What do you think?
Rate this book
A Scandal Changes Everything
The Scandalous '71 St. Clair
There’s no way around it, Sophia St. Clair is notorious, a cautionary tale to all of London’s young ladies on being found standing amidst shrubbery, alone with a man.
If Society only knew the whole story.
Sophia’s illegitimate daughter was stolen from her arms, and she’ll do anything to find her. Disguised as Madame Pigeon, Sophia supports her search by writing speeches for the condemned and, as Lady Sour, wildly-popular, just a tad seditious, broadsides on a woman’s lot.
A powerful earl determined to bare Sophia’s secrets
Roman Montvilliers, the widowed Earl of Haslemere, has responsibilities to rival his power: an illustrious political career, a philandering brother, a five-year old daughter without a mother, and a mother who insists he remarry. As Lady Sour’s broadsides grip London, the Prime Minister adds another responsibility to Roman’s plate: find Lady Sour.
An affair that could destroy them both
As Sophia surrenders to a dangerous passion, Roman risks his career on a ferocious attraction that fast becomes about more than winning. Will Roman sacrifice his ambitions for Sophia, and will Sophia allow Roman to throw it all away for her?
A Scandal Changes Everything, Book 1 in the SOCIETY OF WOMEN REVOLUTIONARIES series, is a steamy historical romance of second chances, family, and a man’s ability to believe in the woman he loves.
TW: Emotional breakdown, gas-lighting, stolen child, open door, profanity
There’s no way around it, Sophia St. Clair is notorious, a cautionary tale to all of London’s young ladies on being found standing amidst shrubbery, alone with a man.
If Society only knew the whole story.
Sophia’s illegitimate daughter was stolen from her arms, and she’ll do anything to find her. Disguised as Madame Pigeon, Sophia supports her search by writing speeches for the condemned and, as Lady Sour, wildly-popular, just a tad seditious, broadsides on a woman’s lot.
A powerful earl determined to bare Sophia’s secrets
Roman Montvilliers, the widowed Earl of Haslemere, has responsibilities to rival his power: an illustrious political career, a philandering brother, a five-year old daughter without a mother, and a mother who insists he remarry. As Lady Sour’s broadsides grip London, the Prime Minister adds another responsibility to Roman’s plate: find Lady Sour.
An affair that could destroy them both
As Sophia surrenders to a dangerous passion, Roman risks his career on a ferocious attraction that fast becomes about more than winning. Will Roman sacrifice his ambitions for Sophia, and will Sophia allow Roman to throw it all away for her?
A Scandal Changes Everything, Book 1 in the SOCIETY OF WOMEN REVOLUTIONARIES series, is a steamy historical romance of second chances, family, and a man’s ability to believe in the woman he loves.
TW: Emotional breakdown, gas-lighting, stolen child, open door, profanity
421 pages, Kindle Edition
First published January 12, 2026
76 people are currently reading
62 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 51 reviews
Review of advance copy
Thanks to Booksprout for a copy of this story and this is my freely given opinion.
This is listed as book 1 of this series, but there are characters and relationships to other books by this author - on saying that, I am just pointing it out, and those books do not have to be read to enjoy this story. I just wanted to point that out, and this is a story of the St Clair family.
This is an emotional, heart breaking, messy story of betrayal, scandal, and loss, but also of perseverence, resiliance and rebuilding.
Sophia St. Clair appeared to have it all, as a debutante, a society beauty, born to a Society family with a noted and influential politician. All of this was lost when she was caught alone in the garden with a man, and this started a storm of ruinous gossip. It was bad enough to lose her place in society and a possible future of ease and weath if she had married well. But she also secretly birthed a baby girl, who was then torn from her arms. This spirals further as her own family gaslights Sophia, in an attempt to keep her shame a secret and save their own reputation, leading to her being tossed out by her mother, after the death of her father.
She rises above her loss and makes a new life for herself, and with some supports from her sisters, to run a business and secretly a writer, primarily speeches for condemned criminals, but is encouraged to start printing revolutionary articles that are becoming more popular with the public. She uses her earning to hire an investigator to search for her lost daughter.
The writings of Lady Sour, Sophia's alias, are rising in popularity and rising the ire of noted politicians, and Lord Roman Montvilliers, the widowed Earl of Haslemere, is tasked with finding and revealing the seditious author. Roman has his hands full already, as a dutiful lord with great influence, a single father to a young girl he adores, a meddling, manipulative mother intent on finding him a new, and appropriate Society wife to polish his reputation, and a scandalous, philandering wastrel brother to rein in. But he does his duty to the PM and works to discover the author to the notorious broadsides.
As Roman and Sophia meet, and an attraction develops, their relationship is fraught by both their past relationships, and the complexities and interference of ther families. As well, there are lies and hidden truths which interfer as well, as Roman and Sophia engage in a torrid affair, that grows to become more, but with much to overcome. This is a messy, messy story, but an intriguing, dramatic, and emotional one that I did thoroughly enjoy. There is the torrid romance, the past scandal, but there is also family drama of truly phenomenal proportions on both sides that ramp up the tension and drama, and so much that Sophia and Roman must overcome and accept to find their way to each other. There is much in both their pasts which become barriers to overcome to find their future happiness together, including the ghost of Roman's wife and his love and guilt over his past with her.
Messy, emotional, wonderful read that takes you on quite an emotional roller coaster.
... and having read the other stories by this author, and knowing that Sophia is of the St. Clair family, my only question is why or how could the other St Clairs - like Georgiana (Lessons for Marquesses) allow Sophia to be abandoned and maltreated so much without offering her some support or a home if they knew what she suffered??
4.75 stars out of 5
This is listed as book 1 of this series, but there are characters and relationships to other books by this author - on saying that, I am just pointing it out, and those books do not have to be read to enjoy this story. I just wanted to point that out, and this is a story of the St Clair family.
This is an emotional, heart breaking, messy story of betrayal, scandal, and loss, but also of perseverence, resiliance and rebuilding.
Sophia St. Clair appeared to have it all, as a debutante, a society beauty, born to a Society family with a noted and influential politician. All of this was lost when she was caught alone in the garden with a man, and this started a storm of ruinous gossip. It was bad enough to lose her place in society and a possible future of ease and weath if she had married well. But she also secretly birthed a baby girl, who was then torn from her arms. This spirals further as her own family gaslights Sophia, in an attempt to keep her shame a secret and save their own reputation, leading to her being tossed out by her mother, after the death of her father.
She rises above her loss and makes a new life for herself, and with some supports from her sisters, to run a business and secretly a writer, primarily speeches for condemned criminals, but is encouraged to start printing revolutionary articles that are becoming more popular with the public. She uses her earning to hire an investigator to search for her lost daughter.
The writings of Lady Sour, Sophia's alias, are rising in popularity and rising the ire of noted politicians, and Lord Roman Montvilliers, the widowed Earl of Haslemere, is tasked with finding and revealing the seditious author. Roman has his hands full already, as a dutiful lord with great influence, a single father to a young girl he adores, a meddling, manipulative mother intent on finding him a new, and appropriate Society wife to polish his reputation, and a scandalous, philandering wastrel brother to rein in. But he does his duty to the PM and works to discover the author to the notorious broadsides.
As Roman and Sophia meet, and an attraction develops, their relationship is fraught by both their past relationships, and the complexities and interference of ther families. As well, there are lies and hidden truths which interfer as well, as Roman and Sophia engage in a torrid affair, that grows to become more, but with much to overcome. This is a messy, messy story, but an intriguing, dramatic, and emotional one that I did thoroughly enjoy. There is the torrid romance, the past scandal, but there is also family drama of truly phenomenal proportions on both sides that ramp up the tension and drama, and so much that Sophia and Roman must overcome and accept to find their way to each other. There is much in both their pasts which become barriers to overcome to find their future happiness together, including the ghost of Roman's wife and his love and guilt over his past with her.
Messy, emotional, wonderful read that takes you on quite an emotional roller coaster.
... and having read the other stories by this author, and knowing that Sophia is of the St. Clair family, my only question is why or how could the other St Clairs - like Georgiana (Lessons for Marquesses) allow Sophia to be abandoned and maltreated so much without offering her some support or a home if they knew what she suffered??
