What do you think?
Rate this book
Witch in the Wall: Book I
The wicked witch below Everwatch has been imprisoned longer than even the faerie lords can remember. Her name is a curse, and her sins haunt nightmares.
Gavriel Hall, bastard son of a dead king, wants nothing more than to escape the underground prison-city he calls home. But he’s a pathological liar who avoids conflict at all costs, and he doesn’t dare brave the boundary stones.
On bad days, he records the names of those sacrificed as part of the soul tithe. On good days, he lets himself pine for his best friend Aziz, a mysterious outcast with the twin swords of a forgotten hero.
When his half-siblings' war for the throne turns Everwatch into a battlefield—and a spectacularly ill-timed kiss drives Aziz away—Gavriel thinks his hopes of a new life are destroyed. That is, until the witch locked below offers him enough dark magic to fix everything. For a price.
As bloodshed engulfs the city, Gavriel must decide what he's willing to pay for new horizons—and whether he's truly the coward everyone believes him to be.
Gavriel Hall, bastard son of a dead king, wants nothing more than to escape the underground prison-city he calls home. But he’s a pathological liar who avoids conflict at all costs, and he doesn’t dare brave the boundary stones.
On bad days, he records the names of those sacrificed as part of the soul tithe. On good days, he lets himself pine for his best friend Aziz, a mysterious outcast with the twin swords of a forgotten hero.
When his half-siblings' war for the throne turns Everwatch into a battlefield—and a spectacularly ill-timed kiss drives Aziz away—Gavriel thinks his hopes of a new life are destroyed. That is, until the witch locked below offers him enough dark magic to fix everything. For a price.
As bloodshed engulfs the city, Gavriel must decide what he's willing to pay for new horizons—and whether he's truly the coward everyone believes him to be.
498 pages, Kindle Edition
Published January 13, 2026
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 28 of 28 reviews
June 29, 2026
Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC!
Witch In the Wall seems to have received criminally few reviews for how good it is. Despite some stumbles when it comes to language and character, I enjoyed the worldbuilding of this book immensely. The world Quinn Hogshead has created is so fascinating, and it feels real, deep, and lived in. The way this book uses and describes magic is such a treat! I'm going to wax lyrical about what I liked in the hope that people will see this and want to give this book a try.
The absolute stand-out feature of this book was the magic and the worldbuilding. The world Hogshead creates feels steeped in history; everything in this world has a weight of years behind it, and practically all of it is interlinked with the magic of the witches, symbiotic fusions of mortal beings human or fae, and strange eldritch creatures from literally beyond the stars. I loved everything about this set-up, and how the characters grappled with being both two people at once, and many different people, and yet also the same person who had lived for eons. It's such a deliciously unique take on magic and eldritch weirdness that I haven't seen before! The technical use of language when explaining how the magic works, and describing the characters using it, was also really good. I loved the book's images of the endless, eldritch 'Squall,' the dimension of magic outside of time and space. Honestly, I can't talk enough about how cool the magic was!
I also really enjoyed the main character, Gavriel, and his progression throughout the story. He grappled with the harsh realities of his world, and the choices he made, in a really realistic way. I also really liked the progression of how he learnt to use magic. That kind of storyline can often feel either like the character is learning things stupidly fast, or like reems of page-time is being expended on tiny details; Hogshead manages to strike a balance between these two, making it feel like Gavriel is learning things at an authentic pace, but always reminding us how little he actually knows by comparing him to other witches and their powers. I was also so completely totally sold on the romance between him and Aziz! Aziz feels like this very perfect character in the beginning, but he has such hidden depths. The twist surrounding him was something I kind of suspected but that also surprised me, in the best way!
One gripe I had with this book was some of the language it uses. This may be a personal taste thing, but the language sometimes feels too modern or casual to fit the fantasy setting. And this probably is just an issue of personal taste, but I really dislike it when high fantasy characters use 'mom,' or say 'dad' in formal settings, or use specific modern sexuality words like 'gay.' It just sounds odd and doesn't quite fit.
My other problem was that the secondary and tertiary characters who didn't get much focus often felt 2D and flat, reduced to single character traits, tropes, and stock phrases in dialogue. This was especially obvious with characters who should have felt more fully fleshed out, like the Council members and Sadie.
The real problem with character, though, was Gavriel's siblings. The first half of the plot asks us to care about the succession squabble between them, but the truth is that aside from Hannah and maybe Annie, the rest of Gavriel's brothers are all so terrible and unlikeable that the reader doesn't particularly care which one of them wins or dies. They're such assholes that it's hard to care when they bite the dust, which makes it hard to connect with Gavriel when he angsts about them dying. This is especially obvious when Gavriel seems to spend more time mourning asshole Alex than innocent, literal child Hannah. The author introduces Alex's trauma and his softer side right before he dies, but it's not enough to make us really feel sad that he's gone; he, as well as Victor and Tanni, should have had a few more redeeming qualities if the author actually wanted us to care about them dying as much as Gavriel did.
The fact that Gavriel's siblings are very unlikeable, to the point the reader doesn't care about them, has the much bigger problem of hampering reader investment in the first half of the novel, as that section is all about getting invested in Everwatch's succession crisis. I found myself reading solely for the worldbuilding and history of magic, witches, and their wars, rather than anything the humans were doing. In the first half of the book I was genuinely wishing Gavriel would leave Everwatch behind so that the narrative could focus solely on the interesting parts of the book! This improved a lot as we got into the second half, as the story moved away from the succession crisis and became more about the witches and their overall war (and, admittedly, because certain of Gavriel's siblings had died by that point), but I think the book would have massively benefitted from either making Gavriel's siblings more interesting, or finding some other way to have later events happen without having to go through the succession part of the plot.
The second half and ending was where the pace and interest of the plot picked up immensely, though, and I could barely tear my eyes away. The final chapters had loads of fascinating twists and actually impactful, cool battle scenes. I loved how the ending built on things that had come before, and used the MC's special talent that he had built up to using and learning, as a way to succeed.
Overall, I really enjoyed a lot of this book, especially the worldbuilding and the second half of the plot, and I'm really hoping a sequel is in the works! We definitely need more of the amazing worldbuilding and history of this universe!!
Witch In the Wall seems to have received criminally few reviews for how good it is. Despite some stumbles when it comes to language and character, I enjoyed the worldbuilding of this book immensely. The world Quinn Hogshead has created is so fascinating, and it feels real, deep, and lived in. The way this book uses and describes magic is such a treat! I'm going to wax lyrical about what I liked in the hope that people will see this and want to give this book a try.
The absolute stand-out feature of this book was the magic and the worldbuilding. The world Hogshead creates feels steeped in history; everything in this world has a weight of years behind it, and practically all of it is interlinked with the magic of the witches, symbiotic fusions of mortal beings human or fae, and strange eldritch creatures from literally beyond the stars. I loved everything about this set-up, and how the characters grappled with being both two people at once, and many different people, and yet also the same person who had lived for eons. It's such a deliciously unique take on magic and eldritch weirdness that I haven't seen before! The technical use of language when explaining how the magic works, and describing the characters using it, was also really good. I loved the book's images of the endless, eldritch 'Squall,' the dimension of magic outside of time and space. Honestly, I can't talk enough about how cool the magic was!
