What do you think?
Rate this book
Daughters of the Wreckage
Not yet published
Expected 15 Sep 26A woman searching for answers in her own life finds them--and much more--in the wreckage and haunting stories of one of the most infamous maritime disasters in history.
Shortly before Christmas in 2018, Tess McCarthy, after years as a hard-working English teacher who never did anything out of the ordinary, flies to Western Australia's remote Abrolhos Islands. She is in search of answers--both to the infamous Batavia shipwreck and her personal family crises.
Amsterdam, 1628. Saskia, an orphaned young Dutchwoman, boards Batavia with relatives, bound for a new and potentially dangerous life in the East Indies--only for her world to first collide with Aris Jansz, the ship's taciturn under surgeon.
Tess, Saskia, and Aris--their lives linked by secrets that span generations--carry the baggage of past losses and the uncertainty of their futures. And, in the most unlikely circumstances, they may find qualities that echo through faith, acceptance, and love.
Shortly before Christmas in 2018, Tess McCarthy, after years as a hard-working English teacher who never did anything out of the ordinary, flies to Western Australia's remote Abrolhos Islands. She is in search of answers--both to the infamous Batavia shipwreck and her personal family crises.
Amsterdam, 1628. Saskia, an orphaned young Dutchwoman, boards Batavia with relatives, bound for a new and potentially dangerous life in the East Indies--only for her world to first collide with Aris Jansz, the ship's taciturn under surgeon.
Tess, Saskia, and Aris--their lives linked by secrets that span generations--carry the baggage of past losses and the uncertainty of their futures. And, in the most unlikely circumstances, they may find qualities that echo through faith, acceptance, and love.
384 pages, Paperback
Expected publication September 15, 2026
11 people are currently reading
97 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 43 reviews
March 6, 2026
What an interesting story from the history of Australia and The Netherlands. I knew nothing about the wreck of Batavia in the 1600s. The author warned about the horrors to come in Tess’s chapters and I almost stopped reading. But I was invested in Saskia, Aris and Lucretia’s stories and kept reading. Aside from the violence of the mutineers after the Batavia wrecked on the reef, I liked the story. I really liked Saskia, Aris, Lucretia and even the aunt. I liked a couple of the women that Saskia befriended in the lowest quarters of the ship. One of the women turned out to be part of a mystery at the end, that still has me questioning. Tess was not very likable—I don’t think she was supposed to be, though. She was in a rough place of grief.
Advanced reader copy courtesy of the publishers at NetGalley for review.
Advanced reader copy courtesy of the publishers at NetGalley for review.
March 14, 2026
The story of the Batavia shipwreck and the fate of the survivors was interesting although gruesome. The cast of characters abroad the ship were quite the variety and contributed to the historical significance of this fated journey. The modern part of the book with Tess searching for her connection to a passenger on this ship was less engaging .
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
"And I found out that one's wants make a powerful master."
But what if who we want will never be here?
Grief is a powerful pain, but what we miss is that we can grieve life while living people we've never met, even versions of ourselves.
This book was powerful not only through the rebirth of history, giving Batavia another life in another frame, but in its exploration of grief. We see all the characters experience different types of it, and some bond over their shared pains.
We see Tess, once a teacher, now in her own choice to be her father's daughter continuing a history article, the last piece of a life she'll never have again. Through mud cakes, tears, laughs, and cries, Tess's life was never the same. Saskia, in a way, was the same. It was time repeating itself. Both of these incredible women were strong, kind, and most importantly resilient. Each in their own version: Tess up and left to continue finding meaning in life; Saskia kept moving forward without losing who she was. Through the wreckage of Batavia or the life they knew, they kept moving; perfectly? Never. But as humans. The events in reaction were one way we see them connect through the ages.
But this book wasn't solely about grief. It carried a great amount of it, yes, but it was also about love, change, and most importantly: hope.
Master Franz and Aunt Margareta were not only authority figures but, in a way, a bridge of continuity offering a shaky hand in a fragile world. They both protected Aris and Saskia, maybe not perfectly, but they did their best.
We see the horror of Batavia's reality the gruesome facts and crimes that have turned into simple history in our time. But that wasn't the only asset that made me genuinely love this novel. The representation of God specifically as an anchor rather than an upper hand to control, or a miracle in the making, were among the elements that shaped the reader's experience.
The plot unraveling of their survival and the character growth were intricately woven. I especially liked the duality of POV from Tess, Saskia, and Aris. The author managed to weave the past into the present in a way that foreshadow the future as it unravels.
Saskia was a powerful young woman. She remained a surgeon's daughter whose heart beats for helping people thrive, because everyone deserves a chance. Her story wasn't just with Aris. In fact, I admire that we never get to know. It's like history chose to give them privacy from prying eyes due to their sacred love. But we see her grow and learn not only to survive death but to speak up. The moment she met all her friends was her choice to engage, to help, to see and connect even with her aunt's direction and warnings of danger, she didn't cut ties. Maybe Aunt Margareta didn't mean to protect her only from physical harm and monstrous thoughts and actions. On some level, I would like to believe she tried to protect her heart too, even from herself.
Drew and Aris were different in so many ways, but what joined them both was patience, love, and care to provide. Aris maybe was at first just a surgeon's apprentice, but at the end he came out of Batavia a master, a survivor, but most importantly a man of God. We see the importance and value of God's word and wisdom. God was never supposed to be a cure for problems, but a constant in the midst of change and unpredictability, and through it all Aris might have questioned it, but deep down he believed in it just as much he believed that he couldn't be the one to take a life away when he worked to giving it.
It was genuinely a book you can never stop talking about, and honestly it deserves every thought. The more you think about any element or any event, a million new appreciations come to mind. It's a book for those who admire the past, live the moment, and create their own future. The elements of this book are wholeheartedly unique from the pendant and tulip to the Forgotten S. And not forgetting to mention the ethical question about the morality of disturbing the dead in hopes of finding consent. As Katherine said, they still deserve to be heard, because even if time made their suffering history, it remains a crime and their voices deserve to be heard.