4.75 stars out of 5
January 12, 2026
A wonderful, very well-written Georgian romance novel that is equally full of pain, drama, trauma, betrayal, secrets and loss, but also offers many funny moments, unexpected twists and turns, and steamy love scenes. I really enjoyed the author's playful narrative style, the situational comedy, the witty dialogue, the emotional depth and the multitude of quirky supporting characters. The gripping plot is well paced and contains enemies to lovers, forbidden love, hidden/secret identity, secret child and second chance at love tropes.
Sophia and Roman are lovable and complex characters who still struggle with their past and have many obstacles to overcome. Roman is plagued by guilt and must choose between love and career, and Sophia is a ruined, strong and determined heroine who fights for women's empowerment, for her child, and to prove her sanity. I genuinely disliked their mothers, especially the actions of Sophia's mother, which were heartbreaking and repulsive, but that made the bond with her sister Mariah and her friends all the more beautiful. I also liked the heartwarming relationship between Roman and his daughter.
It was only as the story unfolded that I realised it was connected to the author's previous series (the Rakes & Ruin series) and that Sophia was Oliver's daughter, a supporting character I had liked very much at the time and whose early death had made me sad.
Sophia St. Clair is known as the „Scandalous ’71 St.Clair“ after being ruined and spurned by a rake, ostracized by the ton and expelled by her own mother. The child that resulted from her indiscretion was taken from her shortly after birth, and Sophia has made it her life's mission to find her little daughter Olivia, even though her family tries to convince her that she is insane and that the child only existed in her imagination. Now she owns a circulating library as Madame Pigeon, is a member of the „Society of Women Revolutionaries“, writes speeches for doomed criminals and, as Lady Sour, inflammatory articles about women’s subjugation and female empowerment.
Lord Roman Montvilliers, Earl of Haslemere, is a widowed single father who still mourns the loss of his late wife. He is honorable, politically active, advises the Prime Minister and the King, and, as head of his family, is responsible for its reputation and wellbeing.
From the moment their paths cross, Roman is fascinated by Madame Pigeon, who dares to stand up to him. However, he soon discovers that she is the scandal-ridden Sophia St. Clair. Marriage is impossible without ruining his career, so he offers her to become his mistress, also to thwart his mother's attempts to arrange a marriage for him. Their passionate relationship becomes increasingly intense, but Sophia's past becomes more complex and obscure, and Roman is tasked by the king and the prime minister with finding out who is behind Lady Sour, who is on the verge of being charged with sedition…
If you like complex, twisted and spicy forbidden love romances that make you feel raw and make you laugh at the same time, then this book is just right for you!
I received a free ARC of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own and left voluntarily.
Sophia and Roman are lovable and complex characters who still struggle with their past and have many obstacles to overcome. Roman is plagued by guilt and must choose between love and career, and Sophia is a ruined, strong and determined heroine who fights for women's empowerment, for her child, and to prove her sanity. I genuinely disliked their mothers, especially the actions of Sophia's mother, which were heartbreaking and repulsive, but that made the bond with her sister Mariah and her friends all the more beautiful. I also liked the heartwarming relationship between Roman and his daughter.
It was only as the story unfolded that I realised it was connected to the author's previous series (the Rakes & Ruin series) and that Sophia was Oliver's daughter, a supporting character I had liked very much at the time and whose early death had made me sad.
Sophia St. Clair is known as the „Scandalous ’71 St.Clair“ after being ruined and spurned by a rake, ostracized by the ton and expelled by her own mother. The child that resulted from her indiscretion was taken from her shortly after birth, and Sophia has made it her life's mission to find her little daughter Olivia, even though her family tries to convince her that she is insane and that the child only existed in her imagination. Now she owns a circulating library as Madame Pigeon, is a member of the „Society of Women Revolutionaries“, writes speeches for doomed criminals and, as Lady Sour, inflammatory articles about women’s subjugation and female empowerment.
Lord Roman Montvilliers, Earl of Haslemere, is a widowed single father who still mourns the loss of his late wife. He is honorable, politically active, advises the Prime Minister and the King, and, as head of his family, is responsible for its reputation and wellbeing.
From the moment their paths cross, Roman is fascinated by Madame Pigeon, who dares to stand up to him. However, he soon discovers that she is the scandal-ridden Sophia St. Clair. Marriage is impossible without ruining his career, so he offers her to become his mistress, also to thwart his mother's attempts to arrange a marriage for him. Their passionate relationship becomes increasingly intense, but Sophia's past becomes more complex and obscure, and Roman is tasked by the king and the prime minister with finding out who is behind Lady Sour, who is on the verge of being charged with sedition…
If you like complex, twisted and spicy forbidden love romances that make you feel raw and make you laugh at the same time, then this book is just right for you!
I received a free ARC of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own and left voluntarily.
January 25, 2026
Roman and Sophia
“A Scandal Changes Everything” written by Josie Johns is book one in her new series Society of Women Revolutionaries. This is an excellent start to this series dedicated to extraordinary women. Sophia St. Clair is such a woman. She is extremely intelligent, has the ability to write speeches and political broadsides, is quick witted, passionate, and a survivor. The kind of character I love reading about. Sophia was publicly ruined, she was seen in a garden standing near a man by a rival debutante who swooned (not really) to exacerbate the situation. The man in the garden disappeared when Sofia informed him she was pregnant. If society knew of the pregnancy, humiliation and being ostracized would have been permanent. Sophia is such a great, emotional character who had many sides of her personality. I liked Sophia’s determination to search for her daughter after her mother, aunt, and uncle spirited her away after her birth. It was understandable what happened to Sophia caused by pain and anger of the loss. Sophia persevered. The main male character is Roman, an Earl, a widower with a young daughter, and a powerful politician with a very dominant personality . Roman works for the king and the prime minister. This story is about a second chance at a happy ever after for these two very different characters. Also, their relationship, in this time period (early 1770s) is forbidden because of Sophia’s ruination and Roman’s position as a powerful earl with the possibility of becoming 3prime minister if his reputation remained spotless. This book definitely points out the disparity between the sexes. A man was never “ruined” for being caught in the garden, a child wouldn’t have been taken from him against his will. I thoroughly enjoyed this historical romance. There is a lot going on to draw the reader in and stay the distance. The flow and pacing of this story works. The reader learns about past actions that affect the present through well placed flashbacks or explanations. I liked both Sophia and Roman. I liked how these two met and that they were drawn to one another from then on. This was an open door romance, the intimate scenes were super steamy and extremely passionate yet tastefully written. These scenes reflected their personalities. I also liked Sophia’s relationship with her sisters, which was very realistic, and her friend and business partner Priya. Roman’s valet was an important character, he was not only a long time servant but a friend and a confidant to Roman. I must add that I’m also a sucker for a story with an important pet no matter the genre. The story wouldn’t have been as good without Penny, a very precocious pigeon. That’s correct, her beloved pet is a pigeon! This is definitely a story I can recommend and I can’t wait to read the next in the series.
I received a free copy of this book, my thoughts and opinions are entirely my own
“A Scandal Changes Everything” written by Josie Johns is book one in her new series Society of Women Revolutionaries. This is an excellent start to this series dedicated to extraordinary women. Sophia St. Clair is such a woman. She is extremely intelligent, has the ability to write speeches and political broadsides, is quick witted, passionate, and a survivor. The kind of character I love reading about. Sophia was publicly ruined, she was seen in a garden standing near a man by a rival debutante who swooned (not really) to exacerbate the situation. The man in the garden disappeared when Sofia informed him she was pregnant. If society knew of the pregnancy, humiliation and being ostracized would have been permanent. Sophia is such a great, emotional character who had many sides of her personality. I liked Sophia’s determination to search for her daughter after her mother, aunt, and uncle spirited her away after her birth. It was understandable what happened to Sophia caused by pain and anger of the loss. Sophia persevered. The main male character is Roman, an Earl, a widower with a young daughter, and a powerful politician with a very dominant personality . Roman works for the king and the prime minister. This story is about a second chance at a happy ever after for these two very different characters. Also, their relationship, in this time period (early 1770s) is forbidden because of Sophia’s ruination and Roman’s position as a powerful earl with the possibility of becoming 3prime minister if his reputation remained spotless. This book definitely points out the disparity between the sexes. A man was never “ruined” for being caught in the garden, a child wouldn’t have been taken from him against his will. I thoroughly enjoyed this historical romance. There is a lot going on to draw the reader in and stay the distance. The flow and pacing of this story works. The reader learns about past actions that affect the present through well placed flashbacks or explanations. I liked both Sophia and Roman. I liked how these two met and that they were drawn to one another from then on. This was an open door romance, the intimate scenes were super steamy and extremely passionate yet tastefully written. These scenes reflected their personalities. I also liked Sophia’s relationship with her sisters, which was very realistic, and her friend and business partner Priya. Roman’s valet was an important character, he was not only a long time servant but a friend and a confidant to Roman. I must add that I’m also a sucker for a story with an important pet no matter the genre. The story wouldn’t have been as good without Penny, a very precocious pigeon. That’s correct, her beloved pet is a pigeon! This is definitely a story I can recommend and I can’t wait to read the next in the series.