I also really enjoyed the main character, Gavriel, and his progression throughout the story. He grappled with the harsh realities of his world, and the choices he made, in a really realistic way. I also really liked the progression of how he learnt to use magic. That kind of storyline can often feel either like the character is learning things stupidly fast, or like reems of page-time is being expended on tiny details; Hogshead manages to strike a balance between these two, making it feel like Gavriel is learning things at an authentic pace, but always reminding us how little he actually knows by comparing him to other witches and their powers. I was also so completely totally sold on the romance between him and Aziz! Aziz feels like this very perfect character in the beginning, but he has such hidden depths. The twist surrounding him was something I kind of suspected but that also surprised me, in the best way!
One gripe I had with this book was some of the language it uses. This may be a personal taste thing, but the language sometimes feels too modern or casual to fit the fantasy setting. And this probably is just an issue of personal taste, but I really dislike it when high fantasy characters use 'mom,' or say 'dad' in formal settings, or use specific modern sexuality words like 'gay.' It just sounds odd and doesn't quite fit.
My other problem was that the secondary and tertiary characters who didn't get much focus often felt 2D and flat, reduced to single character traits, tropes, and stock phrases in dialogue. This was especially obvious with characters who should have felt more fully fleshed out, like the Council members and Sadie.
The real problem with character, though, was Gavriel's siblings. The first half of the plot asks us to care about the succession squabble between them, but the truth is that aside from Hannah and maybe Annie, the rest of Gavriel's brothers are all so terrible and unlikeable that the reader doesn't particularly care which one of them wins or dies. They're such assholes that it's hard to care when they bite the dust, which makes it hard to connect with Gavriel when he angsts about them dying. This is especially obvious when Gavriel seems to spend more time mourning asshole Alex than innocent, literal child Hannah. The author introduces Alex's trauma and his softer side right before he dies, but it's not enough to make us really feel sad that he's gone; he, as well as Victor and Tanni, should have had a few more redeeming qualities if the author actually wanted us to care about them dying as much as Gavriel did.
The fact that Gavriel's siblings are very unlikeable, to the point the reader doesn't care about them, has the much bigger problem of hampering reader investment in the first half of the novel, as that section is all about getting invested in Everwatch's succession crisis. I found myself reading solely for the worldbuilding and history of magic, witches, and their wars, rather than anything the humans were doing. In the first half of the book I was genuinely wishing Gavriel would leave Everwatch behind so that the narrative could focus solely on the interesting parts of the book! This improved a lot as we got into the second half, as the story moved away from the succession crisis and became more about the witches and their overall war (and, admittedly, because certain of Gavriel's siblings had died by that point), but I think the book would have massively benefitted from either making Gavriel's siblings more interesting, or finding some other way to have later events happen without having to go through the succession part of the plot.
The second half and ending was where the pace and interest of the plot picked up immensely, though, and I could barely tear my eyes away. The final chapters had loads of fascinating twists and actually impactful, cool battle scenes. I loved how the ending built on things that had come before, and used the MC's special talent that he had built up to using and learning, as a way to succeed.
Overall, I really enjoyed a lot of this book, especially the worldbuilding and the second half of the plot, and I'm really hoping a sequel is in the works! We definitely need more of the amazing worldbuilding and history of this universe!!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
January 28, 2026
Witch in the Wall is a book that is full of potential, but disappointing execution. First, let me say that there were several things I genuinely enjoyed about this book. The magic system was creative and unique, and easily the strongest element of the story. The world itself felt thoughtfully constructed, and I appreciated the layered family dynamics and internal conflict woven between the different types of characters (mortals, faeries, witches, etc.) throughout the plot. Conceptually, this book has a lot going for it, and I can absolutely see the potential.
Unfortunately, I ultimately had to DNF this book at around 70%.
My biggest issue was the main character Gavriel. I am completely on board with a weak or insecure protagonist who grows over time, as that can be incredibly compelling. However, even at 70%, Gavriel was still constantly doubting himself, running away from problems, and reacting to situations with the emotional maturity of a much younger character. I really struggled to connect with him and empathize with him because his flaws never meaningfully evolved.
I also didn’t feel the chemistry between the two love interests. Because I found Gavriel so unlikable, it was hard for me to see what Aziz found attractive about him. Their interactions didn’t convince me emotionally, which made any romantic tension fall flat. Alongside this, one of the major “twists” involving Aziz was so heavily foreshadowed that by the time it was revealed, well past the halfway mark, it fell flat for me. I was mostly thinking yes, and?
Another element that left a bad taste for me was the repeated use of women being called “whores.” In a world that otherwise presents itself as inclusive and features LGBTQIA+ characters, this language felt jarring and unnecessary, and it pulled me out of the story more than once.
Pacing was another significant issue. Some sections dragged on far too long, while others felt rushed to the point of complete emotional disconnect. For example, the opening chapter spent several pages on sibling dialogue before the reader even understood why they were there. Meanwhile, later on, an entire fight scene lasted barely a paragraph. Character deaths happen and then are seemingly forgotten about by the next page. Essentially, moments that should have felt impactful instead felt abbreviated, but we spend a lot of time on other moments that aren't really that important.
Related to this, I often struggled with Gavriel's emotional reactions. In one scene that should have been devastating for him, his grief lasted for what felt like a single sentence before he was immediately thinking about kissing Aziz in the next paragraph. He says he's sad, but I don't really see it. This lack of emotional processing made it difficult for me to empathize with him. Gavriel cared much more about Aziz than his own family.
I was also confused by the book’s intended genre. The magic system and worldbuilding read like adult high fantasy, while the romance had a very YA “does he like me or not?” tone. At the same time, there were graphic and gory depictions of death, contrasted with fade-to-black intimate scenes. For instance, I assumed they only kissed, but then later on they talked about having had sex, which was confusing to me. This tonal inconsistency made it difficult to understand who the target audience was meant to be.
Overall, this book had real potential, which makes this DNF disappointing. I tried really hard because the worldbuilding is interesting, the magic system is unique, and the foundation of the plot is strong. However, the combination of pacing issues, confusing tone, character inconsistency, and my strong dislike of the main character made it impossible for me to continue.
I am rating it 2.5 stars because I do commend the author for their imagination and ambition, but unfortunately, this one just wasn’t for me.
Thank you NetGalley and Atmosphere Press for an advanced reader copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. All opinions are my own.
Unfortunately, I ultimately had to DNF this book at around 70%.
My biggest issue was the main character Gavriel. I am completely on board with a weak or insecure protagonist who grows over time, as that can be incredibly compelling. However, even at 70%, Gavriel was still constantly doubting himself, running away from problems, and reacting to situations with the emotional maturity of a much younger character. I really struggled to connect with him and empathize with him because his flaws never meaningfully evolved.
I also didn’t feel the chemistry between the two love interests. Because I found Gavriel so unlikable, it was hard for me to see what Aziz found attractive about him. Their interactions didn’t convince me emotionally, which made any romantic tension fall flat. Alongside this, one of the major “twists” involving Aziz was so heavily foreshadowed that by the time it was revealed, well past the halfway mark, it fell flat for me. I was mostly thinking yes, and?
Another element that left a bad taste for me was the repeated use of women being called “whores.” In a world that otherwise presents itself as inclusive and features LGBTQIA+ characters, this language felt jarring and unnecessary, and it pulled me out of the story more than once.
Pacing was another significant issue. Some sections dragged on far too long, while others felt rushed to the point of complete emotional disconnect. For example, the opening chapter spent several pages on sibling dialogue before the reader even understood why they were there. Meanwhile, later on, an entire fight scene lasted barely a paragraph. Character deaths happen and then are seemingly forgotten about by the next page. Essentially, moments that should have felt impactful instead felt abbreviated, but we spend a lot of time on other moments that aren't really that important.