I would personally really encourage you to read it, not only for the representation of women and Batavia or even the plot, but because in some way it created new questions in my mind. It truly carries you on a shaft through multiple horrifying facts and crimes, but gives you hope and makes you realize how many strong people exist not only in crazy circumstances, but in everyday life.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
Happy reading ◉‿◉
But what if who we want will never be here?
Grief is a powerful pain, but what we miss is that we can grieve life while living people we've never met, even versions of ourselves.
This book was powerful not only through the rebirth of history, giving Batavia another life in another frame, but in its exploration of grief. We see all the characters experience different types of it, and some bond over their shared pains.
We see Tess, once a teacher, now in her own choice to be her father's daughter continuing a history article, the last piece of a life she'll never have again. Through mud cakes, tears, laughs, and cries, Tess's life was never the same. Saskia, in a way, was the same. It was time repeating itself. Both of these incredible women were strong, kind, and most importantly resilient. Each in their own version: Tess up and left to continue finding meaning in life; Saskia kept moving forward without losing who she was. Through the wreckage of Batavia or the life they knew, they kept moving; perfectly? Never. But as humans. The events in reaction were one way we see them connect through the ages.
But this book wasn't solely about grief. It carried a great amount of it, yes, but it was also about love, change, and most importantly: hope.
Master Franz and Aunt Margareta were not only authority figures but, in a way, a bridge of continuity offering a shaky hand in a fragile world. They both protected Aris and Saskia, maybe not perfectly, but they did their best.
We see the horror of Batavia's reality the gruesome facts and crimes that have turned into simple history in our time. But that wasn't the only asset that made me genuinely love this novel. The representation of God specifically as an anchor rather than an upper hand to control, or a miracle in the making, were among the elements that shaped the reader's experience.
The plot unraveling of their survival and the character growth were intricately woven. I especially liked the duality of POV from Tess, Saskia, and Aris. The author managed to weave the past into the present in a way that foreshadow the future as it unravels.
Saskia was a powerful young woman. She remained a surgeon's daughter whose heart beats for helping people thrive, because everyone deserves a chance. Her story wasn't just with Aris. In fact, I admire that we never get to know. It's like history chose to give them privacy from prying eyes due to their sacred love. But we see her grow and learn not only to survive death but to speak up. The moment she met all her friends was her choice to engage, to help, to see and connect even with her aunt's direction and warnings of danger, she didn't cut ties. Maybe Aunt Margareta didn't mean to protect her only from physical harm and monstrous thoughts and actions. On some level, I would like to believe she tried to protect her heart too, even from herself.
Drew and Aris were different in so many ways, but what joined them both was patience, love, and care to provide. Aris maybe was at first just a surgeon's apprentice, but at the end he came out of Batavia a master, a survivor, but most importantly a man of God. We see the importance and value of God's word and wisdom. God was never supposed to be a cure for problems, but a constant in the midst of change and unpredictability, and through it all Aris might have questioned it, but deep down he believed in it just as much he believed that he couldn't be the one to take a life away when he worked to giving it.
It was genuinely a book you can never stop talking about, and honestly it deserves every thought. The more you think about any element or any event, a million new appreciations come to mind. It's a book for those who admire the past, live the moment, and create their own future. The elements of this book are wholeheartedly unique from the pendant and tulip to the Forgotten S. And not forgetting to mention the ethical question about the morality of disturbing the dead in hopes of finding consent. As Katherine said, they still deserve to be heard, because even if time made their suffering history, it remains a crime and their voices deserve to be heard.
I would personally really encourage you to read it, not only for the representation of women and Batavia or even the plot, but because in some way it created new questions in my mind. It truly carries you on a shaft through multiple horrifying facts and crimes, but gives you hope and makes you realize how many strong people exist not only in crazy circumstances, but in everyday life.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
Happy reading ◉‿◉
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
I received this ARC thanks to NetGalley & Thomas Nelson Fiction.
Here’s my review ⬇️
I love historical fiction, and I always try to read as much of it as I can.
I do feel a bit bad because I wasn’t able to finish this ARC before it expired, but what I read was more than enough to convince me that this is a book I definitely want to return to and finish.
The story is told across two timelines, and I really enjoyed how the past slowly brought us closer to the present. One of the biggest reasons this book stood out to me is because the FMC in the present timeline is on a discovery journey; she’s trying to understand her family’s past and make sense of her lineage, especially because there’s trauma tied to her mother’s side of the family. With both her parents gone, it felt like she was searching for answers that could help her understand herself better.
I loved the theme because I think we all get to a point in life where we start asking: what made me who I am? what parts of my past shaped my present? And I liked seeing that reflected through her journey.
There’s also a mystery surrounding a box and a pendant connected to her family history, and it led me into the Batavia shipwreck, which (from what I know) is based on a real historical event.
One thing I found especially chilling is how the book shows that there’s such a thin line between sanity and insanity, and between good and evil, especially when people are pushed into survival mode. The shipwreck survivors thought the worst was over, but what came after was even more brutal.
I also really liked the writing. It was easy to follow, engaging, and never boring. The characters pulled me in, and I especially wanted to know more about Saskia, Lucretia, and Tess.
Overall, based on what I read, I think this is a solid historical fiction with depth and a really compelling mystery. I’m definitely going to pick it up again (when it’s published) so I can finish it properly.
Here’s my review ⬇️
I love historical fiction, and I always try to read as much of it as I can.
I do feel a bit bad because I wasn’t able to finish this ARC before it expired, but what I read was more than enough to convince me that this is a book I definitely want to return to and finish.
The story is told across two timelines, and I really enjoyed how the past slowly brought us closer to the present. One of the biggest reasons this book stood out to me is because the FMC in the present timeline is on a discovery journey; she’s trying to understand her family’s past and make sense of her lineage, especially because there’s trauma tied to her mother’s side of the family. With both her parents gone, it felt like she was searching for answers that could help her understand herself better.
