What do you think?
Rate this book
Once Upon a Time in December: A Sapphic Holiday Romance of Self-Discovery and Second Chances
WHAT IF THE WRONG PROPOSAL LED YOU TO THE RIGHT PERSON?
One disastrous Christmas proposal. One free-spirited violinist. One year that changes everything.
Whitley Dupont has it a high-powered finance job, a picture-perfect fiancé, and a five-year plan—until it all falls apart at her family’s Christmas gala.
Enter Layla Simmons, a quirky British violinist with a classical-pop sound and a knack for turning disasters into unforgettable moments. What starts as a comforting conversation over peppermint cocoa turns into long-distance calls, unexpected feelings, and a slow unravelling of everything Whitley thought she knew about love—and herself.
As the holidays pass and seasons change, Whitley must decide if she’s brave enough to rewrite her story and follow her heart toward the most unexpected person of all.
A warm, witty sapphic romance about second chances, sexual awakening, and finding harmony where you least expect it.
One disastrous Christmas proposal. One free-spirited violinist. One year that changes everything.
Whitley Dupont has it a high-powered finance job, a picture-perfect fiancé, and a five-year plan—until it all falls apart at her family’s Christmas gala.
Enter Layla Simmons, a quirky British violinist with a classical-pop sound and a knack for turning disasters into unforgettable moments. What starts as a comforting conversation over peppermint cocoa turns into long-distance calls, unexpected feelings, and a slow unravelling of everything Whitley thought she knew about love—and herself.
As the holidays pass and seasons change, Whitley must decide if she’s brave enough to rewrite her story and follow her heart toward the most unexpected person of all.
A warm, witty sapphic romance about second chances, sexual awakening, and finding harmony where you least expect it.
442 pages, Kindle Edition
Published November 3, 2025
About the author
Alyson Root
22 books209 followersAlyson was born and raised in the heart of England. She moved to Paris in 2015 when she met her wife. Together they moved to the west of France where they now live with their two dogs and pet bird. Alyson spends her time running a small campsite and holiday home. During her off time, she loves to read lesbian romance books, write and Scuba Dive.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 29 of 29 reviews
November 3, 2025
This novel is like a hot cup of chocolate with lots of marshmallows. It warms your heart and your stomach, and everything feels extremely cozy. In addition to the great cover, which could really come from a fairy tale, it was a beautiful story with little drama but lots of chemistry and attraction.
The dynamic between the two main characters, Layla and Whitley, was damn good from the very first meeting. Paired with the winter month of December, it was just a wonderful atmosphere. A great attraction, a delicious slow burn with lots of waiting, steadily increasing longing and desire, and two very interesting and independent women made this holiday novel almost perfect for me!
I enjoyed immersing myself in the world of Layla and Whitley, who had so much patience and love for each other. A story that not only felt comfortable, but also didn't need a third-act breakup to keep the tension going.
I’ve read several books by Alyson Root, and this one confirms once again that she has an incredibly beautiful writing style. One that allows you to see the characters before your eyes and resonate with every emotion.
Highly recommended, especially now for the cold season.
Thanks to Alyson Root for the ARC. I had a lot of fun and enjoyed it very much. The book somehow makes the world out there a little more wholesome.
The dynamic between the two main characters, Layla and Whitley, was damn good from the very first meeting. Paired with the winter month of December, it was just a wonderful atmosphere. A great attraction, a delicious slow burn with lots of waiting, steadily increasing longing and desire, and two very interesting and independent women made this holiday novel almost perfect for me!
I enjoyed immersing myself in the world of Layla and Whitley, who had so much patience and love for each other. A story that not only felt comfortable, but also didn't need a third-act breakup to keep the tension going.
I’ve read several books by Alyson Root, and this one confirms once again that she has an incredibly beautiful writing style. One that allows you to see the characters before your eyes and resonate with every emotion.
Highly recommended, especially now for the cold season.
Thanks to Alyson Root for the ARC. I had a lot of fun and enjoyed it very much. The book somehow makes the world out there a little more wholesome.
November 7, 2025
4.25 ⭐
Once Upon a Time in December is a cozy and lighthearted strangers-to-lovers romance where Whitley and Layla meet every year at Whitley’s family gala. Through these yearly encounters, we get to see their friendship gradually bloom into something deeper and more meaningful.
Whitley, part of the wealthy Dupont family, is the eldest sister and heir to her family’s empire. She’s a bit of a perfectionist—driven, responsible, and always striving to meet expectations. Even though she grew up surrounded by privilege, she’s incredibly humble and spends her time helping kids from orphanages and supporting underrepresented groups. I really liked seeing her step out of her comfort zone and focus on her own happiness for once. Watching her grow more confident and learn to value herself beyond her work was truly rewarding. Then there’s Layla—an absolute sweetheart and a total force of nature. I loved how supportive she was of Whitley’s sapphic awakening and how patient and respectful she remained throughout their journey. She was such a genuine, memorable character.
The romance itself was just beautiful. Their first meeting felt like a scene straight out of a movie—romantic, warm, and sincere. From the start, their chemistry was undeniable and only grew stronger as the story unfolded. The slow burn was perfectly executed; nothing ever felt rushed. Instead, their bond was built on friendship first, which made their eventual romantic connection feel even more authentic. The “toaster oven” moment was handled so naturally, and I appreciated how the author portrayed emotional vulnerability and physical intimacy with such care and realism.
The writing style was lyrical and steady. Even though the story isn’t packed with angst or heavy drama, it never felt dull. The dialogue flowed effortlessly and felt genuine, which made it easy to stay invested.
Overall, this is the perfect read for the holiday season. It’s tender, heartwarming, and filled with moments that made me swoon. The cozy vibes and emotional depth had me eagerly turning the pages, rooting for Whitley and Layla the whole way. Honestly, it was just that good. 🎄💖
Once Upon a Time in December is a cozy and lighthearted strangers-to-lovers romance where Whitley and Layla meet every year at Whitley’s family gala. Through these yearly encounters, we get to see their friendship gradually bloom into something deeper and more meaningful.