Related to this, I often struggled with Gavriel's emotional reactions. In one scene that should have been devastating for him, his grief lasted for what felt like a single sentence before he was immediately thinking about kissing Aziz in the next paragraph. He says he's sad, but I don't really see it. This lack of emotional processing made it difficult for me to empathize with him. Gavriel cared much more about Aziz than his own family.
I was also confused by the book’s intended genre. The magic system and worldbuilding read like adult high fantasy, while the romance had a very YA “does he like me or not?” tone. At the same time, there were graphic and gory depictions of death, contrasted with fade-to-black intimate scenes. For instance, I assumed they only kissed, but then later on they talked about having had sex, which was confusing to me. This tonal inconsistency made it difficult to understand who the target audience was meant to be.
Overall, this book had real potential, which makes this DNF disappointing. I tried really hard because the worldbuilding is interesting, the magic system is unique, and the foundation of the plot is strong. However, the combination of pacing issues, confusing tone, character inconsistency, and my strong dislike of the main character made it impossible for me to continue.
I am rating it 2.5 stars because I do commend the author for their imagination and ambition, but unfortunately, this one just wasn’t for me.
Thank you NetGalley and Atmosphere Press for an advanced reader copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. All opinions are my own.
January 13, 2026
“Witch in the Wall,” by Quinn Hogshead is a highly recommended, must-read fantasy novel for 2026 due to its impeccable and original world-building, a complex but highly fascinating magic system, the hilarious but also frightening bickering between immortals, and a brutal sibling rivalry unlike any other.
Gavriel Hall lives in Everwatch, a place well-known due to the wicked witch that has been imprisoned beneath it longer than the faerie lords can remember. Her crimes are so great that no one dares speak her name.
Gavriel is the bastard son of the king who rules Everwatch, a king who is now dead. While his siblings fight for their place on the throne, Gavriel spends his days recording the names of those sacrificed as part of the soul tithe and pining after his best friend Aziz, a mysterious outcast with the twin swords of a forgotten hero.
When the rivalry between his siblings turns Everwatch into a battlefield, Gavriel thinks his hopes for a new life elsewhere are impossible. That is, until the witch below offers him enough dark magic to fix everything. But it comes with a price. With magic running through his veins and possibilities at his fingertips, Gavriel must decide what he’s willing to pay for a new future and if he’s really the coward everyone believes him to be.
This is such an incredible story that immediately draws the reader in from the first page when the children of the dead king are revealed. An insight is given into the siblings and their dynamics, offering a purview of who they are before the rivalry for the throne turns them into bloodthirsty hounds lacking morals and empathy. Furthermore, it emphasizes Gavriel’s role as an observer, someone who refuses to involve himself in conflict and politics for the sake of his own desire to flee his home at any cost. Gavriel’s inability to fling himself into action and preference to watch events unfold at a safe distance doesn’t make him a particularly likable character. In fact, often his inaction is aggravating and hard to read. Yet, as the story progresses, he becomes much more likable as he finds a backbone and learns to be the kind of person someone can admire.
The magic system is intriguing for its complexities and originality. Sometimes it becomes hard to follow, especially in high-action scenes where little explanation is given (likely because it would slow down the pacing). One aspect of Gavriel stepping into an advanced magic system that’s enjoyable is how much he needs to learn and how, when it comes to battle, his lack of knowledge and experience becomes a detriment. It’s nice to read a story where the main character has to work at becoming a master of their craft (or gift) because it feels more relatable and realistic.
“Witch in the Wall” by Quinn Hogshead is a fantastic novel that fantasy readers will absolutely love. It’s expected to be published on January 13th, 2026. Make sure to not only add it to your TBR’s but pick it up and give it a read ASAP! Thank you to NetGalley and Atmosphere Press for providing me with an e-arc of this novel and for the opportunity to share my honest opinion in this review.
Gavriel Hall lives in Everwatch, a place well-known due to the wicked witch that has been imprisoned beneath it longer than the faerie lords can remember. Her crimes are so great that no one dares speak her name.
Gavriel is the bastard son of the king who rules Everwatch, a king who is now dead. While his siblings fight for their place on the throne, Gavriel spends his days recording the names of those sacrificed as part of the soul tithe and pining after his best friend Aziz, a mysterious outcast with the twin swords of a forgotten hero.
When the rivalry between his siblings turns Everwatch into a battlefield, Gavriel thinks his hopes for a new life elsewhere are impossible. That is, until the witch below offers him enough dark magic to fix everything. But it comes with a price. With magic running through his veins and possibilities at his fingertips, Gavriel must decide what he’s willing to pay for a new future and if he’s really the coward everyone believes him to be.
This is such an incredible story that immediately draws the reader in from the first page when the children of the dead king are revealed. An insight is given into the siblings and their dynamics, offering a purview of who they are before the rivalry for the throne turns them into bloodthirsty hounds lacking morals and empathy. Furthermore, it emphasizes Gavriel’s role as an observer, someone who refuses to involve himself in conflict and politics for the sake of his own desire to flee his home at any cost. Gavriel’s inability to fling himself into action and preference to watch events unfold at a safe distance doesn’t make him a particularly likable character. In fact, often his inaction is aggravating and hard to read. Yet, as the story progresses, he becomes much more likable as he finds a backbone and learns to be the kind of person someone can admire.
The magic system is intriguing for its complexities and originality. Sometimes it becomes hard to follow, especially in high-action scenes where little explanation is given (likely because it would slow down the pacing). One aspect of Gavriel stepping into an advanced magic system that’s enjoyable is how much he needs to learn and how, when it comes to battle, his lack of knowledge and experience becomes a detriment. It’s nice to read a story where the main character has to work at becoming a master of their craft (or gift) because it feels more relatable and realistic.
“Witch in the Wall” by Quinn Hogshead is a fantastic novel that fantasy readers will absolutely love. It’s expected to be published on January 13th, 2026. Make sure to not only add it to your TBR’s but pick it up and give it a read ASAP! Thank you to NetGalley and Atmosphere Press for providing me with an e-arc of this novel and for the opportunity to share my honest opinion in this review.
February 12, 2026
Witch in the Wall was a super fun book that is easy to fall into. Easily one of the best fantasy novels I've read in a long time! The amazing family dynamics and conflicts, the cool and complex magic systems, and the exciting characters (the Nowhere beast and Annie are my favorite) made the book super difficult to put down.
At the very heart of this book you get thrown into a wild family dynamic. You share and look back at some of the sibling's most grave mistakes and most pure childhood memories. I enjoyed the many flashback scenes throughout the book that further highlighted this strange family. These flashbacks carry a heavy emotional punch revealing great traumas caused by their late father and how the kids coped with the untimely, scarring loss of their mother. Seeing how the siblings forged happiness together, despite the circumstances created by their father made the resolution all the more devastating. On a more lighthearted note, the sibling teasing and conflicts all felt so real. I love reading Annie's quick and sharp remarks against her unruly brothers. She is SUPER funny.
The magic system is like no other; its truly captivating. It is complex and imaginative. Really, I haven't seen another magic system like it. It allows for some really cool effects unique to the individual characters. Without getting into to many spoilers, I can firmly say the way that Gav, The Outcast, and the Nowhere Beast yield their abilities is impressive. The implications of how their powers work is horrifyingly beautiful. I can't wait to see how it is expanded upon in the next book in the series!