I loved the theme because I think we all get to a point in life where we start asking: what made me who I am? what parts of my past shaped my present? And I liked seeing that reflected through her journey.
There’s also a mystery surrounding a box and a pendant connected to her family history, and it led me into the Batavia shipwreck, which (from what I know) is based on a real historical event.
One thing I found especially chilling is how the book shows that there’s such a thin line between sanity and insanity, and between good and evil, especially when people are pushed into survival mode. The shipwreck survivors thought the worst was over, but what came after was even more brutal.
I also really liked the writing. It was easy to follow, engaging, and never boring. The characters pulled me in, and I especially wanted to know more about Saskia, Lucretia, and Tess.
Overall, based on what I read, I think this is a solid historical fiction with depth and a really compelling mystery. I’m definitely going to pick it up again (when it’s published) so I can finish it properly.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I wholeheartedly recommend this book to anyone captivated by historical fiction, fascinated by maritime history, or inspired by powerful stories of resilience. Daughters of the Wreckage is a rerelease of Stephanie Koens’s award-winning debut novel, Daughters of Batavia, which was originally published in Australia. The story unfolds across two timelines: in 2018, as Tess journeys to the Abrolhos Islands off the coast of Western Australia to research the infamous 1629 Batavia shipwreck, and in 1629, following Saskia and Aris as they endure the disaster firsthand. The three different perspectives recount the harrowing historical events surrounding the shipwreck and its tragic aftermath filled with mutiny, murder, and mayhem. Woven throughout the story are themes of resilience and personal recovery after tragic loss, alongside the hope that tomorrow brings better days. From a historian’s perspective- the story is masterfully researched and rich with detail, offering curious readers opportunities for further research. Koens provides a thorough Author’s Note at the end of the book detailing her source material and research institutions.
Although the story was captivating, much of the 1629 action occurs “off screen,” which kept the reader at a safe distance when dealing with themes of sexual assault and murder. However, that distance weakened the interpersonal storylines, leaving them less impactful. That said, a surprise revealed at the end of the book had me immediately flipping back and rereading scenes with a shifted perception.
Overall, I thoroughly enjoyed this book and the hours it inspired me to spend further reading about the Batavia shipwreck and its fascinating history.
Thank you to Thomas Nelson Fiction, Stefanie Koens, and NetGalley for the advanced reader copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.
#DaughtersoftheWreckage #NetGalley
Although the story was captivating, much of the 1629 action occurs “off screen,” which kept the reader at a safe distance when dealing with themes of sexual assault and murder. However, that distance weakened the interpersonal storylines, leaving them less impactful. That said, a surprise revealed at the end of the book had me immediately flipping back and rereading scenes with a shifted perception.
Overall, I thoroughly enjoyed this book and the hours it inspired me to spend further reading about the Batavia shipwreck and its fascinating history.
Thank you to Thomas Nelson Fiction, Stefanie Koens, and NetGalley for the advanced reader copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.
#DaughtersoftheWreckage #NetGalley
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Daughters of the Wreckage-A Novel by Stefanie Koens
Review by Shirley W. 3-15-26
There are 400 years of mysteries and questions that link two women. Tess McCarthy, an English teacher in present time, goes to western Australia’s Abrolhos Islands, after her father passes. Tess saw his paperwork on his desk about her mother’s ancestor who died in the shipwreck of the Batavia in 1628. His name is Aris Jansz and Tess is curious.
In 1628, Saskia, an orphaned young Dutchwoman, boards the ship Batavia with relatives-aunt Margareta, her uncle & cousin. The ship is filled with various levels of sailors, soldiers, and travelers. Such a long journey involves various friendships, classes of travelers, rivalry, and long days and nights of boredom on the sailing ship. Saskia and her cousin enjoy exploring the ship. They meet Aris Jansz, an under surgeon to Franz, the master surgeon, who are both on the journey. A blooming friendship is happening between Aris and Saskia.
Unfortunately, the ship is blown onto the shallow reefs at night. Much chaos and fear occurs as people are separated, drown and find a lifeboat to slowly take them to the reef. Not much food or shelter is available. Different factions cause distress and mutiny.
Tess decided to investigate the scientists that work on the reef looking for answers about the survivors. Artifacts are found that give partial answers.
Author, Stefanie Koens’ historic and well documented story unfolds giving each woman equal time explaining how the events might have happened. A very interesting and eye-opening attempts to survive.
I thoroughly enjoyed this novel based on facts. I received a complimentary copy of this book.
Thank you, Thomas Nelson for providing this book for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
Review by Shirley W. 3-15-26
There are 400 years of mysteries and questions that link two women. Tess McCarthy, an English teacher in present time, goes to western Australia’s Abrolhos Islands, after her father passes. Tess saw his paperwork on his desk about her mother’s ancestor who died in the shipwreck of the Batavia in 1628. His name is Aris Jansz and Tess is curious.
In 1628, Saskia, an orphaned young Dutchwoman, boards the ship Batavia with relatives-aunt Margareta, her uncle & cousin. The ship is filled with various levels of sailors, soldiers, and travelers. Such a long journey involves various friendships, classes of travelers, rivalry, and long days and nights of boredom on the sailing ship. Saskia and her cousin enjoy exploring the ship. They meet Aris Jansz, an under surgeon to Franz, the master surgeon, who are both on the journey. A blooming friendship is happening between Aris and Saskia.
Unfortunately, the ship is blown onto the shallow reefs at night. Much chaos and fear occurs as people are separated, drown and find a lifeboat to slowly take them to the reef. Not much food or shelter is available. Different factions cause distress and mutiny.
Tess decided to investigate the scientists that work on the reef looking for answers about the survivors. Artifacts are found that give partial answers.