Whitley, part of the wealthy Dupont family, is the eldest sister and heir to her family’s empire. She’s a bit of a perfectionist—driven, responsible, and always striving to meet expectations. Even though she grew up surrounded by privilege, she’s incredibly humble and spends her time helping kids from orphanages and supporting underrepresented groups. I really liked seeing her step out of her comfort zone and focus on her own happiness for once. Watching her grow more confident and learn to value herself beyond her work was truly rewarding. Then there’s Layla—an absolute sweetheart and a total force of nature. I loved how supportive she was of Whitley’s sapphic awakening and how patient and respectful she remained throughout their journey. She was such a genuine, memorable character.
The romance itself was just beautiful. Their first meeting felt like a scene straight out of a movie—romantic, warm, and sincere. From the start, their chemistry was undeniable and only grew stronger as the story unfolded. The slow burn was perfectly executed; nothing ever felt rushed. Instead, their bond was built on friendship first, which made their eventual romantic connection feel even more authentic. The “toaster oven” moment was handled so naturally, and I appreciated how the author portrayed emotional vulnerability and physical intimacy with such care and realism.
The writing style was lyrical and steady. Even though the story isn’t packed with angst or heavy drama, it never felt dull. The dialogue flowed effortlessly and felt genuine, which made it easy to stay invested.
Overall, this is the perfect read for the holiday season. It’s tender, heartwarming, and filled with moments that made me swoon. The cozy vibes and emotional depth had me eagerly turning the pages, rooting for Whitley and Layla the whole way. Honestly, it was just that good. 🎄💖
October 30, 2025
Whew Alyson you have out done yourself with this book! I loved every part from start to finish!
Layla is a breath of fresh air. Whitley was so open and could go toe to toe with Layla. The supportive cast were interesting and unique, from the members of the quartet to the twin siblings, offering commentary and shenanigans. Both Layla’s and Whitley’s parents were just amazing and everything you would want to have and/or be for parenting. The DuPont’s are the wealthy of the wealthy and let me just say the way they behave in both business and personal relationships and situations is how every one of that status (everyone really but especially the extreme wealthy) should strive for, in all aspects including active philanthropy and care for others in so many ways. It was a true pleasure to read this story. Highly recommend!
Layla is a breath of fresh air. Whitley was so open and could go toe to toe with Layla. The supportive cast were interesting and unique, from the members of the quartet to the twin siblings, offering commentary and shenanigans. Both Layla’s and Whitley’s parents were just amazing and everything you would want to have and/or be for parenting. The DuPont’s are the wealthy of the wealthy and let me just say the way they behave in both business and personal relationships and situations is how every one of that status (everyone really but especially the extreme wealthy) should strive for, in all aspects including active philanthropy and care for others in so many ways. It was a true pleasure to read this story. Highly recommend!
Read
November 4, 2025I understand why she was driven to that point, but I have a hard time rooting for a main character who literally assaults her ex in the first two chapters.
November 3, 2025
A cracker of a start!
I was too busy reading to make many notes, but I did take note of the smile that barely left my face reading this perfect holiday book.
No angst, no drama but a story that I loved reading every word of!
I was too busy reading to make many notes, but I did take note of the smile that barely left my face reading this perfect holiday book.
No angst, no drama but a story that I loved reading every word of!
November 2, 2025
such a sweet story!!
i loved reading this one, because it brought such tender feelings. the storyline of the gala, whitley’s characterization (her heartbreak at being rejected by that douche), layla’s bluntness and music aspirations all interwove with the holiday atmosphere so well to create a whimsical but straightforward love story.
watching layla’s chaos endear whitley and whitley’s sweetness hold thrall over layla was so rewarding. “i am home, whit.” - and the ending was, of course, so cute and a good show of how their happiness will continue beyond the pages.
i loved reading this one, because it brought such tender feelings. the storyline of the gala, whitley’s characterization (her heartbreak at being rejected by that douche), layla’s bluntness and music aspirations all interwove with the holiday atmosphere so well to create a whimsical but straightforward love story.
watching layla’s chaos endear whitley and whitley’s sweetness hold thrall over layla was so rewarding. “i am home, whit.” - and the ending was, of course, so cute and a good show of how their happiness will continue beyond the pages.
November 8, 2025
🏳️🌈Rep: Sapphic, Lesbian FMC, Queer FMC, Queer SCs
📝Tropes/Themes: Rich/Poor, Strangers to Friends to Lovers, Femme/Femme, Toaster Oven, Quirky Characters, No Third Act Breakup, Coming Out, Holiday Fun
What a truly delightful start to my holiday reading for the year! This was such a fun, lighthearted read filled with whimsy and wonder from start to finish!
After a heart wrenching denial to a very public proposal, Whitley Dupont’s polished and professional veneer begins to crack. And after further public humiliation by the person she was ready to marry, it completely shatters. Also very publicly. I mean…what a start to a book! But this proposal gone wrong leads to one of the best, most romantic meet-cutes imaginable!
Layla Simmons was already admiring the attractive woman before the spectacles began from her perch with the quartet providing music for the Dupont’s gala that evening. So when she stumbles across her in the alley after the event hurling Christmas ornaments with unconcealed rage and anguish, she can’t help but feel pulled into her orbit. Who needs sleep when you can have a late night hot chocolate with a gorgeous woman and maybe provide her a little comfort?
Flash forward a year and both women find themselves once again at the gala, and a tradition is forged. But is what’s sparking between them simply friendship? Or is there something more building in their connection? As far as Layla knows, Whitley is straight as can be. In fact, that’s what Whitley thought too. But she can’t deny the more than friendly feelings she begins to have for this stranger-turned-friend.
I absolutely ADORE both Layla and Whitley. Layla is quirky and a little brash and outspoken and just genuinely such a heart-on-her-sleeve, wonderful human being. Whitley also has this incredibly beautiful soul, but is completely opposite in other ways. She doesn’t speak her mind. She does what she’s told, she goes where she’s needed, and she never puts herself first. Not until Layla anyway.
I love the way Alyson chose to tell this story. The main story takes place over 3 years, but the majority happens in December each year. Between the second and third December, we get more glimpses into what transpires during the year leading up to that third Gala. We get to see Whitley coming to terms with how she is feeling toward Layla and what she wants. We get to see Layla coming even more into herself and sharing her music in new ways. And we get a really freaking hilarious and adorable scene with a trifle in a club that still has me smiling!
That third December though! Ugh! The chemistry between these two! And the way they navigate the newness of their relationship and care for one another. It was utter perfection. They are SO GOOD TOGETHER! I love that neither of them tries to change the other. That Whitley doesn’t try to convince Layla to stop busking or try to "take away" her money problems. Whitley may be rich and have all the finest things money can buy, but Layla’s life is no less extravagant and fills her with such joy. They simply accept each other as they are and celebrate each other and care for one another and it’s pure loveliness.