I received a free copy of this book, my thoughts and opinions are entirely my own
February 17, 2026
This book worked on me at every level. Clean, smooth writing with a good, steady pace. The plots twisted nicely around one another and I was pleased when certain small moments didn’t turn into giant gotchas, but were instead used to develop side characters — all of whom had actual personalities and opinions, and didn’t just bow to the whims of the story. The world felt real and researched, and the author clearly understands the social mores and machinations of the time she’s writing in.
I love historical romances that, when dealing with members of the upper class, treat them like intelligent people whose actions and attitudes are shaped by their upbringing, their society, and the pressure from family and friends to behave. Sophia has an unorthodox life as an author of broadsides, owner of a lending library and stationary shop, and disgraced member of society … and everyone is aware or it. They treat her, depending on their personal connection to her, either as an oddity, an example, or a subject of pity or scorn. When she says or does something, they react like people, not cartoon characters.
Roman is a man used to getting his way — and twice in the book he is more determined to sleep with Sophie when, from the text, it wasn’t her first choice. Not that she’s against it or unwilling, but it might have been second or third on her list, but Roman gets his way. He’s not an abuser or a tyrant, but he’s entitled by rank and money; he can destroy her family, her business, her life. He can also make her happy, and safe, and … well, she’s in love with him.
The book is equally full of arguments as banter, and they are a well matched pair. She’s already been cast out of society and so has no issue with turning her back on Roman. When Roman goes after her, again and again, she keeps choosing her pride, until he gives her something she didn’t realize she was dying without. Her self respect. He gives her the freedom to actually say no, the freedom to tell him to stop coming back, to stop flirting. And I think it’s that moment that made this a five star book for me.
Roman has thoughts, opinions, and will use Sophie for his own gains. He’s also compassionate, thoughtful, and someone who likes to make other people happy. His response to Sophie’s child, and to the reveal — from Sophie’s mother — about the child, was perfect. And that twist was just so well done, both for Sophie and for those around her.
If you’re looking for a solid historical with clever plotting, strong characters, writing and pacing … do pick this book up. It’s one I can see myself coming back to for a reread. Thank you so very much to the publisher and Net Galley for the ARC!
I love historical romances that, when dealing with members of the upper class, treat them like intelligent people whose actions and attitudes are shaped by their upbringing, their society, and the pressure from family and friends to behave. Sophia has an unorthodox life as an author of broadsides, owner of a lending library and stationary shop, and disgraced member of society … and everyone is aware or it. They treat her, depending on their personal connection to her, either as an oddity, an example, or a subject of pity or scorn. When she says or does something, they react like people, not cartoon characters.
Roman is a man used to getting his way — and twice in the book he is more determined to sleep with Sophie when, from the text, it wasn’t her first choice. Not that she’s against it or unwilling, but it might have been second or third on her list, but Roman gets his way. He’s not an abuser or a tyrant, but he’s entitled by rank and money; he can destroy her family, her business, her life. He can also make her happy, and safe, and … well, she’s in love with him.
The book is equally full of arguments as banter, and they are a well matched pair. She’s already been cast out of society and so has no issue with turning her back on Roman. When Roman goes after her, again and again, she keeps choosing her pride, until he gives her something she didn’t realize she was dying without. Her self respect. He gives her the freedom to actually say no, the freedom to tell him to stop coming back, to stop flirting. And I think it’s that moment that made this a five star book for me.
Roman has thoughts, opinions, and will use Sophie for his own gains. He’s also compassionate, thoughtful, and someone who likes to make other people happy. His response to Sophie’s child, and to the reveal — from Sophie’s mother — about the child, was perfect. And that twist was just so well done, both for Sophie and for those around her.
If you’re looking for a solid historical with clever plotting, strong characters, writing and pacing … do pick this book up. It’s one I can see myself coming back to for a reread. Thank you so very much to the publisher and Net Galley for the ARC!
November 9, 2025
"A Scandal Changes Everything" launches the Society of Women Revolutionaries series with an engaging blend of forbidden romance, historical politics, and the enduring theme of second chances. This debut delivers a rich, satisfying story that sets a high bar for the books to follow.
The central relationship between Sophia and Roman is the undisputed heart of the novel. The author skilfully manages their dynamic, avoiding the pitfall of rushed romance. Instead, their connection is slow-burn, based on a genuine, intellectual compatibility that makes the eventual romantic tension rewarding and believable. The witty, fast-paced dialogue between them provides great back-and-forth, establishing them as equals rather than tropes.
Sophia is a truly impressive heroine—intelligent, strong, and deeply determined not to let past betrayals or life’s challenges define her future. Equally admirable is Roman's development. His realisation of his love for Sophia is genuinely moving, and his consistent support, regardless of the mounting societal challenges, paints him as a compelling and supportive leading man.
The narrative strikes an excellent balance between the core romance, the political plot, and the historical context. It keeps the pace engaging, though I did find a few sections could have been tightened up slightly for conciseness. While the plot involving the mother’s affliction felt like an unnecessary complication—as Sophia and Roman already faced enough formidable external conflicts—the story managed to tie up all other loose ends very nicely, providing a satisfying sense of closure.
The spicy scenes are handled well, landing in the 2 to 3 🌶️, but what truly elevated them was the emotional component, particularly after the MCs’ first coupling and the respectful inclusion of references to Roman's deceased wife. It’s clear this story was well thought out from every angle.
Ultimately, A Scandal Changes Everything is a beautifully told story that leaves the reader eagerly anticipating more. I’m particularly invested in learning more about Timmy and Mariah’s true involvement, and excited to see if Casey will get her own deserving second chance. A brilliant start to a promising new series.
⚠️ Trigger Warnings for Readers:
Emotional breakdown
Gaslighting
Stolen child
Open door spice
Profanity
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
The central relationship between Sophia and Roman is the undisputed heart of the novel. The author skilfully manages their dynamic, avoiding the pitfall of rushed romance. Instead, their connection is slow-burn, based on a genuine, intellectual compatibility that makes the eventual romantic tension rewarding and believable. The witty, fast-paced dialogue between them provides great back-and-forth, establishing them as equals rather than tropes.
Sophia is a truly impressive heroine—intelligent, strong, and deeply determined not to let past betrayals or life’s challenges define her future. Equally admirable is Roman's development. His realisation of his love for Sophia is genuinely moving, and his consistent support, regardless of the mounting societal challenges, paints him as a compelling and supportive leading man.
The narrative strikes an excellent balance between the core romance, the political plot, and the historical context. It keeps the pace engaging, though I did find a few sections could have been tightened up slightly for conciseness. While the plot involving the mother’s affliction felt like an unnecessary complication—as Sophia and Roman already faced enough formidable external conflicts—the story managed to tie up all other loose ends very nicely, providing a satisfying sense of closure.
The spicy scenes are handled well, landing in the 2 to 3 🌶️, but what truly elevated them was the emotional component, particularly after the MCs’ first coupling and the respectful inclusion of references to Roman's deceased wife. It’s clear this story was well thought out from every angle.
Ultimately, A Scandal Changes Everything is a beautifully told story that leaves the reader eagerly anticipating more. I’m particularly invested in learning more about Timmy and Mariah’s true involvement, and excited to see if Casey will get her own deserving second chance. A brilliant start to a promising new series.