Author, Stefanie Koens’ historic and well documented story unfolds giving each woman equal time explaining how the events might have happened. A very interesting and eye-opening attempts to survive.
I thoroughly enjoyed this novel based on facts. I received a complimentary copy of this book.
Thank you, Thomas Nelson for providing this book for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This is a dual timeline story based on the story of the actual wreckage in 1629 of the Dutch East India Company ship, Batavia, on the islands off Western Australia.
The main character of the 1629 story, was Saskia a young woman that was traveling with her aunt and 11 year old cousin, Tobias on the maiden voyage of the Batavia to join her uncle who, as an employee of the Dutch East India Company has already arrived at their new home. The story is told in the third person (1629) and first person (current).
The current day character is Tess a young woman who has recently loss her father. Upon his sudden death she discovers he was working on a paper involving the wreck of the Batavia and had discovered a family link with the ship's young apprentice doctor, Aria. Tess decides she is going to finish his paper and goes to the archeological site via a charter boat captained by a handsome, interesting young man named Drew to learn more.
Although there is quite a bit of death as result of mutiny of some of the men and is very depressing at times. I really enjoyed the way the author would bring up something discovered at the current day site wondering the story behind it. Then it would go back to the actual wreckage and fill in the blanks of what happened.
All this said, I found the book very good and enjoyed the strong females, portrayed during the actual wreckage. I did find the current main character, Tess, a little one-sided although know the story was primarily a tale of fiction based on the actual event in 1629.
There was one twist at the very end of the book that I wished had of been answered. I will follow and hope someone else has thoughts as to what it meant.
The main character of the 1629 story, was Saskia a young woman that was traveling with her aunt and 11 year old cousin, Tobias on the maiden voyage of the Batavia to join her uncle who, as an employee of the Dutch East India Company has already arrived at their new home. The story is told in the third person (1629) and first person (current).
The current day character is Tess a young woman who has recently loss her father. Upon his sudden death she discovers he was working on a paper involving the wreck of the Batavia and had discovered a family link with the ship's young apprentice doctor, Aria. Tess decides she is going to finish his paper and goes to the archeological site via a charter boat captained by a handsome, interesting young man named Drew to learn more.
Although there is quite a bit of death as result of mutiny of some of the men and is very depressing at times. I really enjoyed the way the author would bring up something discovered at the current day site wondering the story behind it. Then it would go back to the actual wreckage and fill in the blanks of what happened.
All this said, I found the book very good and enjoyed the strong females, portrayed during the actual wreckage. I did find the current main character, Tess, a little one-sided although know the story was primarily a tale of fiction based on the actual event in 1629.
There was one twist at the very end of the book that I wished had of been answered. I will follow and hope someone else has thoughts as to what it meant.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
More than 5 stars for this incredible book! I was captivated by the very first paragraph. This dual timeline story follows two women: Saskia in 1628 and Tess in modern time. The imagery in this book is spectacular! The author uses such descriptive words that bring every setting to life. "The ocean unrolled to the horizon, a dark blue carpet scattered with flecks of sunlight."
Tess is an amazing character! She's searching for information on a long lost relative but in reality she's searching for closure. Saskia is extraordinary! She refuses to be put in a box. Her adventurous nature sometimes gets her into trouble. She's also very compassionate, stubborn and a survivor. Aris is my favorite! He takes his work as an under surgeon seriously. He seems gruff but he has a heart of gold. His life intertwines with both women. He's a relative of Tess's and a significant person in Saskia's life.
There are some disturbing issues in the book. S**ual assault, a shipwreck and horrifying murders. These issues are essential to the story as most of them are facts relating to the atrocities that happened to the passengers aboard the Batavia.The author offers some hope to counter the despair. Many of the characters trust in God and there are quotes from hymns and scripture.
This is the first book that I've read by this author, but it won't be the last! I was provided a complimentary ARC copy of the book from Thomas Nelson via NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Tess is an amazing character! She's searching for information on a long lost relative but in reality she's searching for closure. Saskia is extraordinary! She refuses to be put in a box. Her adventurous nature sometimes gets her into trouble. She's also very compassionate, stubborn and a survivor. Aris is my favorite! He takes his work as an under surgeon seriously. He seems gruff but he has a heart of gold. His life intertwines with both women. He's a relative of Tess's and a significant person in Saskia's life.
There are some disturbing issues in the book. S**ual assault, a shipwreck and horrifying murders. These issues are essential to the story as most of them are facts relating to the atrocities that happened to the passengers aboard the Batavia.The author offers some hope to counter the despair. Many of the characters trust in God and there are quotes from hymns and scripture.
This is the first book that I've read by this author, but it won't be the last! I was provided a complimentary ARC copy of the book from Thomas Nelson via NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
The Daughters of the Wreckage by Stefanie Koens genuinely surprised me. I had little knowledge of the Batavia before picking this up, and I found myself pausing between chapters to search the history.
The dual timeline works well here. The historical chapters, following Saskia and Aris, are where the novel truly comes alive for me. Saskia is the kind of character you root for instinctively — a surgeon's daughter with an unshakeable desire to help people, even when everything around her is crumbling. Aris grows quietly and steadily throughout, and by the end he feels like a man genuinely forged by his circumstances rather than just described by them. Their story is brutal, but it's told with real empathy and humanity.
Tess, the modern-day narrator, offers a lighter perspective that I appreciated as a reprieve from the historical horrors. Her storyline is more introspective and slower-paced.
What struck me most across both timelines was the exploration of grief — not just the obvious kind, but the quieter grief of lives interrupted, paths not taken, and selves left behind.
Overall, this is a book I'd genuinely recommend, especially to anyone who loves historical fiction with emotional depth. It shines light on a piece of history that deserves to be remembered, and it does so through characters who feel real enough to stay with you well after the last page.
Thank you to Netgalley and the author for allowing me the ARC to review.