I also love the rest of Layla’s quartet, Whitley’s whole family, Layla’s parents, the kids in the choir - just so many wonderful characters who add richness and beauty to an already magnificent story. Also, I REALLY need to find/go to/create a steampunk Alice in Wonderland winter themed party of some sort now. Just saying. And the chapter titles were just as whimsical as the story itself!
If you are looking for a lighthearted, heartwarming, low angst holiday romance - look no further! This book is like a warm mug of hot chocolate on a cold winter night with the best company you could ask for.
I received an ARC from the author and this is my honest and voluntary review.
⚠️TW/CW: Sexual Content, infidelity (not by an MC), public rejection, minor accident/injury (SC - no graphic details), discussions of homelessness and poverty
📝Tropes/Themes: Rich/Poor, Strangers to Friends to Lovers, Femme/Femme, Toaster Oven, Quirky Characters, No Third Act Breakup, Coming Out, Holiday Fun
What a truly delightful start to my holiday reading for the year! This was such a fun, lighthearted read filled with whimsy and wonder from start to finish!
After a heart wrenching denial to a very public proposal, Whitley Dupont’s polished and professional veneer begins to crack. And after further public humiliation by the person she was ready to marry, it completely shatters. Also very publicly. I mean…what a start to a book! But this proposal gone wrong leads to one of the best, most romantic meet-cutes imaginable!
Layla Simmons was already admiring the attractive woman before the spectacles began from her perch with the quartet providing music for the Dupont’s gala that evening. So when she stumbles across her in the alley after the event hurling Christmas ornaments with unconcealed rage and anguish, she can’t help but feel pulled into her orbit. Who needs sleep when you can have a late night hot chocolate with a gorgeous woman and maybe provide her a little comfort?
Flash forward a year and both women find themselves once again at the gala, and a tradition is forged. But is what’s sparking between them simply friendship? Or is there something more building in their connection? As far as Layla knows, Whitley is straight as can be. In fact, that’s what Whitley thought too. But she can’t deny the more than friendly feelings she begins to have for this stranger-turned-friend.
I absolutely ADORE both Layla and Whitley. Layla is quirky and a little brash and outspoken and just genuinely such a heart-on-her-sleeve, wonderful human being. Whitley also has this incredibly beautiful soul, but is completely opposite in other ways. She doesn’t speak her mind. She does what she’s told, she goes where she’s needed, and she never puts herself first. Not until Layla anyway.
I love the way Alyson chose to tell this story. The main story takes place over 3 years, but the majority happens in December each year. Between the second and third December, we get more glimpses into what transpires during the year leading up to that third Gala. We get to see Whitley coming to terms with how she is feeling toward Layla and what she wants. We get to see Layla coming even more into herself and sharing her music in new ways. And we get a really freaking hilarious and adorable scene with a trifle in a club that still has me smiling!
That third December though! Ugh! The chemistry between these two! And the way they navigate the newness of their relationship and care for one another. It was utter perfection. They are SO GOOD TOGETHER! I love that neither of them tries to change the other. That Whitley doesn’t try to convince Layla to stop busking or try to "take away" her money problems. Whitley may be rich and have all the finest things money can buy, but Layla’s life is no less extravagant and fills her with such joy. They simply accept each other as they are and celebrate each other and care for one another and it’s pure loveliness.
I also love the rest of Layla’s quartet, Whitley’s whole family, Layla’s parents, the kids in the choir - just so many wonderful characters who add richness and beauty to an already magnificent story. Also, I REALLY need to find/go to/create a steampunk Alice in Wonderland winter themed party of some sort now. Just saying. And the chapter titles were just as whimsical as the story itself!
If you are looking for a lighthearted, heartwarming, low angst holiday romance - look no further! This book is like a warm mug of hot chocolate on a cold winter night with the best company you could ask for.
I received an ARC from the author and this is my honest and voluntary review.
⚠️TW/CW: Sexual Content, infidelity (not by an MC), public rejection, minor accident/injury (SC - no graphic details), discussions of homelessness and poverty
October 27, 2025
the dupont family always host a christmas party and every year its has a fantastic turnout. This year though everyone will remember the proposal that was turned down....
poor whitley she was on bended knee with a hopeful expression that soon crumbled when she was turned down and so the band carried on playing even though everyone was more interested in the main event....
lyla was the violinist and could see the drama enfolding so she played her heart out even though she couldnt believe what she had witnessed...
after the event was ending the rest of the band went out clubbing but lyla was tired and needed to rest and after a toilet break she found herself locked in.... panicking slightly but not to concerned she found a back exit and walked out whereupon she found whitley taking her anger out on the christmas baubles she had been thoroughly embarrassed again by her supposedly boyfriend when it turned out he had stayed after the humilating scene and had also stayed beyond his time with a girlfriend he had in line... where upon whitley had lost it all and had thrown the christmas baubles at him and then had him forcefully removed... again stopping the evening entertainment by becoming the entertainment
but now whitley didnt have any witnesses and was taking her anger out on the whole christmas debacle
and the start of a friendship formed with the agreement of a hot chocolate on a cold day in new york
they were from two different worlds lyla loved music and played her violin her way and her love of busking know no bounds and whitley was a dupont who came from money, but she worked for her fathers company and was one day going to take over there were a lot of expectations on her
ohhh this storyline has it all... and I loved how most of the book was centred around christmas over the years
my one laugh was thinking I hope all americans dont think all english people talk like that... I did laugh at some of lyla one liners and slightly missed marks but then again if everyone thinks dick van dyke portrayal of bert in mary poppins was right then no wonder lyla was written that way
will be looking out for more of this authors books as I thoroughly enjoyed this book and the christmasy feel good factor ohh and the spice was nice as well
poor whitley she was on bended knee with a hopeful expression that soon crumbled when she was turned down and so the band carried on playing even though everyone was more interested in the main event....
lyla was the violinist and could see the drama enfolding so she played her heart out even though she couldnt believe what she had witnessed...
