying the past. But when an anonymous message appears under her door, she’s pulled into a reality she has tried desperately to escape.
With a renewed determination and a growing list of questions, Cosette finds herself in the middle of a glamorously deceptive world of Chicago’s social elite—a world built on privilege, power, and secrets.
As she delves deeper into her father’s mysterious case, Cosette must confront painful memories, long-buried secrets, and class divides that threaten to consume her. With each revelation, she questions who she can trust—and whether the truth is worth the price.
Lilac is a story about grief, immense loss, and the dark secrets powerful people will do anything to protect. As one woman searches for the truth, she will uncover a world where silence is currency, and the cost of speaking out is everything.
- GenresMystery Thriller
316 pages, Paperback
Published October 28, 2025
6 people are currently reading
86 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 50 reviews
February 11, 2026
Oh this was a fun ride. think this is one of the better mystery I have read recently so I appreciate that. This book was refreshing and good. It kept you guessing!
Read
January 9, 2026Dnf @20%
With some encouragement from my friends (lol) I decided to DNF Lilac at around 20%, though I may revisit it at another time.
The title, cover and plot really pulled me in and there is definitely potential here but in my era of branching out (happy new year) I’m learning what I like and dislike and I fear overall , the writing style didn’t work for me.
Early on, I began to notice moments where the prose felt overly specific or oddly framed in ways that pulled me out of the story. I also struggled with the heavy reliance on telling rather than showing. The main character’s thoughts and emotions are often stated directly, word for word, which left little room for interpretation or emotional discovery as a reader.
The writing sometimes swung between very conventional, introspective language and unexpectedly blunt descriptions, which created an uneven reading experience for me personally. While I appreciate what the book may be trying to do, I think maybe it’s just not for me
With some encouragement from my friends (lol) I decided to DNF Lilac at around 20%, though I may revisit it at another time.
The title, cover and plot really pulled me in and there is definitely potential here but in my era of branching out (happy new year) I’m learning what I like and dislike and I fear overall , the writing style didn’t work for me.
Early on, I began to notice moments where the prose felt overly specific or oddly framed in ways that pulled me out of the story. I also struggled with the heavy reliance on telling rather than showing. The main character’s thoughts and emotions are often stated directly, word for word, which left little room for interpretation or emotional discovery as a reader.
The writing sometimes swung between very conventional, introspective language and unexpectedly blunt descriptions, which created an uneven reading experience for me personally. While I appreciate what the book may be trying to do, I think maybe it’s just not for me
September 23, 2025
This book was SO freaking good. I’m typically a romance girlie, but when I saw this was a mystery with a romance subplot, I thought, ‘let’s give it a try’—and wow, did it deliver! Let’s start with the romance because GIRL. You now have me waiting for a full-blown romance novel from you because you clearly know how to write a sexy CEO. 👀 Now back to the mystery because that’s where this book really shines.
Cosette is our FMC whose father vanished five years ago, and she’s finally ready to dig for answers. What she uncovers is a web of secrets, family ties, and past investigations that pull her deeper into a dangerous truth. She teams up with a PI her family hired years ago, and together they try to unravel her father’s disappearance—while Cosette deals with still trying to navigate her own grief and start to learn what moving forward really means. As someone who has experienced the grief of losing a parent, this hit me so hard. The way Burton writes about Cosette’s grief, and how it continues to change over time even five years later, is so raw and beautifully done.
This author can WRITE. I still cannot believe this is only a debut, because it felt polished, emotional, and perfectly paced. A.A. Burton is officially on my auto-buy list. Can’t wait to see what she does next!
Ps one of my favorite things is when you meet a character that you instantly relate to, and Esther felt like that for me. She’s a little more of a party girl than I am, but she’s the ultimate ride-or-die friend—the one who makes life less heavy when you need it most—and exactly what Cosette needed.
Cosette is our FMC whose father vanished five years ago, and she’s finally ready to dig for answers. What she uncovers is a web of secrets, family ties, and past investigations that pull her deeper into a dangerous truth. She teams up with a PI her family hired years ago, and together they try to unravel her father’s disappearance—while Cosette deals with still trying to navigate her own grief and start to learn what moving forward really means. As someone who has experienced the grief of losing a parent, this hit me so hard. The way Burton writes about Cosette’s grief, and how it continues to change over time even five years later, is so raw and beautifully done.
This author can WRITE. I still cannot believe this is only a debut, because it felt polished, emotional, and perfectly paced. A.A. Burton is officially on my auto-buy list. Can’t wait to see what she does next!
Ps one of my favorite things is when you meet a character that you instantly relate to, and Esther felt like that for me. She’s a little more of a party girl than I am, but she’s the ultimate ride-or-die friend—the one who makes life less heavy when you need it most—and exactly what Cosette needed.
September 9, 2025
Okay this book had me in a complete chokehold. I don’t normally love a mystery novel (I’m a romance girlie) but this book delivered.
Cosettes dad went missing without any clues as to what happened. It’s been 5 years and she wants answers, but is she ready for all she will uncover? Cosette quickly realizes there’s more to what happened than she ever could have imagined. Caught up in secrets and powerful people, Cosette will uncover more than she planned too and learns to live with her grief in the process.
A mystery served with a side of romance? IM IN. This debut novel was EVERYTHING. The writing was beautiful and the story had me flipping pages at midnight. You will want to scream at Cosette and also give her a hug 😭 I cried, I laughed, I was frustrated and mad and happy. This pulled out all the emotions. Don’t miss the release of this one!!
Cosettes dad went missing without any clues as to what happened. It’s been 5 years and she wants answers, but is she ready for all she will uncover? Cosette quickly realizes there’s more to what happened than she ever could have imagined. Caught up in secrets and powerful people, Cosette will uncover more than she planned too and learns to live with her grief in the process.
