“Mentink is at her peak.” –Korina Moss, Agatha Award-winning author of the Cheese Shop Mysteries series
In this witty historical murder mystery set in a San Francisco hotel, an unlikely trio of amateur sleuths must uncover a killer before another guest checks out for good. This first book in the Murder Most Fowl Mysteries is perfect for fans of Only Murders in the Building.
In 1905, the Grand Mallard Marquee is well known for its iconic style, as well as its daily duck parade. For Saul Niffler, a reformed jewel thief, working at the luxurious hotel offers a much-needed second chance. Staying out of trouble and in gainful employment is essential. Which makes seeing a body plummet from a penthouse window extra complicated.
Except…did he see it? There’s no body to be found, and Saul knows he should concentrate on his new duties as “Duck Commandant” rather than meddle. If only Kitty Rossi, a persistent young guest yearning to be a Pinkerton detective, would leave well enough alone. Kitty has already roped in Henry, the elevator man, to investigate suspicious goings-on around the hotel. And against his better judgment, Saul feels compelled to join them.
Between the mystery of Saul’s missing predecessor and a grisly discovery in a drain, all signs point to murder most fowl. And with a cold-blooded killer roaming the Marquee’s lavish corridors, keeping his job may be the least of Saul’s problems…
For fans Amateur Sleuths Historical Cozy Mystery Twisty-Turny Whodunits Turn-of-the-Century SettingsDon't miss Book 2 in the Murder Most Fowl Mysteries series, Missing from Suite Five, coming Fall 2027!
USA TODAY bestseller Dana Mentink enjoys writing in many different capacities. She currently writes for Harlequin's Love Inspired Suspense and Poisoned Pen Press.
Dana is the recipient of a Romantic Times Reviewer's Choice Award, two ACFW Carol Awards as well as a Holt Medallion.
It’s 1905, and Saul has just landed a new job at the Grand Mallard Marquee. But, on his first day, he thinks he sees someone fall from an upper floor. When his new friends, Kitty and Henry, convince him to investigate, they are left with more questions. There’s also the question of what happened to the man that Saul replaced. Can the trio figure out what is going on?
I’ll admit, this book took a couple of chapters for me to full get into, but once I did, I loved it. The main characters came to life, and I loved them and their growing friendship. The rest of the cast is strong as well. The mystery had quite a few different things going on. I figured a thing or two out early, but there were plenty of things I didn’t. Yet it all made sense at the end. I also enjoyed the time and place, and I’m already curious to see how a certain famous event that takes place the next year will be handled. This is a great debut, and I’ve already booked my room for a return visit.
This is a different and quirky story set at the Grand Mallard Marquee Hotel set in San Francisco in the early 1900's. Saul made a mistake and served a prison sentence and estrangement from his wife. Now he is working at the hotel with the resident ducks, parading them through the hotel entertaining guests while getting his life in order. He is drawn into working with a young lady guest and a bellhop who are trying to solve some disappearance of the former duck commandant and other people. I was pulling for the group to find answers while the hotel management were trying to stuff any negative things under the rug. This is an unusual premise with interesting characters, mysteries, and some red herrings. I had some idea of what was going on but the conclusion was well done and satisfying. I received a copy in exchange for an honest review. These are my thoughts.
Murders in the Marquee by Dana Mentink 4 Stars Thank you to Dana Mentink and thank you Harlequin for providing a gifted copy of this book. All thoughts are my own.
This is a fun cozy, historical mystery! It's set in 1905 at a grand hotel in San Francisco with a daily duck parade - its unique and stands out among the crowd. I liked the unique cast of characters, especially Saul as he was starting over after being a former convict. The ducks cracked me up. Nice faith thread.
Saul, Henry and Kitty were a dynamic trio who really bring the story to life. Funny and lighthearted to me - very cozy vibes. Kind of leans like classic mystery too, which was good change of pace compared to other cozies. I read a lot of modern cozy mysteries, so it was cool to have a historical one.