after the event was ending the rest of the band went out clubbing but lyla was tired and needed to rest and after a toilet break she found herself locked in.... panicking slightly but not to concerned she found a back exit and walked out whereupon she found whitley taking her anger out on the christmas baubles she had been thoroughly embarrassed again by her supposedly boyfriend when it turned out he had stayed after the humilating scene and had also stayed beyond his time with a girlfriend he had in line... where upon whitley had lost it all and had thrown the christmas baubles at him and then had him forcefully removed... again stopping the evening entertainment by becoming the entertainment
but now whitley didnt have any witnesses and was taking her anger out on the whole christmas debacle
and the start of a friendship formed with the agreement of a hot chocolate on a cold day in new york
they were from two different worlds lyla loved music and played her violin her way and her love of busking know no bounds and whitley was a dupont who came from money, but she worked for her fathers company and was one day going to take over there were a lot of expectations on her
ohhh this storyline has it all... and I loved how most of the book was centred around christmas over the years
my one laugh was thinking I hope all americans dont think all english people talk like that... I did laugh at some of lyla one liners and slightly missed marks but then again if everyone thinks dick van dyke portrayal of bert in mary poppins was right then no wonder lyla was written that way
will be looking out for more of this authors books as I thoroughly enjoyed this book and the christmasy feel good factor ohh and the spice was nice as well
October 30, 2025
💫Arc Review - release date Nov 3rd
THIS is genuinely such a beautiful book!
It gives all the cosy warm vibes needed for a wonderful Christmas story.
Makes you want to be wrapped up in their warmth for each other. You can literally feel the festive glow of the twinkling lights, Christmas tree smells, taste of hot chocolate and the
kindness we all seem to feel more this time for year.
Whitley DuPont has just had THE worst embarrassing moment of her life by the one person who is supposed to love her more than anyone else.
Layla Simmons has just witnessed it all play out, along with a room full of people at a Christmas party, whilst she and her friends provide the music with their quartet.
Layla is adorable, quirky and kind. When she finds Whitley releasing her pent-up anger and frustration in an alley out back of the very posh establishment, Layla can’t stand the idea of leaving her there so upset.
The two head off together to a diner for hot chocolate and much needed honest chat with a stranger for Whitley.
Whitley has a warmth and friendliness to her that draws Layla in.
To be fair I wouldn’t be able to say whom I liked more.Normally I could pick out one MC being more for me than the other
Not with these two!
After their first meeting they part ways for a whole year and when Christmas comes around again Layla is back, playing her beautiful music for another charity event held by the DuPont’s.
They still find each other funny, attractive and the spark is most definitely alive and kicking!
However, Poor Whitley must go away to London for a YEAR! To help set up a charity run by her family.
They finally swap numbers, and Whitley decides to take this time to work out her feelings for the quirky, beautiful, talented musician as she’s never been attracted to women before.
Layla thinks she has no chance as Whit is straight! But wants her friendship
We have the perfect side characters to help Whitley figure out her feelings with her Twin sister and brother .. Aubrey & William…They offer their own perfectly timed lines and moments in the story.
The chemistry is off the charts with these two!
I'm utterly in love with Layla and Whitley!!
THIS is genuinely such a beautiful book!
It gives all the cosy warm vibes needed for a wonderful Christmas story.
Makes you want to be wrapped up in their warmth for each other. You can literally feel the festive glow of the twinkling lights, Christmas tree smells, taste of hot chocolate and the
kindness we all seem to feel more this time for year.
Whitley DuPont has just had THE worst embarrassing moment of her life by the one person who is supposed to love her more than anyone else.
Layla Simmons has just witnessed it all play out, along with a room full of people at a Christmas party, whilst she and her friends provide the music with their quartet.
Layla is adorable, quirky and kind. When she finds Whitley releasing her pent-up anger and frustration in an alley out back of the very posh establishment, Layla can’t stand the idea of leaving her there so upset.
The two head off together to a diner for hot chocolate and much needed honest chat with a stranger for Whitley.
Whitley has a warmth and friendliness to her that draws Layla in.
To be fair I wouldn’t be able to say whom I liked more.Normally I could pick out one MC being more for me than the other
Not with these two!
After their first meeting they part ways for a whole year and when Christmas comes around again Layla is back, playing her beautiful music for another charity event held by the DuPont’s.
They still find each other funny, attractive and the spark is most definitely alive and kicking!
However, Poor Whitley must go away to London for a YEAR! To help set up a charity run by her family.
They finally swap numbers, and Whitley decides to take this time to work out her feelings for the quirky, beautiful, talented musician as she’s never been attracted to women before.
Layla thinks she has no chance as Whit is straight! But wants her friendship
We have the perfect side characters to help Whitley figure out her feelings with her Twin sister and brother .. Aubrey & William…They offer their own perfectly timed lines and moments in the story.
The chemistry is off the charts with these two!
I'm utterly in love with Layla and Whitley!!
October 31, 2025
In Once Upon a Time in December, Alyson Root has delivered a wonderful story about self discovery, sexual awakening and finding your person in the most expected places, all centred around Christmas. I absolutely fell in love with Whitley and Layla from the moment I met them, felt Whitley’s pain from the failed proposal and absolutely adored the way that Layla helped to pick her up and help her find her way.
The two women are so very different with Whitley growing up as an heiress in a very wealthy family, working in finance and managing fundraising galas on behalf of her family. Meanwhile, Layla grew up in a middle-class British Family where she fell into playing the Violin, eventually moving to the US, sharing a small apartment with three fellow musicians while busking and seeking out gigs to keep a roof overhead and the cupboards stocked with ramen noodles.
After witnessing the disastrous proposal while playing at the gala and then witnessing Whitley’s subsequent breakdown Layla helps her to pick herself up and a friendship is quickly formed. Little does Whitley realise at the time, just how much this new friendship is going to rock her world despite long gaps between seeing each other over the first couple of years with the two women initially only seeing each other at the annual Christmas gala.
One of the aspects of this story that I really loved were the two women’s families who were just delightful. I particularly loved Whitley’s twin brother and sister and the role they played in helping to bring these two wonderful women together.
Once Upon a Time in December was definitely a 5-star read for me and I would definitely recommend it to anyone looking for a heartwarming, low-angst, Christmas-centric story full of wonderfully accepting family. Do yourself a favour and check it out.
I am grateful to Alyson Root for providing me with an ARC copy of Once Upon a Time in December and am leaving this review voluntarily.