⚠️ Trigger Warnings for Readers:
Emotional breakdown
Gaslighting
Stolen child
Open door spice
Profanity
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Set in a time period not often utilised by ‘Regency’ romance writers A Scandal Changes Everything is based in the Politics of 1770’s Britain when Lord North was the Prime Minister and England was involved in the War of Independence in America.
Societies rules were strict and anyone, namely women, found breaking those rules was an immediate outcast, a ruined woman, a family shame and disgrace. Hanging was commonplace for a wide range of crimes and worse if you were considered as a traitor to England.
Sophie St Clair was a social outcast, having been found standing in a garden with a very handsome man, later to give birth to a child which was then removed from her at the tender age of six months. She is known in society as the scandalous ’71. On a small inheritance she has established herself as the owner of small bookstore, writes letters and speeches for the condemned and also for a broadsheet under the pen name of Lady Sour.
She and her sisters have formed a Society of Women Revolutionaries determined to make change; Mariah her third sister is engaged in Moneylending and other illegal but profitable enterprises, whereas Cassandra is Lady Cassandra Ellington, wife to man she cannot stand but suffers, as he gives her a place in Society which due to her birthright she deserves. Her youngest sister is yet to be launched into Society.
Roman Montvilliers, Earl of Hazelmere is a powerful man both politically and through his title of Earl. He sits on the right hand of the prime minister, is widowed and the father to a small daughter. He has a mother who wishes him married again and has a book of likely prospects, one of whom, even though it is crossed through many times, is the Honourable Miss Sophie St Clair, daughter of Lord Oliver St Clair, respected politician, now deceased.
When Roman and Sophie come together in a range of most unusual circumstances it is the beginning of a romance that does not proceed according to any plan, rubs dangerously up against the volatile politics of the day and could end in bliss or death.
A Scandal Changes Everything contains a raft of entertaining issues held together with a very well researched historic background that makes the story well worth the telling. Add strong characters, a little or a lot of levity, a good sense of humour from Josie Johns and there you have an exceptionally entertaining historic romance, 1772 style.
Societies rules were strict and anyone, namely women, found breaking those rules was an immediate outcast, a ruined woman, a family shame and disgrace. Hanging was commonplace for a wide range of crimes and worse if you were considered as a traitor to England.
Sophie St Clair was a social outcast, having been found standing in a garden with a very handsome man, later to give birth to a child which was then removed from her at the tender age of six months. She is known in society as the scandalous ’71. On a small inheritance she has established herself as the owner of small bookstore, writes letters and speeches for the condemned and also for a broadsheet under the pen name of Lady Sour.
She and her sisters have formed a Society of Women Revolutionaries determined to make change; Mariah her third sister is engaged in Moneylending and other illegal but profitable enterprises, whereas Cassandra is Lady Cassandra Ellington, wife to man she cannot stand but suffers, as he gives her a place in Society which due to her birthright she deserves. Her youngest sister is yet to be launched into Society.
Roman Montvilliers, Earl of Hazelmere is a powerful man both politically and through his title of Earl. He sits on the right hand of the prime minister, is widowed and the father to a small daughter. He has a mother who wishes him married again and has a book of likely prospects, one of whom, even though it is crossed through many times, is the Honourable Miss Sophie St Clair, daughter of Lord Oliver St Clair, respected politician, now deceased.
When Roman and Sophie come together in a range of most unusual circumstances it is the beginning of a romance that does not proceed according to any plan, rubs dangerously up against the volatile politics of the day and could end in bliss or death.
A Scandal Changes Everything contains a raft of entertaining issues held together with a very well researched historic background that makes the story well worth the telling. Add strong characters, a little or a lot of levity, a good sense of humour from Josie Johns and there you have an exceptionally entertaining historic romance, 1772 style.
December 29, 2025
REVIEW
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for this ARC. I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
👩🏼❤️👨🏼👩🏼❤️👨🏼
STORYLINE (40%): 30%
Technically, I didn't really get the storyline promised in the synopsis. It fell short, and some things fell short. I would have loved it if the Lady Sour aspect had been explored more and with hints of danger and mystery surrounding it. I liked the MCs' relationship, but it was not what I expected. It happened too fast, I wanted some drama before the actual relationship. I loved the raw emotions the FMC, Sophia, experienced at her great loss. I felt her pain. I also liked the mystery surrounding Sophia's rake. Everything tied up perfectly at the end.
I would have loved an extensive epilogue too.
👩🏼❤️👨🏼👩🏼❤️👨🏼
CHARACTERS (20%)- 20%
The characters were perfect. The good guys were really good and you have no choice but to hate the villains. Sophia, the FMC is a gentle, tough spirit. It was nice to see her get herself back together despite her loss. She's a CEO and an excellent writer and a revolutionary.
The MMC, Roman is a very good guy. I liked him as a lover brother, father, and son. He did the right thing, and I liked that
I loved the side characters too especially Sophis's sister, Mariah. My least favourite character is Sophia's mom, she's horrible.
👩🏼❤️👨🏼👩🏼❤️👨🏼
WRITING STYLE (20%): 15%
It was really okay, the words and sentences were flowing and I liked it. I especially liked the Lady Sour's segments.
👩🏼❤️👨🏼👩🏼❤️👨🏼
SETTINGS (20%): 15%
The settings were limited, and I wanted more. On the other hand, it was understandable considering the storyline. We only revolved around the MMC's house, the cottage, and the FMC's shop. But, I liked that important social matters were addressed like women's lack of rights and Britain's colonialism.
👩🏼❤️👨🏼👩🏼❤️👨🏼
OVERALL (100%): 80%
I liked this book and I was able to read it in a day. I can't wait to read the stories of the other St Clair girls. I liked that the villains got the punishment they deserved.
👩🏼❤️👨🏼👩🏼❤️👨🏼
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for this ARC. I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
👩🏼❤️👨🏼👩🏼❤️👨🏼
STORYLINE (40%): 30%
Technically, I didn't really get the storyline promised in the synopsis. It fell short, and some things fell short. I would have loved it if the Lady Sour aspect had been explored more and with hints of danger and mystery surrounding it. I liked the MCs' relationship, but it was not what I expected. It happened too fast, I wanted some drama before the actual relationship. I loved the raw emotions the FMC, Sophia, experienced at her great loss. I felt her pain. I also liked the mystery surrounding Sophia's rake. Everything tied up perfectly at the end.
I would have loved an extensive epilogue too.
👩🏼❤️👨🏼👩🏼❤️👨🏼
CHARACTERS (20%)- 20%
The characters were perfect. The good guys were really good and you have no choice but to hate the villains. Sophia, the FMC is a gentle, tough spirit. It was nice to see her get herself back together despite her loss. She's a CEO and an excellent writer and a revolutionary.
The MMC, Roman is a very good guy. I liked him as a lover brother, father, and son. He did the right thing, and I liked that
I loved the side characters too especially Sophis's sister, Mariah. My least favourite character is Sophia's mom, she's horrible.
👩🏼❤️👨🏼👩🏼❤️👨🏼
WRITING STYLE (20%): 15%
It was really okay, the words and sentences were flowing and I liked it. I especially liked the Lady Sour's segments.
👩🏼❤️👨🏼👩🏼❤️👨🏼
SETTINGS (20%): 15%
The settings were limited, and I wanted more. On the other hand, it was understandable considering the storyline. We only revolved around the MMC's house, the cottage, and the FMC's shop. But, I liked that important social matters were addressed like women's lack of rights and Britain's colonialism.
👩🏼❤️👨🏼👩🏼❤️👨🏼
OVERALL (100%): 80%
I liked this book and I was able to read it in a day. I can't wait to read the stories of the other St Clair girls. I liked that the villains got the punishment they deserved.
👩🏼❤️👨🏼👩🏼❤️👨🏼
January 24, 2026
A Scandal Changes Everything is the first book in the Society of Women Revolutionaries series. This can be a stand-alone read.
Sophia St. Clair appeared to have it all, as a debutante, a society beauty, born to a Society family with a noted and influential politician until a misstep in the garden over a bench changed everything. The gossip began with Sophia being seen standing in the garden with a man. After that her future was never the same.
