What do you think?
Rate this book


288 pages, Hardcover
First published October 13, 2026
A Date With Santa is this year’s Christmas novel by Debbie Macomber. I have read over twenty novels by this romance author, the majority of them with a Christmas theme. I have enjoyed some, but was disappointed with last year’s novel, and felt the same with her holiday contribution this year. It must be hard to come up with new ideas for Christmas romances when the public–and your publisher–expects a new book every year.
This story wasn’t as clichéd and eye-rolling as last year’s, however the Macomber trope of featuring precociously wise and annoyingly loquacious children made me loathe it even more. The story centres on Sage Madison, a career-driven advertising executive who is suddenly saddled with her five-year-old nephew Ricky throughout the month of December. Is this another coincidence of names or what: I had just read back-to-back novels where a protagonist was named Edna, and this Macomber novel centres on a woman named Sage. My first Christmas novel this year, All is Bright, told the story of an architect named Sage McKnight. They even have the same surname initial.
While Ricky’s mother Saffron is helping with hurricane relief across the country in Florida, Sage must drop everything in order to look after her nephew. (The cutie-pie spicy naming of the sisters is maudlin; the women’s mother is named Rosemary.) This couldn’t come at a worse time, as Sage is up to her eyeballs in putting together an advertising campaign which will also serve as a test for the position of new company manager. With two rivals vying for the same promotion, how can she juggle her long office hours while caring for a five-year-old?
The love story involves Sage’s colleague Ethan, who is also vying for the same position. In fact, he is favoured to get the promotion as he was hand-picked to apply for it by the man who is currently in charge. Could Sage and Ethan still be friends–and lovers–if they are up against each other? Could one of them live with being turned down for the job and then have to work under the authority of the other? There is a third candidate for the job but he is the Nellie Oleson rival who no one likes and gets his comeuppance at the end.
I do not like chatterbox children whether in real life or in the pages of fiction. Ricky is always talking and long paragraphs are devoted to his unfiltered non sequiturs where he is expressing out loud what everyone is secretly thinking, but hasn’t come to terms with accepting yet. And it gets annoying pretty fast. How can an iPad-obsessed five-year-old express his emotions so maturely? No child of that age has the wisdom of a psychologist to probe the psyches of the adults in his life. I wanted to muzzle him and make him stand in a corner of a dark and locked room. While his mother Saffron is away in Florida helping out with hurricane relief–and her deployment is threatened with an extension to keep her away from her son over Christmas–Ricky is forlorn. So what does he do? Macomber does exactly what she did in last year’s novel, she stooped to the most clichéd soppy trick in the manual on heartstrings manipulation: she has Ricky ask Santa to bring his mother back home in time for Christmas. By this time, at the very end of the novel, I so despised Ricky that I maliciously wished that Santa–who was really Ethan in disguise–would take one smirky look at the boy on his lap and tell him in no uncertain terms “HELL NO! Your ma ain’t never comin’ back cuz you talk too much dude!”.
As Sage and Ricky were making cookies, Sage informed her nephew that adding salt to the batter gives the cookies “a certain panache”. In spite of the wisdom we have seen from this young boy so far, he did not know the meaning of the word panache, so he learns it by sounding it out slowly. Why then did Macomber write it out this way:
“I want the cookies we take to Santa to have pan…ac…he.” ?
Surely you don’t split the phoneme rendered in English by ch. If Ricky is sounding out the word panache, write it as pa…nash. (I won’t worry about Macomber misidentifying the vowel sounds. No Christmas romance needs a formal phonetic transcription.)
At the end of the novel Sage and Ethan fall deeper in love and Sage realizes that there is more to life than the competitive rat race in her professional life. Her feelings for Ethan were triggered by the excessive verbiage spilled out of Ricky’s nonstop gob, and she comes to reconcile what she would do if she didn’t win the promotion. This is a typical Macomber Christmas romance, so there is no spoiler alert when every reader should know what is coming. Ethan withdraws his candidacy and opens his own advertising firm, and Sage is awarded the position of new company manager.
The publisher certainly knows how to flesh out a short story. This is another pamphlet disguised as a book, a small hardcover of 245 pages with a large font (not that I’m complaining about that) and wide spaces between the lines. All the chapters start on the right side of the layout, thereby leaving a blank page on the left side for a bonus cheat increase in the page count. And the price is now up to $37 Canadian. Last year’s novel cost $34–and it was slightly longer. Most people could read this novel in one sitting; I did it in two. That’s a lot of money to spend on only a few hours of reading. I was also irked by the superfluous product placement within the text. Company names were identified when there didn’t seem a need to drop a corporate plug. With a readership as large as Macomber’s, I am sure companies lined up to get a mention in her latest Christmas story.