The two women are so very different with Whitley growing up as an heiress in a very wealthy family, working in finance and managing fundraising galas on behalf of her family. Meanwhile, Layla grew up in a middle-class British Family where she fell into playing the Violin, eventually moving to the US, sharing a small apartment with three fellow musicians while busking and seeking out gigs to keep a roof overhead and the cupboards stocked with ramen noodles.
After witnessing the disastrous proposal while playing at the gala and then witnessing Whitley’s subsequent breakdown Layla helps her to pick herself up and a friendship is quickly formed. Little does Whitley realise at the time, just how much this new friendship is going to rock her world despite long gaps between seeing each other over the first couple of years with the two women initially only seeing each other at the annual Christmas gala.
One of the aspects of this story that I really loved were the two women’s families who were just delightful. I particularly loved Whitley’s twin brother and sister and the role they played in helping to bring these two wonderful women together.
Once Upon a Time in December was definitely a 5-star read for me and I would definitely recommend it to anyone looking for a heartwarming, low-angst, Christmas-centric story full of wonderfully accepting family. Do yourself a favour and check it out.
I am grateful to Alyson Root for providing me with an ARC copy of Once Upon a Time in December and am leaving this review voluntarily.
November 7, 2025
In Once Upon a Time in December by Alyson Root, we meet Layla Simmons and Whitley Dupont. Layla, a whimsical violinist, witnesses a very public proposal denial and a following breakdown, and does what she can to make Whitley’s evening just a tiny bit better. Bonding over a cup of hot chocolate, not knowing it will go another full year before they meet again. Neither forgetting about the other during their time apart, always feeling that pull towards each other, no matter the distance☕️
I absolutely loved following both these characters on their respective journeys. Layla, as she works and develops her career as a violinist, both with and without help from Whitley. And Whitley, who is slowly realizing that she is not quite who she thought she was, and we get to tag along on her journey of self-discovery🎇
The side characters we meet, come in all shapes and sizes, and every single one of them adds something to the story, just a little bit of extra colour. From Layla’s parents and her musician friends to Whitley’s richer-than-god family (who is a breath of fresh air, not being the uptight snobs you’d often expect)☃️
This is such an amazing slow-burn romance (we’re talking years in the making), a story of self-discovery, family drama, and development, both professional and personal. A low angst romance that will have you giggling and kicking your feet, blushing (the spice is 🥵), as well as tear up🎄
I have read a few of Alyson’s novels, and they have yet to disappoint me. This one has sailed right into second place of my favourite novels by Alyson, with Sleigh Bells Ring still on first place (which will honestly be very difficult to beat)💁🏼♀️
I absolutely loved following both these characters on their respective journeys. Layla, as she works and develops her career as a violinist, both with and without help from Whitley. And Whitley, who is slowly realizing that she is not quite who she thought she was, and we get to tag along on her journey of self-discovery🎇
The side characters we meet, come in all shapes and sizes, and every single one of them adds something to the story, just a little bit of extra colour. From Layla’s parents and her musician friends to Whitley’s richer-than-god family (who is a breath of fresh air, not being the uptight snobs you’d often expect)☃️
This is such an amazing slow-burn romance (we’re talking years in the making), a story of self-discovery, family drama, and development, both professional and personal. A low angst romance that will have you giggling and kicking your feet, blushing (the spice is 🥵), as well as tear up🎄
I have read a few of Alyson’s novels, and they have yet to disappoint me. This one has sailed right into second place of my favourite novels by Alyson, with Sleigh Bells Ring still on first place (which will honestly be very difficult to beat)💁🏼♀️
November 7, 2025
Whitney proposed to her boyfriend... only to get turned down AND to find out they were interested in someone else. And then she sees the two together, and finally loses it.
Violinist Layla was there providing music and saw it all go down. Once they get paid she leaves via a side door, stumbling over Whitney throwing stuff at a wall. Befriending her, they go to a choir run by the homeless and drink cocoa at a café.
Whitney discusses her woes, and Layla points out he might be trying to take her for a ride. She realizes that's probably so, and thanks her.
One year later they meet again, and sadly Whitney has another a-hole boyfriend, Steven. Whom Layla tells off, him being a obnoxious drunk. Whitney dumps him and takes Layla home for hot chocolate, and they spend a enjoyable evening together. Nothing happens, but she realizes she's attracted to Layla.
(Layla has been into her from the start, but assumes she's straight.)
Complicating matters, Whitney needs to go out of the country for work... they meet again on the next Christmas, and Whitney asks Layla out.
I loved that Whitney 's brother and sister actively ships them, and when her mom and dad find out, they're all for it. And Layla's parents instantly support them too.
Wrap up, good conclusion.
4 out of 5 stars
Violinist Layla was there providing music and saw it all go down. Once they get paid she leaves via a side door, stumbling over Whitney throwing stuff at a wall. Befriending her, they go to a choir run by the homeless and drink cocoa at a café.
Whitney discusses her woes, and Layla points out he might be trying to take her for a ride. She realizes that's probably so, and thanks her.
One year later they meet again, and sadly Whitney has another a-hole boyfriend, Steven. Whom Layla tells off, him being a obnoxious drunk. Whitney dumps him and takes Layla home for hot chocolate, and they spend a enjoyable evening together. Nothing happens, but she realizes she's attracted to Layla.
(Layla has been into her from the start, but assumes she's straight.)
Complicating matters, Whitney needs to go out of the country for work... they meet again on the next Christmas, and Whitney asks Layla out.
I loved that Whitney 's brother and sister actively ships them, and when her mom and dad find out, they're all for it. And Layla's parents instantly support them too.
Wrap up, good conclusion.
4 out of 5 stars
October 27, 2025
*Thank you to the author for this ARC in exchange for an honest review.*
I loved this story. I loved everything about it. It had everything I wanted in a holiday book and honestly, there's a good chance I will read it again before the holiday season is over. Now listen, if you want angst and drama and third act breakups, this book is NOT for you. This is possibly the lowest-angst book I've ever read and I loved every second.
Sometimes you just want to be happy through the entire journey of a story, and this book gave me exactly that. Am I now slightly obsessed with Lindsey Stirling’s music and performances after reading this story? Possibly. Do I care? Nope. I fell in love with both characters, and that's unusual for me. I usually prefer one over the other, but both of these characters just dug into my heart. Layla is the best kind of chaos with the biggest heart and Whitley had every reason to be a snob given her privilege, but her and her entire family were just perfect. The whole cast of side characters were well developed and really added to the overall story. This is my second book by Alyson Root and I loved this one even more than the last. The story was fun and emotional and festive and it was just perfect for what i needed right now.