A mystery served with a side of romance? IM IN. This debut novel was EVERYTHING. The writing was beautiful and the story had me flipping pages at midnight. You will want to scream at Cosette and also give her a hug 😭 I cried, I laughed, I was frustrated and mad and happy. This pulled out all the emotions. Don’t miss the release of this one!!
October 9, 2025
5 ⭐️ AMAZING! A cold case mystery with a side of romance.
This is a story with grief and a healing journey so beautifully written you will feel every emotion right along with Cosette. So many raw emotions and it was written so beautifully. The storyline was so unique and kept me engaged the entire time.
“My little lilac” 💜
“Numb acceptance of a traumatic outcome is a sure way to know hope is a long way from home.”
A perfect debut novel.
Thank you so much AA Barton for this ARC. I can’t wait to read more of your books!
This is a story with grief and a healing journey so beautifully written you will feel every emotion right along with Cosette. So many raw emotions and it was written so beautifully. The storyline was so unique and kept me engaged the entire time.
“My little lilac” 💜
“Numb acceptance of a traumatic outcome is a sure way to know hope is a long way from home.”
A perfect debut novel.
Thank you so much AA Barton for this ARC. I can’t wait to read more of your books!
September 23, 2025
Was honored to be a beta reader for this book, and it is soooo good. The writing is stunning, the mystery hooks you, and the romantic subplot keeps you turning the pages even if it’s 3am (trust me I lost sleep over this book)
The way the author immerses you in the story and brings the characters to life is astounding, especially when you consider that this is her debut.
Can’t wait to read more A A Barton, definitely a new autobuy author for me
The way the author immerses you in the story and brings the characters to life is astounding, especially when you consider that this is her debut.
Can’t wait to read more A A Barton, definitely a new autobuy author for me
November 11, 2025
Thank you to NetGalley and A.A. Barton for providing me with an advanced copy of this book! ⭐️
I was immediately drawn in by the premise of Lilac, a mystery-suspense novel with a romance subplot. While this isn't usually a genre I gravitate toward, I am quite glad I gave it a chance. It is a captivating, emotionally resonant, and well-written debut.
The story follows the protagonist, Cosette, as she investigates and unravels the mystery surrounding her father's disappearance five years prior. The novel delves into universal themes of pain, love, and loss, those experiences that feel just as relevant to those in their 20s as they do to readers of any age.
One of the novel’s most striking elements is how Barton weaves flashbacks into the present-day narrative. Moments like these are a powerful way to explore grief and the lingering effects of loss, no matter how much time has passed. She handles these themes with such poignancy and tenderness that make the emotional depth of the story all the more impactful. While the plot could be slightly predictable at times, I don’t find that it takes away from anything, as there were also some moments that kept me guessing, leaving me curious as to what could possibly happen next.
Some bits I could do without, and at times I wanted to shout at Cosette, "DON'T DO IT! IT'S A TRAP!", though, moments like these were necessary for the plot. But overall, Lilac is a lovely, easy-to-follow, promising debut, and I look forward to seeing what A.A. Barton writes next!
I was immediately drawn in by the premise of Lilac, a mystery-suspense novel with a romance subplot. While this isn't usually a genre I gravitate toward, I am quite glad I gave it a chance. It is a captivating, emotionally resonant, and well-written debut.
The story follows the protagonist, Cosette, as she investigates and unravels the mystery surrounding her father's disappearance five years prior. The novel delves into universal themes of pain, love, and loss, those experiences that feel just as relevant to those in their 20s as they do to readers of any age.
One of the novel’s most striking elements is how Barton weaves flashbacks into the present-day narrative. Moments like these are a powerful way to explore grief and the lingering effects of loss, no matter how much time has passed. She handles these themes with such poignancy and tenderness that make the emotional depth of the story all the more impactful. While the plot could be slightly predictable at times, I don’t find that it takes away from anything, as there were also some moments that kept me guessing, leaving me curious as to what could possibly happen next.
Some bits I could do without, and at times I wanted to shout at Cosette, "DON'T DO IT! IT'S A TRAP!", though, moments like these were necessary for the plot. But overall, Lilac is a lovely, easy-to-follow, promising debut, and I look forward to seeing what A.A. Barton writes next!
January 9, 2026
What a way to blend “The image of your body is seared into my mind, Cosette. It wasn't hard to find something that would fit it perfectly” and here’s where your father’s body is into one book!
Captivating, emotional, hot, dark, bold. Such a great first book of the year AND a great debut from this author.
Remember, don’t trust the politicians ;)
Captivating, emotional, hot, dark, bold. Such a great first book of the year AND a great debut from this author.
Remember, don’t trust the politicians ;)
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
December 24, 2025
“It's when you are losing someone that you truly realize how much you love them-the reality sinking in that this will be the last time you hold them or speak to them. I know we will all go through it at some point in our lives, but I don't think anyone truly understands what it is to love someone until you lose them, until you watch them die.
In hindsight, I now understand what the songwriter meant, and I am not ready to do it again.”
I couldn’t put this down! Loved the main character. Loved the side characters. Loved all the coffee. Perfect debut novel!
In hindsight, I now understand what the songwriter meant, and I am not ready to do it again.”
I couldn’t put this down! Loved the main character. Loved the side characters. Loved all the coffee. Perfect debut novel!
February 8, 2026
Lilac immediately caught my attention. The cover, the premise, and the promise of a mystery set within Chicago’s glamorous social elite felt entirely up my alley — particularly the line about Cosette being pulled into “a glamorously deceptive world,” which made me excited to step into that setting.