The dual timeline works well here. The historical chapters, following Saskia and Aris, are where the novel truly comes alive for me. Saskia is the kind of character you root for instinctively — a surgeon's daughter with an unshakeable desire to help people, even when everything around her is crumbling. Aris grows quietly and steadily throughout, and by the end he feels like a man genuinely forged by his circumstances rather than just described by them. Their story is brutal, but it's told with real empathy and humanity.
Tess, the modern-day narrator, offers a lighter perspective that I appreciated as a reprieve from the historical horrors. Her storyline is more introspective and slower-paced.
What struck me most across both timelines was the exploration of grief — not just the obvious kind, but the quieter grief of lives interrupted, paths not taken, and selves left behind.
Overall, this is a book I'd genuinely recommend, especially to anyone who loves historical fiction with emotional depth. It shines light on a piece of history that deserves to be remembered, and it does so through characters who feel real enough to stay with you well after the last page.
Thank you to Netgalley and the author for allowing me the ARC to review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Daughters of the Wreckage by Stefanie Koens is my favourite kind of novel - a dual‑timeline historical story that immerses me in a time and place I knew little about, while slowly revealing the connection between two compelling characters across the centuries. A particular positive is that it avoids the overused device of “finds a diary and reads a couple of entries before dinner” to move between timelines!
I had never heard of the harrowing true events surrounding the Dutch East India Company ship Batavia, or the coral reefs of the Abrolhos, islands off Western Australia, where she was wrecked almost 400 years ago, before facing further tragedy and death in a mutiny of survivors.
Both female leads, 17th‑century Saskia and 21st‑century Tess, carry painful histories of loss and grief, and both begin the story wary and guarded around their potential romantic counterparts, Aris and Drew.
Saskia’s chapters are narrated in third person, while Tess’s are told in first person. I’m still pondering what the author intended by that choice, perhaps emotional distance, or just the way each woman’s story is meant to be experienced.
While the book ends with unanswered questions, it was exceptionally well researched and written, and extremely satisfying.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
I had never heard of the harrowing true events surrounding the Dutch East India Company ship Batavia, or the coral reefs of the Abrolhos, islands off Western Australia, where she was wrecked almost 400 years ago, before facing further tragedy and death in a mutiny of survivors.
Both female leads, 17th‑century Saskia and 21st‑century Tess, carry painful histories of loss and grief, and both begin the story wary and guarded around their potential romantic counterparts, Aris and Drew.
Saskia’s chapters are narrated in third person, while Tess’s are told in first person. I’m still pondering what the author intended by that choice, perhaps emotional distance, or just the way each woman’s story is meant to be experienced.
While the book ends with unanswered questions, it was exceptionally well researched and written, and extremely satisfying.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
February 8, 2026
🌟 “What happened to them isn’t considered a crime anymore, it’s just history.”
Prior to picking up this book, I had never heard of the Batavia shipwreck. What an incredibly fascinating (and horrifying) story. The novel introduces us to real people who endured the mutiny that followed the wreck of the ship Batavia on its journey.
The sheer evil men are capable of was deeply disheartening to read about, as was the fragility of human life and humanity during that particular period of history. That era never fails to blow my mind.
Jeronimus Cornelis — one of the ships biggest villains — was truly savage.
The story follows Tess, a descendant of Aris, one of the ship’s surgeons, as she works to complete an article her late father began. The narrative moves back and forth between Tess’s present day perspective, Aris’s experience, and that of a young woman named Saskia, working to gradually reveal the treachery that unfolded on the Abrolhos Islands all those years ago.
Overall, this was a quick and engaging historical fiction read that delivered a compelling story without being overly emotionally heavy.
I did hop on YouTube and watch some videos on the wreckage site and where they were confined— CRAZY. I love being able to research what I’m reading.
Thank you @netgalley for the ARC!
Prior to picking up this book, I had never heard of the Batavia shipwreck. What an incredibly fascinating (and horrifying) story. The novel introduces us to real people who endured the mutiny that followed the wreck of the ship Batavia on its journey.
The sheer evil men are capable of was deeply disheartening to read about, as was the fragility of human life and humanity during that particular period of history. That era never fails to blow my mind.
Jeronimus Cornelis — one of the ships biggest villains — was truly savage.
The story follows Tess, a descendant of Aris, one of the ship’s surgeons, as she works to complete an article her late father began. The narrative moves back and forth between Tess’s present day perspective, Aris’s experience, and that of a young woman named Saskia, working to gradually reveal the treachery that unfolded on the Abrolhos Islands all those years ago.
Overall, this was a quick and engaging historical fiction read that delivered a compelling story without being overly emotionally heavy.
I did hop on YouTube and watch some videos on the wreckage site and where they were confined— CRAZY. I love being able to research what I’m reading.
Thank you @netgalley for the ARC!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Daughters of the Wreckage is a historical fiction book that follows a double timeline centered around the fateful ship, Batavia. The ship was voyaging from Amsterdam to the East Indies and was shipwrecked. The following is a story centered around those that were on the ship and connected to the ship. Throughout the multiple characters in the book, we see lies, deceit, and evil but most of all hope and resilience to survive as each of the stories play out.
In modern day, we follow Tess who is trying to deal with her grief as she tries to uncover her family ties to the Batavia.
In 1628, we follow multiple viewpoints.
Saskia who is a strong orphan teen taken from all she knows to go with her aunt to a new country. She often has to navigate hostile and dangerous situations in order to survive.
Aris who was on the ship as a surgeon’s apprentice. He is determined to survive on the island while trying to avoid dangerous and evil men that have taken over as leaders.
This was a fascinating read. I found myself Googling maps to see the route and where the shipwreck was located. I do wish that there was more of Lucretia’s story as I really enjoyed reading about her.
Thanks to NetGalley and the author for the advanced copy.
In modern day, we follow Tess who is trying to deal with her grief as she tries to uncover her family ties to the Batavia.
In 1628, we follow multiple viewpoints.
