The Three Billy Goats Gruff

by Paul Galdone (Adaptor, Illustrator)

The three goat brothers brave the terrible troll in a colorful version of the classic tale.

Genres: Picture Books, Childrens, Classics, Animals, Fiction, Fairy Tales, Fantasy

32 pages, Hardcover

First published January 1, 1841

About the author

Paul Galdone (1907 - November 7, 1986) was a children's literature author and illustrator. He was born in Budapest and he emigrated to the United States in 1921. He studied art at the Art Student's League and New York School for Industrial Design. He served for the US Army during world War II.

He illustrated nearly all of Eve Titus' books including the Basil of Baker Street series which was translated to the screen in the animated Disney film, The Great Mouse Detective.

Galdone and Titus were nominated for Caldecott Medals for Anatole (1957) and Anatole and the Cat (1958). The titles were later named Caldecott Honor books in 1971.

He died of a heart attack in Nyack, New York. He was posthumously awarded the 1996 Kerlan Award for his contribution to children's literature. His retellings of classic tales like "The Little Red Hen" or "Three Billy Goats Gruff" have become staples.

Reviews

[Matt · Rating 4 out of 5]

The Three Billy Goats have found that their current abode is devoid of much in the way of scrumptious grass and other grazing options. When they locate a field across the way, all they need do is cross a bridge to find fresh options. This bridge is guarded by a troll, whose main interest is to devour the goats. The smallest argues that he is too petite, the middle one speaks of his larger brother about to cross, and the largest... well he takes matters into his own hooves. Neo laughed, having not heard this story before, but knows that violence does not solve anything.

[Almira · Rating 5 out of 5]

Of all the versions of this classic, Paul Galdone's is my absolute favorite.
His illustrations are OVER the TOP! Can't think of a better Troll then Paul's.

You know the story, so I will leave this review with...….."So, snip, snap, snout. This tale's told out."

[Debbie W. · Rating 5 out of 5]

Love Paul Galdone's versions of fairy tales!

[Mariah Roze · Rating 4 out of 5]

This is such a cute, easy read.

[Melki · Rating 3 out of 5]

I never realized until this reading just what a strange tale this one is. The moral seems to be that the way to deal with a bully is not through kindness, or cleverness, but with a bigger bully. Weird, huh?

But, I did like Galdone's artwork, so there's that . . .

[The Library Lady · Rating 5 out of 5]

Every child should be exposed to the work of Paul Galdone. He took classic fairy tales and told them in language that keeps the cadence and style of the originals, yet is accessible to a preschooler. His illustrations were strong and bright-- no cluttered margins as in Jan Brett, no Janet Stevens dressed up animals--just clean, clear pictures that are extremely visually pleasing.

This title is one of the best examples of that work--complete with the "Snip, Snap Snout, this tale is out" ending straight from Peter Christen Asbjørnsen's Norwegian Folktales. This is THE version of that tale--and there are many other titles to enjoy.

Your library SHOULD have them. If they don't have these and have Disney crap instead, find another library!

[Sara · Rating 3 out of 5]

هیچوقت با بز بالغ در نیوفتید.
اسفند ۱۴۰۳

[Nathan "N.R." Gaddis]

Hell yeah! The nostalgia that bubbles through whilst bouncing around gr. Haven't seen/thought of this little nugget since I was young enough to be targeted!! Didn't even know it was Norwegian. Didn't know I was surrounded by Norwegian descendents at the time either. Here's to the Sons/Goats of Northern Darkness :: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BstHb...

[Kirran · Rating 4 out of 5]

This book is about 3 billy goats called Gruff,Gruff,Gruff who want to cross the bridge and get to the meadow on the other side in order to get some delicious grass. However a wicked old troll lives under the bridge and he gobbles up anyone who tries to cross the bridge. The littlest billy goat is the first to cross the bridge,when the troll tries to eat him the goat tells him that the second billy goat is much much bigger and fatter. The troll decides to eat the middle sized billy goat instead.When the second billy goat crosses the bridge and sees the troll,he tells him that third billy goat is much bigger and much fatter than him. The troll decides to eat the big billy goat gruff.However when the third billy goat crosses the bridge he bends his head and uses his horns to push the evil troll over the bridge.
This book is aimed at children in Nursery and Reception. It can be used to teach them about different sizes,they can also discuss whether they are the eldest,the middle or the youngest child in their families. In addition,you can discuss the types of food goats eat.

[John Yelverton · Rating 5 out of 5]

What an absolutely fun and adorable book for young children.

[Jennifer · Rating 5 out of 5]

Just tracking to see how many times I teach this ESL lesson.