There’s a compelling foundation here: grief, long-buried secrets, and the tension between power and privilege. It’s the kind of story that has all the ingredients for an immersive, character-driven thriller.
That said, the novel ultimately wasn’t the right fit for me. I found the writing style quite direct and explanatory at times, often guiding the reader’s emotions rather than allowing moments to unfold organically. Because of this, I struggled to fully connect with the characters, who sometimes felt underdeveloped or lacking distinct voices. I kept wanting a bit more depth and nuance to help them feel more layered and believable.
The pacing is quick and the story easy to follow, which will likely appeal to readers who prefer accessible, fast-moving mysteries. For me personally, I tend to gravitate toward thrillers with more subtlety and atmosphere, so I found myself wishing for greater complexity and unpredictability.
Overall, while this one didn’t quite land for me, I can see the potential in the premise and would be interested to see how the author’s voice continues to grow in future work.
Thank you to NetGalley and A.A. Barton for providing an advance copy in exchange for an honest review.
There’s a compelling foundation here: grief, long-buried secrets, and the tension between power and privilege. It’s the kind of story that has all the ingredients for an immersive, character-driven thriller.
That said, the novel ultimately wasn’t the right fit for me. I found the writing style quite direct and explanatory at times, often guiding the reader’s emotions rather than allowing moments to unfold organically. Because of this, I struggled to fully connect with the characters, who sometimes felt underdeveloped or lacking distinct voices. I kept wanting a bit more depth and nuance to help them feel more layered and believable.
The pacing is quick and the story easy to follow, which will likely appeal to readers who prefer accessible, fast-moving mysteries. For me personally, I tend to gravitate toward thrillers with more subtlety and atmosphere, so I found myself wishing for greater complexity and unpredictability.
Overall, while this one didn’t quite land for me, I can see the potential in the premise and would be interested to see how the author’s voice continues to grow in future work.
Thank you to NetGalley and A.A. Barton for providing an advance copy in exchange for an honest review.
February 2, 2026
Lilac | Debut Mystery | 278 Pages | ARC Ebook | ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Get in losers, we’re solving a cold case!
Lilac is a mystery set in the heart of Chicago (my favorite city) and explores the grief of a daughter, Cosette Emory, on the five year anniversary of her father’s disappearance. With the case gone cold, she’s left with the only family member in her life now - her Aunt Billie.
When a mysterious note is left at her door, questions start to form for her. Was her dad actually murdered? Who knows about this? And worse - are they still nearby? Secrets are unleashed and you won’t know who to trust. Especially men that owned the computer father worked at. A bunch of bitch ass rich men strike again.
“Not all men are bad men—my father wasn’t. But not all men are good men, and ones with money, with power—those can be the most dangerous of them all.”
I enjoyed the story and surprised it came from a debut author! There were some aspects they were pretty predictable for me, but it was a fun ride nonetheless. Enjoyed it!
Get in losers, we’re solving a cold case!
Lilac is a mystery set in the heart of Chicago (my favorite city) and explores the grief of a daughter, Cosette Emory, on the five year anniversary of her father’s disappearance. With the case gone cold, she’s left with the only family member in her life now - her Aunt Billie.
When a mysterious note is left at her door, questions start to form for her. Was her dad actually murdered? Who knows about this? And worse - are they still nearby? Secrets are unleashed and you won’t know who to trust. Especially men that owned the computer father worked at. A bunch of bitch ass rich men strike again.
“Not all men are bad men—my father wasn’t. But not all men are good men, and ones with money, with power—those can be the most dangerous of them all.”
I enjoyed the story and surprised it came from a debut author! There were some aspects they were pretty predictable for me, but it was a fun ride nonetheless. Enjoyed it!
October 14, 2025
We begin with the main character sitting in a café, alone, expecting a companion, with two cups of coffee served. However, as time passes and the coffee goes cold, no one shows up. This ominous start had me hooked instantly, with the events in the rest of the book circling it perfectly, complementing the writing and tone.
This is a mystery about Cosette Emory, a 23-year-old bartender who, after years of hearing consolations about her father's sudden disappearance, has decided to find her own way to the truth after being provoked by a mysterious letter left at her front door.
With trickles of romance, the extravaganza of parties of the rich society, and the suspense of the impending events, the book makes a perfect compelling mystery, but it is more than just that; it talks about the cryptic nature of financial laxity and economic disparity in society, and the mistreatment and exploitation of financially struggling workers.
This is a mystery about Cosette Emory, a 23-year-old bartender who, after years of hearing consolations about her father's sudden disappearance, has decided to find her own way to the truth after being provoked by a mysterious letter left at her front door.
With trickles of romance, the extravaganza of parties of the rich society, and the suspense of the impending events, the book makes a perfect compelling mystery, but it is more than just that; it talks about the cryptic nature of financial laxity and economic disparity in society, and the mistreatment and exploitation of financially struggling workers.
January 15, 2026
Rating: 4.5 Stars
A.A. Barton had me second guessing myself multiple times as I read Lilac. How coincidental is it that Cosette meets her love interest Dylan within the same 24 hours that the mysterious letter arrived at her doorstep asking her to resurface the mystery of her father's disappearance 5 years ago? It was beyond suspicious! There were many times in the book that I thought I had figured out who killed her father and was SO surprised at the end to find out that none of my theories proved true.
A.A. Barton not only walks us through a mystery, she's touches on the topic of grief. As someone who is involved in the after-care industry, I truly appreciated reading about Cosette's walk through grieving her father & mother. I love reading books that aren't so picture perfect and that really expose the rawness of hard topics - such as grieving.
Thank you for a fantastic read A.A. Barrton! I literally could not put it down! I will be trying to wait patiently for your next novel!