If you enjoy lighthearted historical mysteries with eccentric characters and a very memorable cast of ducks, this might be one to try!
content: no language, clean romance, cozy mystery but few mentions of body parts in the murders
I am thankful for the opportunity to READ & REVIEW this book from you. I WILL PROVIDE FEEDBACK when I am caught up; but I am currently behind on ARC books. I apologize for the delay in reading and reviewing and still hope we are able to continue working together in the future.
PUBLISH DATE: Sept 1, 2026 BOOK TITLE: Murders in the Marquee SERIES: Murder Most Fowl Mysteries AUTHOR: Dana Mentink PUBLISHER: Harlequin- Romance FORMAT: ebook PAGES: 336
I received a complimentary digital ARC [Advanced Readers Copy] of this book via NetGalley. Thank you to the Publisher and the Author for the opportunity to read and review this title prior to publication. As always, the opinions expressed in this review are my own.
In "Murders in the Marquee," Dana Mentink combines an endearing trio of unlikely friends turned amateur sleuths, punny humor, quirky characters, and adorable ducks on parade into a charming tale of friendship and murder most fowl.
If you're searching for a cozy mystery that'll make you quack up with laughter, book your reservation with Murders in the Marquee!
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher via NetGalley. A favorable review was not required. All views expressed are my own honest opinion.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ A Delightfully Clever Historical Cozy Mystery
I received digital and audiobook copies of Murders in the Marquee through NetGalley. I was not required to leave a positive review, and all opinions are my own.
Murders in the Marquee was such an enjoyable historical cozy mystery and a five-star read and listen for me!
Set in 1905 at San Francisco’s Grand Mallard Marquee, the story has such a fun and distinctive premise. Between the luxurious hotel, its famous duck parade, a possible body falling from a penthouse window, and a trio of unlikely amateur sleuths, there was plenty to keep me entertained and curious about what would happen next.
I especially enjoyed the combination of Saul, Kitty, and Henry. Their investigation brings plenty of mystery and humor to the story, while Saul’s past as a reformed jewel thief gives the plot an interesting extra layer.
I read approximately the first half of the book digitally and listened to the second half on audiobook, and I enjoyed both formats. The narrator did a wonderful job and made the transition from reading to listening seamless for me.
This was a witty, entertaining historical cozy with an engaging mystery, an unusual setting, and characters I’m looking forward to spending more time with. I’m delighted that this is the beginning of the Murder Most Fowl Mysteries series and will definitely be watching for the next adventure.
This was such a fun period story! While it was turn of the century, it gave me 1920s vibes. If you've ever watched Only Murders in the Building you'll get the same feel with this only without the language and it's historical.
Now, because I'm a Dana Mentink fan, I didn't even ask what the story was about. The title and cover got me after seeing her name on it, too!
Anyhow, this was such a well-written whodunit story that sweeps readers to the turn of the century (1905). Possible bodies falling from the sky. That's Saul's introduction to his new job and life! Kitty is a wealthy guest staying at the hotel with her parents. And dear, young Henry who dreams of being a magician. Turns out, all three of them have secrets!
Together, they try to figure out what happened to Saul's predecessor, Commandant Lee, who led the duck parade. Yes, duck parade! A duckling might even make an appearance! There's also the wealthy Mrs. Potter who no one has seen for quite some time.
Following this trio as they try to solve the mysteries at the Marquee had me 🤭🫣😬! They had to be clever in evading Mr. Clausen who would allow nothing to tarnish the hotel, avoid people who seemed to have shady behaviors, and keep up appearances like nothing was wrong!
Seriously, just an overall delightful mystery! I can't wait to read book two in the Murder Most Fowl Mysteries.
*Thanks to the author who sent me the print copy for review. This is my personal opinion.
This was such a cute, quirky, and delightful cozy mystery set in 1905, San Francisco at the luxurious Grand Mallard Marquee. This story had all the classic cozy-mystery ingredients. An intriguing whodunit, an eccentric cast of characters, plenty of humor, and just the right amount of off-the-wall charm. A hotel with a daily duck parade!? Yes, please! Lol
I really enjoyed Saul, Henry, and Kitty. This trio came together to investigate the crime while each trying to find their own second chance. Watching their individual journeys unfold alongside the mystery added a sweet layer of heart to the story.