All of the characters are so wonderfully written, from the witches, to the knights, to the family members. Every character also feels so alive and varied. They are each pulled by their own conflicts and interests that define them well, making each character interesting and relatable. There are no flat one-dimensional characters; each has an explanation for why they way they are, making their actions and choices all the more believable. My personal favorite characters were Annie, Aziz, and The Nowhere beast. Annie and Aziz are hilarious, in their own unique ways. Annies is witty and quick in a way only an older sister can be. My favorite character by far is the Nowhere beast. His ability to dominate a scene is incredible. Characters bend and fall to his will not only because of his strength, but because of is ability to play on other's desires and weaknesses. The way his character changes throughout the book, once the Nowhere Beast's own motivations come into light, is spectacular. Truly, an amazing character! Every character in this book is strongly written and captivating.
The book was not only incredibly entertaining, it felt new and fresh within the fantasy genre, with many exciting twists and turns. I highly recommend reading this book. I know you will love it just as much as I did!
At the very heart of this book you get thrown into a wild family dynamic. You share and look back at some of the sibling's most grave mistakes and most pure childhood memories. I enjoyed the many flashback scenes throughout the book that further highlighted this strange family. These flashbacks carry a heavy emotional punch revealing great traumas caused by their late father and how the kids coped with the untimely, scarring loss of their mother. Seeing how the siblings forged happiness together, despite the circumstances created by their father made the resolution all the more devastating. On a more lighthearted note, the sibling teasing and conflicts all felt so real. I love reading Annie's quick and sharp remarks against her unruly brothers. She is SUPER funny.
The magic system is like no other; its truly captivating. It is complex and imaginative. Really, I haven't seen another magic system like it. It allows for some really cool effects unique to the individual characters. Without getting into to many spoilers, I can firmly say the way that Gav, The Outcast, and the Nowhere Beast yield their abilities is impressive. The implications of how their powers work is horrifyingly beautiful. I can't wait to see how it is expanded upon in the next book in the series!
All of the characters are so wonderfully written, from the witches, to the knights, to the family members. Every character also feels so alive and varied. They are each pulled by their own conflicts and interests that define them well, making each character interesting and relatable. There are no flat one-dimensional characters; each has an explanation for why they way they are, making their actions and choices all the more believable. My personal favorite characters were Annie, Aziz, and The Nowhere beast. Annie and Aziz are hilarious, in their own unique ways. Annies is witty and quick in a way only an older sister can be. My favorite character by far is the Nowhere beast. His ability to dominate a scene is incredible. Characters bend and fall to his will not only because of his strength, but because of is ability to play on other's desires and weaknesses. The way his character changes throughout the book, once the Nowhere Beast's own motivations come into light, is spectacular. Truly, an amazing character! Every character in this book is strongly written and captivating.
The book was not only incredibly entertaining, it felt new and fresh within the fantasy genre, with many exciting twists and turns. I highly recommend reading this book. I know you will love it just as much as I did!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
A Fantasy book where Gavriel Hall, a bastard son of a king who transforms from being a mere scribe to something greater.
Gavriel, although he grew up with his family, was never regarded truly as one of them. He would love nothing more than to escape the underground "home" he lives in and forget about everything about his life here in Everwatch.
Upon the announcement of the King dying, the siblings gather to see who become next warden, and as with any sibling relationships, not all see eye to eye. There is a palpable tension between the siblings, and we explore who they are, and what drives each of them to want to become Warden.
What is one willing to do to get revenge? or to gain control? As we explore their pasts in the first half of the book, we grieve who they were as children with Gavriel and the events that shaped them today.
Gavriel would rather stay out of it, but is pushed into being someone he never knew how to be, someone who has a backbone, who can stand up for himself, someone who doesn't run, someone who now has another voice in his head and memories of past lives that both are and are not him. Who is he now that these events have pivoted in a direction he could have never seen coming? Will he allow his grief to win, or can he push passed and save Everwatch?
I loved the magic in this book, and the concept of how the witches work is analogus to the way the avatar (the last Airbender) would tap into his power , which made the concepts easy to picture and understand.
I was not expecting the scenes to be as gruesome and savage as they were, but it does get graphic, and feels.... intense. I enjoyed this book. It was a nice pace, easy to follow , and the grief Gavriel feels is relatable, although there were many times I wished he would just get a grip haha.
Gavriel, although he grew up with his family, was never regarded truly as one of them. He would love nothing more than to escape the underground "home" he lives in and forget about everything about his life here in Everwatch.
Upon the announcement of the King dying, the siblings gather to see who become next warden, and as with any sibling relationships, not all see eye to eye. There is a palpable tension between the siblings, and we explore who they are, and what drives each of them to want to become Warden.
What is one willing to do to get revenge? or to gain control? As we explore their pasts in the first half of the book, we grieve who they were as children with Gavriel and the events that shaped them today.
Gavriel would rather stay out of it, but is pushed into being someone he never knew how to be, someone who has a backbone, who can stand up for himself, someone who doesn't run, someone who now has another voice in his head and memories of past lives that both are and are not him. Who is he now that these events have pivoted in a direction he could have never seen coming? Will he allow his grief to win, or can he push passed and save Everwatch?
I loved the magic in this book, and the concept of how the witches work is analogus to the way the avatar (the last Airbender) would tap into his power , which made the concepts easy to picture and understand.
I was not expecting the scenes to be as gruesome and savage as they were, but it does get graphic, and feels.... intense. I enjoyed this book. It was a nice pace, easy to follow , and the grief Gavriel feels is relatable, although there were many times I wished he would just get a grip haha.
January 25, 2026
A Fresh Take on MM Fantasy!
Oh wow! I loved this book so much. It was very well written with an amazing plot and characters! I loved Gav’s story, and the magic system was really well thought out. Ugh the magic! Just a well built system, and I loved it. It was a breath of fresh air to get some high fantasy with an intriguing world and characters in the MM genre. It is quite clear that Quinn took a great deal of time building this world. I cannot wait for the sequel! I highly recommend the book for lovers of Jocelyn Drake’s Godstone Saga, KD Edward’s Tarot Sequence, AH Lee’s The Knight and The Necromancer, Tobias Begley’s Evander Tailor, or Hailey Turner’s Infernal War Saga.
====SPOILERS====
The ending!!! Oh my death above. I could not have predicted the Emissary’s identity. I frankly love that there is so much more to explore in this world. Many more mysteries to dive into. Cough cough, Outcast and Gav’s mom.
Gav and Aziz have such a great chemistry, and I am loving the build up of inevitable heart break that may come. I really hope we get some previous Outcast and Voyager love story. I would love a time when the Outcast broke the Voyager’s heart.
Rian making his move! It broke my heart. Chefs kiss. I gasped.
I hope we get to see more of what makes the Voyager so terrifying besides being a Hexomachy. Especially as a foil to the Wayfinder who has cosmic ending powers.
Beth’s story is so beautifully heartbreaking. Ugh I can’t wait for more of her and Gav’s relationship to be explored. There is something so relatable to her as an anti hero and I love that the Masque’s complicate the relationship. Blurring mentor/mentee with past and future was giving me all the feels.
Oh wow! I loved this book so much. It was very well written with an amazing plot and characters! I loved Gav’s story, and the magic system was really well thought out. Ugh the magic! Just a well built system, and I loved it. It was a breath of fresh air to get some high fantasy with an intriguing world and characters in the MM genre. It is quite clear that Quinn took a great deal of time building this world. I cannot wait for the sequel! I highly recommend the book for lovers of Jocelyn Drake’s Godstone Saga, KD Edward’s Tarot Sequence, AH Lee’s The Knight and The Necromancer, Tobias Begley’s Evander Tailor, or Hailey Turner’s Infernal War Saga.