A.A. Barton had me second guessing myself multiple times as I read Lilac. How coincidental is it that Cosette meets her love interest Dylan within the same 24 hours that the mysterious letter arrived at her doorstep asking her to resurface the mystery of her father's disappearance 5 years ago? It was beyond suspicious! There were many times in the book that I thought I had figured out who killed her father and was SO surprised at the end to find out that none of my theories proved true.
A.A. Barton not only walks us through a mystery, she's touches on the topic of grief. As someone who is involved in the after-care industry, I truly appreciated reading about Cosette's walk through grieving her father & mother. I love reading books that aren't so picture perfect and that really expose the rawness of hard topics - such as grieving.
Thank you for a fantastic read A.A. Barrton! I literally could not put it down! I will be trying to wait patiently for your next novel!
February 7, 2026
wonderfully written and the ending had me welling up a bit
December 29, 2025
This book was AMAZING!! Couldn’t put it down!
December 20, 2025
Thoroughly enjoyed this book and look forward to other novels from Barton. The fact that I would look for any moment to read while taking care of a 10 month old should tell you how much this novel pulls you in.
October 20, 2025
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️-3/4
Pub. date 10/28/25
Lilac by A. A. Barton follows Cosette, a twenty-something bartender struggling to make ends meet while dealing with the mysterious disappearance of her father five years before. This is Barton’s debut novel, and I hope and pray there will be (many) more! The writing was clear, concise, and witty. Character development was impeccable and made it easy to connect with them. The story line was well thought out and easy to follow, even through the twists and turns!
I felt a special connection to Colette having lost my mother to cancer, and I found myself empathizing with her on many occasions. The lilac was one of my mother’s favorite flowers, as well. One of my favorite quotes is “you can’t fully grieve someone you never got to say goodbye to.”
I am a huge fan of mysteries and thrillers, and Lilac ticked all the boxes for me: mystery, intrigue, murder, humanity, and a little bit of love. Oh, and LOTS of surprises! I caught myself gasping out loud several times! And I promise you - if you think you know how the story is going to end … you do not!!!!
I loved every minute of this book - the story, the characters (even the ones I hated!), the writing…. When I was about halfway through, I realized I didn’t want the book to end, but at the same time, I couldn’t wait to find out how it ends! I admit that I even delayed writing a review because I felt that I would be letting go of the characters, and I was just not ready to do that.
I would recommend Lilac to anyone who is looking for a well-written mystery with an ending you may not expect.
Thank you to NetGalley and A. A. Barton for the opportunity to read an advance copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
Pub. date 10/28/25
Lilac by A. A. Barton follows Cosette, a twenty-something bartender struggling to make ends meet while dealing with the mysterious disappearance of her father five years before. This is Barton’s debut novel, and I hope and pray there will be (many) more! The writing was clear, concise, and witty. Character development was impeccable and made it easy to connect with them. The story line was well thought out and easy to follow, even through the twists and turns!
I felt a special connection to Colette having lost my mother to cancer, and I found myself empathizing with her on many occasions. The lilac was one of my mother’s favorite flowers, as well. One of my favorite quotes is “you can’t fully grieve someone you never got to say goodbye to.”
I am a huge fan of mysteries and thrillers, and Lilac ticked all the boxes for me: mystery, intrigue, murder, humanity, and a little bit of love. Oh, and LOTS of surprises! I caught myself gasping out loud several times! And I promise you - if you think you know how the story is going to end … you do not!!!!
I loved every minute of this book - the story, the characters (even the ones I hated!), the writing…. When I was about halfway through, I realized I didn’t want the book to end, but at the same time, I couldn’t wait to find out how it ends! I admit that I even delayed writing a review because I felt that I would be letting go of the characters, and I was just not ready to do that.
I would recommend Lilac to anyone who is looking for a well-written mystery with an ending you may not expect.
Thank you to NetGalley and A. A. Barton for the opportunity to read an advance copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
November 26, 2025
What an extraordinary debut from A. A. Barton. From the very first page, her prose pulls you in—haunting, atmospheric, and beautifully written. The mystery unfolds in a way that keeps you constantly guessing, layering tension, suspense, and unanswered questions into a story that feels deeply intimate and emotionally resonant. At the heart of it all is a powerful emotional core. The themes of lust, loss, inequality, and injustice aren’t merely present—they’re felt, woven so seamlessly into the narrative that you experience them right alongside Cosette. I became genuinely attached to the characters, invested not only in the resolution of the mystery but in their heartbreaks, hopes, and the choices they’re forced to make.
The ending landed perfectly for me—devastating, satisfying, and impossible to shake. I laughed, I cried, and I truly could not put this book down. A. A. Barton has officially earned a permanent spot on my TBR list, and I sincerely hope she has many more stories in store, because I cannot wait to devour whatever she writes next!
The ending landed perfectly for me—devastating, satisfying, and impossible to shake. I laughed, I cried, and I truly could not put this book down. A. A. Barton has officially earned a permanent spot on my TBR list, and I sincerely hope she has many more stories in store, because I cannot wait to devour whatever she writes next!
December 6, 2025
Thank you NetGalley and A A Barton for an ARC of this book.
This is why you should read self-published books! I loved this. ‘Lilac’ is a compelling crime story packed full of emotion, clear characterisation, and heart. Cosette’s complex ties to her father’s disappearance involve her in the city’s elite. She shows resolve, morality, and will in her pursuit of truth and justice. Her relationships with her aunt, friends, and Dylan were all so well-done - I particularly enjoyed the romance sub-plot, which is something I’m not usually a fan of. I was so pulled in from the off and couldn’t put this book down.