This book leans into the classic cozy-mystery vibe, with a little bit of Clue and Only Murders in the Building energy thrown in. And somehow, a story involving murder, dead bodies, and dismembered body parts still manages to feel downright sweet. 😂
I had a great time with this one, and the sneak peek at the next book, Missing from Suite Five, has me looking forward to continuing in the series.
*For more reviews and bookish content, be sure to follow me on Instagram @aliciasbooksanctuary
Unfortunately, this one just wasn’t for me. It was too long and felt drawn out. The story was dense that it became difficult to stay engaged and I never felt a connection to the characters or the plot.
I really wanted to like this book. The mystery felt too drawn out. Kind of like if someone spends an hour handing you puzzle pieces one by one, and then suddenly dumped the rest of the pieces on the table at once and gave you 30 seconds to finish the puzzle. I could tell the red herrings were red herrings, and by the time the solution was revealed, I hadn’t guessed it, but I also didn’t really care.
The characters were fine. The side characters were just kind of there, like NPCs in a video game who have only one line and are just there to make it feel like the area has the right amount of people but who don’t add anything to the experience.
I liked Saul and Henry, but didn’t really feel that much more connected to them by the end of the book as I did at the beginning. I wish Saul had been given more thievery/sleight of hand to do. And Henry while part of the trio was never a POV, so he felt particularly flat. I also felt like his crush on Kitty was just thrown in at the end and actually took away from his character.
Then there was Kitty, and hoo boy, buckle up because she is the sole reason this book got 2.5 instead of 3 stars. As the book went on, my frustrations with her only grew until I actively disliked her. Below I’m going to go into spoilery detail into exactly why I disliked her, but if you don’t want anything spoiled, here’s the spoiler free version.
Kitty is like friends I’ve had before where when you confide in them the things you’re struggling with or anxious about, they interrupt you with “Oh, that’s NOTHING!” and then proceed to tell you whatever they’re dealing with. Like, thanks, I didn’t realize that this was a competition but remind me to never tell you anything ever again. She was incredibly whiny throughout the book, despite having an extraordinary amount of privilege for the time. I’m not saying that she can’t have frustrations, but it was the timing of those frustrations plus her telling Saul and Henry how much more privileged they were than her while actively ignoring how difficult their lives were that really, really got under my skin. She came off as a spoiled, selfish child, and I just could not deal with her anymore.
(Side note, she frequently talks about how she wants to be a Pinkerton but can’t because she’s a woman. Um, ma’am, Allan Pinkerton himself employed female Pinkertons all the way back in the 1860s. Maybe it was more difficult to be a female Pinkerton, but how about you stop being so maudlin, and at least try. The female Pinks didn’t sit around feeling sorry for themselves, they went out and sacrificed to make things happen.)
In conclusion: As you can see if you read below, I was pretty much done with Kitty by the end. This idea that all men are always more privileged than all women drives me absolutely up a wall. And quite frankly why I struggle with modern historical fiction.
Kitty has an education and the security of food and shelter. My grandpa who was born 30 years after this book takes place couldn’t say the same thing. He had to drop out of school in 8th grade and get a job so his family could put food on the table. And not some prestigious dream job either, Kitty! Even men don’t get to do whatever they want. This attitude also ignores God’s blessings. And considering that God and faith is actually discussed in this book, made Kitty’s attitude even more obnoxious. God gave Kitty many gifts, and she isn’t grateful for any of them.
HERE THERE BE SPOILERS (not for the solution of the mystery, though, just for situations the characters find themselves in near the end of the book):
These are the notes I took regarding my grievances against Kitty
-“At that moment, it dawned on him that despite his incarceration he’d likely had more freedom in his life than the well-bred young woman before him.”
Nope. No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no. I’m sorry, Ms. Mentink, but no. No.
Let’s recap; before this sentence, Kitty’s complaints were having to spend hours embroidering a pillowcase, pretending to be interested when people discuss their causes and politics, and wearing a corset. And you compare this to PRISON?! Or the knife’s edge that Saul exists on currently while on parole?