====SPOILERS====
The ending!!! Oh my death above. I could not have predicted the Emissary’s identity. I frankly love that there is so much more to explore in this world. Many more mysteries to dive into. Cough cough, Outcast and Gav’s mom.
Gav and Aziz have such a great chemistry, and I am loving the build up of inevitable heart break that may come. I really hope we get some previous Outcast and Voyager love story. I would love a time when the Outcast broke the Voyager’s heart.
Rian making his move! It broke my heart. Chefs kiss. I gasped.
I hope we get to see more of what makes the Voyager so terrifying besides being a Hexomachy. Especially as a foil to the Wayfinder who has cosmic ending powers.
Beth’s story is so beautifully heartbreaking. Ugh I can’t wait for more of her and Gav’s relationship to be explored. There is something so relatable to her as an anti hero and I love that the Masque’s complicate the relationship. Blurring mentor/mentee with past and future was giving me all the feels.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Witch in the Wall is one of those rare fantasy novels that feels both claustrophobic and expansive at the same time. Set in the shadowy depths of Everwatch—a prison‑city carved into the earth—this story blends dark magic, political intrigue, and aching, complicated relationships into something genuinely compelling.
Gavriel Hall is an immediately memorable protagonist: a chronic liar with a soft heart, a sharp tongue, and absolutely no desire to be a hero. His voice carries the book with a mix of humour, self‑loathing, and reluctant hope that makes him impossible not to root for. His dynamic with Aziz is tender, messy, and beautifully human, grounding the story even as the stakes spiral into the mythic.
The worldbuilding is rich without ever feeling heavy, and the atmosphere—gloomy tunnels, cursed stones, whispered legends of a witch who should never be woken—wraps around you like damp fog. When the witch finally enters the narrative in earnest, the tension sharpens deliciously. The moral ambiguity throughout is handled with a deft touch; every choice Gavriel faces feels both inevitable and devastating.
What really stands out is how the book balances its darkness with genuine warmth. Amid soul tithes, political bloodshed, and ancient magic, there’s a beating heart: friendship, longing, and the desperate desire to carve out a future that looks different from the past.
A moody, character‑driven fantasy with teeth—and a surprising amount of soul. I’ll be thinking about Gavriel and Aziz for a long time.
with thanks to Quinn Hogshead, the publisher and netgalley for the ARC
Gavriel Hall is an immediately memorable protagonist: a chronic liar with a soft heart, a sharp tongue, and absolutely no desire to be a hero. His voice carries the book with a mix of humour, self‑loathing, and reluctant hope that makes him impossible not to root for. His dynamic with Aziz is tender, messy, and beautifully human, grounding the story even as the stakes spiral into the mythic.
The worldbuilding is rich without ever feeling heavy, and the atmosphere—gloomy tunnels, cursed stones, whispered legends of a witch who should never be woken—wraps around you like damp fog. When the witch finally enters the narrative in earnest, the tension sharpens deliciously. The moral ambiguity throughout is handled with a deft touch; every choice Gavriel faces feels both inevitable and devastating.
What really stands out is how the book balances its darkness with genuine warmth. Amid soul tithes, political bloodshed, and ancient magic, there’s a beating heart: friendship, longing, and the desperate desire to carve out a future that looks different from the past.
A moody, character‑driven fantasy with teeth—and a surprising amount of soul. I’ll be thinking about Gavriel and Aziz for a long time.
with thanks to Quinn Hogshead, the publisher and netgalley for the ARC
March 8, 2026
Witch in the Wall by Quinn Hogshead ended up being a really engaging dark fantasy read for me. The premise immediately caught my attention. Following Gavriel Hall, the bastard son of Everwatch’s dead ruler, the story begins right as the fragile balance in the city starts to collapse and his siblings begin maneuvering for power.
Gavriel has always lived on the margins of his family, and that sense of being an outsider really shapes the choices he makes. At the same time, he is dealing with complicated feelings for his friend Aziz and a growing desperation to escape Everwatch altogether. When everything starts falling apart, Gavriel makes a reckless decision and accepts an offer from the witch imprisoned beneath the city. In return he gains magic that could change his fate, though it comes with its own consequences.
One of the things that stood out most to me was the worldbuilding. Hogshead builds a very interesting world around Everwatch, the witches, and the strange magic tied to them. The hints of deeper lore make the setting feel much bigger than what we see in this first book, and it definitely feels like a world with a lot of potential to explore further.
Gavriel is a messy and sometimes frustrating protagonist, but that also made him feel very human. Watching his decisions ripple outward as tensions between his siblings escalate kept the story engaging.
All in all, this was a dark and imaginative start to a series that left me very curious to see where both the story and this world go next.
Thanks to Netgalley and Atmosphere Press for the review copy. My opinions are my own!
Gavriel has always lived on the margins of his family, and that sense of being an outsider really shapes the choices he makes. At the same time, he is dealing with complicated feelings for his friend Aziz and a growing desperation to escape Everwatch altogether. When everything starts falling apart, Gavriel makes a reckless decision and accepts an offer from the witch imprisoned beneath the city. In return he gains magic that could change his fate, though it comes with its own consequences.
One of the things that stood out most to me was the worldbuilding. Hogshead builds a very interesting world around Everwatch, the witches, and the strange magic tied to them. The hints of deeper lore make the setting feel much bigger than what we see in this first book, and it definitely feels like a world with a lot of potential to explore further.
Gavriel is a messy and sometimes frustrating protagonist, but that also made him feel very human. Watching his decisions ripple outward as tensions between his siblings escalate kept the story engaging.
All in all, this was a dark and imaginative start to a series that left me very curious to see where both the story and this world go next.
Thanks to Netgalley and Atmosphere Press for the review copy. My opinions are my own!
February 10, 2026
Witch in the Wall is a dark and thoughtful fantasy that focuses on choices, fear, and the cost of power rather than fast paced heroics. The world of Everwatch feels heavy and enclosed, with a constant sense that something dangerous is always pressing in from just out of sight. The setting itself plays a major role in the story, shaping the characters and their decisions in ways that feel intentional and believable.
Gavriel is not an easy character to love, but that is clearly by design. He is cautious to the point of self sabotage, often choosing inaction when action would be easier to admire. While this can be frustrating at times, it also makes his internal struggle feel honest. His growth is slow and uneven, but it fits the tone of the story and the world he lives in. The emotional tension in his relationships adds depth and helps balance the darker elements of the plot.
The magic in this book is dangerous and unpredictable, which adds to the overall unease. At times the mechanics of it can feel dense, especially during more intense moments, but it reinforces the idea that power in this world is not meant to be easily controlled. The pacing is uneven in places, with some sections taking longer to unfold than others, but the atmosphere and character work kept me invested.
Overall, this is an immersive and ambitious fantasy that prioritizes mood, internal conflict, and worldbuilding over spectacle. It may not work for everyone, but for readers who enjoy slower character driven stories with a darker edge, this is a solid and engaging read.
Gavriel is not an easy character to love, but that is clearly by design. He is cautious to the point of self sabotage, often choosing inaction when action would be easier to admire. While this can be frustrating at times, it also makes his internal struggle feel honest. His growth is slow and uneven, but it fits the tone of the story and the world he lives in. The emotional tension in his relationships adds depth and helps balance the darker elements of the plot.
The magic in this book is dangerous and unpredictable, which adds to the overall unease. At times the mechanics of it can feel dense, especially during more intense moments, but it reinforces the idea that power in this world is not meant to be easily controlled. The pacing is uneven in places, with some sections taking longer to unfold than others, but the atmosphere and character work kept me invested.