And it is the utmost compliment when I say that this book felt like the stories I used to read on Wattpad as a teen.. but like, actually good. Well done. I’ll be keeping an eye out for A A Barton’s next works 👀 consider me a fan.
This is why you should read self-published books! I loved this. ‘Lilac’ is a compelling crime story packed full of emotion, clear characterisation, and heart. Cosette’s complex ties to her father’s disappearance involve her in the city’s elite. She shows resolve, morality, and will in her pursuit of truth and justice. Her relationships with her aunt, friends, and Dylan were all so well-done - I particularly enjoyed the romance sub-plot, which is something I’m not usually a fan of. I was so pulled in from the off and couldn’t put this book down.
And it is the utmost compliment when I say that this book felt like the stories I used to read on Wattpad as a teen.. but like, actually good. Well done. I’ll be keeping an eye out for A A Barton’s next works 👀 consider me a fan.
January 10, 2026
I was excited to receive an ARC of this. I can’t believe this is Barton’s first novel. I feel like she has such an amazing career ahead of her.
This book was beautiful, filled with real-life wisdom, loss, pain, love, friendship, and thriller-esque elements as Cosette tries to make sense of her past and navigate the uncertainty of her future. This was an easy read in the best way - especially if you enjoy a good twist on a detective-type-investigative plot... was emotionally rich yet effortlessly engaging.
I think it will be landing a spot in my top five reads of the year, and I’ll definitely be recommending it to friends once it hits shelves.
This book was beautiful, filled with real-life wisdom, loss, pain, love, friendship, and thriller-esque elements as Cosette tries to make sense of her past and navigate the uncertainty of her future. This was an easy read in the best way - especially if you enjoy a good twist on a detective-type-investigative plot... was emotionally rich yet effortlessly engaging.
I think it will be landing a spot in my top five reads of the year, and I’ll definitely be recommending it to friends once it hits shelves.
December 5, 2025
3.5⭐️
Lilac was a book I found myself putting down and picking back up several times. The story itself is good, and the premise is genuinely brilliant. The cover is also one of my favourites I’ve come across—it immediately drew me in.
However, even with such a strong concept, I personally struggled to stay fully hooked. It took a while for me to really get into the story, and my engagement wavered throughout.
Overall, Lilac has a fantastic idea behind it, but it just didn’t consistently hold my attention.
Lilac was a book I found myself putting down and picking back up several times. The story itself is good, and the premise is genuinely brilliant. The cover is also one of my favourites I’ve come across—it immediately drew me in.
However, even with such a strong concept, I personally struggled to stay fully hooked. It took a while for me to really get into the story, and my engagement wavered throughout.
Overall, Lilac has a fantastic idea behind it, but it just didn’t consistently hold my attention.
November 8, 2025
I did not expect to like this book as much as I did! The FMC reminded me of a friend that we all have that we get frustrated with, want to scream at, and are annoyed by but you always are there riding for her and backing her up. She may be frustrating but you love her and she is your frustration. I loved the blend of the romance and mystery. I thought it kept it interesting in more ways. When I would want a change of pace it was there. I loved this book and it was so well written.
October 21, 2025
Rounded up- 4.5 Stars!!!!
Cosette Emory is haunted by the disappearance of her father 5 years ago. She has spent these years not questioning what happened, except on the day that he disappears. Then she goes to a local diner and has 2 coffees- one for her, and one for her father. This was where they were supposed to meet for lunch that long ago day, but he never showed up.
Oh. My, Gosh!!! This book was fantastic. A cold case mystery, a hint of romance (but still mostly mystery). and main character that was real and authentic.
Colette goes home from the diner, and later finds a letter slipped under her door telling her to ask questions about her father. She does not recognize the name of the person who sent it. She decides that she needs to look into this and try to get answers and begins by asking her aunt if she knows what this is about. From there the story and clues ratchet up.
The writing is lovely, and Colette is relatable. I found myself hurting for her, and wanting the answers too. She has no closure, so there is a pain that simply exists all the time. As she begins investigating, she finds ties to high society. She is drawn to parties and events and finds shocking information about what was really happening in her father's life and in his job. She begins to question who she can trust.
The supporting characters were fantastic. Aunt Billie, Esther (her best friend) and even Dylan (the new guy she has met). Each of them add important support to Nellie. While she is investigating, she finally opens up and lets herself feel the loss and the grief. IT is an astounding debut novel, and I could not put this book down. There was mystery, intrigue, found family, loss and hope. And throughout the book you are rooting for Colette not only to find out what happened, but to also be able to move forward and get healing. I cannot recommend this book enough. It is shocking that his is a debut!
Highly recommend for anyone looking for a deep, intelligent, emotional mystery with well rounded characters and heart! I cannot wait to read AA Barton's next book!!!
Thank you to NetGalley and A.A. Barton for the ARC. This is my honest and voluntary review.
Cosette Emory is haunted by the disappearance of her father 5 years ago. She has spent these years not questioning what happened, except on the day that he disappears. Then she goes to a local diner and has 2 coffees- one for her, and one for her father. This was where they were supposed to meet for lunch that long ago day, but he never showed up.
Oh. My, Gosh!!! This book was fantastic. A cold case mystery, a hint of romance (but still mostly mystery). and main character that was real and authentic.
Colette goes home from the diner, and later finds a letter slipped under her door telling her to ask questions about her father. She does not recognize the name of the person who sent it. She decides that she needs to look into this and try to get answers and begins by asking her aunt if she knows what this is about. From there the story and clues ratchet up.