I’ve been trying to ignore Kitty’s whining up to this point, but it’s getting to be too much.
(Also if your corset is uncomfortable it’s because it’s fitted improperly or it’s not been broken in, similar to new shoes.)
-Saul fears he is about to lose the job he desperately needs to keep so he can be reunited with his wife and put his criminal past behind him.
Henry is facing being framed for the murder of a man who was his sole friend in a world he feels incredibly isolated from due to, among other things, being illiterate.
These dire situations having just been discussed, Kitty breaks down crying, saying that her parents are leaving on a world cruise and she must go with them because, as a woman, they can’t leave her to live in a hotel on her own, though they would if she were a boy. Then Kitty says this,
“You men have no idea your own privilege.” 🙄
Girl, you will be gone for six months. In that time, you get to see the world, make new friends, stick your nose into any mysteries you want on the ship, etc. Meanwhile, Saul might lose his wife and struggle to find a job due to his criminal past, and Henry might be in prison, or worse! Because as a reminder, this is 1905 and the death penalty is still very much on the table. But no, you cry your tears because you can’t stay in your fancy hotel and live your no responsibilities, follow your detective whims cushy life.
-“Alone to wander the decks of a cruise ship, sipping cups of tepid tea with people her parents insisted she meet, and devouring newspapers to catch whiffs of mysteries that she could neither investigate nor solve. It made her want to outright sob.”
Oh, no, Kitty! Not tepid tea!! Say it ain’t so!!!
At least you can READ the newspapers! At least you’ll be seeing the world instead of the inside of a prison cell! At least you’ll still have your whole life ahead of you to play detective. Meanwhile, a lot of men of the time were dying of black lung from working in the mines. They didn’t get to just do whatever they wanted either!
You silly, stupid, selfish girl!!! I can’t stand you! 😡
-I really thought there’d be a moment when Kitty learned that Henry couldn’t read, and she’d reevaluate her idea of him being better off than her just because he’s a man, but nope. Never happened. Somehow Kitty not getting to do whatever she wants in life is seen as being worse off than being illiterate!!
Mystery, murder, & mallards! I thoroughly enjoyed this new historical cozy mystery from Dana Mentink! Murders in the Marquee is the first engaging book in the Murder Most Fowl Mysteries series & I’m excited to read the next. Set in 1905 San Francisco at the Grand Mallard Marquee, three charming sleuths, delightful humor, & a clever whodunit kept me turning the pages as I tried to unravel each clue.
My heart went out to Saul Niffler, a reformed jewel thief trying to put his life back together & win his estranged wife back. He’s landed a job as the hotel’s “Duck Commandant,” guiding twelve ducks in the famous duck parade. But before he even starts, he thinks he sees a body fall from a hotel window. When no body turns up, he pretends he didn’t see anything. Unfortunately, Kitty, the daughter of a prominent opera singer, & Henry, the elevator operator, know what he saw & are determined to solve the mystery. As more clues surface & Saul makes a disturbing discovery in his drain, he’s compelled to join them. With danger closing in, these three sleuths must solve the mystery before one of them is accused of murder.
I loved this trio! Saul’s such a softy despite his checkered past, & I enjoyed the way he interacted with the darling ducks. (Uncle Joe was adorable!) I also loved Kitty, who dreams of being a Pinkerton detective while her parents want her to be a demure debutante. It was fun watching her fly from one theory to the next. Henry’s delightful too, an aspiring juggler with secrets of his own. They make such an endearing team, & I found myself laughing at their antics as they searched for clues while trying to evade discovery. I also loved the history & famous hotel guests brilliantly woven in.
The mystery kept me on my toes with one red herring after another & lots of suspects with different motivations. Enjoyed the nail-biting conclusion & seeing if my guesses were correct! Highly recommend to cozy historical mystery fans. I received an advance copy with no expectation of a positive review. All opinions are my own & voluntarily provided.
Murders in the Marquee is one of the best historical mysteries I've read in a long time. It checks all the boxes for me: fast-paced, an intriguing first chapter, an endless list of suspects, a relatable amateur sleuth, and loyal yet quirky sidekicks.