[Kelly Beigl · Rating 5 out of 5]

The Three Billy Goats Gruff by Paul Galdone is the most straightforward folktale story you can find. For this story in particular it is very easy from the beginning to pinpoint the genre. This story starts with the ever so classic line of “Once upon a time”. It can be assumed that this story has been told orally for many years and was eventually turned into a children's story book, but the author of this book is most likely not the original author of this story.
Another element of this story that helps the reader to identify that it is a folklore is its lack of character development. We are given very little information about the three billy goats and troll in this story. The three billy goats are briefly described by their 3 sizes varying from small to very large, and we are told that they are all named Gruff. The troll in this story was said to be “as mean as he was ugly”. For more modern stories the characters are developed much more. These folklore stories have been passed down orally and in writing for many years so over time they loose specific information and details that may have originally been apart of the story.
I think this book would be perfect to use in a classroom if I were teaching about different types of genres. I feel as if this folklore is very straightforward and to the point, containing many indicators of its genre in the text. The “once upon a time” feel this book gives is a classic that isn't found in more modern stories.

[Taylor Hart · Rating 4 out of 5]

The Three Billy Goats Gruff is a time old fairy tale about three goat siblings that are very hungry. They've run out of good grass to graze on in their valley so they must travel up the meadow to where the greenery is plentiful. To do this, however, they must cross a bridge that a mean and ugly Troll lives under. The goats, being extremely hungry, decide to chance it. The littlest goat crosses first. When confronted by the Troll, who wants to eat the animal, the little goat holds him off by convincing him that his older, much larger brother will be by next. The middle goat is also able to trick the Troll into waiting for the third goat to pass over. When the third and largest of the goats Gruff comes clicking across the Troll's bridge the troll pops out and claims he's going to eat the goat. The goat, unafraid and quite bravely, shouts, "Well, come along!" The goat butts the Troll with his horns, tramples him with his hard hooves, and tosses him into the river. The goats are then free to pass to the green hillside where they can eat to their hearts desire. I think this is a cute tale about sticking together to help your fellow brother and sister (whether related by blood or not.)

(Original Fairy Tale)

[Kari Doering · Rating 4 out of 5]

The story of the three Billy Goats Gruff is a great story that has been around for along time. The story talks about the three Billy Goat all named Gruff. They lived in a valley that did not have much free grass for them to eat. So they decided to go up stream to find some. All of a sudden they came across a bride where a mean old troll liver.The youngest Billy goat decided to go over first and that is when the mean troll cave out and said "he was going to eat him up"the Billy goat replied with I'm just really skinny and trying to get over to the meadows to eat some grass and fatten me up. The mean troll let him through. This continued till the last Billy goat tried to come over and the troll replied with "I am going to eat you up". The billy goat replied with " ok try it I have four huffs and 2 horns" So as the troll tried to get on the bridge the Billy Goat Gruff butted him with his horns and trampled over his hooves and then.....
This book has a double page spread(bleed) where the pictures are spread over two pages and the words are only on one. This book also contains front matter and very colorful pictures.

[Patrick · Rating 4 out of 5]

I read this book to my year one class and I thoroughly enjoyed it and it brought back so many memories from my childhood. The story is about 3 goats who need to cross a bridge, to eat grass on the other side, in order to survive. However there is a troll who lives under the bridge and he stops the 3 Billy Goats from crossing. The billy goats devise a plan and trick the troll into letting them cross.

[Paul Kirby · Rating 5 out of 5]

This picture book of the widely known norwiegan twist of the three little pigs was amazing. The illustrations were vivid and pleasant to the eye. The text followed along with each illustration making it clear and understandable for even the youngest reader. Overall I give it a perfect five stars and salute Paul Galdone for another masterpiece.

[Siobhan · Rating 4 out of 5]

A wonderful read from my childhood, one I’d certainly suggest for other youngsters. Whilst it is not my all-time favourite childhood read I can still recall all the details of this one meaning it certainly left a lasting impression upon my young mind.

And isn’t that what we want with children’s books, for them to leave a positive lasting impression?

[Neva · Rating 5 out of 5]

the three billy goats are starving. they need to eat but the do not have any green grass left. so they try to get to the other side of the rushing river. But there was only one way. to cross the river on the bridge. But under the bridge lived a very mean troll. Read the book to find out more!


Neva Horning

[Jonathan Ayres · Rating 4 out of 5]

A classic goodies v baddie tale where the trickery of the goats is matched by the good faith or naivety of the troll. The high quality of the illustration really added a lot to the story. Could be enjoyed by early years and KS1 classes

[Jenny · Rating 3 out of 5]

My 3rd grade students really got a kick out of the illustrations of the troll.

[Russell Gray · Rating 4 out of 5]

This probably seems like a very random read, and I suppose it is. I was working on something recently and ended up reading or rereading a few dozen fairy tales.

This one is very short compared to many, and simple rather than complicated - at least at a glance. I had to think for a few minutes what the point of this story was. The problem was that I initially tried thinking from the perspective of the titular billy goats. There was no lesson to be learned from their side of the story, and honestly, they seemed like conniving and back-stabbing animals. From the troll's perspective, the lesson suddenly became clear: Don't be greedy. Similar to the saying "A bird in hand is better than two in the brush."

