I can’t decide what is worse... a so-so story that is written well or a SUPER good story that has infuriating holes in the writing! This book is the latter.
Honestly - the story had me from the minute I started reading. The premise of a “choosing” where the men line up in hopes that a woman will pick them for a mate and the women having the decision of getting that choice is perfect! How many times do we read of just the opposite? And, add to that, Torkel is a Navy Seals-type warrior (albeit on another planet) who has had to live down his low-birth and deal with the rejection in that Choosing for seven long years before Faith finally chooses him.
It was the very best of romance reading!! Then, the holes started showing up. First, they were small, like a Sci-fi with no world building or explanations at all. That isn’t something I minded much, though. BUT... then Faith made some decisions that were truly TSTL and with those, the impending plot was immediately given away. From there it was just super annoying waiting for the bomb to drop. After everything hit the fan, however, things got back on track and the tension and nail-biting hit nuclear levels as we watched the devastating fall-out for Faith’s choices.
That’s when another HUGE hole opens and completely swallows the reader. We are absolutely aching for the conversation between Tarkel and Faith that will bring about the resolution. But WE DON’T GET IT!!! Instead we have a quickly rushed, half-baked attempt, gloss over and... The End. The author doesn’t give readers the time for Faith and Torkel to really understand and connect - with BOTH of them seeing how they messed up - NOT just Faith. Good Grief, Torkel needed to understand what she went through because of HIS neglect for heavens sake!!!! We need to see him hear her story and know what she went through to protect him. Because of this, the story overlooks any depth that would have made this an unforgettable story.
SO... my dear friends, Would I recommend this book? I’m honestly not sure. It had a world’s worth of potential but where much is given, much is expected. Those expectations just weren’t met - at least for me. I guess I would suggest trying it and see if it is worth it for you. I know I’ll be giving the series at least one more chance just to see if things develop better down the road.