The writing is lovely, and Colette is relatable. I found myself hurting for her, and wanting the answers too. She has no closure, so there is a pain that simply exists all the time. As she begins investigating, she finds ties to high society. She is drawn to parties and events and finds shocking information about what was really happening in her father's life and in his job. She begins to question who she can trust.
The supporting characters were fantastic. Aunt Billie, Esther (her best friend) and even Dylan (the new guy she has met). Each of them add important support to Nellie. While she is investigating, she finally opens up and lets herself feel the loss and the grief. IT is an astounding debut novel, and I could not put this book down. There was mystery, intrigue, found family, loss and hope. And throughout the book you are rooting for Colette not only to find out what happened, but to also be able to move forward and get healing. I cannot recommend this book enough. It is shocking that his is a debut!
Highly recommend for anyone looking for a deep, intelligent, emotional mystery with well rounded characters and heart! I cannot wait to read AA Barton's next book!!!
Thank you to NetGalley and A.A. Barton for the ARC. This is my honest and voluntary review.
February 7, 2026
I’m so sorry but I found very little in this book to hold my interest. I started reading it a couple months ago and put it down because life happened and all I could remember is I absolutely HATED the writing. That did continue, but my ability to overlook it waxed and waned as I got more and less invested. Everyone was yelling when they didn’t need to and their tone was dripping and drenched all the time. There were weird, slightly overwritten and slightly incorrect turns of phrases, and usually I could figure out what sentences meant in context but I was quite frequently doing double takes because sentences were worded just slightly wrong where they seemed to mean the opposite of what the author intended, or meant nothing at all.
Cosette, our main character, wasn’t really all the likable and just grew more and more misogynistic as the book went on- NOT a girl’s girl. Kept describing everything at bitchy and described her supposed BEST FRIEND as a “horny bitch always looking for her next dick appointment.” Sorry, if my BEST FRIEND said that about me, I’d absolutely sob and also be in the market for a new best friend.
I didn’t find the romance compelling in the least, especially because it was the same back and forth and fight and absolute refusal to communicate for less than 300 pages (but it felt like WAY WAY more). I was also confused by the first scene where they sleep together and he makes a point to get her verbal and enthusiastic consent, yet two pages later just flies by Cosette going “wait stop”. Sir that’s assault. He’s also frequently described as predatory, but I think the book wants that to be a compliment???????
The mystery was the best part, but it often took second fiddle to the romance which was annoying. I did think I was getting a thriller. And the majority of the book made zero progress aside from Cosette going “omg this is so dangerous, except I’m not going to take any precautions to keep myself safe, so maybe it’s not that dangerous, but wait something happened so this is super dangerous”. It got tiresome. Again, this book felt way longer than its 270ish page count.
Two stars because it did pull me in at times. I think this had potential. Just wasn’t for me
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for proving a free eARC
Cosette, our main character, wasn’t really all the likable and just grew more and more misogynistic as the book went on- NOT a girl’s girl. Kept describing everything at bitchy and described her supposed BEST FRIEND as a “horny bitch always looking for her next dick appointment.” Sorry, if my BEST FRIEND said that about me, I’d absolutely sob and also be in the market for a new best friend.
I didn’t find the romance compelling in the least, especially because it was the same back and forth and fight and absolute refusal to communicate for less than 300 pages (but it felt like WAY WAY more). I was also confused by the first scene where they sleep together and he makes a point to get her verbal and enthusiastic consent, yet two pages later just flies by Cosette going “wait stop”. Sir that’s assault. He’s also frequently described as predatory, but I think the book wants that to be a compliment???????
The mystery was the best part, but it often took second fiddle to the romance which was annoying. I did think I was getting a thriller. And the majority of the book made zero progress aside from Cosette going “omg this is so dangerous, except I’m not going to take any precautions to keep myself safe, so maybe it’s not that dangerous, but wait something happened so this is super dangerous”. It got tiresome. Again, this book felt way longer than its 270ish page count.
Two stars because it did pull me in at times. I think this had potential. Just wasn’t for me
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for proving a free eARC
December 14, 2025
I absolutely loved this book and would give it a full five stars.
The story follows Cosette Emory, a woman whose life has been shaped by the unexplained disappearance of her father five years earlier. His absence hangs over everything. She has tried to move forward, to live normally, but that unresolved loss never really lets go. When a mysterious note appears at her door, it forces her to confront a past she has spent years avoiding.
As Cosette starts digging into her father’s disappearance, the story pulls her into the polished but dangerous world of Chicago’s elite. What looks elegant and controlled on the surface hides secrets, corruption, and people who will do anything to protect their reputations. Every answer she uncovers only leads to more questions, and the deeper she goes, the more she realizes how little she truly knew about her father and the people around him.
What makes this book so strong is how emotional it feels. The mystery is gripping, but it is Cosette’s grief, confusion, and determination that really drive the story. She is not fearless or detached. She doubts herself, makes mistakes, and carries the weight of years of unanswered questions. That makes her feel real. The investigation is not just about solving a case but about understanding loss and finding the courage to face painful truths.
The pacing kept me hooked, and the tension builds steadily without feeling forced. The atmosphere is heavy with unease, and there is always a sense that something dangerous is just beneath the surface. The twists felt earned, and the revelations hit hard both emotionally and narratively.
By the end, I was completely invested. Lilac is a powerful mix of mystery and emotional depth. It explores grief, memory, and the cost of uncovering the truth in a way that stayed with me long after I finished reading. This was a standout read for me and easily a five star book.
The story follows Cosette Emory, a woman whose life has been shaped by the unexplained disappearance of her father five years earlier. His absence hangs over everything. She has tried to move forward, to live normally, but that unresolved loss never really lets go. When a mysterious note appears at her door, it forces her to confront a past she has spent years avoiding.