While she was sent away, she gave birth to a baby girl named Olivia. The baby was taken away, and Sophia was told there was no baby, she imagined the whole thing. Sophia had a breakdown while trying to prove the baby was not her imagination. In the years that followed she has tried to find the baby that was stolen from her. After the death of her father, Sophia is thrown out of the house to save her sister's reputation. But her mother treats her terribly and she finds her way by running a business and becoming a writer under the name 'Lady Sour.'
Meanwhile Roman, Lord Roman Montvilliers, Earl of Haslemere, a widower with a child. is tasked to find 'Lady Sour', meets Sophia, who is masquerading in the name 'Lady Pigeon.' He is taken with her intelligence. The more time he spends with her, the more he is drawn to her. But his family has a scandal of its own, with his brother, a scandalous, philandering wastrel., who is addicted to his lifestyle and not interested in changing for his wife and daughter.
This is a complicated story full of ups and downs as the writer weaves an emotional story. The ending is rewarding and worth investing in the trials of Sophia. I hope to see more of Sophia and Roman in the next chapter. I hope there is more to tell about this couple.
I received an ARC from NetGalley for an unbiased review.
Sophia St. Clair appeared to have it all, as a debutante, a society beauty, born to a Society family with a noted and influential politician until a misstep in the garden over a bench changed everything. The gossip began with Sophia being seen standing in the garden with a man. After that her future was never the same.
While she was sent away, she gave birth to a baby girl named Olivia. The baby was taken away, and Sophia was told there was no baby, she imagined the whole thing. Sophia had a breakdown while trying to prove the baby was not her imagination. In the years that followed she has tried to find the baby that was stolen from her. After the death of her father, Sophia is thrown out of the house to save her sister's reputation. But her mother treats her terribly and she finds her way by running a business and becoming a writer under the name 'Lady Sour.'
Meanwhile Roman, Lord Roman Montvilliers, Earl of Haslemere, a widower with a child. is tasked to find 'Lady Sour', meets Sophia, who is masquerading in the name 'Lady Pigeon.' He is taken with her intelligence. The more time he spends with her, the more he is drawn to her. But his family has a scandal of its own, with his brother, a scandalous, philandering wastrel., who is addicted to his lifestyle and not interested in changing for his wife and daughter.
This is a complicated story full of ups and downs as the writer weaves an emotional story. The ending is rewarding and worth investing in the trials of Sophia. I hope to see more of Sophia and Roman in the next chapter. I hope there is more to tell about this couple.
I received an ARC from NetGalley for an unbiased review.
November 10, 2025
4.5 stars
We have Sophia St Claire who lives on the fringes of society!
Sophia was taken advantage of a a garden party which resulted in a child! Her mother, aunt and others denied the existence of the child! When the child was removed Sophia sought to end her life! When she refused to denounce her existence well her mother and others literally cast her out!
She and Mariah have forged a life together! She has a writer and Mariah as a smuggler and sell the goods to the unsuspecting Ton!
Sophia writes under a secret identity to fund the search for her daughter! Her writing is brilliant and incendiary and according to the politician borderline treason!
Roman Montvilliers, the widowed Earl of Haslemere, has responsibilities to rival his an illustrious political career has an assignment!
He needs to find Lady Sour and the last thing he needs is to find Lady Sophia beautiful and intriguing! Sophia is afraid of society and wants nothing to do with it after the betrayal and heartache it has caused her!
But Roman won’t be stopped much like his name he sets out to conquer! He sets out his command with gifts, money and extravagant gestures!
Sophia is love starved and shares very little beyond the physical with him!
There are times she is so closed mouthed at the “wrong” times I could shake her! She allows Roman to form incorrect opinions of her actions by refusing to reveal the truth!
More secrets, more deceptions but Roman against all hope believes her and sets out to restore the one things she deems most precious! Does Roman prove himself yes again and again! Sophia not so much she has her reasons but not enough for me!
Do they finally get a HEA? They do deserve one! Roman more than anyone! Bravo!
I received an ARC copy for my unbiased review!
We have Sophia St Claire who lives on the fringes of society!
Sophia was taken advantage of a a garden party which resulted in a child! Her mother, aunt and others denied the existence of the child! When the child was removed Sophia sought to end her life! When she refused to denounce her existence well her mother and others literally cast her out!
She and Mariah have forged a life together! She has a writer and Mariah as a smuggler and sell the goods to the unsuspecting Ton!
Sophia writes under a secret identity to fund the search for her daughter! Her writing is brilliant and incendiary and according to the politician borderline treason!
Roman Montvilliers, the widowed Earl of Haslemere, has responsibilities to rival his an illustrious political career has an assignment!
He needs to find Lady Sour and the last thing he needs is to find Lady Sophia beautiful and intriguing! Sophia is afraid of society and wants nothing to do with it after the betrayal and heartache it has caused her!
But Roman won’t be stopped much like his name he sets out to conquer! He sets out his command with gifts, money and extravagant gestures!
Sophia is love starved and shares very little beyond the physical with him!
There are times she is so closed mouthed at the “wrong” times I could shake her! She allows Roman to form incorrect opinions of her actions by refusing to reveal the truth!
More secrets, more deceptions but Roman against all hope believes her and sets out to restore the one things she deems most precious! Does Roman prove himself yes again and again! Sophia not so much she has her reasons but not enough for me!
Do they finally get a HEA? They do deserve one! Roman more than anyone! Bravo!
I received an ARC copy for my unbiased review!
November 11, 2025
A love story built around second chances and mysteries:
Second Chances:
a second chance to fall in love for both Sophia and Roman; a second chance for Sophia to be a mother; and a second chance for s country to set right laws that favor one group over another.
Mysteries:
Who is “Evan”, and where is Olivia?
Sophia St. Claire, ill-used by a man known to her only as “Evan”, later gave birth to a little girl she named “Olivia” after Sophia’s deceased father. At 5 months old, Olivia was taken from Sophia by her own mother, while Sophia slept. Her mother then proceeds to try to convince Sophia there never was a child.
3 years later, Sophia is in London, writing articles in support of the rights of those abused by the country’s laws. She comes to cross-purposes with Roman Montvilliers, Earl of Haslemere, who finds himself first irritated, then enchanted with, Sophia.
The characters are so well developed that the reader is easily able to view the world from first Sophia’s point of view, then Roman’s, as they face situations that are real for the times. There are some open bedroom door scenes, tastefully done, that make this a work for mature audiences, but are not purposefully erotic. The point of the book is not such scenes, but the evaluation of English society at this point in history, and to find a happy outcome for Sophia and Roman.
I have not yet read any other of the books in this series, and indeed did not realize the book was part of a series, until reading the end notes. As I enjoyed this book so much, I intend to find and read the preceeding books next.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Second Chances:
a second chance to fall in love for both Sophia and Roman; a second chance for Sophia to be a mother; and a second chance for s country to set right laws that favor one group over another.
Mysteries:
Who is “Evan”, and where is Olivia?
Sophia St. Claire, ill-used by a man known to her only as “Evan”, later gave birth to a little girl she named “Olivia” after Sophia’s deceased father. At 5 months old, Olivia was taken from Sophia by her own mother, while Sophia slept. Her mother then proceeds to try to convince Sophia there never was a child.
3 years later, Sophia is in London, writing articles in support of the rights of those abused by the country’s laws. She comes to cross-purposes with Roman Montvilliers, Earl of Haslemere, who finds himself first irritated, then enchanted with, Sophia.
The characters are so well developed that the reader is easily able to view the world from first Sophia’s point of view, then Roman’s, as they face situations that are real for the times. There are some open bedroom door scenes, tastefully done, that make this a work for mature audiences, but are not purposefully erotic. The point of the book is not such scenes, but the evaluation of English society at this point in history, and to find a happy outcome for Sophia and Roman.