Saskia who is a strong orphan teen taken from all she knows to go with her aunt to a new country. She often has to navigate hostile and dangerous situations in order to survive.
Aris who was on the ship as a surgeon’s apprentice. He is determined to survive on the island while trying to avoid dangerous and evil men that have taken over as leaders.
This was a fascinating read. I found myself Googling maps to see the route and where the shipwreck was located. I do wish that there was more of Lucretia’s story as I really enjoyed reading about her.
Thanks to NetGalley and the author for the advanced copy.
March 30, 2026
I waver between 4.5-5 stars. This is one interesting albeit sad true story!!
I’ve been sitting here fact checking it and finding more information on the shipwreck survivors for thirty minutes beyond when I finished the book.
There’s a twist at the end that had me flipping back a few chapters to see if I interpreted it correctly and though I was indeed right I feel like it was left a bit unsure. Like, some may not get the importance of what was found. Fortunately I did and it had me thinking about the early chapters of the book. I may reread them to see how it feels knowing what I know now.
Either way, fantastic read. Very, very interesting history of the shipwreck and absolutely horrible what people will do to one another.
I’m really glad I was able to go read all the true facts of the punishment doled out to the mutineers. I’m happy it wasn’t just speculation but that we do know they were punished.
I would have loved a longer look at how Saskia started her second life but I guess we can all imagine it for ourselves.
Now I’m off to go find more tidbits of information on the survivors when they got home.
Thank you to NetGalley, Stephanie Koens and the publisher for an advance e-reader copy. This review is my own.
I’ve been sitting here fact checking it and finding more information on the shipwreck survivors for thirty minutes beyond when I finished the book.
There’s a twist at the end that had me flipping back a few chapters to see if I interpreted it correctly and though I was indeed right I feel like it was left a bit unsure. Like, some may not get the importance of what was found. Fortunately I did and it had me thinking about the early chapters of the book. I may reread them to see how it feels knowing what I know now.
Either way, fantastic read. Very, very interesting history of the shipwreck and absolutely horrible what people will do to one another.
I’m really glad I was able to go read all the true facts of the punishment doled out to the mutineers. I’m happy it wasn’t just speculation but that we do know they were punished.
I would have loved a longer look at how Saskia started her second life but I guess we can all imagine it for ourselves.
Now I’m off to go find more tidbits of information on the survivors when they got home.
Thank you to NetGalley, Stephanie Koens and the publisher for an advance e-reader copy. This review is my own.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I’m giving this a 4 stars! ⭐⭐⭐⭐
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
A massive thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC! This is exactly my favorite kind of novel—a dual-timeline historical story that completely immersed me in a time and place I knew very little about. The plot revolves around the true events of the Dutch East India Company ship Batavia and the Abrolhos islands off Western Australia.
What I loved most was how the connection between the two leads, 17th-century Saskia and 21st-century Tess, was revealed. Both women carry painful histories of loss and grief, making their journeys incredibly compelling. A huge positive for me was that the author avoided the overused "finding a diary" trope to bridge the timelines!
While the book ends with some unanswered questions, it was exceptionally well-researched and satisfying. If you love historical fiction with a side of archaeological mystery and new relationships, this is a must-read.
Fascinated by historical mysteries? Sail over to my profile @TheLitWhisperer to see my top dual-timeline picks!
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
A massive thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC! This is exactly my favorite kind of novel—a dual-timeline historical story that completely immersed me in a time and place I knew very little about. The plot revolves around the true events of the Dutch East India Company ship Batavia and the Abrolhos islands off Western Australia.
What I loved most was how the connection between the two leads, 17th-century Saskia and 21st-century Tess, was revealed. Both women carry painful histories of loss and grief, making their journeys incredibly compelling. A huge positive for me was that the author avoided the overused "finding a diary" trope to bridge the timelines!
While the book ends with some unanswered questions, it was exceptionally well-researched and satisfying. If you love historical fiction with a side of archaeological mystery and new relationships, this is a must-read.
Fascinated by historical mysteries? Sail over to my profile @TheLitWhisperer to see my top dual-timeline picks!
April 25, 2026
Really fascinating and brutal piece of history. I found myself googling about the history of the Batavia in between chapters because the story of a wrecked ship with the resulting passengers and crew being split up and then taken over by a psychopath who leads a group to slaughter and terrorize everyone is just crazy, and finding it was all very much true.
I thought the story, given its brutality and violence, was both informative and intriguing, and true to history, while creating a sense of compassion and empathy for the victims and survivors as you read thru the eyes of the Aris and Saskia, as well as Tess looking back. I liked when pieces of the past were picked up in the future and it created that sense of being linked.
I did not get a great sense of chemistry between Drew and Tess, but that was more of a minor plot point for the story so not the end of the world.
Overall I really enjoyed this lesser known piece of history, and appreciated the people who survived and fought in such an horrific event.
Thanks to Netgalley for the advanced copy of this book. All opinions are mine.
I thought the story, given its brutality and violence, was both informative and intriguing, and true to history, while creating a sense of compassion and empathy for the victims and survivors as you read thru the eyes of the Aris and Saskia, as well as Tess looking back. I liked when pieces of the past were picked up in the future and it created that sense of being linked.
I did not get a great sense of chemistry between Drew and Tess, but that was more of a minor plot point for the story so not the end of the world.
Overall I really enjoyed this lesser known piece of history, and appreciated the people who survived and fought in such an horrific event.
Thanks to Netgalley for the advanced copy of this book. All opinions are mine.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Wow! What a fantastic read! "Daughters of the Wreckage" sucked me in at once and didn't let me go until the last page! I am not generally a fan of dual-timeline, multi-POV books, but this author did an amazing job keeping the story moving, while also providing details to fill in some time gaps between past-perspective POV chapters. I had never heard of the Batavia shipwreck and the atrocities committed, and I really appreciated the author not sugarcoating the events and using a real event as the focal point of this novel. I will say, it was gut wrenching to read some of the atrocities committed (reader beware), but it was done with the perfect balance of showing the truth without getting gory.