As Cosette starts digging into her father’s disappearance, the story pulls her into the polished but dangerous world of Chicago’s elite. What looks elegant and controlled on the surface hides secrets, corruption, and people who will do anything to protect their reputations. Every answer she uncovers only leads to more questions, and the deeper she goes, the more she realizes how little she truly knew about her father and the people around him.
What makes this book so strong is how emotional it feels. The mystery is gripping, but it is Cosette’s grief, confusion, and determination that really drive the story. She is not fearless or detached. She doubts herself, makes mistakes, and carries the weight of years of unanswered questions. That makes her feel real. The investigation is not just about solving a case but about understanding loss and finding the courage to face painful truths.
The pacing kept me hooked, and the tension builds steadily without feeling forced. The atmosphere is heavy with unease, and there is always a sense that something dangerous is just beneath the surface. The twists felt earned, and the revelations hit hard both emotionally and narratively.
By the end, I was completely invested. Lilac is a powerful mix of mystery and emotional depth. It explores grief, memory, and the cost of uncovering the truth in a way that stayed with me long after I finished reading. This was a standout read for me and easily a five star book.
November 9, 2025
“Lilac” is the first self-published novel I’ve ever read, and I’m happy to say it was a good debut.
A.A. Barton delivers a compelling story centered on Cosette Emory, whose father mysteriously disappeared five years ago. When a new piece of evidence surfaces, Cosette is pulled back into the search for answers—this time with renewed hope and determination.
I was genuinely excited to read this book. Barton’s writing style is smooth and cinematic, making it easy to visualize scenes as if watching a film. Cosette, the main character, feels relatable and realistic, and her emotional journey kept me engaged throughout.
Although the novel is primarily a suspense story, I found the romantic subplot surprisingly dominant—it drew more of my attention than expected. I personally chose to skip the spicy scenes, as they don’t align with my values, but they were easy to bypass without losing the thread of the story. While the thriller elements felt somewhat predictable, I still found myself worrying about Cosette and her aunt’s safety, which speaks to the emotional investment the story creates.
One character who frustrated me was Cosette’s friend Esther. I questioned many of her decisions and found her romantic choices reckless. As for Dylan, the MMC, he came across as almost too perfect—but I still found him quite charming.
Overall, I believe A.A. Barton has real potential as a romance novelist. Thank you for providing me with this ARC. All opinions expressed are my own.
A.A. Barton delivers a compelling story centered on Cosette Emory, whose father mysteriously disappeared five years ago. When a new piece of evidence surfaces, Cosette is pulled back into the search for answers—this time with renewed hope and determination.
I was genuinely excited to read this book. Barton’s writing style is smooth and cinematic, making it easy to visualize scenes as if watching a film. Cosette, the main character, feels relatable and realistic, and her emotional journey kept me engaged throughout.
Although the novel is primarily a suspense story, I found the romantic subplot surprisingly dominant—it drew more of my attention than expected. I personally chose to skip the spicy scenes, as they don’t align with my values, but they were easy to bypass without losing the thread of the story. While the thriller elements felt somewhat predictable, I still found myself worrying about Cosette and her aunt’s safety, which speaks to the emotional investment the story creates.
One character who frustrated me was Cosette’s friend Esther. I questioned many of her decisions and found her romantic choices reckless. As for Dylan, the MMC, he came across as almost too perfect—but I still found him quite charming.
Overall, I believe A.A. Barton has real potential as a romance novelist. Thank you for providing me with this ARC. All opinions expressed are my own.
September 26, 2025
I was hooked from the very beginning. The mystery and suspense kept me on my toes, and while there were moments where I could predict the outcome, it didn’t make them any less powerful or jarring. The author balanced tension and emotion in a way that kept me invested all the way through.
What stood out most to me was the raw portrayal of grief, heartbreak, and loss. It wasn’t just surface level sadness, it captured the way grief lingers, reshapes relationships, and forces people to find new layers of strength. I felt for the relationships that were fractured, for the silences left behind, and for the resilience of the characters who carried on despite their pain.
The writing itself flowed beautifully, and I found it especially impressive considering this is the author’s first work. The pacing was steady and engaging, and I appreciated how the story never lost its emotional core even when the suspense took center stage.
Just like in life, not all stories have a happy or clear cut ending. Some people are meant to pass through our lives, leaving behind heartbreak, while others are meant to stay and leave an undeniable impact.
Overall, this was a moving, suspenseful, and heartfelt read that I’ll be thinking about for a while. I’m excited to see what this author creates next.
I wanted to thank NetGalley for this ARC.
What stood out most to me was the raw portrayal of grief, heartbreak, and loss. It wasn’t just surface level sadness, it captured the way grief lingers, reshapes relationships, and forces people to find new layers of strength. I felt for the relationships that were fractured, for the silences left behind, and for the resilience of the characters who carried on despite their pain.
The writing itself flowed beautifully, and I found it especially impressive considering this is the author’s first work. The pacing was steady and engaging, and I appreciated how the story never lost its emotional core even when the suspense took center stage.
Just like in life, not all stories have a happy or clear cut ending. Some people are meant to pass through our lives, leaving behind heartbreak, while others are meant to stay and leave an undeniable impact.
Overall, this was a moving, suspenseful, and heartfelt read that I’ll be thinking about for a while. I’m excited to see what this author creates next.
I wanted to thank NetGalley for this ARC.
December 28, 2025
Compelling, compulsive, and quietly showing off
“Lilac” had me from the first page. The opening scene is unusual enough to snap your attention straight into place, while also making it very clear that this book has no interest in doing things the safe or predictable way.
Which, frankly, is excellent news for the reader.