I have not yet read any other of the books in this series, and indeed did not realize the book was part of a series, until reading the end notes. As I enjoyed this book so much, I intend to find and read the preceeding books next.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
January 19, 2026
Wow! This is a really good book, but it is hard to review without ruining it for other readers. There is just so much going on. Sophia St. Clair, daughter of Viscount Acomb, was ruined. She ended up opening a stationery store under the name of Madame Pigeon. Her sister Mariah was a loan shark and dealt in questionable purchases and sales. Cassandra, another of the four sisters, married Viscount Etherington, and was miserable in her marriage. The youngest, Edie, still lived with their mother. Cassandra and Mariah talked Sophia into writing broadsheets, that spoke of the unfair treatment of women, criminals etc., under the name ‘Lady Sour’. The more popular the broadsheets became, the more uncomfortable the powers-that-be got. Roman Montvilliers, the Earl of Haslemere, a highly connected politician, was given the task of finding the elusive Lady Sour. On a mission regarding his wayward brother, Roman had a run in with Madame Pigeon that piqued his interest. What follows is an intricate and somewhat intense tale that is too complex to explain. You will find kidnapping, familial discord and distress, smuggling, convoluted courting, lies, accusations and steamy encounters. It took me a little bit to get into the author’s rhythm, but once I did, I couldn’t put it down. To say that it is an emotional rollercoaster is an understatement. It is well written, has twists, multiple surprises, a varied cast of characters, and a satisfying ending. Be prepared to clench your teeth, shake your head and stare in disbelief as you devour these pages. I can’t even imagine what the next book in the series will be like, but I am definitely looking forward to it.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Sophia St. Clair the eldest of the St. Clair sister was a scandal and had to b removed from her sister’s lives to prevent it from damaging their chances of marriage. Roman, the Earl of Haslemere, is a widower with a small daughter and who is being prompted by his mother to remarry to have an heir. As he is going through a book she provided him he comes across Sophia’s name. Sophia owns a stationery shop and wears spectacles and a mob cap to draw attention away from herself. As she is looking for her daughter, Olivia, who was taken from her 3 years ago by her mother and an aunt and uncle, she meets Roman and gives her name as Madame Pigeon. Roman is intrigued by Sophia and propositioned her to spend time with him for money. Though she could use the money to assist with her search for Olivia, Sophia refuses. Roman investigates Sophia after he believes she is researching and his brother for blackmail purposes when he runs into her at a brothel. They eventually get together despite both of their mother’s objections but Sophia’ secrets that she hasn’t shared with Roman may be too complicated for their relationship to overcome. A Scandal Changes Everything is the second book I have read from Josie John’s and I am impressed with the characters she develops in her heartwarming and at times heartbreaking stories. Each of the characters and events in the book are described so vividly that the reader is able get a sense what each is experiencing as the plot develops. There is a lot of family drama involving grief, emotional and financial turmoil but eventually the main characters get their HEA.
I received an ARC from NetGalley and I am voluntarily leaving a review.
I received an ARC from NetGalley and I am voluntarily leaving a review.
November 13, 2025
Longer than many other romances, A Scandal Changes Everything allows you to spend enough time with its FMC, MMC, and supporting characters that by the time it is finally over, you’re desperately sad to have to say goodbye to what feels like a group of your friends. I adored the journey that Roman goes on as a man, as a romantic partner, and as a father. The central mystery to the book, having to do with did Sophia or did she not, have a child, is handled in a way that really entertained me because in the beginning I was so sure of things. And then as the author intended me to, I questioned what I knew. So that by the end when we finally get the answer, it feels much more earned than other conclusions to other mysteries. It’s so satisfying to see our FMC get her happily ever after in more than one way. While it is long, I felt the book was a fairly easy read. There are some quirks that took getting used to. And I didn’t really love or connect with Sophia as Madame Pigeon but I did like that our FMC had so many facets, and I enjoyed reading a love story with a woman so strong, who still succumbs to love without giving up who she is or who she wants to be. Finally, if you’re looking for a romance with an overabundance of intimate scenes, this isn’t that. But what there is, will make you hotter than a five alarm fire. I wasn’t familiar with Josie Johns until I read this but now I look forward to the rest of the series, and other books she’s already written. I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
January 22, 2026
Sophia St. Clair, Madame Pigeon or Pidge
Casandra, her sister and Viscountess
Mariah St. Clair, her sister and smuggler to of salt Peter to America
Edie, her sister, young and still at home
Mother, stole Sophia’s daughter
Aunt, stole Sophia’s daughter
Uncle, stole Sophia’s daughter
Roman Montvilliers, the widowed Earl of Haslemere
Mercy, his daughter, 5 years old
Hayden, his brother, father of Sophia’s daughter
Lydia, his sister, 16
This author was new-to-me and so I approached the book with a little trepidation but at the same time excitement! And I was not disappointed, this story was well written, well developed and the characters and dialogue are woven together so well that it kept me turning pages!
This story had it all, drama, family, friends, suspense with mystery and a touch of sadness. Sophia and Roman pulled me in with their separate stories but when they are brought together and the sparks fly, watch out!
The heat, the spice, the push & pull so wonderful. I loved the way that Roman believed in and stuck by Sophia’s side when she needed it the most.
The side characters (Sophia’s sisters, a pet pigeon) added humor, touching moments and grounded the main characters when the tough stuff started!
I am so happy that I read this book and I will be reading more from Josie and I’m looking forward to the next book in this series!
I would strongly recommend this story and series to everyone.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Casandra, her sister and Viscountess
Mariah St. Clair, her sister and smuggler to of salt Peter to America
Edie, her sister, young and still at home
Mother, stole Sophia’s daughter
Aunt, stole Sophia’s daughter
Uncle, stole Sophia’s daughter
Roman Montvilliers, the widowed Earl of Haslemere
Mercy, his daughter, 5 years old
Hayden, his brother, father of Sophia’s daughter
Lydia, his sister, 16
This author was new-to-me and so I approached the book with a little trepidation but at the same time excitement! And I was not disappointed, this story was well written, well developed and the characters and dialogue are woven together so well that it kept me turning pages!
This story had it all, drama, family, friends, suspense with mystery and a touch of sadness. Sophia and Roman pulled me in with their separate stories but when they are brought together and the sparks fly, watch out!
The heat, the spice, the push & pull so wonderful. I loved the way that Roman believed in and stuck by Sophia’s side when she needed it the most.
The side characters (Sophia’s sisters, a pet pigeon) added humor, touching moments and grounded the main characters when the tough stuff started!
I am so happy that I read this book and I will be reading more from Josie and I’m looking forward to the next book in this series!
I would strongly recommend this story and series to everyone.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
February 9, 2026
This has all the things I look for in a historical romance: scandal, secret identities, political trouble, and a romance that feels risky in the best way.
Sophia St. Clair is already infamous in London society, but what people don’t know is the devastating reason behind her reputation. Her illegitimate child was stolen, and everything Sophia does—writing radical broadsides as Lady Sour, disguising herself as Madame Pigeon, risking her safety and standing—is driven by that loss. She’s smart, angry, grieving, and determined, which made her incredibly compelling to read, and impossible not to want to root for her.
Roman Montvilliers, Earl of Haslemere, is equally torn between duty and desire. He’s a widower juggling politics, family pressure, and a young daughter, and when his hunt for the mysterious Lady Sour leads him straight to Sophia, sparks fly fast. Their romance is intense, messy, and full of real emotional stakes. This isn’t just attraction—it’s two people daring to want more than society allows.
The book mixes steamy romance with heavier themes like gas-lighting, loss, and women pushing against society’s rules. It definitely gets emotional at times, and even a little painful. Overall, this is a solid start to the series and left me wanting to see what happens next.
If you love second-chance romances and morally complicated characters, then this should prove to be a satisfying read.
I received a complimentary copy from NetGalley and am voluntarily leaving my review.
Sophia St. Clair is already infamous in London society, but what people don’t know is the devastating reason behind her reputation. Her illegitimate child was stolen, and everything Sophia does—writing radical broadsides as Lady Sour, disguising herself as Madame Pigeon, risking her safety and standing—is driven by that loss. She’s smart, angry, grieving, and determined, which made her incredibly compelling to read, and impossible not to want to root for her.
Roman Montvilliers, Earl of Haslemere, is equally torn between duty and desire. He’s a widower juggling politics, family pressure, and a young daughter, and when his hunt for the mysterious Lady Sour leads him straight to Sophia, sparks fly fast. Their romance is intense, messy, and full of real emotional stakes. This isn’t just attraction—it’s two people daring to want more than society allows.