Overall, this is an immersive and ambitious fantasy that prioritizes mood, internal conflict, and worldbuilding over spectacle. It may not work for everyone, but for readers who enjoy slower character driven stories with a darker edge, this is a solid and engaging read.
April 17, 2026
Witch in the Wall: Book I by Quinn Hogshead is a dark, character-driven fantasy that blends political intrigue, emotional vulnerability, and forbidden magic into a deeply immersive and gripping narrative.
At the heart of the story is Gavriel Hall, a protagonist who immediately stands apart from the typical heroic mold. Flawed, evasive, and painfully human, his internal struggles are just as compelling as the external chaos surrounding him. His journey is not one of simple bravery, but of self-confrontation, making his arc feel authentic, layered, and genuinely engaging.
The world of Everwatch is rich with tension, where sacrifice, power, and legacy intertwine beneath the surface of a crumbling political order. The concept of the imprisoned witch is particularly striking, adding an undercurrent of dread and temptation that steadily intensifies as the story unfolds. Her presence lingers like a shadow over every decision, raising the stakes in a way that feels both intimate and catastrophic.
Equally compelling is the emotional thread woven through Gavriel’s relationship with Aziz. Their dynamic adds depth and vulnerability, grounding the larger narrative in something deeply personal and human. It’s this balance between emotional nuance and high stakes conflict that gives the novel its lasting impact.
Atmospheric, morally complex, and driven by a protagonist who defies expectations, Witch in the Wall is a powerful opening to what promises to be a captivating series. It’s a story about choice, consequence, and the cost of becoming who you’re meant to be.
At the heart of the story is Gavriel Hall, a protagonist who immediately stands apart from the typical heroic mold. Flawed, evasive, and painfully human, his internal struggles are just as compelling as the external chaos surrounding him. His journey is not one of simple bravery, but of self-confrontation, making his arc feel authentic, layered, and genuinely engaging.
The world of Everwatch is rich with tension, where sacrifice, power, and legacy intertwine beneath the surface of a crumbling political order. The concept of the imprisoned witch is particularly striking, adding an undercurrent of dread and temptation that steadily intensifies as the story unfolds. Her presence lingers like a shadow over every decision, raising the stakes in a way that feels both intimate and catastrophic.
Equally compelling is the emotional thread woven through Gavriel’s relationship with Aziz. Their dynamic adds depth and vulnerability, grounding the larger narrative in something deeply personal and human. It’s this balance between emotional nuance and high stakes conflict that gives the novel its lasting impact.
Atmospheric, morally complex, and driven by a protagonist who defies expectations, Witch in the Wall is a powerful opening to what promises to be a captivating series. It’s a story about choice, consequence, and the cost of becoming who you’re meant to be.
February 1, 2026
the concept for Witch in the Wall was cool as hell. witches, eldritch power/beings, a violent war for the throne, intense sibling rivalry, and an entire kingdom city imprisoned underground?? say less. from the start, everything about this felt so new and unique to me.
the magic system in particular is one of the most unique magic systems i’ve read in a while. BUT I’ll be honest, it did get a little confusing at times. there’s a lot going on, and tons of terminology that you need to remember (but fear not! this book does have a glossary 😌). this book is dark, gritty, and quite violent. and for the first third especially, I was convinced it was on track to become a new all time favorite of mine.
somewhere toward the end though… something just didn’t fully click for me. and i wish i could explain exactly what it was, but i honestly can’t put my finger on it. nothing was bad, it just didn’t quite hit with the same intensity as the beginning to me.
even with that, i still really enjoyed this book. the world, the ideas, the chaos? amazing. i’m excited to see where this series will go next. if you’re into dark fantasy with strange magic, high stakes, and a unique setting that’s different from anything you’ve read before, this one is absolutely worth picking up 👑💫🗡️🏰🌲
thank you to netgalley and the publishers for this arc!
the magic system in particular is one of the most unique magic systems i’ve read in a while. BUT I’ll be honest, it did get a little confusing at times. there’s a lot going on, and tons of terminology that you need to remember (but fear not! this book does have a glossary 😌). this book is dark, gritty, and quite violent. and for the first third especially, I was convinced it was on track to become a new all time favorite of mine.
somewhere toward the end though… something just didn’t fully click for me. and i wish i could explain exactly what it was, but i honestly can’t put my finger on it. nothing was bad, it just didn’t quite hit with the same intensity as the beginning to me.
even with that, i still really enjoyed this book. the world, the ideas, the chaos? amazing. i’m excited to see where this series will go next. if you’re into dark fantasy with strange magic, high stakes, and a unique setting that’s different from anything you’ve read before, this one is absolutely worth picking up 👑💫🗡️🏰🌲
thank you to netgalley and the publishers for this arc!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Thank you to net galley and the publishers for an eArc in exchange for an honest review.
I WAS NOT EXPECTING TO ENJOY THIS AS MUCH AS I DID!!!!!
I was so close to a reading slump and knew I needed some good old fashioned fantasy to pull me out of it, but I also went in with pretty low expectations. I don't know what I was expecting but it wasn't this. The plot was very much giving Mistborn meets Avatar The Last Air Bender but much bleaker and not so hopeful. The plot kept moving forward at a steady pace but every now and then you'd get flashback chapters which helped to unravel the family relationship which at the core of the story. While the storyline was interesting I did keep getting a bit lost with the magic system and the worldbuilding. There wasn't much explanation and I'd get confused trying to figure out what was actually going on. I'd have liked more worldbuilding and a more consistent tone, there were a few times where the writing style skewed more YA and the use of "mom" and "dad" really pulled me out of the story. But other than that, it was quite an enjoyable read and I'm looking forward to the next book. Especially after that bloody cliffhanger!!!!!!
I WAS NOT EXPECTING TO ENJOY THIS AS MUCH AS I DID!!!!!
I was so close to a reading slump and knew I needed some good old fashioned fantasy to pull me out of it, but I also went in with pretty low expectations. I don't know what I was expecting but it wasn't this. The plot was very much giving Mistborn meets Avatar The Last Air Bender but much bleaker and not so hopeful. The plot kept moving forward at a steady pace but every now and then you'd get flashback chapters which helped to unravel the family relationship which at the core of the story. While the storyline was interesting I did keep getting a bit lost with the magic system and the worldbuilding. There wasn't much explanation and I'd get confused trying to figure out what was actually going on. I'd have liked more worldbuilding and a more consistent tone, there were a few times where the writing style skewed more YA and the use of "mom" and "dad" really pulled me out of the story. But other than that, it was quite an enjoyable read and I'm looking forward to the next book. Especially after that bloody cliffhanger!!!!!!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
WITW is a debut novel from Quinn Hogshead and I am so thouroughly impressed with this read.
Quick breakdown:
Pacing: 4.5/5
Plot: 5/5
Character voice: 3.5/5
Setting: 5/5
Overall the book reads very well, starts strong, uses flashback passages tactfully and carefully, and is (most importantly) captivating.
A note to the unassuming: there are brief mild romance scenes, but nothing approaching romatasy style books.
The anti-hero protagonist was written in a way to be very relatable even though their world is so different from ours. The twists upon twists align very well with established lore in the book. At first, when I saw appendicies with names and definitions, I thought the book was going to be tough to digest, but everything flowed well and Quinn did well to describe things in an approachable manner.
If I had to take anything to task, I feel like the Voyager had a confusing voice considering who his character is supposed to be. I couldn't buy that his speech patterns matched how his character was defined.
I recieved an Advance Reader Copy and am providing a fair and honest review.