I've been on the fence about the new trend of historical murder mysteries. You'd think I love them but I tend to find them slow in the set up. But Murders in the Marquee proved me wrong! This story starts out with what looks like a body falling from the balcony of a hotel.--except no body was found. Danger on page one! And from start to finish, I loved everything about this novel. The story has one setting - the Grand Mallard Marquee hotel in San Francisco. This gives off Agatha Christie vibes for sure - one location where everyone is "trapped" with the murderer. And anyone could be the culprit. Readers will fall in love with Kitty Rossi, a young woman who wants to make it on her own in an era where that isn't acceptable. And Saul Niffler just wants to untangle himself from his past mistakes. Plus, the ducks might as well be the main character as they steal the show.
This book is one to move up your must read list. If you like mysteries, heartwarming characters, exciting twists and turns, and a "who-dun-it" page turner, look no further than Murders in the Marquee.
I received an ebook review copy of this book through NetGalley. All opinions expressed in this review are my own
Murders in the Marquee by Dana Mentink has a beautiful cover. This is what drew me into read the cozy mystery. However, the mystery was very lackluster, and I couldn't wait to finish the story. The characters were pretty flat with barely any personality. Yes, they wanted to focus on the mystery, but at times, they follow the clues, and only focused on that clue until they solved what it has to do with the mystery, then they moved onto trying to find another clue. The setting was nice. I have heard about the Duck Parade at the Marquee, so it was nice to see an inside look to the workings of a hotel with high-end clients. Overall, Murders in the Marquee did not live up to my feelings of what a murder mystery should be. I needed more action and solving of the mystery.
I received a complimentary copy of Murders in the Marquee by Dana Mentink from Love Inspired Trade, but the opinions stated are all my own.
A fast-paced mystery! The characters were interesting enough and fun in the moment. As a person who would usually find a regular Love Inspired publication to be a little bland, this one definitely piqued my interest better than Love Inspired's usual fair. I would be interested in reading more similar publications that they will have coming out soon.
Also, I am such a fan of little Moonstone! (The cutest little duckling.)
Squeamish level: 2 out of 5
The mystery plot may or may not contain: a severed digit, posthumous dismembered limbs, AND a body falling from a building.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Netgalley, but was not required to leave a positive review.
This was kinda fun (as fun as a murder can be 😂)! It's definitely no Agatha Christie or Dorothy Sayers, and Kitty is no Miss Marple, but I still enjoyed this for the most part. Kind of a fun and strange story. I did have some guesses and was right on one, but the ending still wasn't as I expected, as the story was written it leaves open a few options/guesses.
I absolutely loved this book!!! People disappearing, ducks, love and Murder. What more could you want??? Pick this up today you will not be disappointed!!
This was a good start for a new series. I loved the setting of turn-of-the-century San Francisco and the luxury hotel, in particular. The characters were quirky and fun, and the ducks were a cute addition. I think where this fell short for me was that it was entirely too long, and it felt repetitious for the sake of drawing it out. Other than that, I enjoyed it and look forward to more in the series.
Thank you to NetGalley and Harlequin Audio for the review copy.
“Murder, mayhem, and mallards. Who could conceive of such a thing?”
Only Dana Mentink, on a quest to develop a zany cozy mystery! Imagine my surprise when I discovered that the imaginary Grand Mallard Marquee Hotel in San Francisco is actually patterned to a degree after a famous hotel in another part of the country! I was already prepared to laugh by the ridiculousness of the prestigious 1905 San Francisco hotel’s name. And a duck parade through the lobby twice a day? Complete with a duck commander?
But this is where things get a little hairy. The prominent hotel’s duck commander has disappeared. The hotel manager, desperate to impress one particular guest he believes to be scouting city hotels for a famous literary guest, well, he doesn’t read Saul Niffler’s resume very well. “Shady Saul” as I might refer to him finds himself the bewildered leader of 12 prized ducks, about which he knows nothing.