The book mixes steamy romance with heavier themes like gas-lighting, loss, and women pushing against society’s rules. It definitely gets emotional at times, and even a little painful. Overall, this is a solid start to the series and left me wanting to see what happens next.
If you love second-chance romances and morally complicated characters, then this should prove to be a satisfying read.
I received a complimentary copy from NetGalley and am voluntarily leaving my review.
Review of advance copy
This is the story of Sophia St Clair and Roman Montvillier, the Earl of Haselmere. When Sophia is ruined she’s sent away to the country to have the baby, which is then taken from her against her will, but she never stops searching for her daughter. Roman has a chance encounter with Sophia in a brothel, and their worlds collide………..
This story reminds me of why I love good historical fiction. It’s well written, has great characters with an excellent plot, and it doesn’t hesitate to get down to the nitty gritty of just how bad life could be for women in the late eighteenth century.
It’s a story of second chances and how it’s not always easy to take them. Sophia is a complicated character who wants love but is afraid of hurting Roman with the scandal already attached to her. Roman has responsibilities to consider but also wishes to follow his heart. As their relationship develops you really get drawn into the story to the point where you hate to put the book down. The banter is great, the spicy scenes are extremely well written, and I loved the part where Sophia’s sister walks into her bedroom while disparaging her husband’s lack of sexual prowess, only to realise it’s actually Roman in the room and not Sophia. It really is an excellent start to the new Society of Women Revolutionaries series, and I can’t wait for the next book 🐈⬛.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
This story reminds me of why I love good historical fiction. It’s well written, has great characters with an excellent plot, and it doesn’t hesitate to get down to the nitty gritty of just how bad life could be for women in the late eighteenth century.
It’s a story of second chances and how it’s not always easy to take them. Sophia is a complicated character who wants love but is afraid of hurting Roman with the scandal already attached to her. Roman has responsibilities to consider but also wishes to follow his heart. As their relationship develops you really get drawn into the story to the point where you hate to put the book down. The banter is great, the spicy scenes are extremely well written, and I loved the part where Sophia’s sister walks into her bedroom while disparaging her husband’s lack of sexual prowess, only to realise it’s actually Roman in the room and not Sophia. It really is an excellent start to the new Society of Women Revolutionaries series, and I can’t wait for the next book 🐈⬛.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
January 26, 2026
This historical romance offers a truly intriguing setup. The female main character is a woman who had a child out of wedlock and secretly writes articles for various publications — a bold and scandalous act for the historical period, when women were largely limited to letters or private diaries. Her sharp, outspoken writing causes such a stir that even the Prime Minister wants to uncover her identity and put an end to it, which sets the romance in motion.
From there, the story unfolds in a very natural and engaging way. The writing style fits the historical epoch beautifully, making the setting feel authentic and immersive rather than forced or modernized. The social constraints, risks, and consequences feel believable, which adds real tension to both the plot and the romance.
What I especially appreciated is how the book highlights the quiet but powerful ways women fought for their voices and rights long before those struggles were widely acknowledged. The heroine’s rebellion isn’t loud or flashy, but it’s meaningful and courageous in a way that feels true to the time.
Overall, this is a well-crafted historical romance with an interesting premise, strong atmosphere, and a heroine you can genuinely admire. A lovely read for anyone who enjoys romance with depth, history, and a nod to the women who paved the way in their own unique ways.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
From there, the story unfolds in a very natural and engaging way. The writing style fits the historical epoch beautifully, making the setting feel authentic and immersive rather than forced or modernized. The social constraints, risks, and consequences feel believable, which adds real tension to both the plot and the romance.
What I especially appreciated is how the book highlights the quiet but powerful ways women fought for their voices and rights long before those struggles were widely acknowledged. The heroine’s rebellion isn’t loud or flashy, but it’s meaningful and courageous in a way that feels true to the time.
Overall, this is a well-crafted historical romance with an interesting premise, strong atmosphere, and a heroine you can genuinely admire. A lovely read for anyone who enjoys romance with depth, history, and a nod to the women who paved the way in their own unique ways.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
December 2, 2025
This is a big, sometimes messy, ambitious book: stolen baby, secret radical pamphleteer, widowed earl, plus a whole bunch of side quests including a “just sleeping” arrangement that is absolutely not just sleeping. The early chapters feel chaotic and some of Roman’s gestures (sir, the house??) land a little over the top, especially at first.
But once it finds its stride, it’s gripping. Sophia, finally getting her second chance, is vividly drawn—desperate, stubborn, and completely understandable even when her choices hurt. Roman’s hyper-political brain trying to protect his career while his heart sides with Sophia, and the gaslighting from her awful family makes his belief in her all the sweeter. The revolutionary politics, Lady Sour broadsides and subplot with her missing daughter all build into a tense, emotional payoff. By the end, the major plot threads click into place in a really satisfying way, even if a couple of side quests still feel extra.
Third-person dual POV, set mostly in 1770s London with plenty of nods to unrest in the American colonies. Messy in spots, but bold, emotional, and ultimately worth hanging in for.
Rounding up to a 4 star. Definitely worth the read.
But once it finds its stride, it’s gripping. Sophia, finally getting her second chance, is vividly drawn—desperate, stubborn, and completely understandable even when her choices hurt. Roman’s hyper-political brain trying to protect his career while his heart sides with Sophia, and the gaslighting from her awful family makes his belief in her all the sweeter. The revolutionary politics, Lady Sour broadsides and subplot with her missing daughter all build into a tense, emotional payoff. By the end, the major plot threads click into place in a really satisfying way, even if a couple of side quests still feel extra.
Third-person dual POV, set mostly in 1770s London with plenty of nods to unrest in the American colonies. Messy in spots, but bold, emotional, and ultimately worth hanging in for.
Rounding up to a 4 star. Definitely worth the read.
January 13, 2026
Sophia St. Clair is already notorious in London society, whispered about as a cautionary tale, yet few know the truth behind her reputation. Her illegitimate daughter was stolen from her, and Sophia will risk everything to find her, even disguising herself as the radical pamphleteer Lady Sour while secretly writing speeches for the condemned under the name Madame Pigeon. Roman Montvilliers, the widowed Earl of Haslemere is ambitious and burdened by duty. When he is tasked by the Prime Minister with uncovering the identity of Lady Sour, he is unaware that she is Sophia, a woman that he is drawn to. Their romance is intense and fraught with consequence, balancing fierce attraction with real emotional and political stakes.
I found this story shone in its portrayal of a heroine who refuses to be silenced and a hero forced to choose between power and love. Their romance was full of emotion, but I found myself frustrated that Sophia was not as open with Roman as she could have been, leading to misunderstandings between them. Her story is tragic, but with Roman, there is hope. A great read.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I found this story shone in its portrayal of a heroine who refuses to be silenced and a hero forced to choose between power and love. Their romance was full of emotion, but I found myself frustrated that Sophia was not as open with Roman as she could have been, leading to misunderstandings between them. Her story is tragic, but with Roman, there is hope. A great read.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
November 15, 2025
This is so much more than a modern 'regency' style romance. Set earlier in Georgian England, on one level it's an easily read romance, but it's underlain by the social mores of the time, particularly the differences between how men and women were allowed to behave and the awful hypocrisy when a young woman erred. It's a well-crafted story with well-drawn characters, including the children, various twists and turns and ups and downs covering so many different emotions, all leading to a satisfying ending, with some humour thrown in.
I love the way that Josie Johns has continued the story of the St Clairs, taking them through the generations. This book is stand alone - there's no need to have read the preceding books, but I suspect you will want to. I've enjoyed them all, but I think this is her best to date and look forward to more of her work. I do so hope she eventually gives us a grown up Mercy, even though she's not a St Clair!
I was lucky enough to receive an advance review copy for free and am very happy to leave this voluntary review in order to support this author.
I love the way that Josie Johns has continued the story of the St Clairs, taking them through the generations. This book is stand alone - there's no need to have read the preceding books, but I suspect you will want to. I've enjoyed them all, but I think this is her best to date and look forward to more of her work. I do so hope she eventually gives us a grown up Mercy, even though she's not a St Clair!