Quick breakdown:
Pacing: 4.5/5
Plot: 5/5
Character voice: 3.5/5
Setting: 5/5
Overall the book reads very well, starts strong, uses flashback passages tactfully and carefully, and is (most importantly) captivating.
A note to the unassuming: there are brief mild romance scenes, but nothing approaching romatasy style books.
The anti-hero protagonist was written in a way to be very relatable even though their world is so different from ours. The twists upon twists align very well with established lore in the book. At first, when I saw appendicies with names and definitions, I thought the book was going to be tough to digest, but everything flowed well and Quinn did well to describe things in an approachable manner.
If I had to take anything to task, I feel like the Voyager had a confusing voice considering who his character is supposed to be. I couldn't buy that his speech patterns matched how his character was defined.
I recieved an Advance Reader Copy and am providing a fair and honest review.
January 18, 2026
3.5 stars out of 5
Thank you to NetGalley and Atmosphere Press for the ARC copy.
This book had great ideas and a compelling storyline that made me want to know how everything works out in the end. It has an interesting and fresh magic system that can take a moment to wrap your head around.
However, I can tell it’s a debut novel. For many scenes, it felt that the author had a thesaurus in front of them, trying not to repeat any descriptors. I will admit, there are times where the author gets into the groove and the scene just flows smoothly. Gav receives the same description regarding the magic several times, all from different witches and it felt too repetitive.
I think that this could be a story that booktok would love as it seems to fit in the New Adult genre really well.
I am excited to see Quinn’s writing evolve and I do plan on reading the next installment of this series.
Thank you to NetGalley and Atmosphere Press for the ARC copy.
This book had great ideas and a compelling storyline that made me want to know how everything works out in the end. It has an interesting and fresh magic system that can take a moment to wrap your head around.
However, I can tell it’s a debut novel. For many scenes, it felt that the author had a thesaurus in front of them, trying not to repeat any descriptors. I will admit, there are times where the author gets into the groove and the scene just flows smoothly. Gav receives the same description regarding the magic several times, all from different witches and it felt too repetitive.
I think that this could be a story that booktok would love as it seems to fit in the New Adult genre really well.
I am excited to see Quinn’s writing evolve and I do plan on reading the next installment of this series.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I received an e-ARC of this book from NetGalley in return for an honest review.
Got to say, I read this book in two sittings, and if I'd not needed to break for lunch I probably could have gone all way through it in one. The world building is interesting, the magic system is unlike any I've read before and somewhat creepy to boot, and the juxtaposition of past and present was really well done, leading the plot well, and really, the ~500 pages went along like a breeze. There were one or two wrong-word type errors that a spellchecker or editor might miss but on the whole a very enjoyable start to the series. And the epilogue was nice and juicy too; while I kind of linked some plot points early on, that last little bomb shell was a good way to keep me wanting more.
Got to say, I read this book in two sittings, and if I'd not needed to break for lunch I probably could have gone all way through it in one. The world building is interesting, the magic system is unlike any I've read before and somewhat creepy to boot, and the juxtaposition of past and present was really well done, leading the plot well, and really, the ~500 pages went along like a breeze. There were one or two wrong-word type errors that a spellchecker or editor might miss but on the whole a very enjoyable start to the series. And the epilogue was nice and juicy too; while I kind of linked some plot points early on, that last little bomb shell was a good way to keep me wanting more.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Witch in the Wall
Rating: 4
Holy moly, what a debut.
This is fantasy novel came as such a delightful surprise and a great way to kick off my 2026 reading year.
Focussing on Gabriel Hall, the illegitimate son of the king, being summoned with all of his siblings to announce a death which will cause his world to crumble.
The world building in this tale is brilliant, creating an eerie sense of "otherness" and ensuring that the reader has a claustrophobic feel.
On top of that, the magic system used is one of the most unique and interesting that I have read.
Does it baffle me slightly? Yes.
Am I still a fan? Absolutely!
Thank you to Netgalley for this ARC!
Rating: 4
Holy moly, what a debut.
This is fantasy novel came as such a delightful surprise and a great way to kick off my 2026 reading year.
Focussing on Gabriel Hall, the illegitimate son of the king, being summoned with all of his siblings to announce a death which will cause his world to crumble.
The world building in this tale is brilliant, creating an eerie sense of "otherness" and ensuring that the reader has a claustrophobic feel.
On top of that, the magic system used is one of the most unique and interesting that I have read.
Does it baffle me slightly? Yes.
Am I still a fan? Absolutely!
Thank you to Netgalley for this ARC!
January 26, 2026
3.5 rounded up
I liked a lot about this book - the beginning with the mother was absolutely fantastic.
The world is dark and unforgiving. Everwatch is a prison city carved into the hills on the ruins of an ancient battlefield. Souls are sacrificed weekly to appease a fae lord, and when the Warden dies the fight between his children for the title turns bloody.
I enjoyed the dark humour - how The Voyager used their portalling abilities to kill got me.
The magic system and how witches were hosted was really interesting, but I did sometimes get lost with who was who due to the many names.
(ARC provided by NetGalley)
I liked a lot about this book - the beginning with the mother was absolutely fantastic.
The world is dark and unforgiving. Everwatch is a prison city carved into the hills on the ruins of an ancient battlefield. Souls are sacrificed weekly to appease a fae lord, and when the Warden dies the fight between his children for the title turns bloody.
I enjoyed the dark humour - how The Voyager used their portalling abilities to kill got me.
The magic system and how witches were hosted was really interesting, but I did sometimes get lost with who was who due to the many names.
(ARC provided by NetGalley)
May 9, 2026
Hmmmm…
I have mixed feelings on this book. The magic system and world building were done well and were so intriguing! I loved these elements of the book!
My two big hangups are that this book seemed to flip flop between elements to of being YA and then having super descriptive gorey scenes. Then there was talk of sleeping together. It felt like whiplash.
This is a personal hangup, but I didn’t like that the MMC consistently seems juvenile and was not growing in his confidence to make decisions.
I have mixed feelings on this book. The magic system and world building were done well and were so intriguing! I loved these elements of the book!
My two big hangups are that this book seemed to flip flop between elements to of being YA and then having super descriptive gorey scenes. Then there was talk of sleeping together. It felt like whiplash.
This is a personal hangup, but I didn’t like that the MMC consistently seems juvenile and was not growing in his confidence to make decisions.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Witch in the Wall (Book I) was weird in a good way. The magic feels creepy and super personal, like the house itself is watching you. It’s definitely a slower burn, but the atmosphere kept pulling me in. If you like dark fantasy that feels a little haunted and uncomfortable (in a fun way), this one’s worth checking out. 🖤✨
📚I was able to read an advanced copy of title thanks to NetGalley, Quinn Hogshead and Atmosphere Press📚
📚All reviews and opinions are entirely my own📚
📚I was able to read an advanced copy of title thanks to NetGalley, Quinn Hogshead and Atmosphere Press📚
📚All reviews and opinions are entirely my own📚
May 9, 2026
DNFing at 17% due to consistently being pulled out of the action of the story for flashbacks that are not relevant. The prologue of this one really pulled me in but as I dived deeper I was annoyed with the introspection of the main character and lack of world building leaving me confused. When the plot was revealed at 16% it was kind of interesting but not enough to make me want to drudge through pages and pages of flashback to uncover it.
June 7, 2026
Witch in the Wall: Book I is an immersive fantasy novel that blends dark magic, political conflict, and meaningful character development into a compelling adventure.
Quinn Hogshead creates a memorable journey through a richly imagined world where difficult choices, hidden dangers, and personal growth shape every step of the story.
