Ezra-Nehemiah is the Old Testament equivalent of the Acts of the Apostles--it is a book of new beginnings. Just as Acts narrates the early history of the church through the work of the apostles, Ezra-Nehemiah narrates the re-establishment of the people of God after the exile through the work of Sheshbazzar, Zerubbabel, Ezra, and Nehemiah. Allen explores Ezra-Nehemiah as a single literary text made up of three parts telling the story of three missions and the opposition they meet with. Wise and insightful, Leslie Allen has written a commentary that illuminates these texts and their intended message.
Esther is a story about a young girl who becomes queen. Laniak's thoughtful commentary examines this narrative as a story with many levels of meaning. Esther is about the minority Jewish community in the dependent state of Diaspora, navigating a precarious existence in two worlds, and it is about the triumph of right over wrong, of God's people over their enemies.
I read this combo volume to teach adult, auditorium bible classes where I was covering large swathes of material at once and didn't have as much time as I'd like to read as deeply as I'd like--time constraints stink. So, I grabbed this for Ezra-Nehemiah reading because I'd really appreciated the Esther section that I'd read for a different class, a few years ago. However, this just wasn't as good.
This is a mixed bag in a lot of ways. I'd read the Esther commentary awhile ago when I taught Esther and I thought it punched well above its weight for the time allotted and simplicity of the commentary (probably a weighted 4.5 stars). Ezra was perfectly serviceable and clocked a solid 3.5 stars, but Nehemiah was... not good 2 stars.
So, it's tough top rate as a whole. I'd say if you're similarly constrained it would definitely be worth reading Ezra, but I'd find something better for Nehemiah.
Pretty good. A great and classic commentary on these three wonderful books. I probably would have stuck with the New American because the two covered the same ground at points.