I was lucky enough to receive an advance review copy for free and am very happy to leave this voluntary review in order to support this author.
November 17, 2025
Sophia could have taken the easy path and accepted the future her family planned for her. Instead, she chose strength and conviction, determined to build a life on her own terms. I appreciated how her courage and independence developed throughout the story, especially as she learned that love and second chances can come when least expected.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
The relationship that grew between Sophia and the equally stubborn hero was heartfelt and sincere.However, some storylines felt unfinished or abandoned, leaving me wanting more closure. This created a bit of frustration as certain subplots seemed to fade away before reaching resolution. Despite these gaps, the emotional growth and resilience of the main character made the story worthwhile overall.Thank you to the publisher and BookSirens for providing a complimentary copy in exchange for an honest review.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
The relationship that grew between Sophia and the equally stubborn hero was heartfelt and sincere.However, some storylines felt unfinished or abandoned, leaving me wanting more closure. This created a bit of frustration as certain subplots seemed to fade away before reaching resolution. Despite these gaps, the emotional growth and resilience of the main character made the story worthwhile overall.Thank you to the publisher and BookSirens for providing a complimentary copy in exchange for an honest review.
January 20, 2026
I received an eBook copy of "A Scandal Changes Everything" from NetGalley in exchange for a fair and honest review. Sophia is a ruined woman, having had a child out of wedlock, given away to hide her shame. Roman is a Roman is a widower with a young daughter and a promising career in government as the Earl of Haslemere. When there worlds collide, Roman makes an indecent proposal- sleep in the same bed as him(just sleep) and he will pay Sophia the money to find her child. A game of wills between the two keeps the story interesting. I personally wish Roman would have been written as less cocky and pressuring, but get that his personality moves the story forward. His most redeeming quality is his loyalty to his first wife, and his seemingly active parenting for a story set in a time when men were not active parents. The sisters are fun characters, and I enjoyed their banter. Overall, while some cliche elements are found here, it was an interesting read that I finished in two sittings.
November 16, 2025
This was a fun Regency story featuring a group of women with refreshingly modern and revolutionary ideas. The star of the book is a young lady whose future was marred by scandal, leaving her in second-class status. She carves out an independent life by running a subscription library, writing speeches for men condemned to die, and penning scandalous essays for a newspaper under the pseudonym Lady Sour.
Her essays begin to ruffle feathers among the elite and royals, prompting the hero of the story—Roman—to investigate and uncover Lady Sour’s identity. The plot unfolds as Roman pieces together the mystery and the two decide what to do about the truth.
I thoroughly enjoyed this story and look forward to reading more in the series as they are released.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Her essays begin to ruffle feathers among the elite and royals, prompting the hero of the story—Roman—to investigate and uncover Lady Sour’s identity. The plot unfolds as Roman pieces together the mystery and the two decide what to do about the truth.
I thoroughly enjoyed this story and look forward to reading more in the series as they are released.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Review of advance copy received from Author
Very well written, full of drama, love, family, friends, intrigue, suspense, mystery and sadness. Sophia is a woman who has had lots of bad breaks from getting pregnant on her first time with a rogue to having a mother take her child away from her. She really has a bad time dealing with it and tries to hurt herself. She has been looking for her daughter, Olivia, which her tells her there was never a child. Roman is a Lord who hears from the King to find a writer that is causing trouble. Roman meets Sophia and finds he wants her and goes out of his way to have her. Add in her sister Mariah, a friend Timmy and other characters to the storyline and what a fabulous story you have. Would strongly recommend to everyone.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
December 4, 2025
My heart ached for Sophia from the start of the story on through. Her mother was a lying selfish monster. Sophia was taken advantage of during a party, and became pregnant. Her family sent her away to have the child at 18 and then returned to kidnap the baby ,so she didn't ruin chances for her sister's marriage prospects. How heartless and vile. She searched for her child for several years and employed a private investigator to no avail.
Sophia will never agree to mistress status. I cried so many times reading this, and hoped for a grand reunion. Will Roman and Sophia ever beat the odds against them? Take this emotional plunge? I voluntarily read a free copy of this book provided by book sirens and am giving an honest review.
Sophia will never agree to mistress status. I cried so many times reading this, and hoped for a grand reunion. Will Roman and Sophia ever beat the odds against them? Take this emotional plunge? I voluntarily read a free copy of this book provided by book sirens and am giving an honest review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I truly loved this book and the characters in it, except for the mothers of the main characters, Roman and Sophia. Gaslighting your own daughter to save you and your family's "standing in the ton" is never acceptable and thank heaven, Sophia's sisters all stand by her and not by their mother. Roman's mother is just as bad giving love and support to her wayward and evil son, Hayden, and ignoring the goodness of Roman, fighting him on his every chance for happiness. Mothers should be like Sophia, who never gave up hope of finding her stolen baby/child despite the lies she was told. For a different take on this period in history, this book is a terrific read. ALthough I received an advance review copy for free, I am leaving this review with my honest opinions voluntarily.
February 4, 2026
I'd give this book 3.5 stars (rounded up to 4). I really loved the independence of Sophia's life and her strength, as well as the relationship between her sisters and the other women in her circle. I'm particularly keen to read Mariah's story.
I wasn't overly keen on the hero Haslemore however and I found myself losing focus.
The book contains some upsetting and tragic scenes, which were emotional and hard to read. The ending as well was very emotional bit in a satisfying and happy way.
The plot was predictable and I'd guessed the twist quite early on.
I think if you enjoy a heroine overcoming dramatic and tragic circumstances you will enjoy the book.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
I wasn't overly keen on the hero Haslemore however and I found myself losing focus.
The book contains some upsetting and tragic scenes, which were emotional and hard to read. The ending as well was very emotional bit in a satisfying and happy way.
The plot was predictable and I'd guessed the twist quite early on.
I think if you enjoy a heroine overcoming dramatic and tragic circumstances you will enjoy the book.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
November 13, 2025
I received an ARC of this book through NetGalley. Thank you for the opportunity to read this lovely book.
I was captivated by the two main characters. Both grew and developed as the plot unfolded. There were times when I wanted to shake them both as they tried to protect themselves from emotions and the fear of censure especially for the MFC.
Supporting characters were amusing, spiteful and caring all in different ways. They added to the story and showed how society at that time never really forgave or forgot. I particularly hope we will get a book about Maria.
There was some heat which was relevant to the plot.
All in all this was an enjoyable read.
I was captivated by the two main characters. Both grew and developed as the plot unfolded. There were times when I wanted to shake them both as they tried to protect themselves from emotions and the fear of censure especially for the MFC.
Supporting characters were amusing, spiteful and caring all in different ways. They added to the story and showed how society at that time never really forgave or forgot. I particularly hope we will get a book about Maria.
There was some heat which was relevant to the plot.
All in all this was an enjoyable read.
December 2, 2025
A concoction of a plot with some (for me) unbelievable elements and others that were surely all too true.
The author made me connect with Sophie’s anguish and self doubt, her searching for her lost child, clinging to hope.
Roman, I took a while to warm to - too selfish, too powerful, until we learned that he isn’t always both simultaneously.
At times the writing was fanciful and I confess I skimmed through some passages but the unfolding scenario held my interest to the end.
I like how the author gives power to the women, however unlikely it may be.
It’s a different read and I value that.
I received an advance review copy for free and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
The author made me connect with Sophie’s anguish and self doubt, her searching for her lost child, clinging to hope.
Roman, I took a while to warm to - too selfish, too powerful, until we learned that he isn’t always both simultaneously.
At times the writing was fanciful and I confess I skimmed through some passages but the unfolding scenario held my interest to the end.
I like how the author gives power to the women, however unlikely it may be.
It’s a different read and I value that.
I received an advance review copy for free and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
January 14, 2026
Great story. Sophia St. Clair was taken in by a rake and when compromised, he disappears. Her mother steals her baby and she is left searching for her daughter. She is scorned by her mother and society, but she finds relief by writing about the double standard that there is between men and women. She comes to the attention of Roman, Lord Haslemere, and he is determined that she can help him. This book is full of drama, tangled emotions, politics, and will end with a happy ending. I enjoyed reading this wonderful story.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 51 reviews