I loved this story. I loved everything about it. It had everything I wanted in a holiday book and honestly, there's a good chance I will read it again before the holiday season is over. Now listen, if you want angst and drama and third act breakups, this book is NOT for you. This is possibly the lowest-angst book I've ever read and I loved every second.
Sometimes you just want to be happy through the entire journey of a story, and this book gave me exactly that. Am I now slightly obsessed with Lindsey Stirling’s music and performances after reading this story? Possibly. Do I care? Nope. I fell in love with both characters, and that's unusual for me. I usually prefer one over the other, but both of these characters just dug into my heart. Layla is the best kind of chaos with the biggest heart and Whitley had every reason to be a snob given her privilege, but her and her entire family were just perfect. The whole cast of side characters were well developed and really added to the overall story. This is my second book by Alyson Root and I loved this one even more than the last. The story was fun and emotional and festive and it was just perfect for what i needed right now.
November 4, 2025
Review ARC provided by Netgalley
Although I see the appeal, this particular type of romance wasn't my favorite. It follows a rich heiress, Whitney, and a violinist, Layla. They get crushes, fall in love, the works, with a lot of it themed around Christmas.
The characters weren't horrible, but they felt a little bit juvenile, strangely enough. I was surprised when they were both said to be 30+. Some people act differently though, so it wasn't too bad
The writing was fine, but I noticed a few terms pop up a few times in a way that was distracting, and the quick overview of what happened for the second time skip kind of threw me off. It leaned overly fluffy, with the main characters and their families being universally kind and class not really being touched on. They're silly points, but I think I'm too cynical for these sorts of books
This book also contains lemon/open door scenes as I believe they're called. There is quite a bit of it, which caught me quite off guard because I'm not used to kissing books.
Overall, it was cute and silly, but not really my thing. Certain types of readers would certainly get a kick out of this book though.
Although I see the appeal, this particular type of romance wasn't my favorite. It follows a rich heiress, Whitney, and a violinist, Layla. They get crushes, fall in love, the works, with a lot of it themed around Christmas.
The characters weren't horrible, but they felt a little bit juvenile, strangely enough. I was surprised when they were both said to be 30+. Some people act differently though, so it wasn't too bad
The writing was fine, but I noticed a few terms pop up a few times in a way that was distracting, and the quick overview of what happened for the second time skip kind of threw me off. It leaned overly fluffy, with the main characters and their families being universally kind and class not really being touched on. They're silly points, but I think I'm too cynical for these sorts of books
This book also contains lemon/open door scenes as I believe they're called. There is quite a bit of it, which caught me quite off guard because I'm not used to kissing books.
Overall, it was cute and silly, but not really my thing. Certain types of readers would certainly get a kick out of this book though.
November 9, 2025
First and foremost, Once Upon a Time in December only further solidified that I am, in fact, VERY into women. 😂 I got a digital copy from Netgalley, and it was my first time reading any e-book! The experience wasn't bad, but it did hurt my eyes a bit. I absolutely loved it.5 out of 5 stars!
When I tell you, I DEVOURED this book! It was my first time reading a WLW story, and... why have I never read one before now??? Definitely need to read more! AND, it switched POV's! Ugh, so good!
The book was so silly, and it made it so enjoyable! The way things were being described was iconic, and the fun title names continued to keep me guessing! There were so many incredibly funny, out of pocket moments that left me laughing!
Both of the FMCs were amazing! Layla is a blunt, entertaining, musician who's an absolute queen. She also had purple highlights in her hair! That's always the sign of an icon (I had purple hair for a while lol). Whitley is more reserved, wealthy, and we followed her journey of discovering herself and falling in love.
I'd recommend Once Upon a Time in December! It was adorable, funny, and contains characters that are impossible not to fall in love with.
When I tell you, I DEVOURED this book! It was my first time reading a WLW story, and... why have I never read one before now??? Definitely need to read more! AND, it switched POV's! Ugh, so good!
The book was so silly, and it made it so enjoyable! The way things were being described was iconic, and the fun title names continued to keep me guessing! There were so many incredibly funny, out of pocket moments that left me laughing!
Both of the FMCs were amazing! Layla is a blunt, entertaining, musician who's an absolute queen. She also had purple highlights in her hair! That's always the sign of an icon (I had purple hair for a while lol). Whitley is more reserved, wealthy, and we followed her journey of discovering herself and falling in love.
I'd recommend Once Upon a Time in December! It was adorable, funny, and contains characters that are impossible not to fall in love with.
October 29, 2025
Once Upon A Time In December- Alyson Root
I thought Alyson Root’s Christmas offering of Sleigh Bells Ring last year was amazing but with Once Upon A Time In December she has managed to once again knock it out of the park!
If this story doesn’t give you the warm Christmas fuzzies then I don’t know what will.
Layla and Whitley first meet in December under unusual circumstances and particularly difficult ones for Whitley!!
Layla is quirky, forthright and a talented violinist, Whitley a serious senior executive in the family business - chalk and cheese you could say!
Whitley and Layla’s journey is heartwarming, funny, sexy and joyful.
As I’m not a writer I can’t truly put into words how much I enjoyed going on this journey of discovery with them and their equally wonderful supporting cast of family and friends.
If you only read one ‘Christmas’ romance this year then this should be it!!
Thanks to Alyson Root for the ARC. This review was freely and gratefully left.
Can’t wait to get the paperback to add to my collection!!
I thought Alyson Root’s Christmas offering of Sleigh Bells Ring last year was amazing but with Once Upon A Time In December she has managed to once again knock it out of the park!
If this story doesn’t give you the warm Christmas fuzzies then I don’t know what will.
Layla and Whitley first meet in December under unusual circumstances and particularly difficult ones for Whitley!!
Layla is quirky, forthright and a talented violinist, Whitley a serious senior executive in the family business - chalk and cheese you could say!
Whitley and Layla’s journey is heartwarming, funny, sexy and joyful.
As I’m not a writer I can’t truly put into words how much I enjoyed going on this journey of discovery with them and their equally wonderful supporting cast of family and friends.
If you only read one ‘Christmas’ romance this year then this should be it!!