Overall, it's a rewarding read for fans of dark fantasy, magical intrigue, and character-focused storytelling.
Quinn Hogshead creates a memorable journey through a richly imagined world where difficult choices, hidden dangers, and personal growth shape every step of the story.
Overall, it's a rewarding read for fans of dark fantasy, magical intrigue, and character-focused storytelling.
April 12, 2026
Witch in the Wall is a dark and immersive fantasy that pulls readers into a world of danger, magic, and difficult choices. Quinn Hogshead crafts a compelling story driven by a deeply human protagonist and the tension between fear and ambition. With its rich atmosphere and emotional stakes, this is a gripping read for fans of character-driven dark fantasy.
January 14, 2026
Interesting world building and a compelling use of first person narration. I think this novel tonally balanced humor and dark themes well, def recommend giving it a read. Looking forward to the next installation :)!
February 5, 2026
This book had real potential.
The foundation of the plot is strong, but the pacing is much varied and I didn't really connect with the main character.
Thank you NetGalley and the publisher for the e-ARC.
The foundation of the plot is strong, but the pacing is much varied and I didn't really connect with the main character.
Thank you NetGalley and the publisher for the e-ARC.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
4,5⭐
One of the best parts of ‘Witch in the Wall’ is the relationships between Gavriel and his siblings. Their dynamics are really fun to read about, especially when all of them are first introduced, and I would have loved even more scenes focused on them.
Gavriel’s relationship with his love interest is also enjoyable to follow, though I did feel that the pacing of their relationship sped up a bit too quickly at times. Still, their interactions were charming overall. (Aziz is a hottie)
That said, the best relationship in the entire book is easily the one between Gavriel and his masque, The Voyager. Watching them learn how to co-exist as one person while still remaining true to themselves was fascinating, and their constant bickering made me laugh multiple times.
‘Witch in the Wall’ is very well paced, the ending may feel a little fast, but it works because the final scenes unfold like a domino effect, with each moment naturally triggering the next.
I went into the book expecting the magic system to be fairly basic, but I was pleasantly surprised. The magic is well thought out, complete with ranks, rules, and a rich backstory that adds depth to the world.
Quinn Hogshead is a great writer overall. The dialogue feels natural, the descriptions are vivid, and the characters feel alive on the page. I cannot wait for future installments in the Squall series, as well as other novels Hogshead will write.
One of the best parts of ‘Witch in the Wall’ is the relationships between Gavriel and his siblings. Their dynamics are really fun to read about, especially when all of them are first introduced, and I would have loved even more scenes focused on them.
Gavriel’s relationship with his love interest is also enjoyable to follow, though I did feel that the pacing of their relationship sped up a bit too quickly at times. Still, their interactions were charming overall. (Aziz is a hottie)
That said, the best relationship in the entire book is easily the one between Gavriel and his masque, The Voyager. Watching them learn how to co-exist as one person while still remaining true to themselves was fascinating, and their constant bickering made me laugh multiple times.
‘Witch in the Wall’ is very well paced, the ending may feel a little fast, but it works because the final scenes unfold like a domino effect, with each moment naturally triggering the next.
I went into the book expecting the magic system to be fairly basic, but I was pleasantly surprised. The magic is well thought out, complete with ranks, rules, and a rich backstory that adds depth to the world.
Quinn Hogshead is a great writer overall. The dialogue feels natural, the descriptions are vivid, and the characters feel alive on the page. I cannot wait for future installments in the Squall series, as well as other novels Hogshead will write.
April 12, 2026
Witch in the Wall holds great promise. The book opens strongly.
I found it far too easy to put the book down, and finishing it became a slough. I delayed writing any review because I cannot quite put my finger on why I took so much time to read it.
I think the world building felt simultaneously incomplete yet overwrought with details, leaving the reader with too many holes to fill.
Though not inherently detrimental to a great book, the characters feel highly unlikable. Still, something about this book simply did not work for me.
I think Quinn Hogshead will write some fantastic books in his career. This is just the opening gambit.
Thank you to NetGalley and Atmosphere Press for the advance copy.
I found it far too easy to put the book down, and finishing it became a slough. I delayed writing any review because I cannot quite put my finger on why I took so much time to read it.
I think the world building felt simultaneously incomplete yet overwrought with details, leaving the reader with too many holes to fill.
Though not inherently detrimental to a great book, the characters feel highly unlikable. Still, something about this book simply did not work for me.
I think Quinn Hogshead will write some fantastic books in his career. This is just the opening gambit.
Thank you to NetGalley and Atmosphere Press for the advance copy.
May 15, 2026
A superb debut novel from Quinn Hogshead. After reading the blurb I knew this was a book for me, but I didn't expect to enjoy it so much.
Gavriel Hall is a bastard son of the king of Everwatch. A place where humans live in an enclosed valley controlled by the faeries. When the king dies and his half - siblings start waring for the crown, Gavriel's only wish is to escape this prison - like city and start a new life. When all his plans and hopes are ruined a witch offers to help but for a price.
Gavriel's relationship with his siblings is very strained, he feels like part of the family but prefers to stay away from them and not interfere with their quarrels. After their father's death any familial feelings between them were gone and they started to see each other as enemies, rivals for the throne. To get it they will do anything.
The author poses difficult questions about humanity and grief. Can you hate and miss a person at the same time, is it right to kill somebody you love because it needs to be done for the sake of others.
Gavriel struggles with his emotions of grief and belonging. He always ran away whenever things got too much for him, choosing to become a witch was supposed to be the easy way out. He struggles to embraces his powers without losing his humanity. As the story progresses Gavriel starts to understand what is expected of him and what he can achieve with his powers.
"Things get worse until someone tries to make them better. If you sit around waiting to be happy, you'll never find it. "
All the characters in the novel are well fleshed out. The world building and magic system were amazing. The use of magic was very unique and complex. The concept of witches being a host and type of "parasite" was very interesting and adds depth to characters. The writing was poetic and the descriptions were very vivid.
Overall, this is a magnificent start to a new series. I would recommend it to everyone who loves magic, witches and amazing fight scenes. I will definitely read more books from this author.
Many thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.
Gavriel Hall is a bastard son of the king of Everwatch. A place where humans live in an enclosed valley controlled by the faeries. When the king dies and his half - siblings start waring for the crown, Gavriel's only wish is to escape this prison - like city and start a new life. When all his plans and hopes are ruined a witch offers to help but for a price.
Gavriel's relationship with his siblings is very strained, he feels like part of the family but prefers to stay away from them and not interfere with their quarrels. After their father's death any familial feelings between them were gone and they started to see each other as enemies, rivals for the throne. To get it they will do anything.
The author poses difficult questions about humanity and grief. Can you hate and miss a person at the same time, is it right to kill somebody you love because it needs to be done for the sake of others.
Gavriel struggles with his emotions of grief and belonging. He always ran away whenever things got too much for him, choosing to become a witch was supposed to be the easy way out. He struggles to embraces his powers without losing his humanity. As the story progresses Gavriel starts to understand what is expected of him and what he can achieve with his powers.
"Things get worse until someone tries to make them better. If you sit around waiting to be happy, you'll never find it. "
All the characters in the novel are well fleshed out. The world building and magic system were amazing. The use of magic was very unique and complex. The concept of witches being a host and type of "parasite" was very interesting and adds depth to characters. The writing was poetic and the descriptions were very vivid.
Overall, this is a magnificent start to a new series. I would recommend it to everyone who loves magic, witches and amazing fight scenes. I will definitely read more books from this author.
Many thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.
Displaying 1 - 28 of 28 reviews