When I looked online, I was genuinely surprised to see that most readers seemed to think this was a story about working together to overcome problems. Wait, what? Oh, it's because the smaller goats had to trick the troll and rely on the bigger goat to help them. No, that doesn't work for me. Because if the big goat could handle the problem, why didn't he lead the way? He could have even stood on the bridge while the smaller goats crossed, protecting them like a goat crossing guard.

This strange story seems to benefit more from the trip trap sound effects for a younger audience than the message, as many people seem to come away from the story somehow thinking about how smart the goats were. Of course, I prefer the Grimm's version, where the 3rd billy goat put out the troll's eyes with its horns and crushed its body and bones with its hooves before throwing the corpse off the bridge.

[The Gazillionth Reader · Rating 5 out of 5]

4.5 stars


If I were the last goat I would’ve just lied and said there was a bigger fourth goat behind me



This morning I read Henny Penny (thanks to a Golden Girls episode) and while I was here checking out other books by Paul Galdone I saw this, and I love goats so of course I had to read it. I went in knowing nothing about it except for the title. It was fun! I’d totally buy this book for a kid. Henny Penny too… but I liked this one more.






My Rating System 📖 (but I'm indecisive so ratings subject to change and not be consistent with my scale. A 4 star may actually be a 5 star and a 3 star may be a 4.5 star)

1 star: hated it. Would never recommend
2 stars: Not my cup of tea, but could be somebody else's
3 stars: I liked it well enough, I don't know if I'd reread, but I
would recommend if occasion arose
4 stars: I really liked it!! I would reread one day. I'd
recommend if occasion arose
5 stars: I LOVED IT!! I shall rave about it even if nobody
listens
*half stars get rounded up. For example, 3.5 stars will be 4 stars

[Thikrayat Al-aradi · Rating 4 out of 5]

If it wasn't for a dare I wouldn't have done it, but I did 💪🏻

[Helen · Rating 5 out of 5]

I read this to my yr 3 class.
It brought back memories of my now 12 year son screaming the place down every time someone mentioned the troll under the bridge.

[caroline · Rating 5 out of 5]

I want a billy goat.

[Danielle · Rating 3 out of 5]

Not my favourite version of this classic tale.

[Shaneka Taylor]

Text-to-World Connection: The gruff moral of three billy goats are not to be greedy. If the troll hadn't been greedy, he would have had the first and the second goat a big meal. The troll decided to be greedy for the biggest reward, though and ended up under the bridge in the water. If we want to be greedy in life and want more and more without being appreciative of what we have in front of us, at some stage later, it will all fall, which is a situation that no one wants to be in!

[Christine · Rating 5 out of 5]

Just like "The Three Little Bears," this story needed representation in my son's library. To me, this author's book is the perfect version. The illustrations are fanciful, silly, and eye catching. It doesn't do anything crazy new to the story, but that works in getting the basics across as an introduction to a one year old.

[Charlotte · Rating 3 out of 5]

Don't be a troll.

[Michael Hitchcock · Rating 4 out of 5]

I love the kinds of stories where a character says to a monster "OH DON'T EAT ME MY BROTHER IS SO MUCH MORE DELICIOUS" or "I WILL BE SO MUCH MORE DELICIOUS LATER" or etc etc. It's a great trope and it's a great life lesson. The monsters of this world are always just self centered enough that they can believe you when you take their view into account.

I love the grey area ambiguity of modern stories, but the old stories like this one where the troll is clearly intended to just be evil are also satisfying in their own way. Where a modern story will go through many stages of editing and readers and rewriting, these types of myths go through a Darwinian kind of editing process over time (until the advent of and worship of print halts the process and changes it forever) that leave just the purest forms of the story to be passed down.

Don't fight the troll, tiny child. Don't threaten the troll. Trick him and get away. It's a fine lesson.

This one, like so many of the great myths and fables uses a repeating catch phrase that kids love to hear and squeal about and imitate and hyper intellectual adults can use to trace the development and reflection of themes between sections and hummmmm about while stroking chins and beards. WHO'S THAT TRIP TRAP TRIPPING OVER MY BRIDGE. It's a good one.

The art for this particular edition is great. The troll's hair is wild and the goat's eyes are vivid and intelligent. Everything is Earth toned, even the blue of the troll's nose. It's easy to look at.

The points of view of the pictures are great too. When the small goat is tripping over the bridge, you just see his little nervous face glancing over the side while most of the two pages is taken up by the immense bridge. The second goat is depicted from above, covering about half of the area of the page while the bridge he's standing on fills up almost the rest. They're almost equal to one another in size. The third goat takes up most of both pages and you cannot see the bridge at all. It's a great buildup.

The book is full of artistic flourishes like that worth looking into but the pictures are never too busy. They're just right.