As Saul acquaints himself with his duties via journals left behind, he is amazed to find himself in partnership with a famous tenor’s young adult daughter, Kitty, and the young elevator man, Henry. “‘You were an eyewitness, Saul.’ The paleness of his face blanched to bone white. ‘An eyewitness to what?’ ‘That’s exactly what Henry and I want to know.’ She skewered him with her hardest detective stare. ‘And I’m not leaving here until you come clean.’” Oy, vey. Kitty wants to be a Pinkerton, not a socialite. Henry dreams of becoming a juggler, performing in shows. Saul, in his 30s, checkered past, just wants to keep his past hidden, his nose clean, and be able to woo his estranged wife back.
This book had me in stitches with the unlikely trio’s escapades, attempts to unmask the visitor who isn’t all he claims, and the wealthy widow who is behaving oddly. Could there actually have been a murder at the hotel, and a cover-up to boot?
Kitty is young, used to getting her own way because of her wealth, and trying out her wings as much as possible. She is a darling, but quite excitable and easily swayed from one theory to the next.
Henry is also young, has a secret, and needs a bit of guidance. Plus, he may be sweet on a forbidden character.
And now, somehow Saul is not only leading the duck parade but this impossible group as they secretly defy given instructions and work hard to prove what none of them saw.
Great twists and use of side characters! Uncle Joe is one of my fave characters. If you like historic, twisty cozy mysteries, I highly recommend Murders in the Marquee. I am ready for book 2!
I received a copy of the book from the author and publisher via NetGalley. I also pre-ordered my own ebook. No positive review was required, and all opinions are my own.
Notable Quotables:
‘A woman reasons by telegraph, and a man’s stage-coach reasoning cannot keep pace with hers,’” - Saul’s paraphrase of quote by Dr. Mary Walker
“You did bad things, Saul. We all have. God forgives,” Henry said. “He forgives. You’re gonna mess up and do more bad things still, but only He can tell how you’re being polished up.”
“The chaplain…insisted that God was doing a new thing to Saul’s crusty, battered soul. With ducks? That was a novel way to go about it.”
“Opera singers are like roosters. They each believe there’s only room enough for one in the flock.”
“He heard the voice of the tiny chaplain. God’s doing a new thing in you, Saul. A new thing? It sure felt like he was about to step in a boiling vat of trouble and that was nothing new at all.”
“Choices. That was all she really wanted, to be able to make them for herself.”
3.5 Stars but bumped to 4 since no half stars available here. Warning – incoming puns that are just ducky… 🦆
They would label this a "Quirky Mystery" if that were an official genre.
A Duck Commandant? This is a first for me! An actual job keeping your ducks in a row... 🦆🦆🦆🦆🦆🦆🦆🦆🦆🦆🦆🦆
Picture it: San Francisco 1905. A glorious hotel, where the guests are pampered almost as much as the ducks. Imagine a flock of fine feathered fowl forming a conga line!
But stop the mallard march - we seem to have a murder on our hands. Well, just a finger for now.
Favorite Character: Kitty was the bright spot. Raised to be a high-society socialite, this bored little rich girl dreams of being a professional Pinkerton detective, much to her family’s dismay. She’s teamed up with Saul (the reformed jewel thief Duck Commandant) and Henry (the aspiring Vaudeville juggler Elevator Operator). These three mismatched amateur sleuths just might have been the original inspiration for the Three Stooges. 🙈🙉🙊😉
It’s a cute fun book, and while the high-society waddle pageant provides an entertaining backdrop, the actual murder mystery was not all it was quacked up to be for me. Let’s just say it didn’t have me perched on the edge of my seat, but it was still an enjoyable listen (audiobook narrator Kimberly M Wetherell).
Not yet published. Expected 9-1-2026 Thank you NetGalley and Harlequin Audio for the free ALC in exchange for my honest review.
How I LOVE mystery of old San Francisco type books. This one has a MMC which I’m not used to, and takes place around 1905 which is later than many books I’ve read recently. Neither of these were to the detriment of the novel, and in fact I sincerely enjoyed Saul Niffler as the main character.
Kitty, and Henry are also likable but curious and adventurous characters who completed the crime solving trio.