Thanks to Alyson Root for the ARC. This review was freely and gratefully left.
Can’t wait to get the paperback to add to my collection!!
October 29, 2025
Such a sweet and warm love story. Like a fairytale!
But it isn't a fairytale, it's definitely set in the here and now!
That's just how it felt while reading.
Before I started reading, I read a review that said both characters were equally lovable this time, and it's true.
Normally, i root for a main character, but here, Alyson Root has created two magical and beautiful women who, despite their complete opposites, are perfect for each other.
A story that flows along and is so lovely to read, with no major breakups in the third act, etc.
They have it tough enough and are separated enough, but it's a strong love, wonderfully accompanied by the best sounds in the world.
The music, like their love, is at the forefront, because Layla is music, chaos, and love.
Whitley is exactly the haven where this tempestuous love finds its home.
An exceptionally beautiful Christmas love story! Many thanks to Alyson Root.
Thanks so much for the ARC!
But it isn't a fairytale, it's definitely set in the here and now!
That's just how it felt while reading.
Before I started reading, I read a review that said both characters were equally lovable this time, and it's true.
Normally, i root for a main character, but here, Alyson Root has created two magical and beautiful women who, despite their complete opposites, are perfect for each other.
A story that flows along and is so lovely to read, with no major breakups in the third act, etc.
They have it tough enough and are separated enough, but it's a strong love, wonderfully accompanied by the best sounds in the world.
The music, like their love, is at the forefront, because Layla is music, chaos, and love.
Whitley is exactly the haven where this tempestuous love finds its home.
An exceptionally beautiful Christmas love story! Many thanks to Alyson Root.
Thanks so much for the ARC!
November 7, 2025
Once Upon a Time in December had me hooked since the first ornament was launched. I DEVOURED this book in just a few hours, I just couldn’t put it down.
This is my first Alyson Root read and I’m going back to read everything else that I can if they’re all like this.
Layla and Whitley’s opposites attract, reunite once a year in December dynamic was wonderful. The chemistry from the first meeting was insane, Whitley discovering her feelings and taking the time to actually ponder on them before taking action knowing that the most important thing between them was the friendship they had built. I loved Layla’s free spirit and adaptability to any situation but knowing when to draw boundaries in the topics that truly matter to her. Truly a beautiful love story.
I love stories in which families are unconditionally supportive and the incredibly wealthy are actually decent people.
Thank you to Alyson Root for providing me with an ARC, can’t wait to read she publishes next.
This is my first Alyson Root read and I’m going back to read everything else that I can if they’re all like this.
Layla and Whitley’s opposites attract, reunite once a year in December dynamic was wonderful. The chemistry from the first meeting was insane, Whitley discovering her feelings and taking the time to actually ponder on them before taking action knowing that the most important thing between them was the friendship they had built. I loved Layla’s free spirit and adaptability to any situation but knowing when to draw boundaries in the topics that truly matter to her. Truly a beautiful love story.
I love stories in which families are unconditionally supportive and the incredibly wealthy are actually decent people.
Thank you to Alyson Root for providing me with an ARC, can’t wait to read she publishes next.
November 9, 2025
Disclaimer: I received a free copy of this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
I liked this one, it's very cute and extremely low angst! If you're looking for a sapphic Christmas romance filled with yearning, and a lot of sweet moments this is a good choice.
Both characters are very into each other right from the start, and they are straightforward about how much they mean to one another.
Although there are some time jumps, there isn't really a break in the relationship, things continue to progress between them as if no time has passed. Their relationship really takes precedence above all else in this book.
There's also a lot of meeting the family and friends scenes, with some very silly encounters.
Finally, there was quite a bit of spice in this story, more than I was expecting!
Overall, this is a very cozy Christmas book, with a sweet sapphic relationship at the heart. 4.4/5 stars
I liked this one, it's very cute and extremely low angst! If you're looking for a sapphic Christmas romance filled with yearning, and a lot of sweet moments this is a good choice.
Both characters are very into each other right from the start, and they are straightforward about how much they mean to one another.
Although there are some time jumps, there isn't really a break in the relationship, things continue to progress between them as if no time has passed. Their relationship really takes precedence above all else in this book.
There's also a lot of meeting the family and friends scenes, with some very silly encounters.
Finally, there was quite a bit of spice in this story, more than I was expecting!
Overall, this is a very cozy Christmas book, with a sweet sapphic relationship at the heart. 4.4/5 stars
November 9, 2025
Thoroughly enjoyed the story as a whole, but the final, HEA chapter was a bit weird for me. It makes zero sense why Layla waited 4 years to propose to Whitley, and it felt a bit of a contrived reason to keep them apart, even though those four years were just mentioned in a summary. Almost like the author wanted to create more angst (or set up a possible sequel...) before wrapping up the story. I think postponing the engagement would make more sense if the characters were in their mid-twenties and still figuring out life, but they were mid-30s when Layla went on tour, knowing they both wanted marriage and children. Or maybe not give their ages at all? It just felt like the timing was weird, like Laya couldn't fully commit to Whitley while also growing her career, so Whitley had to wait her turn.
I will probably read it again, but imo the ending would have been better if they found a way to get married and support each other as they pursued success in their respective careers.
I will probably read it again, but imo the ending would have been better if they found a way to get married and support each other as they pursued success in their respective careers.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
November 5, 2025
perfect Christmas story..
Two women from different worlds. Whitley the successor to the DuPont legacy had a knack for picking lousy boyfriends(understatement). The worst made a scene at the family’s annual Christmas charity event. Whitley snapped when after proposing (his idea) he said no, left and reappeared with his new girlfriend that apparently he’d been seeing on the side. Who wouldn’t snap.
Whitley was taking out her frustration throwing Christmas bobbles against the outside wall when Layla found her. Layla and her group had just played the music for the event. Noticing and understanding Whitley’s reaction she invites her for a cup of hot chocolate. Surprisingly the two have an instant connection. The story takes you through their friendship to relationship.
Definitely a Christmas winner..
Two women from different worlds. Whitley the successor to the DuPont legacy had a knack for picking lousy boyfriends(understatement). The worst made a scene at the family’s annual Christmas charity event. Whitley snapped when after proposing (his idea) he said no, left and reappeared with his new girlfriend that apparently he’d been seeing on the side. Who wouldn’t snap.