I do wish we had more robust ending where we could see more of what happened to the main characters, but other than that, it was an enthralling and fantastic read. Highly recommend to those who love historical fiction!
I received a complimentary copy of this book from NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
I do wish we had more robust ending where we could see more of what happened to the main characters, but other than that, it was an enthralling and fantastic read. Highly recommend to those who love historical fiction!
I received a complimentary copy of this book from NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Daughters of the Wreckage is a dual timeline historical fiction novel. In the present day it follows Tess as she writes an article her father started about the Batavia shipwreck. The historical timeline follows several passengers on the Batavia from the time it leaves port until they finally make it to their destination. It appears all of the characters except Saskia are based on real passengers. Overall I really enjoyed the novel. My only complaint is that I did find the story immediately after the shipwreck a little hard to follow. The story was engaging and from what little research I did appears to follow the historical facts. The author did a good job of weaving the two timelines together. The pacing of the story was also good. Some of the violence that occurred after the wreck is quite graphic so this may not be the book for you if that type of thing bothers you.
Thank you to NetGalley and the author for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.
Thank you to NetGalley and the author for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I LOVED THIS BOOK!
Written from three different points of view and two different timelines, it tells a fictional account of the true story of the 1629 shipwreck of the Batavia and subsequent mutiny and horrific massacre. I love learning about lesser-known historical events (although this may be well-known for those from Australia or the Netherlands). Switching between the viewpoints of two fictional passengers pulls you right into the chaos—you're not just reading about the tragedy; you're living it moment by moment as events unfold through their eyes. That immediacy makes the horror feel raw and personal, turning a historical event into something visceral and unforgettable. The third point of view is that of a descendant of one of the survivors who visits the site of the wreckage while researching for an article she is writing and coming to grips with her own tragic loss.
Written from three different points of view and two different timelines, it tells a fictional account of the true story of the 1629 shipwreck of the Batavia and subsequent mutiny and horrific massacre. I love learning about lesser-known historical events (although this may be well-known for those from Australia or the Netherlands). Switching between the viewpoints of two fictional passengers pulls you right into the chaos—you're not just reading about the tragedy; you're living it moment by moment as events unfold through their eyes. That immediacy makes the horror feel raw and personal, turning a historical event into something visceral and unforgettable. The third point of view is that of a descendant of one of the survivors who visits the site of the wreckage while researching for an article she is writing and coming to grips with her own tragic loss.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
“Daughters of the Wreckage” was a fascinating book. As a work of historical fiction, the author has taken some artistic license with the story. However, it is compelling to think about the historical events. Shipwrecks were likely more common than we realize but then having a mutiny and massacre of a significant portion of the survivors would certainly have been an aberration.
I enjoyed the alternation between the Batavia’s voyage and wreck and the experience of its passengers and crew and the modern day story of Tess’s investigation into the events for the academic article she was writing, including visiting an archaeological dig on the island where survivors lived and died, as well as exploring a family connection to Aris, one of the ship’s surgeons (and also Saskia, a passenger on the ship).
I enjoyed the alternation between the Batavia’s voyage and wreck and the experience of its passengers and crew and the modern day story of Tess’s investigation into the events for the academic article she was writing, including visiting an archaeological dig on the island where survivors lived and died, as well as exploring a family connection to Aris, one of the ship’s surgeons (and also Saskia, a passenger on the ship).
February 18, 2026
I was hooked from the first page. I love a good historical fiction and the way Stefanie wove a story of love and hope into the evidence of a historical tragedy that really happened had my heart gripped. I was so grateful to get to be a part of this ARC group and I see good things for this story. I also had to go research the truth behind the Batavia tragedy. I really liked how we got to follow Tess in the present as she wove her way through her own emotional tragedy and found her own hope on the other side. I would have loved to get more banter and insight to her journey but that is just my curiosity speaking. I think the weaving of past and present, fiction and history, was so well intertwined. I couldn't put it down and then when it ended I had my own feelings of hope. Very good read!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I picked this book to read because I knew absolutely nothing of this history of Batavia. The first few chapters had me totally interested and the set up of the characters was good. The back and forth between them was clear and well written. I just really struggled to get into the story after the first few chapters. For me, it read as a very dry plot and I found that I didn't care much about what was happening with the people in the story. It didn't captivate me and I struggled to finish reading it. The ending picks up just a bit and that was helpful. The history is interesting and it made me want to research some of it myself. If this is something that interests you with history then you will probably enjoy it. I know many others have loved this book, it simply was not for me.
"I received a complimentary copy from NetGalley. All opinions are my own and I was not required to write a positive review."
"I received a complimentary copy from NetGalley. All opinions are my own and I was not required to write a positive review."
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This was an ARC from Net Galley all opinions are my own.
Clear your schedule once you pick this historical novel up you will not be able to put it down. It is told in two voices; present day and the women who were on the ill fated Batavia maiden voyage.
Tess is trying to figure out her path forward after the unexpected death of her father. He was working on an article tracing his wife’s ancestor who survived the shipwreck of the Batavia. Tess decides to complete the article and heads to the islands where the shipwreck occurred.
The story of the Batavia shipwreck and the mutiny that occurred was so engrossing that I looked up the history and was horrified to learn that this story was true.
Clear your schedule once you pick this historical novel up you will not be able to put it down. It is told in two voices; present day and the women who were on the ill fated Batavia maiden voyage.
Tess is trying to figure out her path forward after the unexpected death of her father. He was working on an article tracing his wife’s ancestor who survived the shipwreck of the Batavia. Tess decides to complete the article and heads to the islands where the shipwreck occurred.
The story of the Batavia shipwreck and the mutiny that occurred was so engrossing that I looked up the history and was horrified to learn that this story was true.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
The Daughters of the Wreckage by Stefanie Koens is a really engaging read, especially if you like dual timelines. The historical parts (around the Batavia shipwreck) are super vivid and honestly the highlight of the book, while the modern storyline adds a nice emotional layer.