The constant tension between Saul’s parole, Kitty’s freedom in some areas but not others, and Henry’s wonderful personality but light stomach were fascinating. Three people in such different circumstances who ‘wouldn’t be friends’ but end up each adding much to the partnership.
I knew immediately upon reading ‘Duck parade’ that I would be entranced by the waterfowl, but they ended up being better than my greatest expectations. Their inclusion was so natural to every part of the story, and they played such key roles that I’m honestly very impressed. And Mooney??? Don’t even get me started, my heart.
Overall I was really pleasantly surprised by this story! At times I got a little spooked reading it at night and had to take breaks, but I’m so glad I would start again the next day as the author does a great job with the ending.
Would recommend!
Thank you NetGalley for this eARC in exchange for an honest review
MURDERS IN THE MARQUEE is set during a lavish historical period in San Francisco where a hotel's image is set above all else, even if that includes hiding some dead bodies. The author forms a motley group of characters who make a trio of sleuths which include two of the hotel workers led by one of the upper crust. What ensues is a somewhat dramatic, but sweet and cozy mystery.
I liked the characters from the start of the story. They're an interesting group. Saul is the mature member who recently was released from prison and is trying to restart his life. He's married but hasn't seen his wife in some time and doesn't know if she'll keep him. There's young Henry who runs the elevator, has dreams of being a showman, and has a crush on the Kitty. And Kitty, who is an 18-year-old affluent woman staying at the hotel with her parents who wants to be like the detectives she's so fond of in her books. The characters work well together even though they're all a bit bumbling about trying to solve the disappearance of the former “Duck Commandant.”
The plot itself meanders along. Sometimes it feels like there isn't actually a mystery to solve, but then there are some red flags that pop up and some other characters acting strangely. There definitely is a feeling that something, if not several, is off, but it's hard to know exactly what. It starts to come together towards the end, and what an end it is!
In the end, was it what I wished for? This is one of those books you can read or listen to while you relax. It is definitely a cozy mystery with emphasis on the cozy, and has some delightful characters, including some adorable ducks. Recommended if you're a fan of the genre and the historical period.
Content: Some references to murder, but not overly detailed. Clean. Source: I received a complimentary copy through Celebrate Lit, which did not require a positive review. All opinions are my own.
Murders in the Marquee is the first book in Dana Mentik's Murder Most Fowl Mystery Series. The story is set in 1905 at the Grand Mallard Marquee, a San Francisco hotel well known for its iconic style. The amateur sleuth is Saul Niffler, a reformed jewel thief working at the luxurious hotel. Saul teams up with two other amateur sleuths: a fellow employee named Henry and Kitty Rossi, a persistent young guest yearning to be a Pinkerton detective.
Murders in the Marquee is a fun, fast-paced historical cozy mystery debut featuring an endearing trio of amateur sleuths and a hotel setting so distinctive it feels like its own character. The hotel hosts a daily duck parade (cute) and an interesting ensemble of guests who make excellent suspects in this closed-circle mystery.
The author incorporated period details in all the right places, and the writing was easy to follow and enjoyable to read. I liked how the mystery elements were constructed, but the characters were my favorite part. They have little in common but create a dynamic team that is easy to root for and fun to sleuth with.
I am definitely interested in continuing this series. Thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for the ARC.
Do you have an author that you'll read, no matter what he/she writes? I mean, it automatically goes on your TBR list, no matter what is? Dana Mentink is one such author for me. I am excited to see this new series from her.
Murders in the Marquee is the first in the "Murder Most Fowl Mysteries" series. What a delight it is, indeed. We're introduced to an unlikely trio of amateur sleuths, who manage to find themselves in various forms of "hot water" at times.
It's fun to watch Kitty, Henry and Saul work together to piece the puzzle together, and keeps the reader engaged and guessing throughout. Most enjoyable was the daily duck parade through the hotel, led by Saul, and captivating to the guests. I love the ducks!
It becomes even more engaging when a famous author shows up as a guest, with a request at the end for accommodations for a prolonged visit.
I look forward to more encounters with Kitty, Henry and Saul. Sign me up for the next one!