Whitley was taking out her frustration throwing Christmas bobbles against the outside wall when Layla found her. Layla and her group had just played the music for the event. Noticing and understanding Whitley’s reaction she invites her for a cup of hot chocolate. Surprisingly the two have an instant connection. The story takes you through their friendship to relationship.
Definitely a Christmas winner..
October 30, 2025
I was accepted by Alyson Root to be a part of the ARC team for Once Upon A Time In December and below is my honest review.
Alyson.. you’ve done it again 😍 what a book! A perfect little Christmassy, cosy sapphic read.
Layla and Whitley are written so beautifully, I loved them both. Their story is realistic and so heartwarming.
The chapter names are iconic too, honourable mention to ‘Mistletoe & Meltdown’ 😂
There’s one scene where they are reunited at a fundraising gala and I had actual goosebumps. It was so well written and it’s sprinkled with a generous amount of spice!
I recommend this to anyone who loves sapphic, cosy romance.
I give this 5 stars!
Thank you Alyson for asking me to read and review!
Alyson.. you’ve done it again 😍 what a book! A perfect little Christmassy, cosy sapphic read.
Layla and Whitley are written so beautifully, I loved them both. Their story is realistic and so heartwarming.
The chapter names are iconic too, honourable mention to ‘Mistletoe & Meltdown’ 😂
There’s one scene where they are reunited at a fundraising gala and I had actual goosebumps. It was so well written and it’s sprinkled with a generous amount of spice!
I recommend this to anyone who loves sapphic, cosy romance.
I give this 5 stars!
Thank you Alyson for asking me to read and review!
November 6, 2025
Whitley + Layla
-sapphic romance
-holiday romance
-opposites attract
-violinist x financier
-second chance encounter
okokok first off...this was like zero angst...no third act break up...there was no drama...& i know when it comes to me..this will come to a surprise when you see i rated this a soliddd 5 stars!! but it was just soooo cute..the slow burn build was written perfectly! it was even written in third person!! & I DIDN'T EVEN NOTICE!! which is a feat for me also!! it was just the perfect little queer awakening story of fate really between two people that most likely would have never crossed paths! & i loved it!! ...also can we talk about this cover?? ITS STUNNINGGG!! the artwork for the girls is PERFECTION!!!
-sapphic romance
-holiday romance
-opposites attract
-violinist x financier
-second chance encounter
okokok first off...this was like zero angst...no third act break up...there was no drama...& i know when it comes to me..this will come to a surprise when you see i rated this a soliddd 5 stars!! but it was just soooo cute..the slow burn build was written perfectly! it was even written in third person!! & I DIDN'T EVEN NOTICE!! which is a feat for me also!! it was just the perfect little queer awakening story of fate really between two people that most likely would have never crossed paths! & i loved it!! ...also can we talk about this cover?? ITS STUNNINGGG!! the artwork for the girls is PERFECTION!!!
November 3, 2025
Thank you so much to NetGalley, BooksGoSocial and Alyson Root for sharing this ARC with me, in exchange for my honest opinions and thoughts.
Ms. Alyson made the SuperBowl winning touchdown with this one. Layla is just too adorable and quirky for words. Whitley is so amazing. I couldn't decide which MC I liked the best, I'm completely in love with both of them. The side characters were integrated in perfectly. This book is just phenomenal. All the holiday cozy/comfy things...Rainy Sunday, sitting infront of the fireplace, good book and a glass of wine.
I wholeheartedly recommend this book to all y'all.
Ms. Alyson made the SuperBowl winning touchdown with this one. Layla is just too adorable and quirky for words. Whitley is so amazing. I couldn't decide which MC I liked the best, I'm completely in love with both of them. The side characters were integrated in perfectly. This book is just phenomenal. All the holiday cozy/comfy things...Rainy Sunday, sitting infront of the fireplace, good book and a glass of wine.
I wholeheartedly recommend this book to all y'all.
November 5, 2025
Loved how this was done! Their relationship built over years of Decembers, hot chocolate, and galas. I loved that a friendship was formed first and even though one was gay the other couldn’t figure out why she was drawn. The long distance was for me such a cool dynamic and not one I read a lot and it was refreshing to read something a little different!
Such an opposite attracts but in the best way. The families both biological and found were amazing and i thoroughly enjoyed as the relationships organically developed between all of them.
Such an opposite attracts but in the best way. The families both biological and found were amazing and i thoroughly enjoyed as the relationships organically developed between all of them.
October 30, 2025
This book is the perfect cozy holiday read. It’s everything you could want from a cup of hot chocolate: warm, steamy, decadent, a little sinful and so sweet it lingers long after the last sip. I fell for Layla right away. Her wild, confident, rebellious energy hooked me instantly, but seeing Whitley through her eyes made me love her just as much. I really enjoyed Layla’s straightforward nature and how Whitley let her guard down and met her energy head-on. All in all, it’s a fantastic read!
November 9, 2025
Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC.
I wish I had picked to read this over my Xmas break, as this is wonderful easy read with almost zero angst.
We have Whitley who is a late blooming sapphic, who also happens to be incredibly rich but a total sweetheart, and loves running her charitable foundations.
Then we have Layla a lesbian, who is an incredibly talented and hard working musician. She's a straight forward person who isn't overawed by Whitley's wealth.
They have great chemistry, they are super fun together and they have great communication.
Well worth a read.
I wish I had picked to read this over my Xmas break, as this is wonderful easy read with almost zero angst.
We have Whitley who is a late blooming sapphic, who also happens to be incredibly rich but a total sweetheart, and loves running her charitable foundations.
Then we have Layla a lesbian, who is an incredibly talented and hard working musician. She's a straight forward person who isn't overawed by Whitley's wealth.
They have great chemistry, they are super fun together and they have great communication.
Well worth a read.
November 10, 2025
New Favorite Christmas story
This book was beautiful from beginning to end. A true Christmas love story. Uplifting, romantic and just the right tone to set me up for the Season.
Highly recommended.
This book was beautiful from beginning to end. A true Christmas love story. Uplifting, romantic and just the right tone to set me up for the Season.
Highly recommended.
November 9, 2025
Magically Delightful
The sitter had me laughing and kicking my feet several times. I loved the direct and open communication between the MCs. It was sweet and heartwarming.
The sitter had me laughing and kicking my feet several times. I loved the direct and open communication between the MCs. It was sweet and heartwarming.
Displaying 1 - 29 of 29 reviews