The characters feel real and easy to connect with, and the themes of resilience and healing come through well. It does slow down a bit at times—mainly in the present-day chapters—but it never drags too much.
Overall, a solid, enjoyable read that sticks with you after you finish it.
Thank you to Netgalley and the author for allowing me the ARC to review
The characters feel real and easy to connect with, and the themes of resilience and healing come through well. It does slow down a bit at times—mainly in the present-day chapters—but it never drags too much.
Overall, a solid, enjoyable read that sticks with you after you finish it.
Thank you to Netgalley and the author for allowing me the ARC to review
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
This was an interesting novel about a part of history little-known.
I enjoyed the perspectives of Tess, Saskia, and Aris, the latter two being characters in the past. Tess’s more lighthearted and modern day perspective was a welcome reprieve from the atrocities Saskia and Aris were witnessing throughout the book.
I must say, with how awful the events of this book were, I wished that it weren’t based off of real historical events. That being said, I did quite enjoy this book and learning about the Batavia. I would recommend it to anyone who enjoys historical fiction.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this advanced copy.
I enjoyed the perspectives of Tess, Saskia, and Aris, the latter two being characters in the past. Tess’s more lighthearted and modern day perspective was a welcome reprieve from the atrocities Saskia and Aris were witnessing throughout the book.
I must say, with how awful the events of this book were, I wished that it weren’t based off of real historical events. That being said, I did quite enjoy this book and learning about the Batavia. I would recommend it to anyone who enjoys historical fiction.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this advanced copy.
Review of advance copy
Shipwreck, archeological digs, new relationships, and more!
This book was an exciting read through an interesting historical lens. Told in alternative perspectives from modern day story of Tess, to the historical events aboard the ship Batavia with Saskia and Aris. I loved how this story weaved together these different stories to create one story about fresh starts and new beginnings. If you love historical fiction, this book is an interesting read while following the interesting lives of the characters. I enjoyed the mystery surrounding the ship and the connections between the characters.
This book was an exciting read through an interesting historical lens. Told in alternative perspectives from modern day story of Tess, to the historical events aboard the ship Batavia with Saskia and Aris. I loved how this story weaved together these different stories to create one story about fresh starts and new beginnings. If you love historical fiction, this book is an interesting read while following the interesting lives of the characters. I enjoyed the mystery surrounding the ship and the connections between the characters.
February 10, 2026
I received an early copy of this book through NetGallery.
Historical fiction is usually outside of my wheelhouse, but this- this was an emotional experience. The details of the story are absolutely fascinating and, while intriguing, it does take a minute to get invested. With that being said, the story is emotionally overwhelming in the best way! As a history lover, it leaves you wanting more information while tying us satisfying ends. The only “negative” that I have is that the changing POVs can be a bit jarring at times.
Historical fiction is usually outside of my wheelhouse, but this- this was an emotional experience. The details of the story are absolutely fascinating and, while intriguing, it does take a minute to get invested. With that being said, the story is emotionally overwhelming in the best way! As a history lover, it leaves you wanting more information while tying us satisfying ends. The only “negative” that I have is that the changing POVs can be a bit jarring at times.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Received as an ARC through Netgalley to review, this is an honest review.
Thanks to Thomas Nelson Fiction for the approval to read this book.
Daughters of the Wreckage is a beautiful and harrowing historical fiction that intertwines dual timelines of Tess McCarthy in the present and Saskia, a dutch woman in the 17 century; that for both women the Dutch East Indies vessel the Batavia is the heart of everything. And fate, fortune, live and determination echo across time and a shipwrecked vessel can unlock what it means to challenge ourselves in times of uncertainty.
Highly recommended.
Thanks to Thomas Nelson Fiction for the approval to read this book.
Daughters of the Wreckage is a beautiful and harrowing historical fiction that intertwines dual timelines of Tess McCarthy in the present and Saskia, a dutch woman in the 17 century; that for both women the Dutch East Indies vessel the Batavia is the heart of everything. And fate, fortune, live and determination echo across time and a shipwrecked vessel can unlock what it means to challenge ourselves in times of uncertainty.
Highly recommended.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Daughters of the Wreckage has all the elements I love in historical fiction: romance and tragedy based on true historical facts. The story goes back in forth in time from the present day life of Tess McCarthy, who travels to Western Australia's remote Abrolhos Islands to write an article about the Batavia shipwreck there in the 1620’s. We also hear from Saskia who is traveling on the ship to the East Indies from Amsterdam with her Aunt and cousin. On the ship she catches the eye of Aris Jansz, the ship's under surgeon. This story kept me up late reading with a great ending.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This book is told from three different points of view. Tess is in the present, finishing an article that her father began before his death. It involves the wreck of the Batavia, a Dutch ship run aground on a coral reef. Saskia is a young woman who is a passenger on the Batavia, as is Aris, a junior surgeon.
I enjoyed this book very much. I basically read it in one sitting. I couldn't wait to find out what would happen next. I had never heard of this disaster, so I found it very interesting. Highly recommended.
I enjoyed this book very much. I basically read it in one sitting. I couldn't wait to find out what would happen next. I had never heard of this disaster, so I found it very interesting. Highly recommended.
March 24, 2026
It’s a 3.5 for me. I don’t feel as engrossed in the story and sometimes the two timelines seemed a little disconnected to me, like they didn’t quite pull at each other the way one might expect.
However, it wasn’t bad at all. A little on the drier side but I could see a lot of people enjoying this story. Overall, it wasn’t too bad just not my favorite.
Thank you negalley for the arc! This review is mine and the words my own.
However, it wasn’t bad at all. A little on the drier side but I could see a lot of people enjoying this story. Overall, it wasn’t too bad just not my favorite.
Thank you negalley for the arc! This review is mine and the words my own.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 43 reviews