If you enjoy historical, cozy mysteries I highly recommend Murders in the Marquee for your TBR list.
I received a complimentary copy. These opinions are my own.
A historical mystery set in the Marquee in San Francisco although patterned after the Peabody Hotel with its Duck Brigade. A few light moments in spite of the dead bodies are in store for Kitty, daughter of a famous opera star, Henry an elevator man and Saul fresh out of jail and tasked with overseeing a dozen mallards. Saul is sure he saw something drop from a balcony but the trio cannot find a body. They find lots of other puzzling happenings and fishy acting people. Ms. Mentink sends us on a merry chase with lots of suppositions by Kitty who wants to become a Pinkerton, new Christian Saul who strives not to be just another ex-con and Henry who wants to break into Vaudeville as a juggler. The author kept me guessing right up to the end. I wonder what these stealthy sleuths will get into next. There is a teaser that another case is in the works for Kitty, Henry and Saul. *A complimentary copy of this book was provided by Love Inspired through NetGalley. I was not required to post a favorable review. All opinions are mine alone.*
This fun, historical mystery is set in 1905 and would be a really good palate cleanser for anything super heavy.
It takes place in a grand hotel in San Francisco - I feel like the cover really fit the vibes of the book. There’s eccentric characters and a daily duck parade - this had me giggling and it was something different from other books I’ve read recently. I think Saul was my favorite though - having served time in person, he’s trying to redeem himself and the way he parades these ducks through the hotel - I just can’t!
I liked the more historical cozy mystery vibes. It was fitting for the story for sure! There were parts that will have you laughing out loud and then at the next turn, you’re trying to solve the mystery. Overall, well done and I’d definitely recommend if you want more of a quirky, easy read. Thank you NetGalley, Harlequin and Dana Mentink for the early review copy. All opinions are my own but it was the ducks for me!
This story was quirky and a lot of fun! The mystery kept me guessing and the ducks were a great addition. Saul, Henry and Kitty make a great investigative team and you can’t help root for them to solve the case. The ending was not with out a surprise or two, and was one of the best endings I have read this year. This series promises a lot of enjoyable moments to come!
I received a copy of this book from the author and was not required to post a positive review. All thoughts are my honest opinion.
I loved everything about this cozy mystery steeped in history which initiates the Murder Most Fowl Mysteries series. The cleverly plotted storyline, with its perfect mix of lighthearted and serious scenes, along with a diverse cast of expertly crafted, memorable characters kept me immersed in the story and turning the pages quickly to see what trouble amateur detectives Saul, Henry and Kitty would get into next. The 1905 San Francisco luxury hotel setting, which includes an endearing flock of talented parading ducks, took on a life of its own and kept me smiling. The comradery of the sleuthing team's unlikely friendship is heartwarming. I heartily recommend this book and look forward to the next book in the series! I received a copy of this book from the publisher via NetGalley with no obligation to write a positive review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Murders in the Marquee is a charming, slow-burn historical cozy mystery set in a grand hotel complete with a delightful daily duck parade. The story follows a complex, well-crafted mystery kicked off by a vanishing body and solved by Kitty Rossi and her fantastic crew of amateur sleuths. While you'll need to stretch your suspension of disbelief a bit for the historical social dynamics, the quirky setting and lovable characters make it a total treat. An absolute joy on audiobook—especially if you've ever witnessed a real-life hotel duck parade like the one in Memphis! I'm eagerly looking forward to the next book in the series.
Really cute read! Definitely read if you’re a fan of Only Murderers in the Building. Set in 1905, an unlikely team of amateur sleuths investigate a mysterious chain of events at a luxurious hotel.
I want to thank the author and publisher for sending me this book in exchange for an honest review.
That being said, this book was just not for me although I know it will definitely be for some other reader. This is a mystery set in a historical fiction era, and the early 1900s in San Francisco. It’s a quirky, cozy mystery with also a a positive religious undertone. There’s no spice in this book, It’s just a cute story. For me though, I couldn’t get into these characters and I had a hard time with the writing in general. The story seemed to drag on and I was not invested in the story.