Yes, I worked out the plot, antagonists, and general story arc fairly early on — and no, that didn’t matter one bit. This is one of those novels where the how is every bit as satisfying as the what. The writing is confident and polished, the characterisation is pitch-perfect, and the setting consistently delivers exactly the atmosphere each scene requires.
The depiction of grief — particularly Cosette’s — is handled with real skill: expressive, emotionally honest, and never overwhelming. Esther is a gloriously flawed, hysterically funny, and completely believable best friend, the kind you recognise instantly and are deeply grateful exists only on the page. And the letter from Dylan? That was the point at which I stopped pretending I was going to get through this book with dry eyes.
And this was a debut. A debut.
Almost unreasonably accomplished, really.
Brava, A. A. Barton — but please, for the sake of your readers, don’t make us wait another 34 years.
My thanks to NetGalley and A. A. Barton for the ARC of “Lilac”.
“Lilac” had me from the first page. The opening scene is unusual enough to snap your attention straight into place, while also making it very clear that this book has no interest in doing things the safe or predictable way.
Which, frankly, is excellent news for the reader.
Yes, I worked out the plot, antagonists, and general story arc fairly early on — and no, that didn’t matter one bit. This is one of those novels where the how is every bit as satisfying as the what. The writing is confident and polished, the characterisation is pitch-perfect, and the setting consistently delivers exactly the atmosphere each scene requires.
The depiction of grief — particularly Cosette’s — is handled with real skill: expressive, emotionally honest, and never overwhelming. Esther is a gloriously flawed, hysterically funny, and completely believable best friend, the kind you recognise instantly and are deeply grateful exists only on the page. And the letter from Dylan? That was the point at which I stopped pretending I was going to get through this book with dry eyes.
And this was a debut. A debut.
Almost unreasonably accomplished, really.
Brava, A. A. Barton — but please, for the sake of your readers, don’t make us wait another 34 years.
My thanks to NetGalley and A. A. Barton for the ARC of “Lilac”.
December 7, 2025
I was lucky enough to be selected as a Beta reader for this debut author. Lilac hooked me right from the jump with its mystery-suspense vibes with a little sprinkle of romance mixed in. This debut is emotional and hooks you rather early on, I found myself not being able to put it down.
We follow Cosette as she digs into the five-year-old disappearance of her father. Barton takes us through several themes: grief, love, and loss. The flashbacks are where Barton really pulled me in. They add in that emotional gut punch that reminds you that grief is an universal language that we all speak.
Cosette as a main, made me remember my 20s and there were times I found myself yelling at her through the page, "Cosette, get it together lady!" Yes, a few plot points were predictable, but some of those reveals still had me gasping—and that’s saying something, because after a lifetime of devouring every episode of Law & Order: SVU, I fully consider myself a detective at heart.
Barton delivers a super promising debut. I’ll definitely be keeping an eye on whatever A.A. Barton does next.
3.75 stars
Thanks to NetGalley & AA Barton for the ARC!
We follow Cosette as she digs into the five-year-old disappearance of her father. Barton takes us through several themes: grief, love, and loss. The flashbacks are where Barton really pulled me in. They add in that emotional gut punch that reminds you that grief is an universal language that we all speak.
Cosette as a main, made me remember my 20s and there were times I found myself yelling at her through the page, "Cosette, get it together lady!" Yes, a few plot points were predictable, but some of those reveals still had me gasping—and that’s saying something, because after a lifetime of devouring every episode of Law & Order: SVU, I fully consider myself a detective at heart.
Barton delivers a super promising debut. I’ll definitely be keeping an eye on whatever A.A. Barton does next.
3.75 stars
Thanks to NetGalley & AA Barton for the ARC!
October 28, 2025
4.75
Cosette’s life has been riddled with loss. Despite that, she and her aunt are still standing. On the anniversary of her father’s disappearance, Cosette receives a letter stating that there’s more to it than she realizes, so she turns to her aunt for help. Before his passing, her uncle was investigating what happened to her father with a private investigator, Remy. He is hesitant to help Cosette because of who is connected to her father’s case, but maybe the FBI will be able to assist them? Cosette is determined to uncover the truth, even after she is being threatened. While she is dealing with this, she also is handling the realization of who Dylan is. She met him while bartending, and they instantly had a connection; what if he too has ties to her father’s disappearance, and how can she trust that he doesn’t? I was worried about Esther because of her connections, but I’m glad she ended up being the best friend possible for Cosette. Remy might be my favorite character, especially because he kept showing up. I didn’t see the reveal coming. The writing of this story was so descriptive, and readers felt the loss Cosette was going through. I’m excited for what’s to come from A.A. Barton: this is such a good debut.
ARC Review 🩵
Cosette’s life has been riddled with loss. Despite that, she and her aunt are still standing. On the anniversary of her father’s disappearance, Cosette receives a letter stating that there’s more to it than she realizes, so she turns to her aunt for help. Before his passing, her uncle was investigating what happened to her father with a private investigator, Remy. He is hesitant to help Cosette because of who is connected to her father’s case, but maybe the FBI will be able to assist them? Cosette is determined to uncover the truth, even after she is being threatened. While she is dealing with this, she also is handling the realization of who Dylan is. She met him while bartending, and they instantly had a connection; what if he too has ties to her father’s disappearance, and how can she trust that he doesn’t? I was worried about Esther because of her connections, but I’m glad she ended up being the best friend possible for Cosette. Remy might be my favorite character, especially because he kept showing up. I didn’t see the reveal coming. The writing of this story was so descriptive, and readers felt the loss Cosette was going through. I’m excited for what’s to come from A.A. Barton: this is such a good debut.
ARC Review 🩵
Displaying 1 - 30 of 50 reviews